Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I'm trying to remember....are you a physician in the US?

Do you have an impression as to how much of this is physician led? I looked at some survey information which found that most parents had made the decision for or against circumcision before talking to the physician. And that very few changed their mind based on what the physician said. I said earlier that I thought measures directed at changing parents' attitudes and behaviours would probably be more effective than changing physicians' behaviour. But I haven't dismissed consideration of the physician's part (while trying not to stray into paternalism :)).



I touched on this idea earlier. I think that rejection of the procedure for religious reasons would have to come from the AAP or AMA, rather than individual practitioners.* Do you think that could happen in the current political climate in the US? I don't have a feel for how lightly secular organizations have to tread when it comes to the impact on religious choices.

Linda

*I'm willing to discuss this further if it doesn't make sense.

Nope not in the US, but in The Netherlands. We can refuse under the WGBO ( a law that handles the treatment agreement between physicians and patients in the Netherlands). I agree that in most cases patients have made their decision already, but physicians deal with medical reasons for a procedure not individual preference. Although I agree that we sometimes try to give the patients what they want, that does not necessarily make it a medical indication. We don't do circumcision for religious reasons, it can be done in a hospital, but we normally don't do that... (I reckon that must be a suprise :D )
The decision becomes a non-medical issue in the Netherlands. Actually, having a circumcision is not the norm in Europe. Religious reasons for a circumcision do occur here, but are often not part of hospital policy. Most patients know better then to ask the doctor for it over here, but we do see the complications. Some doctors do provide this service of circumcision, but it's not offered as standard medical treatment. If you ask for it it can be done, but does not get the label "religious" on it.

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
Nope not in the US, but in The Netherlands. We can refuse under the WGBO ( a law that handles the treatment agreement between physicians and patients in the Netherlands). I agree that in most cases patients have made their decision already, but physicians deal with medical reasons for a procedure not individual preference. Although I agree that we sometimes try to give the patients what they want, that does not necessarily make it a medical indication. We don't do circumcision for religious reasons, it can be done in a hospital, but we normally don't do that... (I reckon that must be a suprise :D )

I'm Canadian and it's not really a surprise. I was looking for some insight into US practices, but I see I'm closer to the action than you. :)

Linda
 
It seems you aren't sticking with the medical research and as your emotional response clarifies simply want to inflict genital mutilation on defenceless children for your own cosmetic reasons.

nonono.. admittedly, I've skipped a few of SG's posts, but I haven't seen ANY indication that she takes the position she takes for "her own cosmetic reasons." The medical argument is the only ethical defense of RIC, and to her credit, she's "sticking" to that "issue". (pun intended. sorry.)

So let's get it over with, shall we? It seems to me we could simply stack some numbers side-by-side and see how they compare. We've got at least one developed nation where RIC is common, and at least one where it is not. I don't have the numbers, but can we agree that those numbers would go a long way towards settling this?
 
So far I'm just as anti-circ as I was at the start of the thread, but I consider myself a highly rational and reasonable person and my mind can still be changed. Here's my tally of the debate:

cosmetic argument: invalid
cultural/Jew argument: invalid
ethical argument: negative (don't cut!)
sexual argument: negative (don't cut!)
medical argument: pending
 
You asked how a distinction could be made. Other than some superficial similarities, the tissues are anatomically, physiologically and embryologically different, which allows one to make a distinction on that basis.

No I didn't.

However even your point is quite easily countered - they end up serving a similar function e.g. sexual pleasure and sexual stimulation therefore functionally they are comparative across the sexes.

I have not made the claim that genital cutting is acceptable in males (I have stated that I am not in favour of genital cutting).

Yet that is part of the argument you made to try and explain why the comparison between some male and some female genital cutting are not appropriate.

...snip...

When grown men consent to circumcision for their son, they are essentially consenting to their own circumcision.

No they are not.


...snip...

If I am confident that they are making the choice freely, without coercion, I can't really justify intervening just because I consider the practice questionable.

...snip...

Since your starting premise is wrong this conclusion that is based on that is not necessarily correct.

...snip...

However, I have no confidence that females are freely consenting to FGC considering that they may not have the power to withhold their consent, and that the situation is strongly coercive when refusal leads to a life of abuse and ostracization.

I'm not trying to persuade (you seem to already feel strongly about this issue), but rather explain.

Linda

Yet you are not doing so you are merely repeating your assertions.
 
Then, once again, may I point out that your comparisons of the procedure to rape and child abuse and so forth are specious and inflammatory.

You may. I think the reason you think these acts are particularly different to circumcision is because you imagine they always involved an aggressive motive. E.g., no one who loved their child could let them be beaten with a cane, could they? No one who loved their wife could force themself on her, could they?

In the case of caning children, people really did think they were helping the child "learn" right from wrong.

I keep pointing out that essentially, I agree with your position, but the reason I said what I did above is because that just because I agree with what you are saying about circumcision does not mean that I agree with all of your arguments.

