Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I have a question for persons on both sides of the issue: What do you think would be required for you to change your mind? A certain type of study and/or finding? A personal experience (of what kind)? A line of reasoning? Something else? A combination of factors?

The legality isn't really at issue in my question unless a change in the law/policy would be a factor in changing your opinion, as well.

I think if you look the people who have argued against circumcision have never argued against circumcision that is medically indicated so I think it is safe to assume that if there was some significant medical reason to routinely circumcise all males there would be no objection. What is being objected to is the genital mutilation that is being inflicted on male children for non-medical reasons.
 
Likewise to the above post, Im sure noone would have a problem with removing any other part of a baby if it gave "significant" medical benefit.


Detect: Sarcasm.
 
I have a question for persons on both sides of the issue: What do you think would be required for you to change your mind? A certain type of study and/or finding? A personal experience (of what kind)? A line of reasoning? Something else? A combination of factors?

The legality isn't really at issue in my question unless a change in the law/policy would be a factor in changing your opinion, as well.

Like all other surgery, a medical indication to perform it. E.g., to correct an anatomical deformity, or to avoid a likely future problem.

But after 150 years of failing to find some for healthy children, I don't hold out much hope any will be found.

What I really want is for physicians in the US to start saying to parents: "We recommend against circumcision unless there is a medical indication to perform it."

I can dream, can't I?
 
I appologize for not responding to your post earlier, Ivor.

I stated, "There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex." You responded:

Yes, there is

And you then cited two studies. I have to say that I am a little suprised. One of the studies is irrelevant to the question and the other actually supports my point of view.

For the first study, you state:

There is evidence that circumcision removes the most sensitive part of the penis

indeed, this study concludes: "The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis." This is hardly surprising as our expectation would be that exposing what had been a protected surface would desensitize it.

I couldn't read the entire paper because I guess you need a subscription. But I did notice that the paper says absolutely nothing about sexual enjoyment. My point was that there is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable. This study does not address that. Considering the vast number of circumcised males in the world, one would think there could be a way to collect this data.

Now, I realize that you are inviting me to conclude that a less sensitive glans necessarily means less enjoyable sex, however I do not accept your invitation. There is no reason why this would necessarily be true. The infant brain - pre-programmed but not yet pre-wired to enjoy sex - may well just assign the sexual enjoyment function to the remaining area on the circumcised glans with no loss of enjoyment at all. I knew a girl whose brain has transfered some of her sexual enjoyment to the soles of her feet.

This study is irrelevant to the point.

Your second study is relevant, but not in the way you'd like. This study concludes that, "There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."

Now, I will dispense with pointing out that this study, bizarrely, comes from the Department of Physics and Astronomy. It is, after all, either good science or it is not.

However, can you pick out the one word in the study's conclusion that most hurts your point? I will bold it: "... indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function ..."

This was a study only of men who were circumcised after the age of 20. No individuals circumcised as infants were included.

Moreover, there is no necessary reason why these findings would translate to people circumcised as infants. Nerve damage in adults occurs after the brain has assigned certain nerves the job of sexual stimulation while it is possible that infant circumcision occurs before these nerves have been assigned a sexual function. And we can feel confident in this because there is no large-scale reporting of sexual dissatisfaction among individuals circumcised as infants.

Once again, if you claim that infant circumcision reduces sexual pleasure, all you have to do is measure the effect. Just provide evidence for your conclusion.

Instead, you have provided evidence for mine:

You and your fellow foreskinners here have been arguing for pages and pages that parents should allow their children to decide for themselves whether to get circumcised when they become adults. You and others here have claimed that I cannot know what my son would want and I should let him decide for himself before irreversibly cutting off healthy tissue. You and others have claimed that I am invading my son's bodily integrity "against his will" by circumcising him as an infant.

Now, however, you have given me an answer. I cannot wait until my child is an adult because I have scientific evidence that adult circumcision will negatively affect his sexual enjoyment. I must, for the benefit of my son, circumcise him as an infant so that he does not have to suffer a loss of sexual enjoyment. If my son, as an adult, wants to be circumcised as part of the Jewish tradition but is faced with a loss of sexual satisfaction, he will clearly be upset that I did not circumcise him at a time when no such side-effects would occur.

Because of this study that you have quoted, I can finally answer that there is a medical reason why circumcision must be done on my children long before they are capable of making the decision for themselves.

Thank you for your help with this issue.
 
Now, however, you have given me an answer. I cannot wait until my child is an adult because I have scientific evidence that adult circumcision will negatively affect his sexual enjoyment. I must, for the benefit of my son, circumcise him as an infant so that he does not have to suffer a loss of sexual enjoyment. If my son, as an adult, wants to be circumcised as part of the Jewish tradition but is faced with a loss of sexual satisfaction, he will clearly be upset that I did not circumcise him at a time when no such side-effects would occur.

Because of this study that you have quoted, I can finally answer that there is a medical reason why circumcision must be done on my children long before they are capable of making the decision for themselves.

Thank you for your help with this issue.


OMFG you have to be kidding me. There is nothing in the study which says that the loss only occurs if you are circumcised as an adult. It would be reasonable to assume the loss occurs in both situations (although I would agree they only TESTED the one case).

LL, here's a question. If the above were shown to be universally true (e.g. any cutting causes a reduction in pleasure) would you be willing to not circumcise, or would the religious element still overrule that?

I would agree that it's more likely that someone circumcised as a child would be more likely to not notice what they have lost as they have nothing to compare to as the adults do.

This study is a solid argument against circumcision IMHO and to say that it magically doesn't apply to children is ridiculous until something contradicts it in children. I think designing a study to test this would be very difficult which is one of the reasons we don't have definitive proof that circumcision is harmful. Or more accurately why we don't have definitive proof that it causes harm.

As a side note isn't it obvious to everyone that this is about sexual control? Human society has struggled with issues of sexuality since the beginning of civilisation. Make no mistake this isn't about a compact with god, it's about the holy men controlling you.
 
OMFG you have to be kidding me. There is nothing in the study which says that the loss only occurs if you are circumcised as an adult.

You're right. The study only measured people circumcised as adults.

It would be reasonable to assume the loss occurs in both situations (although I would agree they only TESTED the one case).

No, this would not be reasonable. Only one circumstance was tested, meanwhile there is no wholesale reporting of sexual dissatisfaction among people circumcised as infants. The assumption that this study applies to infant circumcision is unwarranted.

LL, here's a question. If the above were shown to be universally true (e.g. any cutting causes a reduction in pleasure) would you be willing to not circumcise, or would the religious element still overrule that?

A showing of a significant physical disfunction would cause me to rethink circumcision. Indeed, I have already been convinced by your arguments that infant circumcision for nonreligious reasons should not be routine.

I would agree that it's more likely that someone circumcised as a child would be more likely to not notice what they have lost as they have nothing to compare to as the adults do.

Not notice? I think it's more than that. I think if you handed out a survey to all men that said, "How much do you enjoy sex?" the scores from circumcised and uncircumcised men would be identical. What then is the difference between not noticing an effect and there being no effect to notice?

This study is a solid argument against circumcision IMHO and to say that it magically doesn't apply to children is ridiculous until something contradicts it in children.

I didn't say that it "magically" doesn't apply to children. I said that it doesn't apply to infant circumcision. They didn't measure infant circumcision; there's nothing magical about it.

It turns out that the recipe I have for tiramisu "magically" doesn't apply to a flourless chocolate torte.

I think designing a study to test this would be very difficult which is one of the reasons we don't have definitive proof that circumcision is harmful. Or more accurately why we don't have definitive proof that it causes harm.

Excelent. Call me when you do.

As a side note isn't it obvious to everyone that this is about sexual control?

Not to me.
 
I appologize for not responding to your post earlier, Ivor.

I stated, "There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex." You responded:



And you then cited two studies. I have to say that I am a little suprised. One of the studies is irrelevant to the question and the other actually supports my point of view.

For the first study, you state:

There is evidence that circumcision removes the most sensitive part of the penis

indeed, this study concludes: "The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis." This is hardly surprising as our expectation would be that exposing what had been a protected surface would desensitize it.

I couldn't read the entire paper because I guess you need a subscription. But I did notice that the paper says absolutely nothing about sexual enjoyment. My point was that there is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable. This study does not address that. Considering the vast number of circumcised males in the world, one would think there could be a way to collect this data.

Now, I realize that you are inviting me to conclude that a less sensitive glans necessarily means less enjoyable sex, however I do not accept your invitation. There is no reason why this would necessarily be true. The infant brain - pre-programmed but not yet pre-wired to enjoy sex - may well just assign the sexual enjoyment function to the remaining area on the circumcised glans with no loss of enjoyment at all. I knew a girl whose brain has transfered some of her sexual enjoyment to the soles of her feet.

This study is irrelevant to the point.

Your second study is relevant, but not in the way you'd like. This study concludes that, "There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."

Now, I will dispense with pointing out that this study, bizarrely, comes from the Department of Physics and Astronomy. It is, after all, either good science or it is not.

However, can you pick out the one word in the study's conclusion that most hurts your point? I will bold it: "... indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function ..."

This was a study only of men who were circumcised after the age of 20. No individuals circumcised as infants were included.

Moreover, there is no necessary reason why these findings would translate to people circumcised as infants. Nerve damage in adults occurs after the brain has assigned certain nerves the job of sexual stimulation while it is possible that infant circumcision occurs before these nerves have been assigned a sexual function. And we can feel confident in this because there is no large-scale reporting of sexual dissatisfaction among individuals circumcised as infants.

Once again, if you claim that infant circumcision reduces sexual pleasure, all you have to do is measure the effect. Just provide evidence for your conclusion.

Instead, you have provided evidence for mine:

You and your fellow foreskinners here have been arguing for pages and pages that parents should allow their children to decide for themselves whether to get circumcised when they become adults. You and others here have claimed that I cannot know what my son would want and I should let him decide for himself before irreversibly cutting off healthy tissue. You and others have claimed that I am invading my son's bodily integrity "against his will" by circumcising him as an infant.

Now, however, you have given me an answer. I cannot wait until my child is an adult because I have scientific evidence that adult circumcision will negatively affect his sexual enjoyment. I must, for the benefit of my son, circumcise him as an infant so that he does not have to suffer a loss of sexual enjoyment. If my son, as an adult, wants to be circumcised as part of the Jewish tradition but is faced with a loss of sexual satisfaction, he will clearly be upset that I did not circumcise him at a time when no such side-effects would occur.

Because of this study that you have quoted, I can finally answer that there is a medical reason why circumcision must be done on my children long before they are capable of making the decision for themselves.

Thank you for your help with this issue.

Nice try, LL.;) You are aware there is a paper that has used the argument you have just presented (somatosensory remapping) to justify FGM, aren't you?

Alas, this happens in adults too, so your unsubstantiated claim that the sensitivity would be lost in adults but not in infants is incorrect.

Even if this were the case, the type of sensory nerves in the foreskin are different to that in the glans. So you can have some vague idea about what amazing sensations you are missing out on, the difference in sensation is similar to that experienced between rubbing a finger on the palm of your hand (foreskin-type nerves) to that experienced by rubbing the back of your hand (glans-type nerves).

Go on - try it now.

Quite a difference, isn't there?

Then you have the mechanical function of the foreskin, which IMO, was probably the biggest problem (and disappointment) for the circumcised men in the study.
 
Nice try, LL.;) You are aware there is a paper that has used the argument you have just presented (somatosensory remapping) to justify FGM, aren't you?

Alas, this happens in adults too, so your unsubstantiated claim that the sensitivity would be lost in adults but not in infants is incorrect.

...

Then you have the mechanical function of the foreskin, which IMO, was probably the biggest problem (and disappointment) for the circumcised men in the study.


Terrific. Then you should have no problem presenting me a peer-reviewed study that concludes that infant circumcision decreases sexual satisfaction.

I will just wait here while you do that.
 
Now, I realize that you are inviting me to conclude that a less sensitive glans necessarily means less enjoyable sex, however I do not accept your invitation. There is no reason why this would necessarily be true. The infant brain - pre-programmed but not yet pre-wired to enjoy sex - may well just assign the sexual enjoyment function to the remaining area on the circumcised glans with no loss of enjoyment at all. I knew a girl whose brain has transfered some of her sexual enjoyment to the soles of her feet.

This study, referenced earlier by Skeptigirl, would seem to support your point.

Linda
 
Terrific. Then you should have no problem presenting me a peer-reviewed study that concludes that infant circumcision decreases sexual satisfaction.

I will just wait here while you do that.

From the evidence provided, a reasonable person would infer that the change in sensation and mechanical function caused by circumcision is most probably going to be deleterious to the enjoyment of sex, just as we infer FGM is. E.g., most men in the study found it harder to masturbate after being circumcised.

Please answer these two questions:

Did you run your finger across back and palm of your hand?

Did you notice the difference in sensation?
 
From the evidence provided, a reasonable person would infer that the change in sensation and mechanical function caused by circumcision is most probably going to be deleterious to the enjoyment of sex, just as we infer FGM is. E.g., most men in the study found it harder to masturbate after being circumcised.


No, I'm sorry but that is not a reasonable inference. It is an understandable inference but it is not logically necessary or warranted. The fact is that there is a huge population of circumcised men today and there has been throughout history. Evidence of sexual disfunction should be easy to measure. These people should be having sex less, taking longer to masturbate, having fewer children, reporting impotency more, or something that somehow shows that there is a sexual difference between circumcised and uncircumcised men. But the numbers just simply are not there.

The fact that you think that it is logical that decreased sensitivity means decreased pleasure might be relevant if the evidence didn't disagree with you. There may be reason to suspect decreased sexual pleasure, but our suspicions have yielded no evidence.

Burning items makes them weigh less. This leads the reasonable person to suspect that burning things removes some substance from them - perhaps phlogiston. It was a very reasonable hypothesis. Testing for phlogiston, however, was unsuccessful. There is no evidence that such a substance exists.

So, as I said, I will wait here while you prove that your reasonable suspicions about sexual pleasure are borne out by the evidence.
 
No, I'm sorry but that is not a reasonable inference. It is an understandable inference but it is not logically necessary or warranted. The fact is that there is a huge population of circumcised men today and there has been throughout history. Evidence of sexual disfunction should be easy to measure. These people should be having sex less, taking longer to masturbate, having fewer children, reporting impotency more, or something that somehow shows that there is a sexual difference between circumcised and uncircumcised men. But the numbers just simply are not there.

The fact that you think that it is logical that decreased sensitivity means decreased pleasure might be relevant if the evidence didn't disagree with you. There may be reason to suspect decreased sexual pleasure, but our suspicions have yielded no evidence.

Burning items makes them weigh less. This leads the reasonable person to suspect that burning things removes some substance from them - perhaps phlogiston. It was a very reasonable hypothesis. Testing for phlogiston, however, was unsuccessful. There is no evidence that such a substance exists.

So, as I said, I will wait here while you prove that your reasonable suspicions about sexual pleasure are borne out by the evidence.

Try this (read the numbered references):

Sexual behaviour. The alteration to the sexual organ causes many circumcised males to change their sexual behavior. Foley reported that circumcised males are more likely to masturbate.10 Hooykaas et al. (1991) reported that immigrant (mostly circumcised) males have a greater tendency to engage in risky sexual behavior with prostitutes as compared with Dutch (mostly normal intact) males.23 The U. S. National Health and Social Life Survey found that circumcised males have a "more elaborated" set of sexual practices, including more masturbation, and more heterosexual oral sex.30 The British National Survey of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles (2000) reported that circumcised males were more likely to report having a homosexual partner and more likely to have partners from abroad as compared with normal intact males.56 Circumcised men are significantly less likely to use condoms.38 50
 
Thank you. I remembered having seen it before but I couldn't find it.

I wouldn't thank Linda. That study does not test the sensitivity of the prepuce. In fact it supports my argument.

(And Linda is only (thought she was) helping you because she's mad at me for calling her an apologist for child abuse. The enemy of my enemy and all that;))

An amusing aside: The only comment in my (American, 2nd edition, 2006) anatomy book about the prepuce is "Removed in the procedure of circumcision.":)
 
Try this (read the numbered references):


It's obviously a very detailed piece with many references. I appologize if it takes me some time to work through but I promise to examine it carefully. The main article appears to have an editorial bias but I am only interested in the science that it cites.

I hope for my sake that you have not posted this link before because I have taken pride in reading and considering all of the appropriate scientific literature that has been produced at least since I joined the thread.
 
Well LossLeader, you should look up something called confirmation bias. As it pertains to the shutdown of reasoning centers of the brain when confronted with something you dont like.


All your justifications fall through, so you just make up some nonsensical argument and call it true.

Flesh is being eradicated, along with nervous tissue. But of course it would be stupid to say that any sensitivity is lost, its not a common sense issue. I suppose if I were to scrape off a portion of your retina youde go ahead and tell me that you could see better, or at least your enjoyment of seeing things had increased.

There is no reason for the mutilation of your children, or any children. You give nonsensical reasons, very much in line with advocates of Female Genital Mutilation, which for some reason is just naturally wrong. By the way everyone, FGM doesnt leave a female incapable of orgasm, unless youre referring to some type that destroys the nerves in the walls of the vagina, which as I understand it are just as capable of causing orgasm, though generating slightly different sensations. Nor does it destroy the capability of the female to have children. Its just "something thats done" for the sake of the girl, the community, and her future husband.

It is obvious to anyone that bothers to consider the issue that circumcision is just as much a mutilation as female genital cutting, the fact that some seem to be desensitized to it isnt a deciding factor.

Also for whoever was referring to the prepuce of animals rather frequently, Z perhaps, the exposed genitalia become necrotic and can cause quite serious problems in a number of creatures, dogs for example. So its not simply a sleeve to keep it warm, which by the way, I recommend that the fellows here lucky enough to have parents that decided to let them keep all of their penis should pull back the foreskin and attempt to do anything without the glans becoming extremely irritated, but should also bear in mind that there is of course no difference in sensitivity in their and nonintact penises. Due to my interesting situation I have experience with this.

Apologies if this is hardish to understand, Id be glad to rephrase any of it if someone would like. Wrote in a bit of a rush.
 
Flesh is being eradicated, along with nervous tissue. But of course it would be stupid to say that any sensitivity is lost, its not a common sense issue.


I have not and would not argue that it is "stupid to say that any sensitivity is lost." What I have said is that I have not seen evidence of a decrease in sexual enjoyment for people circumcised as infamts. The fact that some sensitivity is lost is only a reason to suspect that sexual enjoyment is decreased. So far (at least before ItE's last article), I have not seen that suspicion borne out in the evidence.

As regards confirmation bias, I would suggest that you nose around your home for a bit and locate a mirror.
 
As regards confirmation bias, I would suggest that you nose around your home for a bit and locate a mirror.

I have a mirror, I have evaluated my side for holes. I have asked questions from the pro camp, none of them hold water. There is no medical basis, there is no benefit, there is only rights violation and mutilation.

Your current argument that pleasure isnt lost is speculative at best, as Ive seen surveys that swing both ways, leaving only the ethical and medical considerations. If its not ethical to cut off a female's labia its not ethical to cut off a male's foreskin, unless medically indicated, which it isnt. It is an act of mutilation, it is an insult in the greatest form. To leave wounded but functional, even your Jewish theologians admit that the removal of the foreskin in its current incarnation, not the ancient tip snip, is damaging to the sexuality of the male.

Ill ask again, why is it only the genitals of infants that are broken at birth and need fixed? Is there any correlation between sexual taboo and the subsequent loathing of self that relates to the practice?

I will also present this scenario.

If a man were working in a railyard when suddenly a boxcar moved and ended up crushing his arm, and was subsequently moved to a hospital to have the damage repaired. Over the course of the procedures that would be associated with repairing an injury of that sort it becomes apparent that the arm will have to be removed, and so is removed.

Would you expect the man to then hate all procedures seeking to repair damaged arms? Would you expect him to feel violated? Would you expect the man to be able to go into a hospital without feeling sick from knowing that doctors are out to save people's injured arms?

No.

The difference, as was expressed at some point, is that where as the doctor was repairing an injury caused by presumably accident, circumcision is the deliberate damaging of a healthy, functional, worthwhile, and enjoyable body part. There is no reason to cut it off, excluding of course the idiotic weak reasons like peer pressure and fashion. In the instance of circumcision there is harm being done deliberately, ordered by the parent.

Edit: Yes yes here comes your reply. "There is no harm." Then you wont mind laying on your side and letting me remove 15 or so square inches of skin from your abdomen will you?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom