Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

This is rather an unfair conclusion. I tried to say something which was not taken as intended. It was a difficult concept to communicate. When my attempt to communicate the concept failed, I tried to clarify it. And now that I have restated it as I was originally attempting to, you choose to take your misunderstanding of what I said instead of the repeated clarifications of what I had tried to say.

Clearly I failed to communicate. That doesn't mean what you wrongly concluded I had said was factual. It means I failed to communicate. You were offended. I get it. But you were offended because you didn't understand what I was saying, because as you have now pointed out once again, it came across as my saying doctors were not patient advocates. Yet I never said that, you claim I implied it. Don't you think after all this time you've been reading my posts that if I believed nurses were good, doctors were bad or whatever it is you think I was saying, you wouldn't have read that sentiment in at least some of my previous posts by now?

This is why I consider this an exercise in futility. I have never said that I was offended and explicitly stated otherwise, yet you continue to centre your argument around the idea that I was offended.

I again tried to clarify what I had said in this post which was never responded to:

Because the post was a strawman from beginning to end, and attempts to explain why had already been demonstrated to be futile.

And then along comes Dr Sylvester bemoaning the fact he cannot always dictate to the patients what they should do, "The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision..."

The statement that you quoted does not reflect dictating to patients what they should do. You simply chose to interpret it differently from its intent in order to support that particular agenda.

I repeat, the nursing model differs from the medical model of care. I practice in both fields. I have observed the difference. It does not mean any individual nurse or doctor is restricted to these models. In fact, both professions have considerable overlap. We went through this already. But it seems you aren't willing to entertain the idea the original issue was simply failed communication. Instead you remain convinced after all this time that I have some belief/attitude never revealed until this thread that doctors are not patient advocates.

From my viewpoint, in this case, the idea nurses do not have any unique professional contribution to patient care is what seems to be the implication. Any attempt by me to discuss that unique professional perspective has been taken as insulting.

Again, you have misrepresented what has been said to you. I don't think this is purposeful, but I do think that you are so focussed on making sure that you are understood, that you haven't paid attention to making sure you understand others. Until that barrier has been breached, I don't see how further explanations on my part can make any difference.

Linda
 
Care to describe your description of the medical model and enlighten us?

Not really. Since it's already been made clear that you're not reading what I've written anyway.

University of WA Family Nurse Practitioner program, MSN in 1985. And that in-depth knowledge comes from 31 years of practice, 4 states, a number of practice settings, a wide variety of positions in both inpatient and outpatient settings.

So again I ask, this gives you insight into what is taught in medical school in 2007...how?

Are you claiming only med school provides any worthwhile education? I couldn't possibly know anything about the medical model of patient care or subtle difference between nursing and physician philosophies from 30 years of working with physicians, 20 of which were in the role of family nurse practitioner, 17 of which have been in a very successful private solo practice? Listen to your snobbery.

Ye gads, who's defensive now?

Heck no, I'm claiming no such thing. I'm just claiming that perhaps I do know what is[/is] being taught in medical school. Mine, anyway. You seem to be assuming a lot about the curriculum.

It is a simple calculation. There are more UTIs in uncircumcised infants with no GU dysfunction than in circumcised infants with no GU dysfunction. Therefore you can expect at least some uncircumcised infants will have a UTI that necessitates an invasive work up which will be negative and which had they been circumcised would not have occurred. You don't need to prove which ones.

That works for the aggregate. For individual parents, not so much. And what's the difference? Apparently you agree with us that most parents do not want the procedure for preventive measure anyway--so why would this even be an issue?

And I have said many more than 3 times, I am not advocating routine circumcision. What I am saying never quite gets to the top of the top of the discussion pile. It's instead assumed repeatedly I am arguing for the medical benefit.

That would be because you keep quoting medical articles on UTI in support of your thesis.

I can understand being the infant's advocate. Except for a simple matter, where is the empirical evidence which the physician is deciding for the infant? As the infant's advocate, where does the evidence end, and the personal values begin?

For me, around the time when it comes to a permanent alteration of the body for non-medical reasons. I don't need empirical evidence arguing against not intervening--I need to support my position if I do intervene, or if I don't intervene and I should have taken some action.

I accused no one of insensitivity. You need to re-read what I said because it was the opposite.

You accused me of potentially telling the parents of a child who died of septicemia that their concerns were no big deal. That seems to me to be the very definition of insensitivity.

Retraction, please.

Tell me why if the evidence is equivocal, you should impose your values on someone else's child? You claim to not be paternalistic.

Once again--here you go again talking about risk and benefit, and then wondering why we think you're all talking about infection. I'm imposing nothing on the child. That's the point. Not taking the decision about whether to remove the foreskin out of the power of the individual to make is not 'imposing'.

Since I assume 'he' is Sylvester, here is yet another case where you are impliciting assuming the parents' chief concern is risk reduction:

SYLVESTER1592 said:
3) The hospital admission by itself is a risk factor and I don't want to seem insensitive, but to prevent one infection (ever), you need to circumcise more then a hundred men. Most of the infections are benign, you don't even know they had one.
skeptigirl said:
So?

My point is, you tell the parent what the actual risk is, the best you can. Then their values determine how they perceive that risk. Your job is to accurately describe the risk. Why do you see it as your job to also tell them how to value that risk. If they had a child who died, (again I'm just trying to illustrate we don't all get our values out of the same box), then do you think they are supposed to care that it takes a couple hundred circs to prevent one UTI and a couple thousand to prevent one hospitalization?

Again with the 'child who died'. Yes, you are giving the impression that you're talking about risks. Not values.

Originally Posted by SYLVESTER1592
3) The hospital admission by itself is a risk factor and I don't want to seem insensitive, but to prevent one infection (ever), you need to circumcise more then a hundred men. Most of the infections are benign, you don't even know they had one.
So?

If there was evidence of harm, you could argue you were the infant's advocate.

The harm is in having an unnecessary permanent alteration to the body in the absence of medical benefit.

Yet without empirical evidence to sway that decision, your position here is you will determine if you will perform the circumcision based on your value of the parents' motives. If they are motivated to prevent UTIs, you might 'approve' of their decision. If you disapprove of the parents' motive, you will 'allow' the decision but not approve.

*yawn* Again and again and again with the UTI. And the next time you post you'll just say again "I know most parents do it for other reasons! Show me where I said otherwise!"

Cripes.

I would approve of whatever decision the parents made, it is their child, their right, their values, not mine. I cannot say there is medical evidence allowing me to claim my medical expertise should supercede their values.

Really? Any decision? Any at all?
 
Since we are at post 1055 and since the issue of practice philosophy has a bearing on at least my part of this discussion, I think the little side discussion here is worth at least one more go. Frankly I'm disappointed my bringing up this particular issue has resulted in annoying some of those in the medical profession in this thread. Instead of a discussion on this room elephant, I have been accused of offending. Well, that's one of my weaker skills, always being tactful. Since I'm being demonized over this, I'm going to forgo further attempts at tactfulness and stick up for myself.

Was that really necessary?

The following come from the top of the lists on a Google search of "medical model paternalism" and "nursing model paternalism".

Poverty and Paternalism, A Psychiatric Viewpoint.

Which further specifies the paternalism within the medical model as that of an "altruistic servant" and one where physicians "put the welfare of the individual above that of the group". None of that seems to apply to your supposition that paternalism in medicine leads doctors to impose their will onto that of their patients.

Medical Paternalism; Allen Buchanan; Philosophy and Public Affairs, (1978) (I note this is dated, but I'm not so sure the concept has changed as much as Linda believes.)

Only if you believe that the medical code of ethics, which specifies that information should be conveyed to the patient in a complete and understandable manner, does not reflect the current medical model.


The article specifies that an interpretation of paternalism as an imposition of the physician's will is indefensible. This seems to contradict your supposition.


This one is about how paternalism flows from inequalities in knowledge and that a non-normative assumption allows that information to be value neutral. Again, this seems to contradict your supposition that paternalism leads to the imposition of physician values.


I am skeptical until I see support for the claims of widespread paternalism as described.


So paternalism in nursing is called beneficence instead.

None of what you provided supported your assertion that paternalism as you described is part of the medical model. Not only that, the descriptions of paternalism specifically denied the imposition of the physician's will or values.

Linda
 
Risk perception is the key factor here in my opinion. The public is not aware of the risk which infection and hospitalization alone carry. We live in a society where parents perceive vaccines to be riskier than the diseases the vaccines prevent because they have never seen a child die of measles or diphtheria.

And in this case, many (most?) of those posting in this thread have simply concluded that a UTI in a male infant is a minor event. I assume the thread members have had personal lives free from knowing children who have died from infection.
It isn't about whether UTI is minor event, or how often it occurs.

We all place a value/weight on factors as we consider them, and it seems that you have placed a big zero next to "body integrity", "loss of a sensory organ" and "risk of complications". I personally know the parents of two children who experienced rather serious complications from circumcision, requiring numerous reconstructive surgeries as the boys got older.

I don't give the risk factors you and others have mentioned a zero, but they don't get very high because circumcision isn't required to deal with those risk factors. To illustrate, if circumcision prevented measles just as effectively as the vaccine, it would not be a persuasive argument in favor of circumcision, because the risk for measles is easily addressed without the loss of a sensory organ.

Circumcision is done for religious, cultural, cosmetic, and superstitious reasons. I place a big fat zero next to all of these factors, and IMO objective medical professionals should as well, since we are talking about the permanent non-consentual removal of a sensory organ. Circumcision is almost never done for the medical "benefits" that have been heralded here.

Whenever we are talking about non-consentual removal of a healthy, functioning body part, it isn't enough to prove there is some slight overall medical advantage. The standard must be whether the procedure is medically necessary.

And this isn't just the removal of a body part, it is the removal of a sensory organ. And not just a sensory organ, a sexual sensory organ. Given the importance of human sexuality in the overall human experience, the question of whether to circumcise should be considered more carefully than (for example) a decision to amputate a functional but misformed digit for cosmetic purposes.

To go back to the point of circumcision and UTIs, in order for this to be a valid argument in favor of circumcision, the consequences of UTI would need to be severe, and circumcision would need to be the least destructive means available to deal with the risk. If, for example, you had data that showed that showed a significant risk of death or disability resulting from a UTI, and that circumcision was the only means available to effectively deal with that risk, I would find that persuasive.

I find it profoundly unpersuasive to say that circumcision is A-OK because it reduces the chance of UTIs, when UTIs are rare and easily treated without permanent body modification.

Circumcision is not a no-loss procedure -- ignoring complications, damage to an unconsenting individual's sexual organ is guaranteed! It seems that you are ignoring the damage done by the procedure in order to try to find some medical justification.

skeptigirl said:
So let me once again re-direct this discussion to the actual issue. Whose decision is it? Is the evidence against circumcision so strong that the physician is justified in promoting the physician's decision?
Legally, today it is the decision of the parents. That doesn't make it right, it just means unnecessary circumcision is one in a long list of injustices that are still allowed by the law. And parents who circumcise almost always are uneducated on the topic, completely unaware of any risks or benefits other than "old wives tales" (easier to clean, etc.).

If I take my child in to the doctor and demand some treatment that wouldn't be in my child's best interest, at the very least I would hope the doctor would educate me on the topic and try to dissuade me. If the procedure was unnecessary and could (or would) cause irreversible harm, I would expect the doctor to try to set me straight and ultimately refuse to perform the procedure. Something about "do no harm..." comes to mind.

skeptigirl said:
I would approve of whatever decision the parents made, it is their child, their right, their values, not mine. I cannot say there is medical evidence allowing me to claim my medical expertise should supercede their values.
As a society, we (wisely) allow parents to make decisions for their children only within certain bounds. IMO, a nurse or doctor's concern and loyalty should lie with the patient, and when the parents' desires and the patient's best interests are at odds, the medical professional should always choose the side of the patient.
 
In the past that was one of its uses. To humiliate.

What a mass of contradictions you are, skeptigirl; you support the empowerment of women and at the same time, parents to make choices for their boy that he would probably (based on evidence) not make for himself as an adult.
Ivor, you make this statement of fact and in the post above say[quyote]Based on the number of men who decide to change their circumcision status when capable, American parents suck at this intellectual exercise.

Perhaps they should be asked why they think their boy in particular is going to change his mind later in life if he's left intact, given that 80% of the men in the world aren't circumcised and the vast majority of them (including American men) do not change their minds?

The statistics don't support the decision to circumcise based on the likely wishes of the infant when he is older.[/quote]The risk of UTI is only in the young child in this case. So your adult analogy doesn't apply. In addition, you are hypothesizing uncircumcised men don't often desire circumcision, therefore men prefer to be uncircumcised. But neither do circumcised men often complain they preferred not to be circumcised. A more appropriate hypothesis is men prefer not to change.
 
Last edited:
It isn't about whether UTI is minor event, or how often it occurs.

We all place a value/weight on factors as we consider them, and it seems that you have placed a big zero next to "body integrity", "loss of a sensory organ" and "risk of complications". I personally know the parents of two children who experienced rather serious complications from circumcision, requiring numerous reconstructive surgeries as the boys got older.
Again I am misquoted. It's getting a bit ridiculous people here cannot read!

I am not for or against circumcision. I am for the parents' right to be the ones who decide. I have no reason to tell a parent whose values differ from yours, that they should adopt your values.
 
.
But neither do circumcised men often complain they preferred not to be circumcised. A more appropriate hypothesis is men prefer not to change.

Well, most circumcised men are either:
1) of a religion that 'requires' it
2) American, and were raised with the idea that it 'has to be done'.

Men who understand that it's not really necessary are more inclined to feel kind of ripped off. That's my anecdotal experience, at least, although being anecdotal and all, it could be wrong.
 
.

Well, most circumcised men are either:
1) of a religion that 'requires' it
2) American, and were raised with the idea that it 'has to be done'.

Men who understand that it's not really necessary are more inclined to feel kind of ripped off. That's my anecdotal experience, at least, although being anecdotal and all, it could be wrong.

Ouch!

:D
 
This is why I consider this an exercise in futility. I have never said that I was offended and explicitly stated otherwise, yet you continue to centre your argument around the idea that I was offended.
You said
post 690

Your contention that you provide education while physicians provide opinion in comparable situations may look different to a neutral third-party.

Post 745

When considering whether HawkeyeMD is unreasonably defensive, you may want to take into consideration that there is an implied "and doctors aren't" at the end of that last sentence (regardless of what you meant). You rush in to defend your profession when you see statements that misrepresent it. I don't think it is unreasonable to expect her to do the same.
Both of those statements say my discussion of the nursing and medical models was or could have been taken as offensive toward the medical profession. Yet it was never stated with the intent of claiming either nursing or medicine was the superior way to interact with patients. Both models have their place and sometimes one is better than the other. I brought it up because I believe it does apply, it does affect our relative positions here.

Post after post I support why I think the parents should control this decision and post after post I am described as supporting circumcision based on the medical evidence. Post after post I discuss why values of the providers are trumping the empirical medical evidence here. And post after post that issue is glossed over.

And what is one of the differences in our backgrounds that affects my view of the parent's rights here? It is the difference in the medical and nursing emphasis in patient care.

I gave examples from my experiences, you discredited those as examples not sufficing to illustrate the differences in nursing and medicine. So I went to the literature and it overflows with examples. If you are not offended then why are you refusing to consider it may indeed be one reason affecting the professional positions in this discussion?

Because the post was a strawman from beginning to end, and attempts to explain why had already been demonstrated to be futile.
This has nothing to do with the circumcision decision if that is the strawman you are referring to. But it does have to do with the negative reaction I have gotten in this thread for bringing up the issue of paternalism in medicine. If there is a situation where the medical model is better suited, physicians are well suited. But when the nursing model is better suited to some patient provider interactions, then there are many physicians who don't do as well as an experienced nurse. You seem to be saying nursing expertise is no more than common sense. Talk about offending a profession.

I'll have to finish later, I have an appointment right now.
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl, near the start of this thread you made these statements:
And a number of we females prefer a circumcised penis. I have no excuses, citations or explanations, I like them bald. Wrinkly skins are just not attractive. It's purely aesthetic, and not the least bit scientific.
<snip>

And my son was circumcised because I thought it was better according to the medical evidence, and I've not met a circumcised man that wasn't sexually satisfied and I have no moral qualms whatsoever about my decision. As it turns out, I had not heard of this controversy before I made that decision. However, after an extremely thorough review of the medical literature, I have no regrets about my decision.

Reading that, it seems you are for circumcision?

Again I am misquoted. It's getting a bit ridiculous people here cannot read!

I am not for or against circumcision. I am for the parents' right to be the ones who decide. I have no reason to tell a parent whose values differ from yours, that they should adopt your values.

Really? If you had to make the decision again, would you circumcise another son?
 
Ivor, you make this statement of fact and in the post above say
Based on the number of men who decide to change their circumcision status when capable, American parents suck at this intellectual exercise.

Perhaps they should be asked why they think their boy in particular is going to change his mind later in life if he's left intact, given that 80% of the men in the world aren't circumcised and the vast majority of them (including American men) do not change their minds?

The statistics don't support the decision to circumcise based on the likely wishes of the infant when he is older.
The risk of UTI is only in the young child in this case. So your adult analogy doesn't apply. In addition, you are hypothesizing uncircumcised men don't often desire circumcision, therefore men prefer to be uncircumcised. But neither do circumcised men often complain they preferred not to be circumcised. A more appropriate hypothesis is men prefer not to change.

Yes, it's called self-concept. Mentally healthy people generally like who they are, whatever their state is.

Let's do Linda's idea of adult Ivor considering being circumcised as an infant:

Ivor imagines standing over his infant self, 29 years ago, bald but with a full set of teeth, (nickname: Kojak) contemplating having painful plastic surgery on his penis.

He's informed this will reduce the risk of contracting a disease he would stand a 98.7% chance of never having in the first place and would stand an excellent chance of being treated with antibiotics if he did contract it, though in about 7.5% of cases it could cause the serious complication of renal scaring.

Adult Ivor also then thinks of all the fun times he and his foreskin have had in the last 30 years and proclaims:

Are you ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ NUTS! Get that scalpel away from my cock!
 
Ivor, Agreed. I would literally defend myself with lethal force if someone tried to circumsize me as an adult.

The entire practice is utterly disgusting and I seriously cannot understand how people are defending it. Must be some sort of brainwashing because I really don't get it.
 
Again I am misquoted. It's getting a bit ridiculous people here cannot read!

I am not for or against circumcision. I am for the parents' right to be the ones who decide. I have no reason to tell a parent whose values differ from yours, that they should adopt your values.
Misquoted? I quoted you directly.

It's beyond a question of "parental values" because it is the removal and/or impairment of a sensory organ without the informed consent of the patient. Such a decision is far too important to be left to the superstitions of the parents. We're not even talking about informed parental decisions here -- the decision to circumcise is usually made without consideration of the harm being done.

Trying again:
skeptigirl said:
Risk/cost vs benefit/risk of not doing

That is how you weigh risk benefit.
I've read every single post you've made in this thread, and I can't recall you ever giving any weight to the patient's rights or whether the patient would choose circumcision when they were capable of doing so. The consistent theme (which I admit you've backed up with references) in your posts has been to evaluate whether there was a demonstrable/statistical medical benefit to the procedure.

On the other hand, I suppose the only way we can have a discussion on this topic is to set aside the patient's rights and interests, and consider circumcision in the same light we would consider the disposition of any other property. Once the patient's rights and interests are considered, they far outweigh a statistical improvement in treatable rare condition (UTI).

Deaf parents who consider their deafness a blessing can't choose to deafen their child. Parents who desperately wanted a girl but gave birth to a boy, can't choose sexual reassignment surgery to get the girl they always wanted. Yes these are far-out examples, but they illustrate that parents' wishes aren't the ultimate consideration when considering permanent body alteration, especially one that results in the loss or impairment of a sensory organ.

It is not for the parents to decide whether a sensory organ should be removed or impaired, unless it is medically necessary. I'd like to see you specifically address the question of why you think parents should be allowed to decide to have their child's sensory organs removed and/or impaired without first establish that the procedure is medically necessary.

Quoting again for emphasis:
skeptigirl said:
I am for the parents' right to be the ones who decide. I have no reason to tell a parent whose values differ from yours, that they should adopt your values.
You've repeatedly dodged the question of FGM, but FGM applies equally to the above attitude you've expressed. The only difference is that you probably recognize the harm of FGM, but you ignore the harm of male circumcision.

skeptigirl said:
Post after post I support why I think the parents should control this decision and post after post I am described as supporting circumcision based on the medical evidence. Post after post I discuss why values of the providers are trumping the empirical medical evidence here. And post after post that issue is glossed over.
By saying that it is perfectly acceptable for parents, for whatever whimsical reason, to choose circumcision, you are supporting circumcision. You may not be advocating it, but you are certainly supporting it. And your posts leave me with the impression that you are opposed to doctors trying to dissuade parents from circumcising their children, as that is imposing the doctors values onto the parents. IMO that crosses over into advocacy in favor of circumcision, as it prevents the parents' choice from being educated.
 
http://www.infocirc.org/facts.htm
Quoted :
Urinary tract infection (UTI)
  • Worldwide, infant UTI is treated antibiotically, not amputatively.
  • In the 1980s, retrospective studies by Wiswell et al. suggested that 98-99% of intact (non-circumcised) male infants will not develop UTI (compared with his finding of 99.9% in circumcised male infants). In 1989, the AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) cautioned that Wiswell’s studies comparing the two groups may be methodologically flawed, and that the percentage of intact male infants who will not develop UTI may be even higher. Research in the 90s has since confirmed that Wiswell’s studies are flawed, as the AAP cautioned, and that the incidence of UTIs in intact male infants is significantly lower than the 1-2% he reported.
  • Females have higher rates of UTI in childhood and throughout life than either intact or circumcised boys.
  • European doctors cite American birthing practices, not the foreskin, as the cause of the U.S.’s allegedly higher rate of UTI in intact boys.
  • UTI in males often results from a congenital abnormality which predisposes the child to bacterial infection. Such congenital abnormalities have nothing to do with the foreskin.
  • Antimicrobial management of UTI in infants is routine, and the outcome generally good.
Penile Cancer
  • Among intact (i.e., non-circumcised) males, 99.999% will not develop penile cancer [The rate of penile cancer is 1 in 100,000. It is one of the rarest cancers, rarer even than male breast cancer.]
  • Testicular cancer strikes 1 in 300 males, prostate cancer 1 in 11. (Source: American Cancer Society)
  • It has been suggested that performing 100,000 infant circumcisions – thus removing in 100% of those circumcisions 100% of the foreskin’s irreplaceable health benefits – in order to possibly prevent an otherwise preventable cancer in one elderly man is absurd.
  • Annually, there are more infant deaths from infant circumcisions than deaths from cancer of the penis.
  • It has been erroneously claimed that penile cancer virtually never occurs in men who have been circumcised in infancy.
  • In a recent study on penile cancer, a full 20% of the study-group had been circumcised at birth.


http://www.caringforkids.cps.ca/babies/Circumcision.htm

Circumcision is a “non-therapeutic” procedure, which means it is not medically necessary. Parents who decide to circumcise their newborns often do so for religious, social or cultural reasons.



Therefore :
“Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?”

Nope.
 
OK, here we go.

My wife will give me oral gratification. She would not for a previous boyfriend who was not circumcised.

Game over.;)
 
"The entire practice is utterly disgusting and I seriously cannot understand how people are defending it. Must be some sort of brainwashing because I really don't get it."

Hear hear!
 
Ivor, Agreed. I would literally defend myself with lethal force if someone tried to circumsize me as an adult.

I'd defend my child with lethal force, but not necessarily myself..

Speaking of which, when I was born the doctors were going to circumsize me just because it was such a routine practice they didn't even think about it. My mom literally had to ask "where are you taking him?" and then "uh, no."

That was 1974 and apparently things are changing for the better. RIC is becoming less common.. although it's still too common IMO

I've never had a woman turn her nose up at my penis, or refuse to gratify me in any way. I was with a woman about (guessing) 15 years older than me recently, and she had never seen an uncut before. She didn't complain though :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom