Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

:D

I'll play advocate for the devil and state that this is a nice avoiding argument.
The physician has a responsibility too...
The parents don't choose a procedure, they have the right to agree with it or reject it. The physician chooses the procedure... Both for male and female circumcision.
I refer you to all my past posts. :D

You just proved my point about the medical and the nursing models of patient care. ;)

Now I'll wait for the other two MDs and the 4th yr medical student to gripe at me again for my previous comments on this matter before going back over some of those issues.

A child consent does not matter in sexual abuse. It is statutory rape, no matter what the child "chooses"...
I knew that was going to muck up my example as soon as I used it. Accept the flaw in my analogy, I was well aware of it.

The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision...
More evidence of the different patient provider philosophy I have from you. I was admonished this was more individual than professional so I'll remind the other providers here I did acquiesce to that position with the caveat I still think the educational and professional experiences have a significant influence on one's philosophy.

And now you're going to have to find my past posts to know what the heck I am talking about. ;)

I have not even discussed women who decide to have genital plastic surgery for aesthetic reasons at an age at which they can decide for themselves, which far outnumbers the female circumcisions, but which comes very close to the same thing.

Feminists have made female circumcision their new flagship, but remain advocates for male circumcision while claiming the right to alter their body as they see fit including the same genital mutilation they abhore, but ofcourse by a plastic surgeon for aesthetic reasons...
This is silly. Where is your evidence any of these are universal positions? And are you looking at different motivations women have in seeking plastic surgery from disguising aging which I believe is not unique to the female gender and those women who want what they perceive as more attractive features? Is weight reduction surgery the same as breast enlargement surgery? And how many women ever concern themselves with FGM? Some women I know probably haven't even heard of it.

So your combination of beliefs is overgeneralized to say the least.

My point is: this is not really about medicine in most cases. It is about lobbies, puritan ideas from the 1900's in the US, hundreds of years of religious ideas, Yes, some medical benefits for specific groups in specific circumstances exist, but only few for a specific group of men. If there is a medical indication, I see no problem, but in most cases there isn't a medical reason.
So you don't buy the medical lit you posted about reducing UTIs? I guess I'd better go read the links. Perhaps they don't say what I assumed from the titles.

Let's imagine:
suppose that parents would decide to give their child a tattoo instead of a circumcision. It is done to a child at a young age. Reason: the parents want it. Is a doctor obliged to comply?

SYL :)
Actually, doctors don't do tattoos to my knowledge. :D But you are back to apples and oranges. My example was the parents who had lost a previous child to infection. If they valued the reduction of risk of UTI in their healthy newborn, would you tell them your values (in this case*) superceded theirs?

(*Given that the medical evidence supports the UTI risk reduction and that any other situation where there was no evidence of medical benefit would allow a different decision on your part.)
 
Reviewing your citations, RESULTS. Serious bacterial illness (SBI) was diagnosed in 44 (10.3%) of 429 infants:
41 with bacteruria and 4 with bacteremia
Although the infants with bacteruria were evenly split along gender lines, from the data available, uncircumcised males had a 22.5 times greater risk compared with circumcised males. Unfortunately, circumcision status was unrecorded in 39 infants; however, even in the unlikely event that all of them were uncircumcised (none of whom had bacteruria), the observed rate of bacteruria in uncircumcised males is still 13-fold higher. Previously published reports have found uncircumcised males at greater risk for urinary tract infections; some investigators advocate circumcision for repeated urinary tract infections.17,18 Our data corroborate previously noted association of race with incidence of bacteruria.19–22 Lower incidence of vesicoureteral reflux in blacks compared with other racial groups might partially account for the lower incidence of bacteruria.19,23

Clinical and Demographic Factors Associated With Urinary Tract Infection in Young Febrile Infants
Results. A total of 1025 (67%) of 1513 eligible patients were enrolled; 9.0% of enrolled infants received a diagnosis of UTI. Uncircumcised male infants had a higher rate of UTI (21.3%) compared with female (5.0%) and circumcised male (2.3%) infants. Infants with maximum recorded temperature of ≥39°C had a higher rate of UTI (16.3%) than other infants (7.2%). After multivariable adjustment, UTI was associated with being uncircumcised (odds ratio: 10.4; bias-corrected 95% confidence interval: 4.7–31.4) and maximum temperature (odds ratio: 2.4 per °C; 95% confidence interval: 1.5–3.6). Factors that were reported previously to be associated with risk for UTI in infants and toddlers, such as white race and ill appearance, were not significantly associated with risk for UTI in this cohort of young infants.

Conclusions. Being uncircumcised and height of fever were associated with UTI in febrile infants who were ≤60 days of age. Uncircumcised male infants were at particularly high risk and may warrant a different approach to screening and management.

The question is whether the risk reduction is worth the cost: loss of sensation/or other sexual benefits & inability to directly consent. Re the former, while there are plenty of emotional pleas and anecdotes from individuals, the literature is mixed.

I supported a couple other considerations such as any UTI in a child under age two necessitated antibiotic maintenance until a full GU exam was completed including either a nuclear medicine study or an IVP. In addition, UTIs in infants often required IV antibiotics and hospitalization, both of which carry additional risks in themselves. I think such risks are often left out of risk benefit analyses.
 
Last edited:
....

If we forget the religious reasons for a while and the lack of benefits in later life. There may be a benefit in early life between 2 and 6 months. When you consider the high mortality risk in the first year and a higher risk for UTI for boys in the first year, it may have made sense 1000 years ago......

SYL :)
Looking again at this post, I think you could drop a 0 off that 1,000. I remind you that antibiotics were a 20th century discovery. And in less than a century we are facing more than a few multi-drug resistant strains of common bacterial pathogens. New antibiotics are so far not looking so side effect free, and to say they are a tad expensive is an understatement.
 
I would say this is far more an emotional argumentation then the rest of the comments, and I presume it is not even about you... weird
I have some comments to this rant:
1) preventing UTI is only effective for age 2 months to 6 months after that females catch up with males (uncircumcised) and after the 4th year have far more infections than males. So the infection argument is only valid if there if an infection problem in the first year of life and only if it's recurrent and not easily treated by antibiotics.
Females have a larger number of UTI's (far exceeding men for various reasons: toilet training, hygiene, short urethra....etc)
The rate of UTIs in any group other than the one in question is irrelevant. Are you mixing arguments here, because I don't get your point. If there were some procedure in girls which reduced UTIs and one was arguing for male circs but not the equivalent female procedure then your argument would make sense. Otherwise, what relevance is this?


2) the potentially life threatening infection is very rarely caused by a cystitis. A nephritis which is less frequent and even rare in men even at a young age, often occurs in conjunction with other abnormalities (vesico-ureteral reflux= VUR). This may require surgery, but not always a circumcision and even circumcision in conjunction with VUR treatment may not lead to significant results. To prevent renal scaring it is hypothesized that there may be an effect but it has not been proven yet as far as I know. The medical committees of the AAP leave room for the treatment but do not endorse it. Compared to the European population you would expect a huge reduction in child mortality if circumcision was that effective and if your estimation of it's effects were true. It's not there... I don't think that American children are healthier then European ones. (I think it's rather the opposite, for different reasons)
The AAP and the AAFP find the evidence equivocal. I have never stated otherwise. My position is since the evidence suggests some risk reduction and there is not strong evidence of harm, it is the parents' values that should influence the decision, not mine.

3) The medical effects were not noticed out of the blue and then researched, the urological and pediatric tradition in North America is to perform this procedure and that leads to a follow-up of possible benefits. Research is often led by funding and the fund for the research exist in North America. The European studies are less positive and remain very skeptical.
I think you misunderstood my post. Ivor was claiming someone should study FGM to see if there were any medical benefits. I said show me some evidence and suggest an hypothesis. What was it he was proposing anyone look for? I said one doesn't just start studying things at random. There was evidence of lower UTI and HIV rates first, then the hypotheses, then the research.

4) the same reasons apply against circumcision in men as in women. The difference is your cultural viewpoint. So if we are going to put our emotions aside and look critically, let's do that and try to separate what you know from what you are taught.

SYL :)
That would be true if there were no UTI risk reduction. You can say in your opinion, the risk reduction doesn't warrant the procedure. I would say the medical evidence of risk reduction is clear. The question is one of how much one values the benefit of lowered risk of UTI. My example of the parents who had lost a previous child to infection was to illustrate a case where one might very legitimately have developed different values on which they were basing this decision.
 
Last edited:
Risk perception is the key factor here in my opinion. The public is not aware of the risk which infection and hospitalization alone carry. We live in a society where parents perceive vaccines to be riskier than the diseases the vaccines prevent because they have never seen a child die of measles or diphtheria.

<snip>

Risk perception influences those decisions but one cannot achieve a risk free life or protect your children from all risks. That's why I maintain this decision is up to the parents and how they perceive the risks and benefits, on what they value.

<snip>

What I don't think is right are those who cannot recognize that for some people the right decision is to reduce the risk of infection. We make decisions about what level and kinds of risks we want our children to have all through their young lives. I am comfortable telling parents I expect them to put that child in a proper vehicle restraint and they need a smoke alarm and a fire escape. I am not comfortable telling them they shouldn't value the benefit of circumcising their child because I have personal emotional feelings about the matter.

OK, I understand better than you might think, but while trying not to be insensitive.

A few things:

1) the work up for boys is because there is a high chance that there is a anatomical or functional problem when they start getting UTI's.

2) The risk perception is rather out of wack, the children dying due to a complicated UTI is very low in previously healthy children without antomical defects, so is the antibiotic resistance in bacteria that cause UTI (urea is a rather hostile substance to bacteria when they can't produce urease, this means the selection is less based on the antibiotic treatment, most uropathogens are not multiresistent, patients with a permanent cathether is a different story)

3) The hospital admission by itself is a risk factor and I don't want to seem insensitive, but to prevent one infection (ever), you need to circumcise more then a hundred men. Most of the infections are benign, you don't even know they had one.

4) When it comes down to the really ill children, with serious recurrent infections and no good way to stop it, I truly understand that pediatricians and pediatric urologists choose circumcision as a last resort that may have an additional positive effect. As a doctor a large part of the job is to support your patient and in pediatrics the parents both emotionally and with good advice. When it comes to advice, reason is a better advisor then emotions (it may be hard to do, but is necessary)

5) The problem in this thread is not circumcision for a medical indication, but as an infectious disease prevention of dubious effect, performed on the general population before they can consent to it. Parents choose and are often led by their physician. The physician gives them the advice... either to go on with it or not to do it. As a prevention strategy it is pointless and still a surgical procedure, with risks.
Most often these are not as gruesome as some people think, but definitely problematic in later life: circumcision too short with pain, too long with irritation, not wel alligned...
Ofcourse there are also the normal postoperative problems: pain, infection, bleeding,...

So in conclusion: I'm sorry if this sounds very insensitive, but as a prevention strategy, I would reject it. As a medical treatment, I would consider it. As an "aesthetic preference", I think it's just wrong in so many ways... I wouldn't know where to start. For religious reasons, you need someone else then a doctor, I don't think I could fully understand that in the way that would be required.

P.S.
Read the literature carefully. It is written with purpose, every word is weighed and should be read as such. I showed the oldest most strongly supporting evidence and foundation of the perceived benefit of this procedure in modern medicine. It was showed purposely, because it shows why there may be a benefit and that it entails a very limited group for a very limited time (this is the 2months- 6months group, after that there is no point, you start a prevention measure that is aimed at the lowest risk group, after the maximal effect has passed with all the risks of the treatment: compare with giving a cocktail flu shot after you had the flu). In later studies, the limitations were confirmed and the effects were questioned more and more. However, in severely ill patients it may be the basis on which a doctor can choose to try this as a last resort. When the risks are higher in a population, prevention becomes more effective...

For the plastic surgery part: it's similar because the operation, does essentially the same, just a lot neater with less damage
The mental picture of the tattoo is used for the same reason as the plastic surgery (actually some plastic surgeons do place tattoos, more specifically the skin of burn victims), to change your perspective and make you think in a less emotionally involved way, to clarify the essence of what you are looking at and why you make the decisions that you make.

I'm sure this will render a point by point discussion why you are right and I am wrong,... But the simple fact that children in Europa are not worse of, should illustrate the relatively small part (if any) that circumcision plays in the health care of children.

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
Risk/cost vs benefit/risk of not doing

That is how you weigh risk benefit.

In your appendectomy example you left out the risk/cost of taking the appendix out.

That presumes that it is any different from cutting bits of the genitals of defenceless infants, which you have not demonstrated. Unfortunately simply asserting your conclusion does not make it correct.

You appear not to understand that anyone could use exactly the same argument to you, as, without any valid justification, you have apparently defined yourself as the appropriate arbiter of the meaning of risk and reward and therefore that other viewpoints are by definition wrong, as you suggest in your post.

Unfortunately this is another demonstration of resorting to euphemism as a method of avoiding the reality of what you are advocating, which is the genital mutilation of defenceless children.

Please let us know if you would let anyone chop a bit off your genital organs without your permission because they had satisfied themselves there was a positive risk/reward outcome?
 
OK, I understand better than you might think, but while trying not to be insensitive.
It wasn't insensitivity. I had a previous discussion that my position was influenced by my background as a patient advocate. The 2 MDs and med student interpreted that to mean I felt they weren't. But what I was trying to say was the medical model was more paternalistic, physicians tell patients what they need. Again, I am merely speaking of the medical model and the educational and professional influence, not that all providers were one way or the other.

As a nurse practitioner, I had a nursing education first, and my medical education was completely different from what one gets in med school. I've been trying to verbalize the difference but haven't been too successful so far. The whole focus of nursing is directed toward giving control back to the patient. So regardless of individual providers, our professions grew from different philosophies.

I don't think you are being insensitive. I think you are working in the medical model and I am working in the nursing model. We are seeing the problem differently. However, I think in this case, I am looking at a side of this that other people seem to not see. And it is my nursing expertise that gives me my perspective.

A few things:

1) the work up for boys is because there is a high chance that there is a anatomical or functional problem when they start getting UTI's.
That reinforces my point. If the UTI is simply because the infant isn't circumcised, then being uncircumcised leads to unnecessary invasive medical procedures.

2) The risk perception is rather out of wack, the children dying due to a complicated UTI is very low in previously healthy children without antomical defects, so is the antibiotic resistance in bacteria that cause UTI (urea is a rather hostile substance to bacteria when they can't produce urease)
The medical literature does not put the risk of UTI at zero. Again, I'm not arguing the risk suggests circumcision should be recommended. I am arguing it is the parent's values that matter here, not whether you or I think the risk is minimal. You (if I may be so bold) are in the medical mode thinking it is up to you to decide what is the acceptable risk for this child. There is not a question of some risk reduction, there is some. There also isn't a compelling argument that circumcised men are protesting in droves. The evidence is mixed and while a few people have strong feelings in the matter, the actual research doesn't support that those feelings are terribly widespread.

In nursing mode, I find the parents' values judging the value of risk reduction are what matters in this case. Who am I to tell them what to value? Yes, when the evidence is not so equivocal, then I have the expertise to tell them and I certainly spend a lot of time educating patients about risk. But in this case, one has to be darn careful that you are talking actual risk with those parents. Are you so sure that what you are calling "insensitive" to the parents might not really be insensitivity to the risk?

3) The hospital admission by itself is a risk factor and I don't want to seem insensitive, but to prevent one infection (ever), you need to circumcise more then a hundred men. Most of the infections are benign, you don't even know they had one.
So?

My point is, you tell the parent what the actual risk is, the best you can. Then their values determine how they perceive that risk. Your job is to accurately describe the risk. Why do you see it as your job to also tell them how to value that risk. If they had a child who died, (again I'm just trying to illustrate we don't all get our values out of the same box), then do you think they are supposed to care that it takes a couple hundred circs to prevent one UTI and a couple thousand to prevent one hospitalization?

4) ... When it comes to advice, reason is a better advisor then emotions (it may be hard to do, but is necessary)
And one must separate emotions from values. In addition, one must be at least aware that values and our own emotions are coloring our interpretation of the evidence as well.

5) The problem in this thread is not circumcision for a medical indication, but as an infectious disease prevention of dubious effect, performed on the general population before they can consent to it. Parents choose and are often led by their physician. The physician gives them the advice... either to go on with it or not to do it.
I find some patients want my advice. But others are more satisfied when I give them information and they make decisions.

As a prevention strategy it is pointless and still a surgical procedure, with risks.
Most often these are not as gruesome as some people think, but definitely problematic in later life: circumcision too short with pain, too long with irritation, not wel alligned...
Ofcourse there are also the normal postoperative problems: pain, infection, bleeding,...
I don't think the medical evidence supports this conclusion.

So in conclusion: I'm sorry if this sounds very insensitive, but as a prevention strategy, I would reject it....

....

I'm sure this will render a point by point discussion why you are right and I am wrong,... But the simple fact that children in Europa are not worse of, should illustrate the relatively small part (if any) that circumcision plays in the health care of children.

SYL :)
Back this up with some evidence and I'll always consider it. I pride myself on professional growth that comes with an insatiable appetite for more reading. But just on your 'gut' feeling, I am not convinced.

Nine% of those serious bacterial infections in those febrile kids in one of your citations had bacturia. That's a lot of UTIs that circumcisions could potentially prevent. That's a lot of hospitalizations that could be prevented. And that's a lot of invasive procedures that could be prevented.
 
Last edited:
That presumes that it is any different from cutting bits of the genitals of defenceless infants, which you have not demonstrated. Unfortunately simply asserting your conclusion does not make it correct.

You appear not to understand that anyone could use exactly the same argument to you, as, without any valid justification, you have apparently defined yourself as the appropriate arbiter of the meaning of risk and reward and therefore that other viewpoints are by definition wrong, as you suggest in your post.

Unfortunately this is another demonstration of resorting to euphemism as a method of avoiding the reality of what you are advocating, which is the genital mutilation of defenceless children.

Please let us know if you would let anyone chop a bit off your genital organs without your permission because they had satisfied themselves there was a positive risk/reward outcome?
I am not much affected by this absurd portrayal of a circumcision. I'll stick with the medical research, thank you.
 
... I am not comfortable telling them they shouldn't value the benefit of circumcising their child because I have personal emotional feelings about the matter.

It seems that much of your argument boils down to 'I choose to define those who disagree with me as emotional.'

I'd rather not visit a health worker who did that.
 
I am not much affected by this absurd portrayal of a circumcision. I'll stick with the medical research, thank you.
Let us take you thorugh it one more time then.

'Circumcision is genital mutilation of a defenceless child.'
Instead of merely asserting that your argument is correct in a very emotional manner would you be so kind as to tell me specifically which one (or more) of those words is absurd?

You claim that you will stick to the medical research. Perhaps you have not heard that 'In the UK, routine circumcision isn't thought to be medically necessary. This is because the risks associated with having a surgical procedure that involves a general anaesthetic and the possible postoperative complications outweigh any possible medical benefits.' from http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/conditions/circumcision1.shtml
The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend routine circumcision.

The American Medical Association states that decreases in urinary-tract infections among infants and penile cancer among adults are not significant enough to warrant the procedure.

The Australian Association of Pediatric Surgeons says that "We do not support the removal of a normal part of the body, unless there are definite indications to justify the complications and risks which may arise."

It seems you aren't sticking with the medical research and as your emotional response clarifies simply want to inflict genital mutilation on defenceless children for your own cosmetic reasons.
 
Last edited:
It wasn't insensitivity. I had a previous discussion that my position was influenced by my background as a patient advocate. The 2 MDs and med student interpreted that to mean I felt they weren't.

That's kinda the opposite of what happened. What you did was say something that explicitly implied that physicians weren't patient advocates (as well as several other things). I pointed out (as did HawkeyeMD) that I didn't think that was what you were trying to say. I dropped the discussion as an exercise in futility, and I don't really see that anything has changed, so maybe you could leave me (maybe the others as well, but I don't speak for them) out of this?

Linda
 
Parents choose and are often led by their physician. The physician gives them the advice... either to go on with it or not to do it.

I'm trying to remember....are you a physician in the US?

Do you have an impression as to how much of this is physician led? I looked at some survey information which found that most parents had made the decision for or against circumcision before talking to the physician. And that very few changed their mind based on what the physician said. I said earlier that I thought measures directed at changing parents' attitudes and behaviours would probably be more effective than changing physicians' behaviour. But I haven't dismissed consideration of the physician's part (while trying not to stray into paternalism :)).

So in conclusion: I'm sorry if this sounds very insensitive, but as a prevention strategy, I would reject it. As a medical treatment, I would consider it. As an "aesthetic preference", I think it's just wrong in so many ways... I wouldn't know where to start. For religious reasons, you need someone else then a doctor, I don't think I could fully understand that in the way that would be required.

I touched on this idea earlier. I think that rejection of the procedure for religious reasons would have to come from the AAP or AMA, rather than individual practitioners.* Do you think that could happen in the current political climate in the US? I don't have a feel for how lightly secular organizations have to tread when it comes to the impact on religious choices.

Linda

*I'm willing to discuss this further if it doesn't make sense.
 
I am not much affected by this absurd portrayal of a circumcision. I'll stick with the medical research, thank you.

But that would mean that you also disagree with the label of "female genital mutilation" for most of the female circumcisions that are carried out in the world (i.e. about 80-85% are Type 1 as defined by the WHO ETA - correction it is 85% for Type I & II combined can't find a figure for just Type 1) - which I have to say I don't think you do.

Why the apparent discrepancy in viewing comparable forms of "genital tissue removal" (to try and avoid any accusations of using "emotive language") based on the sex of the patient?
 
Last edited:
But that would mean that you also disagree with the label of "female genital mutilation" for most of the female circumcisions that are carried out in the world (i.e. about 80-85% are Type 1 as defined by the WHO ETA - correction it is 85% for Type I & II combined can't find a figure for just Type 1) - which I have to say I don't think you do.

Why the apparent discrepancy in viewing comparable forms of "genital tissue removal" (to try and avoid any accusations of using "emotive language") based on the sex of the patient?

Most cases of FGC (female genital cutting - less emotive?) do not remove tissue that is analogous to that removed in the male circumcision. Type 1 is with or without partial or complete excision of the clitoris. According to this report from 2005 (previously supplied by KellyB), removal of all or part of the clitoris is included in the majority of the procedures in many countries where it is practised (table on page 40).

The second component is the degree of control available to women within the culture where FGC is practiced, and the consequences of not having the procedure. This profound difference also makes the two incomparable when it comes to issues of choice.

Linda
 
It wasn't insensitivity. I had a previous discussion that my position was influenced by my background as a patient advocate. The 2 MDs and med student interpreted that to mean I felt they weren't. But what I was trying to say was the medical model was more paternalistic, physicians tell patients what they need. Again, I am merely speaking of the medical model and the educational and professional influence, not that all providers were one way or the other.

Same old song, eh?

Linda (fls) has my authority to speak for me on this subject. Since the actual discussion was several pages before Sylvester joined in (S., I would be the medical student), and since he probably has better things to do than to exhaustively read what Linda correctly describes as an exercise in futility, perhaps you would be so kind as to do as she asks and leave us out of it, particularly since you stopped responding to us as soon as it was made clear that you a) weren't actually reading what we were saying and b) were unable to justify your conclusions.

The 'medical model' does not advocate paternalism. Since you are unwilling to release your inherent bias on this subject, it would be better for all concerned if you would, as I previously suggested, stop bringing it up as a justification.

As a nurse practitioner, I had a nursing education first, and my medical education was completely different from what one gets in med school.

Right, so you went to med school...where?

Which gives you an in-depth knowledge on what is taught there...how?

That reinforces my point. If the UTI is simply because the infant isn't circumcised, then being uncircumcised leads to unnecessary invasive medical procedures.

There is no possible way to definitively state 'the UTI is simply because the infant isn't circumcised.' Circumcised infants also get UTIs.

It has been pointed out to you again and again, both by me and by Linda, that the evidence also does not support the theory that most parents are interested in circumcision because of risk reduction at all. As I believe Linda stated in a previous post, the most common reasons are things like tradition, religion and because the father is circumcised.

My point has been that I do not think that these are sufficient medical reasons to perform a procedure that permanently alters the body. As I have also said, and this is the third time, it might indeed be something to consider in a child with recurrent UTI, or for parents who are primarily concerned with UTI--although as a patient advocate, I would certainly have to point out that the medical evidence is equivocal on this point--as you have agreed.

Sylvester1592 said:
So in conclusion: I'm sorry if this sounds very insensitive, but as a prevention strategy, I would reject it. As a medical treatment, I would consider it. As an "aesthetic preference", I think it's just wrong in so many ways... I wouldn't know where to start. For religious reasons, you need someone else then a doctor, I don't think I could fully understand that in the way that would be required.

Sylvester has summed up the medical evidence that was discussed in the first 25 pages of this thread admirably. This is essentially my position in a nutshell.

The problem is that you keep trying to make this about "not respecting the parent's decision", ignoring the fact that the decision is generally not made on the basis of risk reduction, and then bolstering your argument by statistics on infection. Then, when it is pointed out yet again that the medical evidence is equivocal on whether the procedure has value as a preventive measure, you accuse the doctor of insensitivity or paternalism. It is arguing in a circle.

Darat said:
But that would mean that you also disagree with the label of "female genital mutilation" for most of the female circumcisions that are carried out in the world (i.e. about 80-85% are Type 1 as defined by the WHO ETA - correction it is 85% for Type I & II combined can't find a figure for just Type 1) - which I have to say I don't think you do.

Why the apparent discrepancy in viewing comparable forms of "genital tissue removal" (to try and avoid any accusations of using "emotive language") based on the sex of the patient?


Darat, good luck with that one. :cool:
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl,

Any advantages of FGM have not been discovered because the procedure has not been adopted by the medical community and what is actually removed is highly variable compared to male circumcision.

You may not want to accept my statement:

So ignoring the magnitude of the complications (which can be just as serious as renal scaring), for a group of healthy boys circumcision will cause more problems than it prevents.

but that is what the best available evidence indicates. You keep on finding small studies compared to the cohort of 400000 boys, which showed just over a 1% absolute risk reduction for UTI, giving a NNT of ~100. The complication rate is estimated to be from 2-10%. Even taking the lower figure, more complications arise in circumcised boys because of circumcision than UTI's in uncircumcised boys.

So, tell me why the studies you quote are more likely to be true than a cohort study with over 400000 boys. Tell me why the estimate of a 2% complication rate is too high.

Then there is the pain and distress that the infant experiences, both during and after the procedure. EMLA is not totally effective at reducing the pain during the procedure (and is not always (often) used:eye-poppi). Either way, there is going to be several days of discomfort after the procedure, from both mild infection and the exposed sensitive glans being irritated by clothing (or a nappy in the case of infants). Being strapped down to a table by the wrists and ankles is obviously distressing for many infants.

Are these facts provided to parents by physicians? I doubt it. Just the 2% complications for 1% benefit should be enough to dissuade parents without a hefty bias toward circumcision from electing to have the procedure performed.

Please stop using the fact than most circumcised men are not protesting. They have never known any different. Or those men who needed to be circumcised for medical reasons are "satisfied" with the results. Satisfaction is relative. I'm satisfied with my appendix unless it gets infected. If it does I'll be satisfied with a scar on my body and with it removed.

And finally, as Sylvester1592 has already pointed out, if circumcision was providing a worth-while benefit to American boys it would show up in morbidity and mortality rates between similar cultures that do and do not circumcise their infants.

It's probably going to be the insurance companies who stop it in America, by refusing to pay a few hundred dollars for a non-essential procedure and one that is often largely done for cosmetic reasons to be performed on millions of infants.

HawkeyeMD said:
Maybe because you only see "persuasion" as "total agreement with and expression of equal outrage with Ivor"?

Just a thought, y'know.

No, it was actually because I was expecting intelligent people to see the logic of my arguments, rather than come up with excuses and exceptions as to why this particular form of mutilation is acceptable for members of their profession to practice on mass.

BTW, I only find the idea of circumcisions performed without effective pain relief outrageous.

HawkeyeMD said:
Disclaimer: none of the following is intended to address the question of circumcision directly.

Point one: what you believe is in the best interests of the patient is not, by a strict definition, what the best interests of the patient necessarily is.

True, but physicians do tend to sell themselves on the idea that they know better than the patient what is medically required for their condition;) Though Google and Pubmed run a pretty close second:D

Point two: where are you getting this "order of the day" stuff? If you do decide to go into this profession, Ivor, you will find that schools spend a great deal of time going over the concepts of explaining risks and benefits, patient autonomy, and informed consent. The idea that "no communication at all" is a norm of medicine or nursing is not only a complete straw man, but appears to me to reveal a very deep bias on your part.

It has been my experience in the UK that medical professionals rarely convey an accurate idea of the level of pain or discomfort a procedure is going to cause. I’ll add that I often think it is a good thing. I don’t think a physician or nurse saying to a patient “Now Mr. Jones, this is really going to hurt during/after.” would be in the best interests of the patient in many cases.

Perhaps you thought I was implying physicians and nurses do not empathise with the patient?

Point three: You greatly underestimate the complexity of the practice of medicine if you think that most questions are as simple as "a direct question deserves a direct answer". I would like to point out that this forum deals with a large number of people who profess certainty on difficult questions, people who have definite answers and who have no problem explaining this certainty to their patients at great length, and to describe what they do as 'safe', 'natural', 'painless', 'noninvasive' and 'nontoxic', among many other reassuring terms.

Do I need to go on, or do you see where I'm going with this?

I understand what you’re saying but think you misunderstood what I meant by ‘direct answer’. All questions have a direct answer, even if it is “I don’t know”. For some reason that answer is not seen as professional by many physicians, along with the statement “I was wrong”.
 
No, it was actually because I was expecting intelligent people to see the logic of my arguments, rather than come up with excuses and exceptions as to why this particular form of mutilation is acceptable for members of their profession to practice on mass.

BTW, I only find the idea of circumcisions performed without effective pain relief outrageous.

Then, once again, may I point out that your comparisons of the procedure to rape and child abuse and so forth are specious and inflammatory.

I keep pointing out that essentially, I agree with your position, but the reason I said what I did above is because that just because I agree with what you are saying about circumcision does not mean that I agree with all of your arguments.

If you truly think that circumcision is analogous to the acts you instanced, then you should not find only unaenesthetized circumcision to be outrageous. Even if you were only using them to illustrate an underlying philosophical principle. I just find that inconsistent.

True, but physicians do tend to sell themselves on the idea that they know better than the patient what is medically required for their condition;) Though Google and Pubmed run a pretty close second:D

If they don't, then the patient should probably get another doctor. That's just silly, Ivor. It isn't some kind of medical holier-than-thou attitude that makes medical professionals think they know more about the subject than most patients. Years of training and experience does have something to do with it.

I know you meant this jokingly, but come on. Google and Pubmed are not good sources of medical knowledge unless you have the ability to read what you find on them critically. That presupposes a certain amount of knowledge. Using Google and Pubmed uncritically is how you wind up with all those websites against vaccination. This is not to say that laymen are incapable of using these sources critically--you seem to be a perfect example of one who is--but it is not a given.

You are confusing 'best interests' with 'medical advice'. They are two separate things. Which is what skeptigirl seems to think I don't understand, but I digress.

It has been my experience in the UK that medical professionals rarely convey an accurate idea of the level of pain or discomfort a procedure is going to cause. I’ll add that I often think it is a good thing. I don’t think a physician or nurse saying to a patient “Now Mr. Jones, this is really going to hurt during/after.” would be in the best interests of the patient in many cases.

Perhaps you thought I was implying physicians and nurses do not empathise with the patient?

Nope, I thought you were generalizing from personal or anecdotal evidence. :cool: Which, apparently, you were. :D

I understand what you’re saying but think you misunderstood what I meant by ‘direct answer’. All questions have a direct answer, even if it is “I don’t know”. For some reason that answer is not seen as professional by many physicians, along with the statement “I was wrong”.

Perhaps I did. It is not, in fact, my experience that "I don't know" is usually considered by a patient to be a direct answer. :rolleyes:

Mr. Randi's oft-quoted quip aside, again, I think you are over-generalizing. Since I have occasionally been accused of defensiveness ;) , I will just say that it does get tiresome to hear these same old stereotypes of doctors trotted out over and over again as implication that 'this is how doctors behave' or 'this is all doctors' attitude.'

Right here on this forum, you have at least three MDs (if I am understanding correctly that Sylvester is also an MD) who I think have all been discussing both sides of this issue with a fair amount of knowledge and bringing up some very interesting points (at least, IMHO). I don't think any of them have implied that they have the Ultimate Answer to LTUAE. I keep reading your responses and it seems like nothing but complete agreement with your every point will do, Ivor. If you're going to discuss the medical evidence, fine. If you're going to discuss the ethical implications, fine. But I don't have to agree with everything you say about both, and it just seems to me that you're keeping arguments going instead of having real discussions because you will accept nothing less.
 
Most cases of FGC (female genital cutting - less emotive?) do not remove tissue that is analogous to that removed in the male circumcision. Type 1 is with or without partial or complete excision of the clitoris. According to this report from 2005 (previously supplied by KellyB), removal of all or part of the clitoris is included in the majority of the procedures in many countries where it is practised (table on page 40).

Which makes it very comparable since male genital cutting removes tissue very rich in nerves and significantly reduces the overall sensitivity of the male genitals - as does some Type I female genital cutting.

The second component is the degree of control available to women within the culture where FGC is practiced,and the consequences of not having the procedure. This profound difference also makes the two incomparable when it comes to issues of choice.

Linda

You've asserted this before however you have not so far as I am aware substantiated your claim that this makes genital cutting acceptable in males but not in female. (Indeed societies and cultures that routinely practice genital cutting use the same arguments and social and cultural pressures regardless of which sex they favour cutting.)
 
Which makes it very comparable since male genital cutting removes tissue very rich in nerves and significantly reduces the overall sensitivity of the male genitals - as does some Type I female genital cutting.

You asked how a distinction could be made. Other than some superficial similarities, the tissues are anatomically, physiologically and embryologically different, which allows one to make a distinction on that basis.

You've asserted this before however you have not so far as I am aware substantiated your claim that this makes genital cutting acceptable in males but not in female. (Indeed societies and cultures that routinely practice genital cutting use the same arguments and social and cultural pressures regardless of which sex they favour cutting.)

I have not made the claim that genital cutting is acceptable in males (I have stated that I am not in favour of genital cutting). I am attempting to figure out when someone else's ideas cross the line - when my concerns should be allowed to supersede someone else's. When grown men consent to circumcision for their son, they are essentially consenting to their own circumcision. If I am confident that they are making the choice freely, without coercion, I can't really justify intervening just because I consider the practice questionable. However, I have no confidence that females are freely consenting to FGC considering that they may not have the power to withhold their consent, and that the situation is strongly coercive when refusal leads to a life of abuse and ostracization.

I'm not trying to persuade (you seem to already feel strongly about this issue), but rather explain.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom