Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Well, I started this thread with this:

[qimg]http://www.randi.org/forumlive/images/icons/icon5.gif[/qimg] Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?
I consider circumcision (both male and female) to be abhorrent and barbaric.

Can any rational thinker consider it otherwise ?


I have seen no reason to change my mind, and I get to post 1,000 :D

That was a pretty safe bet. After all, how often does anyone change their mind on a strongly held opinion.

Linda
 
The difference between an opinion and a fact is this.


Your opinion won't change the facts, but if you look at the facts, you might change your opinion.
 
Nah, I only know because there is a thread in Forum Management with the same name as this one, and the missing post are there, I think. Some of them may be in Hell, I didn't check.

But it screws with the numbering I think.
 
I stayed out of this discussion for a while, thinking someone would most definitely bring this up:

References from Pediatrics

1) http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/117/5/1695

“Although the infants with bacteruria were evenly split along gender lines, from the data available, uncircumcised males had a 22.5 times greater risk compared with circumcised males. Unfortunately, circumcision status was unrecorded in 39 infants; however, even in the unlikely event that all of them were uncircumcised (none of whom had bacteruria), the observed rate of bacteruria in uncircumcised males is still _13-fold higher. Previously published reports have found uncircumcised males at greater risk for urinary tract infections;some investigators advocate circumcision for repeated urinary tract infections.”

2) http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/116/3/644

If we forget the religious reasons for a while and the lack of benefits in later life. There may be a benefit in early life between 2 and 6 months. When you consider the high mortality risk in the first year and a higher risk for UTI for boys in the first year, it may have made sense 1000 years ago...

These days things are different, although for some conditions circumcision is still one of the recommended treatments (phimosis, paraphimosis). For the infection part: in young boys (age 2-6 months) with vesico-ureteral reflux and persistently recurrent urinary tract infections it can be defended to perform a circumcision to minimise infection risk if further testing does not reveal uretheral valves or another urethral outlet obstruction. (just an example)

I don't think the circumcision of (almost) every male (as is done in the US) is a good idea and the circumcision for religious reasons is beyond me, but I wouldn't say it is a completely useless surgical procedure in specific cases.

I just thought I put that out there :wackywink:

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
I'm going to attempt an argument here that I've seen touched upon only lightly, too lightly in my opinion.

I believe, as an intact male, that I have am able to experience a deeper and more satisfying sexual bond with women.

The crux of my argument is this: as my glans is still an internal organ and therefore more sensitive, and as I have several square inches of a special kind of skin (not just more, but more sensitive also) there is an extra dimension to the sexual act that I am able to perceive.

Because of the physical proportions of my intact body, and because of my heightened awareness, it is that much more pleasurable for the female also. It not only "feels better" but the sexual act itself is more intense and erotic; The emotional bond is stronger, the shared experience more vivid.

In a sense, I actually feel sad for the majority of men who have been robbed of this, although I don't think they have any clue what they're missing. If only they knew what I know..

Just thought I'd throw that out there.
 
There is no doubt circumcision changes the sensitivity and development of the penis. Something you can't know, is how over sensitive a circumcised penis is, until the skin on the glans is hardened, at which point it is far less sensitive than a normal penis.
 
Well, foreskin helps masturbation. Probably the reason why all the puritans love the idea of circumcision. ;)

I'm always "amazed" that so many women are such great advocates of circumcision...
 
Well, I was gone from Monday until yesterday. Don't know if I can catch up on this fast paced repeating argument thread but I'll at least address a couple posts.

You say, Ivor, you can't see how you mis-stated my position. You are really too emotional in this discussion to remain objective. The following quotes from the post I was replying to are false:
Skeptigirl, let me see if I understand your position on routine infant circumcision correctly:

You think it’s similar to parents choosing to vaccinate their child.
No I do not. An injection is hardly the equivalent of a circumcision. The risks and benefits of vaccinations are not equivocal as you noted. Apples and oranges.

However, unlike standard vaccinations which have clear benefits and extremely low risks, the evidence for circumcision is equivocal. Even so, you think parents should be allowed to use their judgement after being provided with the evidence. You do not see any significant ethical problems with this approach.
What do you mean, "even so"? It's equivocal!

And from what I can gather, the physicians who have contributed so far point of view on this can be summarised by:

You think routine infant circumcision is ethically dubious, but aren’t prepared to stand up for what you believe, or accept some non-medical reasons but not others given by parents for the circumcision of their child. Even if you disagree with the decision to circumcise a child and will not perform it yourself, you will tell the parents of the child where they can get it performed, because you believe that parents will turn their backs on all of 21st century medicine if they can’t get their kid cut.
While not referring to me, this is BS.

Both the physicians and Skeptigirl think ALL forms of FGM are wrong, even if they are carried out in 21st century hi-tech hospitals, if performed on non-consenting (infant) girls.
This is false and a set up to your strawman argument below. The infant's consent has nothing to do with the rationale that FGM, regardless of arguments of preserving traditional cultures, serves to oppress women, and serves no medical purpose.

Neither Skeptigirl or the physicians appear to comprehend that the ethics of one are identical to the other, or they do and are hypocrites.
Comprehension has nothing to do with it. You applied the "non-consenting" rationale to why FGM is supposedly the same, and now argue this strawman.

Now would any of you like to summarise what you think my position is (obviously when you’ve stopped bickering about what nurses do that doctors don’t and vice-versa)?
I'm not bickering, I am discussing. Not everyone is happy with the discussion.

If I were to paraphrase your position on circumcision I'd say you are more emotion and less than objective. You projected that your belief in the 'consent' issue should be universally valued. While a child's consent certainly matters in situations such as sexual abuse, it is not up to the child to consent to medical interventions the parents choose for the child, whether that be an immunization or an elective surgery that reduces risk of infection. Those are parental decisions since the care and safety of that child is their responsibility.

Hopefully that clarifies things for you.
 
Last edited:
While a child's consent certainly matters in situations such as sexual abuse, it is not up to the child to consent to medical interventions the parents choose for the child, whether that be an immunization or an elective surgery that reduces risk of infection. Those are parental decisions since the care and safety of that child is their responsibility.

What about when circumcision is performed for cosmetic reasons according to the parents? Is there an issue of consent when it's a cosmetic genital surgery performed?
 
While a child's consent certainly matters in situations such as sexual abuse, it is not up to the child to consent to medical interventions the parents choose for the child, whether that be an immunization or an elective surgery that reduces risk of infection. Those are parental decisions since the care and safety of that child is their responsibility.

:D

I'll play advocate for the devil and state that this is a nice avoiding argument.
The physician has a responsibility too...
The parents don't choose a procedure, they have the right to agree with it or reject it. The physician chooses the procedure... Both for male and female circumcision.

A child consent does not matter in sexual abuse. It is statutory rape, no matter what the child "chooses"...
If you mean consent to investigation, again not really the choice of the child.

The problem is quite clearly that physicians are deprived of their judgement and are instructed to comply with the demands of parents. This goes far beyond circumcision...

I have not even discussed women who decide to have genital plastic surgery for aesthetic reasons at an age at which they can decide for themselves, which far outnumbers the female circumcisions, but which comes very close to the same thing.

Feminists have made female circumcision their new flagship, but remain advocates for male circumcision while claiming the right to alter their body as they see fit including the same genital mutilation they abhore, but ofcourse by a plastic surgeon for aesthetic reasons...

My point is: this is not really about medicine in most cases. It is about lobbies, puritan ideas from the 1900's in the US, hundreds of years of religious ideas, Yes, some medical benefits for specific groups in specific circumstances exist, but only few for a specific group of men. If there is a medical indication, I see no problem, but in most cases there isn't a medical reason.

Let's imagine:
suppose that parents would decide to give their child a tattoo instead of a circumcision. It is done to a child at a young age. Reason: the parents want it. Is a doctor obliged to comply?

SYL :)
 
This is the last time I am going to address your lack of objectivity, Ivor. The reason being is it's a waste of time. You have shown you are not taking in what people are saying, but instead, you are repeating your same straw arguments again and again. (Unless that is, if you have changed your view in the last 4 pages I have yet to read.)
Skeptigirl, I’ve just read what you’ve written below and can’t see how I misrepresented your position at all:confused:
Answered above.

The largest study I found was a Cohort study of over 400000 boys, which indicated that the incidence of UTI in uncircumcised boys was just over 1.1% and in circumcised boys it was 0.13%. So it appears circumcision gives a 10-fold reduction in UTI’s. Other research has estimated that ~7.5% of infants who get a UTI have renal scaring.

The complication rates for circumcision are not well researched, but have been estimated at about 2%.

So ignoring the magnitude of the complications (which can be just as serious as renal scaring), for a group of healthy boys circumcision will cause more problems than it prevents.
According to who? You, but not everyone reaches the same conclusion. You just ignore that fact and repeat your personal conclusions as if everyone should simply see it your way. Everyone does not accept your statements of fact!!!

Why do you consider my (and others) ethical argument an emotional appeal? If I were arguing that we should not fondle a women’s breasts (unless she wants them to be fondled;)), would that be an appeal to emotion?
Your example is not valid, that's an emotional appeal. Your ethical argument isn't the issue, it is your failure to see other facts involved in the decision. You simply ignore many facts such as you have in your conclusion above that preventing UTIs is a minor thing.

Hopefully you would reply that there is a large amount of empirical evidence that women do not want their breasts fondled unless they request it. I’ll say now there’s just as much evidence that a man does not want his penis altered without his informed consent being asked for first.
Emotional straw.

Two things are absolutely certain: No mentally healthy person chooses to have their body altered without a great deal of thought. No person wants a part of their body to be altered at the decision of someone else when they are incapacitated.
This is not absolutely certain, in fact it is absurd. Suppose you had to decide to have a surgeon amputate a loved one's limb or risk their life trying to save it?

I agree with you 100% that tit-for-tat should be avoided. If the evidence points clearly in one direction then a rational person should be swayed by it. However, after researching male circumcision for over 100 years in the West, the only effects it seems to have clearly demonstrated are a reduction in UTI’s and some increased resistance to HIV infection and some other STD’s.
"The only effects" :rolleyes: So according to Ivor, his opinion that preventing a potentially life threatening infection is a minor thing. Ivor is the medical expert having read a few abstracts. The medical opinion of the policy committees of the AAFP and the AAP are inferior to Ivor's medical opinion. And we should all simply agree that Ivor's minimizing of the medical benefits is an accurate portrayal of those benefits. That is not an accurate portrayal.

Not much research has been done into FGM because it has not been widely practiced in the West. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It is therefore hypocritical to play the ethics card to object to FGM, especially since in the regions of the world it is practiced, male circumcision can be pretty brutal too.
Another false assumption about why the medical benefits of FGM have not been examined, if it is even true that they haven't been. Certainly the consequences have been researched to some extent. Benefits might have shown up if they were there. But tell me, did you draw this conclusion out of your hat about why potential benefits of FGM may not have researched? Could it possibly be instead there is no hint of a benefit and therefore no hypothesis there is a benefit and therefore no study to examine that hypothesis? The reduction of UTIs in circumcised infants was noticed first before it was studied. No one decided to test whether removing foreskin had some benefit simply out of the blue.

Neither did anyone decide to look at HIV rates out of the blue. The incidence of HIV in circumcised men was observed to be lower than in uncircumcised men long before anyone hypothesized a relationship. That is how research is done. You need a reason to form an hypothesis. Random out of the blue trial and error is not very productive.

If we were living at a time or in a place where condoms were in short supply or men generally did not want to use them, then infant circumcision starts to look like a better option. But we don’t. We live in the richest, most oversupplied part of the world. I can buy a condom 24-7 and I’m pretty sure you can too. We educate our children about the risks of unsafe sex. If the worst happens and they do contract HIV, they stand a good chance of living for decades.
And again, no one is arguing this is a reason to circumcise males in low risk populations. To once again argue this straw man is getting tiring. If you want to discuss this particular rationale for circumcision, you need to be arguing it in the context of countries with large segments of the population infected with HIV.

Are you really trying to argue that male circumcision is used for the same reasons (i.e. your reasons) all over the world? I think if you look into it a bit more closely you’ll find what we would consider ethically dubious (or flat-out wrong) uses of male circumcision.
What does this have to do with anything I have been saying? Or were you addressing this to someone else?

What do you think FGM would have evolved into if we in the West had liked the idea?
Considering women's liberation in this country compared to the rest of the world, I'd say we'd have dispensed with it 100 years ago. But you are not interested in that. You only want to build more straw men to tear down. Male circumcision to prevent infection risk has nothing at all to do with FGM, the reasons for or against FGM or any other gender rights issues.
 
The risk of having appendicitis is greater if you don't remove the appendix. Some poor little kids have died of appendicitis.

Those who have a need to genitally mutilate defenceless children really can't use your point as a valid argument.


Risk/cost vs benefit/risk of not doing

That is how you weigh risk benefit.

In your appendectomy example you left out the risk/cost of taking the appendix out.
 
Heh. I've been on the Internets for a loooong time. There isn't any other way for this conversation to end up. Because circumcision is THE basic requirement for being Jewish, and being Jewish mean you are different from everybody else, that you are special. Sure, the Christians tried to take over this deal, but you can still be a Christian and not be cut.

Jews do not have that option. It says so, right in the book man. Do NOT mess with cutting off kids penis skin. God said to do it.

And you can't argue with God.
Except the Earth isn't flat, and Darwin was right. So your argument is relative and shifts with the time.
 
<snip>

Your example is not valid, that's an emotional appeal. Your ethical argument isn't the issue, it is your failure to see other facts involved in the decision. You simply ignore many facts such as you have in your conclusion above that preventing UTIs is a minor thing.

<snip>

"The only effects" :rolleyes: So according to Ivor, his opinion that preventing a potentially life threatening infection is a minor thing. Ivor is the medical expert having read a few abstracts. The medical opinion of the policy committees of the AAFP and the AAP are inferior to Ivor's medical opinion. And we should all simply agree that Ivor's minimizing of the medical benefits is an accurate portrayal of those benefits. That is not an accurate portrayal.

Another false assumption about why the medical benefits of FGM have not been examined, if it is even true that they haven't been. Certainly the consequences have been researched to some extent. Benefits might have shown up if they were there. But tell me, did you draw this conclusion out of your hat about why potential benefits of FGM may not have researched? Could it possibly be instead there is no hint of a benefit and therefore no hypothesis there is a benefit and therefore no study to examine that hypothesis? The reduction of UTIs in circumcised infants was noticed first before it was studied. No one decided to test whether removing foreskin had some benefit simply out of the blue.

<snip>

And again, no one is arguing this is a reason to circumcise males in low risk populations. To once again argue this straw man is getting tiring. If you want to discuss this particular rationale for circumcision, you need to be arguing it in the context of countries with large segments of the population infected with HIV.

<snip>

Considering women's liberation in this country compared to the rest of the world, I'd say we'd have dispensed with it 100 years ago. But you are not interested in that. You only want to build more straw men to tear down. Male circumcision to prevent infection risk has nothing at all to do with FGM, the reasons for or against FGM or any other gender rights issues.

I would say this is far more an emotional argumentation then the rest of the comments, and I presume it is not even about you... weird
I have some comments to this rant:
1) preventing UTI is only effective for age 2 months to 6 months after that females catch up with males (uncircumcised) and after the 4th year have far more infections than males. So the infection argument is only valid if there if an infection problem in the first year of life and only if it's recurrent and not easily treated by antibiotics.
Females have a larger number of UTI's (far exceeding men for various reasons: toilet training, hygiene, short urethra....etc)
2) the potentially life threatening infection is very rarely caused by a cystitis. A nephritis which is less frequent and even rare in men even at a young age, often occurs in conjunction with other abnormalities (vesico-ureteral reflux= VUR). This may require surgery, but not always a circumcision and even circumcision in conjunction with VUR treatment may not lead to significant results. To prevent renal scaring it is hypothesized that there may be an effect but it has not been proven yet as far as I know. The medical committees of the AAP leave room for the treatment but do not endorse it. Compared to the European population you would expect a huge reduction in child mortality if circumcision was that effective and if your estimation of it's effects were true. It's not there... I don't think that American children are healthier then European ones. (I think it's rather the opposite, for different reasons)
3) The medical effects were not noticed out of the blue and then researched, the urological and pediatric tradition in North America is to perform this procedure and that leads to a follow-up of possible benefits. Research is often led by funding and the fund for the research exist in North America. The European studies are less positive and remain very skeptical.
4) the same reasons apply against circumcision in men as in women. The difference is your cultural viewpoint. So if we are going to put our emotions aside and look critically, let's do that and try to separate what you know from what you are taught.

SYL :)
 
I stayed out of this discussion for a while, thinking someone would most definitely bring this up:

References from Pediatrics

If we forget the religious reasons for a while and the lack of benefits in later life. There may be a benefit in early life between 2 and 6 months. When you consider the high mortality risk in the first year and a higher risk for UTI for boys in the first year, it may have made sense 1000 years ago...

These days things are different, although for some conditions circumcision is still one of the recommended treatments (phimosis, paraphimosis). For the infection part: in young boys (age 2-6 months) with vesico-ureteral reflux and persistently recurrent urinary tract infections it can be defended to perform a circumcision to minimise infection risk if further testing does not reveal uretheral valves or another urethral outlet obstruction. (just an example)

I don't think the circumcision of (almost) every male (as is done in the US) is a good idea and the circumcision for religious reasons is beyond me, but I wouldn't say it is a completely useless surgical procedure in specific cases.

I just thought I put that out there :wackywink:

SYL :)
I put a lot of this out there. The majority of those arguing against circumcision do not perceive the risks from UTI, sepsis, subsequent kidney disease, medical mistakes, iatrogenic disease especially considering all first UTIs in a child under age 2 necessitate a radiologic or other invasive work up, risk of additional nosocoimal infection from the treatment and/or hospitalization, and/or the growing risk of antibiotic resistant bacteria.

Risk perception is the key factor here in my opinion. The public is not aware of the risk which infection and hospitalization alone carry. We live in a society where parents perceive vaccines to be riskier than the diseases the vaccines prevent because they have never seen a child die of measles or diphtheria.

And in this case, many (most?) of those posting in this thread have simply concluded that a UTI in a male infant is a minor event. I assume the thread members have had personal lives free from knowing children who have died from infection. Granted some in the thread have made some effort to judge that risk by reviewing the medical literature, still, I doubt any of the non-medical posters have seen a parent hold a dead infant. I've sadly seen more than one.

It's not that I am trying to portray this as the other side of the emotional coin. We all take risks every day. We make decisions for our kids (those of us who have them) everyday. You don't necessarily say to your child he/she can't go on the boating trip or that your 16 year old cannot get in a car with a friend driving. Risk perception influences those decisions but one cannot achieve a risk free life or protect your children from all risks. That's why I maintain this decision is up to the parents and how they perceive the risks and benefits, on what they value. I am pointing out the medical benefits because they are being overlooked or minimized. They are not minimal to everyone.

What concerns me about those here who are so quick to say they see no reason for circumcision, is that I wonder how they would see that same conclusion if they had the experience of seeing children die from infection. I wonder if they could so easily discount that risk if they didn't live the insular lives we live today. Work in a pediatric hospital for a year and you will not have the same view of minor childhood infections and antibiotics that can treat anything. It's easy if you have not had that experience to think only chronically ill children die of infection. But if you have had that experience you know a different world.

I can understand those saying for their child, their values, their decision. What I don't think is right are those who cannot recognize that for some people the right decision is to reduce the risk of infection. We make decisions about what level and kinds of risks we want our children to have all through their young lives. I am comfortable telling parents I expect them to put that child in a proper vehicle restraint and they need a smoke alarm and a fire escape. I am not comfortable telling them they shouldn't value the benefit of circumcising their child because I have personal emotional feelings about the matter.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom