Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Would you describe these women as attractive?

It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct? How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?

I would argue it takes exactly the same amount as an uncut penis. Take some soap rub it up and down a couple of times and yer done. It's way less of a burden than cleaning your asscrack.

Anyway I'm going to stop listening to arguments from

a) People that have already been mutilated - phsycologically you need to believe you aren't mutilated. I get it, I would probably be in the same position.

b) Women who don't have the equipment. Sorry but I think it's pretty arrogant to think that your opinion matters.

As far as women complaining they wouldn't blow an uncircumcised guy it's pretty hard to tell the difference when erect and certainly I doubt you would notice if presented with it at that point.

Also I'm uncirced and I've lived in the US for my entire adult life and I've never had one woman complain about it. If anything they are excited to try something new. However, I am an outlier case anyway as I tend to associate with people that are a bit on the sexual fringe to begin with.

I asked a question way earlier in the thread that I still didn't get an answer to. Why do I keep hearing people talking about lotion at the same time as whacking off? My theory is that circ'd penises are a lot more broken than most people think. Not just sensitivity but actual function like easier whacking.

Comments? :p
 
I really have noticed in this thread that with very few exceptions, the people who are against circumcision are using a lot more rude or insulting language than they normally would. Why is that? What is it about this subject that makes them so emotional?

Simple we think that it's horrible mutilation (just as FGM is) and we feel strongly about it. To answer a question from earlier nobody touches my body for even $1M, especially not my gonads.

Also don't you think that it makes sense from an evolutionary biology perspective for men (and women) to be horribly sicked out by having their genitals messed with? Why do you think it hurts when you get kicked in the balls?
 
1/ Can I make a teensy weensy suggestion? People who do not agree with you are not, by definition, nuts. Some of them may indeed be nuts but calling them all nuts suggest a certain lack of, how can I put this discreetly, common sense on your part.

2/ I see you are a proponent of words can mean whatever you want them to mean. The word I used was defenceless and the word I meant to use was defenceless and the correct word is defenceless. See any number of dictionaries but let me pick say, the Oxford compact English Dictionary where it states 'defence n. (US defense)...'. In my language therefore I used the correct word. You can choose to use whatever language you want but please don't tell me how to speak my own language, thanks. Sorry, was that a tad patronising?

3/ As indicated in point 2/ I have not ever, do not now and never will need your permission for anything I do. Sorry, but you will simply have to live with it.
As you seem to need to resort to euphemism (see the Oxford compact English Dictionary for definition) feel free. What does the Free Dictionary online say about 'mutilation'. Amongst other things it defines 'mutilate' as '3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.'
I believe that is a perfect descritioon of mutilating the genitals of defenceless infants for non-medical reasons. QED.

4/ Yet more nutters! My my. That you feel the need to call those who disagree with you names I think says it all about the quality of your input and arguments.
...

1. I did not call people who disagree with me nuts. I called people who attrribute their impotency to missing their foreskin psychologically nuts.

2. Well pardon me. But here we say defense. Just like we also say color.

3. That is the same as clinic bombers who claim abortion is murder.

4. Again it wasn't people who disagree with me I called nuts. It was people who take a statistic and multiply it by 100 and claim their number is right. That's arch-propaganda if I ever saw it.

And the standard statement (including the AAP/AMA) most medical organizations make about circumcision is not against circumcision but is as follows:
Circumcision is not medically positive enough to reccommend it.
Circumcision is not medically negative enough to reccommend against it.
Parents should be informed of +/- and decide.
Pain killers should always be used for circumcision.
 
Simple we think that it's horrible mutilation (just as FGM is) and we feel strongly about it. To answer a question from earlier nobody touches my body for even $1M, especially not my gonads.

Also don't you think that it makes sense from an evolutionary biology perspective for men (and women) to be horribly sicked out by having their genitals messed with? Why do you think it hurts when you get kicked in the balls?

So you won't be getting a Prince Albert then? That's a shame.

Most people who are pro-circumcision think of the foreskin is a genetic throwback to penile sheathes animals that walk around on all fours use to keep the thing from dangling overmuch and keep it warm. Since we have underpants and walk upright this is why we don't have as much of a sheathe as in the past, and why eventually people will not be born with foreskins at all(or body hair for that matter). The reason by the way that the testicles (converse to the penis on most land mamals) do not normally retract into the body is to keep them from overheating and not having the ideal temperature for sperm production.
 
Last edited:
...That is for their parents' to decide...

No it is not.

I really have noticed in this thread that with very few exceptions, the people who are against circumcision are using a lot more rude or insulting language than they normally would. Why is that? What is it about this subject that makes them so emotional?

For me it's mainly the inflicting of pain and suffering on a helpless human for such pathetically small benefit. I struggle to understand a person who can witness a baby screaming in pain and distress needlessly for minutes and not want to stop it, or at least not repeat it.

I don't think parents who circumcise are monsters. I just think they have gotten used to the idea of this cruel and unusual punishment. They justify it by vastly playing up the tiny advantages and down-playing all the pain, suffering and complications.

Another reason it goes on is because the father must make sure his son looks like him. Why? My father felt no compulsion to inflict what his Grandmother did to him on me.

My final bug bare is the way pro-circ. people and physicians find infinite difference between any form of FGM and male circumcision. That is inconsistent and hypocritical. Both are cruel and unnecessary.

Just stop doing it! Your child's penis is perfect with a foreskin. He will love it the way it is and will not miss the pain and suffering of being circumcised.
 
Oh, you "thought it best not to fan the flames" and you did that by using wholesale bigoted statements about ethnic groups?

No, but I'm apparently not allowed to "personalize" this discussion, which forces me to speak in overly general terms about certain things.

Fascinating. This says a great deal about your integrity.

I'm certain you don't understand what I meant.
 
Both of you are from Canada which means you don't count. We're talking about Americans as in from the USA.

Oh right, only Americans count.. LOL :rolleyes:

And the statements I made are not BS as you so rudely put it.

Sorry, they were.

I am saying if you came from Canada to America many women would not find your penises attractive.

Again, BS. Canadians are very similar to Americans, at least northern Americans. It's not like you walk across that imaginary line and suddenly the circ rate jumps.

I'm pretty sure if I went to America (I have been there, you know) and hooked up with someone, she'd love it just as much as the other women did. What makes you think it would be so different in the USA?


Just as if I came from America to Canada many women there might not find my penis attractive if circumcision is not the norm there.

I'm sure only the truly shallow women on either side of the border would make such a judgement.

In short, just because you have had sex with someone does not change the fact that most (not all) women in the U.S.A (not Canada or Eritria or wherever you're from) don't like putting foreskins in their mouth.

LOL you're so clueless about this subject. It's not like a foreskin extends several inches beyond the glans.. at least, mine doesn't. When erect, it is a simple procedure to pull it back so it doesn't even show at all, if that's such a big deal. So far in my life, it's never come up, no pun intended.
 
Would you describe these women as attractive?

Some were, some weren't. Some were absolutely gorgeous. Not sure why you're asking.

It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct?

Yes, proper hygiene is important with or without a "fun flap."

How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?

I can't speak for anyone else, but about 15 seconds, including rinse. I'm only guessing though, for some strange reason I've never timed the procedure.
 
BTW, what's the Jewish obsession with ethnic purity? Why do you frown upon inter-faith marriages so much? Or is this something Jews don't like to talk about to non-Jews?


I'm not a rabbi so don't consider this an official answer but:

I don't think the desire of some Jews to have their children marry Jewish is much different in type or degree than the same desire among ethnic Italians, Greeks, Albanians, Koreans, etc. It tends to be law among my grandparents' generation, a strong tendency among my parents' and almost ignored among my own. I have more Jewish friends married to non-Jews than Jews.

I would probably ask for some evidence that there is a Jewish "obsession with ethnic purity" that differs significantly from any other immigrant group.

If such a tendency exists (and I do not agree it does), I would think that it is at least partly informed by a fear that our population is shrinking at too quick a rate. I don't know if you heard but we lost a large contingent a few years back.


*Obviously 21st century Jews try to put a PC spin on this inherent in-group/out-group view of humanity of the Jewish faith. It falls flat on its face when you read interviews of Israeli children about what they think of (and presumably have been taught about) "impure" Arabs. (See The God Delusion p.254-256).


This quote seems to conflate "Israeli children" with all Jews. The two groups are not the same. I, for exampe, have no ill will against Arabs and do not consider them "impure" in any way.

ETA: Found the answer myself.

No.56: Not to intermarry with gentiles.

So all those Jews who have are no longer Jewish! LOL!:D


From the evidence I have gathered, I would say that any religious prohibition is the least of any motivating factors. I know of no Jew who has refused to date non-Jews because of a religious prohibition. The social pressure to conform to parental expectation is much stronger. And even this, as I have said, is dying out.
 
a) People that have already been mutilated - phsycologically you need to believe you aren't mutilated. I get it, I would probably be in the same position.

What a great way to go through life without really getting to know both sides of an argument.

So you couldn't learn something about the dangers of drug addiction or the benefits of drug rehab from a former drug addict?
 
Most people who are pro-circumcision think of the foreskin is a genetic throwback to penile sheathes animals that walk around on all fours use...

I hope you're wrong about that, because that's the same kind of "reasoning" racists use to denegrate people with different skin tones and facial features.
 
I hope you're wrong about that, because that's the same kind of "reasoning" racists use to denegrate people with different skin tones and facial features.

No. It is not.

All animals that have penises have some form of penile sheathe. In primates it is less pronounced because we don't have our penises dangling in quite the same way as animals which remain more quadrupedal. Plus humans have been wearing clothing for a very long time. These things combined to necessitate a lesser version of the nearly fully retractable penis most mammals still utilize. In humans the foreskin is the penis sheathe.
http://books.google.com/books?id=A6...nts+of+the+Comparative+Anatomy+of+Vertebrates
p. 382
http://manstouch.com/mensunderwear/historyofmensunderwear.html
LOL
 
Last edited:
So far this thread has failed to show the harm that will befall circumcised infants when they reach adulthood.

What's wrong with the harm done during the procedure? Is that not enough harm? Is there something more shocking you'd prefer?

What is this elusive harm? I haven't seen it in my life.

It's a very subtle thing involving having slightly less enjoyment of sex, and being slightly less capable of bringing a woman to orgasm. But since it's the norm, most people do not know what they are missing.

It's also an ethical harm, having to live your life without a sensory organ, because someone else didn't have the presence of mind to give you any choice in the matter.

Unfortunately, few people seem to care about the ethical argument. Emotional appeals are what really sway opinions, not ethics.
 
No. It is not.

Yes. It is.

To say that an uncircumcised male somehow resembles a four-legged animal is no different than saying, for example, that African-Americans resemble Neanderthals because of their heavy eyebrow ridges and strong jaw bones.
 
I'm not trying to persuade you or any other religious Jewish (or Muslim for that matter) people reading. I already know you believe you are a member of God's chosen people and that I am mere gentile. It says so in your story book*.

I have been presenting logical, common sense arguments so that everyone else can see what a deluded individual you are. Congratulations, you have excelled.

Just like the faiths that practiced FGM, your group will be forced to comply when the law is changed to stop parents mutilating their male children.

BTW, what's the Jewish obsession with ethnic purity? Why do you frown upon inter-faith marriages so much? Or is this something Jews don't like to talk about to non-Jews?

*Obviously 21st century Jews try to put a PC spin on this inherent in-group/out-group view of humanity of the Jewish faith. It falls flat on its face when you read interviews of Israeli children about what they think of (and presumably have been taught about) "impure" Arabs. (See The God Delusion p.254-256).

ETA: Found the answer myself.

No.56: Not to intermarry with gentiles.

So all those Jews who have are no longer Jewish! LOL!:D


Whoa, Ivor the Engineer, hold up! That is entirely unfair.

I'm not Jewish so I probably shouldn't be talking but Jews are one of the most ethnically diverse populations on the planet with a very, very long history of intermarriage. I was just reading about it today on about.com, in fact.

They have a lot of information about intermarriage:

http://judaism.about.com/od/interfaithissu2/Interfaith_Issues.htm
http://judaism.about.com/od/interfaithfamilies/a/intermarr_jew_2.htm

and quite alot about intermarriage in the USA:

http://judaism.about.com/od/americanjewry/a/amjews2000.htm

which confirms what Loss Leader was saying and what's been my experience as well: more Jews in the US are married to non-Jews than to Jews! Enspecially among young men, who are more prone to marriage to shiksas than the other way around.
 
Fascinating discussion. I never realized just how much circumcision changes the nature of a penis,
http://www.foreskin.org/33-color.htm
or how animal looking human beings are, if they are not cut.

And even cooler, in koalas the foreskin contains naturally occurring bacteria that play an important role in fertilization.
http://www.uq.edu.au/news/?article=2193

I can understand how somebody who has never observed, much less interacted with, a natural human penis, would be shocked by the appearance.

Examination of a natural human penis makes it obvious, that like almost every other mammal on the planet, (except the platypus and the echidna), nature devised a protective covering of skin for that sensitive organ, only revealing the moist and delicate head, when aroused, and ready for business.
 
I would argue it takes exactly the same amount as an uncut penis. Take some soap rub it up and down a couple of times and yer done. It's way less of a burden than cleaning your asscrack.

Anyway I'm going to stop listening to arguments from

a) People that have already been mutilated - phsycologically you need to believe you aren't mutilated. I get it, I would probably be in the same position.

b) Women who don't have the equipment. Sorry but I think it's pretty arrogant to think that your opinion matters.

As far as women complaining they wouldn't blow an uncircumcised guy it's pretty hard to tell the difference when erect and certainly I doubt you would notice if presented with it at that point.

Also I'm uncirced and I've lived in the US for my entire adult life and I've never had one woman complain about it. If anything they are excited to try something new. However, I am an outlier case anyway as I tend to associate with people that are a bit on the sexual fringe to begin with.

I asked a question way earlier in the thread that I still didn't get an answer to. Why do I keep hearing people talking about lotion at the same time as whacking off? My theory is that circ'd penises are a lot more broken than most people think. Not just sensitivity but actual function like easier whacking.
Comments? :p
Maybe they just like to do it that way? I am circumcised, and don't need anything to help me have fun. You truly don't want to knwo how often that is, either.

To all those who claim sex is better uncut:
If it were any better than it is cut, I'd be a sex maniac and my wife would be bow legged and sore on the bottom all the time.
 
Whoa, Ivor the Engineer, hold up! That is entirely unfair.

I'm not Jewish so I probably shouldn't be talking but Jews are one of the most ethnically diverse populations on the planet with a very, very long history of intermarriage. I was just reading about it today on about.com, in fact.

They have a lot of information about intermarriage:

http://judaism.about.com/od/interfaithissu2/Interfaith_Issues.htm
http://judaism.about.com/od/interfaithfamilies/a/intermarr_jew_2.htm

and quite alot about intermarriage in the USA:

http://judaism.about.com/od/americanjewry/a/amjews2000.htm

which confirms what Loss Leader was saying and what's been my experience as well: more Jews in the US are married to non-Jews than to Jews! Enspecially among young men, who are more prone to marriage to shiksas than the other way around.

So if modern Jews can go directly against commandment No. 56, why can't they go against commandment No. 17: To circumcise the male offspring? Some Jewish people already are.

Doesn't that fact blow Loss Leader's Jewish argument out of the water?

As for Muslims, there is actually no requirement for them to circumcise their children at all in the Qur'an!

BTW, 'shiksas' is a derogatory Jewish term for non-Jewish females married to Jewish men;)
 
I'm not a rabbi so don't consider this an official answer but:

I don't think the desire of some Jews to have their children marry Jewish is much different in type or degree than the same desire among ethnic Italians, Greeks, Albanians, Koreans, etc. It tends to be law among my grandparents' generation, a strong tendency among my parents' and almost ignored among my own. I have more Jewish friends married to non-Jews than Jews.

I would probably ask for some evidence that there is a Jewish "obsession with ethnic purity" that differs significantly from any other immigrant group.

Yeah, the one thing humans excel at is prejudice. I agree with you that many immigrant groups behave in similar ways. In the UK this has been a resounding failure. Multiculturalism does not work.

If such a tendency exists (and I do not agree it does), I would think that it is at least partly informed by a fear that our population is shrinking at too quick a rate.

What's to fear? No ethnic group, unless small and isolated from others, can last for any significant length of time. Many have disappeared and it didn't hurt them a bit. I don't understand clinging to the past. Cultures mix and create new cultures.

I don't know if you heard but we lost a large contingent a few years back.

The same thing is happening in African now. Seems we haven't learned much in 60 years.

This quote seems to conflate "Israeli children" with all Jews. The two groups are not the same. I, for exampe, have no ill will against Arabs and do not consider them "impure" in any way.

Good.

From the evidence I have gathered, I would say that any religious prohibition is the least of any motivating factors. I know of no Jew who has refused to date non-Jews because of a religious prohibition. The social pressure to conform to parental expectation is much stronger. And even this, as I have said, is dying out.

So why can't commandment No. 17 die out too? Or be changed into a symbolic ritual that does not involve removing the foreskin, as is used when a non-Jewish man who is already circumcised converts to Judaism?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom