Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I refer you to all my past posts.
I'll play advocate for the devil and state that this is a nice avoiding argument.
The physician has a responsibility too...
The parents don't choose a procedure, they have the right to agree with it or reject it. The physician chooses the procedure... Both for male and female circumcision.
You just proved my point about the medical and the nursing models of patient care.
Now I'll wait for the other two MDs and the 4th yr medical student to gripe at me again for my previous comments on this matter before going back over some of those issues.
I knew that was going to muck up my example as soon as I used it. Accept the flaw in my analogy, I was well aware of it.A child consent does not matter in sexual abuse. It is statutory rape, no matter what the child "chooses"...
More evidence of the different patient provider philosophy I have from you. I was admonished this was more individual than professional so I'll remind the other providers here I did acquiesce to that position with the caveat I still think the educational and professional experiences have a significant influence on one's philosophy.The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision...
And now you're going to have to find my past posts to know what the heck I am talking about.
This is silly. Where is your evidence any of these are universal positions? And are you looking at different motivations women have in seeking plastic surgery from disguising aging which I believe is not unique to the female gender and those women who want what they perceive as more attractive features? Is weight reduction surgery the same as breast enlargement surgery? And how many women ever concern themselves with FGM? Some women I know probably haven't even heard of it.I have not even discussed women who decide to have genital plastic surgery for aesthetic reasons at an age at which they can decide for themselves, which far outnumbers the female circumcisions, but which comes very close to the same thing.
Feminists have made female circumcision their new flagship, but remain advocates for male circumcision while claiming the right to alter their body as they see fit including the same genital mutilation they abhore, but ofcourse by a plastic surgeon for aesthetic reasons...
So your combination of beliefs is overgeneralized to say the least.
So you don't buy the medical lit you posted about reducing UTIs? I guess I'd better go read the links. Perhaps they don't say what I assumed from the titles.My point is: this is not really about medicine in most cases. It is about lobbies, puritan ideas from the 1900's in the US, hundreds of years of religious ideas, Yes, some medical benefits for specific groups in specific circumstances exist, but only few for a specific group of men. If there is a medical indication, I see no problem, but in most cases there isn't a medical reason.
Actually, doctors don't do tattoos to my knowledge.Let's imagine:
suppose that parents would decide to give their child a tattoo instead of a circumcision. It is done to a child at a young age. Reason: the parents want it. Is a doctor obliged to comply?
SYL![]()
(*Given that the medical evidence supports the UTI risk reduction and that any other situation where there was no evidence of medical benefit would allow a different decision on your part.)
). Either way, there is going to be several days of discomfort after the procedure, from both mild infection and the exposed sensitive glans being irritated by clothing (or a nappy in the case of infants). Being strapped down to a table by the wrists and ankles is obviously distressing for many infants.