Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Ohh ok, thanks for sidestepping my entire post.

So you dont believe that pleasure isnt lost?..... or that it is?....

So why exactly are you even talking?
 
Ohh ok, thanks for sidestepping my entire post.


Sorry. I'll take another look at it.


There is no medical basis, there is no benefit, there is only rights violation and mutilation.


Just because you have assigned the familial and religious benefit a value of zero doesn't mean that there is no benefit. It only means that you don't believe the family and religious benefits to have value.


Your current argument that pleasure isnt lost is speculative at best, as Ive seen surveys that swing both ways, leaving only the ethical and medical considerations. If its not ethical to cut off a female's labia its not ethical to cut off a male's foreskin, unless medically indicated, which it isnt. It is an act of mutilation, it is an insult in the greatest form. To leave wounded but functional,


You've sort of descended into hysteria here. In any case, you present no evidence, just opinion. There is nothing for me to answer.


even your Jewish theologians admit that the removal of the foreskin in its current incarnation, not the ancient tip snip, is damaging to the sexuality of the male.


If you have a cite for this assertion, I would be glad to review it. However, the religious leaders I trust all advise circumcision.


Ill ask again, why is it only the genitals of infants that are broken at birth and need fixed? Is there any correlation between sexual taboo and the subsequent loathing of self that relates to the practice?


These questions contain so many unwarranted assumptions that I cannot respond to them. I deny your implied assertions that I believe the genitals of infants are broken and need to be fixed, that I loath myself and that my assumed self-loathing has anything to do with my desire to circumcise my sons.


I will also present this scenario.


Hit me.


If a man were working in a railyard when suddenly a boxcar moved and ended up crushing his arm, and was subsequently moved to a hospital to have the damage repaired. Over the course of the procedures that would be associated with repairing an injury of that sort it becomes apparent that the arm will have to be removed, and so is removed.

Would you expect the man to then hate all procedures seeking to repair damaged arms? Would you expect him to feel violated? Would you expect the man to be able to go into a hospital without feeling sick from knowing that doctors are out to save people's injured arms?

No.


I cannot fathom what you mean by this story. I have read it several times and its meaning, if any, is utterly opaque to me. I am not saying that I disagree with it; I am saying that I do not even comprehend it.


The difference, as was expressed at some point, is that where as the doctor was repairing an injury caused by presumably accident, circumcision is the deliberate damaging of a healthy, functional, worthwhile, and enjoyable body part. There is no reason to cut it off, excluding of course the idiotic weak reasons like peer pressure and fashion. In the instance of circumcision there is harm being done deliberately, ordered by the parent.


I do not understand how any of this follows from your story. Towards the middle of the paragraph, you just start making assertions about circumcision which, for what its worth, I deny.


Edit: Yes yes here comes your reply. "There is no harm."


I have never argued that circumcision causes no harm. I have only argued that, when the harms and benefits are added up, allowing Jews to circumcise their children causes more good than harm.


Then you wont mind laying on your side and letting me remove 15 or so square inches of skin from your abdomen will you?


I would mind for the following three reasons:

1. I am not incompetent to weigh the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure; and
2. You are not my next of kin and do not hold my health care proxy; and
3. Absent more evidence, it does not seem that removing 15 square inches of skin from my abdomen would be in my best interests.

Of course, were I to have a particularly virulent form of skin cancer and be in a coma and you were my wife (as I'm sure you'd look great in her clothes), perhaps I would not mind having the proposed procedure.
 
Sorry. I'll take another look at it.

1. Just because you have assigned the familial and religious benefit a value of zero doesn't mean that there is no benefit. It only means that you don't believe the family and religious benefits to have value.

2. You've sort of descended into hysteria here. In any case, you present no evidence, just opinion. There is nothing for me to answer.

3. If you have a cite for this assertion, I would be glad to review it. However, the religious leaders I trust all advise circumcision.

4. These questions contain so many unwarranted assumptions that I cannot respond to them. I deny your implied assertions that I believe the genitals of infants are broken and need to be fixed, that I loath myself and that my assumed self-loathing has anything to do with my desire to circumcise my sons.

Hit me.

5. I cannot fathom what you mean by this story. I have read it several times and its meaning, if any, is utterly opaque to me. I am not saying that I disagree with it; I am saying that I do not even comprehend it.

6.I do not understand how any of this follows from your story. Towards the middle of the paragraph, you just start making assertions about circumcision which, for what its worth, I deny.

7. I have never argued that circumcision causes no harm. I have only argued that, when the harms and benefits are added up, allowing Jews to circumcise their children causes more good than harm.

8. I would mind for the following three reasons:

1. I am not incompetent to weigh the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure; and
2. You are not my next of kin and do not hold my health care proxy; and
3. Absent more evidence, it does not seem that removing 15 square inches of skin from my abdomen would be in my best interests.

Of course, were I to have a particularly virulent form of skin cancer and be in a coma and you were my wife (as I'm sure you'd look great in her clothes), perhaps I would not mind having the proposed procedure.

Lets start with 8, for fun. So youre somehow saying that removing a part of you for no reason is wrong?

7. Nice excuse to hide behind.

6. Well you already admitted that you couldnt understand the story, so further commentary is rather pointless.

5. Im saying, that the opposition from circumcised males, where it exists, stems from the fact that the harm they are victim to wasnt accidental. Highlighting, through an example, (why noone understands these examples...) that you wouldnt expect resentment from someone who lost their arm through a medical procedure that was trying to save a part of them, vs circumcision which is solely designed to damage. This was mostly aimed at the less religiously oriented defendees of circumcision, such as Z. The fact that some men have lost their ability to enjoy sex, were it for a reason, wouldnt be so appalling. "Im sorry son, I think the circumcised penis looks better, thats why youle never be able to enjoy sex... sorry."

4. If you could actually analyze your religion for truth rather than just blind belief. Again this was aimed more at a more rational reasoning for circumcision, other than "ohh that fellow up in the sky, who is himself male, for God needs gender(always a fun thought) told me I need to cut off this part of my son, despite the fact that the current radical procedure, resulting as a punishment for restorers of old, of removing the entire foreskin wasnt even the original practice."

3. The citation is available elsewhere in the thread, the old Jewish fellow citing effects for circumcision, as well as a small host of others. Dont feel like looking it up right now, maybe later.

2. Ive descended into hysteria, lets analyze whose advocating cutting off a functional part of their son's penis because a man in the sky told them to.
There is reasoning there, I should have kept it more sterile I suppose. Is it or is it not ethical to cut off a female's labia for no reason? Yes? No? If not why is it ethical to cut off a male's foreskin?

1. Explain to me what benefit to the baby the circumcision has. Since the benefits wouldnt primarily affect you, in the form of not being criticized by your Jewish friends. What is the family value of damaging your baby for other people?

Your people know the nondamaging effects of circumcision well, what with the clause for allowing exemption of other children if already some in the family have died from the procedure.


In terms of family, dont misunderstand. I am an advocate for family. I wish family units were stronger. I wish that you didnt need to mutilate your baby to feel that you have a strong family.
I am for religious observation and activity, so long as it doesnt harm anyone else or impede their rights, religion has a positive effect on many people's lives.
 
Last edited:
1. I am not incompetent to weigh the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure;

Well, not for your own body you're not. For someone else's body, though..

2. You are not my next of kin and do not hold my health care proxy;

Irrelevant. Yet another evasion.

3. Absent more evidence, it does not seem that removing 15 square inches of skin from my abdomen would be in my best interests.

Wow, total shift of the burden of proof there. In this case, there has to be evidence of benefit to do it, but in the case of your child's foreskin, there has to be evidence of harm not to do it.

Why the double standard?
 
I really do not get some of the arguments being attempted here.

To me the question is really simple:

Should parents be allowed to have performed on their babies potentially dangerous surgical procedures which significantly alter the natural functions of their baby's body, if the procedure is not medically necessitated?

Anybody who answers this question with a "no" should be opposed to non-medically necessitated circumcision. If they are not opposed to it, then they either do not understand what circumcision actually does, or they contradicting themselves.

Apparently Loss Leader answers this question with a "yes". I regard this as an example of an extremely immoral position on his part. Apparently others here do as well. He clearly does not.

Any discussion of to what degree sensitivity is lost, or whether the person will "know what they're missing", or how painful it is, is really not relevant to the issue. If you answer "no" to my above question, then none of these issues matter because it is still wrong even if it is totally painless and no loss of sensation occurs. If your answer to my above question is "yes" then nothing more really needs to be said. You have already established that you think that parents should be allowed to harm their children. What more need be said?

Appeals to religious tradition are complete non-starters. If your religion said brand your baby on the ass with the star of David, doing so would land you in prison. But objectively speaking, that is far less dangerous than circumcision, and would have zero affect on how your body functions.

Tell me that you're going to brand your baby to defend your people's right to continue doing so, and I tell you that you are child-abusing scum. How is circumcision any better?


Dr. Stupid
 
I really do not get some of the arguments being attempted here.

To me the question is really simple:

Should parents be allowed to have performed on their babies potentially dangerous surgical procedures which significantly alter the natural functions of their baby's body, if the procedure is not medically necessitated?

The use of the qualifier "potentially dangerous" is probably redundant. Almost anything that can be done is potentially dangerous, so the issue is more appropriately a weighing of benefit and harm.

It has not been established that circumcision does or does not "significantly" alter natural functions when performed in an infant.

The WHO definition of "health", which guides physicians and other health-care providers when determining medical necessity, includes mental and social well-being.

Anybody who answers this question with a "no" should be opposed to non-medically necessitated circumcision. If they are not opposed to it, then they either do not understand what circumcision actually does, or they contradicting themselves.

If by medical necessity you are only referring to physical well-being, then you need to persuade all involved that mental and social well-being are not an important component of health, I think.

Apparently Loss Leader answers this question with a "yes". I regard this as an example of an extremely immoral position on his part. Apparently others here do as well. He clearly does not.

It is fairly clear to me that many people misunderstand his position. I suspect that it is the desire to find his position "extremely immoral" that prevents understanding.

Any discussion of to what degree sensitivity is lost, or whether the person will "know what they're missing", or how painful it is, is really not relevant to the issue. If you answer "no" to my above question, then none of these issues matter because it is still wrong even if it is totally painless and no loss of sensation occurs.

Then why did you include the qualifier "significantly alter the natural functions"?

If your answer to my above question is "yes" then nothing more really needs to be said. You have already established that you think that parents should be allowed to harm their children. What more need be said?

Yes, it has been well-established, on this thread, that the fallacy of "begging the question" is considered a reasonable method of arguing against circumcision. I have no idea why, though.

Appeals to religious tradition are complete non-starters. If your religion said brand your baby on the ass with the star of David, doing so would land you in prison. But objectively speaking, that is far less dangerous than circumcision, and would have zero affect on how your body functions.

Branding is another traditional way of indicating commitment to a group. Since laws reflect culture, I doubt it would have been perceived as a criminal act as an established tradition. As far as I know, cultures that include branding or tattooing of children do not form laws against the activity.

Tell me that you're going to brand your baby to defend your people's right to continue doing so, and I tell you that you are child-abusing scum. How is circumcision any better?


Dr. Stupid

I think it is also well-established here that some people think name-calling is a reasonable response. I am undecided on the issue, myself.

Linda
 
It is fairly clear to me that many people misunderstand his position. I suspect that it is the desire to find his position "extremely immoral" that prevents understanding.
Linda


In the same way I have an innate "desire" to say that rape is immoral, its really not, I just have such a strong desire that I make up arguments as to why rape is wrong.
 
The WHO definition of "health", which guides physicians and other health-care providers when determining medical necessity, includes mental and social well-being.

<snip>

Linda

...and yet physicians in the US will not modify an infant female's genitals, no matter how minor the requested mutilation, even if it means she is likely to suffer social and mental harm by being left intact.

This hasn't always the case though, it's just that removing a girl's clitoris didn't catch on in the US, even with physicians promoting it.
 
Should parents be allowed to have performed on their babies potentially dangerous surgical procedures which significantly alter the natural functions of their baby's body, if the procedure is not medically necessitated?

Anybody who answers this question with a "no" should be opposed to non-medically necessitated circumcision.


Your question contains the following assumptions:

1. Circumcision is potentially dangerous
2. Circumcision alters the natural functions of a baby's body
3. Such alteration is significant
4. medical necessity is the only valid reason to circumcise a child

What you have done is carefully frame the question in such a way as to make your desired answer more reasonable. It is logically identical to asking people in a political survey: "Do you believe the US should abandon the Iraqi people even if it means that the ensuing chaos will cause thousands of unnecessary deaths?"

Any yes or no answer has the effect of agreeing with your assumptions.

I do not agree with your assumptions (except assumption 1 which is true of everything on earth from brain surgery to buttering toast).

Either ask a question that makes no judgments or just admit that you are too biased to care about any position other than your own. I don't really care which you do.
 
<snip>

Branding is another traditional way of indicating commitment to a group. Since laws reflect culture, I doubt it would have been perceived as a criminal act as an established tradition. As far as I know, cultures that include branding or tattooing of children do not form laws against the activity.

Linda

Hmmm. Not so long ago, weren't slavery, a man raping his wife and the beating of disobedient children legal too?

Which intolerant racists made those acts illegal?
 
Hmmm. Not so long ago, weren't slavery, a man raping his wife and the beating of disobedient children legal too?

Which intolerant racists made those acts illegal?


For the eleven kabillionth time:

Both slavery and rape involve one person imposing his will on another competent adult. In the case of slavery at least, the individual imposing his will is not the next of kin holding the medical proxy for the slave. And it would be difficult to argue that either slavery or rape are in the best interests of the oppressed individuals.

So, here you have listed two instances that are so completely unlike circumcision as to be worthless comparisons.

The fact that you have not comprehended this after repeated explanation is ... troubling.
 
In the same way I have an innate "desire" to say that rape is immoral, its really not, I just have such a strong desire that I make up arguments as to why rape is wrong.

I don't really know, since I don't recall any posts from you on that topic. But I do see the same sort of responses in discussions on date rape when someone makes the suggestion that a woman consenting while under the influence of alcohol does not necessarily make it rape. Arguments supporting that idea also sometimes end up characterized as "extremely immoral".

Linda
 
For the eleven kabillionth time:

Both slavery and rape involve one person imposing his will on another competent adult. In the case of slavery at least, the individual imposing his will is not the next of kin holding the medical proxy for the slave. And it would be difficult to argue that either slavery or rape are in the best interests of the oppressed individuals.

So, here you have listed two instances that are so completely unlike circumcision as to be worthless comparisons.

The fact that you have not comprehended this after repeated explanation is ... troubling.

What kind of weird explanation of rape and slavery is that? There have never been child slaves? Children have never been raped? Children have never been raped by their parents? Children have never been raped by their parents for purported religious reasons? I call BS.

Actually circumcision and FGM are both closely related to if not included in the definition of rape. Circumcision and FGM are both about power over the individual and specifically sexual power. I don't get how you cannot see this. You basically admit as much when you talk about doing this for the good of the group, not the good of your son. Somehow you have it intermixed in your mind that what's good for the group is good for him when there is nothing that implies that at all. If it's truly important to him he can get circumcised anytime during this life, why the hurry to do it when he cannot tell you in his own words that he wants it? The only explanation I can come up with is that you've been brainwashed by your religiion...
 
Religion, it sucks

During traditional circumcision, the
mohel may perform metsitsah, a sucking on
the circumcised bleeding penis
. This ritual
is described as an integral part of the
circumcision ritual from its earliest reli-
gious description
, and is considered to be
obligatory. Therein lies the difficulty in
persuading mohalim to eliminate metsitsah
from the circumcision ritual. A possible
explanation behind the ritual is that suck-
ing the blood demonstrates that a proce-
dure has been performed. Another modern
explanation is that the mohel applies
natural anticoagulants and antibacterial
agents to the open wound. However, we
believe this is a source of infection rather
than an effective protective measure
.
Several cases of transmission of infec-tious
diseases during ritual circumcision
have been documented. In 1999, HSV
infection of the penis was described in
two infants who underwent ritual circumcision
including metsitsah
[4]. Neither patient
had a parent with a previous herpes
infection. The first infant presented 4 days
after circumcision with an erythematous,
swollen penis and a purulent discharge
from the glans. The second infant
presented 3 days after circumcision with a
similar picture. Viral culture grew HSV-I
from skin lesions of both infants. Recurrent
cutaneous lesions appeared in the genital
area several months later. Both circumcisions
were performed by the same mohel
,
who denied a history of oral herpes
infection [4]. However, excretion of the
HSV in the saliva of seropositive asymptomatic
subjects is a proven phenomenon
[5], and HSV can be cultured from the
pharynx of 1±2% of asymptomatic seropositive
individuals.

Other infectious diseases transmitted
during ritual circumcision
(and metsitsah)
are syphilis and tuberculosis [4]. The risk of
infection is bi-directional; the mohel also
risks being infected by blood-borne pathogens
from the neonate, including hepatitis
and human immunodeficiency viru
s.

http://www.ima.org.il/imaj/ar03dec-14.pdf

Warning! Images in the linked document may be disturbing. Circumcised infant with herpes infection.
 
What kind of weird explanation of rape and slavery is that?


Circumcision is a procedure in the best interests of a child performed by parents who hold the medical proxy for their incompetent child.

Neither slavery nor rape meets this definition so neither is sufficiently like circumcision to be of any use as a comparison.


There have never been child slaves? Children have never been raped? Children have never been raped by their parents? Children have never been raped by their parents for purported religious reasons? I call BS.


What are you calling BS on? Child slaves are not enslaved for their own good by a person who holds their medical proxy. Children are not raped in their own best interests. And when some parents might try to claim some sort of religious reason for rape, no courts have ever agreed. None of these are anything like circumcision.


Actually circumcision and FGM are both closely related to if not included in the definition of rape.


Please explain exactly what aspect of circumcision constitutes sexual intercourse. source

The answer is: none. You are engaging in unwarranted hysterics.


Circumcision and FGM are both about power over the individual and specifically sexual power.


No, circumcision is not. I deny this. If it is true, please cite specific sources other than your own personal feelings.


If it's truly important to him he can get circumcised anytime during this life, why the hurry to do it when he cannot tell you in his own words that he wants it?


There is an excellent reason to hurry. This study makes it clear that adults who were circumcised over the age of twenty suffered "a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."

So, there is harm in waiting for my child to be old enough to make the decision for himself. If I were to wait until he was an adult, this medical study indicated that circumcision would adversely affect his sexual function. I love my son far, far too much to force his to make this kind of choice. The harm to him in waiting until adulthood is far greater than the harm to him of circumcision as a newborn.

My thanks to Ivor for finding this study.
 
(Broadish response to the new topics.)

Why you even continue to comment on this topic is a matter of curiosity Loss.

If you dont agree with it, its hysterics. You can remove flesh from your child, but noone can touch you, which would seem to imply your child wouldnt want to have flesh removed from him, as you dont from yourself.

I love how you say its in the best interest for the incompetent child, implying what, that the child will never be competent to decide if they want it or not?

Id like to point out on the issue of slavery that slaves were indeed enslaved for their own good, or that was one of the rationales used anyway. Christians enslaving heathens were saving their souls, just as youre saving your son's soul by mutilating him.

"There is an excellent reason to hurry. This study makes it clear that adults who were circumcised over the age of twenty suffered "a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."

So, there is harm in waiting for my child to be old enough to make the decision for himself. If I were to wait until he was an adult, this medical study indicated that circumcision would adversely affect his sexual function. I love my son far, far too much to force his to make this kind of choice. The harm to him in waiting until adulthood is far greater than the harm to him of circumcision as a newborn."

That is pretty frankly, moronic. Youre worried about him becoming sexually damaged.... so you sexually damage him, good logic there.


"Both slavery and rape involve one person imposing his will on another competent adult. In the case of slavery at least, the individual imposing his will is not the next of kin holding the medical proxy for the slave. And it would be difficult to argue that either slavery or rape are in the best interests of the oppressed individuals."

Right, the reasoning, as above, is the same youre using. God told them to, or at least they used God, cause he so readily speaks for himself, to justify what they wanted.

Heres a site, it purports itself to be Jewish, it is an older article, but your mandate to cut your baby's penis is slightly older ay ;). http://www.jewishcircumcision.org/jnews90.htm

Id also like to comment on your lack of response to the issue of modern Jewish circumcision not being the original practice. I, as well as others, would have a much harder time arguing against the cutting off of the protruding tip of the foreskin, vs removing the majority of skin from your son's penis, which come to think of it, isnt even what God told you to do... hmm.

(Always surrounded by noisy people, apologies again for any poorly articulated thoughts. Also, Linda, that was a bit of sarcasm in the last post, Rape is immoral and wrong in any situation, as is circumcision. Its not a desire of mine to see it one way or another, it is the way it is. Also, you seem to have an attitude of "its ok so long as its not done to me." Would you like to have had your labia, or more, removed when you were defenseless, by your defenders?)
 
Last edited:
Also, Linda, that was a bit of sarcasm in the last post,

Yes. One of the ways to respond to sarcasm is to take it seriously. Sarcasm often depends upon an assumed consensus, and exposing that assumption can stimulate insight.

Or not.

Rape is immoral and wrong in any situation, as is circumcision. Its not a desire of mine to see it one way or another, it is the way it is.

The question isn't whether or not rape is immoral (an issue on which there is consensus). It's whether or not a particular act constitutes rape.

The question isn't whether or not physical abuse of children is immoral, it's whether or not circumcision constitutes an act of physical abuse. As do many others here, you are beg the question. You assume the answer in your argument.

Also, you seem to have an attitude of "its ok so long as its not done to me."

Where on earth did you get that idea? It's pretty much the opposite of the way that I think. I'm all about symmetry.

Would you like to have had your labia, or more, removed when you were defenseless, by your defenders?)

If those involved sincerely had my best interests at heart, yes.

Linda
 
Since youre being a bit silly about the definition of rape by the way, here you go. (Not you Linda.)

Rape. N.

1. The crime of forcing another person to submit to sex acts, especially sexual intercourse.
2. The act of seizing and carrying off by force; abduction.
3. Abusive or improper treatment; violation: a rape of justice.


But, to Linda. If they had your best interests at heart? So, if you educated yourself later in life, and found out that you had a valuable part of you removed for no reason at all, other than lack of will to research / superstition, youde be ok with it? Not to mention learning that it was probably sold to some biocorp to make skin grafts... Etc.

One of my many problems with it, as well as other mutilations, is that the entire time, anyone of my supposed defenders could have said no, could have went and researched the topic, and consequently saved me alot of agony. Of course noone did, if that was the case I probably wouldnt be in this topic, because I wouldnt have had reason to research why I was deformed. Likewise, had I found ANY reason for it to be done, not only to me but the majority of people in my area, then I also probably wouldnt be in this topic.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom