Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I'm trying in vain to find a local chapter of CVA. (Circumcision Victims Anonymous) Anyone have a linky for the Internet?

Tabitha, if it's so bad for a male to be circumcised as an infant, why is it males elect to have the surgery performed for cosmetic reasons as adults? What do they think they are missing by being uncircumcised?
 
Last edited:
Tabitha, if it's so bad for a male to be circumcised as an infant, why is it males elect to have the surgery performed for cosmetic reasons as adults? What do they think they are missing by being uncircumcised?

What percentage of men do that?
 
So I'm sitting around waiting for that time when it becomes a detriment in my own life? I'm 36. At what age does this detrimental effect manifest itself?.


Well you'll never know how much better sex can be intact. You never had that choice.

The same could be said of the anti-circumcision crowd on this forum. How many of those are circumcised and how many are not? Are the uncut ones simply upset that they would now have to fork out their own money to have a more attractive penis?

I don't think many intact males would let you circumcise even if you gave them money! Really, it is quite easy (and cheap) to get circumcised as an adult. Why don't men opt for this...could it be that the foreskin has a function?;)
 
Well you'll never know how much better sex can be intact.

For the man or the woman? Are there studies showing it's better one way or the other? Could be it's better for circumcised men, couldn't it?
 
Last edited:
He is going to get laid more than the uncircumsised kid (again, this applies only to America)
That's just ridiculous. If anything, there is a tremendous benefit to avoiding the very tiny number of women who are that shallow and petty.

Also, depending on where in America you live, circumcision may now be the minority. You may have inadvertently doomed your son to being rejected by the same shallow and petty women, who in the next generation can't stand the thought of a mutilated penis.

On the other hand, had you left your boy intact, his fully-functional penis may have given him an advantage when it comes to bringing women to orgasm. Now that would definitely get him laid more. I know I never had trouble getting repeat business.

he is not going to miss his foreskin ...
the tiny loss of sensory information ... has been a plus.
The male ego self-defense mechanism demands that we consider ourselves nothing less than whole and fully functional. You're right that he probably won't miss his foreskin, and he will likely insist that his penis is better the way it is. This same bias is also a problem for any circumcision satisfaction study.

The fact is that you truly have no idea what you have lost, or what your son has lost, as you are no longer capable of feeling the sensations that would have been produced by your foreskin.

If your son wants it, fine. Why shouldn't he make this choice for himself, based in the information available? You have taken something from him that can't be given back. If you're right and he would be better off circumcised, he could have had it done when he could make the choice himself, and any of the "benefits" would have still been there.
 
Potential social-psychological issues with uncircumcised male children in certain cultures where circumcision is the norm should not be taken lightly, in my opinion.

Appeal to tradition fallacy and circular reasoning: everyone should be circumcised because everyone is circumcised. If everyone else believed the left arm should be amputated as an offering to god, would you do it to your infant so he or she would "fit in"?

In first world countries there are apparently as many pros as there are cons to circumcision, disregarding the removal of body tissue, which seems to be the thorn-in-the-side for the anti-circumcision crowd.

You're just imagining that thorn, it's not actually there. In first world countries, there are (apparently) NO pros to circumcision, it's all con, whether one chooses to realize it or not.

If someone presents some good medical evidence indicating the procedure routinely, that might change, but so far the evidence does not exist or nobody has posted it.

In my opinion, the potential consequences of not altering the appearance in my 'neck of the woods' outweighs my reluctance to choose having the procedure performed on my child.

In my opinion, that's not your decision to make.

I've asked the opinions of about a dozen co-workers, all of whom had been circumcised as infants (In fact, I know no male who is not circumcised, but then I haven't asked to see the penises of all the males I know either.), and not one of my co-workers was upset about the procedure having been done to them as infants. They found my questioning humerous as if to say ' Why wouldn't I have been circumsized?"

Right, why wouldn't they? A mere 30 years ago, most doctors didn't even bother asking the parents for permission before they did it. Of course they're circumcised.

As for their apparent lack of concern, well I know for a fact there are plenty of infibulated women in this world who not only defend the procedure and it's effects, they'll hold their children down while it's being performed.

Are those of you against circumcision circumcised yourselves? Are you pissed off about it?

No, and yes. But then, I know things you apparently don't, such as a good woman will accept your body with or without that supposedly "unimportant" piece of skin that has thousands of nerve endings in it. And that human rights issues are infinitely more important than vague notions of "fitting in".

Who defines perfect from imperfect? I think my penis is perfect,

Of course you do. Almost every man does.

and so have many women.

I bet some of them were just telling you what you wanted to hear, because they knew how obsessed you are with it.

This anti-circumcision movement is rather new, and reminds me of typical vegan arguments.

That's hardly an accurate comparison, anti-circ is about human rights, vegans, at least the way you're portraying them, are about animal rights. I wouldn't know, myself, I'm not the caricature of a vegetarian, tree-hugging, pot smoking activist you are trying to make me out to be. Well, except for that last part.
 
You know that does not answer the question, don't you?

Sorry. I was being facetious. I know there is a percentage of men who get circumcised as adults, but I cannot find numbers. I realize the percentage for elective surgery is low compared to those who have the surgery due to medical problems.
 
Sorry. I was being facetious. I know there is a percentage of men who get circumcised as adults, but I cannot find numbers. I realize the percentage for elective surgery is low compared to those who have the surgery due to medical problems.

It's low, period. Very low.
 
There are plenty of emotional posts here and at the same time, not everyone on either side of the discussion has posted emotional arguments.

However, your dismissal of everything I posted about the UTIs and about different people having different values by this attempt to attack the messenger isn't likely to lead to a productive discussion.

Try this key word:

equivocal
I notice that you have not addressed the substantive points again or addressed my questions as to what words you emotionally claimed were absurd.

By definition most non-medical genital mutilation of defenceless infants is not carried out because they have a UTI. I have already dealt with the mutilation of body parts for disease prevention and you fail to address the point of who is the definer of risk/reward or why you do not promote similar operations.

Try this key word - Euphemism.
 
Last edited:
By definition most non-medical genital beautification of completely willing infants is not carried out because they have a UTI. I have already dealt with the beautification of body parts for disease prevention and you fail to address the point of who is the definer of risk/reward or why you do not promote similar operations.

There. Fixed the quote fer ya'.

You're welcome.
 
(most of post snipped) I've also asked my wife about her opinion. She was engaged to a non-circumsized Brazilian. She likes my appearance better.
Well, she is your wife! :D "You know I love you, honey, but if I had to tell the truth, I much preferred his penis over yours!"

To quote Snoopy's famous stories: "About this time, the relationship began to go downhill."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom