Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Yes. It is.

To say that an uncircumcised male somehow resembles a four-legged animal is no different than saying, for example, that African-Americans resemble Neanderthals because of their heavy eyebrow ridges and strong jaw bones.

You might want to actually read what I write before hitting the reply button.
I did not say that at all (even if you completely jumble the words I wrote up to display in a different order) and indeed I think that this is merely a tactic of deliberate obsfucation intended to make you feel your posts are more righteous.

Again (for the third and final time I will restate my point)

Foreskins are the human version of the penile sheathe.
All animals have penile sheathes. It does not matter if you walk on four or two legs. And four legged animals are not inherently "less evolved" than primates. They just evolved on a divergent path. But because primates did evolve differently their penile sheathes are significantly less pronounced than animals that would have their penises bouncing around more because of their method of locomotion. Another reason that primates have smaller penile sheathes is because it is intended to keep the penis warm. But because primates (including the first humans) live in warmer climates than many mammals it does not need to cover the entire penis to maintain the required temperatures.

Now around 7000 years ago humans developed the first recognizable pair of underpants. And even before that they developed loin cloths.

Thus with the advent of underpants we do not need foreskins to keep penises warm or protect the glans at all. This may someday in the far distant future lead to children being born with even less foreskin, or eventually none. We have not had clothing long enough to chart this. Who knows? Maybe someday they'll determine baldness is a response to the first hats. Hard to say without enough data over several millennium past and future.

This does not serve to show people without foreskins "look more evolved" as you postulate. But it does show that humans (via clothing) have evolved past needing a foreskin. What it does show is the reasons for having a foreskin are mostly gone and that it has become largely vestigial. Whether one is circumcised or not the penis functions properly. Having a foreskin or not has been reduced to whether one likes the way it looks or does not.
 
Last edited:
...But it does show that humans (via clothing) have evolved past needing a foreskin. What it does show is the reasons for having a foreskin are mostly gone and that it has become largely vestigial. Whether one is circumcised or not the penis functions properly. Having a foreskin or not has been reduced to whether one likes the way it looks or does not.

Replace 'foreskin' with 'little finger' and 'penis' with 'hand'.

Apart from that I disagree with your functional assessment of the foreskin. What about its function during intercourse? What about the lubricating function it provides?

Just because a human can survive without a certain body part does not make that part vestigial. Tonsils were thought to be vestigial by 'experts'. Given the same 'experts' have been very keen to remove the foreskin for over a hundred years, I doubt many of them would like to admit that they are ignorant of the human foreskin's function.
 
Replace 'foreskin' with 'little finger' and 'penis' with 'hand'.

Apart from that I disagree with your functional assessment of the foreskin. What about its function during intercourse? What about the lubricating function it provides?

Just because a human can survive without a certain body part does not make that part vestigial. Tonsils were thought to be vestigial by 'experts'. Given the same 'experts' have been very keen to remove the foreskin for over a hundred years, I doubt many of them would like to admit that they are ignorant of the human foreskin's function.

You can't replace a non-functional object with a functional one and have the analogy work.

If you replaced the word 'foreskin' with 'ear lobe' it would work. I like my earlobes but some people do not. Ear piercing and even ear lobe stretching are common practices, including with infants.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stretching_(body_piercing)
Nobody has ever (as a culture) promoted their complete removal but it could happen.

Tonsils were never thought to be vestigial as they have a place in the immune system but it was thought that removing them when they became inflamed was safer than not removing them. This debate still occurs to this day and has by no means been settled.

As to foreskins functions during intercourse...
We have this thing now called foreplay. It means lubrication is rarely an issue if you are doing it right.
 
Or, perhaps, because of the culture where you live you've been brainwashed into believing it's always best to keep the foreskin.
Please. The onus is on you to prove that a body part ought to be removed, not to the way around.

When I see more than 1 in 10 men washing their hands in public restrooms after urinating MAYBE, just maybe then I will actually believe that all you men with unenhanced penises are really properly keeping them clean.
:newlol Oh, and non-sequitur noted.

Nothing like a bit of self-righteous bigotry and racism to make you feel warm and tingly all over, eh?
:newlol Okay, what the hell? Loss Leader is the one who brought up his Jewish heritage into this. In fact, he has done so quite vocally, quite insistently, and had no qualms about using it to play the victim. That's what we are making fun of, not the fact that he's Jewish.

I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.
What a bunch of bizarre, outrageous claims. With of course not a single shred of evidence... as always.

Forcing your son to only listen to a certain type of music would be less cruel than permanently altering his body.
Now now, let's not go too far. I can think of few worse things than forcing hip/hop on your kid... ;)

The closest equivalent to infant circumcision would be a parent having the child's hair follicles killed off so the child could never grow hair on that part of their body again.
Great idea. After all, hair is not useful, and it would prevent the child from having to do basic hygiene such as washing, brushing and trimming the hair, and plus, we all know shaved heads on boys are all the rage (just look at Vin Diesel!), he'll never get laid otherwise. And what's more, it reduces the possibility of harm such as having your hair pulled in a fight, as well as the xx% probability of having lice.

You're a genius. :D People who cling to such vestiginal body parts such as hair (we invented hats, duh, we don't need hair anymore!) are just emotional. It's all clear now. Let us destroy those follicles. For Great Justice.

Er, wrong. I simply thought it best not to fan the flames of a particular fire that showed no signs of responding to rational argument.
Silence, you vile RACIST you.

Would you describe these women as attractive?
...Why in the seven hells would you ask a question like that? I mean... wow.

It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct? How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?
Are you implying that a few seconds of hygiene is too much effort? I don't understand the point of this question. Do you NOT take time to wash your private parts? o_O On second thought, please don't answer that, too much information.
 
You can't replace a non-functional object with a functional one and have the analogy work.

I would say the functionality of a little finger is less than that of the foreskin.

If you replaced the word 'foreskin' with 'ear lobe' it would work. I like my earlobes but some people do not. Ear piercing and even ear lobe stretching are common practices, including with infants.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stretching_(body_piercing)
Nobody has ever (as a culture) promoted their complete removal but it could happen.

Would you be ok with earlobe modification being performed on infants? How about tattoos? How about infant labia reduction? Where do you draw the line to what can be done to an infant?

Tonsils were never thought to be vestigial as they have a place in the immune system but it was thought that removing them when they became inflamed was safer than not removing them. This debate still occurs to this day and has by no means been settled.

So worse than vestigial - a body part that is actively harmful! How did that slip through the evolutionary net?

As to foreskins functions during intercourse...
We have this thing now called foreplay. It means lubrication is rarely an issue if you are doing it right.

So circumcised men and their partners do not use more artificial lubricant than uncircumcised men? What about during masturbation?

ETA: BTW, tattooing is illegal in the UK for anyone under the age of 18 or (maybe) 16 with parental consent.
 
Last edited:
I would say the functionality of a little finger is less than that of the foreskin.
Never typed, played an instrument, pitched a baseball, picked up an object?

Would you be ok with earlobe modification being performed on infants? How about tattoos? How about infant labia reduction? Where do you draw the line to what can be done to an infant?
Earlobes yes, tattoos yes, labia no.
The criteria is "Is this procedure medically beneficial or at least neutral?"
So long as it is either it's ok.
Circumcision is neutral btw.

So worse than vestigial - a body part that is actively harmful! How did that slip through the evolutionary net?
The body part is not actively harmful. It is beneficial so long as it remains uninfected (particularly by Streptococcal pharyngitis). But any body part which becomes infected can swell in a dangerous manner.

So circumcised men and their partners do not use more artificial lubricant than uncircumcised men? What about during masturbation?

No they don't.
In fact I have never heard of anyone using artificial lubrication for sexual activities that were not involving anal play or anal intercourse or latex (i.e. condoms). Does not mean it does not occur, but it is not that prevalent. In fact lubrication would decrease the friction sensations along the dorsal penile nerve at the base of the shaft which most people concentrate on during masterbation.

ETA: BTW, tattooing is illegal in the UK for anyone under the age of 18 or 16 with parental consent.
I and my siblings have all had tattoos long before 16, although in our cases it was against our parent's wishes.
 
Last edited:
"Circumcision is neutral btw."
Then lay back while we do it to you!

What a load of horsesh!t!


"I have never heard of anyone using artificial lubrication for sexual activities that were not involving anal play or anal intercourse or latex"
You really aughta try leaving your house from time to time.... What you've never heard of could fill an encyclopedia!
 
Never typed, played an instrument, pitched a baseball, picked up an object?

Most of which can be performed just as well without a little finger. Many instruments do not require a little finger.

Earlobes yes, tattoos yes, labia no.
The criteria is "Is this procedure medically beneficial or at least neutral?"
So long as it is either it's ok.
Circumcision is neutral btw.

What special functionality are you applying to the labia? Many women have their labia cosmetically altered. Why shouldn't parents who think their child would be better off with labia that look like mom's be justified in requesting the procedure?

What about permanent hair removal?

The body part is not actively harmful. It is beneficial so long as it remains uninfected (particularly by Streptococcal pharyngitis). But any body part which becomes infected can swell in a dangerous manner.

So tonsils should not be removed unless they are causing a problem. Very sensible.

No they don't.
In fact I have never heard of anyone using artificial lubrication for sexual activities that were not involving anal play or anal intercourse or latex (i.e. condoms). Does not mean it does not occur, but it is not that prevalent. In fact lubrication would decrease the friction sensations along the dorsal penile nerve at the base of the shaft which most people concentrate on during masterbation.

Any women care to comment?
 
"Circumcision is neutral btw."
Then lay back while we do it to you!

What a load of horsesh!t!

Already had it done.

It has already been demonstrated by dozens of links to medical viewpoints that circumcision is medically neutral. It is not beneficial enough to reccommend, nor is it detrimental enough to reccommend against. This is the standard that the AAP and AMA follow. That you choose to ignore them does not make those doctors views as you so eloquently put it "a load of horsesh!t!"

"I have never heard of anyone using artificial lubrication for sexual activities that were not involving anal play or anal intercourse or latex"
You really aughta try leaving your house from time to time.... What you've never heard of could fill an encyclopedia!

Nice use of selective quoting. But it is indeed the case that the use of artificial lubrication in standard intercourse (except when condoms are used which should be standard) is not common. Nor do most men feel the need to smear foreign substances on their penises when stroking them. They want more friction, not less.
 
So if modern Jews can go directly against commandment No. 56, why can't they go against commandment No. 17: To circumcise the male offspring? Some Jewish people already are.

Doesn't that fact blow Loss Leader's Jewish argument out of the water?


Actually, it makes my argument stronger. I have previously argued that banning circumcision might have a harmful effect on the Jewish religion. As you have so ably pointed out, some Jewish people are already abandoning many religious practices - they get tattoos, they don't keep kosher, they marry non-Jews, etc. This is not an argument for abandoning another Jewish practice, it is an argument for preserving as much of Judaism as possible.

The fact that some Jews don't follow some Jewish practices does not mean all Jews should be prohibitted from following a Jewish practice. Already our religion is being eroded by the sea of secularism. It does not follow that we should abandon our efforts to preserve it.


So why can't commandment No. 17 die out too? Or be changed into a symbolic ritual that does not involve removing the foreskin, as is used when a non-Jewish man who is already circumcised converts to Judaism?


Incidentally, we don't refer to our religious rules by number. We're Jews, not Ferengi.
 
"it is an argument for preserving as much of Judaism as possible."

So, we should also preserve flat-earth-ism? Maybe we should still 'burn witches'... Or treat peoples 'humours' when they don't feel well....

Cause if you're going to preserve one ignorant stupidstition, you aughta preserve them all.


"But it is indeed the case that the use of artificial lubrication in standard intercourse (except when condoms are used which should be standard) is not common. Nor do most men feel the need to smear foreign substances on their penises when stroking them. They want more friction, not less."

Source?!?!?!?!? (This aughta be good....)
 
Last edited:
It has already been demonstrated by dozens of links to medical viewpoints that circumcision is medically neutral. It is not beneficial enough to reccommend, nor is it detrimental enough to reccommend against. This is the standard that the AAP and AMA follow.

Actually, infant circumcision is a very rare exception for the modern medical profession who on the whole do not just do what parents want to have done to their child's body. It might have something to do with the fact that the medical profession promoted circumcision as a cure-all for so many years they find it hard to admit that it should never of been offered so widely in the first place.

The medical profession in the US created the demand for the procedure but it now refuses to bring circumcision back within therapeutic bounds, probably in part because of nutters like Dr. Schoen (the head of the 1989 AAP task force on circumcision), who has expressed in several medical journals that he thinks circumcision is such a great idea that ALL infants should be circumcised. Everywhere. That sounds like an objective view of the evidence:rolleyes:
 
Actually, it makes my argument stronger. I have previously argued that banning circumcision might have a harmful effect on the Jewish religion. As you have so ably pointed out, some Jewish people are already abandoning many religious practices - they get tattoos, they don't keep kosher, they marry non-Jews, etc. This is not an argument for abandoning another Jewish practice, it is an argument for preserving as much of Judaism as possible.

Only if you think that the changes that have already taken place have been detrimental. For example, do you think better integration into the community because of Jews marrying non-Jews is a good or bad thing?

The fact that some Jews don't follow some Jewish practices does not mean all Jews should be prohibitted from following a Jewish practice. Already our religion is being eroded by the sea of secularism. It does not follow that we should abandon our efforts to preserve it.

So do you consider yourself to be part of a hardcore Jewish minority, while other Jews, doing their best to integrate by altering their beliefs and practices to be more into line with 21st century thinking, are sell-outs?

Incidentally, we don't refer to our religious rules by number. We're Jews, not Ferengi.

Oh, ok.
 
So do you consider yourself to be part of a hardcore Jewish minority, while other Jews, doing their best to integrate by altering their beliefs and practices to be more into line with 21st century thinking, are sell-outs?


Your question contains too many unwarranted assumptions to be taken seriously.
 
Okay, what the hell? Loss Leader is the one who brought up his Jewish heritage into this. In fact, he has done so quite vocally, quite insistently, and had no qualms about using it to play the victim. That's what we are making fun of, not the fact that he's Jewish.
Get off it and stop whining. If you want to try making stupid, bigoted remarks, be a man and at least acknowledge what you're doing.

The fact you're "making fun", so-called, only destroys your own argument; you're making hysterical personal abuse, is what. It certainly isn't convincing to those of us who don't give much of a heck either way about male circumcision.
 
"to those of us who don't give much of a heck either way about male circumcision"
Then why are you in this thread at all?
 
... vestigial foreskin Americans will continue to, by some majority, to circumcise their male children.

...
I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive.
There's nothing irrational about carefully weighing the advantages to having one against the advantages of not having one, and coming to an evidence based decision that the have-nots are better off. And there is nothing irrational about coming to that same conclusion for your child who is in no state to make ANY decisions for themselves about anything (some would argue this holds true until they're about 35).
The is something profoundly irrational about ignoring the function of the foreskin and continuing to call it "vestigal", just so you can feel better about your own penis and justify what you've done to your own kids.

Exactly the same kind of irrationality that keeps Mr. Randi busy.

You talk as if you've "weighed the advantages", but you had your mind made up the first time you looked between your legs.
 
The is something profoundly irrational about ignoring the function of the foreskin and continuing to call it "vestigal", just so you can feel better about your own penis and justify what you've done to your own kids.

Exactly the same kind of irrationality that keeps Mr. Randi busy.

You talk as if you've "weighed the advantages", but you had your mind made up the first time you looked between your legs.

What function? It has no significant function to me since I am not a nudist in a temperate to arctic climate.
Thanks but I wear underpants. Don't need it.

Again for the bizillionth time in this thead somebody says "Only my viewpoint of what is sacred is right". Try having an open mind about penises. There's room for all kinds. Nobody is forcing you to get circumcised. If your family does not value the sleek aerodynamics of my jet age penis that is their own business. But my family does value streamlining.

By the same logic you apply to penises only your view of what is Art is right. Same must go for music? So whose records should we burn now?

Seriously though ...
The medical studies show that there may be some advantages to circumcision and that there may be some disadvantages to circumcision. None are equivocal enough to reccommend either course as a standard practice. That's why doctors just tell the facts both ways and let the parents make the decision. Obviously somebody weighed the evidence for me and circumcision won. In the same situation with me doing the weighing I see slightly more advantages medically, and tons more socially (which is much harder to quantify and depends a lot on the society you live in).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom