As I said, my own observations. 35 years of living, watching parents hamstringed in many areas, and in turn, watching people grow up without respect, discipline, decency, etc.
I'm sure that the FGM Act was just the first nail in the coffin of civilization. Are you then saying that it should be repealed on the basis of parental rights?
I'm against FGM in general, as to the best of my knowledge, the majority of those who practice it actually remove or damage the clitoris significantly. IFF this practice were limited in scope as circumcision, I might be for it. But that would also mean demonstrating that removal of the equivalent bit left the female equally as functional and capable of enjoyment as removal of the foreskin does for men.
If we were discussing MGM as in the removal of the head of the penis, castration, etc. then I would be against that. But we're not. We're talking about a procedure which, if done correctly, does not impact the future adult male whatsoever.
Sure sucks when you've been irreparably harmed because of a cosmetic procedure. I don't mean self-image, I mean inability to have sex, inability to enjoy sex, painful sex, or to never have the chance to have sex, because they're dead. I know it didn't happen to you, or your relatives, so it's easily minimized, but the fact remains that people are harmed by this unnecessary procedure.
No. People are harmed by the procedure being done incorrectly. I'm against ANY incompetent surgery or doctors. Hundreds of people have died from botched appendectomies... are you saying we should not perform this surgery either? Some people are harmed from the removal of their wisdom teeth - so does that make their removal a barbaric and dangerous practice?
Or perhaps you'd care to show the records of circumcisions done properly which resulted in the inability to have sex, enjoy sex, have painless sex, etc? I doubt you'll find any.
No, circumcisions are not done properly in many parts of the world. And those practicioners should be stopped. I for one do not think that the Jews should be leaving circumcisions up to their religious practicioners, either. Nor should circumcision be done by witch doctors in Africa, or shamen on the reservations, or any other unskilled and unequipped individuals.
Oh I know, and no, it doesn't "bother me to no end." In fact, that's great if some people aren't bothered by it. I'm glad that they can live with themselves. On the other hand, you should notice that I never said all men are dissatisfied, I said some.
Indeed - few.
So what's your evidence that circumcision should be practiced?
50% reduction in the spread of HIV is good enough for me. As for any other evidence, I've presented what I have, as have others. NONE of that is good enough for some of you, and that's fine. Further discussion is irrelevant, then, isn't it?
And, why can't circumcision wait until the child can decide for himself?
Because a parent is more likely to make a good judgement than a child. Is that same child guaranteed to practice only safe sex until such time as he has his circumcision done? Further, quicker recovery times, less chance of complications, the pain - if any - is quickly forgotten (forever, no less), etc. All very good reasons to do it in infancy. Plus, adolescent males might well fear such a procedure for no more complicated reason than they think of it as 'slicing the penis'. Certainly, I'd be apprehensive about having such a procedure done as an adult - I'd much rather the procedure be done to me at a time when I'd be certain to forget all about it.
And what age can a child 'decide for himself'? When is the child going to be mature enough to properly weigh the benefits versus the risks, and come to a rational judgement? Heck, some people with decades of life behind them can't make rational judgements for anything. And someone who isn't mature enough to rationally decide whether or not to become circumcised is also not mature enough to rationally avoid unsafe sex.
Really, though, I think this thread has gone its course, many times over. The anticirc crowd are unswayed by ANY arguments, whatsoever. They prefer to see this as a horrible, bloody, painful mutilation of the penis, with nothing but sorrow, pain, and suffering for the life of the adult. They show videos and images of circumcisions being done incorrectly, using archaic techniques and without anesthesia. They appeal to the emotions by deliberately using evocative language and misrepresenting modern circumcision methods. They quote-mine a few doctors who have concerns about circumcision in general. They make strange attempts to compare removal of the foreskin to removal of the entire clitoris. They scream for the non-existant rights of infants to make decisions that they absolutely cannot make, and would gleefully prevent any parent from making such decisions for the infant.
Yes, I find it regrettable that some people have suffered at the hands of incompetent practioners who botched the circumcision procedure, used antiquated techniques and no pain relief, and left their victims mutilated and impaired. Such a horror, really, that medical incompetence exists anywhere in the world today. But I feel just fine with the modern practice of circumcision, having witnessed five of them in person, and seeing no distress on my sons' faces nor in their few quiet sobs. The results are excellent, handsome, hygenic, and I'm reasonably sure fully functional. And having lived my life as a circumcised male, I'm certain beyond a shadow of a doubt that each of them will have as full and pleasurable a sex life as I have had, and mine is nothing to complain about, for certain.
My opinion is that circumcision should be mandatory, on the basis of the reduction of the spread of HIV alone; but that all circumcisions should be done using the most up-to-date methods, equipment, and pain relief available. My opinion is that it is inherently the right of the parent to decide whether or not to have circumcision done, just as it is inherently the right to decide whether or not a child will have pierced ears, a tattoo, cosmetic reconstructive surgery, haircuts, makeup, personal clothing choices, dietary choices, etc.
Should society so change that circumcision becomes equated with child abuse, so be it. I find that to be an unlikely change to occur, but it could happen. But at the moment, there's no pressure to change my opinions, and no evidence that doing so would in any way benefit anyone involved, so I'll hold my opinion for now.
Certainly no one on THIS thread has given me any reason to reconsider that opinion.
But please, carry on with the emotional outcries, the strawman arguments, the appeals to outdated procedure and medical incompetence in general. Carry on ignoring the vast majority of circumcised men who are quite pleased with their willies. Carry on focusing on the minority that feel wronged or damaged or ashamed. Insult me, insult my opinions, desperately try to make false analogies to mutilations and castrations. Perhaps you can sway a few less rational fence-sitters to your point of view. Congratulations, if you do. Condolences, if you don't. But I believe that, once more, the only rational act left to me on this thread is to bow out, unsubscribe, and let the 'debate' rage on unimpeded.
Good day.