It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct? How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?
How long does it take you to lift your arm to wash your armpit? Not the actual washing, just the time spent lifting the arm. That's how much longer it takes to care for an uncut penis.
I myself have weighed the positive and negative effects of circumcision.
This is disingenuous, your penis-defense mechanism has entirely ignored the function and usefulness of the foreskin, and you continue to refer to it as "useless" and "vestigal", and hold to the inane argument that somehow modern underwear performs the same function. You most certainly have
not considered the negative effects, you refuse to even acknowledge them!
Maybe I do not value body integrity as much as most people... I do come from a subculture where tatttoos, piercings, hair dying, etc are all considered almost mandatory.
This is the only subculture I can think of where lack of body modification might be seen as a valid reason to refuse sex. Quick question, how many of these tattoos were performed on incapacitated infants at the request of the parents? Or does your particular subculture still place value on one making one's own decisions regarding their body, with the obvious exception of the penis?
And I would gladly circumcise any son of mine as I am ecstatic that I was circumcised as an infant. But by the statements people make here almost every US parent is some sort of sadomasichistic monster. They are not. They just want their child's penis to be right and to them right=circumcised.
How exciting for you! Congratulations! What is wrong with the child deciding once he is old enough to make the choice himself? Why can't a person choose for themselves what is "right" for their own penis? I notice all of the pro-circs in this thread steadfastly avoid that question.
I really have noticed in this thread that with very few exceptions, the people who are against circumcision are using a lot more rude or insulting language than they normally would. Why is that? What is it about this subject that makes them so emotional?
Do you not see the rudeness that has been present in so many of your own posts?
Most people who are pro-circumcision think of the foreskin is a genetic throwback to penile sheathes animals that walk around on all fours use to keep the thing from dangling overmuch and keep it warm.
Most people? This just illustrates how out of touch you are. Most people don't think beyond "it's what you do when you have a baby boy", let alone to analyze the evolutionary history behind the foreskin. Your assertions keep getting more and more absurd.
Since we have underpants and walk upright this is why we don't have as much of a sheathe as in the past, and why eventually people will not be born with foreskins at all(or body hair for that matter).
Wow. OK first, can you explain for the rest of us mere skeptics exactly how underpants and walking upright replace these foreskin functions:
- Protecting the glans from keratinization and desensitization
- Provide a gliding action during intercourse
- Provide increased sensation and sensitivity during intercourse and foreplay
And could you also explain how humans will eventually be born without foreskins? By what process observed today would boys with a genetic tendency toward smaller foreskins be favored for survival and reproduction until eventually no foreskin was present?
You've presented an unfounded assertion that foreskins are without any value or function for a human who wears underpants, then piled on the absurdity (and demonstrated your lack of understanding of the evolutionary processes) by proclaiming that human males will eventually be born without foreskins. Apparently your only justification for this is your stubborn and unfounded assertion that the foreskin has no value.
The only foreskin function that underpants can replace is the need to keep the glans warm.
To all those who claim sex is better uncut:
If it were any better than it is cut, I'd be a sex maniac and my wife would be bow legged and sore on the bottom all the time.
Nobody claimed that it made the sex drive stronger, only that sex was more pleasurable. There is no reason (to my knowledge) to think that circumcision would make any difference one way or the other when it comes to sex drive. And more pleasurable sex does not equate to becoming a sex maniac and wearing your wife raw. On the contrary, you and your wife would simply get more satisfaction from the sex you have anyway.
BlackKat said:
Thus with the advent of underpants we do not need foreskins to keep penises warm or protect the glans at all.
What protects your glans from the damage caused by your underpants? What protects your glans from drying out and becoming less sensitive as a result of being in constant contact with a dry cloth?
Oh, right. Nothing.