Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I still don't think what was observed under the conditions of the trials is necessarily reliable as far as predicting what will happen in the "real world" goes. In fact, from what I recall, the newly circumcised men were slightly more inclined to wear condoms compared to the controls.

No. They were equivalent or slightly less likely to be regular condom users.

I agree that one cannot be certain of the future. It helps that the trial took place under real world conditions, but it is well-recognized that trial participants may act differently than non-trial participants. It also helps that the effect is strong. I previously calculated, in this thread, that even if all the circumcised men stopped using condoms, there would still be more HIV acquired in the uncircumcised men. It required an absolute difference in condom usage of 60 percent between uncircumcised and circumcised men to make the rate of HIV acquisition the same between the two groups.

Linda
 
No. They were equivalent or slightly less likely to be regular condom users.

:confused:

I looked it up again. From the Uganda trial:

http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140673607603134/fulltext


Consistent condom use during this interval was slightly higher in the intervention group than it was in the control group (table 6; p=0·11). Similarly, inconsistent condom use was higher in the intervention group than it was in the control group (table 6; p=0·0004). At the 12 and 24 months follow-up visits, the number of sexual partners, non-marital relationships, and condom use were much the same in the two groups

So initially the circumcised guys used condoms more frequently, but went back to "normal" later.
 
:confused:

I looked it up again. From the Uganda trial:

Consistent condom use during this interval was slightly higher in the intervention group than it was in the control group (table 6; p=0·11). Similarly, inconsistent condom use was higher in the intervention group than it was in the control group (table 6; p=0·0004). At the 12 and 24 months follow-up visits, the number of sexual partners, non-marital relationships, and condom use were much the same in the two groups


http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140673607603134/fulltext

So initially the circumcised guys used condoms more frequently, but went back to "normal" later.

Your confusion comes from choosing to bold and underline a non-significant difference.

The only significant difference in condom usage was that during the first six months more circumcised men in the Uganda trial reported inconsistent or no condom usage.

Linda
 
There is this:

http://www.ias-2005.org/planner/Abstracts.aspx?AID=3138

Conclusions: A lowered risk of HIV infection among circumcised women was not attributable to confounding with another risk factor in these data. Anthropological insights on female circumcision as practiced in Tanzania may shed light on this conundrum.

Whoops. Wrong result. Let's call it a "conundrum".

ETA: You can bet the pitch in Africa for male circumcision will be based on the Relative risk reduction (60%) rather than the absolute risk reduction (2%).
 
Last edited:
http://www.ias2007.org/pag/Abstracts.aspx?SID=55&AID=3176

Objectives: Observations that reduced adult HIV prevalence in sub-Saharan Africa are correlated with levels of male circumcision have suggested that male circumcision could be used as a preventative measure against HIV infection. The exact benefits of this intervention are uncertain. Moreover if this is infeasible for the whole male population, which groups should be targeted?
Methods: A deterministic, compartmental mathematical model simulated observed levels of HIV prevalence under the complete range of current levels of circumcision. Increased male circumcision from 2007 was incorporated in this model and HIV prevalence in 2020 was simulated.
Results: Simulations predict that complete male circumcision in an average country could reduce HIV prevalence in 2020 from 8.3% to 5.3% and incidence from 13.5 seroconversions per thousand to 7.3 per thousand. The results were scaled in proportion if a lower level of circumcision was achieved. Also, targetting only 20 to 30 year old men or men with greater sexual activity produced the most cost-effective reduction in HIV prevalence, 2.0% and 1.1% respectively. These benefits are lessened with increasing sexual activity in men who have been circumcised, with complete negation of the intervention occuring once a lower bound of 40% of men increase their activity.
Conclusions: Male circumcision provides an effective intervention in sub-Saharan Africa to reduce HIV prevalence that is not vulnerable to lessening of effect through drug resistance or lack of availability of other prevention measures. Where it is not feasible to provide complete coverage, targeting young men or more sexually active men can still produce a significant reduction in HIV prevalence. However an intervention will fail if steps are not taken to prevent the majority of men increasing their sexual activity due to overestimation of circumcision´s benefits.
 
Here's some news regarding male-to-female transmission:

http://health.howstuffworks.com/circum-aids-female.htm

Six months into a two-year study following 2,000 HIV-infected men and their uninfected female partners, the preliminary results are disturbing. At the start of the study, about half of the men underwent a circumcision procedure. The other half -- the control group -- did not. Looking at the data for just 125 of the couples in the study, it appears that women have twice the chance of contracting HIV from a circumcised partner. The six-month-mark data show that of the women whose HIV-positive partners had been circumcised, 16 percent had contracted HIV. Of the women whose partners had remained uncircumcised, seven percent had acquired the disease.

But there's a major caveat here: The researchers believe that the circumcised men may have had sex with their partner before their wound was fully healed. It takes about a month for a circumcision wound to heal, and while the couples were warned not to have intercourse until a doctor declared it safe -- and were counseled to always use condoms -- it appears that some of the couples didn't follow at least the condom recommendation. So the researchers are wondering if those couples didn't end up following "wait until it heals" recommendation, either. It's natural that having intercourse before the wound were fully healed would increase the risk of transmission. HIV is carried in blood, not just semen, and an unhealed wound on the tip of the penis is very likely to tear during sex.
 
There's this too:

http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/HIV/brewer2007/

Male and Female Circumcision Associated With Prevalent HIV Infection in Virgins and Adolescents in Kenya, Lesotho, and Tanzania
DEVON D. BREWER, PHD, JOHN J. POTTERAT, BA, JOHN M. ROBERTS JR., PHD, AND STUART BRODY, PHD

PURPOSE: Remarkable proportions of self-reported virgins and adolescents in eastern and southern Africa are infected with HIV, yet non-sexual routes of transmission have not been systematically investigated in such persons. Many observers in this region have recognized the potential for HIV transmission through unhygienic circumcision procedures. We assessed the relation between male and female circumcision (genital cutting) and prevalent HIV infection in Kenyan, Lesothoan, and Tanzanian virgins and adolescents.

METHODS: We analyzed data from recent cross-sectional national probability sample surveys of adolescents and adults in households, focusing on populations in which circumcision was common and usually occurred in puberty or later.

RESULTS: Circumcised male and female virgins were substantially more likely to be HIV infected than uncircumcised virgins (Kenyan females: 3.2% vs. 1.4%, odds ratio [OR] Z 2.38; Kenyan males: 1.8% vs. 0%, OR undefined; Lesothoan males: 6.1% vs. 1.9%, OR 3.36; Tanzanian males: 2.9% vs. 1.0%, OR 2.99; weighted mean phi correlation Z0.07, 95% confidence interval, 0.03 to 0.11). Among adolescents, regardless of sexual experience, circumcision was just as strongly associated with prevalent HIV infection. However, uncircumcised adults were more likely to be HIV positive than circumcised adults. Self-reported sexual experience was independently related to HIV infection in adolescent Kenyan females, but was unrelated to HIV infection in adolescent Kenyan, Lesothoan, and Tanzanian males.

CONCLUSIONS: HIV transmission may occur through circumcision-related blood exposures in eastern and southern Africa.

ETA: And this.

So it looks like circumcision for HIV prevention in Africa is not the panacea its proponents would like us to believe it is.
 
Last edited:
Hey Cat, just watched the video you linked to http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/video/prepuce.html
Very scientific and informative.


I did, although I already agree with you. Actually, I tried, but couldn't watch the circumcision video because they're too horrible for me to watch.

Yeah, and after watching that medical video, it is even worse. One almost imagines only a monster could watch a child suffer in such extreme distress, and not be effected. I would guess anyone who insist on the right to remove half the skin on their kids penis wouldn't watch either or any of the linked videos. They might have to change their beliefs. And then they can't say, "I've seen no evidence to convince me...", because if they actually watch evidence, they can't say that anymore.

They upset me way too much.

Me too, me too. The Jewish ceremonial one was freaking me the F out actually. But at least they get the baby drunk first. It isn't the horror of the act so much as it was the rejoicing over it being done. Nightmarish.

But the video about the Doctors who've changed their minds was very interesting, and I wish more Docs would follow suit.

I wonder how many Jewish Doctors could, even if they wanted to?

I would bet money back when tonsils and adenoids were routinely removed, without much thought, that the same stupid reasoning was used. Most Doctors actually believed nature had made some kind of mistake, and it was best to cut off valuable living tissue, for the good of the child. Horrors. The Dark Ages are still with us.
 
"only a monster could watch a child suffer in such extreme distress, and not be effected"
There are a couple in this thread.

"The Dark Ages are still with us."
Especially as represented by "The Religious"...
 
robinson said:
One almost imagines only a monster could watch a child suffer in such extreme distress, and not be effected.
What about the folks that actually do it for a living?
 
What about the folks that actually do it for a living?

Check out the second line on my sig.;)

I think most people have it in them to inflict pain on another individual, be it for the benefit or detriment of them. All they need is the right justification and perceptual filter for what it is they are doing.
 
Hey Cat, just watched the video you linked to http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/video/prepuce.html
Very scientific and informative.
Thanks, I thought so, too. I think it would be impossible to watch that video and still say that the foreskin is "vestigial" or "useless."

Yeah, and after watching that medical video, it is even worse. One almost imagines only a monster could watch a child suffer in such extreme distress, and not be effected. I would guess anyone who insist on the right to remove half the skin on their kids penis wouldn't watch either or any of the linked videos. They might have to change their beliefs. And then they can't say, "I've seen no evidence to convince me...", because if they actually watch evidence, they can't say that anymore.
I know. I have watched circumcision videos before, but I just can't anymore. I don't know how people can watch them and not be affected. Oh, and what you said about having to change their mind is very true. It's easy to dismiss something when you close your mind to it, or ignore evidence of it.

I don't know if you saw Penn and Teller's BS about circumcision, but I think they had an actual video of a circumcision. And afterwards, someone on the video made some comment like, "oh, he's finally quieted down." To which Penn yells, "No! He's in ****ing shock!" Then they cut back to the baby, and he is in shock! He's just staring into space with his eyes wide open. That was a very disturbing moment for me. Babies just don't act like that.

Me too, me too. The Jewish ceremonial one was freaking me the F out actually. But at least they get the baby drunk first. It isn't the horror of the act so much as it was the rejoicing over it being done. Nightmarish.
Reminds me of LL's pride.

I would bet money back when tonsils and adenoids were routinely removed, without much thought, that the same stupid reasoning was used. Most Doctors actually believed nature had made some kind of mistake, and it was best to cut off valuable living tissue, for the good of the child. Horrors. The Dark Ages are still with us.
Too true. The only thing that I can think of doing is bringing this issue up with family members and friends, particularly those who are planning to have children. Not everyone will listen, of course, sometimes just talking about it can make people think about something they wouldn't have thought about. For me, though, it seems like a difficult topic to bring up, because people just don't talk about circumcision. I wish I could think of a tactful way to bring it up.
 
Check out the second line on my sig.;)

I think most people have it in them to inflict pain on another individual, be it for the benefit or detriment of them. All they need is the right justification and perceptual filter for what it is they are doing.
Isn't that what the Milgram experiment taught us? That a lot of people can do bad things, especially if an authority figure tells us to? (doctor = authority figure)

By the way, I love the studies you've posted. They've really made me think about widespread use of circumcision in Africa. I think it may not be as great or even as useful as people hope it will be.
 
Isn't that what the Milgram experiment taught us? That a lot of people can do bad things, especially if an authority figure tells us to? (doctor = authority figure)

I don't think many parents even perceive circumcision as a "bad" thing. Quite the contrary; I think they see their child as disadvantaged by having a foreskin.

By the way, I love the studies you've posted. They've really made me think about widespread use of circumcision in Africa. I think it may not be as great or even as useful as people hope it will be.

It will be interesting to see what the WHO and UNAIDS recommends in the light of this new information. The Kenyan and other RCT's were well done but still not "real life".

I did find the conclusion the researchers of the female circumcision study came to to be rather amusing.:D
 
Last edited:
The only thing that I can think of doing is bringing this issue up with family members and friends, particularly those who are planning to have children. Not everyone will listen, of course, sometimes just talking about it can make people think about something they wouldn't have thought about. For me, though, it seems like a difficult topic to bring up, because people just don't talk about circumcision. I wish I could think of a tactful way to bring it up.

I think (without any evidence to back me up :)) that that has to accomplish something. Continuing to instill the idea that in many places it's not the norm, and that it's not just the radicals, but also the average parent, that doesn't see the need to have it done, should get some people to think about it (rather than being passive). I think the idea has a snowball effect and just needs to gain more momentum in the US. I worry that foaming-at-the-mouth reactions reinforce the idea that it's radical (rather than normal) to forego circumcision.

Linda
 
I am genuinely saddened that your family and others in your life must be infected by your filthy, worm-ridden ideology.

I'm sure others in my family will enjoy hearing that, especially the ones that fought Hitler's murder machine so you could be alive today to insult them. Alas, many of them did not make it home, and will not be hearing the good news.

On the other hand, when someone says that I live up to the negative stereotypes of Jews, the implication is that I am in some way lacking based on the very fact of my actions.

There, fixed it for you ;)

Now, you did call me deluded ... twice. But that was just impolite. It wasn't hateful.

hmm.. irony meter, or kitten.. I can't decide.. "OH NOES!!?!! IVE BIN CALLED RASCIST!!@!"
 
I wonder how all those American men ended up being circumcised in the first place? There must have been a time when most American men were uncircumcised and were persuaded by somebody to have their child cut. Ah, yes - physicians told them it was a good idea.

Now that we know it is generally not a good idea, most physicians in the US appear to be rather reluctant to tell parents this. Talk about a profession dodging its responsibility. Perhaps they're worried about being sued by their victims former patients?
 
I owe a debt to my mother who refused to have me or my brothers circumcised in the face of much criticism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom