Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

In early mormonism, it was taught that the ancient practice of polygamy was a commandment, and that its practice was mandatory in order to get into heaven. This was a fundamental doctrine of the religion. To obey this commandment, mormon girls were often married away in their early teens. Only rarely was this done against their will. These marriages were celebrated by friends and family, who saw nothing terribly wrong with a 45 yr old man taking a 13 yr old wife. Sound familiar?

Just because a practice is required by a religion, or because the minor's parent(s) approve, or even if the minor consents, does not make a practice acceptable.

The same arguments to defend jewish circumcision can be used practically word-for-word to defend the early mormon practice of predatory polygamy.

Unfortunately this world is full of parents who consent or participate in all kinds of horrible abuse of their children. There is a long list of other examples of unacceptable things parents might force upon their minor children, or allow their minor children to do, but I think those examples would be unnecessary. The bottom line is that parental consent or directive does nothing to establish that something is either ethical or acceptable.
 
Ivor said:
I agree that sex workers appear to be a major cause for the spread of HIV and solutions that reduce the chances of men catching an STD from them should be part of the approach. But in some areas 1 in 3 people are infected. Focusing on the sex workers will not control the spread with that many people exposed to the virus.

Well, neither will circumcision. But the question is, what would be a better use of resources?

The incidence isn't that high (one in three) in most areas, anyway.

http://www.un.org/ecosocdev/geninfo/afrec/vol15no1/aidsmap.htm

And treating sex workers should be as effective as, if not significantly more effective than circumcision.

http://www.aidsonline.com/pt/re/aid...JLW19SSz5f86tH1z9!675572714!181195628!8091!-1

Objective: To compare the seroincidence of HIV infection among female sex workers in Abidjan, Cote d'Ivoire before and during an intervention study to control sexually transmitted diseases (STD) and to study the effect of two STD diagnosis and treatment strategies on the prevalence of STD and on the seroincidence of HIV infection.


Results: Of 542 women enrolled in the study, 225 (42%) had at least one outcome assessment. The HIV-1 seroincidence rate during the intervention study was significantly lower than before the study (6.5 versus 16.3 per 100 person-years;P = 0.02). During the study, the HIV-1 seroincidence rate was slightly lower in the intensive than in the basic strategy (5.3 versus 7.6 per 100 person-years;P = 0.5).

And....

http://www.jaids.com/pt/re/jaids/ab...qkmT4TQlLSx21hkMn!675572714!181195628!8091!-1

Increasing evidence demonstrates a substantial link between the epidemics of sexually transmitted HIV-1 and herpes simplex virus (HSV)-2 infection. More than 30 epidemiologic studies have demonstrated that prevalent HSV-2 is associated with a 2- to 4-fold increased risk of HIV-1 acquisition. Per-sexual contact transmission rates among couples from Rakai, Uganda indicate that at all levels of plasma HIV-1 RNA in the source partner, HSV-2-seropositive HIV-1-susceptible persons have a 5-fold greater risk of acquiring HIV-1 compared with HSV-2-negative persons.

So vaccinating all girls for herpes in high risk areas should be very effective. More effective than circumcising all the baby boys. If circumcision literally worked "like a vaccine" then circumcision would be a better game plan, maybe. With a vaccine, the more you're exposed (as a general rule) the better the vaccine works. Every exposure boosts immunity.
With circumcision, it's an entirely different thing going on. All it does is buy some time. Which I guess would be better than nothing if it were the only option, but it's not.
 
Last edited:
I stopped reading this thread about 100 post ago. Has it ended up Jews versus the rational world yet? I've never read an discussion of circumcision that didn't end up that way.

Oh, and has anybody mentioned that circumcision was started by the Egyptians? To mark slaves as property? That always helps the discussion.

;)
 
Fascinating thread. All posts deeply informative and well-reasoned; fls and skeptigirl of course quoting the latest in the medical ethics papers, and making sure to tie it into a well-learnt basis in philosophy; a lack of emotion overall, and of course a disinterested, thoughtful reply from Clinton that covers all bases, everyone knowing of course that it is only genuine, well-thought debate and not emotive, polemical screaming that will serve the cause of genuine skepticism.

Carry On, oh please do Carry On. * No bris without a hiss.

________

* Brit reference, for those whose knowledge of the rest of the world is on a par with their knowledge of ethics and logic.

If you think you can do it better, show us how it´s done.
 
Well, neither will circumcision. But the question is, what would be a better use of resources?

This is where I think politics come into it. The question is: What would be a better use of the available resources? How much does circumcision cost? How much will a herpes vaccine cost?

The incidence isn't that high (one in three) in most areas, anyway.

Yes, there is quite a wide range of incidence from country to country in Africa. Circumcision may be particularly useful in areas of high incidence over an extended period of time.

For example, using 0.1% chance of infection per sexual encounter, 50 sexual encounters a year and a 50% protective effect of circumcision:

1 year:

(no circ.) 0.9990^50 = 0.951
(circ.) 0.9995^50 = 0.975
Difference = 2.4%

10 years:

(no circ.) 0.9990^500 = 0.606
(circ.) 0.9995^500 = 0.779
Difference = 17%

That's a lot of people not infected who otherwise would have been.

And treating sex workers should be as effective as, if not significantly more effective than circumcision.

Has there been a study showing this effect for the general population, rather than just the sex workers? Also, the western definition of 'sex worker' could cover a huge range of sexual relationships in Africa. You may end up treating a lot of women!

So vaccinating all girls for herpes in high risk areas should be very effective. More effective than circumcising all the baby boys. If circumcision literally worked "like a vaccine" then circumcision would be a better game plan, maybe. With a vaccine, the more you're exposed (as a general rule) the better the vaccine works. Every exposure boosts immunity.
With circumcision, it's an entirely different thing going on. All it does is buy some time. Which I guess would be better than nothing if it were the only option, but it's not.

It slows the spread and its effects are cumulative. If this were being hailed as the solution for HIV in Africa then I'd agree with you. It is clearly only a useful additional measure.

I haven't heard anyone arguing that what is being done now should be cut-back to offer circumcision. Different people will argue that the (extra ?) money spent on offering circumcision could be better spent on herpes vaccinations or condoms or treatment of malaria or every other problem that fuels the spread of HIV in Africa. If circumcision is offered and performed in an ethical way I have no problems with money being spent offering it to people.
 
Last edited:
I didn´t mean that. That´s not woo, it´s just a crap attempt at justifying circumcision but not woo.

I don´t really care about that right now. I just want to talk about how RIC is immoral, which happens to be what this thread is about.

I find it really difficult to understand you, most of the times. You mean I´m trying to "affect real change stirring up a passionate response"? I don´t know, I´m just debating an issue... and trying to stick to it...

Using words like "crap" and "immoral" seems designed to generate an emotional response. Especially since the use of these terms as appropriate has not been demonstrated through the use of logical progression.

If you don't understand me (I realize this happens), let me know what it is that you don't find clear and I will attempt to clarify it.

I´d call what Loss Leader defends RIC.

Yes, that´s what I´d say RIC is. Since it´s routine for some collectives it could be called RIC, but yes, "Medically unnecessary circumcision for underaged persons" would be more accurate. Or even more "Medically unnecessary and irreversible physical alterations for underaged homo sapiens"...

Okay, that helps make it more specific. So are you saying that you don't consider mental and social well-being worth consideration?

The fact that at present it is not a criminal offense to circumcise an infant is not a valid argument, for reasons already provided. (Is that what you mean with "I am fully aware that this process is fluid and progressive."?)

That is not correct. The reasons already provided have only recognized that the process is fluid and progressive. And I don't think anyone is arguing otherwise. That is what I hoped to curtail with my disclaimer - the continued insistence by you and others that I recognize that morality is relative, as though I (and others) wasn't already taking it into consideration. My attempts to move the conversation beyond that point have so far been in vain, but that is nothing new.

Exactly. Do you consider a newborn AND his parents to be "an individual"? That´s the problem, see? basic human rights are for people, for individuals, not for cultures, nations, "parents+infant units", religions or anything. Individuals. Since a newborn IS (as far as I know) an individual and WILL have the right to choose, parents shouldn´t have the right to do anything to him that he cannot undo in the future. They´d be taking away his right to choose freely what to do with his own body.

See Emperor´s example.

I see the newborn as the individual under consideration, since the decision is being made on their behalf. I think I see the family as having greater interest in the infant than you do (also relative to the state). I think the parents are in a far better position to understand the wishes of their child than you (as in the collective you) are.

Linda
 
It's ok. She does it to me, too, sometimes. I just assume there's a maximum of 4 posts I'll get out of her before the cryptic message appears, shutting the dialogue down.
It's not so frustrating when you know it's coming.

:duck:

There are many conversations I don't take part in. It doesn't mean anything in particular - it may be that I just don't see how my contribution could be useful (not that that always stops me :)).

Linda
 
There are many conversations I don't take part in. It doesn't mean anything in particular - it may be that I just don't see how my contribution could be useful (not that that always stops me :)).

Linda

Touché:D

Ok, if you really want to move the conversation on, let's talk about persuasion techniques. Interested?

ETA: Look like the answer's "no."

Can't let this go, though:

fls said:
I see the newborn as the individual under consideration, since the decision is being made on their behalf. I think I see the family as having greater interest in the infant than you do (also relative to the state). I think the parents are in a far better position to understand the wishes of their child than you (as in the collective you) are.

The only way a parent could know such a thing is if they are planning to inflict their view of a (more) perfect body on their child. That is unless you have knowledge of a $1million winning technique we should know about?

Not too long ago it was thought a man was better placed than his wife to know if she wanted to have sex.

Lots of kids who've been beaten with objects think they deserved it.

Find me a physically and mentally healthy person who wants to amputate or alter part of their body without giving it a lot of thought first.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I misunderstood. Did you mean persuasion techniques specific to changing circumcision practices?

Linda

That's what I thought you were getting at with your replies to Abooga et al.

I've read about persuasion techniques in general.

I've actually been trying them out in this thread. Not having much success though - tough audience:D

ETA: Both ways - getting African parents and men to consider circumcision more and American parents to consider it less.
 
Last edited:
Has it ended up Jews versus the rational world yet? I've never read an discussion of circumcision that didn't end up that way.

Wow, Robinson, you may just have qualified for the $1M prize! How could you possibly have known in advance that a Jew would come along and play the "faith" card? I'm astounded!

Did you also know that said Jew was eager to take offense at the comments of others, and would try to shift the discussion to wherever was most self-serving (or, "Jew-serving"), and when all else failed would simply jam his fingers into his ears and say "I can't hear you!"

Amazing!

Seriously though, I'm always a bit disappointed when someone so thoroughly lives up to a negative stereotype. I guess I'm too generous.
 
Stop with the personal comments.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Ivor said:
This is where I think politics come into it. The question is: What would be a better use of the available resources? How much does circumcision cost? How much will a herpes vaccine cost?
How much the Herpes vaccine will end up costing will very much depend on politics. If the uptake is high in the developed world, production costs will quickly go down, and it'll become pretty cheap for Africa pretty quickly. But if there's a lot of opposition in the developed world and no one wants it, it'll be really expensive. What'll happen with all that won't be known till whatever happens happens.

For example, using 0.1% chance of infection per sexual encounter, 50 sexual encounters a year and a 50% protective effect of circumcision:

1 year:

(no circ.) 0.9990^50 = 0.951
(circ.) 0.9995^50 = 0.975
Difference = 2.4%

10 years:

(no circ.) 0.9990^500 = 0.606
(circ.) 0.9995^500 = 0.779
Difference = 17%

That's a lot of people not infected who otherwise would have been.

Right...that's the way it'll work for people who engage in high-risk behaviors. But for people on the other end of the spectrum, the lifetime risk reduction will be much smaller, which will water the effect down.
But either way...yeah...it could end up being a "lot" of people. But circumcising ALL the male babies is a pretty massive investment, too. Especially when you add in potential infection rates in areas without running water, disposable diapers, etc. So far, I haven't seen any of the "cost/benefit" models accounting for those kinds of factors.

Has there been a study showing this effect for the general population, rather than just the sex workers?
Weirdly, no. Not that I've been able to find, at least. But logically, it would have to work. There's no way it wouldn't, is there?

Also, the western definition of 'sex worker' could cover a huge range of sexual relationships in Africa. You may end up treating a lot of women!

Well, it wouldn't be as many women needing treatment to get an effect from that as men/babies getting circumcised to get an effect from circumcision. Antivirals are pretty expensive, though, so that would balance things out a bit, at the least.

If circumcision is offered and performed in an ethical way I have no problems with money being spent offering it to people.

Well, me neither. It's the definition of "ethical" that's tricky. "Ethics" and "circumcision" don't tend to mesh real well, historically, from my point of view.
 
Last edited:
How much the Herpes vaccine will end up costing will very much depend on politics. If the uptake is high in the developed world, production costs will quickly go down, and it'll become pretty cheap for Africa pretty quickly. But if there's a lot of opposition in the developed world and no one wants it, it'll be really expensive. What'll happen with all that won't be known till whatever happens happens.

Well that depends on whether it's an election year:)

Right...that's the way it'll work for people who engage in high-risk behaviors. But for people on the other end of the spectrum, the lifetime risk reduction will be much smaller, which will water the effect down.
But either way...yeah...it could end up being a "lot" of people. But circumcising ALL the male babies is a pretty massive investment, too. Especially when you add in potential infection rates in areas without running water, disposable diapers, etc. So far, I haven't seen any of the "cost/benefit" models accounting for those kinds of factors.

That's the big question: all the studies to date have been on men, not infants, who had access to much better health care than could be provided if circumcision was implemented on a large scale. It could end up being another Nestle Baby Milk cock-up (pardon the pun).

With regards to the cost/benefit models, I'm amazed insurance companies in the US pay for parents to have their child circumcised.

Weirdly, no. Not that I've been able to find, at least. But logically, it would have to work. There's no way it wouldn't, is there?

I agree, it sounds logical enough. I had a look for some models that could explain the spread of HIV in Africa. It appears that this is still an active area of research, indicating that the factors that lead to one area being overwhelmed and another close by relatively mildly affected are not fully understood.

It sounds like a good enough reason to conduct a larger trial.

Well, it wouldn't be as many women needing treatment to get an effect from that as men/babies getting circumcised to get an effect from circumcision. Antivirals are pretty expensive, though, so that would balance things out a bit, at the least.

Yes, I'd imagine the number of women needed to treat would be smaller.

Well, me neither. It's the definition of "ethical" that's tricky. "Ethics" and "circumcision" don't tend to mesh real well, historically, from my point of view.

I'm currently looking at methods of persuasion for circumcising/not circumcising.

I read one paper that indicated that the most sensitive factor to whether or not a reasonable parent chooses to circumcise their child is pain. Those parents that give their child's pain a small weight think circumcision is worth performing. Those who give pain a higher weight tend to think it is not.

So it would seem messages about the pain of circumcision could be the most effective in swaying parents either way.
 
Ivor said:
I'm currently looking at methods of persuasion for circumcising/not circumcising.

I read one paper that indicated that the most sensitive factor to whether or not a reasonable parent chooses to circumcise their child is pain. Those parents that give their child's pain a small weight think circumcision is worth performing. Those who give pain a higher weight tend to think it is not.

So it would seem messages about the pain of circumcision could be the most effective in swaying parents either way.

Are you wondering about persuasion in areas with a lot of HIV, or areas without much HIV?
The "rules" for what would be effective would be different in different areas.

Also, knowing people on a friendly basis will be different from a medical study.

With regards to the cost/benefit models, I'm amazed insurance companies in the US pay for parents to have their child circumcised.
That's actually in the process of changing. I wouldn't be surprised if in 10 years it wasn't covered by any insurance companies.
 
Are you wondering about persuasion in areas with a lot of HIV, or areas without much HIV?

Both.

In Africa explain how the pain resulting from the procedure can be treated.

In the US explain how the treatment for the pain is not totally effective.

Same message, just presented from different angles to affect the desired response from the recipient.

The "rules" for what would be effective would be different in different areas.

Almost certainly, but there are general guidelines. A message has to be simple and consistently presented. Sometimes it helps to be seen as being flexible, or compromising on your extreme position.

Also, knowing people on a friendly basis will be different from a medical study.

Yes. If you make friends with someone you can usually persuade them much more easily. Though the risk is they can more easily persuade you:) Once we like someone, we want to agree with them.

That's actually in the process of changing. I wouldn't be surprised if in 10 years it wasn't covered by any insurance companies.

That might kill it off in the US faster than anything else, given the amount physicians charge. I mean, they're just overpaid body engineers really...:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom