Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

The point of the asking the questions was to find out if you put a positive value on your body integrity. You do and it is pretty high.

Now explain how you managed to put a negative value on your child's healthy, functional foreskin when you put a positive value on your own body integrity.

The problem with this retort to my answers is this:

I don't value foreskin.

I value the integrity of my son's little finger, as, apart from some sort of birth defect, all his classmates should have intact little fingers.

On the contrary, at least 76% of his classmates (probably more given my local) will be circumcised. He'll fit right in with the rest of the brain-washed school children!
 
The problem with this retort to my answers is this:

I don't value foreskin.

No, you actually put a negative value on this particular piece of normal, healthy and functional body tissue, while at the same time put a positive value on other normal body parts. That's why you're a hypocrite.

I value the integrity of my son's little finger, as, apart from some sort of birth defect, all his classmates should have intact little fingers.

Apart from some sort of birth defect, all his classmates should have intact foreskins.

On the contrary, at least 76% of his classmates (probably more given my local) will be circumcised. He'll fit right in with the rest of the brain-washed school children!

What happens to the other 24%? Are they shunned? Have stones thrown at them? Have burning phalluses left on their front lawn?

Tell me what awful acts of discrimination a boy or man will face if he is not circumcised in your neck of the woods.
 
No, you actually put a negative value on this particular piece of normal, healthy and functional body tissue, while at the same time put a positive value on other normal body parts. That's why you're a hypocrite.



Apart from some sort of birth defect, all his classmates should have intact foreskins.



What happens to the other 24%? Are they shunned? Have stones thrown at them? Have burning phalluses left on their front lawn?

Tell me what awful acts of discrimination a boy or man will face if he is not circumcised in your neck of the woods.

I fail to see any hypocrisy. That's like saying if you like one movie you must like ALL movies.

I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.

Having never taken a communal shower with other men I'm not sure what sort of teasing may occur. But I'm sure someone else here who went to middle schools that had such things in their gym locker rooms could contribute.

I would be interested to learn (and not surprised to find it true) if Americans (due to higher rates of circumcision) are more likely to engage in oral and anal sex than their largely uncircumcised counterparts in other countries. A couple of the studies already linked here have hinted at this but since this has not been the focus of the study not really extrapolated on.
 
...snip...

I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.


...snip..

Absolute rubbish - I've had plenty of sex in the USA and having a foreskin never seemed to a hindrance.
 
No, you actually put a negative value on this particular piece of normal, healthy and functional body tissue, while at the same time put a positive value on other normal body parts. That's why you're a hypocrite.


I've answered your questions. If you don't mind, I'd like your answer to the question I asked you:

Oh my god - I've been brainwashed into believing that it is good to have my eyes cut out at birth. How could I be so blind to my brainwashing?


Are you implying, with your above statement, foreskin actually has as much use as the human eye in the world in which we live?



How about this..... Are your hands more important to your career than your foreskin?

If you answer yes, are you being a hypocrite?
 
Are you implying, with your above statement, foreskin actually has as much use as the human eye in the world in which we live?

No. Neither do my little fingers, sense of smell, one of my kidneys, toes, hair, etc.

How about this..... Are your hands more important to your career than your foreskin?

Yes.

If you answer yes, are you being a hypocrite?

No.

I place a positive value on ALL my body parts. That is not to say I place the SAME value on them. E.g., I'd rather loose my little finger to frost-bite than my entire hand.

You have placed a negative value on one particular body part and a positive on the rest. Why did you dislike that part of your son? Why are your aesthetic preferences so important for him? Will you be insisting he likes the same music as you too?
 
I fail to see any hypocrisy. That's like saying if you like one movie you must like ALL movies.

The hypocrisy comes from hacking off the foreskin but not other normal pieces you don't like. E.g., A woman's labia can be pretty ugly to some people. I don't see you arguing for them to be trimmed to your idea of perfection.
 
You have placed a negative value on one particular body part and a positive on the rest. Why did you dislike that part of your son? Why are your aesthetic preferences so important for him? Will you be insisting he likes the same music as you too

You don't think that that is a ridiculous conclusion?

Do you shave? Do you get haircuts?

Please don't tell me you place a negative value on facial hair. Please don't tell me you don't value long, natural, uncut hair on the top of your head.

(The above is just as extreme as asking me the music question.)
 
You are confusing the law with common sense. You are circumcising your children as infants because you have such little faith in your ability to convince them to have it performed when they would be old enough to give informed consent.


No, I was answering E.J. Armstrong. He was confusing "lack of consent" with "lack of capacity." You and I are not. We disagree about what can and should be done to a child during his incompetency, but we agree on the definitions of the concepts.


You are answering a different question...

The question you should be answering is: Would you mind if your wife consented on your behalf for unnecessary cosmetic surgery to be performed on you?


No, I was answering E.J.A.'s question. But I'll answer yours as well. Yours is actually easier than his because it doesn't contain nearly as much emotional language. Here goes:

Should I, Loss Leader, ever become incapacitated and incapable of giving or withholding informed consent, I would like my wife to substitute her judgment as to what is in my best interests and exercise my consent on my behalf including but not limited to unnecessary cosmetic surgery.

Good enough?


That makes it all ok then:rolleyes:


Excellent. I'm glad we've wrapped this up. :)
 
You don't think that that is a ridiculous conclusion?

Forcing your son to only listen to a certain type of music would be less cruel than permanently altering his body.

Do you shave? Do you get haircuts?

Yes and Yes.

Please don't tell me you place a negative value on facial hair. Please don't tell me you don't value long, natural, uncut hair on the top of your head.

(The above is just as extreme as asking me the music question.)

You haven't seen what I've got under that hat:D

They are my aesthetic preferences for my body. If at some point I wish to grow a beard or long hair I can. They are reversible choices. Also, hair is dead with no nerve endings and foreskin has both sensory and sexual functions (not that I expect you to know this).

The closest equivalent to infant circumcision would be a parent having the child's hair follicles killed off so the child could never grow hair on that part of their body again.
 
Should I, Loss Leader, ever become incapacitated and incapable of giving or withholding informed consent, I would like my wife to substitute her judgment as to what is in my best interests and exercise my consent on my behalf including but not limited to unnecessary cosmetic surgery.

Good enough?

No. That is not an answer to the question I asked.

The question was:

Would you mind if your wife consented on your behalf for unnecessary cosmetic surgery to be performed on you?

You're smug answer relies on the fact that your wife could not consent for you to have unnecessary plastic surgery and the doctors would be breaking the law performing it.

So, let's say you wake from a coma, look down and find your wife has elected to have your foreskin restored during your stupor. She's been lying to you all these years about how she prefers you cut! Are you seriously saying you would not mind?
 
No. That is not an answer to the question I asked.

The question was:

Would you mind if your wife consented on your behalf for unnecessary cosmetic surgery to be performed on you?

You're smug answer relies on the fact that your wife could not consent for you to have unnecessary plastic surgery and the doctors would be breaking the law performing it.

So, let's say you wake from a coma, look down and find your wife has elected to have your foreskin restored during your stupor. She's been lying to you all these years about how she prefers you cut! Are you seriously saying you would not mind?


No, Ivor, I answered the question. You just didn't like my answer. I'll back up and take you through my reasoning and maybe your fondness for my answer will grow:

The reason I am able to circumcise my son is because, as his parent, I believe it is in his best interests and the law doesn't care enough to disagree. If I didn't think circumcision was in my son's best interests, I would have no right to do it. I am exercising his judgment for him. I am doing what I think he would want me to do if he were capable of understanding the issues and forming an informed opinion about them.

[I realize you disagree with whether it's in his best interests and whether he would really consent if he could, but I'm only talking about why I'm allowed by law to consent for him and not whether I should.]

Now, if I were incapacitated and unable to give or withhold consent, I trust my wife to make my decisions for me based on what is in my best interests. And the law trusts her as well. If she were to direct a doctor to mess with my junk - attach a foreskin or cut off another piece or whatever - the only reason she would or could is because she believed it to be in my best interests (and it wasn't so obviously harmful that the law cared enough to overrule her).

If I wake up from my coma and find my foreskin has been reattached, would I mind? The answer is no. The only way that could happen is if my wife thought it was in my best interests.

You throw in the words "unncessary surgery" and what my wife "prefers." When you do so, you misunderstand informed consent and substituted judgment. Circumcision is not "unnecessary surgery" for my son as far as I am concerned. I do not circumcise him because I "prefer" it. To me, such a procedure is necessary for his best interests and it is what I think he would want if he could want something.

I would not mind my wife making any of the same decisions for me as she and I make for our son.

[And, in fact, I have been incapacitated in the past and my wife has consented to procedures on my behalf including insertion of a catheter (which messed with my junk) and haircuts and shaves (which were purely cosmetic).]
 
" I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse."
That is the biggest load of unfounded bullskite I've read in this thread.... They'd "Stand these chance" according to whom? You? And what, may I as makes you an authority to even hazard such wild and bizarre claims?

"and the law doesn't care enough to disagree"
... yet.
 
I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse.

a) BS
b) BS
c) BS

News flash: Women don't usually know ahead of time if he's cut or not. Unless his pants are WAY too tight.

Just an anecdote: I'm not cut, and I've made out like a bandit. Seriously. I've had more sex with more women in more kinky ways than I can even summarize. Not one has ever complained about that little piece of skin, noone has denied me access to any orifice or refused me any favors. Noone has ever implied that I wasn't clean enough, and many have complimented me on my ability to make them tingle all over. They seem to appreciate the fact that I'm with them in the moment, not just jackhammering them so my under-sensitive penis can feel something.

I just don't know where you get your superstition that cut men have more sex or more of anything, really. It's totally bogus.
 
Nothing like a bit of self-righteous bigotry and racism to make you feel warm and tingly all over, eh?

Er, wrong. I simply thought it best not to fan the flames of a particular fire that showed no signs of responding to rational argument.

Back in the old days you coulda done more than just only scream on a bulletin board. Pity for you.

Nah, that's fine, I'm too lazy to do anything but scream in this forum.
 
No, Ivor, I answered the question. You just didn't like my answer. I'll back up and take you through my reasoning and maybe your fondness for my answer will grow:

The reason I am able to circumcise my son is because, as his parent, I believe it is in his best interests and the law doesn't care enough to disagree. If I didn't think circumcision was in my son's best interests, I would have no right to do it. I am exercising his judgment for him. I am doing what I think he would want me to do if he were capable of understanding the issues and forming an informed opinion about them.

[I realize you disagree with whether it's in his best interests and whether he would really consent if he could, but I'm only talking about why I'm allowed by law to consent for him and not whether I should.]

You are making up an image of what you would like your son's body to be like and imposing it on him. You have said it yourself: your son is incapable of deciding - he cannot 'want' to be circumcised; it is all your idea. There is no history of your son showing a preference for circumcision for you to make an informed choice.

Your son's health is not under threat. There is no medical need to have him circumcised. The only thing that demands your son be circumcised is your (not your son's) chosen religion's dogma. He cannot have a religion since his cognitive abilities are too limited to understand the concepts. He has the right to freedom of religion, including freedom from your religion. Your religious dogma does not apply to him.

Now, if I were incapacitated and unable to give or withhold consent, I trust my wife to make my decisions for me based on what is in my best interests. And the law trusts her as well. If she were to direct a doctor to mess with my junk - attach a foreskin or cut off another piece or whatever - the only reason she would or could is because she believed it to be in my best interests (and it wasn't so obviously harmful that the law cared enough to overrule her).

Many medical procedures are extremely harmful. What makes the difference in this case is intent and the likely knowledge of your wishes the person giving consent on your behalf is expected to have. That's why it is usually someone who has lived with you for many years.

If I wake up from my coma and find my foreskin has been reattached, would I mind? The answer is no. The only way that could happen is if my wife thought it was in my best interests.

What! After posting pages of how important circumcision is for a Jewish man, you are now saying that waking up with your foreskin restored would not be upsetting to you?

There is another way it could happen: Your wife could manipulate people around her into thinking it was what you would want, when it is only what she wants.

You throw in the words "unncessary surgery" and what my wife "prefers." When you do so, you misunderstand informed consent and substituted judgment. Circumcision is not "unnecessary surgery" for my son as far as I am concerned. I do not circumcise him because I "prefer" it. To me, such a procedure is necessary for his best interests and it is what I think he would want if he could want something.

You misunderstand the meaning of the word 'informed'. As far as your son is concerned you are little more 'informed' than a total stranger as to his 'wants'.

Why not wait and see what he wants? Will you be buying all his toys upfront too?

I would not mind my wife making any of the same decisions for me as she and I make for our son.

[And, in fact, I have been incapacitated in the past and my wife has consented to procedures on my behalf including insertion of a catheter (which messed with my junk) and haircuts and shaves (which were purely cosmetic).]

Asking somebody what someone they have know for many years would want is reasonable. They have a model of that person in their brain based on experience interacting with them.

You have no idea what your son will want. All you know is what you want your son to want. You appear to fool yourself into thinking you have abilities you do not.

BTW, stop using haircuts and shaves as examples. They are completely reversible procedures. Circumcision is not.
 
" I can tell you what will happen if someone is not circumcised in America:
They stand a good chance of never being on the receiving end of oral sex.
They stand a good chance of never being on the delivering end of anal sex.
They stand a small chance of never being on the delivering end of conventional intercourse."
That is the biggest load of unfounded bullskite I've read in this thread.... They'd "Stand these chance" according to whom? You? And what, may I as makes you an authority to even hazard such wild and bizarre claims?

"and the law doesn't care enough to disagree"
... yet.

a) BS
b) BS
c) BS

News flash: Women don't usually know ahead of time if he's cut or not. Unless his pants are WAY too tight.

Just an anecdote: I'm not cut, and I've made out like a bandit. Seriously. I've had more sex with more women in more kinky ways than I can even summarize. Not one has ever complained about that little piece of skin, noone has denied me access to any orifice or refused me any favors. Noone has ever implied that I wasn't clean enough, and many have complimented me on my ability to make them tingle all over. They seem to appreciate the fact that I'm with them in the moment, not just jackhammering them so my under-sensitive penis can feel something.

I just don't know where you get your superstition that cut men have more sex or more of anything, really. It's totally bogus.


Both of you are from Canada which means you don't count. We're talking about Americans as in from the USA.

And the statements I made are not BS as you so rudely put it. You just don't agree with them because you are afraid it means I am saying you don't get as much sex as Americans do up in Canada where you're from. I am not. I am saying if you came from Canada to America many women would not find your penises attractive. Just as if I came from America to Canada many women there might not find my penis attractive if circumcision is not the norm there.

Relax a little there. If you like your own penises that's ok.
All the uncircumcised males in this thread are acting like a bunch of people who attend Rennaissance Fairs and just learned the general public thinks of them as dirty, smelly hippies with capes and no life. So defensive...

Most women in America expect penises to be circumcised and are frequently repulsed when they are not. Whether you think their aversion to uncircumcised penises is right or not does not change the fact that they don't like them.
http://www.circs.org/library/williamson/index.html

Conversely things might be different in countries where circumcision is not prevalant. One thing anti-circumcision posters like the throw out is this:
http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/ohara/

Of course the same "anti-circ" website on another page admits:
The study, conducted by Kristen O' Hare [sic] concludes "the anatomically complete penis offers a more rewarding experience for the female partner during coitus." However, O'Hare even acknowledges the study's shortcomings: The respondents were not selected randomly and several were recruited using a newsletter put out by an anti-circumcision organization.


In short, just because you have had sex with someone does not change the fact that most (not all) women in the U.S.A (not Canada or Eritria or wherever you're from) don't like putting foreskins in their mouth.
 
Er, wrong. I simply thought it best not to fan the flames of a particular fire that showed no signs of responding to rational argument.
Oh, you "thought it best not to fan the flames" and you did that by using wholesale bigoted statements about ethnic groups?

Fascinating. This says a great deal about your integrity.
Nah, that's fine, I'm too lazy to do anything but scream in this forum.
"Lazy" might be one word for it.
 
...snip...

In short, just because you have had sex with someone does not change the fact that most (not all) women in the U.S.A (not Canada or Eritria or wherever you're from) don't like putting foreskins in their mouth.




What a shame for USA women.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom