Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Sarcasm aside from my previous posts, the anti-circ posters here have some very valid points, and it's made me think differently about circumcision.
 
" My only contention is that Jewish parents who want to circumcise their children be allowed to do so."

And what about parents who want their children's little fingers nipped at the last knuckle, or the ones who want their pinky-toes removed? Should I be allowed to have my child's earlobes removed? I'll wager one could removed a percentage of eyelid and still be "Medically Neutral"? (What an horrific phrase that is...)
 
Sarcasm aside from my previous posts, the anti-circ posters here have some very valid points, and it's made me think differently about circumcision.
Kudos, man. I think most people have a tendency to dig in their heels and defend a position just because it's their position... I catch myself doing it too. Takes a lot to reconsider a position, something we should all do regularly. :)

Two thumbs up!
 
I always thought the "Circumcision prevents UTIs" argument pretty funny. Not as funny as the "Penile Cancer" argument (Hey, cut off one of your lungs to reduce lung cancer risk) but still funny. Here's how it goes.

If an infant that is in the process of getting an UTI, gets circumcised, its no longer an UTI. Its sepsis, the pathogens now have easy access to the circulatory system, and with the blood loss and traumatizing pain, the kid's got a realistic chance to die, therefore what it gets is no longer classified as an UTI.

But hey, that's one way to reduce the UTI incidence.
 
Sarcasm aside from my previous posts, the anti-circ posters here have some very valid points, and it's made me think differently about circumcision.

That's awesome! Not because you're starting to see things my way, but because you came here with an open mind and a desire to learn.

Starting to see things my way is just the icing on the cake :rolleyes:
 
Just a thought, what happens to a half-Jewish baby? Half a circumcision? Do they take the left half or the right half..
 
Sensation and Sexual Arousal in Circumcised and Uncircumcised Men
ntroduction. Research, theory, and popular belief all suggest that penile sensation is greater in the uncircumcised as compared with the circumcised man. However, research involving direct measurement of penile sensation has been undertaken only in sexually functional and dysfunctional groups, and as a correlate of sexual behavior. There are no reports of penile sensation in sexually aroused subjects, and it is not known how arousal affects sensation. In principle, this should be more closely related to actual sexual function.

Aim. This study therefore compared genital and nongenital sensation as a function of sexual arousal in circumcised and uncircumcised men.

Methods. Twenty uncircumcised men and an equal number of age-matched circumcised participants underwent genital and nongenital sensory testing at baseline and in response to erotic and control stimulus films. Touch and pain thresholds were assessed on the penile shaft, the glans penis, and the volar surface of the forearm. Sexual arousal was assessed via thermal imaging of the penis.

Results. In response to the erotic stimulus, both groups evidenced a significant increase in penile temperature, which correlated highly with subjective reports of sexual arousal. Uncircumcised men had significantly lower penile temperature than circumcised men, and evidenced a larger increase in penile temperature with sexual arousal. No differences in genital sensitivity were found between the uncircumcised and circumcised groups. Uncircumcised men were less sensitive to touch on the forearm than circumcised men. A decrease in overall touch sensitivity was observed in both groups with exposure to the erotic film as compared with either baseline or control stimulus film conditions. No significant effect was found for pain sensitivity.

Conclusion. These results do not support the hypothesized penile sensory differences associated with circumcision. However, group differences in penile temperature and sexual response were found.
 
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1464-410X.2006.06685.x

Fine-touch pressure thresholds in the adult penis

OBJECTIVE

To map the fine-touch pressure thresholds of the adult penis in circumcised and uncircumcised men, and to compare the two populations.

CONCLUSIONS

The glans of the circumcised penis is less sensitive to fine touch than the glans of the uncircumcised penis. The transitional region from the external to the internal prepuce is the most sensitive region of the uncircumcised penis and more sensitive than the most sensitive region of the circumcised penis. Circumcision ablates the most sensitive parts of the penis.




:p
 
Last edited:

I hate to have to be the one to say this to you, but that's ridiculous! I'm kinda disappointed in you, Skeptigirl. Anyone can cherry-pick some study from somewhere that supports the conclusion they, for whatever reason, want it to support.

Here's something you may want to ask yourself Skeptigirl, why is it that you want to find this particular conclusion? Is it because you've already made up your mind, or is there some other motivating factor at play?

Simple logic dictates that amputating/excising/removing (whatever term you can handle) thousands of nerve endings will necessarily result in reduced sensation. Can you logically argue otherwise? (ETA: and desensitisation of the glans, which dries up a little and is constantly exposed to friction from clothing.)

It's amusing that the study also recorded a difference in forearm sensitivity? Exactly how would circumcision affect forearm sensitivity? The very idea smacks of homunculus. What probably happened is they didn't even know how to work the equipment properly, and I am, shall we say, skeptical of the study you quoted.

Did you read it all the way through, or just skim through to the part where they came to the conclusion you were seeking?

ETA: since I actually bothered to read the study, which I doubt you did, I noticed this:
*Riverside Professional Center, Ottawa, Canada; University of Nevada—Department of Psychology, Las Vegas, NV, USA; McGill University, Department of Psychology, Montreal, Canada; §McGill University Health Center (Royal Victoria Hospital), Montreal, Canada; ¶Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, Canada
 
Last edited:

Skeptigirl,

I am the world expert on the sensitivity of my glans. I can guarantee you that applying direct, un-lubricated stimulation to my glans is at best irritating, both in sensation and physically and at worst, painful. Can you imagine what it would feel like to have 'dry-sex' Skeptigirl? If not, perhaps you should try it and then come back and tell us there is no difference in sensation.

Most circumcised men can masturbate without the need of lubrication. The only physically possible explanation for this is that their glans becomes harder and either less sensitive or their brain responds less to the constant stimulation because of habituation. Obviously, removing the sensitive tissue of the foreskin means that it can no longer provide sensation.

You refuse to admit the ethics of infant circumcision are dubious at best. The procedure is not medically indicated for the vast majority of infants. No sensible doctor in the UK would recommend circumcision for prevention of UTI in a healthy infant.

The American doctors and nurses performing circumcisions know that most of their patients do not require the surgery they are performing on them. This alone makes the procedure unethical and little (or in my mind, no) different from committing actual bodily harm on the child.

You and many medical professionals have been fooled Skeptigirl, either by the pro-circ. doctors in the medical community or yourself.
 
I hate to have to be the one to say this to you, but that's ridiculous! I'm kinda disappointed in you, Skeptigirl. Anyone can cherry-pick some study from somewhere that supports the conclusion they, for whatever reason, want it to support.

Here's something you may want to ask yourself Skeptigirl, why is it that you want to find this particular conclusion? Is it because you've already made up your mind, or is there some other motivating factor at play?

DING! DING! DING! We have a winnah!

... because you've already made up your mind...

I think that sums it up. Time for a new thread-

Trepenation: can any rational thinker defend it ?
 
DING! DING! DING! We have a winnah!

... because you've already made up your mind...

I think that sums it up. Time for a new thread-

Trepenation: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I thought it was trephination, and I think everyone needs a brand new hole in his or her head.
 
I've been following this thread since it was resurrected, and although I'm pretty sure my mind is made up, a well-conceived argument could change my mind.

I've noticed that some pro-circ people seem to skip over questions that are uncomfortable to answer. But perhaps I could bring up one of these questions, phrased in a new way.

This isn't just directed at BlackKat.

I think every parent should be entitled to make the decision whether for or against. I would decide for because I value the results of the procedure and don't value the foreskin. Others should have the right to make the same decision I would make for their children. And Others still should have the right to retain their child's foreskin. I would be just as voiceferous as I am in defending circumcisions towards someone who came in the post and said that ALL children should be circumcised. Whether one "likes" foreskins or not is all opinion.
You almost had me agreeing with you there, until I thought about what you said some more, and a loophole entered my mind.

What if a parent said this about female circumcision? Would you still defend their right to decide?

(Note: "female circumcision" is merely used here to maintain civility, as "FGM" has inflaming connotations.)
 
...
Most circumcised men can masturbate without the need of lubrication. The only physically possible explanation for this is that their glans becomes harder and either less sensitive or their brain responds less to the constant stimulation because of habituation. Obviously, removing the sensitive tissue of the foreskin means that it can no longer provide sensation.
....

I wasn't aware most people even touch the glans during masturbation. Not because it is not sensitive, nor because it is too sensitive. But because the fingers wrap around the shaft of the penis and move up and down the shaft, rarely if ever getting that close to that end of the shaft. I suppose there are multiple techniques though... Maybe people with foreskins masturbate differently than people without...

BlackCat said:
What if a parent said this about female circumcision? Would you still defend their right to decide?
Nice name there...

IF and only if it was the least severe version of that practice which involves trimming the clitoral hood and not touching the clitoris at all, was performed by medical personnel in a safe and sterile manner, and was performed with at least emala. The problem people have with FGM is that it is often not the least severe version, is performed by some old lady in a mud hut with a piece of jagged glass, and is done not to beautify but to stunt sexual freedom.
 
is performed by some old lady in a mud hut with a piece of jagged glass, and is done not to beautify but to stunt sexual freedom.

1)Do you realize how close you just came to describing male circumcision?
Why do you think male circumcision is often so much different?...

2)FGM is performed mostly in Africa and islamic countries and they do the same thing for males in the same conditions...

3)FGM in the Western world is very rare to my knowledge, at least in the way you describe it, where as male circumcision is mostly accepted.

Let's not waste each other's time "demanding the evidence" or the exact numbers, when there is no clear case for the contrary and I don't have the time to stay in here for the entire duration of the debate.
I just like your opinion on these points.

SYL :)
 
Originally Posted by BlackKat
is performed by some old lady in a mud hut with a piece of jagged glass, and is done not to beautify but to stunt sexual freedom.

1)Do you realize how close you just came to describing male circumcision?
Why do you think male circumcision is often so much different?...

Male circumcision (in the U.S. anyhow) is performed in a hospital by a doctor with sterile surgical instruments and with the use of Emala cream. That should be how it performed everywhere. That it is not in some places is generally the result of an overall lack of proper health care in those places. And it is rarely done with anything other than cosmetics in mind. Occasionally it is to prevent recurrent UTIs or because of foreskin retraction issues or because the patient's religion requires it. Mostly it's done because people think that non-circumcised penises look weird.

2)FGM is performed mostly in Africa and islamic countries and they do the same thing for males in the same conditions...

Where the conditions I stated above exist is usually where there are little to no resources for healthcare. No hospitals. No clinics. Not even proper sanitation, running water, or electricity. There are industrialized, non-Western countries that do practice FGM however, and sometimes even in hospital settings. That's almost as disturbing.

3)FGM in the Western world is very rare to my knowledge, at least in the way you describe it, where as male circumcision is mostly accepted.
Yes it is rare.
 
Last edited:
ETA: since I actually bothered to read the study, which I doubt you did, I noticed this:
*Riverside Professional Center, Ottawa, Canada; University of Nevada—Department of Psychology, Las Vegas, NV, USA; McGill University, Department of Psychology, Montreal, Canada; §McGill University Health Center (Royal Victoria Hospital), Montreal, Canada; ¶Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, Canada



Osmosis, after being warned numerous times, you once again appear happily to wade into antisemitism. I will describe what you have implied and I will offer you a chance to retract or clarify your meaning.

The article cited was written by two PhDs and a medical doctor and published in a peer-reviewed journal. You quoted the footnotes which indicate where each doctor practices. You bolded "Jewish General Hospital." It was not in bold in the original article.

Your purpose was to imply that doctors at a "Jewish" hospital have a reason to skew their research to support circumcision. Otherwise, what was the point of bolding the fact that the name of one of the hospitals had the word "Jewish" in it?

In this case, however, you have allowed your hatred for Jews to overcome your reason. Here are the three doctors who authored the (peer-reviewed) study: Kimberley Payne, PhD, Serge Carrier, MD, and Yitzchak Binik, PhD. I will fully admit that one of these names sounds very Jewish. Dr. Binik no doubt enjoys a good latkah with apple sauce. But here's the thing: He's not the doctor who practices at Jewish General Hospital. Dr. Carrier is. And his name, to me, does not sound that Jewish.

But there's more: Dr. Carrier doesn't even just practice at Jewish General. The footnote which you claim to have read so carefully explains that he is also based at McGill University Health Center. In fact, McGill is listed first.

So, did a "Jewish" hospital commission a study to help shore up the case for circumcision as you would like us to infer? Or does one of the three doctors who co-authored the peer reviewed paper just happen to have privileges at one of the best hospitals in Montreal?

Oh right, that's my last point: See, my wife is actually from Montreal. My two neices were born at "the Jewish" (as it's called). Her family all still lives in Montreal. Guess what. It's part of McGill University, genius. The name "Jewish" is no more important than the name Presbyterian is in Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center (which is now part of NYU).

Being a tolerant person, I will be glad to accept your apology. If I have misunderstood, I would be glad to hear exactly why you bolded "Jewish General Hospital" when you quoted the list of medical centers the doctors were affiliated with.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom