Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

These posts just go on and on and on...

But until one can convince the vast majority of the American (as one of the primary circumcising countries) public that circumcised penises are not better looking, better performing, and better smelling/tasting than penises with a vestigial foreskin Americans will continue to, by some majority, to circumcise their male children.

I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive.
There's nothing irrational about carefully weighing the advantages to having one against the advantages of not having one, and coming to an evidence based decision that the have-nots are better off. And there is nothing irrational about coming to that same conclusion for your child who is in no state to make ANY decisions for themselves about anything (some would argue this holds true until they're about 35).

Like any subject where there are two valid positions (not counting extremists on either side - but particularly those who like to use emotionally charged words and dredge up Freudian psychology) the best way for the medical profession to approach this kind of procedure is "to each their own". And here in the U.S. that is what they do.
 
"the best way for the medical profession to approach this kind of procedure is "to each their own"
So, choosing to mutilate children is o.k. with you?

"here in the U.S. that is what they do"
Since when did the U.S. (outside of their own opinion) become the moral meter-stick for the whole planet?

"I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive."
No more repulsive than an elbow, or an ear canal, or labia.... to a rational human anyway.
 
"As an impartial observer"
No such beast.

"the answer appears to be mixed"
I've yet to see a good reason given for arbitrarily hacking off a piece of an infant... Religion is NOT a good reason... Tradition is NOT a good reason... Some twisted, repressed B.S. sense of aesthetics SURE AS HELL isn't a good reason...

There are some rare situations where it's medically beneficial, sure... like having ones appendix out when it gets infected....
 
"the best way for the medical profession to approach this kind of procedure is "to each their own"
So, choosing to mutilate children is o.k. with you?
Again with the emotionally charged language. Freud would be proud. I don't think I have seen you contribute to this discussion much beyond one liners.

"here in the U.S. that is what they do"
Since when did the U.S. (outside of their own opinion) become the moral meter-stick for the whole planet?
Well being that the U.S. is one of the only countries where infant circumcision is predominantly performed, and the the members of this forum are also predominantly American, likely because JREF is an American organization, and the boards are in English which is predominantly spoken and written in America. And that all the discussions around the patient-physician relationship in this thread have revolved around mostly American doctors and nurses...

"I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive."
No more repulsive than an elbow, or an ear canal, or labia.... to a rational human anyway.
None of those items ooze fetid liquids quite like an uncircumcised penis does, nor do they contribute to disease, nor are they vestigial.

robinson said:
True. The reason for cutting off part of a babies penis, is religion.
The primary reasons for circumcision outside of a few minority cultures is aesthetics and cultural uniformity and to a smaller degree, disease prevention. In the United States (again because this is where most of us are from and where circumcision is most common Clinton) only 2-5% of circumcisions are performed for religious reasons. 2% Jewish (and whether it is religious or merely racial/cultural at this point is arguable) and 1-3% Arabic or Evangelical.
Circumcision is almost exclusively a secular act.
 
Are the uncut ones simply upset that they would now have to fork out their own money to have a more attractive penis?
Riiiiiiiiight.

Agreed.. however, DNFTJ
Do not feed the... Jew? :D

How many adult males get circumcised as adults? Whatever that number is, 7 percent of them choose to do it sans medical reasons.
Huh? Where do you get that 7% figure from?
So 7% of all intact men decide to get circumcised as adults, without medical reason to boot. Is that what you are claiming?

But until one can convince the vast majority of the American (as one of the primary circumcising countries) public that circumcised penises are not better looking, better performing, and better smelling/tasting than penises with a vestigial foreskin Americans will continue to, by some majority, to circumcise their male children.
Yeah, yeah, you're brainwashed, we get it.

(Better performing huh... evidence has been posted that suggests intact penises help bring women to orgasm. Uh-oh.)

I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive.
Honestly, I'd have to say it's because you are not quite right in the head. I don't mean to make ad hominems, but to claim a piece of skin is "repulsive" just shows how thoroughly brainwashed you are.
 
Again with the emotionally charged language. Freud would be proud. I don't think I have seen you contribute to this discussion much beyond one liners.
The irony is crushing.

None of those items ooze fetid liquids quite like an uncircumcised penis does,
What?

nor do they contribute to disease,
What?

nor are they vestigial.
What?

You haven't followed the thread at all, have you. In fact, you learned nothing at all, you just kept plugging your ears, "LALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU! EWW FORESKIN BAD, UGLY!" 'til kingdom come.
 
Huh? Where do you get that 7% figure from?
So 7% of all intact men decide to get circumcised as adults, without medical reason to boot. Is that what you are claiming?

I think if you'll read what I wrote one more time you'll realize that that is not what I said.

I've come across the 7% figure (Of men who have DECIDED to get circumcised) several times in articles on the subject.

Has anyone posted links to the recent studies in Africa where the risk of AIDS contraction is reduced by nearly 50% when adult males are circumcised?
 
I don't mean to make ad hominems, but to claim a piece of skin is "repulsive" just shows how thoroughly brainwashed you are.

Or, perhaps, because of the culture where you live you've been brainwashed into believing it's always best to keep the foreskin.
 
What Morrigan said....

"None of those items ooze fetid liquids quite like an uncircumcised penis does"
You really gotta get your head outa yer backside....
 
Has anyone posted links to the recent studies in Africa where the risk of AIDS contraction is reduced by nearly 50% when adult males are circumcised?

That's a whole different thread. The RCT's in Kenya and Uganda showed 50% protective effect of circumcision against infection with HIV in males.

However, it is not reasonable to think circumcision would automatically have similar success elsewhere. For example, the US has both one of the highest incidences of HIV and circumcision in the developed world.
 
Hey, don't start bringing facts into this discussion buddy. Next thing you know, somebody might do a study on people who died from AIDS and how many were circumcised. Then where will we be?
 
What Morrigan said....

"None of those items ooze fetid liquids quite like an uncircumcised penis does"
You really gotta get your head outa yer backside....

When I see more than 1 in 10 men washing their hands in public restrooms after urinating MAYBE, just maybe then I will actually believe that all you men with unenhanced penises are really properly keeping them clean.
 
Nobody has answered my questions:(

1) How much money would you have to be paid to have (a piece of) your little finger removed?

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?

2) How much money would I have to pay you to let me surgically alter your genitals in some way? I promise you'll still be able to reach orgasm after.

$1?, $1000?, $1million?, No amount would be enough?
 
When I see more than 1 in 10 men washing their hands in public restrooms after urinating MAYBE, just maybe then I will actually believe that all you men with unenhanced penises are really properly keeping them clean.

You just cannot make this stuff up.


Correct me if I'm wrong but what you seem to be saying is that because you've never liked the rolls of fat oily skin around the midriff of ugly obese women, which 90% of the time hides who knows what germs and smells and nasties, that you would mutilate their stomachs in infancy lest they grow up and offend your sensibilities.
 
Or, perhaps, because of the culture where you live you've been brainwashed into believing it's always best to keep the foreskin.

Oh my god - I've been brainwashed into believing that it is good to have my eyes cut out at birth. How could I be so blind to my brainwashing?
 
Last edited:
I certainly have not been convinced that foreskins are not repulsive.

So what exactly? THat people were not convinced that your face was not repulsive doesn't give them the right to cut bits of your face at birth in case you grow up to be repulsive.

Mutilating the genitals of defenceless infants to make you happy is child abuse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom