Osmosis, after being warned numerous times, you once again appear happily to wade into antisemitism.
First off, your thinly-veiled threat about me "being warned numerous times" is like when I pet my cat and she drools on my pants.. cute, but in a distateful sort of way.
Second, I will not allow you to insinuate that I am racist. Full stop. I am against religion, not Jews in particular. Your attempts to turn this into a racial issue to paint me as a racist are pathetic, and merely underscore your desperation and lack of credible argument on this topic.
I will describe what you have implied and I will offer you a chance to retract or clarify your meaning.
How benevolent of you LL! <worship>
Your purpose was to imply that doctors at a "Jewish" hospital have a reason to skew their research to support circumcision.
Maybe they do, maybe they don't. Do not presume to dictate to me what my "purpose" is or was.
Otherwise, what was the point of bolding the fact that the name of one of the hospitals had the word "Jewish" in it?
Maybe it's significant, maybe not. I merely pointed it out. I leave it up to the reader to draw his/her own conclusions.
You have allowed your hatred for Jews to overcome your reason.
Wouldn't you like to think so! Wouldn't it be great for you if everything boiled down to beliefs and inclinations. Wouldn't it be great for you if there was no such thing as objectivity, ethics or human rights. Wouldn't it be great for you if your religious beliefs vs. rational arguments really did end in stalemate. Wouldn't it be great for you if everyone who said anything you take offense to was not only wrong, but racist!
(ETA: and wouldn't every circumcised man and proponent of circumcision like to think they've been robbed of nothing, and are robbing their children of nothing! And wouldn't they also like to think there was an ethical difference between circumcision and FGM.. I could go on and on.. )
I have not a shred of hatred for Jews or Hebrews, although it's hardly surprising to me that there are those who prefer to throw up the "antisemitic strawman" when the discussion turns towards their beloved ritual mutilation. Disappointing, perhaps, but not surprising.
I will fully admit that one of these names sounds very Jewish.
What's the name got to do with anything? Judaism's a religion, not a race. I think you're just trying to blur this distinction so you can play the antisemite card, and quite frankly I believe you are being disingenuous.
J'accuse!
(Incidentally, calling you disingenuous is, in my mind, the greatest personal insult leveled at you in this thread so far.)
So, did a "Jewish" hospital commission a study to help shore up the case for circumcision as you would like us to infer?
I don't know, did it? Stranger things have happened! I do know one thing though, that study was either biased as heck, or performed by incompetents. That part is obvious, with or without Jewish affiliation.
If the Catholic church sponsored a study which reached the conclusion that birth control causes cancer, don't you think it would be wise to take those conclusions with a grain of salt?
It's part of McGill University, genius. The name "Jewish" is no more important than the name Presbyterian is in Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center (which is now part of NYU).
The Jewish General Hospital also has a kosher cafeteria, so the name "Jewish" in the hospital is not -completely- without significance either.
That's funny, none of the hospitals I've ever been to had a kosher cafeteria. Surely it's merely coincidence, right? Surely merely pointing it out is a sign of racial hatred, right?
Being a tolerant person, I will be glad to accept your apology.
LOL! I don't think you're nearly as tolerant as you think you are. And don't hold your breath on that apology.