Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Ivor said:
Both.

In Africa explain how the pain resulting from the procedure can be treated.

In the US explain how the treatment for the pain is not totally effective.

Same message, just presented from different angles to affect the desired response from the recipient.

That's really creepy, man. :D

Almost certainly, but there are general guidelines. A message has to be simple and consistently presented. Sometimes it helps to be seen as being flexible, or compromising on your extreme position.

Bah Humbug!

I bet "good cop/bad cop" would work better. Or plain ol' 'emotive language'. (there's a reason why the term "FGM" was popularized, you know? It's effective.)

Yes. If you make friends with someone you can usually persuade them much more easily. Though the risk is they can more easily persuade you Once we like someone, we want to agree with them.

In the US, most people haven't ever thought about it. Sort of like how Christianity is the default belief system over here...you can find lots of people who convert to christianity from "don't-care/never thought-about religionianity", and lots who convert from Christianity to atheism/agnosticism...but they never, ever end up converting back into Christianity. People basically never convert from skepticism into 'wooism' either, come to think about it, although many convert from wooism into skepticism. For whatever reason, the "conversions" with some things only work one way.
 
I'm also amazed that insurance companies and HMOs, who sometimes balk at paying for legitimately necessary treatment, never complain about paying $400 a pop for cosmetic baby cuttings.

Going out on a limb, I think that very few American parents would circumcise their boys if they had to fork over the $400 themselves. This is where the "intactivists" should focus their efforts.

The other thing that I think we'll start seeing is more of the victims of circumcision suing the doctors and hospitals who performed it. Just a few of these (ambulance chasers, where are you?) and insurers will stop covering cosmetic circumcision and doctors won't perform it unless it's medically necessary. I think this outcome is a virtual certainty.
 
Wow, Robinson, you may just have qualified for the $1M prize! How could you possibly have known in advance that a Jew would come along and play the "faith" card? I'm astounded!

Heh. I've been on the Internets for a loooong time. There isn't any other way for this conversation to end up. Because circumcision is THE basic requirement for being Jewish, and being Jewish mean you are different from everybody else, that you are special. Sure, the Christians tried to take over this deal, but you can still be a Christian and not be cut.

Jews do not have that option. It says so, right in the book man. Do NOT mess with cutting off kids penis skin. God said to do it.

And you can't argue with God.
 
Heh. I've been on the Internets for a loooong time. There isn't any other way for this conversation to end up. Because circumcision is THE basic requirement for being Jewish, and being Jewish mean you are different from everybody else, that you are special. Sure, the Christians tried to take over this deal, but you can still be a Christian and not be cut.

Jews do not have that option. It says so, right in the book man. Do NOT mess with cutting off kids penis skin. God said to do it.

And you can't argue with God.

That's not strictly true - if 2 (or 3 - can't remember) of your sons die because they were circumcised then God doesn't mind if you don't have the third (forth) one cut. I bet there aren't many Jewish hemophiliacs.
 
That's really creepy, man. :D

Do you think so? How many physicians and nurses offer up to a patient how much something they’re about to do to them is likely to hurt? Euphemism, distraction or no communication at all is the order of the day as far as the pain of an ‘uncomfortable’ procedure goes.

I think it’s only creepy if it’s being done for reasons that you do not believe are in the best interests of the recipient. Intent is important.

If a direct question is asked, then a direct answer should be provided.

Bah Humbug!

I bet "good cop/bad cop" would work better. Or plain ol' 'emotive language'. (there's a reason why the term "FGM" was popularized, you know? It's effective.)

According to interrogators, good cop/bad cop works quite well for extracting information from captured combatants. I’m not sure how it could be effectively utilized on people who can walk away from you though!

I think you have to be careful with emotive language. If you attempt to change someone’s behaviour by using a message that makes them sound like a monster, they’ll probably just ignore you and class you as an extremist, especially if they believe your view is only held by a minority.

I think FGM has been used as a slogan to get publicity and make the minority who practice it to comply with majority opinion. I’m not sure it changes the attitudes held about female genitalia by those that practice FGM though.

In the US, most people haven't ever thought about it. Sort of like how Christianity is the default belief system over here...you can find lots of people who convert to christianity from "don't-care/never thought-about religionianity", and lots who convert from Christianity to atheism/agnosticism...but they never, ever end up converting back into Christianity. People basically never convert from skepticism into 'wooism' either, come to think about it, although many convert from wooism into skepticism. For whatever reason, the "conversions" with some things only work one way.

There’s a theory that states people are cognitive misers. Basically they only put the minimum amount of thought into something that is required. When they are forced to think about something in depth they form stronger attitudes that are more resistant to change. I think this explains quite well the one-way nature of people’s attitudes with regards to faith to atheist/deist, or woo to skeptic.

Another related explanation I’ve thought of is that trying to keep conflicting ideas in one brain requires significant effort to come up with exceptions and excuses. The minimum energy states appear to be no-thought, narrow thought or consistent thought.
 
I stopped reading this thread about 100 post ago. Has it ended up Jews versus the rational world yet? I've never read an discussion of circumcision that didn't end up that way.

Oh, and has anybody mentioned that circumcision was started by the Egyptians? To mark slaves as property? That always helps the discussion.

;)
Really? I had no idea. Do you have a source for that? I'd be interested in reading it.

This is an interesting read on the history of circumcision.

Link doesn't work. :( All I get is a page that says "An Error Occurred Setting Your User Cookie" and with detailed explanations about what cookies are
and how to enable them... even though I already accept cookies, and I have tried to open the link in three different browsers.
It seems I have to be logged in to be able to see it.
 
Ivor said:
I think it’s only creepy if it’s being done for reasons that you do not believe are in the best interests of the recipient. Intent is important.

If a direct question is asked, then a direct answer should be provided.

I guess I see your point, and really, everyone is always walking around trying to use their own various methods of persuasion on other people for all kinds of things. It's usually not conscious, but still...

I don't know why I find 'persuasion science' creepy. I just do. It just gives me the heebie jeebies....seems slimy and underhanded. It seems deceitful in a way, but passes under the ethics radar by virtue of it's method of stringing true statements together in a way that gives a false impression but staying factually correct at the same time. I've seen papers where it was described as "the objective is to inspire feeling of fear and dread, leaving a memorable impression...nonessential concepts can then be deleted". And there are mathematical formulas on how to frighten people and inspire outrage in just the right ratios to influence behavior. And it's considered ethically sound based on some other person's idea of "correct perception", which is terribly arrogant, in my opinion. It's also "important" to be "consistent"...which means phrasing everything in a way that directs one's attention towards one side of 'risk/fear', minimizing the other. For example, if I wanted to write a "persuasive communication piece" discouraging circumcision...I'd need to say "For many infants, circumcision results in complications, some very serious, including death"...and never say something like "Most infants don't die from being circumcised." The first statement is technically true, but kind of deceptive. BUT...if you were to scrounge international numbers up and include "possible and probable" circumcision complication figures, you could easily make it look like circumcision was horribly dangerous. And if you wanted to be really sneaky, you could phrase it like "Since 1991, worldwide there have been an estimated 94,000 circumcision complications, some serious, including death". Deceptive, yet true. (not literally true, by the way...I made those numbers up...but it wouldn't be too hard to put a figure like that together.)

I think you have to be careful with emotive language. If you attempt to change someone’s behaviour by using a message that makes them sound like a monster, they’ll probably just ignore you and class you as an extremist, especially if they believe your view is only held by a minority.

I guess it depends on the starting point of the other person. Circumcision in the context of human rights is only offensive to people who are either circumcised themselves, or have circumcised a child already.

I think FGM has been used as a slogan to get publicity and make the minority who practice it to comply with majority opinion. I’m not sure it changes the attitudes held about female genitalia by those that practice FGM though.

There's a lot of debate, and it's a fine line. It's had mixed results, I think.

There’s a theory that states people are cognitive misers. Basically they only put the minimum amount of thought into something that is required. When they are forced to think about something in depth they form stronger attitudes that are more resistant to change. I think this explains quite well the one-way nature of people’s attitudes with regards to faith to atheist/deist, or woo to skeptic.

I dunno. A lot of woos and theists devote a LOT of thought to their woo and religion of choice.

Another related explanation I’ve thought of is that trying to keep conflicting ideas in one brain requires significant effort to come up with exceptions and excuses. The minimum energy states appear to be no-thought, narrow thought or consistent thought.

I think that's closer to what's going on. It's a psychological relief to escape cognitive dissonance.
 
Really? I had no idea. Do you have a source for that? I'd be interested in reading it.

Gollaher, David L. (February 2000). Circumcision: a history of the world’s most controversial surgery. New York, NY: Basic Books, 53–72. ISBN 978-0-465-04397-2 LCCN 99-40015.
 
This thread will soon reach 1000 posts. And just to lighten this up, a quote from Arrested Development:

Lindsay: We just had an amazing fundraiser for HOOP.
Michael: HOOP?
Lindsay: My anti-circumcision movement.

Lindsay’s house, where she is hosting a fund-raiser for “H.O.O.P. Hands Off Our Penises.”

Lindsay: (to a guest) I think it looks frightening when it’s cut off. It’s a Doberman. Let it have its ears.

Back to the present

Lindsay: Believe it or not, we brought in over $40,000
Michael: Unbelievable. Sounds like you saved enough skin to make 10 new boys.
 
I don't know why I find 'persuasion science' creepy. I just do. It just gives me the heebie jeebies....seems slimy and underhanded. It seems deceitful in a way, but passes under the ethics radar by virtue of it's method of stringing true statements together in a way that gives a false impression but staying factually correct at the same time.

Perhaps it makes people feel uncomfortable because it impacts on beliefs they hold about free will?

I agree that it can be used for very dubious purposes and if the 'facts' are selectively presented the communicator is lying by omission.

I think there is a middle ground, where all the relevant information can be presented, but that which supports the desired behaviour can be used to explain why doing it is a good idea.

I guess it depends on the starting point of the other person. Circumcision in the context of human rights is only offensive to people who are either circumcised themselves, or have circumcised a child already.

From this thread it certainly appears to be the case. I thought it might persuade the physicians here, but clearly I was mistaken. Maybe it's because performing circumcision is seen as an in-group behaviour?
 
From this thread it certainly appears to be the case. I thought it might persuade the physicians here, but clearly I was mistaken. Maybe it's because performing circumcision is seen as an in-group behaviour?

Maybe because you only see "persuasion" as "total agreement with and expression of equal outrage with Ivor"? :cool:

Just a thought, y'know.

And not to be tetchy on behalf of my collective colleagues, but I really can't let this one go unchallenged:

Do you think so? How many physicians and nurses offer up to a patient how much something they’re about to do to them is likely to hurt? Euphemism, distraction or no communication at all is the order of the day as far as the pain of an ‘uncomfortable’ procedure goes.

I think it’s only creepy if it’s being done for reasons that you do not believe are in the best interests of the recipient. Intent is important.

If a direct question is asked, then a direct answer should be provided.

Disclaimer: none of the following is intended to address the question of circumcision directly.

Point one: what you believe is in the best interests of the patient is not, by a strict definition, what the best interests of the patient necessarily is.

Point two: where are you getting this "order of the day" stuff? If you do decide to go into this profession, Ivor, you will find that schools spend a great deal of time going over the concepts of explaining risks and benefits, patient autonomy, and informed consent. The idea that "no communication at all" is a norm of medicine or nursing is not only a complete straw man, but appears to me to reveal a very deep bias on your part.

Point three: You greatly underestimate the complexity of the practice of medicine if you think that most questions are as simple as "a direct question deserves a direct answer". I would like to point out that this forum deals with a large number of people who profess certainty on difficult questions, people who have definite answers and who have no problem explaining this certainty to their patients at great length, and to describe what they do as 'safe', 'natural', 'painless', 'noninvasive' and 'nontoxic', among many other reassuring terms.

Do I need to go on, or do you see where I'm going with this? ;)
 
Last edited:
That's not strictly true - if 2 (or 3 - can't remember) of your sons die because they were circumcised then God doesn't mind if you don't have the third (forth) one cut.

Do you have a source for that? Interesting. God is caring, and practical, I guess.

"Hey my childrens! If your kids keep dieing after you whack them in the pee pee, after 2 or three die, you can stop cutting them."

--- God ---
 
Others believe that circumcision arose as a mark of defilement or slavery. In ancient Egypt captured warriors were often mutilated before being condemned to the slavery. Amputation of digits and castration was common, but the morbidity was high and their resultant value as slaves was reduced. However, circumcision was just as degrading and evolved as a sufficiently humiliating compromise. Eventually, all male descendents of these slaves were circumcised. The Phoenicians, and later the Jews who were largely enslaved, adopted and ritualized circumcision. In time, circumcision was incorporated into Judaic religious practice and viewed as an outward sign of a covenant between God and man (Genesis XVI, Fig. 2).
http://www.cirp.org/library/history/dunsmuir1/
Barns E. La Circoncision. Paris: Lipshutz 1936:1-2
Boland RP. Ritualistic Surgery --- circumcision and tonsillectomy. N Engl J Med 1969; 280: 591-6
 
Last edited:
Did you investigate what the minor amputations referred to?

I stand by my statement, the use of the term 'amputation' of the foreskin is an irregular use of the term. Would you say appendices are amputated? Are gall bladders amputated? It is you who are seeking the emotional response.
If you wish to redefine the word amputation feel free but you need to recognise that is what you are doing.

You use euphemism to conceal what is actually happening, namely the genital mutilation of defenceless infants.
It is genital because bits of the genitalia are being cut off.
It is mutilation because the bits do not need to be removed and result in reduced appearance and function of the organ affected for no good reason,
The infant is by definition defenceless and has no ability to defend itself from your desires to amputate bits of its body.

Genital mutilation is also accurately described as child abuse.
 
Well, I started this thread with this:

icon5.gif
Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?
I consider circumcision (both male and female) to be abhorrent and barbaric.

Can any rational thinker consider it otherwise ?


I have seen no reason to change my mind, and I get to post 1,000 :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom