Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

The claim to which I was responding did not distinguish between elective and non-elective circumcision.
Let's see. What I said:
RIC causes harm to the baby each and every time.
Routine infant circumcision is elective, medically necessary circumcision is not. How is that not clear? I haven't seen anybody argue that circumcision shouldn't be performed when medically necessary.

But the procedure is not without harm even when medically necessary. I don't disagree that sometimes the benefits will be greater than the harm caused. The problem is that the harm of removing the foreskin is almost universally ignored by those defending medically unnecessary circumcision.
 
I know (although I think it's the one in PLoS, that you mean), but I'm still looking for a good meta-analysis and the general idea that it's a decided debate is not quite true. Still the debate on this is continuing when you look at all the responses and comments linked to the abstract. The medical studies are not conclusive in the sense that there are many reports refuting the benefits. As a result a new meta-analysis at this time would most likely reject the presumed benefits. But I'm just guessing here. If you find a current meta-analysis, please post.

There are two more RTC's coming: one from Kenya and one from Uganda. Together all three trials will give a better idea if the first RTC is correct in their conclusions and recommendations

SYL :)

No...I was talking about the Kenya and Uganda studies. They're in. They were stopped early and apparently rushed through peer review.

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/statements/2007/s04/en/index.html
 
Did anybody watch the videos I linked to? I found watching an actual circumcision to be far more educational than all the words in the world. And the comments from Doctors who changed their minds, and now refuse to do the procedure, based on their Medical experience, to be quite convincing.
 
No.

What I said was "always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.

Ok, I agree. If there is a medical problem presented that circumcision could be used to treat then it could be considered to be providing a benefit for that patient.

According to EBM, treatment of phimosis and paraphimosis would mean ~1% of males would be circumcised. So in the US that leaves ~59% of males being harmed for cultural reasons and unlikely to be realized prophylactic "benefits".

BTW, I missed adding in my summary that breastfeeding has shown a protective effect against UTI and that a large Canadian study estimated an NNT of 195 to prevent 1 case of UTI, giving a RR of 3.7.

Does anybody know if there is anything to the idea that a proportion of UTI's in infants may be occurring because of the hospital environment?
 
Last edited:
First the reasons for circumcision chronologically:
1. God wanted this from the Jews...

I'm fairly sure that never happened. :)

You probably meant to say that an ancient blood-drawing ritual practiced for unknown reasons by some people in the Middle East evolved into a tradition accompanied by a mythical tale of a covenant between the legendary figure of Abraham and a deity named Yahweh, and that this myth was eventually written down in what would later become the Torah and thus was canonized as an aspect of Judaism.
 
If we can agree that circumcision isn't necessary, even if some (with whom I disagree) think it's desirable, isn’t there something a little more useful that all these physicians performing circumcision could be doing with their time?

(I would be more than prepared to accept the answer 'no' if it were justified. I'm very glad I still have my foreskin though. Can't imagine life without it!)



p.s. - q. What's the useless piece of skin at the end of a penis called?

a. A man. (One of my GF's favourite jokes, which worries me.)
 
I personally think it's pretty telling that most guys that still have a foreskin want to keep it. I just don't understand why anyone would want to lop off a part of their body (religious insanity aside).
 
I'm fairly sure that never happened. :)

You probably meant to say that an ancient blood-drawing ritual practiced for unknown reasons by some people in the Middle East evolved into a tradition accompanied by a mythical tale of a covenant between the legendary figure of Abraham and a deity named Yahweh, and that this myth was eventually written down in what would later become the Torah and thus was canonized as an aspect of Judaism.
I'm also pretty sure it never happened, but some people believed this mythical tale to be true, (even in this thread). I like your description better, but mine is easier to remember. :D

SYL :)
 
In Africa it has been shown to provide partial protection (about a 60% risk reduction) for men against contracting HIV. I therefore accept that it is reasonable to offer it to men and parents for their infants, especially since the supply and willingness to use of condoms in Africa does not appear sufficient to control the spread of HIV.

No...I was talking about the Kenya and Uganda studies. They're in. They were stopped early and apparently rushed through peer review.

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/statements/2007/s04/en/index.html
Trying to educate myself here. I've tried to look at the HIV arguments very closely, but there still seems to be some things that I don't understand.

In studying Africa, it seems like three of their main problems with the spread of HIV seem to be: superstition, risky sexual practices (i.e. "dry sex" and other things related to superstition), and lack of condom use.

Although circumcision may confer some degree of protection, it is not guaranteed, and certainly not as good as other things, like routine condom use. Why are people advocating to apply widespread use of circumcision, when it seems like their money and time could be better spent educating them about superstitions, sexual practices, and regular condom use?

Also, isn't it a real phenomenon that people who think they're "safe" (such as when wearing helmets on a motorcycle, or seatbelts in a car) engage in riskier behavior, thereby negating some effects of that which protects them? If so, it would seem likely that circumcised males in Africa would do the same, correct?

Another thing, being circumcised in the US didn't seem to protect the millions who've contracted HIV or died from AIDS.

Again, I'm just trying to learn here. Although I am against RIC, that doesn't necessarily translate to other uses of circumcision.

ETA: One thing I think should be made clear here, is that even though circumcision may work in Africa, that does not mean it will work/should be implemented in the US. The US and Africa are completely different countries, with different cultures and economic levels. In the US, we have ways of dealing with HIV that has nothing to do with circumcision.
 
Last edited:
Did anybody watch the videos I linked to? I found watching an actual circumcision to be far more educational than all the words in the world. And the comments from Doctors who changed their minds, and now refuse to do the procedure, based on their Medical experience, to be quite convincing.
I did, although I already agree with you. Actually, I tried, but couldn't watch the circumcision video because they're too horrible for me to watch. They upset me way too much. But the video about the Doctors who've changed their minds was very interesting, and I wish more Docs would follow suit. If you don't mind, I'd like to post my own video. It's basically a medical video, with medical terminology, on the structure and purpose of the prepuce (foreskin). It's pretty short, and very educational.

http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/video/prepuce.html
 
Trying to educate myself here. I've tried to look at the HIV arguments very closely, but there still seems to be some things that I don't understand.

In studying Africa, it seems like three of their main problems with the spread of HIV seem to be: superstition, risky sexual practices (i.e. "dry sex" and other things related to superstition), and lack of condom use.

Although circumcision may confer some degree of protection, it is not guaranteed, and certainly not as good as other things, like routine condom use. Why are people advocating to apply widespread use of circumcision, when it seems like their money and time could be better spent educating them about superstitions, sexual practices, and regular condom use?

Also, isn't it a real phenomenon that people who think they're "safe" (such as when wearing helmets on a motorcycle, or seatbelts in a car) engage in riskier behavior, thereby negating some effects of that which protects them? If so, it would seem likely that circumcised males in Africa would do the same, correct?

Another thing, being circumcised in the US didn't seem to protect the millions who've contracted HIV or died from AIDS.

Again, I'm just trying to learn here. Although I am against RIC, that doesn't necessarily translate to other uses of circumcision.

ETA: One thing I think should be made clear here, is that even though circumcision may work in Africa, that does not mean it will work/should be implemented in the US. The US and Africa are completely different countries, with different cultures and economic levels. In the US, we have ways of dealing with HIV that has nothing to do with circumcision.

I'm also trying to work all that out in my mind, as well.

I think offering it to older (over 16 or 18) males in HIV endemic areas for the purpose of reducing their chances of catching HIV seems reasonable.
 
Trying to educate myself here. I've tried to look at the HIV arguments very closely, but there still seems to be some things that I don't understand.

In studying Africa, it seems like three of their main problems with the spread of HIV seem to be: superstition, risky sexual practices (i.e. "dry sex" and other things related to superstition), and lack of condom use.

Although circumcision may confer some degree of protection, it is not guaranteed, and certainly not as good as other things, like routine condom use. Why are people advocating to apply widespread use of circumcision, when it seems like their money and time could be better spent educating them about superstitions, sexual practices, and regular condom use?

People are not advocating one or the other, but both. Studies have shown that even concerted efforts at educating people and providing free condoms does not lead to a high level of consistent condom use. In the RCT's testing circumcision, all study participants received intensive education efforts and a liberal supply of condoms. The percentage using condoms regularly improved, but was still only around 20 and 40 percent. It depends upon whether or not you think public policy should centre around realism or wishful thinking.

Also, isn't it a real phenomenon that people who think they're "safe" (such as when wearing helmets on a motorcycle, or seatbelts in a car) engage in riskier behavior, thereby negating some effects of that which protects them? If so, it would seem likely that circumcised males in Africa would do the same, correct?

That's called a "moral hazard". This effect was specifically studied in the circumcision RCT's in Africa and was not found to make a difference.

Another thing, being circumcised in the US didn't seem to protect the millions who've contracted HIV or died from AIDS.

There are many factors that influence whether or not someone contracts HIV or dies from AIDS. Circumcision has protected those in the US as well, but the absolute numbers are much smaller.

Again, I'm just trying to learn here. Although I am against RIC, that doesn't necessarily translate to other uses of circumcision.

Okay, but the research from Africa really should not be applied to recommendations for the US.

Linda
 
fls said:
That's called a "moral hazard". This effect was specifically studied in the circumcision RCT's in Africa and was not found to make a difference.
I still don't think what was observed under the conditions of the trials is necessarily reliable as far as predicting what will happen in the "real world" goes. In fact, from what I recall, the newly circumcised men were slightly more inclined to wear condoms compared to the controls.
 
Everybody understands that the law grants you broad authority to act contrary to your child's best interest.


It most certainly does not. It grants me broad authority to act in a way you personally believe is contrary to my child's best interests. However, your personal beliefs are not currently the barometer by which courts measure these things.


The fact that you insist on doing it when he can't stop you indicates that you place his interests behind your own superstitions and your own need to feel adequate.


You have imputed to me a reason which I have never stated and which I catagorically deny.


I can confidently say that you are not giving serious consideration because you summarily dismiss all scientific information about the benefits of a foreskin as "anecdotal".


I have done no such thing. You stated: "Finally, I can't help but notice that you are still ignoring the harm caused by loss of the sensitivity and function of the foreskin. You are depriving your sons of some of the pleasure of sex, and by extension life."

I answered that I had seen no study that showed a loss of "some of the pleasure of sex" due to circumcision. If you know of such a study, please post it. IIRC, there was a study that said the glans was less sensitive in circumcised people but it went on to say that this did not mean there was a decrease in sexual enjoyment.

Since there is no study that says that there is a decrease in sexual enjoyment, the stories posted here by members are anecdotes. I have my own anecdote. None of them are conclusive of anything. Thus, I reject your contention until you can show me real, solid, statistically significant evidence.


Given what the Jewish people have historically faced from official, legal oppression, you of all people should understand it is inexcusable to try to use this argument to justify the oppression of another.


No one is being oppressed.


All the lawyerly, legalistic arguments for "consent" don't change the fact that you are unnecessarily mutilating the genitals of a baby for your own enjoyment.


You keep saying it but repetition doesn't actually cause it to become true.


That baby is a person and is entitled to make that decision for himself, unless it is medically required.


That baby is eight days old and can make exactly zero decisions for himself.


Priceless coming from the one who seems to rely on repeated lawyerly, legalistic arguments to defend why it is morally acceptable to mutilate the genitals of a child for one's own enjoyment.[/QUOTE]


You realize this isn't true, right? Stuff someone else with straw. Unless you have some evidence that this is my true motivation, step off.


Having a law that says it's ok to mutilate a baby's genitals for your own enjoyment doesn't make it OK to do so, no matter how many times you say it does.


That's not what the law says and that's not what I'm doing. Is your argument really so weak that you have to invent a position for me that's easier for you to defeat? Other posters on this thread have done very well arguing against my position while fully allowing that my motivations are exactly what I say they are.


Yes, you have. Whether intentional or not, you have given no meaningful consideration to the benefits of a foreskin.


Untrue. I have read all of the medical links in this thread very carefull and, in fact, have changed my mind on routine non-religious circumcision as a result.


I and others have posted links to plenty of sound, scientific information explaining the function and benefit of the foreskin, including properly conducted studies. You calling it "anecdotal" and declaring that concept defeated is the closest any of the pro-circs have come to addressing any of it.


No, what I called anecdotal was the claim that a foreskin improved sexual pleasure. If you have such a study, link to it.


I love how you frame this. You put the burden of proof on the people who are trying to preserve and protect.


The burden is on those who are trying to override the presumption that family and religious considerations trump public distate.


I love it!


I love it, too! What are we talking about!


But I guess I'd have to resort to such preposterous arguments too, if I was defending something as indefensible as an adult altering the genitals of a baby for the adult's enjoyment.


This is not my reason for circumcising my son. You have invented a position and assigned it to me. I reject it. Nyehhhhh!


Does this kind of illogic actually work with judges?


I assure you I am very good.


thinking just as a parent, shouldn't the standard be "has it been proven beyond a reasonable doubt that it is harmless?"


You seem to believe that I think circumcision is a neutral procedure. I do not. I believe circumcision confers benefits on my son - not medical but benefits nonetheless. The question is whether the harm outweighs the benefits. In my mind, it does not.


Come on, how can you be on a skeptic site and not see the problem with your logic? You have no foreskin, why would you expect to be able to know whether it would have been any better? Just as a man has no idea what sex feels like for a woman, you have no idea what difference a foreskin makes, except that you can hear what men with foreskin can describe and you can read the research studies on the topic.


I have seen no research on the loss of sexual pleasure caused by circumcision. If you have such research, please post it. Otherwise, you are right that I have no idea what sex feels like uncircumcised but the uncircumcised writers have no idea what sex feels like circumcised. And my anecdote is that it feels great. So all the anecdotes are a wash - they don't help or hurt either side of the debate. Bring me a properly conducted study regarding sexual pleasure and I will reconsider.


Very telling that you categorically dismiss all such information for no reason other than the challenge it poses.


Anecdotes provide no challenge whatsoever.


How much you currently enjoy sex has no bearing on whether it would (or would not) be better with a foreskin.


And how much uncircumcised men enjoy sex has no bearing on whether it would or would not be better without a foreskin. They have their own experiences, not evidence. I have my experiences. The score is tied 1-1 on the anecdote board. If you have some actual, statistically significant, properly controled evidence, I would be very happy to receive it.
 
I still don't think what was observed under the conditions of the trials is necessarily reliable as far as predicting what will happen in the "real world" goes.

I agree. The best evidence available indicates that it should help, but the authors of the studies admit there are potential problems with rolling it out on a large scale and some relatively small changes in behaviour could wipe out any benefit circumcision offers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom