Ivor the Engineer
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 11,103
First, I am not a doctor or a lawyer. I am a father, and I do love my son.
I never doubted it for a second.
He was circumsised, and I believe that the advantage he gains here (USA) from being circumcised is greater than the small benefits due to the reduced rate of disease transmission.
Let's look at the claimed benefits:
He is going to get laid more than the uncircumsised kid (again, this applies only to America)
Urban myth. Any evidence?
he is not going to miss his foreskin
Not now he isn't. You got in there quick, didn't you?
he has no memory of the actual procedure (and his feeding habits never even slightly changed [yes, breast fed, and his sleeping habits were so good that my wife insists that I can not claim to have been a newborn's father, as he was so well mannered)
Not much research into the medium to long term effects. Most experiments performed have shown a difference similar to PTSD. You'll ignore these, though.
and the tiny loss of sensory information, at least as I have experienced in this country with women who have had sex with me as well as one of my intact friends (hey, college, stuff happens), has been a plus.
How do you know it's a "tiny loss"? Quite a few men who have been circumcised as adults would disagree. How do you know your son would not have had the same opinion as them?
Also, they say it looks bigger when flaccid.
No, they don't. If a man wants to make his bits look bigger, he should shave off his pubic hair. I've heard shaved men get laid more
Yes. Infant circumcision is not necessary.
I agree.
Yes, infants feel pain (was there anesthesia when your child's cord was cut?).
Kellyb has answered this. I'll add that it's necessary to detach the umbilical cord and it's done quickly.
It is not, nor can it be, remembered, much less cause trauma later in life.
Even if I accept your statement as true (I don't - memory is more than just what is able to be recalled), why does that make it ethical?
Freud was absoloutly incorrect in every assertion he ever made that was testable.
I agree. Don't think I (or anybody else here) have used any Freudian arguments. They are quite amusing though
Yes, if randomly clipping earlobes became fashionable I would be first to say that it is not needed, but also first to point out that it is not traumatic or barbaric.
Two questions:
1) Would physicians be offering the service for non-consenting infants?
2) Would it be ethical for a parent to permanently alter their child's body for fashion?
It simply is.
I think what you mean is that you feel nothing for what you have taken away from your child.
disagree about the medical necessity, but stop before your knee-jerk reaction to a basically neutral procedure causes you to spout rhetoric that pins you down as a demegouge.
The procedure is not "neutral". Once it has been performed it is impossible to undo. It causes unnecessary pain... etc.
I will not argue for necessity, only for the basic neutrality of the procedure.
Then I will also argue that it is a violation of the child's basic human rights.
And in this method of rational argument, female circumcision still appears to be an unnecessary as well as detrimental procedure (even assuming that it happened in surgical environments).
Cheers.
Even just a little cutting of the labia or clitoral hood?
What no person in favour of infant circumcision seems able to acknowledge is that there are similar ways to mutilate (or cut if you prefer) the female genitalia that are just as "neutral". That just makes them hypocrites.