1.That is not clear to me at all. My motivation is that it is an element of my religion.
2.No, that doesn't follow at all. With circumcision, I am substituting my jusgement for my incompetent child with his best interests in mind. The Aztecs sacrificed their enemies. So, their enemies were not incompetent, they were not the Aztecs' children and the Aztecs didn't have their enemies' best interests in mind.
3.I have said nothing of the sort. I am not Jewish because I am circumcised, I am circumcised because I am Jewish. Also, there's no blood sucking going on anymore in Conservative Judaism.
4.And as I have also said, if I stop the practice of circumcision, it will make it harder for other Jews to continue the practice.
5.No one's rights are being violated. In fact, my son's right to practice his religion is being protected.
6.Indeed, I do.
7.I will, in fact, be preventing my son from eating pork. And I will be forcing him to study the bible.
8.The fact that you are incredulous about my thought process does not mean that there is something else at work.
Ive numbered these, for convenience.
1. Fairly simple, even from your religious perspective, why is no other part of the body singled out for this ceremony. Why do similar ceremonies in other cultures also target the genitals.
2. I was using that example completely to highlight your system of justification, examples dont have to be directly parallel. The reasoning being used by the hypothetical Aztec is the same as the less hypothetical you.
3. So youre highlighting a change in the practice while at the same time going on about how if it changes/goes away that Judaism will cease to exist.
4. What is important about continuing the practice? Why must Jews continue it? As I said, if a Jew doesnt circumcise do they cease to be Jewish? Some practices dont need to continue. Youre not the only group that circumcises, nor is your current practice of circumcision the original form.
5. No, your son's rights to practice religion arnt being enforced. You are using your right to religious freedom to trump his right to personal freedom. I highly doubt a newborn has much interest in religious goings on.
In addition, I really really dont see how you could assert that without knowing that its nonsense.
6. Your faith is on the way to its doom then, because a Jew with a foreskin isnt a Jew at all. (Insert the exceptions)
7. You missed entirely the point of that.
Saying "I wont allow my son to eat pork." Whats the effect that has on you? Or anyone else. (Please others, if anyone reads this far, respond to this point.) Likewise to "Im going to make my son study the Bible."
Vs. "Im going to cut off my son's foreskin no matter what anyone says."
8. Your assertion that there isnt also doesnt prove anything.
Last edited:

)