I appologize for not responding to your post earlier, Ivor.
I stated, "There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex." You responded:
And you then cited two studies. I have to say that I am a little suprised. One of the studies is irrelevant to the question and the other actually supports my point of view.
For the first study, you state:
There is evidence that circumcision removes the most sensitive part of the penis
indeed, this study concludes: "
The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis." This is hardly surprising as our expectation would be that exposing what had been a protected surface would desensitize it.
I couldn't read the entire paper because I guess you need a subscription. But I did notice that the paper says absolutely nothing about sexual enjoyment. My point was that there is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable. This study does not address that. Considering the vast number of circumcised males in the world, one would think there could be a way to collect this data.
Now, I realize that you are inviting me to conclude that a less sensitive glans necessarily means less enjoyable sex, however I do not accept your invitation. There is no reason why this would necessarily be true. The infant brain - pre-programmed but not yet pre-wired to enjoy sex - may well just assign the sexual enjoyment function to the remaining area on the circumcised glans with no loss of enjoyment at all. I knew a girl whose brain has transfered some of her sexual enjoyment to the soles of her feet.
This study is irrelevant to the point.
Your second study is relevant, but not in the way you'd like. This study concludes that, "
There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."
Now, I will dispense with pointing out that this study, bizarrely, comes from the Department of Physics and Astronomy. It is, after all, either good science or it is not.
However, can you pick out the one word in the study's conclusion that most hurts your point? I will bold it: "
... indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function ..."
This was a study only of men who were circumcised after the age of 20. No individuals circumcised as infants were included.
Moreover, there is no necessary reason why these findings would translate to people circumcised as infants. Nerve damage in adults occurs after the brain has assigned certain nerves the job of sexual stimulation while it is possible that infant circumcision occurs before these nerves have been assigned a sexual function. And we can feel confident in this because there is no large-scale reporting of sexual dissatisfaction among individuals circumcised as infants.
Once again, if you claim that infant circumcision reduces sexual pleasure, all you have to do is measure the effect. Just provide evidence for your conclusion.
Instead, you have provided evidence for mine:
You and your fellow foreskinners here have been arguing for pages and pages that parents should allow their children to decide for themselves whether to get circumcised when they become adults. You and others here have claimed that I cannot know what my son would want and I should let him decide for himself before irreversibly cutting off healthy tissue. You and others have claimed that I am invading my son's bodily integrity "against his will" by circumcising him as an infant.
Now, however, you have given me an answer. I cannot wait until my child is an adult because I have scientific evidence that adult circumcision will negatively affect his sexual enjoyment. I must, for the benefit of my son, circumcise him as an infant so that he does not have to suffer a loss of sexual enjoyment. If my son, as an adult, wants to be circumcised as part of the Jewish tradition but is faced with a loss of sexual satisfaction, he will clearly be upset that I did not circumcise him at a time when no such side-effects would occur.
Because of this study that you have quoted, I can finally answer that there is a medical reason why circumcision must be done on my children long before they are capable of making the decision for themselves.
Thank you for your help with this issue.