<snip>
Your example is not valid, that's an emotional appeal. Your ethical argument isn't the issue, it is your failure to see other facts involved in the decision. You simply ignore many facts such as you have in your conclusion above that preventing UTIs is a minor thing.
<snip>
"The only effects"

So according to Ivor, his opinion that preventing a potentially life threatening infection is a minor thing. Ivor is the medical expert having read a few abstracts. The medical opinion of the policy committees of the AAFP and the AAP are inferior to Ivor's medical opinion. And we should all simply agree that Ivor's minimizing of the medical benefits is an accurate portrayal of those benefits. That is not an accurate portrayal.
Another false assumption about why the medical benefits of FGM have not been examined, if it is even true that they haven't been. Certainly the consequences have been researched to some extent. Benefits might have shown up if they were there. But tell me, did you draw this conclusion out of your hat about why potential benefits of FGM may not have researched? Could it possibly be instead there is no hint of a benefit and therefore no hypothesis there is a benefit and therefore no study to examine that hypothesis? The reduction of UTIs in circumcised infants was noticed first before it was studied. No one decided to test whether removing foreskin had some benefit simply out of the blue.
<snip>
And again, no one is arguing this is a reason to circumcise males in low risk populations. To once again argue this straw man is getting tiring. If you want to discuss this particular rationale for circumcision, you need to be arguing it in the context of countries with large segments of the population infected with HIV.
<snip>
Considering women's liberation in this country compared to the rest of the world, I'd say we'd have dispensed with it 100 years ago. But you are not interested in that. You only want to build more straw men to tear down. Male circumcision to prevent infection risk has nothing at all to do with FGM, the reasons for or against FGM or any other gender rights issues.