Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Amusing.

Sure, sure. There, there, there.

:rolleyes: Stop being so damn insipid. Criticizing an aspect of a religion has nothing to do with racial hatred.

and where a clean cut penis is far more attractive than a hooded bestial worm-thing
...
the anti-circ crowd is given to being over-emotional, overly attached to unimportant bits of useless anatomy,
:newlol :newlol

Want some wax for your shiny Hypocrisy Award?

and obsessive to the point of fanaticism that somehow removal of a bit of foreskin does irreparable damage, somehow.
Ah, but it does.

By the way, for emotional reactions, I suggest you look in your camp, where disagreement with an ancient tribal ritual is implied to be racist...
 
...I see potentially serious benefits to it (50% reduction in HIV transmission is enough to make it mandatory, IMO)...

And hasn't that worked out well for the US, a country with one of the highest incidences of HIV in the developed world.

When methodology was discussed, many emotive arguments were attempted - detailing babies crying out in pain, blood and gore, etc. Yet when the plastibell method was discussed, which combined with a topical pain-killing ointment causes no pain and extremely minimal blood loss, the anti-circ crowd switched topics. They brought up potential complications, but again - the plastibell method reduces the chance of complications to near-zero levels. And again, the A-C crowd switched topics.

Absolute nonsense.

ETA: http://www.nature.com/jp/journal/v22/n3/abs/7210653a.html

ETA2: Another ironic thing is that to train to be a doctor you often have to be interviewed and tested. Usually you are asked if you have had any experience in a medical setting such as a hospital, hospice or nursing home. This, along with aptitude and psychometric testing, is used to see if you're the right kind of person to become a doctor. One of the things the psychometric testing is looking for is the applicant's ability to empathize.

How, exactly, is a doctor performing an unrequired circumcision empathizing with their patient?
 
Last edited:
And hasn't that worked out well for the US, a country with one of the highest incidences of HIV in the developed world.

Which is ironic (or alanic, not sure which), considering that several of you anti-circs were willing to accept circumcision for countries with high incidences of HIV.

Interesting, though, how the spread of HIV is inversly proportional to the incidence of circumcisions... Meaning, as less people get circ'd, more people get HIV.

Absolute nonsense.

Got some facts to go with that rebuttal? :D

ETA2: Another ironic thing is that to train to be a doctor you often have to be interviewed and tested. Usually you are asked if you have had any experience in a medical setting such as a hospital, hospice or nursing home. This, along with aptitude and psychometric testing, is used to see if you're the right kind of person to become a doctor. One of the things the psychometric testing is looking for is the applicant's ability to empathize.

How, exactly, is a doctor performing an unrequired circumcision empathizing with their patient?

Hmmm... a painless, harmless, quick and simple procedure that has no significant long-term side effects and numerous social, aesthetic, and health benefits... and with a 40% or greater chance that the doctor is also circumcised... I can see clearly that they can both empathize AND sympathize.

But if you think that this 'testing' is foolproof, you really are naive. All psychometric testing tends to show is that you've studied the expected responses. They've started pulling the same thing at our local airport for the food-service management, and once one manager passed the test, they all started to pass - because they were all spending extra evenings studying the 'desired' responses.

At least, that's here in the U.S., where the Hippocratic Oath means jack diddly squat and doctors HAVE to charge a thousand bucks to pull out a splinter (to cover their insurance rates).

But, I still stand by my statements. Firsthand experience tells me that there's nothing bad about proper modern circumcision, while uncircumcised children have a number of issues that circumcised children do NOT have. And for me, that's good enough. Bodily integrity? Pheh.
 
Which is ironic (or alanic, not sure which), considering that several of you anti-circs were willing to accept circumcision for countries with high incidences of HIV.

The environment and behaviours that drive the spread of HIV in Africa are different to those in the US.

Got some facts to go with that rebuttal? :D

Yes. Here's a report of a study that was linked earlier in the thread:

http://www.pslgroup.com/dg/1f21e.htm

"What we discovered was that the infants who were uncircumcised demonstrated the least pain during vaccination," Dr. Koren explains. "The infants who were circumcised showed substantially more pain."

So it appears children do experience "real" pain during circumcision and the psychological effects last months.

But if you think that this 'testing' is foolproof, you really are naive. All psychometric testing tends to show is that you've studied the expected responses. They've started pulling the same thing at our local airport for the food-service management, and once one manager passed the test, they all started to pass - because they were all spending extra evenings studying the 'desired' responses.

At least, that's here in the U.S., where the Hippocratic Oath means jack diddly squat and doctors HAVE to charge a thousand bucks to pull out a splinter (to cover their insurance rates).

I definitely don't think psychometric testing is foolproof;)

But, I still stand by my statements. Firsthand experience tells me that there's nothing bad about proper modern circumcision, while uncircumcised children have a number of issues that circumcised children do NOT have. And for me, that's good enough. Bodily integrity? Pheh.

Yes, you've already made your views on body integrity well known. They are definitely in the minority, even among pro-circ. people!
 
Z,
What evidence do you have supporting your assertion that the plastibell method is painless?
 
Yeah, I've never been one to follow the crowds.

Probably why I've never seen a single episode of 'American Idol'.
 
Criticizing an aspect of a religion has nothing to do with racial hatred.


I agree with you completely. In what way is it "criticizing an aspect of a religion" to point out that one of the authors of a peer-reviewed study is affiliated with a hospital with the word "Jewish" in its name?
 
Yes. Here's a report of a study that was linked earlier in the thread:

http://www.pslgroup.com/dg/1f21e.htm

Quote:
"What we discovered was that the infants who were uncircumcised demonstrated the least pain during vaccination," Dr. Koren explains. "The infants who were circumcised showed substantially more pain."

So it appears children do experience "real" pain during circumcision and the psychological effects last months.

Hmm.
http://www.pslgroup.com/dg/1f21e.htm
Quote:
The study involved 87 male infants in three groups: 32 uncircumcised infants; 29 infants receiving a topical anaesthetic prior to circumcision; and 26 who were circumcised without pain relief. The infants were recruited to the study through Women's College Hospital. Between ages four and six months, the infants received routine diptheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) vaccinations from their primary care physician and their pain response to the vaccination was measured.

"What we discovered was that the infants who were uncircumcised demonstrated the least pain during vaccination," Dr. Koren explains. "The infants who were circumcised showed substantially more pain."


And directly from the study paper itself:
http://www.cirp.org/library/pain/taddio2/
Quote:
Interpretation Circumcised infants showed a stronger pain response to subsequent routine vaccination than uncircumcised infants. Among the circumcised group, preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination. We recommend treatment to prevent neonatal circumcision pain.

The bolded above is S.O.P. in U.S. hospitals. Not sure if the same is the case in Canada where the authors are from...
 
Hmm.
http://www.pslgroup.com/dg/1f21e.htm
Quote:
The study involved 87 male infants in three groups: 32 uncircumcised infants; 29 infants receiving a topical anaesthetic prior to circumcision; and 26 who were circumcised without pain relief. The infants were recruited to the study through Women's College Hospital. Between ages four and six months, the infants received routine diptheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) vaccinations from their primary care physician and their pain response to the vaccination was measured.

"What we discovered was that the infants who were uncircumcised demonstrated the least pain during vaccination," Dr. Koren explains. "The infants who were circumcised showed substantially more pain."


And directly from the study paper itself:
http://www.cirp.org/library/pain/taddio2/
Quote:
Interpretation Circumcised infants showed a stronger pain response to subsequent routine vaccination than uncircumcised infants. Among the circumcised group, preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination. We recommend treatment to prevent neonatal circumcision pain.

The bolded above is S.O.P. in U.S. hospitals. Not sure if the same is the case in Canada where the authors are from...

The report indicates being circumcised even when Emla was being used, caused an increased pain response to vaccinations compared to the uncircumcised group.

Also, don't be so sure about the number of physicians either using Emla (or better alternative anesthesia), or using it in a way that provides significant pain relief.

BTW, the most effective anesthesia for circumcision is provided by a subcutaneous ring block.
 
I agree with you completely. In what way is it "criticizing an aspect of a religion" to point out that one of the authors of a peer-reviewed study is affiliated with a hospital with the word "Jewish" in its name?

Numpty! I was simply pointing out a potential source of bias. Next question.
 
Numpty! I was simply pointing out a potential source of bias. Next question.


Tremendous. Why would the fact of one of the doctors' affiliation with a hospital with "Jewish" in the name be a potential source of bias?
 
I think this debate is pretty simple. The pro-circ crowd TRULY believes that the sensory loss is small to the point of being something not to be worried about. Considering how hard it is to gauge this kind of thing and the willingness of people to lie to themselves this is something that will just have to get changed over time. I sure hope we aren't doing this to children in 100 years (I surely don't care if adults want to do it to themselves).

I'm also a little curious about the masturbatory habits of those that are circ'd. Those of us that are uncut use the foreskin as a bearing, as was pointed out above, and this makes it a really nice way to masturbate. Do those circ'd people truly not use the glans? I would also be curious how difficult it is for them to reach orgasm in comparison, anyone have a study?

I've already read some stuff about the orgasm trigger using some nerves in the foreskin. Are circ'd people more prone to premature ejaculation or anything like that? I'm getting the feeling there haven't been too many studies about this kind of stuff...
 
What's that saying in the USA ' If it ain't broke don't fix it ' . If you wish to prevent Aids try using a condom .
Years ago there was push by doctors to force the removal of tonsils regardless of any illness . Nowadays we are told they help prevent certain illness . Maybe this 'useless' piece of skin has some purpose .I don't know . Why take the risk of an operation unless it's necessary ?
As for Female mutilation this should carry a Jail sentence for everyone involved except the victim of course .
 
That consensus does exist for circumcision in the U.S. and while it is not a ringing endorsement of the procedure it is medically neutral.
http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;103/3/686
Even this report which you sited doesn't recommend routine infant circumcision. I fail to see how that makes circumcision medically neutral. How is it medically neutral?

But, I still stand by my statements. Firsthand experience tells me that there's nothing bad about proper modern circumcision, while uncircumcised children have a number of issues that circumcised children do NOT have. And for me, that's good enough. Bodily integrity? Pheh.
I'm sorry, but your "experience" is anecdotal. I've been told many times that I can't use myself as a reference, so you can't either. Is it possible that you've been conditioned by society to think that a cut penis is normal-looking? It's probably irrelevant to you, but I think people in countries where being intact is normal would say that a cut penis is just as ugly as you think an un-cut one is.

Also, I would like some information on these issues that circumcised boys avoid.

I'm curious as to why you would poo-poo bodily integrity. I'm not going to bring up any false analogies, but does this only apply to foreskin, or can it apply to other body parts, too?
 
Last edited:
IF and only if it was the least severe version of that practice which involves trimming the clitoral hood and not touching the clitoris at all, was performed by medical personnel in a safe and sterile manner, and was performed with at least emala. The problem people have with FGM is that it is often not the least severe version, is performed by some old lady in a mud hut with a piece of jagged glass, and is done not to beautify but to stunt sexual freedom.
No the problem is that an adult shouldn't be carving away at a baby girl or boy's genitals unless it is medically necessary. Especially for the detestable reason that the adults "prefer the look" of the carved genitals. Perverse in both cases.

And I've stated about 40 times in this post already what my feeling on human rights are regards to body integrity.
Again:
So long as a procedure is medically and socially neutral or beneficial then it's ok. If it is detrimental then it is not.

This means that male circumcision, tattoos, ritual scarring, and piercings are all largely ok in my book if they are the social norm of the parents' culture. Other forms are not alright (particularly when they are used for gender based rights suppression).
First: Medically neutral. Let me guess... to show medical neutrality, you would merely need to find some information on a pro-circ fetish site supporting your claim. You could then proceed to ignore all contradicting information, no matter how sound.

Second: Nice to see that you're consistent. Really, there is little difference between male and female circumcision; at the roots these customs are all about control and suppression of the individual. I have to wonder why you're drawing this arbitrary line about which types of genital body modification parents should be able to choose. It seems you're imposing your own ideas on cultures who believe that full FGM is necessary to the well-being of the child.

Removing is not. Trimming might be, depending on how it's done, where it's done, how much of it is done, etc. Would have to see some sort of medical consensus that it is being done in a safe manner and that it is not detrimental. And it would have to provide some degree of social benefit.
As we've seen, you'll ignore a mountain of evidence showing the harm to the individual. There is no medical consensus that circumcision is not detrimental; the research shows the opposite. In fact you posted several references showing the loss of foreskin to be detrimental to both the man and woman. Why do you think it is that you're so completely immune to the research showing that the foreskin is both functional and important?

But seriously, that's what it boils down to for me - I see no harm in circumcision (or the exact female equivalent)
The harm caused by circumcision has been explained many, many times. It has not been refuted, simply ignored by the pro-circs.

I do live in the U.S.A., where it's been common most of my life, and where a clean cut penis is far more attractive than a hooded bestial worm-thing.
Oh really? Not more attractive according to the information posted a few pages back.

And I AM glad that you anti-circ wooists don't make policy in the U.S., because what I can clearly see, especially in this thread, is that the anti-circ crowd is given to being over-emotional, overly attached to unimportant bits of useless anatomy, and obsessive to the point of fanaticism that somehow removal of a bit of foreskin does irreparable damage, somehow.

No, not somehow. This has been completely explained, yet you and the other pro-circs seem to see this as penis-challenging and instantly develop a terminal case of cog-dis every time it's discussed. If any wooism is going on here, it's the consistent inability for the pro-circs to even entertain the notion that the foreskin might have some meaningful value. And I love you how resent us opposing medically unnecessary circumcision, yet simultaneously declare that it should be mandatory if HIV protection >50%.

There was even a very emotional appeal related to the removal of earlobes and other unnecessary body parts. Which failed, because the pro-circ crowd has no particular interest in bodily integrity over societal norm where drawbacks are as minimal as they are in circumcision.
Surprise! Still avoiding the issue of the harm caused by loss of the foreskin.
Z said:
Hmmm... a painless, harmless, quick and simple procedure that has no significant long-term side effects and numerous social, aesthetic, and health benefits...
Exactly how many times do you think you have to repeat this, without refuting the studies that show it to be wrong, before it stops being wrong?
 
What's that saying in the USA ' If it ain't broke don't fix it ' . If you wish to prevent Aids try using a condom .
Years ago there was push by doctors to force the removal of tonsils regardless of any illness . Nowadays we are told they help prevent certain illness . Maybe this 'useless' piece of skin has some purpose .I don't know . Why take the risk of an operation unless it's necessary ?
As for Female mutilation this should carry a Jail sentence for everyone involved except the victim of course .

Looking at the guidelines that the BMA gives to doctors with respect to non-therapeutic child circumcision it's to do with "cultural benefits". I don't know about you, but I did not realize British culture required males to be circumcised to be accepted into it:confused:

The other excuse offered is that determined parents will have their child circumcised anyway, so it's better it's done in a hospital by a trained doctor than somewhere else less hygienic and by someone potentially unskilled in the procedure. Which is basically saying given that the child is going to be physically assaulted anyway, it's better that it be done in a place where he has less chance of dying and by a doctor! I don't know about anybody else but that argument sends a shiver down my spine.

At least they admit that these excuses are used for FGM too.

Human rights are not going to be accepted unless the countries pushing for them to be adopted around the world sort out abuses by their own citizens (and medical professions!) on each other first.
 
For some reason, removing healthy tissue from a baby just seems to get some people upset. I wonder if the people supporting cutting on little babies have ever actually observed what happens.
 
For some reason, removing healthy tissue from a baby just seems to get some people upset. I wonder if the people supporting cutting on little babies have ever actually observed what happens.


I stood right over my son during his bris. I observed the entire thing.

I'm not sure what your point is, but there's your answer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom