Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I'm also a little curious about the masturbatory habits of those that are circ'd. Those of us that are uncut use the foreskin as a bearing, as was pointed out above, and this makes it a really nice way to masturbate. Do those circ'd people truly not use the glans? I would also be curious how difficult it is for them to reach orgasm in comparison, anyone have a study?

I've already read some stuff about the orgasm trigger using some nerves in the foreskin. Are circ'd people more prone to premature ejaculation or anything like that? I'm getting the feeling there haven't been too many studies about this kind of stuff...

Actually, circ'd people generally last longer than uncirc'd - I'm a little too lazy to bother finding the relevant research, but there you go. And that shouldn't be a big surprise, since anti-circ folks claim that this process desensitizes the penis.

Warning: the following material is definitely TMI. Read at your own discretion.

[NSFW]As for masturbation techniques, they vary significantly between individuals, and often a single individual uses a variety of techniques. Some claim to use lotion or baby oil; I go dry, myself, and find the natural lube from the opening to be sufficient for the entire task. Some stroke the entire length, some focus on the glans. From what I understand, a few are happy stimulating the base of the penis alone. I don't know if any studies have ever been done on how rapidly circ'd men reach orgasm, but I've experience firsthand both surprisingly rapid orgasms and tortorously long periods of masturbation without orgasm. I've even on a few rare occasions been able to masturbate fully clothed, just by shaking a leg enough times, for my clothes to do the job for me. My preferred methods, though, I'll keep to myself - let's just say that some of us truly get into the process in very in-depth ways.

I can in no way speak for those who use oil or other lubes, toys and gizmos, rubber products, etc.[/NSFW]
 
Even this report which you sited doesn't recommend routine infant circumcision. I fail to see how that makes circumcision medically neutral. How is it medically neutral?


I'm sorry, but your "experience" is anecdotal. I've been told many times that I can't use myself as a reference, so you can't either. Is it possible that you've been conditioned by society to think that a cut penis is normal-looking? It's probably irrelevant to you, but I think people in countries where being intact is normal would say that a cut penis is just as ugly as you think an un-cut one is.

Also, I would like some information on these issues that circumcised boys avoid.

I'm curious as to why you would poo-poo bodily integrity. I'm not going to bring up any false analogies, but does this only apply to foreskin, or can it apply to other body parts, too?

Sure, my experience is anecdotal. But that is my experience, and like anything, my personal experience is my number one deciding factor. The same goes for the effects of artificial food dyes (the FD&C ones), the effects of certain colors in the environment, etc.

My anecdotal experience, from being a father to five cut boys and stepfather to two uncut boys, is that uncut boys have considerable hygiene issues, suffer from numerous infections, and generally stink from said areas more. Uncut boys seem to take a lot longer to potty-train, and suffer far more accidents after training. But, again, this is all from personal, anecdotal experience, so clearly it means nothing.

As for bodily integrity, pheh again, I say. Why? It's just how I am. The body is a vessel, and I'm not meaning in any spiritual sense, but the body is the machine used by the mind to interact with the world. Some parts of that body are irrelevant to the successful interaction of brain with world. And if society declares that an otherwise useless bit of body is more attractive gone than present, then I've no personal gripe with it. I have no problem having babies' ears pierced, having circumcisions done, removing warts or moles from babies, babies undergoing cosmetic surgeries to correct deficiencies in appearance, etc. And in the future, I'm fully in support of genetic tampering to make babies into ideal-appearing beings, whatever that means.

But I'm not for tampering where the missing piece would serve a vital purpose. And having lived for 35 years now, without a foreskin, and having fathered six children, and having had successful sexual relationships with several wonderful women and one rather hot young man, I see no vital purpose served by that missing bit of material - that bit of material that stinks so badly on my stepsons, that bit of material that is often, VERY often, sore and red and infected. Again, just anecdotal experience, and utterly dismissable. But it's my personal experience, and if it's good enough for me it's darn well good enough for my sons.

And yes, I'm projecting my will above and in spite of any will the child potentially has or had. I have no shame of that - that's what parents have always done, and that's what parents should always do. When he's an adult, he can make all those decisions for himself; but until then, those decisions are mine - no matter how irreversible those decisions are.

Does that make me a monster? Probably. Do I care? Not really. My children love me. My women love me. The professionals I have to interact with when dealing with the children's many, many problems and issues admire and respect me. Sorry, but I think I'll stick to what I'm doing, since those whose opinions matter think I'm doing the right thing.

All that being said, I fully respect every other parents' rights to choose whether or not to preserve their children's bodily integrities (not sure if the apostrophe use there was accurate), but I refuse to respect any agency trying to come between a parent and their right to choose for their child.
 
For some reason, removing healthy tissue from a baby just seems to get some people upset. I wonder if the people supporting cutting on little babies have ever actually observed what happens.

Been there for every single circumcision. For the most part, the babies acted like they didn't feel a thing - no crying, no startlement, nothing. I saw no blood in most of them (one, I remember, bled a little), and the babies showed no discomfort from the procedure, either during the actual process, or in the following days as the remaining foreskin died off.

So, again, I see no basis, in personal experience, to think that babies suffer horribly from circumcision. Again, it's just anecdotal and utterly dismissable, but that's been my experience, and that's what I'll go off of.
 
I love it when somebody makes such an obviously false claim. This link takes you to what a real circumcision looks and sounds like. NSFW

http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...723&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=0

Listen to what an infant actually sounds like while being mutilated, then try and convince a skeptic that circumcision is a kind and gentle procedure.

WARNING! Viewing the video may be traumatic, and unless you are a sociopath, it may cause you harm just watching it. It is a real medical video of an actual circumcision.

For anyone who wants to keep insisting on how harmless it is, notice the point where the baby really starts screaming, then goes into shock. The restraint table isn't easy to see, but hell, one showing is worth a thousand tellings.
 
Last edited:
Personally, watching the video brought up the same feelings in me I get when I see the death camps. How can anyone be so inhuman? I got physically ill hearing the frantic cries of pain, how the helpless infant, tied hand and foot, screams so hard it can't breath.

I'm sure the people claiming their kids didn't suffer, are either liars, or deluded, or mentally sick. I've heard it a thousand times, from parents guilty of child abuse. They really don't seem to be able to empathize with another human being. They can shrug off or ignore cries of fear and pain, like it really means nothing to them.

I can't understand it. But I really despise people who torture and maim children.. So forgive me oh Mods, if I overstepped the boundaries of civility here.


Doctors talk about circumcision, telling the truth about it.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...723&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=3

Jewish Circumcision Video, NSFW
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...723&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=8

And yeah, there is screaming in that one too. It sounds like the infant goes into shock, because we don't hear anything after the screams. Of course, the kid is drunk has hell already, so who knows? Don't watch if you have any compassion for babies. It isn't pretty. At least the Jews use booze to block the pain. I give em credit for being practical. Who wants to hear the insane cries of a mutilated baby?

They also edited a shot of the baby from the beginning of the video onto the end, to make it look like the kid is just fine after it is "over".

But if you actually watch, you never see the babies face after the operation. Its friggin creepy as hell.

New information about the level of pain and lasting trauma, medical info NSFW because of the screams of babies
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...10&start=10&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=7

And for you sick sadistic bastards who enjoy watching a baby suffer, the extended version of the medical film NSFW
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...=72&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=3

For you woos, watch the videos, then try and defend circumcision. Good luck with that.
 
Last edited:
I think most people that are circumcized (males) don't really give a ****.... I don't think I'd do it to my kids..... But I bet the risk of having your weiner cut off, weighed with the benefit of circumsicion protecing you from HIV or cancer... you probably swing towards circumsicion.... but jesus there may be a cure for HIV or cancer by the time by future kid gets older... It will be alot longer before there is a cure for a mutilated weiner.
 
Robinson,

You and I both know the pro-circ. people will not watch the videos. It would be so much harder for them to discount the child's suffering if they did.

Anyone else noticed that when the self-proclaimed believers in cultural relativism want to change another culture's practices they call it 'education'. Must help them sleep at night.
 
Personally, watching the video brought up the same feelings in me I get when I see the death camps. How can anyone be so inhuman? I got physically ill hearing the frantic cries of pain, how the helpless infant, tied hand and foot, screams so hard it can't breath.

I'm sure the people claiming their kids didn't suffer, are either liars, or deluded, or mentally sick. I've heard it a thousand times, from parents guilty of child abuse. They really don't seem to be able to empathize with another human being. They can shrug off or ignore cries of fear and pain, like it really means nothing to them.

I can't understand it. But I really despise people who torture and maim children.. So forgive me oh Mods, if I overstepped the boundaries of civility here.


Doctors talk about circumcision, telling the truth about it.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...723&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=3

Jewish Circumcision Video, NSFW
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...723&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=8

And yeah, there is screaming in that one too. It sounds like the infant goes into shock, because we don't hear anything after the screams. Of course, the kid is drunk has hell already, so who knows? Don't watch if you have any compassion for babies. It isn't pretty. At least the Jews use booze to block the pain. I give em credit for being practical. Who wants to hear the insane cries of a mutilated baby?

They also edited a shot of the baby from the beginning of the video onto the end, to make it look like the kid is just fine after it is "over".

But if you actually watch, you never see the babies face after the operation. Its friggin creepy as hell.

New information about the level of pain and lasting trauma, medical info NSFW because of the screams of babies
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...10&start=10&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=7

And for you sick sadistic bastards who enjoy watching a baby suffer, the extended version of the medical film NSFW
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...=72&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=3

For you woos, watch the videos, then try and defend circumcision. Good luck with that.

Gee, a lot of cherry-picked videos of improperly done circumcisions using outdated techniques and no pain relief.

I'm sure we could find similar dentistry videos, or videos of vaccinations gone wrong, to support similar points...

I watched every one, and yes, those barbaric practices were horrible. But I also watched all of my children get circumcised, and it was NOTHING like these videos.

Really - do you guys ONLY get your info from anti-circ woo sites? :rolleyes:
 
I watched every one, and yes, those barbaric practices were horrible. But I also watched all of my children get circumcised, and it was NOTHING like these videos.

Yes, I bet your kids were laughing and smiling while being tied to a table and having their foreskin ripped from their glans:rolleyes:
 
For you woos, watch the videos, then try and defend circumcision. Good luck with that.


Listen, Robinson, I'm going to try to explain this but I'm not very hopeful that you'll see my point.

When my son was four months old, he had a medical emergency that required brain surgery. Watching the nurses (and then a doctor) try to start an IV was the hardest thing I've ever had to witness. My son screamed himself red for ten solid minutes alternating between fear, discomfort and actual pain. It took three nurses just to imobilize him. Lidocaine would have been useless as his biggest complaints were being held down and having the tournequet on his leg. More powerful sedatives required an IV to deliver them in the first place. His circumcision was mild in comparison: for one thing, it lasted less than one tenth the time (a little under a minute).

I did nothing to stop the doctor from starting the IV no matter how much my son screeched. Now, I assume that you would never say that my behavior in the hospital made me guilty of child abuse. You would never claim that a parent who approves of such a procedure is incapable of empathizing with another human being. And I assume that you would not believe based on my behavior in the hospital that I can shrug off or ignore cries of fear and pain, like it really means nothing to me.

The reason, of course, is that it was absolutely necessary for my son's welfare. He could not understand that at the time, he just knew he didn't like it. But it was my job to make sure that he got what was best for him, not just what he most enjoyed. Perhaps he will grow up to disdain all medical intervention for some reason or other, but right at that moment I did what I believed would help him most in the future.

Now, you have asked about circumcision, "How can anyone be so inhuman?"

For the sake of being sociable, assume for a moment that the following is true: circumcision was in my son's best interests. I know that you don't believe that and maybe you have good reason, but just assume it for one moment. If I thought that circumcision was in my son't best interests, it was no more inhuman to have him circumcised than it was to have that IV put in. If circumcision was necessary for my son's welfare, than the fact that he violently disliked it is would have almost no importance.

That is how I was able to proudly stand by and watch my son be circumcised. I believed that it was in his interests.

The only question, then, is if my belief is obviously and objectively wrong. If it isn't, the pain caused to my son cannot be a reason in itself not to do the procedure.

Now, I know that you think my belief is wrong but so far I have not seen evidence that convinces me. I hope that this helps you understand the mindset of people who circumcise their children.
 
Yes, I bet your kids were laughing and smiling while being tied to a table and having their foreskin ripped from their glans:rolleyes:


My son neither was tied to a table nor had his foreskin ripped from his glans.

For that matter, my son was not laughing and smiling when I took away a crayon he was trying to eat this morning.

His momentary happiness is almost meaningless compared to his overall well being.
 
His momentary happiness is almost meaningless compared to his overall well being.

What objective measure of 'well being' are you using?

For example, do you have any statistics to show that Jewish men growing up in 21st century America are likely to be at a significant disadvantage if they are intact?
 
What objective measure of 'well being' are you using?

For example, do you have any statistics to show that Jewish men growing up in 21st century America are likely to be at a significant disadvantage if they are intact?


A) We've been through this.

B) There is no such thing as an "objective" measure of well-being.
 
Listen, Robinson, I'm going to try to explain this but I'm not very hopeful that you'll see my point.

I think I got your point. And I agree with you, we all do things that cause our kids pain, to avoid greater sorrow, or future danger, or just the need for medical treatment. I did mention that I consider the Jews practical, as in, if you are going to cut part of my dick off, get me drunk first.

Now, I know that you think my belief is wrong but so far I have not seen evidence that convinces me. I hope that this helps you understand the mindset of people who circumcise their children.

Not only does it help, it also explains a lot of other actions people take, based on faith, that cause others to suffer. A friends father, a preacher man, used to whip his kids until they bled, based on his beliefs. He really believed that whipping a four year old boy, until he bled from the wounds, until he couldn't walk, he really believed it was for his kids own good.

Nobody ever changed his beliefs either. He only stopped doing it when the boy turned into a man at 12, and threatened to kill him if he ever touched him again.

This was long ago, and the preacher man is long dead, but I'm sure in parts of the world, even in America, some father is whipping a child bloody, confident that it is for the kids own good, and nobody will change his belief. Because God told him to do it.

I pretty much tolerate anybodies beliefs, but I don't tolerate actions that cause harm, for no other reason than a moldy old religion says "God told me to do it."

Call me intolerant.
 
There is no such thing as an "objective" measure of well-being.

That would be really convenient for you if it were true, but alas, it is not.

For example, do you think doctors assess the outcome of treatment totally subjectively? Sure there is a subjective component (e.g., "How do you feel..."), but these are often less important than the objective measurements.

For objective measures of well-being for uncircumcised vs circumcised Jewish men in the 21st century, you could look at income, number of friends, mental health, etc.

Show me evidence that an uncircumcised child/man is likely to be harmed more than a circumcised child/man for some objective measure and I'll reconsider my opinion of infant circumcision for cultural or religious reasons.
 
Last edited:
...This was long ago, and the preacher man is long dead, but I'm sure in parts of the world, even in America, some father is whipping a child bloody, confident that it is for the kids own good, and nobody will change his belief. Because God told him to do it.

Try this.
 
Yes, I bet your kids were laughing and smiling while being tied to a table and having their foreskin ripped from their glans:rolleyes:

Let's see:

1) They weren't tied to a table. A nurse assisted by keeping their arms still, and another person (I think another nurse) held their legs still - very gently, I might add.

2) Their nerve endings are not yet mature at this stage, so their sensations are not as severe as you seem to think they are.

3) They used a topical pain-relief cream which is extremely effective. They just used the same cream on my daughter last week when she had to have stitches, and they were able to sew her up with her awake, and she was quite pleased during the procedure. The stitches were just above an eye, in an area FULL of nerves, and she felt NOTHING. And she's 3 - fully able to tell us if it hurt.

4) The Plastibell Method does NOT involve 'ripping' foreskin. How many people have to explain this method to you? The earlier model, yes, required some cutting away of excess foreskin - but that's all done AFTER the cream is applied, AFTER the string is set to crush the foreskin (which, btw, also stops the nerves from feeling beyond the point of the crush), and does NOT cause pain. The more modern model doesn't even require this much cutting, I've been told. And the probe used to separate the foreskin from the glans itself doesn't apear to be painful either - I was amazed watching my sons' calm, serene and somewhat curious expressions as the probe was used. I, like so many of you, had this preconceived notion that circumcision was a horribly painful process but that children just forgot about it rapidly. I was wrong - it's not horribly painful at all. Not anymore.

And even when it was, the children DO forget about it rapidly.

So take your strawman and apply it somewhere else. Thanks.
 
That is how I was able to proudly stand by and watch my son be circumcised. I believed that it was in his interests.

Oh? And what did your son say about it when you consulted him?

The only question, then, is if my belief is obviously and objectively wrong. If it isn't, the pain caused to my son cannot be a reason in itself not to do the procedure.

And if it is..?
 
"then try and convince a skeptic that circumcision is a kind and gentle procedure"
You can't convince them... They have their fingers jammed into their ears so that they never have to deal with the fact that they are ignorant barbarians....
 
Let's see:

1) They weren't tied to a table. A nurse assisted by keeping their arms still, and another person (I think another nurse) held their legs still - very gently, I might add.

The child was forcefully restrained.

2) Their nerve endings are not yet mature at this stage, so their sensations are not as severe as you seem to think they are.

You are either lying or incredibly ignorant.

3) They used a topical pain-relief cream which is extremely effective. They just used the same cream on my daughter last week when she had to have stitches, and they were able to sew her up with her awake, and she was quite pleased during the procedure. The stitches were just above an eye, in an area FULL of nerves, and she felt NOTHING. And she's 3 - fully able to tell us if it hurt.

Emla is not that effective for circumcision pain. Most doctors who care about the pain the procedure causes use a ring block.

4) The Plastibell Method does NOT involve 'ripping' foreskin. How many people have to explain this method to you? The earlier model, yes, required some cutting away of excess foreskin - but that's all done AFTER the cream is applied, AFTER the string is set to crush the foreskin (which, btw, also stops the nerves from feeling beyond the point of the crush), and does NOT cause pain. The more modern model doesn't even require this much cutting, I've been told. And the probe used to separate the foreskin from the glans itself doesn't apear to be painful either - I was amazed watching my sons' calm, serene and somewhat curious expressions as the probe was used. I, like so many of you, had this preconceived notion that circumcision was a horribly painful process but that children just forgot about it rapidly. I was wrong - it's not horribly painful at all. Not anymore.

The foreskin is attached to the glans. It has to be ripped off. BTW, what about post-operative pain? Or does that not exist in your world view?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom