Loss Leader
I would save the receptionist., Moderator
You can remove flesh from your child, but noone can touch you, which would seem to imply your child wouldnt want to have flesh removed from him, as you dont from yourself.
I do not know why you say, "No one can touch you." I don't know to what you are referring. As to whether my eight day old son would or would not want to be circumcised, the matter is of no consequence.
I love how you say its in the best interest for the incompetent child, implying what, that the child will never be competent to decide if they want it or not?
I have never implied that my child will never be competent. I don't know what I've said that would lead you to infer it.
Id like to point out on the issue of slavery that slaves were indeed enslaved for their own good, or that was one of the rationales used anyway. Christians enslaving heathens were saving their souls, just as youre saving your son's soul by mutilating him.
Great. So of the three prongs of the test for substituted judgment, let's give it to the slaveholders and say that slavery was in the best interests of the slaves. Now you just have to satisfy the other two prongs: that the slaves were incompetent to understand the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure and that the slaveholders were the next of kin and natural medical proxies for the slaves.
Can you do that with slavery?
Because I can when it comes to circumcising my child.
That is pretty frankly, moronic. Youre worried about him becoming sexually damaged.... so you sexually damage him, good logic there.
There is no evidence that infant circumcision negatively affects sexual performance or pleasure. So, in fact, I have exercised good logic and I thank you for recognizing such.
Right, the reasoning, as above, is the same youre using. God told them to, or at least they used God, cause he so readily speaks for himself, to justify what they wanted.
Once again, slavery and rape to not satisfy the prongs of the test for substituted judgment that the individuals be incompetent and that the decision-makers be the family of the individual. They are also not in the individual's best interests. So, the fact that they believe God told them to does not make them analagous to circumcision.
Heres a site, it purports itself to be Jewish, it is an older article, but your mandate to cut your baby's penis is slightly older ay. http://www.jewishcircumcision.org/jnews90.htm
Um, okay.
Id also like to comment on your lack of response to the issue of modern Jewish circumcision not being the original practice. I, as well as others, would have a much harder time arguing against the cutting off of the protruding tip of the foreskin, vs removing the majority of skin from your son's penis, which come to think of it, isnt even what God told you to do... hmm.
The religious authorities I trust recommend circumcision in its current form.