Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

And if an individual has never known what sex feels like with a circumcised penis, they probably don't know that they have had their enjoyment reduced.

They haven't "had" anything reduced. They have been given the chance to decide for them self how they would like their penis to look and feel.

There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex.

Yes, there is:

Kim D, Pang MG.
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea.

OBJECTIVE: To prospectively study, using a questionnaire, the sexuality of men circumcised as adults compared to uncircumcised men, and to compare their sex lives before and after circumcision. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: The study included 373 sexually active men, of whom 255 were circumcised and 118 were not. Of the 255 circumcised men, 138 had been sexually active before circumcision, and all were circumcised at >20 years of age. As the Brief Male Sexual Function Inventory does not specifically address the quality of sex life, questions were added to compare sexual and masturbatory pleasure before and after circumcision. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in sexual drive, erection, ejaculation, and ejaculation latency time between circumcised and uncircumcised men. Masturbatory pleasure decreased after circumcision in 48% of the respondents, while 8% reported increased pleasure. Masturbatory difficulty increased after circumcision in 63% of the respondents but was easier in 37%. About 6% answered that their sex lives improved, while 20% reported a worse sex life after circumcision. CONCLUSION: There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings.

PMID: 17155977 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

So most men in this study had worse sexual satisfaction.

Just because it may seem to you that circumcision would reduce sexual enjoyment does not mean that it's necessarily true. And, in fact, there is no scientific evidence that it is true - just anecdotes.

There is evidence that circumcision removes the most sensitive part of the penis:

Sorrells ML, Snyder JL, Reiss MD, Eden C, Milos MF, Wilcox N, Van Howe RS.
HIV/AIDS researcher, San Francisco, CA, USA.

OBJECTIVE: To map the fine-touch pressure thresholds of the adult penis in circumcised and uncircumcised men, and to compare the two populations. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Adult male volunteers with no history of penile pathology or diabetes were evaluated with a Semmes-Weinstein monofilament touch-test to map the fine-touch pressure thresholds of the penis. Circumcised and uncircumcised men were compared using mixed models for repeated data, controlling for age, type of underwear worn, time since last ejaculation, ethnicity, country of birth, and level of education. RESULTS: The glans of the uncircumcised men had significantly lower mean (sem) pressure thresholds than that of the circumcised men, at 0.161 (0.078) g (P = 0.040) when controlled for age, location of measurement, type of underwear worn, and ethnicity. There were significant differences in pressure thresholds by location on the penis (P < 0.001). The most sensitive location on the circumcised penis was the circumcision scar on the ventral surface. Five locations on the uncircumcised penis that are routinely removed at circumcision had lower pressure thresholds than the ventral scar of the circumcised penis. CONCLUSIONS: The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis. The transitional region from the external to the internal prepuce is the most sensitive region of the uncircumcised penis and more sensitive than the most sensitive region of the circumcised penis. Circumcision ablates the most sensitive parts of the penis.

PMID: 17378847 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

The pro-circ. crowd like to make definitive statements about how little circumcision hurts, or how little circumcision effects sexual sensation, but alas, reality does not back up these assertions.
 
There is evidence that circumcision removes the most sensitive part of the penis:

The pro-circ. crowd like to make definitive statements about how little circumcision hurts, or how little circumcision effects sexual sensation, but alas, reality does not back up these assertions.

So where's the evidence that circumcised penises are more sensitive than intact ones?
Anyone ever seen any of that?
I've seen a couple of "there is no difference" studies, but never a finding in favor of circumcised penises being more sensitive.
 
So where's the evidence that circumcised penises are more sensitive than intact ones?
Anyone ever seen any of that?
I've seen a couple of "there is no difference" studies, but never a finding in favor of circumcised penises being more sensitive.

Its a bit silly, and obviously something invented to make circumcised persons, or circumcisers feel better.

It is impossible that sensation isnt reduced, sensitive tissue is eradicated, there is nothing of it to take in feeling. You cant feel from a hand thats no longer attached to your body, why does it make sense in this case to say you can.
 
Its a bit silly, and obviously something invented to make circumcised persons, or circumcisers feel better.

It is impossible that sensation isnt reduced, sensitive tissue is eradicated, there is nothing of it to take in feeling. You cant feel from a hand thats no longer attached to your body, why does it make sense in this case to say you can.

It is silly. The pro-circ folks just like to make a big deal about the occasional study finding no difference, as though perhaps it's just random chance that causes the other ones to find that sensitivity is reduced. (or fraud, or something.)
But if that were the case, you'd have studies here and there finding that circed penises have greater sensitivity, you'd think.

But I agree...it's not terribly biologically plausible that removing significant parts of the penis doesn't reduce sensitivity.
 
The problem with the dead baby argument is that there are dead babies on both sides.

Just thought you'd want to know.

Linda
Maybe I'm being obtuse, but are you saying that babies have died because they weren't circumcised? (Genuinely curious, not flippant.)

What do you mean?
 
Maybe I'm being obtuse, but are you saying that babies have died because they weren't circumcised? (Genuinely curious, not flippant.)

What do you mean?

Because there's a higher rate of UTIs in intact male infants...some of them must develop fatal bacterial infections every once in a blue moon.
 
So where's the evidence that circumcised penises are more sensitive than intact ones?
Anyone ever seen any of that?
I've seen a couple of "there is no difference" studies, but never a finding in favor of circumcised penises being more sensitive.
I'd like to see studies like that, too.

I've been meaning to bring this up. I have problems with accepting some of these studies that show "no difference" between circed and intact. Not because I doubt people's self-reporting, but because on the studies that I've looked at (earlier in the thread), many of the men circed as an adult reported better sex lives and an overall satisfaction with the procedure. But, if you look carefully, most of the men had the procedure because of some medical problem, likely phimosis. Well, since phimosis prevents retraction of the foreskin and is likely very painful, I'm not surprised that removing the foreskin would be helpful, and the people would report being satisfied, since they can now have sex without problems. (Note that phimosis happens rarely in intact men.)

Also, I would say the sample is biased (although it probably can't be helped). It seems like most of the men in the sample were people who had a medical problem significant enough to seek help for it. Well, that's pretty biased right there, because it's not a random sampling of all men, only men with significant problems. I do recognize that those are some the few men whom we can study, because they're choosing to be circed as an adult, but the inherent bias should be noted.

Finally, when they test sensitivity it bothers me that they neglect testing the foreskin. I know, how can they test the foreskin in circed men? To me, it's like cutting off two fingers on your left hand, then testing whether the remaining three can still feel anything. Well, of course they can, but the main point is that those two fingers that added to feeling are still missing, but we neglect studying it, and report that those with a full hand, and those with two fingers missing still feel the same with the equivalent remaining fingers. It's not an exact comparision.

Just thinking; feel free to dissect.
 
AAP said:
“recommends that its members decline to perform any medically unnecessary procedure that alters the genitalia of female infants, girls, and adolescents”

American Physicians should hang their heads in shame.
 
Plenty of children who suffer emotional, physical and even sexual abuse are absolutely devastated at the thought of being removed from their parents. Their wishes are, rightly, disregarded.


Physical abuse like genital mutilation?


What I am (quite patiently) explaining to you has nothing to do with my religious beliefs. It is a simple and general rule designed to produce the best results for parents, children and society at large over a wide range of issues and circumstances.


Hold on, you're not citing religious beliefs to justify it? What secular reason could you possibly have for cutting off a healthy foreskin?
 
Sure. It is in my son's best interests for me to circumcise my children for the Jewish people. It is in his best interests to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity.


So it's in your son's interest for you to circumcise him for other people? Zuh?

And I suggest that everyone try reading that quote aloud but replacing "jewish" with "aryan".


It is in his best interests to avoid a world where my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.


This is the same kind of argument muslims use to defend their treatment of women: if you object to it you're a bigot.

At least a grown woman can choose wether or not she wears a veil.
 
So it's in your son's interest for you to circumcise him for other people? Zuh?

And I suggest that everyone try reading that quote aloud but replacing "jewish" with "aryan".





This is the same kind of argument muslims use to defend their treatment of women: if you object to it you're a bigot.

At least a grown woman can choose wether or not she wears a veil.

Of course grown women cannot choose this in many societies, they are forced by law to wear the veil. Just as the law allows people here to mutilate infants.

It's funny how LL keeps bringing up the fact that it's legal for him to do this as some sort of justification. Legal != good. Just because society agrees or disagrees with a particular thing doesn't make it a good idea.
 
emphasis mine

"Parents should not be allowed to make this decision. It should not be up to parental consent. If somebody wants to get a circumcision, let them do it when they're an adult. Seriously. It should be stopped, it should be against the law. It’s as barbaric as what goes on in Africa. There is no reason for circumcision, PERIOD!

And I’ll tell you what it is. Most men want their sons to look like themselves. So this keeps going. It keeps going on and on and on. It is so barbaric. And they are saying now people are starting to take a second look at this. And they say that they believe in the future it will be more common to see uncircumcised men in gym class because people are really starting to wake up to this. It is probably the biggest form of child abuse going on in this country right now.

I tell you, if I had a son, I would never allow him to be circumcised. Never! Never! NEVER ALLOW IT! NEVER!

And these Jews who are doing it are wrong, and the goyem [non-Jews] that are doing it are wrong. Everyone’s wrong.

It is wrong. Stop the practice NOW! IMMEDIATELY!

Class action suit against doctors. This is the only way you’ll get them to stop ... no matter who gives consent. Parents have no right to say. PARENTS ARE OUT OF THEIR MINDS. They don’t think things through. They all just go along.

[To a mohel about the Bible] I’m telling you, Sir, this is a BARBARIC process. And everyone has been so BRAINWASHED. I don’t think a book is bad if it tells you not to kill someone. But a book is bad if it’s telling you to mutilate young boys and to cut off their penises ... That’s bad. You’re in the business of mutilating young boys, Sir. And I think you should be arrested!"

July 27, 1998

Howard Stern, from his Radio Broadcast
 
I bet a class action suit would succeed in the US. Boy, will I be pointing and laughing if and when that finally happens.
 
Class action suit against doctors. This is the only way you’ll get them to stop ... no matter who gives consent. Parents have no right to say. PARENTS ARE OUT OF THEIR MINDS. They don’t think things through. They all just go along.
Yes, I think this is one way to make this practice end. There have been lawsuits before, but they always get settled out of court, so no case law has ever been set.

You touch on a very important point, parents don't think things through, and just go along with it. This is because they are socialized to think it's normal and never question their beliefs later. (That sounds familiar.)

AAP said:
“recommends that its members decline to perform any medically unnecessary procedure that alters the genitalia of female infants, girls, and adolescents”
American Physicians should hang their heads in shame.
I'm surprised no one has used the 14th Amendment to either overturn the FGM Act, or to add boys to it. The FGM Act is inherently sexist, and does not afford boys the same protection as girls.

There's another way it could end: insurance companies not paying for it anymore. I think that's how it's ended in the UK. I've seen studies that show when medicaid stops paying for it (implemented in several states) circumcision rates plummet. Seems like people do it when it's free, but as soon as they have to pony up the money for it ... I guess their son's foreskin really is worth something.

I just thought of something. Aren't hospitals getting paid twice for circumcision? Once by the insurance/parents, for cutting it off, then another time for selling it to companies who use it for research and skin grafts.
 
I have a question for persons on both sides of the issue: What do you think would be required for you to change your mind? A certain type of study and/or finding? A personal experience (of what kind)? A line of reasoning? Something else? A combination of factors?

The legality isn't really at issue in my question unless a change in the law/policy would be a factor in changing your opinion, as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom