Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Yes, but to ask the question again on BlackCat's behalf, what would that evidence have to say in order to compel you?


The possible answers are so numerous as to be infinite. There is no way for me to be more exact.

If circumcision raised the risk of illness from insignificant for uncircumcised men to significant for circumcised ones, I might be persuaded to care. So, for example, if I found our that circumcision doubled a child's risk for chronic granulomatous disease, I would hardly be moved. The disease affects about one person in 250,000. Raising that risk to 1 in 125,000 would not change my opinion. [I just picked CGD because it's rare. Circumcision has nothing to do with it.]

And if I found out that circumcised men had an incidence of prostate cancer 1% higher than uncircumcised men (for every 100 uncircumcised men with prostate cancer, there would be 101 circumcised men), I would not care because the change in risk is too small.

Beyond that, I cannot be more specific.
 
If circumcision raised the risk of illness from insignificant for uncircumcised men to significant for circumcised ones, I might be persuaded to care.

What about up to 10% of circumcised boys developing meatal stenosis?
 
What about up to 10% of circumcised boys developing meatal stenosis?

Maybe they should have their diapers changed...

http://www.urologyhealth.org/search/index.cfm?topic=33&search=meatal AND stenosis&searchtype=and
"The condition is most common in circumcised males and seldom occurs in uncircumcised males. In a recently circumcised male infant, maintaining a clean, dry diaper and avoiding any type of diaper irritation usually prevent meatal stenosis."
http://www.emedicine.com/ped/topic2356.htm
" * In a child who is circumcised, persistent exposure of the meatus to urine and mechanical trauma from rubbing against a wet diaper results in ammoniacal dermatitis, loss of meatal epithelium, and fusion of its ventral edges. This results in a pinpoint orifice at the tip of the glans."
 
Maybe they should have their diapers changed...

Or not be circumcised, a much more simple solution.

The possible answers are so numerous as to be infinite. There is no way for me to be more exact.

If circumcision raised the risk of illness from insignificant for uncircumcised men to significant for circumcised ones, I might be persuaded to care.

You gave a surprisingly reasonable answer. Still though, pertaining to what I asked, would it be ok to remove any of the parts I listed simply because they did not cause complications further down the road? Most of the ones I listed I cant imagine causing higher rates of anything.

An issue to consider is, as it will be ruled on eventually(there is already for girls), if there were a law to be made on your behalf, one that enforced your point of view, what would it be? I find it difficult to imagine any law that would rule in your favor that wouldnt open up a huge can of worms pertaining to what parents can and cant do in the name of tradition.
 
You gave a surprisingly reasonable answer. Still though, pertaining to what I asked, would it be ok to remove any of the parts I listed simply because they did not cause complications further down the road? Most of the ones I listed I cant imagine causing higher rates of anything.


Well, you must remember that parents may substitute their judgment for their children's only if it is in their children's best interests. The current law recognizes maintaining religious traditions as being in the interest of a child (and I am sure you and others disagree that it is in children's best interests, but that's the law right now). So circumcision for religious purposes is in a child's interests and the harm is minor to non-existent.

On the other hand, removal of "ear lobes, a number of teeth, male nipples, toenails," etc. is not the tradition of any religion I know of. So, there is no reason to think that routine excisions of such things might be in a child's best interests. Still, I do have a friend who had both of his nipples removed by his parents when he was too young to consent. As he had a rare and agressive form of breast cancer, it was necessary to save his life.


if there were a law to be made on your behalf, one that enforced your point of view, what would it be? I find it difficult to imagine any law that would rule in your favor that wouldnt open up a huge can of worms pertaining to what parents can and cant do in the name of tradition.


That law already exists and is in force all throughout the US. And it does occassionally put parents and the state in conflict with each other but I wouldn't call it a "huge" can of worms. Parents may substitute their judgment for their children in the children's best interests. That's the rule. I think it's a darn good one, not just because it lets me circumcise my child but because it allows for a plurality of beliefs in the US, minimizes state intervention in families and still protects children.
 
Last edited:
"because the religious authorities I trust advise me to."
So, blind ignorant faith...

As long as you're not pretending to be rational.
 
So circumcision for religious purposes is in a child's interests and the harm is minor to non-existent.

Wrong and wronger.

How do you go from "the law currently allows me to circumcise my child for religious reasons" to "circumcision is in my child's best interests" without making the "my will is his will" pit-stop of absurdity?

And what's with the hit-and-run antisemitism accusations? You accused me of something rather offensive, demanded that I explain myself, and then when I did you just move on to your next victim!

Either I'm antisemetic or you owe me an apology. Since I'm a benevolent, tolerant, patient person, I will gladly and graciously accept your humble apology.
 
Either I'm antisemetic or you owe me an apology. Since I'm a benevolent, tolerant, patient person, I will gladly and graciously accept your humble apology.


You are a hate-monger and antisemite of the worst stripe. You are no better than the worst and most despicably disgusting monster the Aryan Nation has ever produced. I am genuinely saddened that your family and others in your life must be infected by your filthy, worm-ridden ideology. I loathe the very thought that you inhabit the same earth as I do and I dedicate myself to eradicating you and your brothers from the face of the planet for all time.

Clear enough, you racist slimebag?

Do not engage in this vitriolic mud-slinging either. "But he started it" is not excuse for not following the Membership Agreement.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sure. If I were presented with compelling medical evidence that circumcision was detrimental to my child's health in some way, I would be glad to reconsider my views.
I guess dying isn't enough, then? Maybe a bit extreme, but it does happen. Circumcision isn't usually listed as the cause of death, so it's hard to find out how often it happens. It's usually listed under bleeding to death, or infection. You keep saying that complications are rare, but I think even if it's 1%, that's still 12,000 boys every year with complications. You don't have to live that life, but I think it must really suck for them. It seems like Koshy is one of those. I hope your children never suffer from complications.

Well, you must remember that parents may substitute their judgment for their children's only if it is in their children's best interests. The current law recognizes maintaining religious traditions as being in the interest of a child (and I am sure you and others disagree that it is in children's best interests, but that's the law right now). So circumcision for religious purposes is in a child's interests and the harm is minor to non-existent.
The law. Another rationalization of yours. Just because something is legal or illegal has no bearing on whether it is moral or not. I know morality in this case is irrelevant to you, but it might not be to lurkers watching this thread. I also know that most laws are moral. That doesn't mean they're all moral. Jim Crow laws weren't moral, but they were still laws. Parents may have the right to decide to circumcise their boys now, but that doesn't make it moral or right.
 
Maybe they should have their diapers changed...
That's a ridiculous statement that unfairly pins the totality of the blame on the parents; "obviously the diaper wasn't changed enough."

The point of boys getting meatal stenosis is that circumcision changes an internal organ to an external one. By doing so, you subject an internal organ, the glans and meatus, to the harshness of the external world, something that it has not evolved to do. Thus, meatal stenosis.

Also, you didn't mention that meatal stenosis requires more surgery to correct. Something that could have been avoided altogether if the boy hadn't been circumcised in the first place.


Oh, and I see that you've returned. Perhaps you'd like to answer my question now?

BlackKat said:
That consensus does exist for circumcision in the U.S. and while it is not a ringing endorsement of the procedure it is medically neutral.
http://aappolicy.aappublications.org...cs;103/3/686
Even this report which you sited doesn't recommend routine infant circumcision. I fail to see how that makes circumcision medically neutral. How is it medically neutral?
 
The law. Another rationalization of yours. Just because something is legal or illegal has no bearing on whether it is moral or not. I know morality in this case is irrelevant to you, but it might not be to lurkers watching this thread.


I've already said this, BC, but I'll repeat it because you may not have been here when I did:

I am a lawyer and, as such, it is very important to me that the law and morality coincide. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to make sure they do. But there is something about a moral judgment that we must accept: We may be wrong.

A thought or idea held at any one time by any one person might be completely wrong. It might turn out that some other idea is right, even an idea that we now despise.

Our law recognizes this and has built in something of a failsafe: a plurality of practices are tolerated. Families and religious groups are allowed to test out their own rules. The more there are, the greater chance that one of them will find the right way. This adds a special robustness to the US that (I personally believe) is lacking in countries where human rights are not as highly prized. It adds a creativity and the friction between different cultures creates an energy that we can harness to move ourselves forward.

So, in order for it to be right that circumcision should be banned for all people including Jews, we must be sure we are 100% correct. There must be not the slightest bit of doubt. If we ban a practice, we may never be able to resurect it. Our society will become less diverse and (I think) less productive.

Are you 100% sure that you are objectively and scientifically right about circumcision? Perhaps you are. In any case, the courts are not and the plurality survives.

I hope this helps you reconcile how I can be in favor of both law and morality in the same sentence.


p.s. I appologize to readers of this thread for the harsh and passionate tone of my earlier message. If I were able to delete it, I would.
 
I've already said this, BC, but I'll repeat it because you may not have been here when I did:

I am a lawyer and, as such, it is very important to me that the law and morality coincide. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to make sure they do. But there is something about a moral judgment that we must accept: We may be wrong.

A thought or idea held at any one time by any one person might be completely wrong. It might turn out that some other idea is right, even an idea that we now despise.

Our law recognizes this and has built in something of a failsafe: a plurality of practices are tolerated. Families and religious groups are allowed to test out their own rules. The more there are, the greater chance that one of them will find the right way. This adds a special robustness to the US that (I personally believe) is lacking in countries where human rights are not as highly prized. It adds a creativity and the friction between different cultures creates an energy that we can harness to move ourselves forward.

So, in order for it to be right that circumcision should be banned for all people including Jews, we must be sure we are 100% correct. There must be not the slightest bit of doubt. If we ban a practice, we may never be able to resurect it. Our society will become less diverse and (I think) less productive.

Are you 100% sure that you are objectively and scientifically right about circumcision? Perhaps you are. In any case, the courts are not and the plurality survives.

I hope this helps you reconcile how I can be in favor of both law and morality in the same sentence.


p.s. I appologize to readers of this thread for the harsh and passionate tone of my earlier message. If I were able to delete it, I would.

That's ok LL;)

I almost totally agree with you. People should be free to do whatever they want so long as it does not hurt (or risk hurting) anybody else.

I am 100% confident that cutting off a infants foreskin hurts him, both physically and mentally and the society that tolerates it to happen. It should therefore be regulated and only performed when medically indicated in the safest and most pain-free way possible.

Obviously you will totally disagree:)
 
As Loss Leader shows us, there's nothing worse than a coward with a big mouth.

Whoa.

Sorry, Clinton, but I've been reading LL's prose for quite a while. You might disagree with him, but LL is NOT a coward. This might hit a hot button for him, and it is something he's very passionate about, but at the same time, to assume he's responding as he is out of fear is wrong.

I think I've made my views on this clear, and while I disagree with LL deeply about this, I respect his choice to disagree.
 
I am 100% confident that cutting off a infants foreskin hurts him, both physically and mentally and the society that tolerates it to happen. It should therefore be regulated and only performed when medically indicated in the safest and most pain-free way possible.

Obviously you will totally disagree:)


I don't totally disagree, but the amount that I disagree is enough to change the result. For example, after having read all of the information on this thread I doubt that I would have my child circumcised if I were not Jewish. Before I encountered this thread, I would have.

For me, the cultural and religious benefit to my child outweighs the fact that I really am convinced there is usually no real medical benefit.

So, it's not total disagreement, a sentiment with which I am sure you will totally disagree. Or agree. I've gotten myself confused.
 
I don't totally disagree, but the amount that I disagree is enough to change the result. For example, after having read all of the information on this thread I doubt that I would have my child circumcised if I were not Jewish. Before I encountered this thread, I would have.

For me, the cultural and religious benefit to my child outweighs the fact that I really am convinced there is usually no real medical benefit.

So, it's not total disagreement, a sentiment with which I am sure you will totally disagree. Or agree. I've gotten myself confused.

You've probably still got me on ignore...
But what, exactly, is the cultural or religious benefit to your child?
If you don't circumcise, you're still Jewish. Would your Jewish peers ostracise you or something? Would they kick you out of Judaism if you say "Hey...I think I'll not do this one little thing right now."?
 
You've probably still got me on ignore...
But what, exactly, is the cultural or religious benefit to your child?
If you don't circumcise, you're still Jewish. Would your Jewish peers ostracise you or something? Would they kick you out of Judaism if you say "Hey...I think I'll not do this one little thing right now."?

I'll quote you KellyB so LL can see your question, something I would like to know his answer to as well.

It appears to me to be more a fear of what the Rabbi and Jewish peers think rather than God, but I could be wrong.

If I believed in God I'd hope he would judge me on how I have lived my life rather than if I have my foreskin attached or not.
 
I'll quote you KellyB so LL can see your question, something I would like to know his answer to as well.

It appears to me to be more a fear of what the Rabbi and Jewish peers think rather than God, but I could be wrong.

If I believed in God I'd hope he would judge me on how I have lived my life rather than if I have my foreskin attached or not.


I generally disapprove of quoting a poster to get around the "ignore" function, but I'm still feeling bad about my outburst earlier, so I'll answer. Luckily, I already answered this very question recently upthread:


I In my case, I believe the world is better off with Jews than without them. As the forces of assimilation are relentless, I believe it is my duty to continue the traditions of Judaism. This is not necessarily because I believe in God but because if I do not practice Judaism, it might make it harder for the next person to do so. I never want to hear the argument made to my neighbor, "Well, Loss Leader didn't circumcise his kid and he's Jewish, so you shouldn't circumcise yours" or "Why don't you eat pork? Loss Leader eats pork and he's just as Jewish as you are."


You see, I circumcise my children for the Jewish people. I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity. I have no fear of what God will do to me (or my children) and I have no fear of what other Jews might think of me. I live in terror that my refusal to circumcise my children or participate in other religious obligations will make it any harder for other Jews to do so.
 
"but LL is NOT a coward"
When every time he's challenged with something his religious/cultural zeal can't rationally defend, he buries his head in the sand.... that's the act of a coward.

"I respect his choice to disagree."
I refuse to 'respect' anyone who advocates mutilating children, especially for BS Stupidstitious reasons.

"Would they kick you out of Judaism"
Only if he's lucky.

" I generally disapprove of quoting a poster to get around the "ignore" function"
Awww... poor little muffin.... Want someone to dial whine-one-one and have them send a whaaambulance?

"I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity."
Blind, stupid, faith.
 
"Would they kick you out of Judaism"
Only if he's lucky.


You're telling me. Do you have any idea what passes for Hannukah presents? Dress socks. That's what I get for Hannukah, dress socks.


" I generally disapprove of quoting a poster to get around the "ignore" function"
Awww... poor little muffin.... Want someone to dial whine-one-one and have them send a whaaambulance?


Considering the fact that I then went on to answer the question, your comment is bizarre.


"I do it to maintain unity, cohesiveness and identity among my ethnicity."
Blind, stupid, faith.


Nothing I said had anything to do with faith. I didn't say I do it because God commanded me to or because I think that we should obey the rules of the Old Testament. I didn't say that I refuse to question why my religion has certain rules or even that I agree with them. My faith has nothing to do with it whatsoever. Perhaps what you meant to write was "blind, stupid loyalty."

In fact, what I said was so obviously not about faith that I question whether you bothered to read it at all. It appears you may simply have determined that you dislike me and thus you consider everything I say to be wrong. I am sorrier for your lack of discernment than for your intolerance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom