Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I'm still amazed that people can justify cutting off body parts from unconsenting children that have no need of this surgery. This is yet another sign of how insane our world really is.


They're not unconsenting, they're incapable of consent. There's a difference.
 
If the pro-circs do respond to this, they'll probably say I'm wrong, and that's not how they think at all.


You are wrong. That's not how I think at all.


Well, only they can know, but I'm skeptical of their self-analysis ability, if they can't even honestly question their own beliefs.


You've engaged in circular reasoning. You assume I cannot honestly question my own beliefs to conclude that I have poor self-analysis ability. Self-analysis and questioning oneself is the same thing. You've assumed I cannot question myself to conclude that I cannot question myself.

In fact, your assumption is unwarranted and is based on nothing other than your own personal beliefs.
 
It is under the following conditions: 1) the decision maker holds the medical proxy of the coma patient; 2) the procedure is in the patient's best interests.

I think in the case of infant circumcision (2) should be restated as:

2) The procedure is unlikely to kill the patient and he will be unable to know what he has lost.

The reasons you have provided for circumcising your son are definitely not in his interests, they are for the benefit of others in your community.

You are forcing him to sacrifice his foreskin for your community and you hide behind the law of substituted judgment.
 
This is interesting.

MONDAY, March 5 (HealthDay News) -- Researchers have discovered that cells in the mucosal lining of human genitalia produce a protein that "eats up" invading HIV -- possibly keeping the spread of the AIDS more contained than it might otherwise be.

Even more important, enhancing the activity of this protein, called Langerin, could be a potent new way to curtail the transmission of the virus that causes AIDS, the Dutch scientists added.
 
I think in the case of infant circumcision (2) should be restated as:

2) The procedure is unlikely to kill the patient and he will be unable to know what he has lost.


That's not the rule.


The reasons you have provided for circumcising your son are in my opinion definitely not in his interests, in my opinion they are for the benefit of others in your community.

In my opinion, you are forcing him to sacrifice his foreskin for your community and in my opinion you hide behind the law of substituted judgment.


Fixed it for you.
 
Not my opinion LL, your words:

You see, I circumcise my children for the Jewish people. I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. I have no fear of what God will do to me (or my children) and I have no fear of what other Jews might think of me. I live in terror that my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.

Yeah, it really sounds like you have your son's wishes in mind:rolleyes:
 
The reasons you have provided for circumcising your son are definitely not in his interests, they are for the benefit of others in your community.

You are forcing him to sacrifice his foreskin for your community and you hide behind the law of substituted judgment.


The reasons you have provided for circumcising your son are in my opinion definitely not in his interests, in my opinion they are for the benefit of others in your community.

In my opinion, you are forcing him to sacrifice his foreskin for your community and in my opinion you hide behind the law of substituted judgment.

Fixed it for you.

Editing another members post will get you banned from this forum, (unless you are a Mod). You can do it, just don't use the quote function, so someone could be confused. Make it clear it is your words, not another members, when you post.

I learned this the hard way.
 
Editing another members post will get you banned from this forum, (unless you are a Mod). You can do it, just don't use the quote function, so someone could be confused. Make it clear it is your words, not another members, when you post.

I learned this the hard way.


Thank you for the reminder. I believe I followed the rule. My use of bold and italics as well as the common phrase "fixed it for you" made it clear that I had added the words as an editorial comment.

Anyone who cares to is free to complain.
 
Yeah, it really sounds like you have your son's wishes in mind:rolleyes:


I honestly don't know how else to clarify this:

I do NOT have my son's wishes in mind. I have my son's best interests in mind. Not only is that all that is required of me, but it's all that makes sense. Who honestly cares about the wishes of an eight day old?

I have a son who is two. He wished for breakfast this morning to have cookies. I know because he told me over and over, "Cookie!" I absolutely, completely and joyfully ignored his wishes. Instead, I fed him toast with cream cheese, strawberries and milk. I did so because I had his best interests in mind.

Get it right.
 
I honestly don't know how else to clarify this:

I do NOT have my son's wishes in mind. I have my son's best interests in mind. Not only is that all that is required of me, but it's all that makes sense. Who honestly cares about the wishes of an eight day old?

I have a son who is two. He wished for breakfast this morning to have cookies. I know because he told me over and over, "Cookie!" I absolutely, completely and joyfully ignored his wishes. Instead, I fed him toast with cream cheese, strawberries and milk. I did so because I had his best interests in mind.

Get it right.

It's cute the way you try to trivialize ritual child abuse by using ridiculous examples such as the one above. Presumably you did not hold your son down on the kitchen table and ram the food in his mouth?

Anyhow, care to address what you actually wrote?

LossLeader said:
You see, I circumcise my children for the Jewish people. I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. I have no fear of what God will do to me (or my children) and I have no fear of what other Jews might think of me. I live in terror that my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.

http://www.lib.mcg.edu/edu/drdilemma...lt/subjudg.htm

Substituted Judgment: The objective of substituted judgment is to respect the autonomy of the incompetent or incapacitated patient by, as far as possible, enforcing that patient’s own wishes regarding care permitted. This means that the person authorized to give consent on behalf of such a patient tries to determine what the patient would have wanted had he or she understood the circumstances under which treatment or procedures would be provided.
 
It's cute the way you try to trivialize ritual child abuse by using ridiculous examples such as the one above.


It's cute the way you are incapable of learning no matter how many times information is presented to you. Now that we got that out of the way:


Presumably you did not hold your son down on the kitchen table and ram the food in his mouth?


In fact, I have forceably rammed food into my son's mouth despite his vehement protestations. He won't try new things and would be eating nothing but banana yogurt if I hadn't.

Recently, my wife and I were required to force him to swallow antibiotics. The thrashing, screaming, spitting and crying were most unpleasant. Actually, he cried harder and about five times longer twice a day when we gave him his antibiotics than when he was circumcised.

Anyhow, care to address what you actually wrote?
You see, I circumcise my children for the Jewish people. I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. I have no fear of what God will do to me (or my children) and I have no fear of what other Jews might think of me. I live in terror that my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.


Sure. It is in my son's best interests for me to circumcise my children for the Jewish people. It is in his best interests to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. It is in his best interests to avoid a world where my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.

http://www.lib.mcg.edu/edu/drdilemma...lt/subjudg.htm
Substituted Judgment: The objective of substituted judgment is to respect the autonomy of the incompetent or incapacitated patient by, as far as possible, enforcing that patient’s own wishes regarding care permitted. This means that the person authorized to give consent on behalf of such a patient tries to determine what the patient would have wanted had he or she understood the circumstances under which treatment or procedures would be provided.


This link did not work.

However, it is quite clear that the paragraph you quoted is only vaguely right. It only has meaning or aplicability when discussing substituted judgment for a person who had previously been competent. It is true, to the limited extent that it is, only when considering the best interests of an adult later rendered incompetent.

Children, on the other hand, have never been competent. There was never a period where they expressed their wishes after fully weighing the risks and benefits of a procedure. For this reason, the paragraph you quoted is utterly and completely without meaning when applied to children. It is not the rule and no amount of hand waiving by you can make it so.
 
<snip>
In fact, I have forceably rammed food into my son's mouth despite his vehement protestations. He won't try new things and would be eating nothing but banana yogurt if I hadn't.

And if he really didn't like it he could spit it out. Or do you hold his nose and mouth shut and force him to swallow?

Recently, my wife and I were required to force him to swallow antibiotics. The thrashing, screaming, spitting and crying were most unpleasant. Actually, he cried harder and about five times longer twice a day when we gave him his antibiotics than when he was circumcised.

Presumably there was a medical need for him having antibiotics, so this is yet another ridiculous example.

Sure. It is in my son's best interests for me to circumcise my children for the Jewish people. It is in his best interests to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. It is in his best interests to avoid a world where my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.

Please explain how mutilating your son's genitals and inflicting pain on him for "the Jewish people" is in his interests. (Reading your twisted logic is quite entertaining.)

However, it is quite clear that the paragraph you quoted is only vaguely right. It only has meaning or aplicability when discussing substituted judgment for a person who had previously been competent. It is true, to the limited extent that it is, only when considering the best interests of an adult later rendered incompetent.

Children, on the other hand, have never been competent. There was never a period where they expressed their wishes after fully weighing the risks and benefits of a procedure. For this reason, the paragraph you quoted is utterly and completely without meaning when applied to children. It is not the rule and no amount of hand waiving by you can make it so.

It is only without meaning for you and people like you who wish to inflict pain and suffering on children for ritual or cultural reasons. Most humane people understand it perfectly.
 
It is only without meaning for you and people like you who wish to inflict pain and suffering on children for ritual or cultural reasons. Most humane people understand it perfectly.


You are wrong.

It's not surprising, you're engaging in an ends-oriented analysis. You want the answer to come out a certain way so you are backwards-engineering a rule that will get you to your answer.

However, your rule leaves a mess in just about every other area where decision-making for children is involved.

Courts have long concluded that it is impossible to know what a child would want if he were competent. This is true no matter what the issue is: whether to have a medical procedure, what to eat for breakfast, which parent to live with after a divorce, etc.

Courts are not in the habit of consulting tarrot cards or navel gazing. They do not simply guess about things that cannot under any circumstance ever be known.

Thus, the rules regarding how to make decisions for children are necessarily different than those regarding how to make decisions for once-competent adults. In the case of an adult rendered incompetent, it is in fact possible to find out what he would have wanted. One mearly consults his worlds and actions when he was competent. This cannot be done for children.

Thus, the rules regarding decision-making for children involve weighing their best interests. In no case does one ever consider the possible wishes of the child when he one day becomes competent.

I am very sorry you do not like this. But this is not just the rule for people who like circumcision with "most humane people" thinking differently. This is the only rule there ever has been and the only one that makes sense. In Family Courts all across the nation today, it was this rule that judges used to conclude what visitation rights one parent should have. And that is just one of the many, many issues that are determined in this manner.

Try, please, to comprehend this. It's actually a very simple concept.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom