Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

McGill University is actually famous for having most wealthy anglophone students, a lot of which are Jews, though. ;) (I also happen to be from Montreal.)
The Jewish General Hospital also has a kosher cafeteria, so the name "Jewish" in the hospital is not -completely- without significance either. Another anecdotal coincidence (?): my last job was a project which was funded by the Jewish Hospital, so we were technically employed by the hospital (they signed all our paychecks), and the sweet lady responsible for the human resources, basically our link to the hospital, was... you guessed it, Jewish. :)

I'm not saying this means the study is inherently skewed because of that, but because he implied potential bias doesn't mean he's an evil bigotted racist, so you can step off the soapbox now.
 
Osmosis, after being warned numerous times, you once again appear happily to wade into antisemitism.

First off, your thinly-veiled threat about me "being warned numerous times" is like when I pet my cat and she drools on my pants.. cute, but in a distateful sort of way.

Second, I will not allow you to insinuate that I am racist. Full stop. I am against religion, not Jews in particular. Your attempts to turn this into a racial issue to paint me as a racist are pathetic, and merely underscore your desperation and lack of credible argument on this topic.

I will describe what you have implied and I will offer you a chance to retract or clarify your meaning.

How benevolent of you LL! <worship>

Your purpose was to imply that doctors at a "Jewish" hospital have a reason to skew their research to support circumcision.

Maybe they do, maybe they don't. Do not presume to dictate to me what my "purpose" is or was.

Otherwise, what was the point of bolding the fact that the name of one of the hospitals had the word "Jewish" in it?

Maybe it's significant, maybe not. I merely pointed it out. I leave it up to the reader to draw his/her own conclusions.

You have allowed your hatred for Jews to overcome your reason.

Wouldn't you like to think so! Wouldn't it be great for you if everything boiled down to beliefs and inclinations. Wouldn't it be great for you if there was no such thing as objectivity, ethics or human rights. Wouldn't it be great for you if your religious beliefs vs. rational arguments really did end in stalemate. Wouldn't it be great for you if everyone who said anything you take offense to was not only wrong, but racist! (ETA: and wouldn't every circumcised man and proponent of circumcision like to think they've been robbed of nothing, and are robbing their children of nothing! And wouldn't they also like to think there was an ethical difference between circumcision and FGM.. I could go on and on.. )

I have not a shred of hatred for Jews or Hebrews, although it's hardly surprising to me that there are those who prefer to throw up the "antisemitic strawman" when the discussion turns towards their beloved ritual mutilation. Disappointing, perhaps, but not surprising.

I will fully admit that one of these names sounds very Jewish.

What's the name got to do with anything? Judaism's a religion, not a race. I think you're just trying to blur this distinction so you can play the antisemite card, and quite frankly I believe you are being disingenuous. J'accuse!

(Incidentally, calling you disingenuous is, in my mind, the greatest personal insult leveled at you in this thread so far.)

So, did a "Jewish" hospital commission a study to help shore up the case for circumcision as you would like us to infer?

I don't know, did it? Stranger things have happened! I do know one thing though, that study was either biased as heck, or performed by incompetents. That part is obvious, with or without Jewish affiliation.

If the Catholic church sponsored a study which reached the conclusion that birth control causes cancer, don't you think it would be wise to take those conclusions with a grain of salt?

It's part of McGill University, genius. The name "Jewish" is no more important than the name Presbyterian is in Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center (which is now part of NYU).
The Jewish General Hospital also has a kosher cafeteria, so the name "Jewish" in the hospital is not -completely- without significance either.

That's funny, none of the hospitals I've ever been to had a kosher cafeteria. Surely it's merely coincidence, right? Surely merely pointing it out is a sign of racial hatred, right?

Being a tolerant person, I will be glad to accept your apology.

LOL! I don't think you're nearly as tolerant as you think you are. And don't hold your breath on that apology.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't aware most people even touch the glans during masturbation. Not because it is not sensitive, nor because it is too sensitive. But because the fingers wrap around the shaft of the penis and move up and down the shaft, rarely if ever getting that close to that end of the shaft. I suppose there are multiple techniques though... Maybe people with foreskins masturbate differently than people without...

Without going into too much detail, yes they do. The foreskin acts as a roller-bearing allowing indirect stimulation of the glans.

IF and only if it was the least severe version of that practice which involves trimming the clitoral hood and not touching the clitoris at all, was performed by medical personnel in a safe and sterile manner, and was performed with at least emala.

So what human rights (if any) do you believe infants have with respect to their body integrity?

What you fail to understand is that amputation equals physical harm. It really is that simple and doesn't matter how hi-tech the procedure is. The only ethical reasons to perform an amputation on an infant is if leaving the body part attached is likely to cause more harm than if it was removed, or obvious deformities.

The problem people have with FGM is that it is often not the least severe version, is performed by some old lady in a mud hut with a piece of jagged glass, and is done not to beautify but to stunt sexual freedom.

As SYL has already said, what makes you think male circumcision is performed under better conditions than female circumcision? Male circumcision can be very brutal.
 
Last edited:
Without going into too much detail, yes they do. The foreskin acts as a roller-bearing allowing indirect stimulation of the glans.

So what human rights (if any) do you believe infants have with respect to their body integrity?

What you fail to understand is that amputation equals physical harm. It really is that simple and doesn't matter how hi-tech the procedure is. The only ethical reasons to perform an amputation on an infant is if leaving the body part attached is likely to cause more harm than if it was removed, or obvious deformities.

As SYL has already said, what makes you think male circumcision is performed under better conditions than female circumcision? Male circumcision can be very brutal.

No more wire hangers!
Um circumcision is performed (in the countries that do it most) in hospitals with proper instruments and pain killers. That's because it's a legal, medical procedure. There's no need for back alley circumcisions in industrialized countries.

And I've stated about 40 times in this post already what my feeling on human rights are regards to body integrity.
Again:
So long as a procedure is medically and socially neutral or beneficial then it's ok. If it is detrimental then it is not.

This means that male circumcision, tattoos, ritual scarring, and piercings are all largely ok in my book if they are the social norm of the parents' culture. Other forms are not alright (particularly when they are used for gender based rights suppression).

I wouldn't choose any of those besides circumcision for myself or for my children, but that is because I live in the U.S.A. I'm not going to exhibit the hubris to universally condemn someone else's differing culture though without learning more about it. If something I find personally abhorrent means the child grows up happier and more socially functional amongst their people then I don't feel I have a lot of right to judge them or their parents.

On a side note have you not ever seen an episode of Taboo?
http://www9.nationalgeographic.com/channel/taboo/
 
Um circumcision is performed (in the countries that do it most) in hospitals with proper instruments and pain killers. That's because it's a legal, medical procedure. There's no need for back alley circumcisions in industrialized countries.

Yes, it’s given a veneer of respectability by doctors in the US. Gotta keep those dollars rolling in…

And I've stated about 40 times in this post already what my feeling on human rights are regards to body integrity.
Again:
So long as a procedure is medically and socially neutral or beneficial then it's ok. If it is detrimental then it is not.

This means that male circumcision, tattoos, ritual scarring, and piercings are all largely ok in my book if they are the social norm of the parents' culture. Other forms are not alright (particularly when they are used for gender based rights suppression).

Who do you think you are dictating that a particular culture should not give its men more rights than its women? Just because you find it abhorrent that in a particular culture the men dominate women doesn’t make it wrong.

I wouldn't choose any of those besides circumcision for myself or for my children, but that is because I live in the U.S.A. I'm not going to exhibit the hubris to universally condemn someone else's differing culture though without learning more about it. If something I find personally abhorrent means the child grows up happier and more socially functional amongst their people then I don't feel I have a lot of right to judge them or their parents.

What you have written above is an argument for allowing cultures to continue practicing FGM!

On a side note have you not ever seen an episode of Taboo?
http://www9.nationalgeographic.com/channel/taboo/

I’ve watched similar programs on UK TV.

BlackKat (and any others who agree with him), you can’t have it both ways. Either you believe in cultural relativism or you believe human rights should be universal and independent of culture. I.e. you believe any cultures that disagree with you should be coerced into complying with your will.

For example, if you object that some cultures suppress their females and think it is right for the West to coerce them to stop doing it, then you do not believe in cultural relativism.
 
"I wasn't aware most people even touch the glans during masturbation."
You've exhibited a staggering lack of awareness when it comes to "Most People" all through this thread... why should this be any different? What you don't know could fill volumes!

"Your attempts to turn this into a racial issue to paint me as a racist are pathetic, and merely underscore your desperation and lack of credible argument on this topic."
+10! Don't be surprised if he adds you to his ignore list soon... cause that's his next step.
 
...
Who do you think you are dictating that a particular culture should not give its men more rights than its women? Just because you find it abhorrent that in a particular culture the men dominate women doesn’t make it wrong.
Hope you're being facetious.

BlackKat (and any others who agree with him), you can’t have it both ways. Either you believe in cultural relativism or you believe human rights should be universal and independent of culture. I.e. you believe any cultures that disagree with you should be coerced into complying with your will.

For example, if you object that some cultures suppress their females and think it is right for the West to coerce them to stop doing it, then you do not believe in cultural relativism.

I believe in relative cultural relativism. If it does not do more harm then good then it's ok no matter how odd or wrong I find it. If it does more harm then good it's not ok no matter how right they find it. Determining this takes a lot of thought and study and it means knee jerk reactions are never warranted.

Qualifiers are used every day in law and courts worldwide (killing in self-defense, eminent domain, freedom of speech, etc). Why you feel I can't use them is boggling. Do you approach all issues as black or white?
 
Last edited:
Hope you're being facetious.

Yes.

I believe in relative cultural relativism. If it does not do more harm then good then it's ok no matter how odd or wrong I find it. If it does more harm then good it's not ok no matter how right they find it. Determining this takes a lot of thought and study and it means knee jerk reactions are never warranted.

LOL! You're accusing me of a 'knee-jerk reaction'!

I'm not the one who had a child circumcised as soon as possible when there was no urgency to perform it at all!

Qualifiers are used every day in law and courts worldwide (killing in self-defense, eminent domain, freedom of speech, etc). Why you feel I can't use them is boggling.

Hmm. I wonder how the "I modified my normal, healthy child's genitals so they look nice to me." defence would sound to most reasonable people?

Do you approach all issues as black or white?

Only when it becomes apparent that what is being done to a child's body is stressful, painful, permanent and medically pointless. Then I don't care about your "culture" or any other excuse you offer to justify your brutal behaviour.
 
IF and only if it was the least severe version of that practice which involves trimming the clitoral hood and not touching the clitoris at all, was performed by medical personnel in a safe and sterile manner, and was performed with at least emala.
To be consistent, I suppose your answer would have to be that. You're not advocating for hood removal, but why would that procedure be ok?

So long as a procedure is medically and socially neutral or beneficial then it's ok. If it is detrimental then it is not.
So, to you, if a procedure is medically neutral, it's ok. That's why you might argue that removing the clitoral hood is ok. How can you be sure that these two procedures are medically neutral?
 
To be consistent, I suppose your answer would have to be that. You're not advocating for hood removal, but why would that procedure be ok?


So, to you, if a procedure is medically neutral, it's ok. That's why you might argue that removing the clitoral hood is ok. How can you be sure that these two procedures are medically neutral?

Removing is not. Trimming might be, depending on how it's done, where it's done, how much of it is done, etc. Would have to see some sort of medical consensus that it is being done in a safe manner and that it is not detrimental. And it would have to provide some degree of social benefit.

That consensus does exist for circumcision in the U.S. and while it is not a ringing endorsement of the procedure it is medically neutral.
http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;103/3/686
And from the link:
Parents and physicians each have an ethical duty to the child to attempt to secure the child's best interest and well-being.119 However, it is often uncertain as to what is in the best interest of any individual patient. In cases such as the decision to perform a circumcision in the neonatal period when there are potential benefits and risks and the procedure is not essential to the child's current well-being, it should be the parents who determine what is in the best interest of the child. In the pluralistic society of the United States in which parents are afforded wide authority for determining what constitutes appropriate child-rearing and child welfare, it is legitimate for the parents to take into account cultural, religious, and ethnic traditions, in addition to medical factors, when making this choice.119
 
Last edited:
Do you approach all issues as black or white?

I hardly see how this issue can be expected to get the same treatment as all issues. Your apparent lack of genuine concern on this particular subject (though for some reason you choose to participate) would be disturbing to me if I: a) thought I was seeing through to the "real you", and b) gave a rat's ass on a Melba Toast what your opinion was.

Considering how it does, after all, pertain to my cock, I for one am deeply invested in this particular debate. Not only that, I feel a deep sympathetic mourning for everyone, male or female, who has had genital (or any other, but especially genital) mutilation. To me, the very idea that anyone could be so ignorant and have so little respect for the intrinsic, inalienable human rights of their defenceless children is just completely beyond comprehension.

To see this pain and suffering rationalised away as minor, necessary or even worse, beneficial, is sickening. To see the "parents' right to choose" ritual mutilation for another individual supported is alarming. To see cosmetic/conformity brought up is, well, not even really worth including in the minutes of the meeting.

Some things really are "just wrong", and non-medical circumcision of unconsenting minors is absolutely one of those things. A kind of, and even worse than, statutory rape, in my opinion.
 
In the pluralistic society of the United States in which parents are afforded wide authority for determining what constitutes appropriate child-rearing and child welfare, it is legitimate for the parents to take into account cultural, religious, and ethnic traditions, in addition to medical factors, when making this choice.119[/i]
Edited by Miss Anthrope: 
Rule 8 violation removed
No matter who, or where, you are.

Please keep in mind the new Rule 8 guidelines and do not use alternate spelling to get around the auto-censor.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So, to you, if a procedure is medically neutral, it's ok. That's why you might argue that removing the clitoral hood is ok. How can you be sure that these two procedures are medically neutral?

Clitoridectomy is equally "medically neutral."
 
Funny how many (presumably American) people have said something along the lines of, "It doesn't matter what arguments you make, you can't stop me because that's the way we do things here in the good 'ole U.S. of A and that's good enough for me."

I haven't seen anyone say anything, like, "I live in Uruguay/Finland/Canada/Antarctica/Neptune and I'm just glad you have no say in what I do."

You'd think having practically the entire rest of the civilized world imploring you to "think outside the box" just a little bit would get some neurons firing, but it just seems to make them ever more steadfast.
 
I haven't seen anyone say anything, like, "I live in Uruguay/Finland/Canada/Antarctica/Neptune and I'm just glad you have no say in what I do."
Uhum... ;)

PS. did you check out the new forum rules on rule 8 ? (referring to post 1353)
 
Last edited:
Reported as a violation of the revised Rule 8.

Oh, that was petty. Within your rights, sure, but petty.

osmosis, you're absolutely right about US'ers. We're very much like that on MANY topics - we don't give a rat's patootie about what the rest of the civilized world thinks, we're gonna do things our own way and screw everyone else. And we're often wrong on many of the things we choose to dig in about.

But that's the USA for you - always thinking outside the global box. :D

But seriously, that's what it boils down to for me - I see no harm in circumcision (or the exact female equivalent), I see potentially serious benefits to it (50% reduction in HIV transmission is enough to make it mandatory, IMO), and I do live in the U.S.A., where it's been common most of my life, and where a clean cut penis is far more attractive than a hooded bestial worm-thing. And I AM glad that you anti-circ wooists don't make policy in the U.S., because what I can clearly see, especially in this thread, is that the anti-circ crowd is given to being over-emotional, overly attached to unimportant bits of useless anatomy, and obsessive to the point of fanaticism that somehow removal of a bit of foreskin does irreparable damage, somehow.

When methodology was discussed, many emotive arguments were attempted - detailing babies crying out in pain, blood and gore, etc. Yet when the plastibell method was discussed, which combined with a topical pain-killing ointment causes no pain and extremely minimal blood loss, the anti-circ crowd switched topics. They brought up potential complications, but again - the plastibell method reduces the chance of complications to near-zero levels. And again, the A-C crowd switched topics.

There was even a very emotional appeal related to the removal of earlobes and other unnecessary body parts. Which failed, because the pro-circ crowd has no particular interest in bodily integrity over societal norm where drawbacks are as minimal as they are in circumcision.

And one poster - forgive me for not saying who, as I'm terrible with names and too lazy to go looking back through this thread - even admitted to attempting to stir the emotions of the readers. He actually seemed to value an appeal to emotions as if it were a good thing.

Sorry, but I just don't think that someone who relies on emotive manipulation would make a good lawmaker. Sadly, a lot of our lawmakers do just that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom