Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Are you sure about that? maybe "moo" was meant to be "jew", and... ah, nevermind..

Clearly the reality you experience is significantly different from the reality I experience, so we'll have to agree to disagree on the whole "who's the bigot" issue.


So, just to be clear, you are refusing to answer this question:

Why would the fact of one of the doctors' affiliation with a hospital with "Jewish" in the name be a potential source of bias?

And you also believe that it is not bigotted to say that I am "Jew-serving," that I "live up to the "worst stereotypes" of my ethnicity and that I "deserved" what I got.

I do not agree to disagree on the whole "who's the bigot" issue. I have never been warned by the mods for insulting the ethnicity of a user. I have never compared someone to the stereotypes of his religion. I have never argued that affiliation with a hospital with a "kosher cafeteria" is a potential source of bias in a peer-reviewed study.

The antisemite is you.
 
I'm just as offended by your religious crap as he is. It's not anti-semitic it's anti ancient superstitious garbage. It's also anti-mutilation. I also think Christians, Muslims and all other religions are a pile of crap. Does that make me anti-semetic? For the record I think the people that think "the jews" are taking over the world (NWO all that crap) are totally bonkers as well.

I guess what I'm saying is that I don't really care what your reasons for mutilating your children are... it's a sick act either way.
 
That is how I was able to proudly stand by and watch my son be circumcised. I believed that it was in his interests.

The only question, then, is if my belief is obviously and objectively wrong. If it isn't, the pain caused to my son cannot be a reason in itself not to do the procedure.
So, it's clear that pain is a non-issue for you, because parents have to do far more painful things that are in their child's interests. This may or may not happen, but did you ever consider that your son might question the beliefs he was raised with, and in particular, your choice to have him circumcised? What are you going to say, if one day he tells you that he is unhappy that you didn't give him the opportunity to decide for himself?

No, you cannot say, "that won't happen!" because frankly, you don't know.

I'm not sure what you're talking about. I didn't circumcise my son because my experience "wasn't bad." I did it because we are Jewish.
Actually, this question wasn't directed at you, because I already knew that you rationalized your behavior with religion.

This is no different than say, some Muslims, who use the Quran to rationalize how they kill others who don't believe in the same religion.

Sure, I'll admit that it's not a good analogy. In fact, the only part that's analogous is the rationalization part. You (and they) rationalize your actions with your religion.

This is not skeptical behavior.
(Are you now going to reply that you aren't a skeptic? That would be strange, because that's how I've perceived you from your other posts on this forum.)
 
What are you going to say, if one day he tells you that he is unhappy that you didn't give him the opportunity to decide for himself?


I will say, "I did what I believed was in your best interests."


This is no different than say, some Muslims, who use the Quran to rationalize how they kill others who don't believe in the same religion.

Sure, I'll admit that it's not a good analogy. In fact, the only part that's analogous is the rationalization part. You (and they) rationalize your actions with your religion.


It's a terrible analogy. In the case of circumcision, I am able to substitute my judgment for my incompetent son for his best interests. [I realize you don't believe circumcision is in my son's best interests but I do and, so far, no judge or legislature has cared enough to disagree.]

In the case of some fundamentalist Muslims killing non-believers, they are not substituting their judgment for their incompetent victims for their best interests. First of all, their victims are rarely incompetent to make their own decisions. Second, the terrorists don't hold their victim's medical proxy. Last, death is rarely (but not never) in someone's best interests.

The better analogy would be Japanese mothers jumping off cliffs with their children to avoid capture by American forces in WWII. And even that analogy wouldn't be great. Also, I'm not sure if that really happened or if it's just a myth.


This is not skeptical behavior.
(Are you now going to reply that you aren't a skeptic? That would be strange, because that's how I've perceived you from your other posts on this forum.)


Well, first of all, thanks. As has been argued in another thread (Is Anyone Here Not An Atheist), it may not be realistic to demand purity in skepticism. Religious beliefs and cultural affiliations may be important safe havens both psychologically and sociologically. The ego cannot constantly battle the world without rest.

In my case, I believe the world is better off with Jews than without them. As the forces of assimilation are relentless, I believe it is my duty to continue the traditions of Judaism. This is not necessarily because I believe in God but because if I do not practice Judaism, it might make it harder for the next person to do so. I never want to hear the argument made to my neighbor, "Well, Loss Leader didn't circumcise his kid and he's Jewish, so you shouldn't circumcise yours" or "Why don't you eat pork? Loss Leader eats pork and he's just as Jewish as you are."

I hope that clears things up.
 
Last edited:
As far a negative side effect that can befall the circumcised or the cisers, I no longer talk to my family as a result of it.

I love that "all men that are circumcised are happy." Apparently Im not a member of this "all men" Ive been hearing so much about.

You defenders of cutting have absolutely nothing to go on.

The HIV = Mandatory argument, lets see. There are 302 million, give or take, Americans. Of those, about 1.3million have HIV. So, hereby, by cutting our babies we are reducing a roughly .3ish% chance of contracting aids, from anyone with it, by 50% down to .15%. I think, if my math isnt completely off, Im not providing links to the population data, if you can do better do so. I had intended to write a fair deal more, but Im not feeling so well at the moment, so Ill return later.

First post wooooo.

Edit: Yes, before you say it, I decided to edit it that I know that none of the circ advocates are actually saying thats the reason, or any other reason, despite its constant appearance throughout this thread, I totally understand that thats totally and completely not going into the rationale totally.
 
Last edited:
As far a negative side effect that can befall the circumcised or the cisers, I no longer talk to my family as a result of it.

I love that "all men that are circumcised are happy." Apparently Im not a member of this "all men" Ive been hearing so much about.

You defenders of cutting have absolutely nothing to go on.


At least there's something we can do about our unfortunate predicament. Do what I'm doing -- Restore your foreskin.

:)
 
I will say, "I did what I believed was in your best interests."
Thanks for answering honestly. I know there's nothing you can do if he said that, but at least you're willing to admit that it might happen. Since the possibility of dissatisfaction is there, might that mean that you really don't know best, despite thinking that you do?

It's a terrible analogy.
I apologize for it then. However, the point still remains. Using religion to rationalize behavior.

[I realize you don't believe circumcision is in my son's best interests but I do and, so far, no judge or legislature has cared enough to disagree.]
Not yet, anyway. It's not like there haven't been lawsuits. They've just been settled out of court. Perhaps to you, as the lawyer, that is unimportant, but I think it speaks volumes. There are people dissatisfied enough to do something about it. I see it as "baby steps," much like any other civil rights movement. Maybe you don't see it that way, that's ok.

Well, first of all, thanks. As has been argued in another thread (Is Anyone Here Not An Atheist), it may not be realistic to demand purity in skepticism. Religious beliefs and cultural affiliations may be important safe havens both psychologically and sociologically. The ego cannot constantly battle the world without rest.
I checked that thread, and saw the arguments about if it was possible to be religious, and also a skeptic. I'm not sure what I think about that, but in any case, it's largely irrelevant what my opinion is. For me, I expect myself to question everything, and it would follow that I expect that of others. Obviously, people don't do that, and I find that terribly disappointing.

I'm trying to understand about what you said about you and your religion; it seems like you are Jewish, but do not believe in god. But you clearly follow the tenets of your flavor of Judaism. (Sorry, not being flippant here, I just am not that familiar with your religion, and so do not know the correct terms.) Why is it that you practice circumcision? (Please don't answer, "because we're Jewish.") Is it because the religion says so, or because your culture values it, or what...?

Not to be rude, but the safe havens argument was not in that thread, except for what you already said about it. I thought that was unfortunate, because I wanted to see people argue that.
 
As far a negative side effect that can befall the circumcised or the cisers, I no longer talk to my family as a result of it.
That sounds sad. I'm curious what happened, but you don't have to talk about it if you don't want to.

First post wooooo.
Welcome. I hope you enjoy your time here. :)

At least there's something we can do about our unfortunate predicament. Do what I'm doing -- Restore your foreskin. :)
That's great. I wanted you to know -- I loved reading your story. It's too bad that restoration can never restore what's been lost (and a lot has been lost, regardless of what the pro-circs say), but at least you can get close. I think it was your post that made me go and look up for myself what really happens when males are circumcised.

In fact, when I came to this thread, I was against circumcision, but didn't really have an opinion either way as to which "looked better." Now that I've researched for myself, I can see the power of socialization, and how even I was socialized to think that a circumcised penis was "normal." I don't know when the change occurred, but somewhere in my research, I came to regard the cut penis as an "anomaly." Not disgusting, just not normal. Much like how we see people in tribes with elongated earlobes or something similar.
 
Thanks for answering honestly. I know there's nothing you can do if he said that, but at least you're willing to admit that it might happen. Since the possibility of dissatisfaction is there, might that mean that you really don't know best, despite thinking that you do?


I'll do better than that: I will catagorically and unequivocally state that my thoughts about what is right for my children are based on absolutely no objective evidence whatsoever and that what I "know" is nothing more than an amalgam of subjective understandings, rules of thumb, moral guides, prejudices and good old fashioned guesswork.

I'm not sure how that separates me from any other person now living on the planet, but there you go.


I apologize for it then. However, the point still remains. Using religion to rationalize behavior.


No, I don't think your point does remain. In one case, I have the legal and moral authority to make decisions for another person. In the other case, I do not.


I'm trying to understand about what you said about you and your religion; it seems like you are Jewish, but do not believe in god. But you clearly follow the tenets of your flavor of Judaism. (Sorry, not being flippant here, I just am not that familiar with your religion, and so do not know the correct terms.) Why is it that you practice circumcision? (Please don't answer, "because we're Jewish.") Is it because the religion says so, or because your culture values it, or what...?

My "flavor" of Judaism is called Conservative.

I practice circumcision because the religious authorities I trust advise me to.

Subjectively, I believe circumcision to be an indelible mark of one's special obligations as a member of the Jewish people. That is not, however, the reason I circumcised my son (and will circumcise the next one in about 12 weeks). The reason is because the religious authorities I trust advise me to.



Not to be rude, but the safe havens argument was not in that thread, except for what you already said about it. I thought that was unfortunate, because I wanted to see people argue that.


Yeah, and then they started insulting each other. That thread takes some patience to work through.
 
That's great. I wanted you to know -- I loved reading your story. It's too bad that restoration can never restore what's been lost (and a lot has been lost, regardless of what the pro-circs say), but at least you can get close. I think it was your post that made me go and look up for myself what really happens when males are circumcised.

In fact, when I came to this thread, I was against circumcision, but didn't really have an opinion either way as to which "looked better." Now that I've researched for myself, I can see the power of socialization, and how even I was socialized to think that a circumcised penis was "normal." I don't know when the change occurred, but somewhere in my research, I came to regard the cut penis as an "anomaly." Not disgusting, just not normal. Much like how we see people in tribes with elongated earlobes or something similar.

Thanks for the reply! I'm very glad when a post of mine is able to help or inspire someone, in any way.

I never really thought about what was "normal" until my wife mentioned that she found intact penii very sexy and attractive, nor did I really know anything about the difference (aside from looks) at the time.

Now I myself find the thought of being "intact", or as close as I can become to being so, more appealing each day. And as I see the small results and differences i have achieved after only a couple months worth of dedicated restoring, it has already made things better for both of us!
 
Just found an interesting argument against the cultural/religious reasons for circumcision:

http://jme.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/30/3/248

CONCLUSION
Human sexuality and the attempts to control it, particularly to reduce or add sexual pleasure, have been, in one way or another, a part of all known cultures and civilisations. While sometimes this fact is acknowledged openly as the main purpose for genital mutilation, in most cases other rationalisations are put forward for the practice. These false reasons have varied from religious and cultural demands to a number of medical "explanations", depending on the wider cultural tradition within which the practice has appeared. These different rationalisations for the maintenance of the practices in various cultures show that no matter what the cultural differences are in beliefs and lifestyles, genital mutilation is a universal sign of human civilisation—or maybe the lack of it. All societies have found the arguments that best fit their local cultural traditions and environments in order to introduce or maintain genital mutilation in its various forms. In the Western, rather individualist tradition, these rationalisations are based on benefit to the individual and/or autonomy; in the Southern and Eastern cultures their support is drawn more directly from social values and ties, or from the need to protect one’s unique cultural identity against Western cultural imperialism. Thus, in this regard one cultural tradition cannot be said to be better than another. Rather, with further education and knowledge the cultural smokescreen around the real reasons for the maintenance of the practice can be overcome in all societies no matter what their cultural background.

(The full article is free but you'll need to register to access it.)
 
So, just to be clear, you are refusing to answer this question:

Just to be clear, I only refused to answer it because the answer is self-evident to anyone with the ability to reason: 2 + 2 = 4. Unless, of course, they have a huge, gaping, religiously-inspired blind spot on this subject.

Why would the fact of one of the doctors' affiliation with a hospital with "Jewish" in the name be a potential source of bias?

I really wonder if you're being deliberately obtuse as part of your overall disingenuity, but in case you aren't and you really cannot put this together, here goes:

People are biased. There is a VERY good chance that the Jewish doctor (and most of the doctors at the Jewish hospital) happened to have a pro-circ bias. There is very little chance that such a person would undertake a study to prove themselves wrong, and even if they did undertake such a study with the best intentions, there is a good chance their personal bias will interfere at some point, and this will tend to skew the results in favor of their personal bias.

And you also believe that it is not bigotted to say that I am "Jew-serving,"

Your arguments ARE Jew-serving. By that I mean, your arguments are wrong, poorly-reasoned and illegitimate. They are not an honest search for truth, they are pro-Jew rhetoric.

Please, spare us.

that I "live up to the "worst stereotypes"

Sorry man, you are living up to them, at least in this thread. You're displaying many traits that the optimist in me had previously categorized as "just a negative stereotype; not true."

I prefer to think the best of people, so I prefer not to believe those negative stereotypes. However, every now and then someone comes along and proves a bunch of them correct, and I don't like that. I guess it's a bit of cog-dis, it causes me to struggle to hang on to my "people are people" philosophy.

and that I "deserved" what I got.

You so did. You actually had the tenacity to enter into a rational debate about circumcision with your "Jewish boys are circumcised" pseudo-philosophy. Even Sylvia Browne could have predicted you'd get your butt handed to you, and even a bigoted redneck could have predicted you'd cry "antisemite" at the first opportunity. I wouldn't have believed that redneck, but I'd have been wrong.

I do not agree to disagree on the whole "who's the bigot" issue.

Too bad for you, you're just digging yourself deeper into the hole.

I have never been warned by the mods for insulting the ethnicity of a user.

Point?

The mods may not be correct about that, but their mistake is both understandable and forgiveable. Anyone can fall into PC thinking.

The antisemite is you.

Impossible. I just don't care. People are people.

Your problem is you're bigoted in favor of Jews. You think Jews are something special, and I think they're nothing special. I am admittedly insensitive to your Jewish angst, and that's the real issue here. You think I should care about you being Jewish and I don't.
 
Last edited:
I'll do better than that: I will catagorically and unequivocally state that my thoughts about what is right for my children are based on absolutely no objective evidence whatsoever and that what I "know" is nothing more than an amalgam of subjective understandings, rules of thumb, moral guides, prejudices and good old fashioned guesswork.
Since your decision isn't based on objective evidence, is there anything that would convince you to change your mind about circumcision and would make you no longer want to practice it? Anything at all?

(Feel free to ask me the same question. I would never ask a question of someone that I would not answer myself.)
 
That sounds sad. I'm curious what happened, but you don't have to talk about it if you don't want to.


Its a long series of events. I realized when I was pretty young that something was wrong with me, what with the areas that looked to have "grown together."
I didnt think anything of it at the time though, whats a penis for anyway? Going to the bathroom and thats about it.

Meanwhile I managed to get quite fat, which probably helped me avoid any sexual situations, reaching a high point of around 300 pounds when I was 16/17.
So, I decided to lose weight, which I can quite easily claim riding a bike at the gym for half and hour with a circumcised penis isnt an exercise(pun) in comfort, which resulted in me just taping the remnants of my shaft skin together over the glans, still under the impression that I was perfectly normal.
After quite a bit of work I managed to bring my weight down to 180-185, at which point I decided, since I was doing all these body improvements anyway, including weight training and all that, I might as well investigate what this growth on my penis was. And also, having weighed so much I had expressed interest in having skin removed, its not a big issue, just some loose skin here and there.

Anyway, upon starting my research I learned about skin bridges and the like, after a few days I kept seeing circumcision in connection to these issues, at the point I didnt really know what it even was, having just seen references in movies and the like, including Mel Brooks(I believe, the comedy director) in one movie shoving a carrot in a guitine, cutting the tip off, and calling it a "circumcision." I didnt get it, but didnt think much of it.
Upon researching that whats wrong with me was in fact a result of my parents deliberate choice, and that had I been left alone chances are that I wouldnt have any problems, wouldnt have to use tape to be comfortable, etc, I became very depressed, and felt extremely betrayed, I started to talk to them less at this point.

I had never directly talked about it with them, up until my mother contacted me saying she had found a surgeon that could help with my skin removal, I was still considering having it done, until by some divine coincidence she said "Its the same doctor that I had you with," I guess he had decided to move on to greener pastures. So, having learned that she was planning to use the same doctor she had cut me in the first place I became extremely angry, but still didnt say anything. She kept calling to push the issue and I finally I suppose snapped and told her, surprisingly articulate considering how I was feeling, "You honestly expect me to go under the knife of the same man that you paid to mutilate me."

Thus, my parents introduction to my feelings on the issue. Needless to say she didnt take kindly to it.

Over the course of a year we started to talk about it, and they increasingly blamed me for everything that was wrong, refusing to read any of the information I sent them, refusing to acknowledge that it was their fault that I am damaged.

Rinse and repeat the same conversation roughly 30 times and you have my current situation. Ive not been home since Christmas, which was a very fun affair with me sitting in a corner until I could leave again, Ive not phoned in a few months, and I generally ignore when they call. I never say "I love you" anymore, except to my grandparents seeing as I suppose they are relatively innocent in this affair. I feel no need to affiliate with people who endorse mutilating babies, who endorse non medical body modifications on helpless people, people that blame me for being damaged as a result of what they had done to me.

Theres a lot more to the story I suppose, and it would have been more correct to say that I talk to them as minimally as possible given the way things are, but theres that. Anyway, I still have alot to add, but consolidating all my feelings on the issue into one posting is impossible, cause there are quite a few.

Until next time campers.

Edit: Thanks Sylvester.
 
Last edited:
Thus, my parents introduction to my feelings on the issue. Needless to say she didnt take kindly to it.

Over the course of a year we started to talk about it, and they increasingly blamed me for everything that was wrong, refusing to read any of the information I sent them, refusing to acknowledge that it was their fault that I am damaged.

Even though I myself was spared the pain and indignity, I totally empathize with what you say. That's exactly how I would feel, coming to the conclusion that I had been permanently altered for whimsical reasons.

My sister just had a baby boy and I'm almost afraid to go visit her now; What if I see him naked and he's circumcised? I could never think of her the same way after that.

What your parents did to you they did out of ignorance, not malice. There's really no point dwelling on it, you can both forgive your parents and maintain that RIC is absolutely wrong. Now that you've fallen down that rabbit hole and fully realised your situation, hopefully time (and knowledge) will heal you on the inside.

Welcome to the forum.
 
Last edited:
Since your decision isn't based on objective evidence, is there anything that would convince you to change your mind about circumcision and would make you no longer want to practice it? Anything at all?


Sure. If I were presented with compelling medical evidence that circumcision was detrimental to my child's health in some way, I would be glad to reconsider my views. Bear in mind that I have reviewed all of the actual medical evidence presented and linked to in this thread and have not yet seen anything that leads me to that conclusion.


(Feel free to ask me the same question. I would never ask a question of someone that I would not answer myself.)


Oh, rest assured that I don't care. I don't care who does or does not circumcise their children or why. My interest starts and ends at the right of Jewish children to be circumcised for religious reasons.
 
Sure. If I were presented with compelling medical evidence that circumcision was detrimental to my child's health in some way, I would be glad to reconsider my views. Bear in mind that I have reviewed all of the actual medical evidence presented and linked to in this thread and have not yet seen anything that leads me to that conclusion.

Yes, but to ask the question again on BlackCat's behalf, what would that evidence have to say in order to compel you? Bearing in mind that the removal of a number of body parts (ear lobes, a number of teeth, male nipples, toenails) would be met with minimal medical concern assuming the operation could be carried out with sufficient skill as to avoid complications directly resulting from it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom