Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

"to those of us who don't give much of a heck either way about male circumcision"
Then why are you in this thread at all?

Because I like to read the evidence on the pros and cons. Sorry if that upsets you. Some of us skeptics actually like rounding out our views and carefully considering all points. Again sorry if you have something against that.

Oh wait. I'm not sorry at all.
 
First of all, I am not with Black Kat. I just want to make that clear. I do not endorse any of those arguments.

Second of all, the stuff from the circumcision fetish site was just weird.

Third, I hope you understand that your statement above is what you wish were the rule. It's what you think should be the rule. It is not the actual rule in any western nation and certainly not the US.

Last, I just want to repeat that the stuff about US women preferring one type of penis I do not agree with and it in no way represents my thinking.

Yeah, the US is one of the few western countries that did not sign up completely to the UN Charter on Human Rights*.

It is actually the 'rule' in the European Union except politicians, constantly looking not to offend voting minority groups, pass local laws that provide exceptions to it.

What usually happens is some individual or small group takes a case to the European court of human rights and the judges then decide if these exceptions are valid.

There has been some interesting cases in the UK too. Generally, it is moving in the direction I stated in my previous post. The individual's rights are being upheld by the courts more often.

*Because some states in the US still believe the death penalty is ethical. But that's a whole different argument;)
 
BlackKat, again you ignored all information which supported function and benefits of the foreskin beyond keeping the glans warm. And, avoided the issue that if ANY of the benefits claimed are true then circumcising an infant is robbing him of some of the future pleasure he will get from sex.

Instead you respond by repeating unfounded statements like "the foreskin serves no purpose for men who wear underpants" and "lots of American women won't have sex with uncut penises" and "evolution means that boys will eventually be born without foreskins". And now the new one, "circumcision is like the abortion debate". Red herrings all. But if that's what it takes to defend your penis, and your decision to force yourself on your child, so be it.

The core issue remains that there is a lot of evidence, even if not conclusive, that the foreskin contributes to the pleasure of sex for both the man and the woman. In light of even a reasonable possibility that the foreskin contributes to pleasure, each medically unnecessary circumcision of an infant is a human rights violation which potentially robs another unwilling person of some of the pleasure life has to offer. Infant male circumcision is morally wrong and unethical for precisely the same reason that FGM is wrong.

Lets boil this down. We have a procedure which:
1) Is irreversible
2) Is guaranteed to result in the loss of part of a sexual organ, and likely to reduce the sensitivity of what remains
3) Research, though not conclusive, indicates that sexual pleasure and function will be reduced for the patient and possibly their sexual partner. But the patient will still be capable of achieving orgasm.
4) Might make the patient slightly more desirable to some sexual partners
5) Provides some level protection against easily treated or prevented diseases/conditions
6) In an infant, will probably result in some secondary infection due to fecal contact with a wound
7) In rare cases results in other serious complications
(notice that this list applies to FGM also)

My point is not that it has no sexual function. It was that the sexual function is minor to the point of being negligble. The same way that uncircumcised penises are more likely to give females cervical cancer, spread disease, or get UTIs is minor to the point of being neglible.
In short +1-1=0.
Medically neutral procedure.

Oh and I never said:
lots of American women won't have sex with uncut penises
But it's been shown that men who are not circumcised get less oral sex.
http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/ohara/
And that women in America tend like circumcsied penises better.
http://www.circs.org/library/williamson/index.html

And this is true (although that's not how I phrased it):
circumcision is like the abortion debate
You may have an absolute moral opinion about the issue, but that does not mean this is a black and white issue.

6+7 almost never occur when the procedure is performed in U.S. Hospitals. Complication rate is rather low.
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html

Most adults, properly informed, would not choose this procedure. If they do, fine, adults can do what they want. I bet that even BlackKat, if offered another procedure with exactly the above benefits and drawbacks, would say "hell no my penis is perfect the way it is".
Nope. Have had it peirced.
 
But it's been shown that men who are not circumcised get less oral sex.
http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/ohara/

That study concludes women prefer uncircumcised penises!

And this is true (although that's not how I phrased it):
circumcision is like the abortion debate
You may have an absolute moral opinion about the issue, but that does not mean this is a black and white issue.

The right to health and life are universal for individuals. The gray area for abortion is when the fetus may be classed as an individual.

ETA: Except for the few cases where individuals are sustained only by life support systems and are not expected to recover.

6+7 almost never occur when the procedure is performed in U.S. Hospitals. Complication rate is rather low.
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html

Complication rates are estimated at 2%. Mild infection of the wound is very common.

Nope. Have had it peirced.

And there I was thinking you were just 1 standard deviation away from the mean:covereyes:D

(I think I'd have more chance convincing Loss Leader circumcision is a bad idea)
 
Last edited:
My point is not that it has no sexual function. It was that the sexual function is minor to the point of being negligble.
You said over and over and over that the foreskin has no value for men who wear underpants. The wikipedia article, which you referenced to support your argument, overwhelmingly contradicts your assertion and documents why there is strong reason to believe that the foreskin provides meaningful function and benefit.

When we are talking about use and function and benefits, we are only talking about meaningful use and function and benefits. It is only meaningless to you because you can't feel it, and you need to tell yourself that you're not really missing out on anything.

The same way that uncircumcised penises are more likely to give females cervical cancer, spread disease
WTF are you talking about? This sounds like the same superstition of "the foreskin does nothing for men who wear underpants".

Oh and I never said:
lots of American women won't have sex with uncut penises
Fine. I'll quote it directly:
I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.

But it's been shown that men who are not circumcised get less oral sex.
http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/ohara/
And that women in America tend like circumcsied penises better.
http://www.circs.org/library/williamson/index.html
You keep trying to make the argument that men who are not circumcised won't be able to get the sex they want, for the sole reason that they are not circumcised. This is not supported by anything you have cited.

First, correlation is not necessarily causation. Some studies (cited earlier in this thread) have shown that circumcised men are more likely to exhibit sexual behavior that many would see as "extreme" or "deviant". Well, duh! If you've lost all that sensitivity and can no longer get the full pleasure from sex, it makes perfect sense that you'd be more motivated to try (or insist on) new things. You have done nothing to demonstrate that being uncut will reduce a man's ability to receive oral sex if that's what he wants.

Second, you make a leap from "women in America tend like circumcised penises better" to "uncircumcised means less sex". This is also unwarranted, and you have done nothing to demonstrate that it would make enough of a difference to enough women that an uncircumcised man would ever get turned down on that basis.

Third, you have an amazing ability to carefully pick-and-choose which data from each study you'll pay attention to. Just like the dowsers remember only the confirming "hits" and forget the "misses". You do know you're on a skeptic site, right?

You linked to the wikipedia article and ignored the majority of the article that contradicted your assertions.

You linked to http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/ohara/ but ignored information such as
CIRP Note: The results of this survey are somewhat obscurely stated. This survey surveyed 138 women. Of that group 20 (14.5%) preferred non-intact circumcised sexual partners while 118 or (85.5%) preferred intact non-circumcised sexual partners. This means that about 6 out of 7 women preferred intact non-circumcised partners while about 1 out of seven preferred non-intact circumcised partners.
and
With their circumcised partners, women were more likely not to have a vaginal orgasm (4.62, 3.69-5.80). Conversely, women were more likely to have a vaginal orgasm with an unaltered partner. Their circumcised partners were more likely to have premature ejaculation (1.82, 1.45-2.27). Women were also more likely to state that they had had vaginal discomfort with a circumcised partner either often (19.89, 5.98-66.22) or occasionally (7.00, 3.83-12.79) as opposed to rarely or never. More women reported that they never achieved orgasm with circumcised partners (2.25, 1.13-4.50) than with their unaltered partners. Also, they were more likely to report never having had a multiple orgasm with their circumcised partners (2.25, 1.13-4.50). They were also more likely to report never having had a multiple orgasm with their circumcised partners (2.22, 1.36-3.63). They were also more likely to report that vaginal secretions lessened as coitus progressed with their circumcised partners (16.75, 6.88-40.77).
Yes, the study you just linked to provides yet more evidence that circumcision interferes with a man's ability to give a woman pleasure.

The sources you cite overwhelmingly seem to contradict your assertions rather than support them, with the exception of the circ fetish site.

6+7 almost never occur when the procedure is performed in U.S. Hospitals. Complication rate is rather low.
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html
6) Infant boys in the US don't poop in their diaper? Come on.
7) I have personally known the families of two different cases where the circumcision developed serious complications requiring multiple surgeries to correct later, and it still isn't known whether the boys will have full sexual function as adults. Saying complications aren't worth considering in the US is just putting your head in the sand.

Nope. Have had it peirced.
Peircing does not fit that list, although I will concede that it shows a willingness to modify one's penis.

Since you've introduced that into the discussion, let's apply your illogic to peircing:
What do you think is the percentage of men who make the decision to get their penis peirced? I think it's very low
What do you think is the percentage of women who find a peirced penis less attractive than an unpeirced one? I'd bet the farm that more women find a peirced penis less attractive than an unpeirced one
What do you think is the number of women who would refuse sex with someone with a peirced penis? again I'd bet the farm that it's more women than would refuse sex with an uncut penis
What do you think is the number of women who would refuse oral sex with someone with a peirced penis? certainly it would be higher than the number who would refuse it on the basis of non-circumcision

And finally, what did your wife say when you peirced your infant son's penis? If you didn't peirce his penis, why not? Do you think parents should be permitted to peirce the genitals of their infant children? Why or why not?
 
And finally, what did your wife say when you peirced your infant son's penis? If you didn't peirce his penis, why not? Do you think parents should be permitted to peirce the genitals of their infant children? Why or why not?

Beh...
If you even took an infant to a peircer for a genital peircing, they'd probably call CPS on you after calling you a sick freak and kicking you out.
 
(I think I'd have more chance convincing Loss Leader circumcision is a bad idea)


I am one hundred percent convinced that if parents don't want their child circumcised, he should not be circumcised. I am completely and totally against mandatory circumcision.

I'll go a step further: I am one hundred percent convinced that Jewish parents who don't want their child circumcised should not have their child circumcised. Although I speak in no way for my religion (which has little to no centralized authority in any case), I would not discriminate in any way against a Jewish male who was uncircumcised. I would not look down on the parents, consider them "less" Jewish or bear them any negativity whatsoever.

My only contention is that Jewish parents who want to circumcise their children be allowed to do so. The religious authorities whom I trust are united in believing that circumcision is an important religious rite and I personally have had my son circumcised (and will have the new guy circumcised when he gets here in 14 weeks).
 
It's worth pointing out a few things here. This paper covers most of the medical benefits of circumcision that have been discussed in this thread, and weighs those benefits against the risks of circumcision.

UTIs
Despite the increased relative risk in uncircumcised infants, the absolute incidence of UTI is small in this population (0.4%-1%).18 Depending on the model employed, approximately 100 to 200 circumcisions would need to be performed to prevent 1 UTI.16,19 In this case, a large relative risk reduction translates into a small absolute risk reduction because the baseline prevalence is low. One model of decision analysis concluded that the incidence of UTI would have to be substantially higher in uncircumcised males to justify circumcision as a preventive measure against this condition.20

Penile Cancer
because this disease is rare and occurs later in life, the use of circumcision as a preventive practice is not justified

HIV/STD
behavioral factors are far more important risk factors for acquisition of HIV and other sexually transmissible diseases than circumcision status, and circumcision cannot be responsibly viewed as "protecting" against such infections

Conclusion
Virtually all current policy statements from specialty societies and medical organizations do not recommend routine neonatal circumcision.
...
Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision

Wow! We have these guys on our side, right? Except that circumcision is big money, so it's not surprising that they avoid taking a stand on the issue.

Most notably, this paper does not even consider the medical and functional value of the foreskin. They have artificially restricted their consideration to:
- The procedure is not necessary to a child's well-being
- What are the medical benefits
- What is the risk, excluding harm caused by loss of the foreskin

They don't claim the foreskin has no use, value, or function; they avoid the topic entirely.

Using the AMA's methodology, they could likewise conclude that FGM is not medically justified, so it is up to doctors to educate parents before performing FGM, and to make sure adequate anesthesia is used for all FGM procedures:
1. The AMA encourages training programs for pediatricians, obstetricians, and family physicians to incorporate information on the use of local pain control techniques for female genital mutilation.
2. Existing scientific evidence is not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal female genital mutilation. In circumstances in which there are potential benefits and risks, yet the procedure is not essential to the child's current well-being, parents should determine what is in the best interest of the child. To make an informed choice, parents of all female infants should be given accurate and unbiased information and be provided the opportunity to discuss this decision. If a decision for female genital mutilation is made, procedural analgesia should be provided.
3. The AMA urges that as part of the informed consent discussion, the risks and benefits of pain control techniques for female genital mutilation be thoroughly discussed to aid parents in making their decisions.
 
Beh...
If you even took an infant to a peircer for a genital peircing, they'd probably call CPS on you after calling you a sick freak and kicking you out.
I agree. But how would infant genital peircing be any worse than infant circumcision? Both would be done for social and cosmetic reasons, but peircing is far less destructive. If anything, society should be more outraged by an infant's circumcision than an infant's genital peircing.
 
If his "evidence" are studies that negate his point of views, then I'm willing to agree. :newlol

Alright then so I copied the wrong link.
http://psychologytoday.com/articles/index.php?term=pto-19941101-000022&page=3 said:
Seventy-eight percent of male respondents reported being circumcised. Preferences reflected these percentages; 42 percent of women reported a strong preference for circumcised men, while only 7 percent preferred uncircumcised men. However, better than half the women with uncircumcised partners expressed some degree of preference for an uncircumcised penis.

But anyhow...
I'm just explaining why I (and other American circumcised males) enjoy being circumcised.

Ultimately, the point of this debate started out being about whether an infant is entitled to "body integrity". The answer I have argued is "Yes, except where that contradicts socially accepted practices that are medically neutral or beneficial.". Some of you feel it is irrelevant what those parents or medical professionals feel. Some of you feel it is not medically neutral although I have not seen much evidence of this. Nor have I seen more than a handful of men who are not happy it was done to them, and done early. Those who are not happy usually had some form of sexual impotence / mid-life crisis and there was not really anything other than testimonial that their impotence was not due to factors like ... them being 55.

So long as the majority of parents and medical professionals in the U.S.A. feel the procedure is medically neutral or beneficial the procedure will continue. It is in fact covered by most medical insurance providers. Doing some quick math...
About 2,000,000 male babies each year at 65% circumcision (that's generous because in the NE + Midwest where I've lived it's in the 80%s) that's:
1,300,000 circumcised babies each year in the U.S. give or take a few.

So are 1,300,000 sets of parents and doctors being sadistic or uncaring? Or are they doing what they believe is in the best interest of their child / patient. I'm going to vote the latter.
 
To all those who claim sex is better uncut:
If it were any better than it is cut, I'd be a sex maniac and my wife would be bow legged and sore on the bottom all the time.

Yes, you probably would be. I know I am. And somehow I keep meeting women who LOVE being bow legged and sore on the bottom all the time.
 
Like your "Do not feed the Jew" remark? What was your excuse again?

I was not aware I needed an excuse. You seem to think so, but I'm guessing you're confusing my meaning. When I said "Jew", I was referring to the religion, not the ethnicity. If I had been referring to his ethnicity, which I cannot actually do because I don't actually KNOW what his ethnicity is, I would probably have used the word "Hebrew" instead (assuming that's his ethnicity.)

I believe you're simply failing to see the difference between two usages of the same word. Had I made a derogatory comment about his race or ethnicity, I could understand your apparent horror. However, I did not.

I hope this clears up your confusion; however, if you wish to berate me further, please do so via PM so as not to interfere with the discussion.
 
Actually, it makes my argument stronger. I have previously argued that banning circumcision might have a harmful effect on the Jewish religion. As you have so ably pointed out, some Jewish people are already abandoning many religious practices - they get tattoos, they don't keep kosher, they marry non-Jews, etc. This is not an argument for abandoning another Jewish practice, it is an argument for preserving as much of Judaism as possible.

I've yet to see an argument for preserving Judaism in this thread. What I've seen is arguments that ritual genital mutilation must not be interfered with, because we "don't know what will happen" to Judaism if it is. I would expect an argument for Judaism to contain words like "Judaism is good because.."

Why the world at large should care what happens to Judaism (or Catholicism, or Bhuddism, etc) is anybody's guess. The part I have trouble with, however, is that some people place their traditions above human rights.

The fact that some Jews don't follow some Jewish practices does not mean all Jews should be prohibitted from following a Jewish practice.

True. The prohibition should be based on ethical grounds. It should be about protecting the human rights of infants from the delusions of their parents, not about who believes what or why.

Already our religion is being eroded by the sea of secularism.

Perhaps, but that's not necessarily a bad thing.

It does not follow that we should abandon our efforts to preserve it.

Nor does it follow that it should be preserved in the first place. But I suspect you'll continue to be concerned nontheless, such is the nature of that particular meme.
 
Nobody is forcing you to get circumcised.

Bingo! You just hit the nail directly on the head, and you don't even know it.

Maybe not me, but many others, and they can't even speak yet. By the time they can, they won't know what was done to them.

The reason we anti-circs get so uppity is because we actually care about other people, especially the helpless ones. Is that such a foreign concept to you?
 
Nor do I understand where you get the idea that circumcision has anything to do with female orgasms.

I am qualified to answer this, being both uncut and a highly skilled provider of female orgasms.

It has to do with the connection between the man and the woman. The foreskin is not only loaded with nerve endings, it keeps the glans softer, moister and more sensitive. With my enhanced sensory equipment, the sensory experience is more intense and, perhaps more importantly, more detailed. I am more "in tune" with my lover, better able to perceive and respond to her in this most intimate act.

Since my penis remains an internal organ, it is also more on par with my partner's vagina, also an internal organ. Therefore, as Captain of the Love Boat, it helps me navigate towards a mutually orgasmic destination.

And, quite frankly, chicks really dig it. No joke. Yes, the foreskin has provided the occasional "surprise!" moment, but never any sort of revulsion. Most women I know who've had both either don't have a preference, or prefer uncut. Once or twice in my life I've met women with a definite preference for cut, but thankfully I didn't meet them in the bedroom. They weren't my type anyway.
 
I dunno...it's just...nutfunk?
Maybe it's old sweat or something? Mixed with some kind of hormonal secretions?
Either way, with proper hygiene it's not an issue. :)

ROFLMAO!! "nutfunk" I'll remember that one! The closest thing I could find to that in the urban dictionary was nut cologne.

Seriously though, yes it's sweat and that special musk. Women get it too, what name could I make up for it.. :D
 
Ultimately, the point of this debate started out being about whether an infant is entitled to "body integrity". The answer I have argued is "Yes, except where that contradicts socially accepted practices that are medically neutral or beneficial.".

The infant is entitled to body integrity. The only exception is when a procedure is medically indicated. Otherwise (s)he gets to choose what is removed.

So are 1,300,000 sets of parents and doctors being sadistic or uncaring? Or are they doing what they believe is in the best interest of their child / patient. I'm going to vote the latter.

Doctors are making lots of money, inflicting unnecessary pain and suffering and committing actual bodily harm. And most of them know it. If I had my way I would prosecute them. What they are doing is a crime against humanity, something they vow never to use their training and skills for.

Parents have responsibilities to look after their child. The rights they have "over" the child are only provided so that they can fulfill these responsibilities. There is very rarely any need to circumcise an infant.
 
Doctors are making lots of money, inflicting unnecessary pain and suffering and committing actual bodily harm. And most of them know it.

Fortunately for us our doctor offered a 'buy one, get one free' on circumcisions (March through June only), so we split the cost between our baby and my brothers. Worked out great!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom