Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

How long does it take you to lift your arm to wash your armpit? Not the actual washing, just the time spent lifting the arm. That's how much longer it takes to care for an uncut penis.

This is disingenuous, your penis-defense mechanism has entirely ignored the function and usefulness of the foreskin, and you continue to refer to it as "useless" and "vestigal", and hold to the inane argument that somehow modern underwear performs the same function. You most certainly have not considered the negative effects, you refuse to even acknowledge them!

This is the only subculture I can think of where lack of body modification might be seen as a valid reason to refuse sex. Quick question, how many of these tattoos were performed on incapacitated infants at the request of the parents? Or does your particular subculture still place value on one making one's own decisions regarding their body, with the obvious exception of the penis?

How exciting for you! Congratulations! What is wrong with the child deciding once he is old enough to make the choice himself? Why can't a person choose for themselves what is "right" for their own penis? I notice all of the pro-circs in this thread steadfastly avoid that question.

Do you not see the rudeness that has been present in so many of your own posts?
Most people? This just illustrates how out of touch you are. Most people don't think beyond "it's what you do when you have a baby boy", let alone to analyze the evolutionary history behind the foreskin. Your assertions keep getting more and more absurd.


Wow. OK first, can you explain for the rest of us mere skeptics exactly how underpants and walking upright replace these foreskin functions:
- Protecting the glans from keratinization and desensitization
- Provide a gliding action during intercourse
- Provide increased sensation and sensitivity during intercourse and foreplay

And could you also explain how humans will eventually be born without foreskins? By what process observed today would boys with a genetic tendency toward smaller foreskins be favored for survival and reproduction until eventually no foreskin was present?

You've presented an unfounded assertion that foreskins are without any value or function for a human who wears underpants, then piled on the absurdity (and demonstrated your lack of understanding of the evolutionary processes) by proclaiming that human males will eventually be born without foreskins. Apparently your only justification for this is your stubborn and unfounded assertion that the foreskin has no value.

The only foreskin function that underpants can replace is the need to keep the glans warm.


Nobody claimed that it made the sex drive stronger, only that sex was more pleasurable. There is no reason (to my knowledge) to think that circumcision would make any difference one way or the other when it comes to sex drive. And more pleasurable sex does not equate to becoming a sex maniac and wearing your wife raw. On the contrary, you and your wife would simply get more satisfaction from the sex you have anyway.


What protects your glans from the damage caused by your underpants? What protects your glans from drying out and becoming less sensitive as a result of being in constant contact with a dry cloth?

Oh, right. Nothing.

Not ignoring other functions of foreskins. Comparing and contrasting those functions with circumcised penises negates them. Studies back that people who are circumcised range from having the same sexual functionality to having better sexual functionality (by a slight margin) than non-circumcised males. This means any purpose of a foreskin in sexual activity is extraneous. And the same studies show a lack of certain types of sexual activity compared to men who were circumcised.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_effects_of_circumcision
Yes it's Wikipedia but they've collected links to all the studies needed in the references.
Note it also addresses the myths of drying glans.


As for why not wait to perform circumcisions?
Simply put:
Easier to perform on babies.

Same reasons for this:
http://www.gofeet.com/childrensfeet.html
This:
http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/positional_plagiocephaly.cfm
And this:
http://www.drgreene.org/body.cfm?id=21&action=detail&ref=550
All being treated ASAP.
 
From BlackKat's fetish site:

http://www.circlist.com/preferences/feelcut.html

I am uncut and have been keeping my skin retracted for more than 15 years. In fact my skin only covers a little bit of my corona now when I am flaccid. To keep your skin off your head, you may want to try wearing some tight underwear which keeps the penis in a fixed position all the time. Keep your skin retracted at all times. Once you find it slipping forward, go to the toilet and skin it back again. The key is to keep it retracted for as long as possible continously. Gradually your skin will completely loosen up and learn to stay back. Even if it is long enough to cover the head, somehow it will 'crease up' like your elbow skin and can never cover the head continously anymore.

The interruption of sleep was experienced by me, but it did not last more than 2 weeks. Soon or later the skin of the glans will toughen up (well in fact it will 'peel' off as if you had a sunburn). In about 1 month, it will completely dry up. You can then try to masturbate like a cut man, using your dry hand on your dry glans. The painful sensitivity is gone - you can touch your glans anyway you want and clean it anyway you want - unlike before.

However, I think that having a long and loose frenulum is essential if you want to keep your skin peeled back at all times; otherwise, a circumcision is recommended.

There's also a handy illustrated guide demonstrating how to use sticky-tape to hold your foreskin back for up to 3 days at a time. You never know when you might need to know how to do that.:)
 
LOL!!:D

BlackKat,

I won't tell anybody. Honest.

Actually the funny thing is (and I'm sure one of the resident Freuds will chime in here and say I'm lying) I am not "pro-circumcision". That would imply that I think everyone should be circumcised. Whereas someone "anti-circumcision: would be against anyone getting circumcised.

Circumcision is not a black and white issue though (few are).
I am in the middle as are most people. I think every parent should be entitled to make the decision whether for or against. I would decide for because I value the results of the procedure and don't value the foreskin. Others should have the right to make the same decision I would make for their children. And Others still should have the right to retain their child's foreskin. I would be just as voiceferous as I am in defending circumcisions towards someone who came in the post and said that ALL children should be circumcised. Whether one "likes" foreskins or not is all opinion.

Really it's not that different a subject than abortion rights.
 
Uh, yeah, that is a circ fetish site. Not just pro-circ, but all about eroticizing circumcision. Ewww.:yikes:

For the non-pornographic presentation of circumcision rates:
http://www.cirp.org/library/statistics/USA/

I live in the western region, only 31% now. That seems about right based on the other parents I know.

Oh just think about all those poor, poor, circumcised boys that just won't fit in with their peers because their penis is different.:rolleyes:
 
Ivor said:
There's also a handy illustrated guide demonstrating how to use sticky-tape to hold your foreskin back for up to 3 days at a time. You never know when you might need to know how to do that.
Yeah. Not a fetish site. Right.

In all seriousness, there are a bunch of pro-circ fetish sites. But I've never, ever run across an anticirc site that was goofy in that way.

Wonder what it is about the procircumcision thing that brings out the weirdos?
Oh, and can I say that I absofu**inglutely hate these guys?

They don't just collect images of grownups doing it...they like to link to vidoes and pictures of little kids getting mutilated for their masturbatory pleasure, too.

:mad: :mad: :mad:

Psychos.
 
Note it also addresses the myths of drying glans.

Myth's your fetish site claims are advantages.

As for why not wait to perform circumcisions?
Simply put:
Easier to perform on babies.

Same reasons for this:
http://www.gofeet.com/childrensfeet.html
This:
http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/positional_plagiocephaly.cfm
And this:
http://www.drgreene.org/body.cfm?id=21&action=detail&ref=550
All being treated ASAP.

All those are deformities or infections. The mis-shapen head can ONLY be corrected during infancy.

Foreskin is both healthy, normal and functional.
There is rarely any medical reason to remove it as an infant.
Uncircumcised men are just as happy with their penises as you are.
Women can orgasm at least as much with an uncircumcised man as circumcised.
There has been no evidence provided that women will not provide oral sex for an uncircumcised man.

All you have left to argue is Loss Leaders point that the law currently allows you to inflict your idea of perfection on your child, therefore it is "right" and nobody can stop you.

That is a really pathetic argument.
 
Uh, yeah, that is a circ fetish site. Not just pro-circ, but all about eroticizing circumcision. Ewww.:yikes:

For the non-pornographic presentation of circumcision rates:
http://www.cirp.org/library/statistics/USA/

I live in the western region, only 31% now. That seems about right based on the other parents I know.

Oh just think about all those poor, poor, circumcised boys that just won't fit in with their peers because their penis is different.:rolleyes:

I don't see a decline in circumcisions on the charts on that web page, and that on an avowed foreskinoganda site.
 
Actually the funny thing is (and I'm sure one of the resident Freuds will chime in here and say I'm lying) I am not "pro-circumcision". That would imply that I think everyone should be circumcised. Whereas someone "anti-circumcision: would be against anyone getting circumcised.

Circumcision is not a black and white issue though (few are).
I am in the middle as are most people. I think every parent should be entitled to make the decision whether for or against. I would decide for because I value the results of the procedure and don't value the foreskin. Others should have the right to make the same decision I would make for their children. And Others still should have the right to retain their child's foreskin. I would be just as voiceferous as I am in defending circumcisions towards someone who came in the post and said that ALL children should be circumcised. Whether one "likes" foreskins or not is all opinion.

No one here is "anti-circumcision" as far as I can tell. If it's going to provide a significant medical benefit then I have no problem with it, so long as it is done with effective pain relief. I am pro-choice for the child.

Really it's not that different a subject than abortion rights.

I think it's a very different issue, but since you bring it up I'll say I have concerns about how late during pregnancy abortions are currently allowed to be performed.

In this day and age there is no need for any woman to be more than 10 weeks pregnant at the time of abortion, probably less. With the morning-after pill they should not be required at all.
 
The results of any study of pleasure and sexual function relating to circumcision is highly suspect if it relies in any way on men self-reporting. Additionally, circumcised researchers have a built in motivation (that they probably don't even recognize) for the results to show the circumcised penis is equal or superior to an intact one. In many ways, a man's ego is his penis, and he can't see it as anything less than magnificent. Its not that they lie on purpose, its that their brains are wired to interpret the information in a self-promoting way.

In all cases where men were uncut, then were circumcized, there would be a strong (maybe even overwhelming bias) for men to report that they were more satisfied after the procedure. This is because to say otherwise would be to imply there is now something permanently wrong with their penis. Mens' egos are tied to their sexual identity, and men reporting that their sexual identity is not somehow damaged can't be taken as evidence that the foreskin has no function.

A perfect example of this can be found in the wikipedia article you cited:
In an American study of 123 men, Fink found that medically necessitated circumcision resulted in worsened erectile function at the 99% confidence level, de-sensitization and/or delayed ejaculation at the 92% certainty level, but improved satisfaction at the 96% certainty level.
So the study finds that it decreased sensitivity, caused erectile problems, but improved satisfaction. The improved satisfaction is a virtually guaranteed result, regardless of the other less subjective metrics.

I have to wonder if you even read that wikipedia article before you posted it to prove your point. It is very damning of your continued assertion that foreskin has no function (and therefor nothing is lost) if you wear underpants:
Another is that circumcision reduces sensitivity in the penis
...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_effects_of_circumcision#Foreskin_sensitivity
There is a traditional belief that the foreskin is sexually sensitive ... Some recent researchers have also asserted that the foreskin may be sexually responsive
...
Circumcision removes the ridged band at the end of the foreskin [20]. Taylor (1996) observed that the ridged band had more Meissner's corpuscles — a kind of nerve ending that is concentrated in areas of greatest sensitivity [21] — than the areas of the foreskin with smooth mucus membranes. Taylor postulated that the ridged band is sexually sensitive and plays a role in normal sexual function. He also suggested that the gliding action, possible only when there was enough loose skin on the shaft of the penis, serves to stimulate the ridged band through contact with the corona of the glans penis during vaginal intercourse.
...
Circumcision ablates" (removes) "the most sensitive parts of the penis."
...
Kim and Pang concluded, "There was a decrease in masturbatory pleasure and sexual enjoyment after circumcision, indicating that adult circumcision adversely affects sexual function in many men, possibly because of complications of the surgery and a loss of nerve endings."
It goes on, too much to quote. Even with the natural bias toward circumcision, the research is strongly indicating beneficial sexual function of the foreskin, regardless of whether men self-report satisfaction with their circumcision.

When it comes to the female's pleasure:
foreskin is a natural gliding stimulator of the vaginal walls during intercourse, increasing a woman's overall clitoral stimulation and helping her achieve orgasm more quickly and more often. Without the foreskin's gliding action, they suggest, it can be more difficult for a woman to achieve orgasm during intercourse.
I don't claim that to be conclusive, but it is an indication of a function and benefit to the foreskin, and that there is good reason to believe that the foreskin contributes to the overall pleasure of sex for a man and maybe for the woman as well.

If any of it is true, infant circumcision is robbing another human being (and maybe his future wife!) of part of the sexual pleasure they would otherwise be able to experience as an adult. That is why FGM is wrong and it is why RIC is just as reprehensible.

That part of the pleasure, which is not hypothetical to me because I experience it every time, is something that you can't experience because of what was done to you against your will when you were an infant. Just because you are not able to experience it doesn't mean it isn't there.
 
I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.
Complete and total and in every other way horse, pig, dog, and pigeon *****. I'm not cut, and it's never been a problem for me.

I've been involved, over my life, with 22 different people. About a third long-term, the rest one(or two)-night-stands" (some hookups at fetish play-parties). Out of those, only four did not offer to perform oral sex. Of those three, one was interested only in conventional intercourse and "golden showers" (not my thing, which is why it never went anywhere beyond the one night), one did not perform oral sex on anyone after her first, circumcized, boyfriend (though was more than happy to receive), and one wasn't interested in anything that wasn't strictly focussed on her (and was the worst sex I've eve had).

Of the rest, three evinced a positive preference for uncut penises (one really liked playing puppets with them, she was a very silly girl, and quite good in bed). Two of them, one a really hot Jewish goth, were only interested in manual and oral sex, no intercourse.

I've never been interested in anal sex (although a couple of partners have mentioned an interest in it), so I can't speak to that.
Having never taken a communal shower with other men I'm not sure what sort of teasing may occur. But I'm sure someone else here who went to middle schools that had such things in their gym locker rooms could contribute. I grew up in a pretty redneck town.
Well, in my experience, absolutely none at all. Zero. Plenty of towel marks snapping for general purposes, but no teasing about physical attributes. Not even the fat kids.
I would be interested to learn (and not surprised to find it true) if Americans (due to higher rates of circumcision) are more likely to engage in oral and anal sex than their largely uncircumcised counterparts in other countries. A couple of the studies already linked here have hinted at this but since this has not been the focus of the study not really extrapolated on.
Not even remotely true. In fact, in areas where low rates of oral or anal sex are reported (such as North and Central Africa), studies have shown that it is, in fact, just as prevalent as in the west; but that reporting is greatly lower than the actuality due to social taboos. It happens, it's just not openly admitted to.
 
Reading through this thread, I doubt that I am the only woman who is rather amused by the references made (mainly by the defenders of circumcision) to the improved aesthetic qualities of a circumcised penis.

Guys, I have a little newsflash for you: most women don’t find male genitals, cut or uncut, particularly pretty. To be frank, your scrotums usually look like the neck skin of a badly plucked chicken and a flaccid penis is a rather sad and comical-looking thing, at the best of times. This is the reason why the atmosphere amongst the female audience at a Chippendales show is one of good-natured, screaming hilarity rather than steamy eroticism. It is also the reason why the market for pornography specifically aimed at heterosexual women is comparatively small. If you take a quick poll of the women around you, I doubt you will find many who list “genitals” as amongst the body parts they find most aesthetically pleasing in a man.

Personally, the only time I really appreciate the aesthetic qualities of a penis is when it is in my bedroom and ready for some action. At that point, there is almost no visible difference between a circumcised and uncircumcised one.

I also find the argument that women won’t want to perform oral sex on uncircumcised men because it’s not as “clean” to be very unpleasantly revealing. The idea that there might be millions of circumcised men out there who are under the impression that it’s ok not to wash your genitals before asking someone else to put them in their mouth is really quite alarming.
 
So if I don't fall down on my knees and say "Oh Morrigan I've been so deluded. Please enlighten me!" I don't have an open mind?
Strawman alert. I already explained why you don't have an open mind, and I'll repeat it: it's because you refuse to even consider the counter arguments and just repeat the same old tired nonsense. Not because you won't fall to your knees. :rolleyes:

If you can provide me with evidence that men who are circumcised have worse sex lives Then and only then will I believe you. I (and others in this thread) have already linked the same studies that show there is no detriment to having no foreskin so many times. I'm not going to link them again just because you're too lazy to go back to page 5 or whatever it is. Nobody has shown more than opinion pieces that show circumcision is bad for you. Nothing more than hysterical Freudian vomit.
I'm beginning to think that you are a troll.
You made a bunch of outrageous statements about the high chances of uncut men not getting laid and keep repeating that the only use of the foreskin is protection from the cold, REFUSE to provide a single shred of evidence for those claims, and now instead change the subject and ask others for evidence when the onus is on you?
Pathetic.

Reading through this thread, I doubt that I am the only woman who is rather amused by the references made (mainly by the defenders of circumcision) to the improved aesthetic qualities of a circumcised penis.

Guys, I have a little newsflash for you: most women don’t find male genitals, cut or uncut, particularly pretty. To be frank, your scrotums usually look like the neck skin of a badly plucked chicken and a flaccid penis is a rather sad and comical-looking thing, at the best of times. This is the reason why the atmosphere amongst the female audience at a Chippendales show is one of good-natured, screaming hilarity rather than steamy eroticism. It is also the reason why the market for pornography specifically aimed at heterosexual women is comparatively small. If you take a quick poll of the women around you, I doubt you will find many who list “genitals” as amongst the body parts they find most aesthetically pleasing in a man.

Personally, the only time I really appreciate the aesthetic qualities of a penis is when it is in my bedroom and ready for some action. At that point, there is almost no visible difference between a circumcised and uncircumcised one.
Oh, you aren't the only female indeed. This bizarre notion that uncut penises are "repulsively hideous", repeated ad nauseum by Blackkat and others, is more funny than outrageous, since the appearance of an uncut erect penis is so similar to a cut one with the foreskin pulled back.

But, I wonder. Perhaps Blackkat suffers from the delusion that women think flaccid penises are beautiful and sexy-looking?
If so, well... :newlol :newlol Poor lad.

I also find the argument that women won’t want to perform oral sex on uncircumcised men because it’s not as “clean” to be very unpleasantly revealing. The idea that there might be millions of circumcised men out there who are under the impression that it’s ok not to wash your genitals before asking someone else to put them in their mouth is really quite alarming.
No kidding.
 
Strawman alert. I already explained why you don't have an open mind, and I'll repeat it: it's because you refuse to even consider the counter arguments and just repeat the same old tired nonsense. Not because you won't fall to your knees. :rolleyes:

Um. You're doing the same thing. We're all running in circles. That's my point in essence. Nobody is going to convince anyone of anything. That's why the decision to circumcise is left up to the individual parents.

I'm beginning to think that you are a troll.
You made a bunch of outrageous statements about the high chances of uncut men not getting laid and keep repeating that the only use of the foreskin is protection from the cold, REFUSE to provide a single shred of evidence for those claims, and now instead change the subject and ask others for evidence when the onus is on you?
Pathetic.

No. I said high chance of no oral sex, not "getting laid", and refered specifically to "with American women" who expect to see a penises circumcised. I didn't ask you to show me evidence you can get laid here in the U.S. so I don't know what you're talking about. But if you don't think American women don't think penises should be circumcised why then do so many have their sons circumcised??

Also you're acting as if I said Almost every woman in the world. I said Most American Women. So please stop acting like I said things I did not.

And why are you acting so hostile? You and others on this post took what was otherwise a fairly civil discourse and thoroughly trashed it. Why don't you stop using insulting words in your posts like troll and pathetic? How are we supposed to have a rational discourse on this subject when people are calling each other names?

Oh, you aren't the only female indeed. This bizarre notion that uncut penises are "repulsively hideous", repeated ad nauseum by Blackkat and others, is more funny than outrageous, since the appearance of an uncut erect penis is so similar to a cut one with the foreskin pulled back.

But, I wonder. Perhaps Blackkat suffers from the delusion that women think flaccid penises are beautiful and sexy-looking?
If so, well... :newlol :newlol Poor lad.

No kidding.

To me circumcised penises look funny, and non-circumcised penises look gross. That's because looks are subjective. Two men could look at the same female and one thinks she is ugly wheras there other is attracted.
Finding aesthetic constants is pretty difficult.

But here is a study showing female preference for cicumcised penises (in America because it was done there)
http://www.circs.org/library/williamson/index.html
 
BlackKat, you're missing the point (again).

Human rights transcend culture. They are for everybody on the planet.

Why do you think removing a body part from another human to suit your preference does _not_ violate that individual's human rights?
 
BlackKat, you're missing the point (again).

Human rights transcend culture. They are for everybody on the planet.

Why do you think removing a body part from another human to suit your preference does _not_ violate that individual's human rights?

It's not as black and white as that. You have to weigh the cultural aspects, the body part in question, the procedure involved, the rights of the parents to make decisions for their children, and the right of the individual, medical benefits, and medical detriments.

No one of those factors automatically trumps the others.

The same fuzzy grayness is true in the debates over abortion rights, euthinasia, cloning.

While I know what decision I would make on infant circumcision I don't agree there should be any blanket policy in either direction on the matter.
 
It's not as black and white as that.

Yes, it is. You think it is for your body, don't you?

You have to weigh the cultural aspects

No, you don't.

the body part in question

No, you don't.

the procedure involved

Only when there is clear medical indication can physical harm (i.e. a surgical or medical procedure) be consented to by another. If a doctor performed a non-indicated surgical or medical procedure on you without your personal consent you could prosecute him/her for actual bodily harm.

Circumcision is not medically indicated in the vast majority of infants.

the rights of the parents to make decisions for their children

The child's rights trump their rights, just as your rights trump mine with respect to your body.

and the right of the individual

For medical procedures that's all that matters.

medical benefits, and medical detriments.

In the case of infant circumcision these cancel out. It is actually considered a waste of money for the National Health Service in the UK unless there are other medical indications.

No one of those factors automatically trumps the others.

Yes, one does. The individual's basic right to body integrity. It is universal.

The same fuzzy grayness is true in the debates over abortion rights, euthinasia, cloning.

No, the right to body integrity holds for these too.

While I know what decision I would make on infant circumcision I don't agree there should be any blanket policy in either direction on the matter.

The only blanket policy is the one that everybody on the planet (including you) believes in to their very core: What happens to your body is your choice.

The only exception is when you need medical intervention and are unable to give consent.
 
The only exception is when you need medical intervention and are unable to give consent.


First of all, I am not with Black Kat. I just want to make that clear. I do not endorse any of those arguments.

Second of all, the stuff from the circumcision fetish site was just weird.

Third, I hope you understand that your statement above is what you wish were the rule. It's what you think should be the rule. It is not the actual rule in any western nation and certainly not the US.

Last, I just want to repeat that the stuff about US women preferring one type of penis I do not agree with and it in no way represents my thinking.
 
BlackKat, again you ignored all information which supported function and benefits of the foreskin beyond keeping the glans warm. And, avoided the issue that if ANY of the benefits claimed are true then circumcising an infant is robbing him of some of the future pleasure he will get from sex.

Instead you respond by repeating unfounded statements like "the foreskin serves no purpose for men who wear underpants" and "lots of American women won't have sex with uncut penises" and "evolution means that boys will eventually be born without foreskins". And now the new one, "circumcision is like the abortion debate". Red herrings all. But if that's what it takes to defend your penis, and your decision to force yourself on your child, so be it.

The core issue remains that there is a lot of evidence, even if not conclusive, that the foreskin contributes to the pleasure of sex for both the man and the woman. In light of even a reasonable possibility that the foreskin contributes to pleasure, each medically unnecessary circumcision of an infant is a human rights violation which potentially robs another unwilling person of some of the pleasure life has to offer. Infant male circumcision is morally wrong and unethical for precisely the same reason that FGM is wrong.

Lets boil this down. We have a procedure which:
1) Is irreversible
2) Is guaranteed to result in the loss of part of a sexual organ, and likely to reduce the sensitivity of what remains
3) Research, though not conclusive, indicates that sexual pleasure and function will be reduced for the patient and possibly their sexual partner. But the patient will still be capable of achieving orgasm.
4) Might make the patient slightly more desirable to some sexual partners
5) Provides some level protection against easily treated or prevented diseases/conditions
6) In an infant, will probably result in some secondary infection due to fecal contact with a wound
7) In rare cases results in other serious complications
(notice that this list applies to FGM also)

Most adults, properly informed, would not choose this procedure. If they do, fine, adults can do what they want. I bet that even BlackKat, if offered another procedure with exactly the above benefits and drawbacks, would say "hell no my penis is perfect the way it is".
 
First of all, I am not with Black Kat. I just want to make that clear. I do not endorse any of those arguments.
My only arguement is that parents can and should be able to choose.
I though you agreed with that.
The rest is why I personally would circumcise my kid. No odder than your reasons.

Second of all, the stuff from the circumcision fetish site was just weird.
I'm still not convinced it's a fetish site per se but I'll take Kelly's word for it. I choose to link from the site because it has collected a number of reports in one place. That's all. I have also linked reports from anti-circumcision sites if I felt their data proved my point.

Third, I hope you understand that your statement above is what you wish were the rule. It's what you think should be the rule. It is not the actual rule in any western nation and certainly not the US.
Agree there.

Last, I just want to repeat that the stuff about US women preferring one type of penis I do not agree with and it in no way represents my thinking.
I'm merely repeating what I have been told by women around me, what certain other men have said in this thread, and what I confirmed by looking at some informal polls and formal studies.
And I don't even know for sure that the perceived reasons for the preference are important as it could just be as simple as prefering what one is used to. That's why I prefer the way circumcised penises look. Because that what I'm used to penises looking like. I also prefer seeing cars drive on the right side of the road but you won't see me running off to England on a crusade to convert them.
 
To me circumcised penises look funny, and non-circumcised penises look gross. That's because looks are subjective. Two men could look at the same female and one thinks she is ugly wheras there other is attracted.
Finding aesthetic constants is pretty difficult.

Well, that’s a perfectly valid argument for an adult male being allowed to have himself circumcised if he chooses. The freedom to choose what happens to our bodies is a fundamental right, and if you were in possession of a foreskin you no longer wanted, I would happily march and wave placards in support of your informed decision to make your genitals look the way you prefer or the way you believe your sexual partners will prefer or the way in which your religious convictions dictate is necessary.

My only arguement is that parents can and should be able to choose.

How is it not hypocritical to champion the rights of parents to choose to rob their child of his future right to choose?:eye-poppi
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom