This is rather an unfair conclusion. I tried to say something which was not taken as intended. It was a difficult concept to communicate. When my attempt to communicate the concept failed, I tried to clarify it. And now that I have restated it as I was originally attempting to, you choose to take your misunderstanding of what I said instead of the repeated clarifications of what I had tried to say.
Clearly I failed to communicate. That doesn't mean what you wrongly concluded I had said was factual. It means I failed to communicate. You were offended. I get it. But you were offended because you didn't understand what I was saying, because as you have now pointed out once again, it came across as my saying doctors were not patient advocates. Yet I never said that, you claim I implied it. Don't you think after all this time you've been reading my posts that if I believed nurses were good, doctors were bad or whatever it is you think I was saying, you wouldn't have read that sentiment in at least some of my previous posts by now?
This is why I consider this an exercise in futility. I have never said that I was offended and explicitly stated otherwise, yet you continue to centre your argument around the idea that I was offended.
I again tried to clarify what I had said in this post which was never responded to:
Because the post was a strawman from beginning to end, and attempts to explain why had already been demonstrated to be futile.
And then along comes Dr Sylvester bemoaning the fact he cannot always dictate to the patients what they should do, "The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision..."
The statement that you quoted does not reflect dictating to patients what they should do. You simply chose to interpret it differently from its intent in order to support that particular agenda.
I repeat, the nursing model differs from the medical model of care. I practice in both fields. I have observed the difference. It does not mean any individual nurse or doctor is restricted to these models. In fact, both professions have considerable overlap. We went through this already. But it seems you aren't willing to entertain the idea the original issue was simply failed communication. Instead you remain convinced after all this time that I have some belief/attitude never revealed until this thread that doctors are not patient advocates.
From my viewpoint, in this case, the idea nurses do not have any unique professional contribution to patient care is what seems to be the implication. Any attempt by me to discuss that unique professional perspective has been taken as insulting.
Again, you have misrepresented what has been said to you. I don't think this is purposeful, but I do think that you are so focussed on making sure that you are understood, that you haven't paid attention to making sure you understand others. Until that barrier has been breached, I don't see how further explanations on my part can make any difference.
Linda
