These are injuries and deaths that could be completely and permanently prevented by outlawing Christmas decorations. The value of celebrating Christmas is zero but there is a value to the lives and healths of the children killed and mutilated every year because of Christmas.
Well, I'm convinced! Let's all rally together and try to put a stop to fires caused by dangerous christmas tree decorations. Let's pass laws regarding fire hazards and safety in general..
Oh, wait, that's already happening..
If the belief in Jesus as one's personal savior requires that one also drag a flamable tree into one's house, it's not much of a religion.
I agree, but then, I already agree that it's not much of a religion. Same as yours, same as everybody else's.
Now you think that my example about Christmas is just plain silly. You think that there is no comparison between the deaths caused by Christmas decorations and the harm of circumcision.
No, that's a
somewhat valid comparison. Although the numbers you cited earlier left out the fact that those deaths and disfigurements resulted from probably greater than 100 million christmas trees. Let's do some quick math here: (warning: I pulled the 100 million number out of my bum.)
Chance of your tree catching fire: 0.000003
Chance of dying by fire: 0.00000014
Chance of injury by fire: 0.00000021
Chance of being injured while decorating tree: 0.000058
Chance of being permanently injured by circumcision: 1.0
If anyone has any real data on the number of christmas trees used every year, please correct me.
meh.. not interested in beliefs.
Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture.
If that's true, then Jews who choose not to circumcise (and they DO exist) are not really Jews. While I myself have no problem accepting the idea that I'm not a real Jew, I suspect they wouldn't be so forgiving.
We have fond memories of attending the circumcisions of our family and friends' children. We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised. We see nothing unusual or untoward about it.
That's just sick.
I find Christmas unbearable.
Yeah, me too. All that traffic, the crowding in the malls, the commercial nature of it..
I find circumcision normal and natural.
Normal I could let slide, but natural? For what definition of "natural" does this alteration of nature qualify?
Why is there so much difficulty understanding that?
I myself have no difficulty understanding what you're saying. The difficulty I have is respecting your right to practice whatyou believe on unconsenting human beings. (Unconsenting in the reality sense, not the legal sense I suspect you're going to attempt to shift the discussion to.)
Here's the problem I see with your comparison between circumcision and christmas trees. With christmas trees, the deaths and injuries are accidental side effects of the desired outcome. With circumcision, the injury itself is the desired effect. Heck, you even feel
good about it.