Tell me where you think my arguments are flawed and I'll either accept your criticism or try to explain what I think you have missed in them.

If you truly think that circumcision is analogous to the acts you instanced, then you should not find only unaenesthetized circumcision to be outrageous. Even if you were only using them to illustrate an underlying philosophical principle. I just find that inconsistent.

I find unaenesthetized circumcision to be outrageous. I find infant circumcision when not medically indicated (i.e. unlikely to have any medical benefit) wrong.

I find a child being burnt with a cigarette (for any reason) outrageous. I find a child being caned for fighting in school wrong.

I find a woman being raped by her husband outrageous. I find a woman who believes she cannot say 'no' to sex because it's her husbands right to demand it when he wants, wrong.

I'll admit the boundary between what I find wrong and what I find outrageous is purely personal. However, I think my reasoning is consistent.

If they don't, then the patient should probably get another doctor. That's just silly, Ivor. It isn't some kind of medical holier-than-thou attitude that makes medical professionals think they know more about the subject than most patients. Years of training and experience does have something to do with it.

It has been my experience that many professionals think (or behave as if) they know more than they actually do. I don't believe medical professionals are any different. My experiences to date with them have not made me change my mind.

It's actually quite refreshing to find a professional <insert profession here> who isn't afraid to admit they don't know something from their own field of expertise.

I know you meant this jokingly, but come on. Google and Pubmed are not good sources of medical knowledge unless you have the ability to read what you find on them critically. That presupposes a certain amount of knowledge. Using Google and Pubmed uncritically is how you wind up with all those websites against vaccination. This is not to say that laymen are incapable of using these sources critically--you seem to be a perfect example of one who is--but it is not a given.

I think the actual figures were Google and PubMed were correct 58% and 88% of the time, respectively. But I completely agree with you that where a physician's skill and training come in is being able to interpret symptoms and other information to figure out what's likely to be wrong with their patient.

You are confusing 'best interests' with 'medical advice'. They are two separate things. Which is what skeptigirl seems to think I don't understand, but I digress.

I can see how this may be the case for healthy and terminally ill people, but how could correct medical advice be different to serving the best interests of the patient if they are treatable?

Nope, I thought you were generalizing from personal or anecdotal evidence. :cool: Which, apparently, you were. :D

All I can say is the people I know must be really unlucky.

Perhaps I did. It is not, in fact, my experience that "I don't know" is usually considered by a patient to be a direct answer. :rolleyes:

Well if all you say is "I don't know" and that's it then yes, it's pretty useless as an answer, other than to inform the patient that you can not be of assistance to them. However, "I don't know, but I know where/what I can try to find out" is both direct and useful.

Mr. Randi's oft-quoted quip aside, again, I think you are over-generalizing. Since I have occasionally been accused of defensiveness ;) , I will just say that it does get tiresome to hear these same old stereotypes of doctors trotted out over and over again as implication that 'this is how doctors behave' or 'this is all doctors' attitude.'

If it makes you feel better I think all professionals who deal with non-professionals behave in the same way. I'm not picking on doctors in particular.

Right here on this forum, you have at least three MDs (if I am understanding correctly that Sylvester is also an MD) who I think have all been discussing both sides of this issue with a fair amount of knowledge and bringing up some very interesting points (at least, IMHO). I don't think any of them have implied that they have the Ultimate Answer to LTUAE. I keep reading your responses and it seems like nothing but complete agreement with your every point will do, Ivor. If you're going to discuss the medical evidence, fine. If you're going to discuss the ethical implications, fine. But I don't have to agree with everything you say about both, and it just seems to me that you're keeping arguments going instead of having real discussions because you will accept nothing less.

I don't mind people disagreeing with me so long as they know they are wrong and do what I want them to do:D

You don't have to agree with anything I say. But it would be nice when you don't if you could say why you don't. Then maybe we could both learn something.

Or should I just post abstracts from PubMed and say "Hmmmm. This looks interesting. Discuss."?
 
That was a pretty safe bet. After all, how often does anyone change their mind on a strongly held opinion.

Linda

I find the frequency of mind changing is inversely proportional to a persons' age, level of education and number of children:D
 
...When grown men consent to circumcision for their son, they are essentially consenting to their own circumcision. If I am confident that they are making the choice freely, without coercion, I can't really justify intervening just because I consider the practice questionable...

Linda

A legal definition does not equal right or (in this case) physically possible.

And who's saying intervene? Just say there is no medical reason to have the child circumcised (already done, I believe), it will hurt a lot during the procedure and for several days after and the foreskin is a functional body part.
 
Tell me where you think my arguments are flawed and I'll either accept your criticism or try to explain what I think you have missed in them.

I think your arguments were flawed because you did not, at least initially, make any such differentiation. I also, to repeat, think that they are flawed because ultimately, you are comparing apples and oranges. Comparing beating a child or raping a woman, neither of which has any possible medical application, to a procedure that may in some cases be medically indicated, is an analogy that breaks down too soon to be useful. When you are trying to make the distinction between something that you find "wrong" and something that you find "outrageous", which I would take to mean that you find it unacceptable under any circumstances whatsoever, and you use examples like that, my response is that I find all of the situations that you outline to be outrageous. I would never agree that any of them are acceptable.

The idea that mores change and ethics are fluid over time is undeniable. I just question the utility of those examples in support of your thesis (i.e., that circumcision is not medically warranted in most cases).

I think the actual figures were Google and PubMed were correct 58% and 88% of the time, respectively. But I completely agree with you that where a physician's skill and training come in is being able to interpret symptoms and other information to figure out what's likely to be wrong with their patient.

That's completely meaningless to me. What's 'correct'? Especially when you are considering a question where evidence has to be evaluated and weighed, I have no idea how anyone would arrive at a number like that. Correct on what question? What year Columbus took sail from Spain? Most sites probably get that right. It means nothing in terms of medical evidence.

I can see how this may be the case for healthy and terminally ill people, but how could correct medical advice be different to serving the best interests of the patient if they are treatable?

'Treatable' is not the same thing as 'curable'. Most medical issues are not curable unless they involve infection (and not always then) or surgery (not always then either).

'Correct' medical advice is another fairly meaningless term. All physicians do not advise the same treatment given the same patient. Also, there's a medical truism that goes "the best treatment is the one the patient can tolerate'. If one medication is the 'best' for treating a particular condition, for example, but the patient doesn't like the side effects, they won't take it.

For that reason, among others, the best interests of the patient is something that can only be determined in conjunction with the patient, or his or her surrogate in cases where the patient is unable or unwilling to participate in his/her own medical decisions.

What I'm trying to get across to you is that medicine is usually more complicated that you seem to be making it out to be.

All I can say is the people I know must be really unlucky.

Shame. You going to change all that? :cool:

Well if all you say is "I don't know" and that's it then yes, it's pretty useless as an answer, other than to inform the patient that you can not be of assistance to them. However, "I don't know, but I know where/what I can try to find out" is both direct and useful.

What about the cases where the honest answer is "I don't know", full stop? Because nobody knows?

People do want answers, Ivor, especially when they or someone they love is sick or hurt. And many times we simply don't have an answer for them. My last week on peds we had a two-year-old who came in for what we thought was a preseptal cellulitis (a bacterial inflammation of the area around the eye) and who turned out to have a neuroblastoma. And there's no reason why. He just did. I can't find out why on Pubmed. Though I can look up incidences and outcomes and hope that they're 88% correct, whatever that means. :boggled:

If it makes you feel better I think all professionals who deal with non-professionals behave in the same way. I'm not picking on doctors in particular.

I think that's a strangely glib attitude towards higher education, frankly. It also seems like you don't want me to say "I don't know" but you don't want me to pretend I know everything.

Kinda feel like I can't win in this scenario. You want to give just a little tiny bit of credit to those of us who really are, pinky finger to heaven, trying to do the best we can?

I don't mind people disagreeing with me so long as they know they are wrong and do what I want them to do:D

Oh, well then that's fine. Why didn't you say so in the first place? :rolleyes:

The point is that I agree with a lot of what you say, I just don't understand why you seem to need to take any disagreement with your arguments as being evidence of some moral failing on our (collective) part.
 
No I didn't.

You asked, "why the apparent discrepancy in viewing comparable forms of "genital tissue removal" (to try and avoid any accusations of using "emotive language") based on the sex of the patient?"

I was elaborating on why you saw a discrepancy in comparable forms, while others do not.

However even your point is quite easily countered - they end up serving a similar function e.g. sexual pleasure and sexual stimulation therefore functionally they are comparative across the sexes.

The contribution to that function is very different in amount and kind, though. Would it really be surprising to you to discover that men who were comfortable consenting to a circumcision on behalf of their son would balk at consenting to cutting off the penis altogether?

Yet that is part of the argument you made to try and explain why the comparison between some male and some female genital cutting are not appropriate.

My argument is that the degree of inappropriateness is related to the details of the relative procedures. It is not that the same procedure is mildly inappropriate in a man, but grossly inappropriate in a woman. It is that one procedure is mildly inappropriate and one is grossly inappropriate. It just so happens that the grossly inappropriate one is performed on women. It would also be grossly inappropriate if performed on men.

No they are not.

I can elaborate a bit. As I've mentioned before, the parent has to act as a surrogate decision maker for the child. They provide the answer to the question, "what would my child choose if they were fully capable of making this decision?" It is as though the future adult male were being asked what he would choose to have done to his infant self. When that circumcised infant grows up and becomes that future adult male, and it's time for him to make that decision for his own son, his consent at that time says that, if asked and capable, he would have consented to his own circumcision.

Since your starting premise is wrong this conclusion that is based on that is not necessarily correct.

Yet you are not doing so you are merely repeating your assertions.

It requires at least a little willingness on your part. I thought I'd give it a go.

Linda
 
It seems that much of your argument boils down to 'I choose to define those who disagree with me as emotional.'

I'd rather not visit a health worker who did that.
There are plenty of emotional posts here and at the same time, not everyone on either side of the discussion has posted emotional arguments.

However, your dismissal of everything I posted about the UTIs and about different people having different values by this attempt to attack the messenger isn't likely to lead to a productive discussion.

Try this key word:

equivocal
1 a : subject to two or more interpretations... b : uncertain as an indication or sign <equivocal evidence>
2 a : of uncertain nature or classification <equivocal shapes> b : of uncertain disposition toward a person or thing : UNDECIDED
 
That's kinda the opposite of what happened. What you did was say something that explicitly implied that physicians weren't patient advocates (as well as several other things). I pointed out (as did HawkeyeMD) that I didn't think that was what you were trying to say. I dropped the discussion as an exercise in futility, and I don't really see that anything has changed, so maybe you could leave me (maybe the others as well, but I don't speak for them) out of this?

Linda
This is rather an unfair conclusion. I tried to say something which was not taken as intended. It was a difficult concept to communicate. When my attempt to communicate the concept failed, I tried to clarify it. And now that I have restated it as I was originally attempting to, you choose to take your misunderstanding of what I said instead of the repeated clarifications of what I had tried to say.

Clearly I failed to communicate. That doesn't mean what you wrongly concluded I had said was factual. It means I failed to communicate. You were offended. I get it. But you were offended because you didn't understand what I was saying, because as you have now pointed out once again, it came across as my saying doctors were not patient advocates. Yet I never said that, you claim I implied it. Don't you think after all this time you've been reading my posts that if I believed nurses were good, doctors were bad or whatever it is you think I was saying, you wouldn't have read that sentiment in at least some of my previous posts by now?

I again tried to clarify what I had said in this post which was never responded to:
So, doctors, are you all saying anything nurses do, you can all do just as well. Nurses have no special patient care skills unique to their education and experience that physicians don't also have? Physicians learn everything nurses do in addition to physicians' medical education and experience. But of course, nurses can not do everything physicians can.

Does it make any sense that I might be trying to describe two sets of skills, two aspects of medical care, and that by doing so I am not saying the medical portion of the care is not as important?

Should I be offended if you say to me, as an NP, I have some medical education but in no way is it the equivalent of med school? That is a factual statement. Should I view it as insulting?

Because I don't. Yet if I try to describe one [of the] thing I think distinguishes physicians and nurses, You've all expressed being insulted by that.
And then along comes Dr Sylvester bemoaning the fact he cannot always dictate to the patients what they should do, "The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision..."

I repeat, the nursing model differs from the medical model of care. I practice in both fields. I have observed the difference. It does not mean any individual nurse or doctor is restricted to these models. In fact, both professions have considerable overlap. We went through this already. But it seems you aren't willing to entertain the idea the original issue was simply failed communication. Instead you remain convinced after all this time that I have some belief/attitude never revealed until this thread that doctors are not patient advocates.

From my viewpoint, in this case, the idea nurses do not have any unique professional contribution to patient care is what seems to be the implication. Any attempt by me to discuss that unique professional perspective has been taken as insulting.
 
But that would mean that you also disagree with the label of "female genital mutilation" for most of the female circumcisions that are carried out in the world (i.e. about 80-85% are Type 1 as defined by the WHO ETA - correction it is 85% for Type I & II combined can't find a figure for just Type 1) - which I have to say I don't think you do.

Why the apparent discrepancy in viewing comparable forms of "genital tissue removal" (to try and avoid any accusations of using "emotive language") based on the sex of the patient?
I don't favor the term, "mutilation", for all classes of this ritual scarring. However, in many cases, it is a very mutilating procedure with removal the clitoris and sewing the opening to the vagina all done with the implicit intent of preventing sexual intercourse until marriage. And such a marriage is often one dictated by the parents. It has many parallels to slavery.

I have respect for other cultural traditions. But I have thought this one through and knowing the benefits in my own culture when women were given equal rights (almost, a little more work to do) I have come to the decision to oppose certain cultural traditions which only serve to oppress women.

So, do you think circumcision has the goal of oppressing men?
 
Same old song, eh?

Linda (fls) has my authority to speak for me on this subject. Since the actual discussion was several pages before Sylvester joined in (S., I would be the medical student), and since he probably has better things to do than to exhaustively read what Linda correctly describes as an exercise in futility, perhaps you would be so kind as to do as she asks and leave us out of it, particularly since you stopped responding to us as soon as it was made clear that you a) weren't actually reading what we were saying and b) were unable to justify your conclusions.

The 'medical model' does not advocate paternalism. Since you are unwilling to release your inherent bias on this subject, it would be better for all concerned if you would, as I previously suggested, stop bringing it up as a justification.
Care to describe your description of the medical model and enlighten us?

Right, so you went to med school...where?

Which gives you an in-depth knowledge on what is taught there...how?
University of WA Family Nurse Practitioner program, MSN in 1985. And that in-depth knowledge comes from 31 years of practice, 4 states, a number of practice settings, a wide variety of positions in both inpatient and outpatient settings.

Are you claiming only med school provides any worthwhile education? I couldn't possibly know anything about the medical model of patient care or subtle difference between nursing and physician philosophies from 30 years of working with physicians, 20 of which were in the role of family nurse practitioner, 17 of which have been in a very successful private solo practice? Listen to your snobbery.

There is no possible way to definitively state 'the UTI is simply because the infant isn't circumcised.' Circumcised infants also get UTIs.
It is a simple calculation. There are more UTIs in uncircumcised infants with no GU dysfunction than in circumcised infants with no GU dysfunction. Therefore you can expect at least some uncircumcised infants will have a UTI that necessitates an invasive work up which will be negative and which had they been circumcised would not have occurred. You don't need to prove which ones.

It has been pointed out to you again and again, both by me and by Linda, that the evidence also does not support the theory that most parents are interested in circumcision because of risk reduction at all. As I believe Linda stated in a previous post, the most common reasons are things like tradition, religion and because the father is circumcised.
Find a post where I claimed otherwise.

My point has been that I do not think that these are sufficient medical reasons to perform a procedure that permanently alters the body. As I have also said, and this is the third time, it might indeed be something to consider in a child with recurrent UTI, or for parents who are primarily concerned with UTI--although as a patient advocate, I would certainly have to point out that the medical evidence is equivocal on this point--as you have agreed.
And I have said many more than 3 times, I am not advocating routine circumcision. What I am saying never quite gets to the top of the top of the discussion pile. It's instead assumed repeatedly I am arguing for the medical benefit.

So let me once again re-direct this discussion to the actual issue. Whose decision is it? Is the evidence against circumcision so strong that the physician is justified in promoting the physician's decision?

My philosophy is to give the information, give the facts, but because there is no clear evidence tipping the balance here, the decision belongs to the parents. There is a lot of personal opinion tipping the balance here. There is not a lot of empirical evidence tipping the balance.

I can understand being the infant's advocate. Except for a simple matter, where is the empirical evidence which the physician is deciding for the infant? As the infant's advocate, where does the evidence end, and the personal values begin?

Sylvester has summed up the medical evidence that was discussed in the first 25 pages of this thread admirably. This is essentially my position in a nutshell.

The problem is that you keep trying to make this about "not respecting the parent's decision", ignoring the fact that the decision is generally not made on the basis of risk reduction, and then bolstering your argument by statistics on infection. Then, when it is pointed out yet again that the medical evidence is equivocal on whether the procedure has value as a preventive measure, you accuse the doctor of insensitivity or paternalism. It is arguing in a circle.
I accused no one of insensitivity. You need to re-read what I said because it was the opposite. And I quoted what was a paternalistic statement. How about addressing the statement he made explaining why it wasn't paternalistic.

Tell me why if the evidence is equivocal, you should impose your values on someone else's child? You claim to not be paternalistic. No medical model, that is supposedly my false assertion. If there was evidence of harm, you could argue you were the infant's advocate. I couldn't find any empirical evidence of harm sufficient to say that it was greater than the empirical evidence of benefit. Both are small. But at the same time, there are scenarios where one person might value harm over potential benefit and in other scenarios, benefit over potential harm.

Yet without empirical evidence to sway that decision, your position here is you will determine if you will perform the circumcision based on your value of the parents' motives. If they are motivated to prevent UTIs, you might 'approve' of their decision. If you disapprove of the parents' motive, you will 'allow' the decision but not approve.

I would approve of whatever decision the parents made, it is their child, their right, their values, not mine. I cannot say there is medical evidence allowing me to claim my medical expertise should supercede their values.
 
Last edited:
Since we are at post 1055 and since the issue of practice philosophy has a bearing on at least my part of this discussion, I think the little side discussion here is worth at least one more go. Frankly I'm disappointed my bringing up this particular issue has resulted in annoying some of those in the medical profession in this thread. Instead of a discussion on this room elephant, I have been accused of offending. Well, that's one of my weaker skills, always being tactful. Since I'm being demonized over this, I'm going to forgo further attempts at tactfulness and stick up for myself. The following come from the top of the lists on a Google search of "medical model paternalism" and "nursing model paternalism".

Poverty and Paternalism, A Psychiatric Viewpoint.
...The first is to underscore that my conception of paternalism comes from the medical model. ....


Medical Paternalism; Allen Buchanan; Philosophy and Public Affairs, (1978) (I note this is dated, but I'm not so sure the concept has changed as much as Linda believes.)
There is evidence to show that among physicians in this country the medical paternalist model is a dominant way of conceiving the physician-patient relationship...


Medical paternalism and the fetus
Abstract

A number of developments in the medical field have changed the debate about the ethics of abortion. These developments include: advances in fetal physiology, the increase in neonatal intensive care and the survival rates of premature infants. This paper discusses the idea of selective termination and the effects that these decisions have on disabled people of today. It presents a critique of the counselling services that are provided for the parents of a disabled fetus and discusses how this is viewed from a social perspective. The article ends with an argument that the mother deserves to be autonomous in the decision of abortion. The easiest and most fair way to develop her autonomy is to consider the relationship between a professional and a mother as an expert–expert relationship. Here both parties are considered experts in diagnostic information, treatment options, possibilities, and their history, family roots, philosophy and way of life, respectively


The Second Fifty Years: Promoting Health and Preventing Disability (1992); Institute of Medicine
The medical model is usually defined in sociological terms. In fact, the classic analysis of Talcott Parsons30 provides the identifying criteria of the medical model: exculpation from responsibility, eligibility for benefits, assumption of the "sick role," and yielding of decision-making authority to medical professionals.

Nonnormativism is a key, albeit neglected, element of the medical model. The assumption of decision-making authority by medical professionals is directly linked to the presumption that doctors can objectively assess dysfunction and disorder and then act to restore proper functioning, whether it be mental or physical. Although critics of the medical model sometimes chafe at the paternalism that is an omnipresent aspect of institutionally based health care, they fail to see that paternalism is a direct result of the presumption of nonnormativism. If doctors do not need to make value judgements in diagnosing and treating illness and disease, and if they are able to detect facts about disease or impairment that are not and cannot be known to those who seek their care, then there is little to fear on the part of patients who cede authority to professionals as part of taking on the "sick role." The medical model is social, but it is also epistemological, and in large measure the social acceptance of the medical model rests on the acceptance of the value-neutrality inherent in the epistemology of nonnormativism, which dominates medicine.


Paternalism in Nursing and Healthcare: Central Issues and their Relation to Theory
William K. Cody, RN; PhD; Professor and Chair, Family and Community Nursing, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, [email protected]

Paternalistic practices, wherein providers confer a treatment or service upon a person or persons without their consent, ostensibly by reason of their limited autonomy or diminished capacity, are widespread in healthcare and in societies around the world. In the United States, paternalism in health and human services is widespread and probably increasing with newly emergent forms. Numerous issues surround paternalistic practices. In this column, the author examines these issues in relation to theory development in healthcare and nursing as well as theory as a guide to practice. It is suggested that scientific and ethical knowing are not separate but must be united in theoretical structures that include both in unity, along with an appreciation of the infinite complexity of life as it is humanly lived. It is also suggested that nursing's unique theory base of frameworks that honor human dignity and focus on human experience offers an opportunity for leadership in further developing theoretical frameworks that transcend paternalistic practices.

Key Words: autonomy • beneficence • human dignity • nursing theory • paternalism • universalism


Restraints: a current perspective - management of nursing home patients - Nursing Care
Actions done in the patient's own best interest but that override the patient's autonomous choice can be defined as paternalism. Neither beneficence nor paternalism is all good or all bad. What the health care provider needs to realize is that, even with the best of intentions, they may find no satisfactory solution to a problem they face. Moreover, risks are inherent in any choice or approach taken. No matter how beneficent are one's motives, the outcomes may still be poor.

Beneficence is certainly not limited to the nursing profession. Concern for the patient's best interest motivates all of medical care. In the medical model, action is usually taken quickly to minimize the possibility of any further harm.

The civil liberty model is another model that is used to weigh the rights of the individual against the need to provide protective services when the individual is unable to care for himself or herself. Unlike the medical model, however, there are a variety of procedural safeguards built into the civil liberty model to protect the person's freedom. The proof rests upon those who would restrict that freedom.(4)

Let's go back to the major dilemma. How do we balance our value system of beneficence with the patient's value system of independence and his or her right to choose a course of action?

Six Guidelines

There are no easy answers. There are guidelines, however, from the civil liberty model to evaluate the patient's right for autonomy in the light of our concerns for patient safety.....


The critical point here is I am not claiming good and evil. The best health care comes from a balance of nursing and medical care, regardless of provider or combinations of providers. There is no denying the underlying differences in the nursing and medical models of patient care. But we both practice some of each. In this particular discussion, I believe it is the parents' choice and if the providers are going to find that unacceptable, there ought to be sufficient medical evidence that no one need be debating whether personal values are obscuring objectivity. The evidence of harm and evidence of medical benefit are equivocal. Individuals here have strikingly different measures of the value attached to the harm and the benefit, but where is the empirical medical evidence which supports the provider's decision? And if there isn't such empirical medical evidence, then why do the parents not have the legitimate position of decision makers?
 
I think your arguments were flawed because you did not, at least initially, make any such differentiation. I also, to repeat, think that they are flawed because ultimately, you are comparing apples and oranges. Comparing beating a child or raping a woman, neither of which has any possible medical application, to a procedure that may in some cases be medically indicated, is an analogy that breaks down too soon to be useful. When you are trying to make the distinction between something that you find "wrong" and something that you find "outrageous", which I would take to mean that you find it unacceptable under any circumstances whatsoever, and you use examples like that, my response is that I find all of the situations that you outline to be outrageous. I would never agree that any of them are acceptable.

Something I find outrageous I would try to stop there and then. Something I find wrong I would try to change over a longer timescale.

The idea that mores change and ethics are fluid over time is undeniable. I just question the utility of those examples in support of your thesis (i.e., that circumcision is not medically warranted in most cases).

There are two parts to my argument, one which you agree with and one you don’t. The first is that the medical evidence does not support infant circumcision in the vast majority of cases.

The second is the ethics of operating on a non-consenting (using the common-sense definition of consent) individual, causing them to suffer for an unlikely benefit and potentially doing them short and/or long-term harm.

That's completely meaningless to me. What's 'correct'? Especially when you are considering a question where evidence has to be evaluated and weighed, I have no idea how anyone would arrive at a number like that. Correct on what question? What year Columbus took sail from Spain? Most sites probably get that right. It means nothing in terms of medical evidence.

From wiki on differential diagnosis:

wiki said:
A recent study by Tang and Ng (BMJ 2006;333:1143-5) examined the effectiveness of Google searches in diagnosing extremely hard and/or unusual cases that are featured in the New England Journal of Medicine's case reports. These are cases that are challenging enough to merit publication in this leading journal. A quick search on 3 to 5 main words or phrases regarding the case found a correct diagnosis 58 % of the time. One responder (Wentz) replicated the study using the PUBMED database, and found the correct diagnosis to these challengingly difficult cases 88% of the time. (Groves T. 2007. "Can Google help you to diagnose patients' problems" sBMJ. Jan. Vol 15. p. 20-21.)

Use of rapid database searches as a tool to aid in differential diagnosis is still in its early stages of development and adoption. It will most likely meet with considerable resistance from some experts, and be the subject of valuable ongoing study and debate.

'Treatable' is not the same thing as 'curable'. Most medical issues are not curable unless they involve infection (and not always then) or surgery (not always then either).

'Correct' medical advice is another fairly meaningless term. All physicians do not advise the same treatment given the same patient. Also, there's a medical truism that goes "the best treatment is the one the patient can tolerate'. If one medication is the 'best' for treating a particular condition, for example, but the patient doesn't like the side effects, they won't take it.
For that reason, among others, the best interests of the patient is something that can only be determined in conjunction with the patient, or his or her surrogate in cases where the patient is unable or unwilling to participate in his/her own medical decisions.

What I'm trying to get across to you is that medicine is usually more complicated that you seem to be making it out to be.

Thank you for your explanation. Sorry that I gave you the impression I did not appreciate the complexities of choosing suitable medical treatments.

Shame. You going to change all that? :cool:

Some people I know tried and the only nurse prepared to testify about the negligent mistakes she witnessed suddenly changed her mind. It’s now the doctors’ word against theirs. Doesn’t sound like a particularly fruitful exercise.

What about the cases where the honest answer is "I don't know", full stop? Because nobody knows?

That’s fine by me. I don’t expect anyone to know everything or everything to be known.

People do want answers, Ivor, especially when they or someone they love is sick or hurt. And many times we simply don't have an answer for them. My last week on peds we had a two-year-old who came in for what we thought was a preseptal cellulitis (a bacterial inflammation of the area around the eye) and who turned out to have a neuroblastoma. And there's no reason why. He just did. I can't find out why on Pubmed. Though I can look up incidences and outcomes and hope that they're 88% correct, whatever that means. :boggled:

My father died of a glioblastoma last year. I don’t remember spending long on the question of why he developed it. My first thought was ‘he’s f*****d’, quickly followed ‘how long has he got?’ by followed by ‘what treatments are available?’ and finally ‘am I likely to get it?’. The last three Google and PubMed were quite useful in finding the ‘correct’ answers.

I think that's a strangely glib attitude towards higher education, frankly. It also seems like you don't want me to say "I don't know" but you don't want me to pretend I know everything.

What I’ve learned from my own higher education is that I can only ever expect to know a tiny amount of what is already known in my current expertise. My body of knowledge is quite tall but pretty narrow.

Kinda feel like I can't win in this scenario. You want to give just a little tiny bit of credit to those of us who really are, pinky finger to heaven, trying to do the best we can?

I give people who work with the general public and help others a lot of respect and credit.

The point is that I agree with a lot of what you say, I just don't understand why you seem to need to take any disagreement with your arguments as being evidence of some moral failing on our (collective) part.

I have failed to convince you (or any other medical professional here) that there is an ethical double-standard in the medical profession with respect to performing an infant male circumcision for unlikely benefit. I’ve currently run out of ideas of what I can say to get you or others to understand why I see it as a double-standard. Would you (or others) like to try to convince me why it is not?
 
I can elaborate a bit. As I've mentioned before, the parent has to act as a surrogate decision maker for the child. They provide the answer to the question, "what would my child choose if they were fully capable of making this decision?" It is as though the future adult male were being asked what he would choose to have done to his infant self. When that circumcised infant grows up and becomes that future adult male, and it's time for him to make that decision for his own son, his consent at that time says that, if asked and capable, he would have consented to his own circumcision.

Linda

Based on the number of men who decide to change their circumcision status when capable, American parents suck at this intellectual exercise.

Perhaps they should be asked why they think their boy in particular is going to change his mind later in life if he's left intact, given that 80% of the men in the world aren't circumcised and the vast majority of them (including American men) do not change their minds?

The statistics don't support the decision to circumcise based on the likely wishes of the infant when he is older.
 
I don't favor the term, "mutilation", for all classes of this ritual scarring. However, in many cases, it is a very mutilating procedure with removal the clitoris and sewing the opening to the vagina all done with the implicit intent of preventing sexual intercourse until marriage. And such a marriage is often one dictated by the parents. It has many parallels to slavery.

I have respect for other cultural traditions. But I have thought this one through and knowing the benefits in my own culture when women were given equal rights (almost, a little more work to do) I have come to the decision to oppose certain cultural traditions which only serve to oppress women.

So, do you think circumcision has the goal of oppressing men?

In the past that was one of its uses. To humiliate.

What a mass of contradictions you are, skeptigirl; you support the empowerment of women and at the same time, parents to make choices for their boy that he would probably (based on evidence) not make for himself as an adult.
 
There are two parts to my argument, one which you agree with and one you don’t. The first is that the medical evidence does not support infant circumcision in the vast majority of cases.

The second is the ethics of operating on a non-consenting (using the common-sense definition of consent) individual, causing them to suffer for an unlikely benefit and potentially doing them short and/or long-term harm.

You haven't been reading anything I've written if you don't think I agree with you on both of these points. I must have said it twenty times. I don't agree with routine circumcision for non-medical reasons. I even said I don't intend to perform routine circumcision for non-medical reasons. I also said I wouldn't do anything to try and stop a parent who wanted it done for other reasons from having it done elsewhere. That could mean a colleague who feels differently, a mohel, whatever. I've explained that in a procedure with equivocal medical benefits, the eventual right of a child to choose for himself has for me at least an equal weight with the parents' wishes.

This seems entirely consistent with both of your points. What I haven't understood is why you then keep trying to get me to agree with further ethical comparisons that I *don't* agree with. The only possible point on which I don't seem to agree with you is on the idea that this is directly analogous to child abuse. Your statement that you would try and change something you thought was only 'wrong' and not 'outrageous' over a larger period of time is also consistent with what I'm saying. The reason I'm not agreeing with your examples is that rape and child abuse are things which I would actively try to prevent.


My father died of a glioblastoma last year. I don’t remember spending long on the question of why he developed it. My first thought was ‘he’s f*****d’, quickly followed ‘how long has he got?’ by followed by ‘what treatments are available?’ and finally ‘am I likely to get it?’. The last three Google and PubMed were quite useful in finding the ‘correct’ answers.

I'm sorry to hear it. Mine died in 2005, during my first year of med school, of a sudden heart attack. It's very difficult.

I have failed to convince you (or any other medical professional here) that there is an ethical double-standard in the medical profession with respect to performing an infant male circumcision for unlikely benefit. I’ve currently run out of ideas of what I can say to get you or others to understand why I see it as a double-standard. Would you (or others) like to try to convince me why it is not?

No, because I basically *agree* with you--and you didn't even have to convince me, I felt that way before the conversation started. What I keep telling you is that your posts give the impression that unless I agree with every nuance of your argument, I am still somehow disagreeing with you. That's why I keep saying it feels like you're battering at me.
 
You haven't been reading anything I've written if you don't think I agree with you on both of these points. I must have said it twenty times. I don't agree with routine circumcision for non-medical reasons. I even said I don't intend to perform routine circumcision for non-medical reasons. I also said I wouldn't do anything to try and stop a parent who wanted it done for other reasons from having it done elsewhere. That could mean a colleague who feels differently, a mohel, whatever. I've explained that in a procedure with equivocal medical benefits, the eventual right of a child to choose for himself has for me at least an equal weight with the parents' wishes.

This seems entirely consistent with both of your points. What I haven't understood is why you then keep trying to get me to agree with further ethical comparisons that I *don't* agree with. The only possible point on which I don't seem to agree with you is on the idea that this is directly analogous to child abuse. Your statement that you would try and change something you thought was only 'wrong' and not 'outrageous' over a larger period of time is also consistent with what I'm saying. The reason I'm not agreeing with your examples is that rape and child abuse are things which I would actively try to prevent.




I'm sorry to hear it. Mine died in 2005, during my first year of med school, of a sudden heart attack. It's very difficult.



No, because I basically *agree* with you--and you didn't even have to convince me, I felt that way before the conversation started. What I keep telling you is that your posts give the impression that unless I agree with every nuance of your argument, I am still somehow disagreeing with you. That's why I keep saying it feels like you're battering at me.

Sorry.:o
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom