Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.
Now that we've established how you prefer your penii, maybe we should hear from the other women?

I have never even heard of an instance of a girl backing out when learning that her love hadn't suffered a partial penile amputation. But then again, I don't exactly hang around with the BMEzine people either.
Having never taken a communal shower with other men I'm not sure what sort of teasing may occur. But I'm sure someone else here who went to middle schools that had such things in their gym locker rooms could contribute.
Took plenty of communal showers in Jr high, high school, locker rooms at public pools, etc. Never had any problem whatsoever. But I've never spent much time around guys who are big on the whole penile exam thing.

I have to say, for a circ'd guy who's never had a communal shower, you're quite the expert when it comes to all the details of adult uncut penii.
 
Now that we've established how you prefer your penii, maybe we should hear from the other women?
Oh noes. I've been called gay. Whatever shall I do.

I have never even heard of an instance of a girl backing out when learning that her love hadn't suffered a partial penile amputation. But then again, I don't exactly hang around with the BMEzine people either.
Imagine you're expecting to see a penis circumcised and you've never in your life seen a foreskin. Your initial reaction is going to be "WTF?" If you knew what came out of the pores in the foreskin and what can grow in it you wouldn't put one in your mouth, why should they? Sure you will argue. People who clean there don't have an issue. But frankly I can't trust men to be hygenic as they have a strong tendency towards unhygenic behavior.

Took plenty of communal showers in Jr high, high school, locker rooms at public pools, etc. Never had any problem whatsoever. But I've never spent much time around guys who are big on the whole penile exam thing.

I have to say, for a circ'd guy who's never had a communal shower, you're quite the expert when it comes to all the details of adult uncut penii.
This is because I don't blindly take the evidence from one side but have read all the pros and cons on circumcision and made my decision. It just happens to be a different decision than yours.
 
But frankly I can't trust men to be hygenic as they have a strong tendency towards unhygenic behavior.
The desire to get it on seems to be a pretty strong motivator.
I've had intact boyfriends and circed boyfriends. It's y'all nuts that get funky, by the way. :)
 
Both of you are from Canada which means you don't count. We're talking about Americans as in from the USA.

And the statements I made are not BS as you so rudely put it.
I am in the US. When I grew up, less than 5% were uncut. I wasn't just in the minority, I was the only one. In fact, through jr high and high school, I can only remember a single time noticing another boy was uncut.

I got more action than everyone I knew except one, and that's because he was less selective than me. I got plenty of blow jobs, never tried for anal. And yes, your statements were complete and utter BS. You have no idea what you're talking about, you're just making stuff up to defend your penis.

Nowadays, it's still a majority in my state, but not by much, and circ'd guys are going to be in the minority soon. Supposedly, one of the rationales for cutting is conformity. Soon, cut guys will be in the minority even in the US. Probably within the next 10 years. It won't take women long to figure out that they orgasm easier with uncut guys, and the circ'd guys are going to find themselves not only in the minority, but less desirable because of this procedure that was forced upon them under the auspices of making them more desirable. Then, thanks to the internet, they can read all about how functional and pleasurable their foreskin was, but that has now been forever taken from them. Gee, thanks dad.
 
Get off it and stop whining. If you want to try making stupid, bigoted remarks, be a man and at least acknowledge what you're doing.

The fact you're "making fun", so-called, only destroys your own argument; you're making hysterical personal abuse, is what. It certainly isn't convincing to those of us who don't give much of a heck either way about male circumcision.

Hmm. Your post drips with so much irony, I fear I'll drown. Let's see.
1) The only person "whining" here is you. Osmosis and I were just kidding around a bit, then you decided to come in and throw a tantrum, shrieking at our alleged evil, nasty bigotry.
2) The only one being "hysterical" here is, again, you (see above). Get off your high horse will you?
3) I'm not a man.
4) You seem to be implying that acknowledging one's fault (or whatever you think I should be doing) is a manly behaviour. Are you saying that women cannot do that? Or that "hiding what you're doing" is womanly behaviour? OMG SEXIST BIGOT!!
5) If you don't care about the topic, then just leave the thread, and stop being whiny and hysterical. ;)

What function? It has no significant function to me since I am not a nudist in a temperate to arctic climate.
Thanks but I wear underpants. Don't need it.
People have gone to great lengths to explain the functions of the foreskin to you in this thread. That you keep repeating that its only "use" is protection from the cold will not make it suddenly true.

Again for the bizillionth time in this thead somebody says "Only my viewpoint of what is sacred is right". Try having an open mind about penises. There's room for all kinds. Nobody is forcing you to get circumcised.
Hilarious, and ironic, to be asked to have an open mind from someone who thinks that "foreskins are repulsive" and who refuses to even listen when other people list off their uses. And the whole debate is about forcing circumcisions on people: namely vulnerable, defenseless infants.

Anyway, please, please stop pretending you have "an open mind", when you just repeat the same thing over and over again and don't listen to anything Ivan, kelly or anyone else says and have clearly made up your mind since day one. It's pretty damn disingenuous. Especially considering you have been asked time and time again to provide evidence for your claims, and have yet to post a single word about that.
 
This is because I don't blindly take the evidence from one side but have read all the pros and cons on circumcision and made my decision. It just happens to be a different decision than yours.

All I want parents to do is give their son the chance to do the same for his own body. There is no urgency for the procedure to be done.

By leaving the child intact he is given the right to choose.

You like having the right to choose, don't you?
 
I am in the US. When I grew up, less than 5% were uncut. I wasn't just in the minority, I was the only one. In fact, through jr high and high school, I can only remember a single time noticing another boy was uncut.

I got more action than everyone I knew except one, and that's because he was less selective than me. I got plenty of blow jobs, never tried for anal. And yes, your statements were complete and utter BS. You have no idea what you're talking about, you're just making stuff up to defend your penis.

Nowadays, it's still a majority in my state, but not by much, and circ'd guys are going to be in the minority soon. Supposedly, one of the rationales for cutting is conformity. Soon, cut guys will be in the minority even in the US. Probably within the next 10 years. It won't take women long to figure out that they orgasm easier with uncut guys, and the circ'd guys are going to find themselves not only in the minority, but less desirable because of this procedure that was forced upon them under the auspices of making them more desirable. Then, thanks to the internet, they can read all about how functional and pleasurable their foreskin was, but that has now been forever taken from them. Gee, thanks dad.

I don't really see a strong pattern of decline:
http://www.circlist.com/rites/usa.html

Nor do I understand where you get the idea that circumcision has anything to do with female orgasms. Here's some very basic web reading but a whole book could be written on the subject.
http://www.cwluherstory.org/CWLUArchive/vaginalmyth.html
http://www.sogc.org/health/health-myths_e.asp
http://femaleorgasmsecrets.com/orgasmmyths.html
 
All I want parents to do is give their son the chance to do the same for his own body. There is no urgency for the procedure to be done.

By leaving the child intact he is given the right to choose.

You like having the right to choose, don't you?


Some people day trade and some people are content to have 401ks.

Really I like having anything at all surgical in nature done to me as early as possible. Circumcision. Ear Tubes. Corrective podiatric surgery. All before I was old enough to care about anything but eating and pooping. If only there had been a way to take care of my wisdom teeth back then.
 
Ivor said:
Really! In what way
I dunno...it's just...nutfunk?
Maybe it's old sweat or something? Mixed with some kind of hormonal secretions?
Either way, with proper hygiene it's not an issue. :)
 
I don't really see a strong pattern of decline:
http://www.circlist.com/rites/usa.html

You know that's a circumcision fetish site, don't you?

ETA:

Look at one of the "testimonials" a little more than halfway down the page:

I've been doing circumcisions since I was a medic in the Army - mostly at Fort Bragg and then in Korea in the 1970's. In Army hospitals, a medic could "tutor" under a Medical Officer and then carry on. Circs became my specailty and the patients were plentiful. Mostly healthy, 18 to 21 year olds who the Army wanted to prepare for jungle warfare by removing their foreskins. Mostly guys from the midwest or the south where infant circ was obviously not as common. The Gomco (or cookie cutter as we called it) was the "weapon" of choice and after observing a few, I took over and my mentor was so impressed with my handy work that I took over the practice, doing as many as 20 in a day. High and tight was the style of the day and just like a military haircut, the soldier was never asked "how do you want it?" I did ask how much they wanted to feel - some didn't want to feel anything, but some (like the Green Berets) wanted to take it "like a man". I did pride myself in my suturing and follow up and was proud of every job.

When I arrived in Korea at the 121 Evac, I found that my previous boss at Bragg had called ahead to arrange for the Urology doc to meet me at the door. By day 2, I was dropping them left and right but not in the same quantity as at Bragg. With this duty came many privileges usually reserved for officers and I ate it up.

I really never counted but I rarely did less than 12 a day and sometimes 20 or more. I was not the only one performing the circs - but the only non-physician that was doing them. We were a big preparation center for soldiers going overseas to S.E.Asia and many were done to prepare them for jungle survival.

I did do some experimenting just to break the boredom. I would cut looser sometimes but that was frowned upon. Mostly I experimented with pain control and how much local to inject and how slowly to close the clamp and different topical applications. I also did a lot of study on different guys "threshold of pain" and how they reacted differently to the same procedure. I really didn't like the Green Berets because they treated anyone not a Beret as inferior, so I like to shame them in to taking their cut "like a man" without any anesthetic. I was not being mean or sadistic, because they really liked the challenge. They would grip the table and tears would run down their cheeks before they would admit they needed some local anesthetic injected.

Even better was watching their face turn red with embarrassment when I would prep them with warm Phisohex water and they would get an erection. They certainly didn't want anyone to think they were enjoying having another guy wash their dick! But actually it was easier to scrub it when it was hard, and it went down immediately when the insturments came out (or the syringe).

I started to save the skins in a jar of formalin solution, but the doc got wind of that and said it was sick and made me get rid of them. I thought maybe I'd save them up and take them to the leather shop and have something made. I had thought about a wallet - that turned into a suitcase when you rubbed it.
Randy
 
Last edited:
...

Anyway, please, please stop pretending you have "an open mind", when you just repeat the same thing over and over again and don't listen to anything Ivan, kelly or anyone else says and have clearly made up your mind since day one. It's pretty damn disingenuous. Especially considering you have been asked time and time again to provide evidence for your claims, and have yet to post a single word about that.

So if I don't fall down on my knees and say "Oh Morrigan I've been so deluded. Please enlighten me!" I don't have an open mind?

If you can provide me with evidence that men who are circumcised have worse sex lives Then and only then will I believe you. I (and others in this thread) have already linked the same studies that show there is no detriment to having no foreskin so many times. I'm not going to link them again just because you're too lazy to go back to page 5 or whatever it is. Nobody has shown more than opinion pieces that show circumcision is bad for you. Nothing more than hysterical Freudian vomit.
 
Oh yes it is. :cool:

Oh not it's not.







seriously. You're going to take a post in the blog section and use it to quantify a web site?

By that method I could read my own posts here on this forum and decide JREF was a pro-circ group.
 
It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct? How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?
How long does it take you to lift your arm to wash your armpit? Not the actual washing, just the time spent lifting the arm. That's how much longer it takes to care for an uncut penis.
I myself have weighed the positive and negative effects of circumcision.
This is disingenuous, your penis-defense mechanism has entirely ignored the function and usefulness of the foreskin, and you continue to refer to it as "useless" and "vestigal", and hold to the inane argument that somehow modern underwear performs the same function. You most certainly have not considered the negative effects, you refuse to even acknowledge them!
Maybe I do not value body integrity as much as most people... I do come from a subculture where tatttoos, piercings, hair dying, etc are all considered almost mandatory.
This is the only subculture I can think of where lack of body modification might be seen as a valid reason to refuse sex. Quick question, how many of these tattoos were performed on incapacitated infants at the request of the parents? Or does your particular subculture still place value on one making one's own decisions regarding their body, with the obvious exception of the penis?
And I would gladly circumcise any son of mine as I am ecstatic that I was circumcised as an infant. But by the statements people make here almost every US parent is some sort of sadomasichistic monster. They are not. They just want their child's penis to be right and to them right=circumcised.
How exciting for you! Congratulations! What is wrong with the child deciding once he is old enough to make the choice himself? Why can't a person choose for themselves what is "right" for their own penis? I notice all of the pro-circs in this thread steadfastly avoid that question.
I really have noticed in this thread that with very few exceptions, the people who are against circumcision are using a lot more rude or insulting language than they normally would. Why is that? What is it about this subject that makes them so emotional?
Do you not see the rudeness that has been present in so many of your own posts?
Most people who are pro-circumcision think of the foreskin is a genetic throwback to penile sheathes animals that walk around on all fours use to keep the thing from dangling overmuch and keep it warm.
Most people? This just illustrates how out of touch you are. Most people don't think beyond "it's what you do when you have a baby boy", let alone to analyze the evolutionary history behind the foreskin. Your assertions keep getting more and more absurd.
Since we have underpants and walk upright this is why we don't have as much of a sheathe as in the past, and why eventually people will not be born with foreskins at all(or body hair for that matter).

Wow. OK first, can you explain for the rest of us mere skeptics exactly how underpants and walking upright replace these foreskin functions:
- Protecting the glans from keratinization and desensitization
- Provide a gliding action during intercourse
- Provide increased sensation and sensitivity during intercourse and foreplay

And could you also explain how humans will eventually be born without foreskins? By what process observed today would boys with a genetic tendency toward smaller foreskins be favored for survival and reproduction until eventually no foreskin was present?

You've presented an unfounded assertion that foreskins are without any value or function for a human who wears underpants, then piled on the absurdity (and demonstrated your lack of understanding of the evolutionary processes) by proclaiming that human males will eventually be born without foreskins. Apparently your only justification for this is your stubborn and unfounded assertion that the foreskin has no value.

The only foreskin function that underpants can replace is the need to keep the glans warm.
To all those who claim sex is better uncut:
If it were any better than it is cut, I'd be a sex maniac and my wife would be bow legged and sore on the bottom all the time.

Nobody claimed that it made the sex drive stronger, only that sex was more pleasurable. There is no reason (to my knowledge) to think that circumcision would make any difference one way or the other when it comes to sex drive. And more pleasurable sex does not equate to becoming a sex maniac and wearing your wife raw. On the contrary, you and your wife would simply get more satisfaction from the sex you have anyway.

BlackKat said:
Thus with the advent of underpants we do not need foreskins to keep penises warm or protect the glans at all.
What protects your glans from the damage caused by your underpants? What protects your glans from drying out and becoming less sensitive as a result of being in constant contact with a dry cloth?

Oh, right. Nothing.
 
Oh not it's not.







seriously. You're going to take a post in the blog section and use it to quantify a web site?

By that method I could read my own posts here on this forum and decide JREF was a pro-circ group.

The circlist owners pick and choose what to put up. That wasn't a "blog section".
Just look at their "resources" page!

http://www.circlist.com/resources/resources.html

http://www.icon.co.za/~hugot/circum/

CIRCLIST Member Mini-Gallery is a 'members only' site containing before, during and after circ photos, and stories (fact & fiction):

tp://www.noharmm.org/CAtuli.htm

A web site showing other examples of ritual Filipino circumcision (albeit from an anti-circ point of view) is as folllows: Faces of Circumcision: Tuli Ritual of Filipino Boys (Philippines H O M E The Cycle of Abuse: Faces of Circumcision "Tuli" Ritual of Filipino Boys (Philippines) Filipino "tuli" is usually done on "Black Saturday," the day after Good Friday, during the Christian Easter season

And then look at the discussion groups circlist links to:

"groupteencirc"
"circumcisionfetish"
"circumcisedkids"
"eroticmalecircumcision"
 
Earlobes yes, tattoos yes, labia no.
The criteria is "Is this procedure medically beneficial or at least neutral?"
"I choose to ignore all of the benefits and function of foreskin, and the ethical considerations implied, therefore it's nuetral."

Well done.

What function? It has no significant function to me since I am not a nudist in a temperate to arctic climate.
Thanks but I wear underpants. Don't need it.
I've explained this over and over and over. Somehow your penis ego has inoculated you against considering any loss of function.

Nobody is forcing you to get circumcised.
That's just the point, this is being done to people without their consent and in many cases against their future wishes.

You've demonstrated quite nicely what I think is the real reason for RIC in the US, and that's the father's need to not feel inadequate. Were it not for your own need to feel that your penis is every bit as good as a whole one, plus better looking, you'd be able to comprehend the function of a foreskin beyond keeping the glans warm.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom