Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

First, I am not a doctor or a lawyer. I am a father, and I do love my son.

I never doubted it for a second.

He was circumsised, and I believe that the advantage he gains here (USA) from being circumcised is greater than the small benefits due to the reduced rate of disease transmission.

Let's look at the claimed benefits:

He is going to get laid more than the uncircumsised kid (again, this applies only to America)

Urban myth. Any evidence?

he is not going to miss his foreskin

Not now he isn't. You got in there quick, didn't you?

he has no memory of the actual procedure (and his feeding habits never even slightly changed [yes, breast fed, and his sleeping habits were so good that my wife insists that I can not claim to have been a newborn's father, as he was so well mannered)

Not much research into the medium to long term effects. Most experiments performed have shown a difference similar to PTSD. You'll ignore these, though.

and the tiny loss of sensory information, at least as I have experienced in this country with women who have had sex with me as well as one of my intact friends (hey, college, stuff happens), has been a plus.

How do you know it's a "tiny loss"? Quite a few men who have been circumcised as adults would disagree. How do you know your son would not have had the same opinion as them?

Also, they say it looks bigger when flaccid.

No, they don't. If a man wants to make his bits look bigger, he should shave off his pubic hair. I've heard shaved men get laid more:p

Yes. Infant circumcision is not necessary.

I agree.

Yes, infants feel pain (was there anesthesia when your child's cord was cut?).

Kellyb has answered this. I'll add that it's necessary to detach the umbilical cord and it's done quickly.

It is not, nor can it be, remembered, much less cause trauma later in life.

Even if I accept your statement as true (I don't - memory is more than just what is able to be recalled), why does that make it ethical?

Freud was absoloutly incorrect in every assertion he ever made that was testable.

I agree. Don't think I (or anybody else here) have used any Freudian arguments. They are quite amusing though:)

Yes, if randomly clipping earlobes became fashionable I would be first to say that it is not needed, but also first to point out that it is not traumatic or barbaric.

Two questions:

1) Would physicians be offering the service for non-consenting infants?
2) Would it be ethical for a parent to permanently alter their child's body for fashion?

It simply is.

I think what you mean is that you feel nothing for what you have taken away from your child.

disagree about the medical necessity, but stop before your knee-jerk reaction to a basically neutral procedure causes you to spout rhetoric that pins you down as a demegouge.

The procedure is not "neutral". Once it has been performed it is impossible to undo. It causes unnecessary pain... etc.

I will not argue for necessity, only for the basic neutrality of the procedure.

Then I will also argue that it is a violation of the child's basic human rights.

And in this method of rational argument, female circumcision still appears to be an unnecessary as well as detrimental procedure (even assuming that it happened in surgical environments).
Cheers.

Even just a little cutting of the labia or clitoral hood?

What no person in favour of infant circumcision seems able to acknowledge is that there are similar ways to mutilate (or cut if you prefer) the female genitalia that are just as "neutral". That just makes them hypocrites.
 
I think you´re being deliberately obtuse, but you seem to agree that the only difference between FGM and circumcision or the earlobe-clipping axample is the "extent of the damage done", otherwise being morally equivalent. The point is that some of us wouldn´t admit ANY irrecoverable damage whatsoever to be inflicted on unconsenting individuals for the reasons of maintaining tradition, religion etc. The extent of the damage matters in the sense that the immorality of the action is more or less serious, like it´s not the same if you steal 1$ from Walmart or you steal some poor widow´s life savings. One more seriously wrong than the other, but both wrong, both "stealing". See now? I think you do, you´re just too cunning in sophistry and misdirection...

You are begging the question. That some of you wouldn't admit any intervention that could have permanent effects is the point being argued.

In order to make your example involving money analogous, the question should be changed to whether or not it is reasonable to expect that, under the circumstances, someone would willingly give you the money.

ETA: I don't think it's fair to refer to sophistry and misdirection. It gives the impression that one can safely ignore attempts to have a more sophisticated or analytical discussion.

Linda
 
Last edited:
How do those of you against infant circumcision feel about breast feeding? Based on numerous studies it seems breastfeeding is the best thing for a child (Improved immunity, better neurological development, etc), yet many mothers choose to go straight to formula, forever alterning the development of the child. Do you think this is a more serious offense than altering the look of the penis?
 
How do those of you against infant circumcision feel about breast feeding? Based on numerous studies it seems breastfeeding is the best thing for a child (Improved immunity, better neurological development, etc), yet many mothers choose to go straight to formula, forever alterning the development of the child. Do you think this is a more serious offense than altering the look of the penis?

My personal opinion is that based on the evidence, breast feeding is better than formula (especially if you don't have a clean water supply:rolleyes:).

However, breast feeding involves two individuals. The mother's milk is hers to do with as she wishes. It is her responsibility to make sure the child thrives, whatever she chooses to do.

The foreskin belongs to the child and unless it is causing or likely to cause a problem, should not be removed for someone else's reasons.
 
You are begging the question. That some of you wouldn't admit any intervention that could have permanent effects is the point being argued.

In order to make your example involving money analogous, the question should be changed to whether or not it is reasonable to expect that, under the circumstances, someone would willingly give you the money.

ETA: I don't think it's fair to refer to sophistry and misdirection. It gives the impression that one can safely ignore attempts to have a more sophisticated or analytical discussion.

Linda

How much for (part of) your little finger? $1? $100? $10,000? more?

How much to alter your (I assume;)) perfectly healthy genitals (only a little bit of tidying up, nothing major)?
 
The point is that some of us wouldn´t admit ANY irrecoverable damage whatsoever to be inflicted on unconsenting individuals for the reasons of maintaining tradition, religion etc.


Yes, I'm quite well aware that if you were to conduct the balancing test, you would find against allowing parents to circumcise their children. I don't care about your position, but I'm aware of it.



But you don´t need to take offense for this, mh´key?


I'll be the judge of what I find offensive, thank you.
 
Potential social-psychological issues with uncircumcised male children in certain cultures where circumcision is the norm should not be taken lightly, in my opinion.

In first world countries there are apparently as many pros as there are cons to circumcision, disregarding the removal of body tissue, which seems to be the thorn-in-the-side for the anti-circumcision crowd. So, it basically boils down to an argument for or against permanently altering the appearance of the male genitalia.

In my opinion, the potential consequences of not altering the appearance in my 'neck of the woods' outweighs my reluctance to choose having the procedure performed on my child.

I've asked the opinions of about a dozen co-workers, all of whom had been circumcised as infants (In fact, I know no male who is not circumcised, but then I haven't asked to see the penises of all the males I know either.), and not one of my co-workers was upset about the procedure having been done to them as infants. They found my questioning humerous as if to say ' Why wouldn't I have been circumsized?"

I know I'm not upset about being circumcised, and if I hadn't been circumcised as a child I would have felt rather 'odd' taking a shower after kick ball in middle school. I would have felt out of place when I was in the military showering with a bunch of other guys. I've also asked my wife about her opinion. She was engaged to a non-circumsized Brazilian. She likes my appearance better. (Brain-washed?) She did not hesitate to consent having our little one circumcised. Never occured to her to question the practice.

Have I been brain-washed? Don't care! I think I have a great looking 'unit', and I'm glad I didn't have to fork out the money and time for recovery to get circumcised as an adult.

Are those of you against circumcision circumcised yourselves? Are you pissed off about it?



Concerning using the term mutilation simply to verbally berate those who are pro-circumcision. It's as appropriate as someone calling poop on a stick 'art'. It's really a matter of opinion, and in common vernacular, a circumsized penis is not 'mutilated'.

mu·ti·late:
1. to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2. to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.

Foreskin, while perhaps nice for some people to have, is about as essential to a normal, functional life as an appendix.

Who defines perfect from imperfect? I think my penis is perfect, and so have many women. I don't consider myself disfigured, nor does any other circumcised male I know consider themselves disfigured. Perhaps I was injured for a brief time after the procedure, but I got over it.

This anti-circumcision movement is rather new, and reminds me of typical vegan arguments. Are the anti-circumcision individuals here vegetarians? Is it o.k. to mutilate and kill a cow for your hamburger or steak? Is that not worse than circumcision. Is a cow's life less valuable than the foreskin of a child?
 
Against circumcision and breastfed all 5 of my children. Still bfing the youngest who's 18 months old. I'm a strong advocate of bfing as well. If you are going to have children, might as well do everything you can to make them as healthy and whole as you can.

Intact young boys look so much more NORMAL. They don't have their glans just hanging out there for all to see. And diaper concerns are MUCH easier. No poop under the ridge, in the hole, etc. And my son did have a UTI at 6 months old. Guess what? He took antibiotics, no amputation of foreskin necessary. No troubles since.

And cloud, you are brainwashed. It's really really hard to see around the brainwashing of "circumcision = normal." Once you get the blinders off, it becomes SO very clear as to why its wrong to intentionally cut off part of your baby's genitals. Really.
 
Intact young boys look so much more NORMAL.

Normal in this case is a matter of opinion, and the definition would vary according to local. A child born with down syndrome is completely normal for a child with down syndrome. A circumcised child looks much more normal in a room full of circumcised children than one who is uncircumcised.

I know we'll simply have to agree to disagree on the issue of circumcision, and I'm fine with that.

I just think there are many other larger problems in the world to worry about than whether or not it's wrong or right to circumcise a male child. There are far worse choices that adults make, with far worse consequences than circumcising their child.

People choose to drive drunk and kill large numbers of people every year. (Many accidentally kill their own siblings and children driving drunk and crashing.) Some parents choose to smoke around their children, even in cars, causing harm to the child. Some husbands/wives choose to cheat on their spouse, ruining their marriage and any chance of a normal (There's that word again!) family life for their kids. Some of those kids grow up depressed and even suicidal. (I've never known an individual who was depressed because he was circumcised, but I'm sure they're out there.) Some single mothers choose to give their child up for adoption, and many of those orphaned kids grow up never having a home, depressed and lonely never thinking about their circumcised penis.

All of the above examples, and countless others, are, to me, larger problems than circumcision.

I grew up my entire life never thinking about the appearance of my penis until I stumbled upon this thread. This thread has not served to change my mind at all. I imagine that people's opinions on circumcision prior to reading this thread will not be changed either. Those for it will still be for it, and those against the same. This thread has simply made me aware that people have differing opinions about most everything in life.

Life is about choices. Some choices we make will harm others and in many of those cases we won't even ever know about the harm we caused. Some choices we make will make other peoples lives a little bit better. It's about doing the best one can for their family and community. For my family it was better to circumcise our son. He will grow up and never think twice about the appearance of his penis unless he happens to stumble upon this long dead thread.
 
Last edited:
Potential social-psychological issues with uncircumcised male children in certain cultures where circumcision is the norm should not be taken lightly, in my opinion.

In first world countries there are apparently as many pros as there are cons to circumcision, disregarding the removal of body tissue, which seems to be the thorn-in-the-side for the anti-circumcision crowd. So, it basically boils down to an argument for or against permanently altering the appearance of the male genitalia.

In my opinion, the potential consequences of not altering the appearance in my 'neck of the woods' outweighs my reluctance to choose having the procedure performed on my child.

What do you think these consequences are? How severe are they? E.g., are they as bad as if you're black? Is there a earnings difference between circumcised and uncircumcised males after adjusting for other factors?

Does every sexual encounter hinge on a woman's aesthetic preference for a body part that when erect looks similar cut or un-cut? Have you ever seen an uncircumcised penis?

I've asked the opinions of about a dozen co-workers, all of whom had been circumcised as infants (In fact, I know no male who is not circumcised, but then I haven't asked to see the penises of all the males I know either.), and not one of my co-workers was upset about the procedure having been done to them as infants. They found my questioning humerous as if to say ' Why wouldn't I have been circumsized?"

My mother thinks it was ok for her to be caned across the hands for fighting in school. Why wouldn't she have been caned? Beating children was "normal" back then. Still is in many parts of the world. Teaches them discipline and respect for authority.

I know I'm not upset about being circumcised, and if I hadn't been circumcised as a child I would have felt rather 'odd' taking a shower after kick ball in middle school. I would have felt out of place when I was in the military showering with a bunch of other guys. I've also asked my wife about her opinion. She was engaged to a non-circumsized Brazilian. She likes my appearance better. (Brain-washed?) She did not hesitate to consent having our little one circumcised. Never occured to her to question the practice.

So no kid you've ever known got teased about some aspect of his body? E.g., weight, height, length, colour, hair, nose, ears, lips, legs, spots, birthmarks, etc.?

Have I been brain-washed? Don't care! I think I have a great looking 'unit', and I'm glad I didn't have to fork out the money and time for recovery to get circumcised as an adult.

Are those of you against circumcision circumcised yourselves? Are you pissed off about it?

No and no.

Concerning using the term mutilation simply to verbally berate those who are pro-circumcision. It's as appropriate as someone calling poop on a stick 'art'. It's really a matter of opinion, and in common vernacular, a circumsized penis is not 'mutilated'.

mu·ti·late:
1. to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2. to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.

Foreskin, while perhaps nice for some people to have, is about as essential to a normal, functional life as an appendix.

Or a little finger. How much can I offer you to have it removed? How about your son's little finger. Much simpler operation when he's young.

Or a girl's labia. A little nip/tuck could do wonders for her chances of getting regular cunnilingus when she's older.

Who defines perfect from imperfect? I think my penis is perfect, and so have many women. I don't consider myself disfigured, nor does any other circumcised male I know consider themselves disfigured. Perhaps I was injured for a brief time after the procedure, but I got over it.

What is anyone else's concept of physical perfection got to do with giving an individual choice with regard to their own body?

This anti-circumcision movement is rather new, and reminds me of typical vegan arguments. Are the anti-circumcision individuals here vegetarians? Is it o.k. to mutilate and kill a cow for your hamburger or steak? Is that not worse than circumcision. Is a cow's life less valuable than the foreskin of a child?

I'm not anti-circumcision, though I am vegetarian. I'm not bothered about eating meat.

The difference between a cow and a child is even if you wait 18 years a cow will still not be able to make an informed choice.
 
What do you think these consequences are? How severe are they? E.g., are they as bad as if you're black? Is there a earnings difference between circumcised and uncircumcised males after adjusting for other factors?

Can we quantify the consequences? I can only speak from my own experience. For me it would have been worse to have been uncircumcised. Obviously you didn't grow up in the Southeastern part of the US.

So no kid you've ever known got teased about some aspect of his body? E.g., weight, height, length, colour, hair, nose, ears, lips, legs, spots, birthmarks, etc.?

Exactly. Kids will be teased. Why give them something else to get teased about by not circumcising them in a culture where it is the norm.

Or a little finger. How much can I offer you to have it removed? How about your son's little finger. Much simpler operation when he's young.

Really, how common is this practice? Is it normal where you live? It's not a comparison, because it is not an accepted practice where I live. Circumcising a male child is.

What is anyone else's concept of physical perfection got to do with giving an individual choice with regard to their own body?

My statement had nothing to do with the act of circumcision itself, but rather calling the procedure mutilation. It is a valid point in that regard.

The difference between a cow and a child is even if you wait 18 years a cow will still not be able to make an informed choice.

I wasn't comparing the life of a cow to the life of a child. I was comparing a cow to the foreskin of a penis. Is one worth more or less than the other?
 
cloudshiprule said:
Can we quantify the consequences? I can only speak from my own experience. For me it would have been worse to have been uncircumcised. Obviously you didn't grow up in the Southeastern part of the US.
That was in the past, though. Many, many more boys in the US are left intact now.

Exactly. Kids will be teased. Why give them something else to get teased about by not circumcising them in a culture where it is the norm.
There haven't been any surveys done in the past few years, but the national average is probably close to 50/50 now. Once the scale tips in favor of more children being left intact, would it cruel to circumcise a child at that point, in your opinion, because of the fact that more than half his peers could, in theory, make fun of him for not having all of his penis?
 
A child born with down syndrome is completely normal for a child with down syndrome. A circumcised child looks much more normal in a room full of circumcised children than one who is uncircumcised.
Genius analogy. Compare intact kids, born like every other healthy male human on Earth, with kids missing an important chromosome! :)
 
Genius analogy. Compare intact kids, born like every other healthy male human on Earth, with kids missing an important chromosome!

A wee bit of sarcasm? Perhaps out of context my analogy wouldn't stand, but given the post I was replying to it was apropos. Normal is relative.

Incidentally, I wasn't comparing intact kids with ones missing a chromosome. I was comparing ones missing a chromosome with other ones missing a chromosome.
 
Last edited:
I know its really hard to come to terms with the idea that something was done to you, without your permission, for no good reason, and you ARE missing an important part of yourself that has a function. It's especially hard once you've perpetrated this abuse upon a child that you love. That doesn't change the fact that its a human rights issue.

Children have the right to grow to adulthood with all their pieces and parts barring medical necessity.
 
Can we quantify the consequences? I can only speak from my own experience. For me it would have been worse to have been uncircumcised. Obviously you didn't grow up in the Southeastern part of the US.

You imagine it would have been worse. Did you know some kid whose life was made a living hell because he was uncircumcised?

Exactly. Kids will be teased. Why give them something else to get teased about by not circumcising them in a culture where it is the norm.

Your missing the point. It doesn't matter what you make your kids look like. There's always something other children will find to make fun of.

Really, how common is this practice? Is it normal where you live? It's not a comparison, because it is not an accepted practice where I live. Circumcising a male child is.

Again, missing the point: The point was how much do you value parts of your body? What would you accept for (part of) your little finger to be cut off?

I.e. how much do you value your body integrity?

Why did you value your son's less?

My statement had nothing to do with the act of circumcision itself, but rather calling the procedure mutilation. It is a valid point in that regard.

Sorry I offended your sensibilities.

I wasn't comparing the life of a cow to the life of a child. I was comparing a cow to the foreskin of a penis. Is one worth more or less than the other?

You cannot equate human rights to physical payments. Or is this a question about animal rights vs. human rights?:confused:

How many cows would you accept for your little finger?
 
Apparently I value my (non-existent) foreskin as much as a hangnail. Same for my child. I really am glad it's gone on both of us, and that's not denial. (Said the cruel bastard.)

Gethane, I have nothing to come to terms with. I live a happy, normal life just as millions of other circumcised individuals do.

(Though sometimes in the wee hours of the night I do find myself standing by the fridge with the door open just enough to let a little light escape as I wrap chicken skin around the head of my penis and imagine what it must have been like to spend my youth with my little friend cloaked in a crown of foreskin.):)
 
I know its really hard to come to terms with the idea that something was done to you, without your permission, for no good reason, and you ARE missing an important part of yourself that has a function. It's especially hard once you've perpetrated this abuse upon a child that you love. That doesn't change the fact that its a human rights issue.

Children have the right to grow to adulthood with all their pieces and parts barring medical necessity.


I think this is the crux of it. People arguing in favour of circumcision have either been circumcised themselves (and don't know what they are missing) OR have circumcised a child of theirs, maybe without all the facts. Of course they are going to try to defend it, by whatever means possible. To think you have put a child thorough unneccesary surgery, which will ultimatley be to their detriment must be a horrible place to be. Of course they love their chidren. I just don't see how any person looking at the facts of circumcision would choose to do so on a newborn now, in this day and age. I *get* the religious argument, although don't agree with it. But other than that, if you look into circumcision befor your baby is born, how can you come to a conclusion that it is better to circ?. it really doesn't make sense. Especially on a forum like this!:confused:
 
To think you have put a child thorough unneccesary surgery, which will ultimatley be to their detriment must be a horrible place to be.

So I'm sitting around waiting for that time when it becomes a detriment in my own life? I'm 36. At what age does this detrimental effect manifest itself?

People arguing in favour of circumcision have either been circumcised themselves (and don't know what they are missing) OR have circumcised a child of theirs, maybe without all the facts.

The same could be said of the anti-circumcision crowd on this forum. How many of those are circumcised and how many are not? Are the uncut ones simply upset that they would now have to fork out their own money to have a more attractive penis?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom