Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

1.That is not clear to me at all. My motivation is that it is an element of my religion.

2.No, that doesn't follow at all. With circumcision, I am substituting my jusgement for my incompetent child with his best interests in mind. The Aztecs sacrificed their enemies. So, their enemies were not incompetent, they were not the Aztecs' children and the Aztecs didn't have their enemies' best interests in mind.

3.I have said nothing of the sort. I am not Jewish because I am circumcised, I am circumcised because I am Jewish. Also, there's no blood sucking going on anymore in Conservative Judaism.

4.And as I have also said, if I stop the practice of circumcision, it will make it harder for other Jews to continue the practice.

5.No one's rights are being violated. In fact, my son's right to practice his religion is being protected.

6.Indeed, I do.

7.I will, in fact, be preventing my son from eating pork. And I will be forcing him to study the bible.

8.The fact that you are incredulous about my thought process does not mean that there is something else at work.

Ive numbered these, for convenience.

1. Fairly simple, even from your religious perspective, why is no other part of the body singled out for this ceremony. Why do similar ceremonies in other cultures also target the genitals.

2. I was using that example completely to highlight your system of justification, examples dont have to be directly parallel. The reasoning being used by the hypothetical Aztec is the same as the less hypothetical you.

3. So youre highlighting a change in the practice while at the same time going on about how if it changes/goes away that Judaism will cease to exist.

4. What is important about continuing the practice? Why must Jews continue it? As I said, if a Jew doesnt circumcise do they cease to be Jewish? Some practices dont need to continue. Youre not the only group that circumcises, nor is your current practice of circumcision the original form.

5. No, your son's rights to practice religion arnt being enforced. You are using your right to religious freedom to trump his right to personal freedom. I highly doubt a newborn has much interest in religious goings on.

In addition, I really really dont see how you could assert that without knowing that its nonsense.

6. Your faith is on the way to its doom then, because a Jew with a foreskin isnt a Jew at all. (Insert the exceptions)

7. You missed entirely the point of that.

Saying "I wont allow my son to eat pork." Whats the effect that has on you? Or anyone else. (Please others, if anyone reads this far, respond to this point.) Likewise to "Im going to make my son study the Bible."

Vs. "Im going to cut off my son's foreskin no matter what anyone says."

8. Your assertion that there isnt also doesnt prove anything.
 
Last edited:
1. Fairly simple, even from your religious perspective, why is no other part of the body singled out for this ceremony. Why do similar ceremonies in other cultures also target the genitals.


I don't know. I think the psycho-social development of circumcision among diverse groups with no contact is absolutely fascinating. I am intrigued by the explanations I have read. It doesn't change the fact that people of my religion circumcise their children but it is very interesting.

2. I was using that example completely to highlight your system of justification, examples dont have to be directly parallel. The reasoning being used by the hypothetical Aztec is the same as the less hypothetical you.


No, it is not. And I explained why. The Aztec is not looking out for the best interests of the enemy he sacrifices, I am. So my reason to circumcise is to help my child, the Aztec's reason to kill is not to help his victim. They are completely different reasons. Likewise, I only substitute my judgment for an incompetent person whereas the Aztec overrules the judgment of a competent person. His reasoning is different than my own.


3. So youre highlighting a change in the practice while at the same time going on about how if it changes/goes away that Judaism will cease to exist.


Hey, man, I'm not a rabbi. If the religious authorities I trust told me tomorrow that circumcision wasn't necessary, I wouldn't do it. But they haven't said that, so I will go ahead with the bris. We're having it catered.


4. What is important about continuing the practice? Why must Jews continue it? As I said, if a Jew doesnt circumcise do they cease to be Jewish? Some practices dont need to continue. Youre not the only group that circumcises, nor is your current practice of circumcision the original form.


I have answered this numerous times.


5. No, your son's rights to practice religion arnt being enforced. You are using your right to religious freedom to trump his right to personal freedom. I highly doubt a newborn has much interest in religious goings on.


You're right about my newborn son's interest in religion. He has none. That is why I must substitute my judgment for his to do what he would want done if he understood the risks and benefits. And don't bother asking how I know he would want it done. What I want is what he wants. The two are indistinguishable.


6. Your faith is on the way to its doom then


We'll see. Many have said that. None have been right.


7. You missed entirely the point of that.

Saying "I wont allow my son to eat pork." Whats the effect that has on you? Or anyone else. (Please others, if anyone reads this far, respond to this point.) Likewise to "Im going to make my son study the Bible."

Vs. "Im going to cut off my son's foreskin no matter what anyone says."



And ... I guess I'm still missing the point because I don't understand what you're saying here.
 
We'll see. Many have said that. None have been right.


And ... I guess I'm still missing the point because I don't understand what you're saying here.

You took that out of context, and clearly cant catch the sarcasm. Twice Ive said it in metaphorical terms, let me just say it outright so as to avoid confusion.

Judaism will not cease because circumcision is no longer practiced. There is more to the Jewish religion than the impulse to cut up its infant's genitals.

The same is true of R.Catholicism, it wouldnt cease to exist if tomorrow the Pope said "no more Eucharist."

And yes, you are missing the point on the other issue. Hopefully someone else will be able to highlight the difference between making your child study the bible and cutting off part of his genitals.

(Ill come back to address the others again later perhaps.)
 
"My motivation is that it is an element of my religion."
And if it was an element of my religion to hold Jews down without their consent and cut off the last knuckle of their little fingers? Would that be o.k. with you too? I'll wager I could find religious justification to beat my wife... I guess that would be o.k. with you too.

Kindly take your blinkered religion and cram it, thanks.

"with his best interests in mind"
I'm glad you THINK that, but I still pity your children.

"Some of them were a little too frank for my taste."
But you're willing, nay PROUD to stand there and watch your male children mutilated?!?! But you can't handle a frank discussion of basic, natural human sexuality? I wasn't aware that people could get access to the internet in 1950.

"your use of both a question mark and an exclamation mark is bizarre"
Ya... You mutilate your children, and refer to the act as the proudest moment of your life, but MY punctuation is bizarre.... That really makes a lot of sense...

"If the religious authorities I trust told me tomorrow that circumcision wasn't necessary, I wouldn't do it."
So, you freely admit that you'll blindly do whatever your LEADERS (Whose opinions are going to be based on fairy tales and mythology) say you have to?!?! I guess, for your sake, I hope they don't start telling you to throw your children off of cliffs. I can't imagine why you frequent a web forum for sceptics...

"What I want is what he wants."
Wow. What overbearing.... what arrogance.... My pity for your children deepens.

"There is more to the Jewish religion than the impulse to cut up its infant's genitals."
Is there? Doesn't seem like it.


1485 posts, and still the answer to the OP is "NO"... Cause following your leaders blindly isn't the act of a 'rational thinker'.


CH, stop personalizing the argument; attack the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And if it was an element of my religion to hold Jews down without their consent and cut off the last knuckle of their little fingers? Would that be o.k. with you too? I'll wager I could find religious justification to beat my wife... I guess that would be o.k. with you too.


No, as I have explained numerous times, circumcision is effected through a parent substituting his judgment for his incompetent child in the child's best interests. In your hypothetical, the Jews you would hold down are not incompetent to give or withhold consent (in fat, you specify that the procedure is without their consent) and you are not your Jewish victim's next-of-kin or other medical proxy. On top of that, one would then have to weigh whether there is any circumstance where cutting off the last knuckle of a little finger is in the best interests of the person being cut.

But then I just explained all of this with the Aztec example. And I'd explained it all several times before that as well. In fact, I've distinguished these examples so often and so clearly that if you were any other poster, one might be tempted to think that you were being deliberately obtuse. Knowing you, however, I am quite certain it is not deliberate.
 
Off topic point:

Pointing your finger and crying "Racist!" when you have lost an online debate, is known as Hitler's Revenge.
 
Ya... but that's all LL has at this point, robinson.


"I am quite certain it is not deliberate"
That's rich coming from someone who revels in blind, follow-the-leaderism...

Again, I can't imagine why you frequent a web forum for sceptics...
 
I'm not even sure why Loss Leader is in this thread, to be honest. It seems clear that he's not here to learn anything. In fact, all he's doing is defending his beliefs. :con2:
 
No one's rights are being disregarded. My son has the right to make decisions regarding his bodily integrity just as you or I do.
Great! Progress!
However, he is incompetent to understand or evaluate his options so the law has asked me to substitute my judgment for him. I have proudly undertaken this honor and intend to execute my duties only in furtherance of his best interests.
You keep repeating this as if it makes any difference. Everybody understands that the law grants you broad authority to act contrary to your child's best interest.

The fact that you insist on doing it when he can't stop you indicates that you place his interests behind your own superstitions and your own need to feel adequate. You are pursuing this for your interests not his. If you truly cared for his interests you would allow him to make this important choice for himself, and you would give serious consideration to the harm you are causing. I can confidently say that you are not giving serious consideration because you summarily dismiss all scientific information about the benefits of a foreskin as "anecdotal".

I don't get why you stick so stubbornly to this "It's OK because the law allows me to" argument. Given what the Jewish people have historically faced from official, legal oppression, you of all people should understand it is inexcusable to try to use this argument to justify the oppression of another.

All the lawyerly, legalistic arguments for "consent" don't change the fact that you are unnecessarily mutilating the genitals of a baby for your own enjoyment. That baby is a person and is entitled to make that decision for himself, unless it is medically required.

First of all, my son is not non-consenting. He is incapable of consenting. There is a difference.
Legally yes, morally no. I'm beginning to think maybe you can't understand the not-so-subtle difference.

Second of all, this is not the rule. I know you'd like it to be the rule. I know it seems logical to you that it should be the rule. But it is not. Your wishing it were does not make it so.
Priceless coming from the one who seems to rely on repeated lawyerly, legalistic arguments to defend why it is morally acceptable to mutilate the genitals of a child for one's own enjoyment.

Having a law that says it's ok to mutilate a baby's genitals for your own enjoyment doesn't make it OK to do so, no matter how many times you say it does.

I have not ignored this argument.
Yes, you have. Whether intentional or not, you have given no meaningful consideration to the benefits of a foreskin.

I and others have posted links to plenty of sound, scientific information explaining the function and benefit of the foreskin, including properly conducted studies. You calling it "anecdotal" and declaring that concept defeated is the closest any of the pro-circs have come to addressing any of it.

The peer-reviewed and properly researched studies linked to in this thread have not demonstrated that circumcised men derive less pleasure from sex than uncircumcised men.
I love how you frame this. You put the burden of proof on the people who are trying to preserve and protect.

I love it! First we have moral by virtue of legal, now we have moral by virtue of having never been proven harmful through properly researched peer-reviewed studies.

But I guess I'd have to resort to such preposterous arguments too, if I was defending something as indefensible as an adult altering the genitals of a baby for the adult's enjoyment.

No scientific evidence having been adduced,
Translated: having ignored all scientific evidence that shows the harm caused by loss of the foreskin
all that is left is anecdotal evidence.
Amazing! Does this kind of illogic actually work with judges? I fear for our country if so.
I have read the descriptions that the uncircumcised men in this thread have given of the sexual pleasure they enjoy. Some of them were a little too frank for my taste.
Yet you are able to dismiss them, completely unconcerned about the harm you might be causing your son, because that harm has not been "proven" according to the impossibly high standards you've set.

Taking off your lawyer hat, and thinking just as a parent, shouldn't the standard be "has it been proven beyond a reasonable doubt that it is harmless?"

But those anecdotes are offset by my own experience as a circumcised male. And my experience is that I enjoy sex quite a great deal (or, at least, I did until I got married).
Come on, how can you be on a skeptic site and not see the problem with your logic? You have no foreskin, why would you expect to be able to know whether it would have been any better? Just as a man has no idea what sex feels like for a woman, you have no idea what difference a foreskin makes, except that you can hear what men with foreskin can describe and you can read the research studies on the topic. Very telling that you categorically dismiss all such information for no reason other than the challenge it poses.
I don't really enjoy anything more than sex. So I have a hard time believing that the uncircumcised men are enjoying it more. If I were to enjoy it any more than I already do, the process wouldn't last nearly as long and that would make me not enjoy it as much.
How much you currently enjoy sex has no bearing on whether it would (or would not) be better with a foreskin. And the last sentence of that quote is wrong in every possible way.

Notice how you simultaneously argue "no benefit" and "it would be bad if sex were more pleasurable"? :rolleyes: Too funny.
 
No offense to everyone who has posted before... but isn't it a bit silly to refer to circumcision as "mutilation", and frame the anti-circumcision position as being about "body integrity"? It is a medical procedure with little risk, and apparent benefit.

And, really, if you have such a profound interest in and obsession with your genitals, and the genitals of others, I think that little flap of skin is the least of your problems.
 
I think Penn and Teller covered this subject in season 3 episode 1 on Circumcision. They reached the same conclusion using the same arguments pitted against each other, with all the references and arguments for and against circumcision.

The conclusion was no circumcision of all boys.

First the reasons for circumcision chronologically:
1. God wanted this from the Jews (but you are not less jewish, and can still be jewish if you are not circumcised... :boggled: )
2. Christians adopted it because they wanted to annihilate "the perverted act of masturbation" (Kellogg and Graham 19th century. Yeah, the same guys from the cereal and cracker multi-nationals)
3. Questionable Health reasons (after declining religious following) 1970's/ 1980's. This has been rejected already as being pointless. There is no apparent benefit when looking at the population. It is not supported as a guideline for the entire population. It is not advocated as a required procedure for every boy that is born. You are not being negligible when you don't perform this procedure as a prevention measure for the entire population.
4. Conformity (we don't want our kids to feel out of place)

For some reason most North American women are afraid of an anatomically correct penis and men will conform to just about anything to please women.

After restoring the mental health of the community, concerning body image, what will the next reason be? :confused:

Basically circumcision is an easy procedure which brings in money. Some doctors (especially in the US) have forgotten one of the first creeds of medicine: "Do no harm". Or maybe they just don't know any better...

Education of the public starts with the education of doctors

(Yeah, yeah, I know. You'd like me to get of my high horse and don't be so pushy... ;) )

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
{snip}

Basically circumcision is an easy procedure which brings in money. Some doctors (especially in the US) have forgotten one of the first creeds of medicine: "Do no harm". Or maybe they just don't know any better...

Education of the public starts with the education of doctors

(Yeah, yeah, I know. You'd like me to get of the high horse and don't be so pushy... ;) )

SYL :)


Or maybe docs have read the evidence (provided earlier in the thread) about circumcision's potential benefits.
 
No offense to everyone who has posted before... but isn't it a bit silly to refer to circumcision as "mutilation", and frame the anti-circumcision position as being about "body integrity"?
Why would it be silly to call it mutilation when an immobilized unconsenting baby's genitals are unnecessary disfigured and desensitized?
It is a medical procedure with little risk, and apparent benefit.
No it's not. RIC causes harm to the baby each and every time. Even when the harm caused by loss of the foreskin is disregarded entirely, the supposed benefits are neither sure enough nor significant enough to indicate circumcision.

http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;103/3/686

In most cases, circumcision is one of the most harmful ways to deal with the various conditions it is thought to help.

And, really, if you have such a profound interest in and obsession with your genitals, and the genitals of others, I think that little flap of skin is the least of your problems.
Gotta love the duplicity. Those supporting the often painful and always harmful genital modification of an unconsenting baby accuse those who oppose the practice of being "perverts". If you can't beat 'em, defame 'em!
 
Or maybe docs have read the evidence (provided earlier in the thread) about circumcision's potential benefits.
As you may have noted before: The "evidence"is debatable and skewed by the interest of the researchers. Mostly there is a lot of pick and choose. When you look at the meta-analysis and follow-up studies the initial recommendations are not supported. It's progress of medical research. However, doctors are human too...

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
Why would it be silly to call it mutilation when an immobilized unconsenting baby's genitals are unnecessary disfigured and desensitized?
No it's not. RIC causes harm to the baby each and every time. Even when the harm caused by loss of the foreskin is disregarded entirely, the supposed benefits are neither sure enough nor significant enough to indicate circumcision.

http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;103/3/686

In most cases, circumcision is one of the most harmful ways to deal with the various conditions it is thought to help.

Gotta love the duplicity. Those supporting the often painful and always harmful genital modification of an unconsenting baby accuse those who oppose the practice of being "perverts". If you can't beat 'em, defame 'em!


"Always harmful" is an inaccurate description of circumcision.
 
In any event Im glad educated rational people are at the forefront of this issue.
In the coming years hopefully it will be made illegal, except in the (very few) cases that its actually beneficial. We will be a much more enlightened society when we leave behind ritual mutilations and all the weird sexual artifacts from history.



(This post really contributes nothing, just be happy that those of you who cut will be looked back upon as perverts at worst, or misguided at best.)



Yes, to BlackCat, I do have a number of problems as a result. Of course these are all marginal, it really doesnt matter to me that Ill never be able to love someone the way I want, and I should really be happy that I dont have an icky foreskin anyway, right?
 
As you may have noted before: The "evidence"is debatable and skewed by the interest of the researchers. Mostly there is a lot of pick and choose. When you look at the meta-analysis and follow-up studies the initial recommendations are not supported. It's progress of medical research. However, doctors are human too...

SYL :)


You can suggest alternative motives, but the evidence of potential benefits exists.

I am not, as some might assume, pro-circumcision. I am simply presenting the fact that performing the procedure does not violate physicians' ethical obligations to do no harm given the available evidence suggesting potential benefits. Having said that, I would agree with the American Academy of Pediatrics that it is insufficient to advocate that every newborn be circumcised.

It is not, as some would like to make it, a black and white issue.
 
Or maybe docs have read the evidence (provided earlier in the thread) about circumcision's potential benefits.
And carefully ignored the harm caused by the loss of the foreskin. In all of the medical community's evaluations of the "benefits" and harm of circumcision, I don't see any cases where this has even been considered.

By no means are doctors immune from superstition, magical thinking, bias, and dishonesty. The natural motivation for circumcised men to rationalize that they have lost nothing important can't be overstated. Doctors are no exception. Even more so when they benefit financially from the parents' decision to cut.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom