Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

"When I see more than 1 in 10 men washing their hands in public restrooms after urinating MAYBE, just maybe then I will actually believe that all you men with unenhanced penises are really properly keeping them clean."

1) Human urine is sterile when it leaves the body.
2) the water you just drank was urine one day not too long ago
3) you watch men pissin'??? You gotta get a hobby.
4)what does washing ones hands have to do with foreskin?!?!?!
5)how long have you been living in The Victorian Age?

"Mutilating the genitals of defenceless infants to make you happy is child abuse."
+1!!
 
Nobody has answered my questions:(

1) How much money would you have to be paid to have (a piece of) your little finger removed?

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

2) How much money would I have to pay you to let me surgically alter your genitals in some way? I promise you'll still be able to reach orgasm after.

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

If I had a choice, I wouldn't allow anyone to alter my body in any way. I don't even have tats, if that tells you anything.
 
Do not feed the... Jew? :D

Correct ;)


Morrigan, Osmosis - this commentary and others like it skirt very close to racial remarks aimed at specific members. I strongly advise that you refrain from making this - and similar comments - of this type. Only generalized comments are permissible under the membership agreement.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
True. The reason for cutting off part of a babies penis, is religion.
Not necessarily at all. Since other reasons have been explained, it would be dishonest to make that claim, wouldn't it?

"As an impartial observer"
No such beast.
You wish.
I've yet to see a good reason given for arbitrarily hacking off a piece of an infant.
You've yet to see a reason you agree with. That is something completely different.
I think if you'll read what I wrote one more time you'll realize that that is not what I said.

I've come across the 7% figure (Of men who have DECIDED to get circumcised) several times in articles on the subject.

Has anyone posted links to the recent studies in Africa where the risk of AIDS contraction is reduced by nearly 50% when adult males are circumcised?
Yes, they've been posted in several threads now.

Hey, don't start bringing facts into this discussion buddy. Next thing you know, somebody might do a study on people who died from AIDS and how many were circumcised. Then where will we be?
The facts have been cited. That you don't like them is a subjective matter.

If I had a choice, I wouldn't allow anyone to alter my body in any way. I don't even have tats, if that tells you anything.
I have no tats at all, either. Same reason.
osmosis said:
Agreed.. however, DNFTJ
Morrigan said:
Do not feed the... Jew?


Nothing like a bit of self-righteous bigotry and racism to make you feel warm and tingly all over, eh?

Back in the old days you coulda done more than just only scream on a bulletin board. Pity for you.
 
Oh my god - I've been brainwashed into believing that it is good to have my eyes cut out at birth. How could I be so blind to my brainwashing?

Are you implying foreskin actually has as much use as the human eye in the world in which we live?
 
Are you implying foreskin actually has as much use as the human eye in the world in which we live?

I had hoped you would get it but sadly it seems not. Let me be a tad more direct then.

What gives you (or anyone) the right to decide what is appropriate to chop off defenceless infants for purely cosmetic reasons?

Many people grow up to have ugly heads. Perhaps you have too, who knows. Should they perhaps be removed in case they might offend your sensibilities in the future?

Why not let some of the defenceless grow up into 200 lb weightlifters, then try approaching them with a sharp knife pointed at their genitals while cooing softly 'This is going to hurt you more than it hurts me' and see how long you manage stay upright.

I submit only cowards would cut bits off defenceless children for cosmetic reasons that they wouldn't cut off people of their own size without consent. I notice that not one single mutilation proponent has agreed that people could mutilate their own genitals without consent. Does that tell us anything I wonder?
 
Last edited:
I had hoped you would get it but sadly it seems not. Let me be a tad more direct then.

What gives you (or anyone) the right to decide what is appropriate to chop off defenceless infants for purely cosmetic reasons?

Many people grow up to have ugly heads. Perhaps you have too, who knows. Should they perhaps be removed in case they might offend your sensibilities in the future?

Why not let some of the defenceless grow up into 200 lb weightlifters, then try approaching them with a sharp knife pointed at their genitals while cooing softly 'This is going to hurt you more than it hurts me' and see how long you manage stay upright.

I submit only cowards would cut bits off defenceless children for cosmetic reasons that they wouldn't cut off people of their own size without consent. I notice that not one single mutilation proponent has agreed that people could mutilate their own genitals without consent. Does that tell us anything I wonder?

Careful there. Your arguments are starting to sound like those used by people who protest outside Planned Parenthood.

In order to make such statements you need to provide irrefutable evidence that circumcision harms rather than benefits the infant.
There is none.
 
Last edited:
From that link:
Among the circumcised group, preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination.

That is the minimum anesthetic used during circumcision in US Hospitals with options going all the way up to a complete nerve block on the penile dorsal nerve.

Actually, the minimum is nothing. Followed by sugar water.
 
I had hoped you would get it but sadly it seems not. Let me be a tad more direct then.

What gives you (or anyone) the right to decide what is appropriate to chop off defenceless infants for purely cosmetic reasons?

Many people grow up to have ugly heads. Perhaps you have too, who knows. Should they perhaps be removed in case they might offend your sensibilities in the future?

Why not let some of the defenceless grow up into 200 lb weightlifters, then try approaching them with a sharp knife pointed at their genitals while cooing softly 'This is going to hurt you more than it hurts me' and see how long you manage stay upright.

I submit only cowards would cut bits off defenceless children for cosmetic reasons that they wouldn't cut off people of their own size without consent. I notice that not one single mutilation proponent has agreed that people could mutilate their own genitals without consent. Does that tell us anything I wonder?

I think you said it better than I could.
 
From that link:
Among the circumcised group, preoperative treatment with Emla attenuated the pain response to vaccination.

The circumcised + Emla group still had an increased pain response over the uncircumcised group.

That is the minimum anesthetic used during circumcision in US Hospitals with options going all the way up to a complete nerve block on the penile dorsal nerve.

Now you're just saying what you and all the "I'm a good person and condone hurting healthy children" physicians here would like to be true.

ETA: Perhaps being bound by the wrists and ankles to a table induces some stress and discomfort?
 
Last edited:
"I'm a good person and condone hurting healthy children"

So far this thread has failed to show the harm that will befall circumcised infants when they reach adulthood.

What is this elusive harm? I haven't seen it in my life.

Should I be expecting it anytime soon, or when I'm in my 40's? 50's? Never?
 
Many people grow up to have ugly heads. Perhaps you have too, who knows. Should they perhaps be removed in case they might offend your sensibilities in the future?


It's not quite the same thing but some parents are choosing to put their children in helments for up to a year to correct a flattening or other deformation of the skull. I assume the helmets are hot and uncomfortable and I know from talking to parents that children are treated differently by adults when wearing them. And yet some parents choose to inflict this on their children despite the fact that the children have no choice and some ... don't chose to do so.

And the world keeps turning.


I submit only cowards would cut bits off defenceless children for cosmetic reasons that they wouldn't cut off people of their own size without consent.?


You're confusing two different concepts: "without consent" and "without the capacity to consent". "Without consent" implies that the procedure is against a person's will. Remember, children circumcised by their parents are not being cut without their consent. They are not being cut against their will. They are being circumcised because they lack the capacity to consent and their parents have substituted their judgment for the infants. The infants cannot consent or refuse; they are incapable of doing so.

I'm not arguing whether circumcision is right or wrong. I'm arguing that you are committing the fallacy of equivocation. Plenty of anti-circ people on this board have managed to defend their position quite well without confusing failure to consent with failure to be able to consent.


I notice that not one single mutilation proponent has agreed that people could mutilate their own genitals without consent.


Sure, let me be the first. I, Loss Leader, am a proponent of allowing Jews (including myself) to circumcise their children. I hearby state unequivocally that should I ever be in a position where I am unable to give or withhold informed consent for a medical procedure, I would like my wife to substitute her judgment as to what is in my best interests and exercise my consent on my behalf including but not limited to mutilating my genitals.

Fair enough?


Does that tell us anything I wonder?


It tells me that you misunderstand some basic legal concepts underpinning our society's entire concept of the self, informed consent and substituted judgment.
 
So far this thread has failed to show the harm that will befall circumcised infants when they reach adulthood.

What is this elusive harm? I haven't seen it in my life.

Should I be expecting it anytime soon, or when I'm in my 40's? 50's? Never?

Care to answer my questions? Afraid you may find out you're a hypocrite?

Loss Leader said:
You're confusing two different concepts: "without consent" and "without the capacity to consent". "Without consent" implies that the procedure is against a person's will. Remember, children circumcised by their parents are not being cut without their consent. They are not being cut against their will. They are being circumcised because they lack the capacity to consent and their parents have substituted their judgment for the infants. The infants cannot consent or refuse; they are incapable of doing so.

You are confusing the law with common sense. You are circumcising your children as infants because you have such little faith in your ability to convince them to have it performed when they would be old enough to give informed consent. Pathetic.

Sure, let me be the first. I, Loss Leader, am a proponent of allowing Jews (including myself) to circumcise their children. I hearby state unequivocally that should I ever be in a position where I am unable to give or withhold informed consent for a medical procedure, I would like my wife to substitute her judgment as to what is in my best interests and exercise my consent on my behalf including but not limited to mutilating my genitals.

You are answering a different question. Circumcision is an elective procedure. I.e. one physicians offer to perform to make money even though they know it is painful and medically pointless for the vast majority of infants.

The question you should be answering is:

Would you mind if your wife consented on your behalf for unnecessary cosmetic surgery to be performed on you?

You will be happy to know that such a procedure is not used during the Jewish bris.

That makes it all ok then:rolleyes:
 
You are answering a different question. Circumcision is an elective procedure. I.e. one physicians offer to perform to make money even though they know it is painful and medically pointless for the vast majority of infants.

Do you mean vast majority except in Aids-Prone regions in Africa and other third world nations?

Care to answer my questions? Afraid you may find out you're a hypocrite?

Frankly, I assumed the questions you put in posts replying to me were hypothetical since they were irrelevant to the discussion. Like this one:

1) How much money would you have to be paid to have (a piece of) your little finger removed?

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

For me the amount removed would be proportional to the amount paid me. For a cool million I'd remove the entire finger. If my parents had elected to remove part of my little finger while I was an infant I would have grown up used to it, and would have embraced it as a unique compared to everyone else's whole finger.

Or this one:

2) How much money would I have to pay you to let me surgically alter your genitals in some way? I promise you'll still be able to reach orgasm after.

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

What, exactly, would you do for the million? You could have one of my balls for a million.

Are there any silly questions I've missed? Repost them and I'll try to check back and answer them.
 
Do you mean vast majority except in Aids-Prone regions in Africa and other third world nations?

Yes. Even in these countries there is still a considerable number of unknown variables that could make it go wrong.

Frankly, I assumed the questions you put in posts replying to me were hypothetical since they were irrelevant to the discussion. Like this one:

1) How much money would you have to be paid to have (a piece of) your little finger removed?

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

For me the amount removed would be proportional to the amount paid me. For a cool million I'd remove the entire finger. If my parents had elected to remove part of my little finger while I was an infant I would have grown up used to it, and would have embraced it as a unique compared to everyone else's whole finger.

Or this one:

2) How much money would I have to pay you to let me surgically alter your genitals in some way? I promise you'll still be able to reach orgasm after.

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

What, exactly, would you do for the million? You could have one of my balls for a million.

Are there any silly questions I've missed? Repost them and I'll try to check back and answer them.

With my current financial situation I would not sell any of my body parts for any price.

The point of the asking the questions was to find out if you put a positive value on your body integrity. You do and it is pretty high.

Now explain how you managed to put a negative value on your child's healthy, functional foreskin when you put a positive value on your own body integrity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom