Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Just an anecdote: I'm not cut, and I've made out like a bandit. Seriously. I've had more sex with more women in more kinky ways than I can even summarize. Not one has ever complained about that little piece of skin, noone has denied me access to any orifice or refused me any favors.

Would you describe these women as attractive?

It's been stated in this thread that proper cleaning of an uncircumcised penis is essential, correct? How much time does one spend in the shower cleaning one's uncut penis? 30 seconds? 1 minute?
 
You are making up an image of what you would like your son's body to be like and imposing it on him ...



Yes, yes. I'm quite well aware that you disagree that circumcision is in my son's best interests and that you disagree about the law's view of when a parent can substitute his judgment for a child. It doesn't change a thing about my answer to your question, however.



What! After posting pages of how important circumcision is for a Jewish man, you are now saying that waking up with your foreskin restored would not be upsetting to you?


Yup. That's what I'm saying. Because the only way that could be true is if my wife thought it was in my best interests.


There is another way it could happen: Your wife could manipulate people around her into thinking it was what you would want, when it is only what she wants.


This is what my crim professor used to call "fighting the hypo." If this were the case, my wife would not have made a decision based on my best interests. She would be guilty of assault and I would be quite upset.

This is utterly irrelevant to the legal concepts surrounding circumcision of an infant, however, at least the way the law stands today.


You misunderstand the meaning of the word 'informed'. As far as your son is concerned you are little more 'informed' than a total stranger as to his 'wants'.


Oh, you are absolutely wrong. You are fundamentally and fatally mistaken. Not only that, you've mixed up "informed" and "consent." "Informed" means able to comprehend the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure. I am able to comprehend those risks and benefits. What you probably mean is that I am in no better position to substitute my judgment for my son than a stranger. Of course, this is absolutely ridiculous.

I substitute my judgment for his regarding what he should wear, what he should eat, when he should go to sleep, what he should watch on tv, what rooms he should go in and everything else. I'm his parent and there is noone on the planet other than his parents who are presumed to be more knowledgeable about what is best for him. Or who are presumed to care more.

Otherwise, what is to stop a court from deciding that Angelina Jolie would raise my son better than I could and just giving her custody?

What you've done is create an ends-oriented analysis. You've started with the conclusion you'd like to see and then created a rule that you think gets you to that conclusion. But starting from the rule quickly reveals it to be utterly and unworkably moronic.


Asking somebody what someone they have know for many years would want is reasonable. They have a model of that person in their brain based on experience interacting with them.


Nope, that's not the rule. It's not just based on what the person would want, it's based on whether the substituted decision-maker is likely to care about the individual. My wife can substitute her judgment for mine when I'm incapacitated not because she has known me for years but just because she's my wife. If we were married ten minutes, she'd have the same ability as if we were married ten years. If we'd never met before our wedding night and I fell into a coma ten minutes after saying "I do," she wouldn have the same ability.

And parents of a ten-minute old infant have the same abilities as well.


You have no idea what your son will want. All you know is what you want your son to want. You appear to fool yourself into thinking you have abilities you do not.


What I want for my son is what he wants, full stop.
 
Last edited:
In short, just because you have had sex with someone does not change the fact that most (not all) women in the U.S.A (not Canada or Eritria or wherever you're from) don't like putting foreskins in their mouth.

Have you ever seen an erect uncircumcised penis? (wiki has a page on everything:))

Not a lot of difference between the two, is there?

The way you post reads you'd think the foreskin was a foot long:rolleyes:
 
Yup. That's what I'm saying. Because the only way that could be true is if my wife thought it was in my best interests.

This is what my crim professor used to call "fighting the hypo." If this were the case, my wife would not have made a decision based on my best interests. She would be guilty of assault and I would be quite upset.

This is utterly irrelevant to the legal concepts surrounding circumcision of an infant, however, at least the way the law stands today.

It is highly relevant. It is possibly one of the reasons the law will be changed. Because of deluded people like yourself. No doubt the Jewish and Muslim lobby groups will whine they're being persecuted.

Oh, you are absolutely wrong. You are fundamentally and fatally mistaken. Not only that, you've mixed up "informed" and "consent." "Informed" means able to comprehend the risks and benefits of the proposed procedure. I am able to comprehend those risks and benefits. What you probably mean is that I am in no better position to substitute my judgment for my son than a stranger. Of course, this is absolutely ridiculous.

Informed:

Possessing, displaying, or based on reliable information: informed sources; an informed opinion.

You are basing your decision on unreliable information. It is unreliable because it is incomplete. It is incomplete because you cannot know what your son's wants are. You use what you want to fill in the missing information and delude yourself that you are 'informed'.

I substitute my judgment for his regarding what he should wear, what he should eat, when he should go to sleep, what he should watch on tv, what rooms he should go in and everything else. I'm his parent and there is noone on the planet other than his parents who are presumed to be more knowledgeable about what is best for him. Or who are presumed to care more.

As a parent you are responsible for his well-being. Your rights to choose for him only go as far as to what does not harm him. All those things you have listed could be reason to remove him from your custody if choices you have made are considered to have caused him significant harm.

By definition, surgical procedures harm people. You cannot choose to have your son's appendix or tonsils removed if it is not medically required. In the not too distant future you will not be able to remove his foreskin for aesthetic or religious reasons either.

Otherwise, what is to stop a court from deciding that Angelina Jolie would raise my son better than I could and just giving her custody?

Because there is some common sense left in the law? But this does happen: Children are removed from their parents custody if they are not considered capable of looking after the child. If Angelina Jolie decided to become a foster parent there is every chance she could be considered better for your son than you.

What you've done is create an ends-oriented analysis. You've started with the conclusion you'd like to see and then created a rule that you think gets you to that conclusion. But starting from the rule quickly reveals it to be utterly and unworkably moronic.

No, what I've done is present logical arguments that you cannot answer and so you are running scared for the cover of the law that protects your religious "rights". Those rights will be curtailed. Religion is dying out, didn't you get the memo?

Perhaps it will be the thing that gets Jews standing shoulder to shoulder with Muslims, whining in unison?

Nope, that's not the rule. It's not just based on what the person would want, it's based on whether the substituted decision-maker is likely to care about the individual. My wife can substitute her judgment for mine when I'm incapacitated not because she has known me for years but just because she's my wife. If we were married ten minutes, she'd have the same ability as if we were married ten years. If we'd never met before our wedding night and I fell into a coma ten minutes after saying "I do," she wouldn have the same ability.

Hmmm. I think your parents or siblings may have some weight in the decision as to what happens to you if a person you've only know for 10-minutes is your legal next-of kin. If not it would make the law look really dumb. Something you appear to revel in.

And parents of a ten-minute old infant have the same abilities as well.

No, they don't. Nobody does. Not even your imaginary God. It gave us free-will, remember?

What I want for my son is what he wants, full stop.

Only in your deluded fantasy world.
 
Ivor said:
No doubt the Jewish and Muslim lobby groups will whine they're being persecuted.

And Christian. It's very much a religious thing to a lot of them, too.
 
Informed:

Possessing, displaying, or based on reliable information: informed sources; an informed opinion.

You are basing your decision on unreliable information. It is unreliable because it is incomplete. It is incomplete because you cannot know what your son's wants are. You use what you want to fill in the missing information and delude yourself that you are 'informed'.


No, you're completely wrong here. And it's not just a matter of opinion; you're wrong on the very definition of the word.

The informed part of "informed consent" has only to do with understanding the risks and benefits of the procedure. It has nothing to do with knowing the subject person's desires. That can be an important part of the equation, but it's not what is meant by "informed." Since I have (thanks to this thread) read abundant medical evidence regarding the risks and benefits of circumcision, I am "informed." It's just that simple. There's no argument; you confused "informed" and "consent."


Hmmm. I think your parents or siblings may have some weight in the decision as to what happens to you if a person you've only know for 10-minutes is your legal next-of kin.


Nope. What you think is completely wrong. Sorry to have to tell you.


Only in your deluded fantasy world.


Considering the fact that you had a conversation in this very thread about your desire to improve your methods of persuasion, it's an odd choice to call me deluded. I can assure you that it does nothing to persuade me to adopt your point of view. In fact, it persuades me to want to disagree with you more.
 
In short, just because you have had sex with someone does not change the fact that most (not all) women in the U.S.A (not Canada or Eritria or wherever you're from) don't like putting foreskins in their mouth.

Newsflash dude! When you give oral sex to an inatact guy, you don't have a foreskin in your mouth, at all! Jeez!
It's normally more pleausurable (erm read quicker;)) to DTD down there on an intact guy! In my (albiet limited) experience of circ'd men, it took waaaaaaaay longer, and made me loathe to attempt;)
 
And Christian. It's very much a religious thing to a lot of them, too.

They obviously dismiss what Paul had to say about circumcision:

1 Corinthians 7:18-19

Was a man already circumcised when he was called? He should not become uncircumcised. Was a man uncircumcised when he was called? He should not be circumcised. Circumcision is nothing and uncircumcision is nothing. Keeping God's commands is what counts.

Galatians 5:2

Mark my words! I, Paul, tell you that if you let yourselves be circumcised, Christ will be of no value to you at all.

ETA: From this site.
 
Newsflash dude! When you give oral sex to an inatact guy, you don't have a foreskin in your mouth, at all! Jeez!
It's normally more pleausurable (erm read quicker;)) to DTD down there on an intact guy! In my (albiet limited) experience of circ'd men, it took waaaaaaaay longer, and made me loathe to attempt;)

While I don't feel qualified to quantify your methods of oral sex having never seen you perform it on someone...

The standard technique is to place most or all of the penis in one's mouth. This would mean that the foreskin, along with the glans and most of the shaft, is in one's mouth. This stimulates primarily the dorsal penile nerve (which is along the bottom side of the shaft) as the oral sex giver is moving the lips up and down the length of the shaft. Additionally the tongue of the oral sex giver is massaging the same dorsal nerve.
 
While I don't feel qualified to quantify your methods of oral sex having never seen you perform it on someone...

The standard technique is to place most or all of the penis in one's mouth. This would mean that the foreskin, along with the glans and most of the shaft, is in one's mouth. This stimulates primarily the dorsal penile nerve (which is along the bottom side of the shaft) as the oral sex giver is moving the lips up and down the length of the shaft. Additionally the tongue of the oral sex giver is massaging the same dorsal nerve.

When an intact penis is erect, it looks pretty much like a circ'd one tbh. The foreskin rolls back. During oral sex, you do not have a foreskin in your mouth, really, you don't! I don't really know how to explain...your descriptions seems quite good:)
 
Correct ;)


Morrigan, Osmosis - this commentary and others like it skirt very close to racial remarks aimed at specific members. I strongly advise that you refrain from making this - and similar comments - of this type. Only generalized comments are permissible under the membership agreement.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer

Quoting to get up to the most recent page.
 
Considering the fact that you had a conversation in this very thread about your desire to improve your methods of persuasion, it's an odd choice to call me deluded. I can assure you that it does nothing to persuade me to adopt your point of view. In fact, it persuades me to want to disagree with you more.

I'm not trying to persuade you or any other religious Jewish (or Muslim for that matter) people reading. I already know you believe you are a member of God's chosen people and that I am mere gentile. It says so in your story book*.

I have been presenting logical, common sense arguments so that everyone else can see what a deluded individual you are. Congratulations, you have excelled.

Just like the faiths that practiced FGM, your group will be forced to comply when the law is changed to stop parents mutilating their male children.

BTW, what's the Jewish obsession with ethnic purity? Why do you frown upon inter-faith marriages so much? Or is this something Jews don't like to talk about to non-Jews?

*Obviously 21st century Jews try to put a PC spin on this inherent in-group/out-group view of humanity of the Jewish faith. It falls flat on its face when you read interviews of Israeli children about what they think of (and presumably have been taught about) "impure" Arabs. (See The God Delusion p.254-256).

ETA: Found the answer myself.

No.56: Not to intermarry with gentiles.

So all those Jews who have are no longer Jewish! LOL!:D
 
Last edited:
Careful there. Your arguments are starting to sound like those used by people who protest outside Planned Parenthood.

In order to make such statements you need to provide irrefutable evidence that circumcision harms rather than benefits the infant.
There is none.

Your arguments are starting to sound like those people who protest that they must be right simply because they say so.

As an example, you make the claim not only do I have to satisfy a bogus requirement that you have erected but, having made the claim, you fail to provide a single shred of evidence to support it, whereas, if you had read the thread you would have seen the many links from reputable medical associations that supports my view that the mutilation is not routinely necessary. many people have posted examples of children dying and being damaged by routine medical mutilation for non-medical reasons. You may choose to interpret posting evidence as a lack of evidence but I would suggest that most rational people would not. The other problem you have in making your invalid comparison is that I am not against adults doing what they want to their own bodies. If they wish to mutilate their own genitals when they are presented with the facts and are harming no-one else I have no objection to them doing so.

Let me point you to some sites to save you having to look back up the thread: -
http://www.canada.com/topics/bodyan...=e6babb2a-2a92-4c8b-bcd2-8278ec64f880&k=89599
http://www.cirp.org/news/dailymail08-16-01/

See this
'. I was circumcised as a baby but now I want to re-grow my foreskin. Is this possible?

A. You are not alone in wanting the circumcision reversed. Requests for foreskin reconstruction, as it is called, is not at all uncommon, especially in America where very many more babies are circumcised than in the UK. There are two main reasons for men to request foreskin reconstruction, one physical the other psychological. On the physical side, following circumcision the glans of the penis may become less sensitive and a man may want foreskin reconstruction to reverse this. Although increased sensitivity of the glans has been reported following foreskin reconstruction, I am not at all sure whether this occurs in all men who have this procedure. On the psychological front, some men who were circumcised when infants feel hey were mutilated without their consent and develop a feelings of resentment and frustration. They feel their body is incomplete and that their penis may not be so attractive to a partner. They may become fixated on such feelings, which become intrusive on their daily life.'
from http://www.malehealth.co.uk/userpage1.cfm?item_id=188

Note that there are two main reasons cited for having foreskin reconstruction psychological and physical. The psychological includes '... men who felt they were 'mutilated without their consent...'

As a proponent of mutilating of defenceless infants genitals what do you have to say to those men when they could have been left to make their own choice when they grew up?
 
Last edited:
It's not quite the same thing but some parents are choosing to put their children in helments for up to a year to correct a flattening or other deformation of the skull. I assume the helmets are hot and uncomfortable and I know from talking to parents that children are treated differently by adults when wearing them. And yet some parents choose to inflict this on their children despite the fact that the children have no choice and some ... don't chose to do so.

And the world keeps turning.





You're confusing two different concepts: "without consent" and "without the capacity to consent". "Without consent" implies that the procedure is against a person's will. Remember, children circumcised by their parents are not being cut without their consent. They are not being cut against their will. They are being circumcised because they lack the capacity to consent and their parents have substituted their judgment for the infants. The infants cannot consent or refuse; they are incapable of doing so.

I'm not arguing whether circumcision is right or wrong. I'm arguing that you are committing the fallacy of equivocation. Plenty of anti-circ people on this board have managed to defend their position quite well without confusing failure to consent with failure to be able to consent.





Sure, let me be the first. I, Loss Leader, am a proponent of allowing Jews (including myself) to circumcise their children. I hearby state unequivocally that should I ever be in a position where I am unable to give or withhold informed consent for a medical procedure, I would like my wife to substitute her judgment as to what is in my best interests and exercise my consent on my behalf including but not limited to mutilating my genitals.

Fair enough?





It tells me that you misunderstand some basic legal concepts underpinning our society's entire concept of the self, informed consent and substituted judgment.

I am afraid that you are confused on a number of points.

1/ You confuse the need to correct deformities for valid medical reasons with causing deformites for no valid medical reasons.

2/ You are confused in claiming that I do not know the difference between the consent capability of the infant and the ability of parents to give their consent. The fact remains and has not been contradicted that the parents feel the need to mutilate their child and the child is defenceless in that action. In the case of non-medically indicated mutilation the procedure is carried out for the cosmetic reasons of the parents. The psychlogical and physical harm this does is indicated in the following: -
'There are two main reasons for men to request foreskin reconstruction, one physical the other psychological. On the physical side, following circumcision the glans of the penis may become less sensitive and a man may want foreskin reconstruction to reverse this. Although increased sensitivity of the glans has been reported following foreskin reconstruction, I am not at all sure whether this occurs in all men who have this procedure. On the psychological front, some men who were circumcised when infants feel hey were mutilated without their consent and develop a feelings of resentment and frustration. They feel their body is incomplete and that their penis may not be so attractive to a partner. They may become fixated on such feelings, which become intrusive on their daily life.' from http://www.malehealth.co.uk/userpage1.cfm?item_id=188

The parents have refused to allow the child to reach maturity and give informed consent.

3/You are confused in thinking that I am against adults mutilating their own genitals after they have been advised of the facts. I am not. If a person, having grown up in whatever faith or non-faith they wish, is given all the facts and decides of their own free will to mutilate their own genitals and in doing so harms no-one else I am completely happy with them doing so.

What is completely wrong is choosing to mutilate the genitals of those who cannot defend themselves and refusing them the chance to choose of their own free will to do it when they are adults and likewise have received all the facts. That is the crime.

4/ You are confused in claiming that I am not aware of the difference between informed consent and substituted judgement. As explained to you I am against people forcing their desire to mutilate the genitals of defenceless infants onto he said defenceless infants and refusing them the opportunity to grow up and carry out the procedure on their own adult bodies.

People who mutilate the defenceless are cowards.
 
Your arguments are starting to sound like those people who protest that they must be right simply because they say so.

As an example, you make the claim not only do I have to satisfy a bogus requirement that you have erected but, having made the claim, you fail to provide a single shred of evidence to support it, whereas, if you had read the thread you would have seen the many links from reputable medical associations that supports my view that the mutilation is not routinely necessary. many people have posted examples of children dying and being damaged by routine medical mutilation for non-medical reasons. You may choose to interpret posting evidence as a lack of evidence but I would suggest that most rational people would not. The other problem you have in making your invalid comparison is that I am not against adults doing what they want to their own bodies. If they wish to mutilate their own genitals when they are presented with the facts and are harming no-one else I have no objection to them doing so.

Let me point you to some sites to save you having to look back up the thread: -
http://www.canada.com/topics/bodyan...=e6babb2a-2a92-4c8b-bcd2-8278ec64f880&k=89599
http://www.cirp.org/news/dailymail08-16-01/

See this
'. I was circumcised as a baby but now I want to re-grow my foreskin. Is this possible?

A. You are not alone in wanting the circumcision reversed. Requests for foreskin reconstruction, as it is called, is not at all uncommon, especially in America where very many more babies are circumcised than in the UK. There are two main reasons for men to request foreskin reconstruction, one physical the other psychological. On the physical side, following circumcision the glans of the penis may become less sensitive and a man may want foreskin reconstruction to reverse this. Although increased sensitivity of the glans has been reported following foreskin reconstruction, I am not at all sure whether this occurs in all men who have this procedure. On the psychological front, some men who were circumcised when infants feel hey were mutilated without their consent and develop a feelings of resentment and frustration. They feel their body is incomplete and that their penis may not be so attractive to a partner. They may become fixated on such feelings, which become intrusive on their daily life.'
from http://www.malehealth.co.uk/userpage1.cfm?item_id=188

Note that there are two main reasons cited for having foreskin reconstruction psychological and physical. The psychological includes '... men who felt they were 'mutilated without their consent...'

As a proponent of mutilating of defenceless infants genitals what do you have to say to those men when they could have been left to make their own choice when they grew up?

First off people who "miss" foreskins they never had since neonatality are nuts. Like the movie Psycho nuts. Mostly they are just trying to find something to blame for sexual malfunctions with other causes (like because they're 60 and not supposed to have a functioning penis anymore). Same is true for people who become mass murderers later in life based on reasons like:
My mother didn't nurse me enough
I should have been a woman
I should have been a man
I got teased as a kid

Secondly the word is defenseless. A form of the word defense.

Thirdly the proper word is not "mutilating" but enhancing or if you are anti-circumcision you may be permitted to use altering instead. Your (and others) use of the word is a fairly transparent attempt to use emotions in this debate but it fails.

Fourthly the rate of surgical complications with circumcision is less than most procedures. 0.2-0.6% according to the AMA. Only if you believe tripe like "Mothers against circumcision" websites who say astounding numbers like 55% would complications be an issue... but if you believe them you are as nutters as they are. I think I will trust an impartial organization of doctors that is neither for nor against circumcision over propaganda websites.

http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html
 
First off people who "miss" foreskins they never had since neonatality are nuts. Like the movie Psycho nuts. Mostly they are just trying to find something to blame for sexual malfunctions with other causes (like because they're 60 and not supposed to have a functioning penis anymore). Same is true for people who become mass murderers later in life based on reasons like:
My mother didn't nurse me enough
I should have been a woman
I should have been a man
I got teased as a kid

Secondly the word is defenseless. A form of the word defense.

Thirdly the proper word is not "mutilating" but enhancing or if you are anti-circumcision you may be permitted to use altering instead. Your (and others) use of the word is a fairly transparent attempt to use emotions in this debate but it fails.

Fourthly the rate of surgical complications with circumcision is less than most procedures. 0.2-0.6% according to the AMA. Only if you believe tripe like "Mothers against circumcision" websites who say astounding numbers like 55% would complications be an issue... but if you believe them you are as nutters as they are. I think I will trust an impartial organization of doctors that is neither for nor against circumcision over propaganda websites.

http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html

Yet more tripe from BlackKat. You should start your own website with the nonsense you offer as evidence to support circumcision.

The best estimate for complications is 2-10%. Most scientific papers and EBM sites quote the lower 2% figure. The benefit is a ~1% absolute risk reduction of UTI, which do not occur in 98%+ of uncircumcised infants.

ETA: The link BlackKat provided gives the UTI incidence of 0.4% to 1% giving an NNT of 100 to 200. More importantly, even taking the complication rate quoted (0.2% to 0.6%) would mean about as many complications occur as UTI's prevented.
 
Last edited:
First off people who "miss" foreskins they never had since neonatality are nuts. Like the movie Psycho nuts. Mostly they are just trying to find something to blame for sexual malfunctions with other causes (like because they're 60 and not supposed to have a functioning penis anymore). Same is true for people who become mass murderers later in life based on reasons like:
My mother didn't nurse me enough
I should have been a woman
I should have been a man
I got teased as a kid

Secondly the word is defenseless. A form of the word defense.

Thirdly the proper word is not "mutilating" but enhancing or if you are anti-circumcision you may be permitted to use altering instead. Your (and others) use of the word is a fairly transparent attempt to use emotions in this debate but it fails.

Fourthly the rate of surgical complications with circumcision is less than most procedures. 0.2-0.6% according to the AMA. Only if you believe tripe like "Mothers against circumcision" websites who say astounding numbers like 55% would complications be an issue... but if you believe them you are as nutters as they are. I think I will trust an impartial organization of doctors that is neither for nor against circumcision over propaganda websites.

http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/13585.html

1/ Can I make a teensy weensy suggestion? People who do not agree with you are not, by definition, nuts. Some of them may indeed be nuts but calling them all nuts suggest a certain lack of, how can I put this discreetly, common sense on your part.

2/ I see you are a proponent of words can mean whatever you want them to mean. The word I used was defenceless and the word I meant to use was defenceless and the correct word is defenceless. See any number of dictionaries but let me pick say, the Oxford compact English Dictionary where it states 'defence n. (US defense)...'. In my language therefore I used the correct word. You can choose to use whatever language you want but please don't tell me how to speak my own language, thanks. Sorry, was that a tad patronising?

3/ As indicated in point 2/ I have not ever, do not now and never will need your permission for anything I do. Sorry, but you will simply have to live with it.
As you seem to need to resort to euphemism (see the Oxford compact English Dictionary for definition) feel free. What does the Free Dictionary online say about 'mutilation'. Amongst other things it defines 'mutilate' as '3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.'
I believe that is a perfect descritioon of mutilating the genitals of defenceless infants for non-medical reasons. QED.

4/ Yet more nutters! My my. That you feel the need to call those who disagree with you names I think says it all about the quality of your input and arguments.

See http://www.circumcision.org/position.htm for some august medical opinions
'003 British Medical Association
“The BMA does not believe that parental preference alone constitutes sufficient grounds for performing a surgical procedure on a child unable to express his own view. . . . Parental preference must be weighed in terms of the child's interests. . . . The BMA considers that the evidence concerning health benefit from non-therapeutic circumcision is insufficient for this alone to be a justification for doing it. . . . Some doctors may wish to not perform circumcisions for reasons of conscience. Doctors are under no obligation to comply with a request to circumcise a child.”

2002 Royal Australasian College of Physicians

“After extensive review of the literature the RACP reaffirms that there is no medical indication for routine male circumcision. The possibility that routine circumcision may contravene human rights has been raised because circumcision is performed on a minor and is without proven medical benefit. . . . Review of the literature in relation to risks and benefits shows there is no evidence of benefit outweighing harm for circumcision as a routine procedure.”

2002 Canadian Paediatric Society (reaffirmed 1996 position)
“Circumcision of newborns should not be routinely performed.”

2000 American Medical Association

“The AMA supports the general principles of the 1999 Circumcision Policy Statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics.”

1999 American Academy of Pediatrics

“Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision.”

1996 Australian College of Paediatrics
“The Australasian Association of Paediatric Surgeons has informed the College that ‘neonatal male circumcision has no medical indication. It is a traumatic procedure performed without anaesthesia to remove a normal functional and protective prepuce [foreskin].’ ”

1996 Australasian Association of Paediatric Surgeons
“We do not support the removal of a normal part of the body, unless there are definite indications to justify the complications and risks which may arise. In particular, we are opposed to male children being subjected to a procedure, which had they been old enough to consider the advantages and disadvantages, may well have opted to reject the operation and retain their prepuce [foreskin]....The 1989 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child states that ‘State parties should take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children.’ ”
 
Yet more tripe from BlackKat. You should start your own website with the nonsense you offer as evidence to support circumcision.

The best estimate for complications is 2-10%. Most scientific papers and EBM sites quote the lower 2% figure. The benefit is a 1% absolute risk reduction of UTI, which do not occur in 98%+ of uncircumcised infants.


I linked the AMA site which has the 0.2-0.6%. Maybe their numbers refer to US only? Maybe not.

But anyhow no need to be rude. I've never tried to offer "evidence to support circumcision" only evidence to support the option of circumcision. I perfectly understand that there are negative AND positive effects to circumcision. But I support the parents' right to make the final decision after being informed of the benefits and risks by an impartial healthcare worker. And that deciding for cosmetic and sociocultural reasons is not wrong as those are valid reasons.

I myself have weighed the positive and negative effects of circumcision. I feel that living in the country I live in being circumcised is far more positive than negative. This may not hold true for people who live in other places or cultures. That is for their parents' to decide.

Maybe I do not value body integrity as much as most people... I do come from a subculture where tatttoos, piercings, hair dying, etc are all considered almost mandatory. And I would gladly circumcise any son of mine as I am ecstatic that I was circumcised as an infant. But by the statements people make here almost every US parent is some sort of sadomasichistic monster. They are not. They just want their child's penis to be right and to them right=circumcised.

I really have noticed in this thread that with very few exceptions, the people who are against circumcision are using a lot more rude or insulting language than they normally would. Why is that? What is it about this subject that makes them so emotional?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom