Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Ah, osmosis back again after his little holiday? Goodness.

Yep, and I've got a wicked tan and brought tequila shooters for everyone.. well, almost everyone.

ps. who are you and why won't you go away.
 
"It's hard to get a woo to change."
For the same reasons that scientists shouldn't bother debating Creationists...

"What about the folks that actually do it for a living?"
... AND hide behind Religion and/or "Tradition" as if that somehow makes a deplorable action o.k....

"I owe a debt to my mother who refused..."
Kiss her on the cheek for me too would ya!
 
Go Australia!

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22227225-2862,00.html

CIRCUMCISION will be banned in Victorian public hospitals unless it is for medical reasons.

The State Government has ordered the ban, which starts next month, following medical advice that circumcision of baby boys was unnecessary.

Health Minister Daniel Andrews said circumcisions would be performed only when doctors were concerned about infection or disease.

"Nationally and overseas, doctors agree there is no medical benefit to routine circumcision, and studies show the complication rate is about 5 per cent," Mr Andrews said.
 
Re: The title of the OP

I am at least a little bit rational, and yes, I can defend the practice of non-medically indicated circumcision.

Brace yourselves, here goes: IT IS A COSMETIC DECISION MADE BY THE PARENTS.

Would you like to go anecdote to anecdote? I can cite dozens of women who are of the opinion that being circumcised is the only way to get a man to last long enough to satisfy them. I can also imagine others who would say the opposite. I do not claim to know the opinion of the infants themselves, but all evidence suggests that they are largely unaware of the arguments, pro and con, and are much more likely to be concerned with being fed and held.

Why are you not going after the insidious practitioners of umbilical cord dissection, as the umbilical cord is just as much a part of an infant as the foreskin? In every other species, the baby has no doctor to dissect the umbilical cord, and does so on its own, when it seems the right time.

Oh, and by the way, the placenta is an organ of and for the infant. It is composed of tissues derived only from the infants genetic code. Did you get a signed consent form before you took the huge step of deciding for your infant that she or he did not need their placenta? Or are you one of the barbaric horde who have taken it upon themselves to decide for the infant that it no longer needs this vital and functional organ?

Grow the hell up. We make decisions for our kids all the time that are infinitely more life-altering than deciding to remove a bit of tissue here or there. The foreskin is just a bit of tissue attached to the shaft of the penis, and it is obviously not vital, as ever increasing numbers of people don't have one.
I would never imagine that I was in a position to tell a person to circumcise their child, as I would consider it to be the acme of arrogance. Likewise, I would not consider telling a parent to not pierce their child's ears, even though I think that it is just plain tacky.
Circumcision is a cosmetic procedure. That's all.
How involved in the lives of everyone else on the planet do you intend to get? I would bet my last penny that if you took one moment to look at the actual problems in the world, circumcision would begin to seem almost... what's the word?...oh, yeah: IRRELEVANT.
 
Re: The title of the OP

I am at least a little bit rational, and yes, I can defend the practice of non-medically indicated circumcision.

Brace yourselves, here goes: IT IS A COSMETIC DECISION MADE BY THE PARENTS.

Would you like to go anecdote to anecdote? I can cite dozens of women who are of the opinion that being circumcised is the only way to get a man to last long enough to satisfy them. I can also imagine others who would say the opposite. I do not claim to know the opinion of the infants themselves, but all evidence suggests that they are largely unaware of the arguments, pro and con, and are much more likely to be concerned with being fed and held.

…and not having (unnecessary) pain inflicted on them.

Why are you not going after the insidious practitioners of umbilical cord dissection, as the umbilical cord is just as much a part of an infant as the foreskin? In every other species, the baby has no doctor to dissect the umbilical cord, and does so on its own, when it seems the right time.

The umbilical cord, at some point, needs to be detached.

Oh, and by the way, the placenta is an organ of and for the infant. It is composed of tissues derived only from the infants genetic code. Did you get a signed consent form before you took the huge step of deciding for your infant that she or he did not need their placenta? Or are you one of the barbaric horde who have taken it upon themselves to decide for the infant that it no longer needs this vital and functional organ?

See above.

Cutting the umbilical cord and removing the placenta are not equivalent to circumcision for any educated, rational person.

Grow the hell up. We make decisions for our kids all the time that are infinitely more life-altering than deciding to remove a bit of tissue here or there. The foreskin is just a bit of tissue attached to the shaft of the penis, and it is obviously not vital, as ever increasing numbers of people don't have one.

I think you meant to say “ever decreasing numbers of people don’t have one.”:)

I would never imagine that I was in a position to tell a person to circumcise their child, as I would consider it to be the acme of arrogance. Likewise, I would not consider telling a parent to not pierce their child's ears, even though I think that it is just plain tacky.

You appear to think a child’s body is the property of its parents and to do with as they wish, so long as it doesn’t kill him (or her).

Circumcision is a cosmetic procedure. That's all.

Circumcision is not just a cosmetic procedure. Just because you want to believe that it is and repeat it over and over again does not make it true. Look at the FACTS: The prepuce has 20,000 nerves in it and has sensory and mechanical functionality during intercourse and masturbation.

How involved in the lives of everyone else on the planet do you intend to get? I would bet my last penny that if you took one moment to look at the actual problems in the world, circumcision would begin to seem almost... what's the word?...oh, yeah: IRRELEVANT.

Perhaps the West would have a stronger argument for stopping FGM if its proponents could not use our tolerance (or in your case enthusiasm) for the barbaric practice of infant circumcision against us?

It’s ironic how pro-circumcision people always whine about people interfering with their right to decide, while at the same time taking away another individual’s right to choose.
 
It’s ironic how pro-circumcision people always whine about people interfering with their right to decide, while at the same time taking away another individual’s right to choose.


No one is taking away anyone's right to choose anything.


ETA: I do not support the arguments made by Autumn except as regards the fact that the post touched briefly upon the general concept of substituted judgment.
 
Last edited:
No one is taking away anyone's right to choose anything.

I know exactly what you mean by this. It is, however, a very narrow interpretation that only a lawyer would possibly claim as reasonable.

ETA: http://www.lib.mcg.edu/edu/drdilemma/consult/subjudg.htm

Substituted Judgement: The objective of substituted judgement is to respect the autonomy of the incompetent or incapacitated patient by, as far as possible, enforcing that patient’s own wishes regarding care permitted. This means that the person authorized to give consent on behalf of such a patient tries to determine what the patient would have wanted had he or she understood the circumstances under which treatment or procedures would be provided.
 
Last edited:
...
ETA: I do not support the arguments made by Autumn except as regards the fact that the post touched briefly upon the general concept of substituted judgment.

I love the way Loss Leader likes to distance himself (as a religious/cultural circumciser) from the other people in the thread (and the majority of American circumcisers) who are cosmetic/cultural circumcisers (their culture holds circumcised penises as being more cosmetic).

My family is a combination of atheists/agnostics who grew up Catholic but moved away (or ran) from religion. Yet we celebrate Christmas and Easter as purely secular holidays because they still have cultural meaning to us even if their origin was religious. Not a perfect parallel I know.

So I'm a bit puzzled as to what makes a religious/cultural circumcision significantly different from a cosmetic/cultural circumcision. Is it more "meaningful" somehow?
 
Last edited:
I know exactly what you mean by this. It is, however, a very narrow interpretation that only a lawyer would possibly claim as reasonable.


See, Ivor, there's where you're wrong. Lawyers don't actually do much of anything on our own. We work for people. We get hired by clients to represent their interests.

When the law grows and evolves the way it does, it's not because lawyers want it to be that way. It is because our clients do.

And it's because hundreds and thousands of judges throughout history weighed all of the arguments, balanced all the equities and determined what was the fairest thing to do.

If at any time a civilization doesn't like what clients are attempting to get lawyers to do, they can simply have their elected officials overrule the entire mess and dictate the law. This has happened numerous times in history. Consider the labor laws of the first three decades of the last century. They exist because lawyers were doing too well at representing their corporate clients to protect the 80 hr. work week for 9 year-olds and such. The politicians had to step in on behalf of labor, at which time lawyers shrugged and found something else to do.

The laws of substituted judgment are not just some trick of "lawyer logic." They exist because clients paid us to argue for them over the last several hundred years, judges chose to find our arguments compelling and legislators agreed. Politicians didn't just leave well enough alone; the laws of substituted judgment were so clearly equitable that legislators codified them - wrote them right into the books.

So, don't tell me that "only a lawyer" would see the current system as reasonable. It is the way it is because you and your neighbors and all of the people who came before you wanted it to be.
 
See, Ivor, there's where you're wrong. Lawyers don't actually do much of anything on our own. We work for people. We get hired by clients to represent their interests.

When the law grows and evolves the way it does, it's not because lawyers want it to be that way. It is because our clients do.

And it's because hundreds and thousands of judges throughout history weighed all of the arguments, balanced all the equities and determined what was the fairest thing to do.

If at any time a civilization doesn't like what clients are attempting to get lawyers to do, they can simply have their elected officials overrule the entire mess and dictate the law. This has happened numerous times in history. Consider the labor laws of the first three decades of the last century. They exist because lawyers were doing too well at representing their corporate clients to protect the 80 hr. work week for 9 year-olds and such. The politicians had to step in on behalf of labor, at which time lawyers shrugged and found something else to do.

The laws of substituted judgment are not just some trick of "lawyer logic." They exist because clients paid us to argue for them over the last several hundred years, judges chose to find our arguments compelling and legislators agreed. Politicians didn't just leave well enough alone; the laws of substituted judgment were so clearly equitable that legislators codified them - wrote them right into the books.

So, don't tell me that "only a lawyer" would see the current system as reasonable. It is the way it is because you and your neighbors and all of the people who came before you wanted it to be.

You have already said the reasons you are circumcising your son are:

1) So another Jewish parent can in the future
2) Because you are Jewish
3) A Rabbi told you to

So it doesn't sound like you've even considered what you son would want if he was capable. You abuse the concept of substituted judgment to impose your will; you claim what you want is what your son wants, rather than asking what your son would want if he were capable of choosing.

Perhaps your imagination is so limited by your environment and experiences you are unable to conceive of your son _not_ wanting to be circumcised?

Your behaviour is within the law but not in the spirit of it, i.e. a loophole - something that some (most?) lawyers excel at finding for their clients and in your case, yourself.
 
So it doesn't sound like you've even considered what you son would want if he was capable.


That's not the rule.


You abuse the concept of substituted judgment to impose your will;


No, I don't.


you claim what you want is what your son wants,


Yes, I do.


rather than asking what your son would want if he were capable of choosing.


That's not the rule.


Perhaps your imagination is so limited by your environment and experiences you are unable to conceive of your son _not_ wanting to be circumcised?


That's not the rule.


Your behaviour is within the law


Yes, it is.


but not in the spirit of it,


Yes, it is.


i.e. a loophole


There is no loophole.


- something that some (most?) lawyers excel at finding for their clients and in your case, yourself.


To the extent that you said that lawyers find loopholes for clients, that's not what lawyers do. To the extent you implied that I excel at being a lawyer, thanks.
 
The foreskin is just a bit of tissue attached to the shaft of the penis, and it is obviously not vital...
This is a lie. If you knew about the structure of the foreskin, you would not say that.

Have you watched this video? http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/video/prepuce.html Please watch it if you haven't, with an open mind, realizing that these doctors might actually know more than you.

If you refuse to watch the video, then you are a woo, who refuses to consider evidence which might change your beliefs.
 
Edited by Katana: 
Edited out personal attack.


CH, you are not to edit out moderator decisions. If you have a problem with what one of us has done, contact one of the Administrators. I have alerted them to your actions and await their review.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Katana
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm still amazed that people can justify cutting off body parts from unconsenting children that have no need of this surgery. This is yet another sign of how insane our world really is.
 
I suspect that the only way that someone can see the evidence, and yet still practice and even openly support circumcision is probably avoidance of cognitive dissonance.

Basically, they themselves are circumcised. If they were to come out and condemn it, what would that mean for them? That circumcision is wrong, and they were wronged by it, and they're now permanently changed. Some people might feel violated or "half a man" just by acknowledging that circumcision is wrong. Because that's uncomfortable, and they don't want to feel uncomfortable, they can get rid of those feelings by insisting and arguing that circumcision is ok. If it's ok, then it was ok for them to be circumcised.

It's not rational or defensible. And it's really sad that people might think this way. You can't change the past, all you can do is change the future. It's not wrong to be circumcised and people shouldn't feel bad about being that way. What is wrong is perpetuating a practice because of emotional reasons.

If the pro-circs do respond to this, they'll probably say I'm wrong, and that's not how they think at all. Well, only they can know, but I'm skeptical of their self-analysis ability, if they can't even honestly question their own beliefs.
 
Forgive me if this has been posted already.

* Do not be afraid to be the first to change and lead your parents, family and community into modern times! Your primary responsibility is to take care of your son, not to satisfy other people’s need for tradition. Your community will eventually see the light.



* What does tradition mean to you? Does it mean putting your son's welfare second? Do you blindly follow tradition even when it maims and mutilates?



* Do not be afraid to think for yourself. Circumcision is barbaric and you are a better parent for not mutilating your son’s penis.



* Do not be afraid to question tradition rather than blindly accepting it. Circumcision continues in our faith because of indoctrination, fear of change, and so-called tradition. Remember that our religious leaders are the products of this same indoctrination.




* If you were told to circumcise your daughter’s vulva, would you blindly obey? Or would you question the order and choose to protect your daughter? Shouldn’t we treat our boys with the same consideration and respect?



* Do not be afraid of divine punishment. God did not mandate circumcision. In the original version of the Torah, the book of J, circumcision is not even mentioned. Fallible men devised circumcision as a way to curb masturbation. Even Rabbi Maimonides acknowledged this fact.


http://www.jewsagainstcircumcision.org/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom