I've already said this, BC, but I'll repeat it because you may not have been here when I did:
I am a lawyer and, as such, it is very important to me that the law and morality coincide. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to make sure they do. But there is something about a moral judgment that we must accept: We may be wrong.
A thought or idea held at any one time by any one person might be completely wrong. It might turn out that some other idea is right, even an idea that we now despise.
Our law recognizes this and has built in something of a failsafe: a plurality of practices are tolerated. Families and religious groups are allowed to test out their own rules. The more there are, the greater chance that one of them will find the right way. This adds a special robustness to the US that (I personally believe) is lacking in countries where human rights are not as highly prized. It adds a creativity and the friction between different cultures creates an energy that we can harness to move ourselves forward.
Even though I am not a lawyer, I'm not stupid, and I actually do understand why our laws are the way they are. I do understand what you're saying here, and I agree.
So, in order for it to be right that circumcision should be banned for all people including Jews, we must be sure we are 100% correct. There must be not the slightest bit of doubt. If we ban a practice, we may never be able to resurect it. Our society will become less diverse and (I think) less productive.
Are you 100% sure that you are objectively and scientifically right about circumcision? Perhaps you are. In any case, the courts are not and the plurality survives.
Ok, I'm not sure where you got the idea that I'm 100% against all circumcisions. I've never said anything like that, and certainly didn't mean to imply it. What I'm against is routine infant circumcision. You don't seem to care what I think, so maybe this part isn't for you. I speak out against circumcision because it really seems like Americans do them for no rational reason at all, in fact, it seems like most people don't even think about it before they do it.
In fact, I get the feeling that most people are so ignorant about their own anatomy, that they can argue that it's a good thing, when they don't even know what they're arguing because they've never had a foreskin that they can remember, and are inherently biased.
No, I am not 100% sure that I am right about circumcision. However, I hold the view that if the outcome of a permanent procedure is unknown or ambiguous, then it is better to be cautious about it, and not do the procedure, than it is to perform it, and be wrong.
Anyway, certainly I believe that there might be medical reasons for circumcision, although, even for conditions like phimosis, it may not be necessary to take the permanent step of circumcision to cure it.
Those things that I said above have nothing to do with you, because your argument is religion. I've come to the realization that I can't argue with you anymore, not because anyone is "right" or "wrong," but because I find the religion argument to be irrational. To me, it's no different than arguing with some christian or whomever about their faith. I don't understand it, it means nothing to me, but obviously it holds relevance for you. Again, I don't mean to be snarky, so I'm sorry if it comes out that way. I'm just being blunt.