Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Please expand on that...
Why is it not harmful to operate and remove any part of on an otherwise healthy baby?


I'm not going to re-hash the evidence that was presented on routine circumcision.

Having said that, read what I said (and what I was responding to).

Then look up "phimosis".
 
And carefully ignored the harm caused by the loss of the foreskin. In all of the medical community's evaluations of the "benefits" and harm of circumcision, I don't see any cases where this has even been considered.

By no means are doctors immune from superstition, magical thinking, bias, and dishonesty.

{snip}


And neither is the general public.

Again, it is not a black & white issue as many would like to think.
 
You can suggest alternative motives, but the evidence of potential benefits exists.

I am not, as some might assume, pro-circumcision. I am simply presenting the fact that performing the procedure does not violate physicians' ethical obligations to do no harm given the available evidence suggesting potential benefits. Having said that, I would agree with the American Academy of Pediatrics that it is insufficient to advocate that every newborn be circumcised.

It is not, as some would like to make it, a black and white issue.
The problem with this is that the potential benefits have not rendered actual benefits for the entire population for the time that this practice has been used.

If this were done by alternative "healers", we would have had no problem condemning it...

The fact is that the religious institutions are well supported in this practice by their followers. Basically we're outnumbered, but not wrong.

SYL :)
 
Why would it be silly to call it mutilation when an immobilized unconsenting baby's genitals are unnecessary disfigured and desensitized?

The language you use is emotional to the point of childishness, and points to the idea that you have a near-religious dedication to a belief system, instead of a rational evidence-based position.
 
phimosis or paraphimosis is a medical condition for which a circumcision is a very helpful long-term treatment, this has absolutely nothing to do with the circumcision of all males...

It's like saying that all women should get a total mammectomy at birth to prevent a serious (and higher chance) of breast cancer. There is bottled milk isn't there?...

See?....

SYL :)
 
No offense to everyone who has posted before... but isn't it a bit silly to refer to circumcision as "mutilation", and frame the anti-circumcision position as being about "body integrity"?

No, it is an accurate description. The ethics of performing non-essential and practically irreversible plastic surgery on a non-consenting child is seen by most people as a breach of the child's human rights. That is until you call it "circumcision", then it is considered by some to be perfectly ethical for a physician to do it and parents to demand it.

It is a medical procedure with little risk, and apparent benefit.

The most significant risk reduction is for UTI's in infants. According to the research, about 98.9% of male infants never have a UTI in the first place. And circumcision provides a 1% absolute risk reduction. So for 1 infant to avoid a UTI, a 100 have to be circumcised. The complication rate of circumcision is estimated at 2%.

Circumcision causes pain. It has been demonstrated that infants' pain response is affected for weeks or months after being circumcised. They become sensitized to pain. The best pain relief is a ring block. This is not standard in the US, where physicians tend to use the not particularly effective Emla cream.

Then you have the recommendation from the AAP that all non-essential trauma should avoid interrupting breast feeding. No medical organization in the developed world recommends circumcision. It is an elective procedure.

And, really, if you have such a profound interest in and obsession with your genitals, and the genitals of others, I think that little flap of skin is the least of your problems.

The foreskin is the most sensitive part of a man's penis and acts as a roller-bearing to during intercourse and masturbation. That is why anti-masturbation physicians in history targeted it (and a girl's clitoris) for removal.

Circumcision has been around for thousands of years. No one is sure when or where it started. Its use in medicine in the developed world should be limited to physical problems, such as phimosis (tight foreskin).

In Africa it has been shown to provide partial protection (about a 60% risk reduction) for men against contracting HIV. I therefore accept that it is reasonable to offer it to men and parents for their infants, especially since the supply and willingness to use of condoms in Africa does not appear sufficient to control the spread of HIV.
 
phimosis or paraphimosis is a medical condition for wich a circumcision is helpfull, this has absolutely nothing to do with the circumcision of all males...

It's like saying that all women should get a total mammectomy at birth to prevent a serious (and higher chance) of breast cancer. There is bottled milk isn't there?...

See?....

SYL :)


Right. This is why I said that "always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.
 
Right. This is why I said that "always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.

By definition, cutting off normal, healthy and functional tissue is harmful.

What you are referring to is the statistical benefits for populations for UTI's and males with anatomical problems.
 
Am I the only person who thinks this thread could have been cut back drastically very early on, if only for the sake of taste and tradition?
 
By definition, cutting off normal, healthy and functional tissue is harmful.

What you are referring to is the statistical benefits for populations for UTI's and males with anatomical problems.


No.

What I said was "always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.
 
No, it is an accurate description. The ethics of performing non-essential and practically irreversible plastic surgery on a non-consenting child is seen by most people as a breach of the child's human rights. That is until you call it "circumcision", then it is considered by some to be perfectly ethical for a physician to do it and parents to demand it.



The most significant risk reduction is for UTI's in infants. According to the research, about 98.9% of male infants never have a UTI in the first place. And circumcision provides a 1% absolute risk reduction. So for 1 infant to avoid a UTI, a 100 have to be circumcised. The complication rate of circumcision is estimated at 2%.

Circumcision causes pain. It has been demonstrated that infants' pain response is affected for weeks or months after being circumcised. They become sensitized to pain. The best pain relief is a ring block. This is not standard in the US, where physicians tend to use the not particularly effective Emla cream.

Then you have the recommendation from the AAP that all non-essential trauma should avoid interrupting breast feeding. No medical organization in the developed world recommends circumcision. It is an elective procedure.



The foreskin is the most sensitive part of a man's penis and acts as a roller-bearing to during intercourse and masturbation. That is why anti-masturbation physicians in history targeted it (and a girl's clitoris) for removal.

Circumcision has been around for thousands of years. No one is sure when or where it started. Its use in medicine in the developed world should be limited to physical problems, such as phimosis (tight foreskin).

In Africa it has been shown to provide partial protection (about a 60% risk reduction) for men against contracting HIV. I therefore accept that it is reasonable to offer it to men and parents for their infants, especially since the supply and willingness to use of condoms in Africa does not appear sufficient to control the spread of HIV.
To consider:

NEJM 1988: pro-circ , circumcision may reduce the incidence of HIV, ulcers on foreskin associated with HIV
International Journal of STD's and AIDS 1999: "Recommending routine circumcision to prevent HIV is scientifically unfounded".
 
Last edited:
"Always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.

No.

What I said was "always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.
And you are unable or unwilling to back that up. What, are you just sniping? Maybe I should report you to a moderator :p

I have read every single post in this monstrous thread. Your assertion that sometimes the medically unnecessary circumcision of a baby boy is harmless is unfounded and contrary to most scientific information that has been posted in this thread. So far, no poster has countered the information showing that elective cosmetic circumcision always causes some harm.
 
And you are unable or unwilling to back that up. What, are you just sniping? Maybe I should report you to a moderator :p

I have read every single post in this monstrous thread. Your assertion that sometimes the medically unnecessary circumcision of a baby boy is harmless is unfounded and contrary to most scientific information that has been posted in this thread. So far, no poster has countered the information showing that elective cosmetic circumcision always causes some harm.


The claim to which I was responding did not distinguish between elective and non-elective circumcision.

ETA: Oh, and :p to you, too. :p
 
I'm generally on your side with this, SYL...but your information is outdated on the HIV thing. The two new RTCs demonstrate that the HIV thing is real.
I know (although I think it's the one in PLoS, that you mean), but I'm still looking for a good meta-analysis and the general idea that it's a decided debate is not quite true. Still the debate on this is continuing when you look at all the responses and comments linked to the abstract. The medical studies are not conclusive in the sense that there are many reports refuting the benefits. As a result a new meta-analysis at this time would most likely reject the presumed benefits. But I'm just guessing here. If you find a current meta-analysis, please post.

There are two more RTC's coming: one from Kenya and one from Uganda. Together all three trials will give a better idea if the first RTC is correct in their conclusions and recommendations

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
I know, but I'm still looking for a good meta-analysis and the general idea that it's a decided debate is not quite true. The medical studies are not conclusive in the sense that there are many reports refuting the benefits. As a result a new meta-analysis at this time would most likely reject the presumed benefits. But I'm just guessing here. If you find a current meta-analysis, please post.

SYL :)


DISCLAIMER: COMPLETELY OFF SUBJECT


What's the significance of the 1592 in your name, Syl?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom