Skepticybe
Scholar
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2006
- Messages
- 79
In early mormonism, it was taught that the ancient practice of polygamy was a commandment, and that its practice was mandatory in order to get into heaven. This was a fundamental doctrine of the religion. To obey this commandment, mormon girls were often married away in their early teens. Only rarely was this done against their will. These marriages were celebrated by friends and family, who saw nothing terribly wrong with a 45 yr old man taking a 13 yr old wife. Sound familiar?
Just because a practice is required by a religion, or because the minor's parent(s) approve, or even if the minor consents, does not make a practice acceptable.
The same arguments to defend jewish circumcision can be used practically word-for-word to defend the early mormon practice of predatory polygamy.
Unfortunately this world is full of parents who consent or participate in all kinds of horrible abuse of their children. There is a long list of other examples of unacceptable things parents might force upon their minor children, or allow their minor children to do, but I think those examples would be unnecessary. The bottom line is that parental consent or directive does nothing to establish that something is either ethical or acceptable.
Just because a practice is required by a religion, or because the minor's parent(s) approve, or even if the minor consents, does not make a practice acceptable.
The same arguments to defend jewish circumcision can be used practically word-for-word to defend the early mormon practice of predatory polygamy.
Unfortunately this world is full of parents who consent or participate in all kinds of horrible abuse of their children. There is a long list of other examples of unacceptable things parents might force upon their minor children, or allow their minor children to do, but I think those examples would be unnecessary. The bottom line is that parental consent or directive does nothing to establish that something is either ethical or acceptable.