Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

... and I'll reconsider my opinion of infant circumcision for cultural or religious reasons.


Despite the fact that you have consistently been one of the more polite and reserved anti-circumcision people in this thread, I can say with complete honesty that almost nothing has ever been less important to me.
 
Oh? And what did your son say about it when you consulted him?


The last thing my son said to me today was, "cow, moo." And I can say with perfect confidence that, unlike the last thing you said to me, it wasn't antisemitic.
 
robinson said:
Personally, watching the video brought up the same feelings in me I get when I see the death camps. How can anyone be so inhuman? I got physically ill hearing the frantic cries of pain, how the helpless infant, tied hand and foot, screams so hard it can't breath.

I'm sure the people claiming their kids didn't suffer, are either liars, or deluded, or mentally sick. I've heard it a thousand times, from parents guilty of child abuse. They really don't seem to be able to empathize with another human being. They can shrug off or ignore cries of fear and pain, like it really means nothing to them.

I can't understand it. But I really despise people who torture and maim children.. So forgive me oh Mods, if I overstepped the boundaries of civility here.
I hear ya'. And remember, about half the circumcisions done in the US now STILL don't use any pain relief. And most the rest use something that's more of a token jesture, like EMLA cream.

Ivor said:
You are either lying or incredibly ignorant.
Remember, this is the poster who claims they put some cream on, waited just a "few minutes" and his son didn't seem terribly bothered by the procedure.
So essentially, he saw a circ with no pain relief and says it doesn't appear to hurt.
And that the plastibell method is painless. Like it involves summoning fairies who simply breathe on the foreskin and it just magically melts away.
 
I hear ya'. And remember, about half the circumcisions done in the US now STILL don't use any pain relief. And most the rest use something that's more of a token jesture, like EMLA cream.

I despise physicians who do not object to this cruelty at every opportunity. They have no excuse.:mad:

Remember, this is the poster who claims they put some cream on, waited just a "few minutes" and his son didn't seem terribly bothered by the procedure.
So essentially, he saw a circ with no pain relief and says it doesn't appear to hurt.
And that the plastibell method is painless. Like it involves summoning fairies who simply breathe on the foreskin and it just magically melts away.

It appears the pro-circ. people left in the thread are too far gone. I shall not be arguing with them any more, mainly for the sake of my own sanity!
 
One showing is worth a thousand tellings.
The following linked image may be disturbing to the sensibility of a rational mind.
http://business.fortunecity.com/mars/272/circ.jpg

Plastibell at work.

I say again, I give the Jews credit for using alcohol to deaden the pain and smooth the trauma. It also helps everyone else out, because who wants to hear the scream of an infant in horrible pain?

I found even more graphic images of circumcision, but I'm not going to link to them. I can't hardly stand to even look at them.
 
Last edited:
So take your strawman and apply it somewhere else. Thanks.

You are defending circumcision, and your opponents (and an fellow defender of circumcision) posts credible references explaining the long term harm and damage to sexual function caused by the loss of the foreskin. What to do?

Focus on a peripheral issue you can deal with, such as the issue of pain & suffering caused by the procedure, and explain how anesthesia and modern practices & equipment make it relatively pain free. Then all suffering can be blamed on improper medical care. You win!

--------

The biggest issue with infant circumcision is that more than just a bit of skin is being taken; some of the pleasure of sex is also taken. All other considerations pale in comparison. Men who are cut insist that the foreskin provides no meaningful increase in pleasure from sex. How they could possibly know this, considering that they lack the capacity to experience the sensations of a foreskin, remains a mystery. Men who are intact, and therefore still able to experience those sensations, will tell you that the sensation and function provided by the foreskin is significant and important. Studies have confirmed this.

Get your hands off that baby's penis until he is of legal age.
 
Last edited:
"summoning fairies who simply breathe on the foreskin"
Heeey... now THAT sounds like something I could get into!

;-)

let's see video footage of that... fairies breathing on foreskin!

Hubba!
 
Two questions that I wish the pro-circs would answer:

Why can't it wait until they are adults and can decide for themselves?

Why do you assume because your experience with circumcision wasn't bad, that others will feel the same way? (Inductive reasoning)
 
Two questions that I wish the pro-circs would answer:

Why can't it wait until they are adults and can decide for themselves?


Because we are Jewish.


Why do you assume because your experience with circumcision wasn't bad, that others will feel the same way? (Inductive reasoning)


I'm not sure what you're talking about. I didn't circumcise my son because my experience "wasn't bad." I did it because we are Jewish.
 
There you have it. If God told his people to cut off a finger, or you were not of the chosen ones, fingers would be removed, and it would be OK.

It is called religion.
 
Weird conversation to be having in the science subforum of a skeptic forum...
 
I just don't get the whole not wanting to wait until the child is old enough to decide for themselves thing. Wouldn't you want to err on the side of caution when lopping off body parts?
 
Oh please. You don't want to wait until a kid is thirteen before doing circumcision, (which is the case in some cultures).

You see, you have to get a kid drunk before cutting off part of a very sensitive organ. To keep them from screaming bloody murder. If you get a kid drunk at thirteen, then whack part of his pee pee off, he might associate drinking with extreme pain and mutilation of body parts.
 
"You don't want to wait until a kid is thirteen before doing circumcision"
I want people to follow good sense and moral decency and not do it at all.
 
Mutilation, ritual scarring, neck stretching, bound feet, piercing, tattoos, enduring pain, mankind has a long history of body modification, as well as using these as rites of passages.
 
And any time they are done to people without their consent, it's disgusting

You wanna bind YOUR feet? Knock yourself out... You want to FORCE all women to bind their feet? As the Glaswegians say, "*'* *** ****" *Edit... cause of pansy rules.


If you want to try to do it for an ignorant reason like "Ghawd said they have to" then you've opted out of all rational reality.
 
The last thing my son said to me today was, "cow, moo." And I can say with perfect confidence that, unlike the last thing you said to me, it wasn't antisemitic.

Are you sure about that? maybe "moo" was meant to be "jew", and... ah, nevermind..

Clearly the reality you experience is significantly different from the reality I experience, so we'll have to agree to disagree on the whole "who's the bigot" issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom