Tell me where you think my arguments are flawed and I'll either accept your criticism or try to explain what I think you have missed in them.
I think your arguments were flawed because you did not, at least initially, make any such differentiation. I also, to repeat, think that they are flawed because ultimately, you are comparing apples and oranges. Comparing beating a child or raping a woman, neither of which has any possible medical application, to a procedure that may in some cases be medically indicated, is an analogy that breaks down too soon to be useful. When you are trying to make the distinction between something that you find "wrong" and something that you find "outrageous", which I would take to mean that you find it unacceptable under any circumstances whatsoever, and you use examples like that, my response is that I find all of the situations that you outline to be outrageous. I would never agree that any of them are acceptable.
The idea that mores change and ethics are fluid over time is undeniable. I just question the utility of those examples in support of your thesis (i.e., that circumcision is not medically warranted in most cases).
I think the actual figures were Google and PubMed were correct 58% and 88% of the time, respectively. But I completely agree with you that where a physician's skill and training come in is being able to interpret symptoms and other information to figure out what's likely to be wrong with their patient.
That's completely meaningless to me. What's 'correct'? Especially when you are considering a question where evidence has to be evaluated and weighed, I have no idea how anyone would arrive at a number like that. Correct on what question? What year Columbus took sail from Spain? Most sites probably get that right. It means nothing in terms of medical evidence.
I can see how this may be the case for healthy and terminally ill people, but how could correct medical advice be different to serving the best interests of the patient if they are treatable?
'Treatable' is not the same thing as 'curable'. Most medical issues are not curable unless they involve infection (and not always then) or surgery (not always then either).
'Correct' medical advice is another fairly meaningless term. All physicians do not advise the same treatment given the same patient. Also, there's a medical truism that goes "the best treatment is the one the patient can tolerate'. If one medication is the 'best' for treating a particular condition, for example, but the patient doesn't like the side effects, they won't take it.
For that reason, among others, the best interests of the patient is something that can only be determined in conjunction with the patient, or his or her surrogate in cases where the patient is unable or unwilling to participate in his/her own medical decisions.
What I'm trying to get across to you is that medicine is usually more complicated that you seem to be making it out to be.
All I can say is the people I know must be really unlucky.
Shame. You going to change all that?
Well if all you say is "I don't know" and that's it then yes, it's pretty useless as an answer, other than to inform the patient that you can not be of assistance to them. However, "I don't know, but I know where/what I can try to find out" is both direct and useful.
What about the cases where the honest answer is "I don't know", full stop? Because nobody knows?
People do want answers, Ivor, especially when they or someone they love is sick or hurt. And many times we simply don't have an answer for them. My last week on peds we had a two-year-old who came in for what we thought was a preseptal cellulitis (a bacterial inflammation of the area around the eye) and who turned out to have a neuroblastoma. And there's no reason why. He just did. I can't find out why on Pubmed. Though I can look up incidences and outcomes and hope that they're 88% correct, whatever that means.
If it makes you feel better I think all professionals who deal with non-professionals behave in the same way. I'm not picking on doctors in particular.
I think that's a strangely glib attitude towards higher education, frankly. It also seems like you don't want me to say "I don't know" but you don't want me to pretend I know everything.
Kinda feel like I can't win in this scenario. You want to give just a little tiny bit of credit to those of us who really are, pinky finger to heaven, trying to do the best we can?
I don't mind people disagreeing with me so long as they know they are wrong and do what I want them to do
Oh, well then that's fine. Why didn't you say so in the first place?
The point is that I agree with a
lot of what you say, I just don't understand why you seem to need to take any disagreement with your arguments as being evidence of some moral failing on our (collective) part.