Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

It one of the many common arguments used in support of all forms of genital mutilation - whether female or male.

Some of the others are:

hygiene
aesthetics
tradition
 
OK, here we go.

My wife will give me oral gratification. She would not for a previous boyfriend who was not circumcised.

Game over.;)

Some less than generously proportioned girls can't have comfortable sex with a circumcised guy, though. More friction isn't always good. :(

And a quick shower will do wonders for a previous boyfriend.
 
It one of the many common arguments used in support of all forms of genital mutilation - whether female or male.

Some of the others are:

hygiene
aesthetics
tradition

I think Loss leader offered another argument: Let´s call it the "legalistic" argument: The parents are considered to be THE SAME individual as the child. Therefore the child is not unconsenting, his parents´ will is his will. Nice dodge, isnt´t it?

But then why are there laws that protect children from possible abuses even from the child´s parents? Why did this guy lose the custody of his kid? http://www.estrelladigital.es/a1.asp?sec=esp&fech=17/07/2007&name=custodia,
(I didn´t have the time to answer Loss Leader´s posts last week and I just found this amusing example...)
 
From AIDS (hah) thread:

Skeptigirl said:
We shouldn't hijack this thread, Ivor. I am 100% against unanesthetized circumcisions and have been since the first time I saw the procedure done in 1976.

Fantastic. That means there's only one difference between our positions.

There are many elective surgical procedures parents consent to for their children. Parents have the position of making medical decisions for their infants.

Is there any similar to male infant circumcision? I can't think of any. Anybody?

Don't just give a name of an elective procedure, I want to see a comparison of the details (such a duration, pain, observable physical impact, short and long term risks/benefits/costs, etc.) between circumcision and the procedure you think is similar to it.

That is all I am going to say about that topic in this thread. This is the second thread I have seen you carry the circumcision discussion into. And you don't think you are a bit emotional over the subject?

I've jokingly referred to this thread's protagonists elsewhere.

My gripe is the hypocrisy I see in parents having their infant circumcised and physicians performing the procedure. Inconsistency bothers me.
 
I think Loss leader offered another argument: Let´s call it the "legalistic" argument: The parents are considered to be THE SAME individual as the child. Therefore the child is not unconsenting, his parents´ will is his will. Nice dodge, isnt´t it?


I'm sorry, but this misrepresents my argument. I did not offer the laws of substituted judgment as an independent reason for circumcision. Substituted judgment is just the mechanism by which parents choose circumcision. It's not the reason they choose it. My car is not the reason I go to work; it is the way I get there.

I, in fact, never offered any argument in favor of circumcision. I offered an argument in favor of allowing other parents to choose circumcision. That argument was that the benefits to a society of allowing a broad range of cultures and practices outweigh any benefit that might come from an absolute prohibition against circumcision.


But then why are there laws that protect children from possible abuses even from the child´s parents? Why did this guy lose the custody of his kid? http://www.estrelladigital.es/a1.asp?sec=esp&fech=17/07/2007&name=custodia


As I have explained numerous times, the state does have an interest in protecting the health and safety of its incompetent citizens. However, this interest must be balanced against religious freedom and family integrity (among other things). In the case of circumcision, at least, the courts and legislatures are so far unanimous that whatever harm circumcision might cause, it is not enough to outweigh those other factors.
 
I, in fact, never offered any argument in favor of circumcision. I offered an argument in favor of allowing other parents to choose circumcision.

Rather subtle difference, if any...

Seems that you´re defending circumcision, anyway, and what looks like for utilitarian reasons...

Most people here seem to think that bodily integrity is a fundamental right, not to be trumped by anyone´s religion or "family integrity". There are many examples, like the one I linked before, where the child´s fundamental rights are to be protected from his parents. Don´t you see a similarty with circumcision? What do you think the difference is (in a moral sense) between circumcision and, for example FGM, apart from the extent of the damage done?

That argument was that the benefits to a society of allowing a broad range of cultures and practices outweigh any benefit that might come from an absolute prohibition against circumcision.

I wouldn´t call for a total prohibition, of course.

But, do you know what would be really impressive? The jewish communities addressing the issue in a reasonable way, thus (logically) changing the custom and performing the operation with the reach of adulthood (on consenting individuals). That would be really good P.R. for the jews... ;)
 
I wouldn´t call for a total prohibition, of course.

But, do you know what would be really impressive? The jewish communities addressing the issue in a reasonable way, thus (logically) changing the custom and performing the operation with the reach of adulthood (on consenting individuals). That would be really good P.R. for the jews... ;)

That's the thing: even the members of barbaric religions that still practice infant/child circumcision know that the chances of convincing a 18+ year-old male to consent to circumcision is soooooo uncertain (in a multicultural society), they have to "get in there quick" while the law allows parents to inflict their will on the child. Pathetic. Seems like a distinct lack of faith to me.
 
Don´t you see a similarty with circumcision? What do you think the difference is (in a moral sense) between circumcision and, for example FGM, apart from the extent of the damage done?


As "the extent of the damage done" is a necessary factor in a balancing test that weighs, in part, the extent of the damage done, it is impossible to answer your question without reference to "the extent of the damage done."


That would be really good P.R. for the jews... ;)


Your implication that Jews either require or should seek "good P.R." is offensive to my ethnicity.
 
Some evidence for Skeptigirl:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15890696

Circumcision for the prevention of urinary tract infection in boys: a systematic review of randomised trials and observational studies.

Singh-Grewal D, Macdessi J, Craig J.

Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, The Children's Hospital at Westmead, Sydney, Australia.

OBJECTIVE: To undertake a meta-analysis of published data on the effect of circumcision on the risk of urinary tract infection (UTI) in boys. DATA SOURCES: Randomised controlled trials and observational studies comparing the frequency of UTI in circumcised and uncircumcised boys were identified from the Cochrane controlled trials register, MEDLINE, EMBASE, reference lists of retrieved articles, and contact with known investigators. METHODS: Two of the authors independently assessed study quality using the guidelines provided by the MOOSE statement for quality of observational studies. A random effects model was used to estimate a summary odds ratio (OR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). RESULTS: Data on 402,908 children were identified from 12 studies (one randomised controlled trial, four cohort studies, and seven case-control studies). Circumcision was associated with a significantly reduced risk of UTI (OR = 0.13; 95% CI, 0.08 to 0.20; p<0.001) with the same odds ratio (0.13) for all three types of study design. CONCLUSIONS: Circumcision reduces the risk of UTI. Given a risk in normal boys of about 1%, the number-needed-to-treat to prevent one UTI is 111. In boys with recurrent UTI or high grade vesicoureteric reflux, the risk of UTI recurrence is 10% and 30% and the numbers-needed-to-treat are 11 and 4, respectively. Haemorrhage and infection are the commonest complications of circumcision, occurring at rate of about 2%. Assuming equal utility of benefits and harms, net clinical benefit is likely only in boys at high risk of UTI.

Here's what a UK medical site recommends:

http://www.patient.co.uk/showdoc/40024657/

Circumcision has other suggested benefits and indications:

Recurrent UTI.3 Circumcision is associated with a significantly reduced risk of UTI (Odds Ratio = 0.13); but the benefit of circumcision only outweighs the risk in boys who have either had recurrent UTI's, or are at high risk of UTI (eg high grade vesicoureteric reflux (≥grade 3). 4,5 Although the relative risk of a UTI in the uncircumcised male infant is 4 to 20 times higher as compared to circumcised male infants, the absolute risk is low (less than 1%). Hence recommending circumcision in all newborn infants on these grounds is not sustainable.

Prevention of penile cancer. This rarely occurs in circumcised men but in countries where there is a high level of personal hygiene the condition is also rare.6 Human papilloma virus (HPV) genotypes 16,18, 31 and 33 are responsible for the great majority of cervical,vulval, vaginal, anal and penile cancers. Circumcision is claimed to reduce the risk of HPV infection in men. Yet again however the low absolute risk means that there is not an argument for universal circumcision.

Reduction in the risk of sexually transmitted disease (particularly ulcerative diseases like syphilis). This is as yet unproven.7 A meta-analysis of 27 studies does apparently show reduction in risk of STD transmission associated with circumcision.8 However other studies show the opposite. Sexual practices of circumcised men may differ from those who are uncircumcised related to their religion.

As for UTI:

http://www.patient.co.uk/showdoc/40000338/

Prognosis
Most children recover quickly and completely with antibiotic treatment.
Recurrence of urinary tract infection is more likely in:

Younger children i.e. aged less than 6 months
Girls compared to boys
Vesicoureteral reflux grade 3 - 5, compared with reflux grade 1- 2, or no reflux
Dysfunctional voiding syndrome16; this is an abnormality of emptying, due to either a small-capacity, unstable bladder or a large-capacity, poorly emptying bladder.

Vesicoureteric reflux (VUR) is found in about 1% of normal infants and normally resolves over several years.17 However, it is a risk factor for pyelonephritis, which can cause renal scarring, which can lead to hypertension and impaired renal function.

Prevention
A common sense approach is advised given the lack of conclusive evidence.18
Relief of voiding dysfunction; good hygiene; wiping from front to back after micturition in girls; avoiding constipation, bubble baths, chemical irritants, and tight clothing.

Children with significant urinary tract abnormalities and/or frequent symptomatic UTI may benefit from prophylactic antibacterials (trimethoprim or nitrofurantoin).15

There is not enough evidence available to assess the benefits/risks/optimal treatment schedules for prophylactic antibiotics in children.

Prodigy suggest that children who suffer a second UTI within a year should receive short-term prophylactic antibiotics and be referred for their assessment for long-term use.7

Just one episode of reflux of infected urine may initiate chronic pyelonephritis, so screening for bacteriuria is useless.18 But once a UTI is suggested e.g. by urine microscopy in an infant, treat it at once before culture sensitivities are known, as renal damage may be about to happen.

Screen siblings for reflux.18

Common Sense != Mutilate Child's Genitals.
 
Your implication that Jews either require or should seek "good P.R." is offensive to my ethnicity.

Ever the professional victim huh?

By the way, criticizing a group because of their traditional, religious practice of circumcision has nothing to do with criticizing their ethnicity, so quit being a drama queer already.
 
By the way, criticizing a group because of their traditional, religious practice of circumcision has nothing to do with criticizing their ethnicity,


I didn't complain about any criticism of a tradition or religious practice. I complained because Abooga implied that Jews are required or advised to seek "good P.R." There's a difference.


so quit being a drama queer already.


Your language is immature and unbecoming.
 
It's actually quite refreshing to find a professional <insert profession here> who isn't afraid to admit they don't know something from their own field of expertise.

lol one time many years ago I made a comment that was described by my good friend as "one of the most honest things he's ever heard."

He had asked me a question and I replied, "You're asking the wrong guy.. oh wait, you're actually asking the right guy, I just don't know."

hehe still get a tiny chuckle from that one
 
Some of the others are:

hygiene
..

This may be a valid concern in some parts of today's world, certainly it was valid everywhere until very recently, what with all our fancy running water and showers and soap.

Until I found out about circumcision being used to mark slaves, I was under the general impression that it may have actually been a good idea 2000 years ago, just like certain other Jewish traditions, such as not eating pork. Before reliable refridgeration was commonly available, it may have been best to avoid the pork, Jewish or not.

Too bad I was wrong about that, it fit so perfectly into my interpretation of Meme Theory.
 
First, I am not a doctor or a lawyer. I am a father, and I do love my son. He was circumsised, and I believe that the advantage he gains here (USA) from being circumcised is greater than the small benefits due to the reduced rate of disease transmission. He is going to get laid more than the uncircumsised kid (again, this applies only to America), he is not going to miss his foreskin, he has no memory of the actual procedure (and his feeding habits never even slightly changed [yes, breast fed, and his sleeping habits were so good that my wife insists that I can not claim to have been a newborn's father, as he was so well mannered), and the tiny loss of sensory information, at least as I have experienced in this country with women who have had sex with me as well as one of my intact friends (hey, college, stuff happens), has been a plus. Also, they say it looks bigger when flaccid.

Yes. Infant circumcision is not necessary.

Yes, infants feel pain (was there anesthesia when your child's cord was cut?).

It is not, nor can it be, remembered, much less cause trauma later in life.

Freud was absoloutly incorrect in every assertion he ever made that was testable.

Yes, if randomly clipping earlobes became fashionable I would be first to say that it is not needed, but also first to point out that it is not traumatic or barbaric.
It simply is.
disagree about the medical necessity, but stop before your knee-jerk reaction to a basically neutral procedure causes you to spout rhetoric that pins you down as a demegouge.
I will not argue for necessity, only for the basic neutrality of the procedure. And in this method of rational argument, female circumcision still appears to be an unnecessary as well as detrimental procedure (even assuming that it happened in surgical environments).
Cheers.
 
Yes, infants feel pain (was there anesthesia when your child's cord was cut?).
No, because the unbilical cord doesn't have any pain sensing nerves in it.
http://health.yahoo.com/topic/children/baby/article/mayoclinic/F0F73250-701F-4590-BFA55E9E2D4AB61E

During pregnancy, the umbilical cord supplies nutrients and oxygen to your developing baby. After birth the umbilical cord is no longer needed, so it's clamped and snipped. This leaves behind a short stump. The umbilical cord doesn't contain pain-sensitive nerve fibers, so your baby won't feel anything during this rite of passage.
 
I didn't complain about any criticism of a tradition or religious practice. I complained because Abooga implied that Jews are required or advised to seek "good P.R." There's a difference.
Right. Jews are a religious group as well as an ethnic group, and whatever "good PR" he implied they might need was clearly regarding their religion.

Your language is immature and unbecoming.
*shrugs* Your pompousness is as tedious as your whiny victim mentality.

He is going to get laid more than the uncircumsised kid (again, this applies only to America),
1) Evidence?
2) Even if true - How do you feel about the fact that this very argument can be (and is) used to defend female circumcision in African tribes? ("My daughter will never find a husband unless I mutilate her genitals, better get on with it!")

he is not going to miss his foreskin,
See 2) above.

Also, they say it looks bigger when flaccid.
Because that's an important point to consider, worth mentioning. Of course. :newlol

They get more desperate every time, it seems...
 
As "the extent of the damage done" is a necessary factor in a balancing test that weighs, in part, the extent of the damage done, it is impossible to answer your question without reference to "the extent of the damage done."
.

I think you´re being deliberately obtuse, but you seem to agree that the only difference between FGM and circumcision or the earlobe-clipping axample is the "extent of the damage done", otherwise being morally equivalent. The point is that some of us wouldn´t admit ANY irrecoverable damage whatsoever to be inflicted on unconsenting individuals for the reasons of maintaining tradition, religion etc. The extent of the damage matters in the sense that the immorality of the action is more or less serious, like it´s not the same if you steal 1$ from Walmart or you steal some poor widow´s life savings. One more seriously wrong than the other, but both wrong, both "stealing". See now? I think you do, you´re just too cunning in sophistry and misdirection...

Your implication that Jews either require or should seek "good P.R." is offensive to my ethnicity.

I´ve never seen anyone so quick at finding anything offensive! Read what I said again please, and see you have no reason to play the victim´s card, I was just making a sort of joke. Sort of, because it is true that I´d find it impressive if Jews did that, personally. But you don´t need to take offense for this, mh´key?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom