Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Ivor said:
And if he really didn't like it he could spit it out. Or do you hold his nose and mouth shut and force him to swallow?
Off topic, but you'd think ramming new food down a child's mouth would give them negative associations with trying new food?

It is only without meaning for you and people like you who wish to inflict pain and suffering on children for ritual or cultural reasons. Most humane people understand it perfectly.

I certainly understood exactly what you were saying. :)
 
You are wrong.

It's not surprising, you're engaging in an ends-oriented analysis. You want the answer to come out a certain way so you are backwards-engineering a rule that will get you to your answer.

However, your rule leaves a mess in just about every other area where decision-making for children is involved.

Courts have long concluded that it is impossible to know what a child would want if he were competent. This is true no matter what the issue is: whether to have a medical procedure, what to eat for breakfast, which parent to live with after a divorce, etc.

Courts are not in the habit of consulting tarrot cards or navel gazing. They do not simply guess about things that cannot under any circumstance ever be known.

Thus, the rules regarding how to make decisions for children are necessarily different than those regarding how to make decisions for once-competent adults. In the case of an adult rendered incompetent, it is in fact possible to find out what he would have wanted. One mearly consults his worlds and actions when he was competent. This cannot be done for children.

Thus, the rules regarding decision-making for children involve weighing their best interests. In no case does one ever consider the possible wishes of the child when he one day becomes competent.

I am very sorry you do not like this. But this is not just the rule for people who like circumcision with "most humane people" thinking differently. This is the only rule there ever has been and the only one that makes sense. In Family Courts all across the nation today, it was this rule that judges used to conclude what visitation rights one parent should have. And that is just one of the many, many issues that are determined in this manner.

Try, please, to comprehend this. It's actually a very simple concept.

I'm used to dealing with incompetent adults (I'm an internist, not a pediatrician). Your explanation makes the distinction clear and illuminates a number of issues for me. Thank you.

Linda
 
You are wrong.

It's not surprising, you're engaging in an ends-oriented analysis. You want the answer to come out a certain way so you are backwards-engineering a rule that will get you to your answer.

And of course the people who came up with the current rules did not have an interest in maintaining the status quo:rolleyes:

However, your rule leaves a mess in just about every other area where decision-making for children is involved.

How so? My only "rule" is that children will be protected from physical cruelty and mutilation of their body unless it provides (or is likely to provide) a significant medical benefit.

I know, I know, I'm a mean SOB.

Courts have long concluded that it is impossible to know what a child would want if he were competent. This is true no matter what the issue is: whether to have a medical procedure, what to eat for breakfast, which parent to live with after a divorce, etc.

Don't US courts ask the child(ren) which parent they would like to live with? Or is it just which parent has the best lawyer in the States "wins" the custody of the children?

Courts are not in the habit of consulting tarrot cards or navel gazing. They do not simply guess about things that cannot under any circumstance ever be known.

Yes they can. How many animals wish to have pain inflicted on them?

Thus, the rules regarding how to make decisions for children are necessarily different than those regarding how to make decisions for once-competent adults. In the case of an adult rendered incompetent, it is in fact possible to find out what he would have wanted. One mearly consults his worlds and actions when he was competent. This cannot be done for children.

You know when your child is screaming in pain and distress while his foreskin is being ripped from his glans? That means HE DOESN'T WANT IT TO HAPPEN. Most parents pick up on that signal pretty early on. Perhaps you were too busy adjusting the focus on your camera or scoffing a sandwich to notice?

Thus, the rules regarding decision-making for children involve weighing their best interests. In no case does one ever consider the possible wishes of the child when he one day becomes competent.

Obviously not when you are a deluded (3rd time, I believe;)) follower of a barbaric religion you don't.

I am very sorry you do not like this. But this is not just the rule for people who like circumcision with "most humane people" thinking differently. This is the only rule there ever has been and the only one that makes sense. In Family Courts all across the nation today, it was this rule that judges used to conclude what visitation rights one parent should have. And that is just one of the many, many issues that are determined in this manner.

I think you'll find that Family Courts are attempting to get the input of children wherever possible before making a decision. Or at least they are in the UK.

Try, please, to comprehend this. It's actually a very simple concept.

I get it alright. It is a "concept" that allows you to continue mutilating children in the name of God.
 
And of course the people who came up with the current rules did not have an interest in maintaining the status quo.


The people who came up with the current rules are judges who have no interest in the outcome whatsoever.


How so? My only "rule" is that children will be protected from physical cruelty and mutilation of their body unless it provides (or is likely to provide) a significant medical benefit.


That's not what you said. What you said, sarcastically, was:
Ivor said:
Yeah, it really sounds like you have your son's wishes in mind
And then you quoted an article you found:
Ivor quoting an article he found said:
The objective of substituted judgment is to respect the autonomy of the incompetent or incapacitated patient by, as far as possible, enforcing that patient’s own wishes regarding care permitted.


So, you have attempted to promulgate a rule. You have argued that the wishes of eight day-olds should be considered when making decisions about them. In fact, you assume this rule again when you, quite coldly, write in the same post where you claim it's not the rule you want:

Ivor in the very same post said:
You know when your child is screaming in pain and distress while his foreskin is being ripped from his glans? That means HE DOESN'T WANT IT TO HAPPEN.


So, you have argued again and again that you think the wishes of eight day olds should be considered when making decisions about their care.

The truth is that this is, of course, ridiculous. My son screamed harder at being held down than during the actual circumcision. And he screamed much, much harder when we were giving him his antibiotics last week. His wishes are one possible indicator but are not and never should be the only barometer of what is in his best interests.


I know, I know, I'm a mean SOB.


Well, I'd say you are so attached to your issue that you will deny logic in order to preserve your opinion.


Don't US courts ask the child(ren) which parent they would like to live with?


If the child is old enough (around 11 or older), the courts may do so. However, the child's wishes are only one possible indicator of what is in the child's best interests. Plenty of children who suffer emotional, physical and even sexual abuse are absolutely devastated at the thought of being removed from their parents. Their wishes are, rightly, disregarded.


Or is it just which parent has the best lawyer in the States "wins" the custody of the children?


Canadian and US law are not significantly different on this issue.


You know when your child is screaming in pain and distress while his foreskin is being ripped from his glans? That means HE DOESN'T WANT IT TO HAPPEN. Most parents pick up on that signal pretty early on. Perhaps you were too busy adjusting the focus on your camera or scoffing a sandwich to notice?


1. I think you mean "scarfing" a sandwich. I didn't look disaprovingly at a sandwich.
2. We didn't have sandwiches at my first son's bris.
3. My eight day old son's wishes were of interest to me only insofar as they may have provided me some clues as to what was in his best interests. However, like every parent on the planet, I disregarded them when I judged that his best interests required something else.


Obviously not when you are a deluded (3rd time, I believe;)) follower of a barbaric religion you don't.


What I am (quite patiently) explaining to you has nothing to do with my religious beliefs. It is a simple and general rule designed to produce the best results for parents, children and society at large over a wide range of issues and circumstances.


I think you'll find that Family Courts are attempting to get the input of children wherever possible before making a decision.


I think you'll find that as a family law attorney with over ten years of experience in the courts of the State of New York that I do not give a rat's ass about your poorly informed lay opinion of what you believe courts are doing.
 
Last edited:
The people who came up with the current rules are judges who have no interest in the outcome whatsoever.

You really do believe this don’t you? How many of those judges were circumcised or had circumcised their children do you think?

So, you have attempted to promulgate a rule. You have argued that the wishes of eight day-olds should be considered when making decisions about them. In fact, you assume this rule again when you, quite coldly, write in the same post where you claim it's not the rule you want:

What I have argued for is blindingly obvious to people with an ounce of common sense. All humans find the experience of pain noxious and unless there is a significant objective benefit it should not be inflicted on them. Also there's the fact that very few men volunteer to have their foreskin removed when they have the opportunity to, thus is it reasonable to assume that a newborn would feel the same way.

So, you have argued again and again that you think the wishes of eight day olds should be considered when making decisions about their care.

Unless it is obvious that the physical mutilation and pain being inflicted are going to provide them with significant medical benefits then the default position should be to make the act illegal and wait until they can provide informed consent. They can have their foreskin removed in the future if they choose. You can't put it back once it’s gone.

The truth is that this is, of course, ridiculous. My son screamed harder at being held down than during the actual circumcision. And he screamed much, much harder when we were giving him his antibiotics last week. His wishes are one possible indicator but are not and never should be the only barometer of what is in his best interests.

It is not ridiculous and I have not argued otherwise. That is why I have said when there are clear medical benefits the inflicting of (necessary) pain is acceptable, but should still be minimised.

BTW, I’m hoping most people reading the first part of your last paragraph will realize how barbaric your chosen religion is. (Wrong word, I know; you had little choice.)

Well, I'd say you are so attached to your issue that you will deny logic in order to preserve your opinion.

This from a man whose actions are determined by what his Rabbi tells him:rolleyes:

No, my point of view on this issue is perfectly consistent. It is you who needs special exceptions, or a law so wide-open to abuse you could drive a truck through it so you can keep hurting and mutilating children in the name of God.

If the child is old enough (around 11 or older), the courts may do so. However, the child's wishes are only one possible indicator of what is in the child's best interests. Plenty of children who suffer emotional, physical and even sexual abuse are absolutely devastated at the thought of being removed from their parents. Their wishes are, rightly, disregarded.

No, they are not ‘disregarded’, they are weighed in to the decision.

Canadian and US law are not significantly different on this issue.

<--------- For a lawyer you’re not very observant.

1. I think you mean "scarfing" a sandwich. I didn't look disaprovingly at a sandwich.

No, I meant what I wrote. Apparently you are not aware of the common alternative meanings of the word ‘scoffing’.

2. We didn't have sandwiches at my first son's bris.

So you were too busy with your camera to bother about his screams?

3. My eight day old son's wishes were of interest to me only insofar as they may have provided me some clues as to what was in his best interests. However, like every parent on the planet, I disregarded them when I judged that his best interests required something else.

No, I’d say your behaviour towards children makes you a member of quite a, ahem, select bunch of parents in the developed world.

What I am (quite patiently) explaining to you has nothing to do with my religious beliefs. It is a simple and general rule designed to produce the best results for parents, children and society at large over a wide range of issues and circumstances.

It is a convenient rule that part-time child abusers can hide behind.

I think you'll find that as a family law attorney with over ten years of experience in the courts of the State of New York that I do not give a rat's ass about your poorly informed lay opinion of what you believe courts are doing.

There you go again. You think I’m trying to reach or change you. I'm not. I came to the conclusion long ago that you will never admit your actions are inhumane. However, your posts have been quite useful in demonstrating to others reading how cruel and thoughtless your treatment of children is.

Hopefully they will want to put some distance between your views on appropriate child rearing and their own.
 
Ivor, your rampant emotionalism has clouded your judgement. Loss Leader, your stubbornness has clouded yours. I suggest both of you step back and take a breath, before this thread gains the attention of the Civility Patrol.

Ivor, I can understand well your own points. However, Loss Leader is right on the legal issue. And until society as a whole determines that circumcision is child abuse - and it's certainly no more child abuse than ear piercing or removal of webbing from toes - your over-emotional reaction to what can be and often is a safe and painless procedure resulting in no long term hazard will remain out of line. Legally, a parent does have the right to choose circumcision for their children. Legally, a parent has the right to choose ear piercing. Legally, a parent could choose cosmetic surgery for their child. Nose reductions, facial restructurings, the whole nine yards. Legally, it's happened for years, and there's very little impetus to change those laws. If it's your opinion that the more enlightened cultures of Europe are working to outlaw the barbarism of a parent choosing elective cosmetic surgery for their child, and that this is a good thing, so be it. But it is your opinion, and nothing more. From an American standpoint, such efforts instead sound like attempting to remove a parent's inherent rights to make choices for their children. And it's nothing new, mind you. Even in the U.S. we suffer from more and more laws designed to cripple the practice of responsible parenting. Children can sue their parents for disciplinary measures, including groundings and restrictions. Children over here have WON lawsuits against their parents over having been grounded from outings with friends, or grounded from proms, etc. And our so-called experts have been no help, advising parents to let children choose what to wear, what to eat, what to watch, when to sleep, and so on and so forth.

It is my observation that as the rights of parents to control their children have diminished, so too has society as a whole diminished in quality and value. Granted, the issue of circumcision isn't one that's going to cause the collapse of modern civilization, but it's just one straw in a large bale, growing over the ages.

Circumcised men who feel they have been wronged by circumcision are in the vast minority, and chances are, until that minority grows significantly, circumcision will remain a normal practice. Anti-circs seem to think that this acceptance of our condition is some form of cognitive dissociation; the truth is, that whether they like this fact or not, circumcised men lead perfectly happy, healthy, and normal sex lives, unimpeded by having been circumcised. There's nothing to miss. There's nothing to be upset about. And that simple fact bothers the anti-circ crowd to no end.

Well, whatever happens, happens. I've done my damage, and chances are that these are the last children I'll have for a while anyway. But my kids will grow up knowing that nothing wrong was done to them, and they'll be able to decide for their own children. Maybe by then we'll have the gene therapy necessary to remove the foreskin from the gene code entirely. What a glorious future that will be!
 
I like how you people keep comparing it to removing webbing in toes, or big growths on the face, or whatever other stupid comparisons youve came up with.

Youre cutting off a part of your child, that will have no effect on them, until they are adults, youre sucker punching your children with your wishes. This pertains to, especially, the cosmetic issue, lets go over it.

Its a cosmetic issue, affecting your children in and area noone will see, except you and the fellow youve paid to cut up their penis. A cosmetic change that strictly applies to your idea of beauty, a cosmetic change that permanently alters the sexual function and appearance of another person. The only reason its done at infancy is because infants cant protest, other than crying for their parents, which seem to all be swept up in a haze of "look like daddy" "cleanliness" "my child is an object that belongs to me."

Circumcision is clearly a sexually motivated act. How is it that of all the things that are wrong with children when their born, just naturally of course, its the genitals. My girl needs her vagina made clean, my boy needs a clean penis, right. Your child needs a parent that will protect them from this sort of thing.

The alteration of the genitals isnt for any benefit of the child, its purely for the parent, subjugation, control, conformity.

Edit: Yeah also Z, how bout you go ask around to regular folk and see if they even know what a circumcision is. My mother didnt, my grandmother didnt. My dad did, which is a story to itself.

The various people Ive talked to generally reply with something weird. "They cut off the tip and pull the skin down." "If we didnt cut it off it would have grown together." "They dont use any clamp." "Babies have to have it done." Yeah, quit using people's ignorance of the procedure to advocate it. The few people that Ive told what it is, and sent information, with the exclusion of my family that refuses to believe theyve damaged me, all now know that the "procedure" is wrong, and have told at least to me that they wont have any future children done.

Find some statistics if you can, maybe from circlist, the ever popular reference for the procirc camp.
 
Last edited:
It is my observation that as the rights of parents to control their children have diminished, so too has society as a whole diminished in quality and value.
Evidence?

Granted, the issue of circumcision isn't one that's going to cause the collapse of modern civilization, but it's just one straw in a large bale, growing over the ages.
I'm sure that the FGM Act was just the first nail in the coffin of civilization. Are you then saying that it should be repealed on the basis of parental rights?

Circumcised men who feel they have been wronged by circumcision are in the vast minority, and chances are, until that minority grows significantly, circumcision will remain a normal practice.
Sure sucks when you've been irreparably harmed because of a cosmetic procedure. I don't mean self-image, I mean inability to have sex, inability to enjoy sex, painful sex, or to never have the chance to have sex, because they're dead. I know it didn't happen to you, or your relatives, so it's easily minimized, but the fact remains that people are harmed by this unnecessary procedure.

Anti-circs seem to think that this acceptance of our condition is some form of cognitive dissociation; the truth is, that whether they like this fact or not, circumcised men lead perfectly happy, healthy, and normal sex lives, unimpeded by having been circumcised. <snip> And that simple fact bothers the anti-circ crowd to no end.
Oh I know, and no, it doesn't "bother me to no end." In fact, that's great if some people aren't bothered by it. I'm glad that they can live with themselves. On the other hand, you should notice that I never said all men are dissatisfied, I said some.

Well, whatever happens, happens. I've done my damage, and chances are that these are the last children I'll have for a while anyway. But my kids will grow up knowing that nothing wrong was done to them, and they'll be able to decide for their own children. Maybe by then we'll have the gene therapy necessary to remove the foreskin from the gene code entirely. What a glorious future that will be!
So what's your evidence that circumcision should be practiced?

And, why can't circumcision wait until the child can decide for himself?
 
Evidence?

As I said, my own observations. 35 years of living, watching parents hamstringed in many areas, and in turn, watching people grow up without respect, discipline, decency, etc.

I'm sure that the FGM Act was just the first nail in the coffin of civilization. Are you then saying that it should be repealed on the basis of parental rights?

I'm against FGM in general, as to the best of my knowledge, the majority of those who practice it actually remove or damage the clitoris significantly. IFF this practice were limited in scope as circumcision, I might be for it. But that would also mean demonstrating that removal of the equivalent bit left the female equally as functional and capable of enjoyment as removal of the foreskin does for men.

If we were discussing MGM as in the removal of the head of the penis, castration, etc. then I would be against that. But we're not. We're talking about a procedure which, if done correctly, does not impact the future adult male whatsoever.

Sure sucks when you've been irreparably harmed because of a cosmetic procedure. I don't mean self-image, I mean inability to have sex, inability to enjoy sex, painful sex, or to never have the chance to have sex, because they're dead. I know it didn't happen to you, or your relatives, so it's easily minimized, but the fact remains that people are harmed by this unnecessary procedure.

No. People are harmed by the procedure being done incorrectly. I'm against ANY incompetent surgery or doctors. Hundreds of people have died from botched appendectomies... are you saying we should not perform this surgery either? Some people are harmed from the removal of their wisdom teeth - so does that make their removal a barbaric and dangerous practice?

Or perhaps you'd care to show the records of circumcisions done properly which resulted in the inability to have sex, enjoy sex, have painless sex, etc? I doubt you'll find any.

No, circumcisions are not done properly in many parts of the world. And those practicioners should be stopped. I for one do not think that the Jews should be leaving circumcisions up to their religious practicioners, either. Nor should circumcision be done by witch doctors in Africa, or shamen on the reservations, or any other unskilled and unequipped individuals.

Oh I know, and no, it doesn't "bother me to no end." In fact, that's great if some people aren't bothered by it. I'm glad that they can live with themselves. On the other hand, you should notice that I never said all men are dissatisfied, I said some.

Indeed - few.

So what's your evidence that circumcision should be practiced?

50% reduction in the spread of HIV is good enough for me. As for any other evidence, I've presented what I have, as have others. NONE of that is good enough for some of you, and that's fine. Further discussion is irrelevant, then, isn't it?

And, why can't circumcision wait until the child can decide for himself?

Because a parent is more likely to make a good judgement than a child. Is that same child guaranteed to practice only safe sex until such time as he has his circumcision done? Further, quicker recovery times, less chance of complications, the pain - if any - is quickly forgotten (forever, no less), etc. All very good reasons to do it in infancy. Plus, adolescent males might well fear such a procedure for no more complicated reason than they think of it as 'slicing the penis'. Certainly, I'd be apprehensive about having such a procedure done as an adult - I'd much rather the procedure be done to me at a time when I'd be certain to forget all about it.

And what age can a child 'decide for himself'? When is the child going to be mature enough to properly weigh the benefits versus the risks, and come to a rational judgement? Heck, some people with decades of life behind them can't make rational judgements for anything. And someone who isn't mature enough to rationally decide whether or not to become circumcised is also not mature enough to rationally avoid unsafe sex.

Really, though, I think this thread has gone its course, many times over. The anticirc crowd are unswayed by ANY arguments, whatsoever. They prefer to see this as a horrible, bloody, painful mutilation of the penis, with nothing but sorrow, pain, and suffering for the life of the adult. They show videos and images of circumcisions being done incorrectly, using archaic techniques and without anesthesia. They appeal to the emotions by deliberately using evocative language and misrepresenting modern circumcision methods. They quote-mine a few doctors who have concerns about circumcision in general. They make strange attempts to compare removal of the foreskin to removal of the entire clitoris. They scream for the non-existant rights of infants to make decisions that they absolutely cannot make, and would gleefully prevent any parent from making such decisions for the infant.

Yes, I find it regrettable that some people have suffered at the hands of incompetent practioners who botched the circumcision procedure, used antiquated techniques and no pain relief, and left their victims mutilated and impaired. Such a horror, really, that medical incompetence exists anywhere in the world today. But I feel just fine with the modern practice of circumcision, having witnessed five of them in person, and seeing no distress on my sons' faces nor in their few quiet sobs. The results are excellent, handsome, hygenic, and I'm reasonably sure fully functional. And having lived my life as a circumcised male, I'm certain beyond a shadow of a doubt that each of them will have as full and pleasurable a sex life as I have had, and mine is nothing to complain about, for certain.

My opinion is that circumcision should be mandatory, on the basis of the reduction of the spread of HIV alone; but that all circumcisions should be done using the most up-to-date methods, equipment, and pain relief available. My opinion is that it is inherently the right of the parent to decide whether or not to have circumcision done, just as it is inherently the right to decide whether or not a child will have pierced ears, a tattoo, cosmetic reconstructive surgery, haircuts, makeup, personal clothing choices, dietary choices, etc.

Should society so change that circumcision becomes equated with child abuse, so be it. I find that to be an unlikely change to occur, but it could happen. But at the moment, there's no pressure to change my opinions, and no evidence that doing so would in any way benefit anyone involved, so I'll hold my opinion for now.

Certainly no one on THIS thread has given me any reason to reconsider that opinion.

But please, carry on with the emotional outcries, the strawman arguments, the appeals to outdated procedure and medical incompetence in general. Carry on ignoring the vast majority of circumcised men who are quite pleased with their willies. Carry on focusing on the minority that feel wronged or damaged or ashamed. Insult me, insult my opinions, desperately try to make false analogies to mutilations and castrations. Perhaps you can sway a few less rational fence-sitters to your point of view. Congratulations, if you do. Condolences, if you don't. But I believe that, once more, the only rational act left to me on this thread is to bow out, unsubscribe, and let the 'debate' rage on unimpeded.

Good day.
 
As I said, my own observations. 35 years of living, watching parents hamstringed in many areas, and in turn, watching people grow up without respect, discipline, decency, etc.

And all of that has absolutely nothing to do with circumcision.

I'm against FGM in general, as to the best of my knowledge, the majority of those who practice it actually remove or damage the clitoris significantly. IFF this practice were limited in scope as circumcision, I might be for it. But that would also mean demonstrating that removal of the equivalent bit left the female equally as functional and capable of enjoyment as removal of the foreskin does for men.

Why perform unnecessary medical procedures?

If we were discussing MGM as in the removal of the head of the penis, castration, etc. then I would be against that. But we're not. We're talking about a procedure which, if done correctly, does not impact the future adult male whatsoever.

Outright lie. A large amount of highly sensitive and functional tissue is removed. Not that you have any idea what that may feel like.

No. People are harmed by the procedure being done incorrectly. I'm against ANY incompetent surgery or doctors. Hundreds of people have died from botched appendectomies... are you saying we should not perform this surgery either? Some people are harmed from the removal of their wisdom teeth - so does that make their removal a barbaric and dangerous practice?

Cosmetic surgery performed on a non-consenting individual, other than that to correct a deformity, is unethical.

Prophylactic surgery performed for an unlikely to be realised benefit on a non-consenting individual is unethical.

Or perhaps you'd care to show the records of circumcisions done properly which resulted in the inability to have sex, enjoy sex, have painless sex, etc? I doubt you'll find any.

If an individual has never known what sex feels like with a normal penis they probably don’t know that they have had their enjoyment reduced.

No, circumcisions are not done properly in many parts of the world. And those practicioners should be stopped. I for one do not think that the Jews should be leaving circumcisions up to their religious practicioners, either. Nor should circumcision be done by witch doctors in Africa, or shamen on the reservations, or any other unskilled and unequipped individuals.

Of course not. When someone wearing a white coat abuses a child you think it's medicine.

Indeed - few.

So as long as the victims of abuse think it’s “normal” it isn’t abuse?

50% reduction in the spread of HIV is good enough for me. As for any other evidence, I've presented what I have, as have others. NONE of that is good enough for some of you, and that's fine. Further discussion is irrelevant, then, isn't it?

Another lie. Circumcision does not reduce the spread of HIV by 50%. Circumcision provides a 50% risk reduction for an individual contracting HIV per vaginal sexual encounter. And that has only been demonstrated in an area of the world with high incidence of HIV, where it is spread mainly by heterosexual intercourse.

Because a parent is more likely to make a good judgement than a child.

“Good” is in eye of the beholder.

Is that same child guaranteed to practice only safe sex until such time as he has his circumcision done?

No. Is circumcision guaranteed to protect him?

Further, quicker recovery times, less chance of complications, the pain - if any - is quickly forgotten (forever, no less), etc. All very good reasons to do it in infancy.

Again with the “pain – if any” comment. CIRCUMCISION IS PAINFUL. The pain is not “quickly” forgotten.

Plus, adolescent males might well fear such a procedure for no more complicated reason than they think of it as 'slicing the penis'. Certainly, I'd be apprehensive about having such a procedure done as an adult - I'd much rather the procedure be done to me at a time when I'd be certain to forget all about it.

They might not want it done because they like their penis the way it is.

And what age can a child 'decide for himself'? When is the child going to be mature enough to properly weigh the benefits versus the risks, and come to a rational judgement? Heck, some people with decades of life behind them can't make rational judgements for anything. And someone who isn't mature enough to rationally decide whether or not to become circumcised is also not mature enough to rationally avoid unsafe sex.

Circumcision does not stop someone contracting HIV or other STD’s.

Really, though, I think this thread has gone its course, many times over. The anticirc crowd are unswayed by ANY arguments, whatsoever. They prefer to see this as a horrible, bloody, painful mutilation of the penis, with nothing but sorrow, pain, and suffering for the life of the adult. They show videos and images of circumcisions being done incorrectly, using archaic techniques and without anesthesia. They appeal to the emotions by deliberately using evocative language and misrepresenting modern circumcision methods. They quote-mine a few doctors who have concerns about circumcision in general. They make strange attempts to compare removal of the foreskin to removal of the entire clitoris. They scream for the non-existant rights of infants to make decisions that they absolutely cannot make, and would gleefully prevent any parent from making such decisions for the infant.

Yet more lies.

Yes, I find it regrettable that some people have suffered at the hands of incompetent practioners who botched the circumcision procedure, used antiquated techniques and no pain relief, and left their victims mutilated and impaired. Such a horror, really, that medical incompetence exists anywhere in the world today. But I feel just fine with the modern practice of circumcision, having witnessed five of them in person, and seeing no distress on my sons' faces nor in their few quiet sobs. The results are excellent, handsome, hygenic, and I'm reasonably sure fully functional. And having lived my life as a circumcised male, I'm certain beyond a shadow of a doubt that each of them will have as full and pleasurable a sex life as I have had, and mine is nothing to complain about, for certain.

...and some more lies.

My opinion is that circumcision should be mandatory, on the basis of the reduction of the spread of HIV alone; but that all circumcisions should be done using the most up-to-date methods, equipment, and pain relief available. My opinion is that it is inherently the right of the parent to decide whether or not to have circumcision done, just as it is inherently the right to decide whether or not a child will have pierced ears, a tattoo, cosmetic reconstructive surgery, haircuts, makeup, personal clothing choices, dietary choices, etc.

A nice demonstration of how extreme your opinions are. Mandatory circumcision indeed.

Should society so change that circumcision becomes equated with child abuse, so be it. I find that to be an unlikely change to occur, but it could happen. But at the moment, there's no pressure to change my opinions, and no evidence that doing so would in any way benefit anyone involved, so I'll hold my opinion for now.

You do that.

Certainly no one on THIS thread has given me any reason to reconsider that opinion.

But you weren’t even trying.

But please, carry on with the emotional outcries, the strawman arguments, the appeals to outdated procedure and medical incompetence in general. Carry on ignoring the vast majority of circumcised men who are quite pleased with their willies. Carry on focusing on the minority that feel wronged or damaged or ashamed. Insult me, insult my opinions, desperately try to make false analogies to mutilations and castrations. Perhaps you can sway a few less rational fence-sitters to your point of view. Congratulations, if you do. Condolences, if you don't. But I believe that, once more, the only rational act left to me on this thread is to bow out, unsubscribe, and let the 'debate' rage on unimpeded.

Good day.

And you finish off with another load of lies.

Tell me Z, are you and Kleinman related?
 
Last edited:
If an individual has never known what sex feels like with a normal penis they probably don’t know that they have had their enjoyment reduced.


And if an individual has never known what sex feels like with a circumcised penis, they probably don't know that they have had their enjoyment reduced.

There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex.

Just because it may seem to you that circumcision would reduce sexual enjoyment does not mean that it's necessarily true. And, in fact, there is no scientific evidence that it is true - just anecdotes.
 
There is no evidence that circumcision makes sex less enjoyable other than personal anexdotes from both sides about how much they like sex.

I think there's a difference between "conflicting evidence" and "no evidence".
 
Also lack of evidence should certainly come down in favor of the anti-circ camp because when performing a procedure of this kind it has to be shown that it doesn't cause any harm. The default position (e.g. how you are born) has to be overridden by evidence, not the other way around.

Studying sexually related issues is extremely difficult which means the pro-circ crowd has a very high mountain to climb.
 
I don't mean self-image, I mean inability to have sex, inability to enjoy sex, painful sex, or to never have the chance to have sex, because they're dead.

The problem with the dead baby argument is that there are dead babies on both sides.

Just thought you'd want to know.

Linda
 
Also lack of evidence should certainly come down in favor of the anti-circ camp because when performing a procedure of this kind it has to be shown that it doesn't cause any harm. The default position (e.g. how you are born) has to be overridden by evidence, not the other way around.

Studying sexually related issues is extremely difficult which means the pro-circ crowd has a very high mountain to climb.

But technically, there is lots of evidence that circumcision reduces sexual pleasure, and decreases sensation. There is also evidence that it doesn't, though. And I'm talking about scientific studies, not anecdotes.

But there actually isn't any evidence that circumcised penises are more sensitive than intact ones. So in my opinion, pooling the results has to swing in favor of intact being more sensitive, since all the studies that find a difference find the difference of intact as the more sensitive.

For it to be a total draw, you'd need some studies that show that circumcised penises are more sensitive than intact ones. And that evidence doesn't exist.
 
Also lack of evidence should certainly come down in favor of the anti-circ camp because when performing a procedure of this kind it has to be shown that it doesn't cause any harm. The default position (e.g. how you are born) has to be overridden by evidence, not the other way around.

Studying sexually related issues is extremely difficult which means the pro-circ crowd has a very high mountain to climb.


Oh, you're quite wrong. When preforming a procedure of this kind, it has to be show to be in the child's best interests. That's more difficult than just showing it doesn't cause any harm.

Where we part ways is that most all of the reasons it is in a child's best interests are discounted by you and your fellow foreskinners as having no value whatsoever. Unfortunately for you, just about everyone who isn't you disagrees.
 
When preforming a procedure of this kind, it has to be show to be in the child's best interests. That's more difficult than just showing it doesn't cause any harm.

Actually, it's easier, as you yourself have demonstrated: simply CLAIM it is in the child's best interests. How do we know? Because you believe it, and for some strange reason you presume to speak on behalf of your infant (who cannot speak) in more areas than you're ethically entitled to. You believe so strongly that you say things like "his religion" -- how can your infant son, who cannot read a book or have a conversation, have a religion?

your fellow foreskinners

The way you use that it almost sounds derogatory. Antiforeskinnic!
 
Damn, this thread keeps going. Lots of catching up to do...

The last thing my son said to me today was, "cow, moo." And I can say with perfect confidence that, unlike the last thing you said to me, it wasn't antisemitic.
When will you stop being a drama queen?

You are a hate-monger and antisemite of the worst stripe. *absurdly hysterical outburst edited*
I see. Nevermind.


In my case, I believe the world is better off with Jews than without them.
Assuming here that Jews = people who follow Judaism and not the ethnic group... why? And how can you sincerely claim that abandoning circumcision will spell the end of Judaism with a straight face?

As the forces of assimilation are relentless, I believe it is my duty to continue the traditions of Judaism. This is not necessarily because I believe in God but because if I do not practice Judaism, it might make it harder for the next person to do so. I never want to hear the argument made to my neighbor, "Well, Loss Leader didn't circumcise his kid and he's Jewish, so you shouldn't circumcise yours" or "Why don't you eat pork? Loss Leader eats pork and he's just as Jewish as you are."

I hope that clears things up.

Not even remotely, to a rational mind at least. In fact, it makes no sense whatsoever. I hope you can at least admit that you are being 100% irrational and blind in your faith. And thus one can't help but wonder why you are on a Skeptics' forum.

Since your decision isn't based on objective evidence, is there anything that would convince you to change your mind about circumcision and would make you no longer want to practice it? Anything at all?
If his rabbi said so, he'd follow. Gotta love sheep.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom