Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

"How stupid is this discussion becoming..."
Only from a couple of perspectives....

I'm still very surprised the hoops that self-described Intelligent People will jump through trying to justify bobbing their male childrens genitals as if they were a dog.... If YOU want to be circumcised, go right ahead.... if you want to INFLICT it on anyone else, I'm here to label you cruel. If you want to circumcise people because some invisible man in the sky told you to, you need treatment.

Darkness and ignorance...
Hear hear. Well said.

It is amazing to me that any justification for a cruel and unusual practice is 'my ancestors did it.'
On that basis, keeping slaves would still be OK.
Keeping slaves and genitally mutilating defenceless children are both wrong - full stop.
 
Fourteen Americans die every year because of Christmas tree fires,

... blah blah blah

These are injuries and deaths that could be completely and permanently prevented by outlawing Christmas decorations.

Didn´t you read what I wrote? Christmas decorations are a nuisance, I know, but no religious group is demanding them to be installed in anyone´s home, is it?

Now you think that my example about Christmas is just plain silly. You think that there is no comparison between the deaths caused by Christmas decorations and the harm of circumcision.

Yup. Quite silly.

Here's what I believe:

I believe the reason that you are willing to tolerate the dead and maimed children each Christmas is because Christmas is familiar to you. Oh, you may not believe in Jesus anymore but you were raised celebrating Christmas, your family celebrates Christmas, your friends celebrate Christmas and perhaps you still do. It is part of your culture and part of what defines you and your society.

Who said I´m willing to tolerate anything? If christmas lights are really that dangerous I´d be well in favour of having stronger safety restrictions decreed. But banning christmas just because of that seeems a bit excessive to me...

Now try to believe this:

Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture. It is familiar to us. We have fond memories of attending the circumcisions of our family and friends' children. We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised. We see nothing unusual or untoward about it.

Complete and utterly irrelevant. Arguments from "tradition" are invalid. Again.

And check the sharia/Rushdie example. See how Human Rights MUST BE always above group-specific practices/rituals to avoid a lot of bad things hapening? Humans have rights, collectives NOT. The right of "jews" to do their rituals cannot compete with the right of an individual human being to his body integrity. The individual has rights, jews, as a collective, don´t. The collective acquires its rights just as a sum of the rights of the individuals. Since, in this case, jews´ right to do their ritual is in conflict with the more fundamental right of the individual to his bodily integrity, the more fundamental right WINS.

You´re the lawyer. What do you think about this?


I find Christmas unbearable. You find Christmas normal and natural.

How do you know? I´m not particularly fond of christmas, which is not a christian celebration anyway (or it wasn´t until they hijacked it)

And it is irrelevant anyway. Stick to the point, please.

You find circumcision unbearable. I find circumcision normal and natural.

Why is there so much difficulty understanding that?

I don´t find it unbearable. Just unethical. I live in Spain and almost nobody here is circd., I don´t feel threatened, angry or anything. I´m just curious about the debate for "intellectual reasons" only. If you give a good pro-circ. argument I´m willing to change my opinion.

Oh, and please answer the question about Rushdie!
 
"She implied that I do not have compassion for my children"
Your actions say it louder than she ever could.


And you become the second person I've ever put on ignore.

I'm not sorry to see you go, though. In every post of yours I've read, you've been kind of a jerk.

Don't bother replying. I won't be able to see it.
 
So once again, Loss Leader jams his fingers into his ears, slams his eyes shut and shouts LALALALALALALALA!

But we're supposed to respect his opinion? Given that he ignores everything that challenges him, I take being on his ignore list as a compliment of the highest order

"Been kind of a jerk"
Coming from someone who revels in mutilating children for no good reason, -I'm- the jerk?!?!?! Ya.. o.k.... no... really.....

"Stick to the point please"
He can't... he's already groundless there and he knows it.
 
Last edited:
That is neither an excuse nor an explanation. I would counsel you not to say anything in cyberspace that you wouldn't say to a person's face. Or, at least, that you wouldn't say if you wanted reasoned debate to continue.

I´m a lot harsher in person, usually. I was almost trying to be nice. But I have acquired a habit of being very blunt, because of the people I usually spend my time with (from whom I learned my english). It gets me in trouble sometimes. I apologise abjectly. Maybe not abjectly. But if it makes you happy... then yes.:D

But we´re having a rational discussion, let´s concentrte on WHAT is being said rather than HOW.
 
I don't think I've ever been put on ignore before.
And my great sin was saying this? :confused:

Me: In all reality, you could have compassion for your baby. You could choose to care about his actual will, his feeling, and his personal rights.
You could choose to abandon an archaic ritual.
In reality, it is his body, not yours.


Some of Loss's responses?

Loss: Oh, my older son did and my new son will protest quite vehemently. I will ignore those protests, however. And I will do so proudly and happily. I'll even video tape it.


Loss: When my son feels pain, I feel pain.



Loss: And that value exists nowhere but in your head. It hurts ... or does it? Do we know what an eight day-old feels as pain?



Interesting logic evasion, there, dude.
Whatever helps you sleep at night, I guess.
 
"we´re having a rational discussion"
No... you are... LL isn't in the least.

"Interesting logic evasion"
That's about all LL has....
 
And check the sharia/Rushdie example. See how Human Rights MUST BE always above group-specific practices/rituals to avoid a lot of bad things hapening? Humans have rights, collectives NOT. The right of "jews" to do their rituals cannot compete with the right of an individual human being to his body integrity. The individual has rights, jews, as a collective, don´t. The collective acquires its rights just as a sum of the rights of the individuals. Since, in this case, jews´ right to do their ritual is in conflict with the more fundamental right of the individual to his bodily integrity, the more fundamental right WINS.

You´re the lawyer. What do you think about this?


I think it is nonsense and misunderstands key concepts. You have written that the individual newborn child has the right to bodily integrity and that whatever rights Jews as a collective may have, they don't trump the individual's rights.

This demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of every concept at work.

You are correct that the individual newborn infant has a right to bodily integrity. However, he is incompetent to exercise that right. He cannot make an informed decision; he can't even make a decision. In that case, his parents exercise his rights for him. His parents substitute their judgment for him. His parents choose for him to have a circumcision exactly as if he were an 18 year-old of sound mind making the decision for himself.

"Jews" don't act on an "individual"; the individual acts upon himself.

Now, the state does have an interest in making sure an incapacitated person's best interests are met but that "best interests" test takes into account a lot of things that you and others in this thread deem unimportant - cultural traditions, family cohesion, etc. Why are the parents choosing for the child to be circumcised? The religious reasons, which I understand are not compelling to you, are compelling to our courts and lawmakers. And the physical harm, which I understand is compelling to you, is not compelling to our courts or lawmakers. So, the parents decide for the child and, in this case, our society agrees that the parents are acting in the child's best interests (or, at least, are not so far from the child's interests as to require intervention).

That's the state of the law today. I agree with it for the reasons of cultural identity that I have so eloquently stated in previous posts.


Oh, and please answer the question about Rushdie!


You got it.


Would you consider giving Rushdie to the Iranians?


Of course not. In the circumcision example, parents are substituting their judgment for their incompetent child. The child's right to bodily integrity is preserved. In your example, Rushdie is not incompetent. He can choose for himself what he wants to do with his body. He can grow that rather natty looking ghotee and get divorced for a fourth time.

The rights of the Iranians, if they have any, cannot overcome the fact that he is competent to make his own decisions about whether or not he is murdered.


I mean, if I understood correctly your position, you´d have to weigh this emotional torment against the value of Rushdie´s life.


You have not understood my position correctly. Salman Rushdie is not incompetent and is able to exercise on his own his right to bodily integrity.

Even if he were incompetent - in a coma or something - there is little doubt in my mind that any jurist would consider his murder by Iranians not to be in his best interests.
 
Last edited:
I don't think I've ever been put on ignore before.
And my great sin was saying this? :confused:

Me: In all reality, you could have compassion for your baby. You could choose to care about his actual will, his feeling, and his personal rights.
You could choose to abandon an archaic ritual.
In reality, it is his body, not yours.


Some of Loss's responses?

Loss: Oh, my older son did and my new son will protest quite vehemently. I will ignore those protests, however. And I will do so proudly and happily. I'll even video tape it.


Loss: When my son feels pain, I feel pain.



Loss: And that value exists nowhere but in your head. It hurts ... or does it? Do we know what an eight day-old feels as pain?



Interesting logic evasion, there, dude.
Whatever helps you sleep at night, I guess.

At least you have an explanation for being ignored. I have no clue as to why Linda refuses to debate me:confused:

Is she scared?:D

Does she consider me an ignorant moron?

I just don't know...
 
At least you have an explanation for being ignored. I have no clue as to why Linda refuses to debate me:confused:

Is she scared?:D

Does she consider me an ignorant moron?

I just don't know...

It's ok. She does it to me, too, sometimes. I just assume there's a maximum of 4 posts I'll get out of her before the cryptic message appears, shutting the dialogue down.
It's not so frustrating when you know it's coming.

:duck:
 
I think it is complete and utter nonsense. You have written that the individual newborn child has the right to bodily integrity and that whatever rights Jews as a collective may have, they don't trump the individual's rights.

This demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of every concept at work.

You are correct that the individual newborn infant has a right to bodily integrity. However, he is incompetent to exercise that right. He cannot make an informed decision; he can't even make a decision. In that case, his parents exercise his rights for him. His parents substitute their judgment for him. His parents choose for him to have a circumcision exactly as if he were an 18 year-old of sound mind making the decision for himself.
So then, parents can do absolutely anything (anything they´d be allowed to do to themselves) to their kid? I don´t like the implications of this way of understanding rights of individuals... Parents could, if they wanted, go without food for as long as they wanted (excepting suicide, against the law, generally) while that would be neglect if they did it to their kid... I can´t think of a better example but you get the gist...

"Jews" don't act on an "individual"; the individual acts upon himself.
So the parents and the kid form legally a "unit", but does that make them "an individual"? Not so sure of that... What if one actually ends up hating his parents and going away... When does the unit break? Weird territory...
Now, the state does have an interest in making sure an incapacitated person's best interests are met but that "best interests" test takes into account a lot of things that you and others in this thread deem unimportant - cultural traditions, family cohesion, etc. Why are the parents choosing for the child to be circumcised? The religious reasons, which I understand are not compelling to you, are compelling to our courts and lawmakers. And the physical harm, which I understand is compelling to you, is not compelling to our courts or lawmakers.
Right. That´s what wherewe don´t agree. A secular state should protect its citizen´s bodies from any religious consideration.
...
that´s it for now. Dinner time over here.
 
Last edited:
It's ok. She does it to me, too, sometimes. I just assume there's a maximum of 4 posts I'll get out of her before the cryptic message appears, shutting the dialogue down.
It's not so frustrating when you know it's coming.

:duck:

It's certainly an interesting tactic. Strange how she'll spend weeks debating Rodney though.

So, what's your view on infant circumcision? Never? Only when it's medically indicated?

I presume that you don't buy Skeptigirl's argument that the 1% absolute risk reduction in UTI is worth the 2% complication rate and ethical problems raised by performing it.

What about in Africa? I was persuaded that, on balance, it was worth it there. At least until there are better alternatives available.
 
It's certainly an interesting tactic. Strange how she'll spend weeks debating Rodney though.

So, what's your view on infant circumcision? Never? Only when it's medically indicated?

I presume that you don't buy Skeptigirl's argument that the 1% absolute risk reduction in UTI is worth the 2% complication rate and ethical problems raised by performing it.

What about in Africa? I was persuaded that, on balance, it was worth it there. At least until there are better alternatives available.

Most of my objection comes from the fact that appropriate pain relief isn't usually used with babies. THAT should be banned. No question in my mind.

From there, I think an ethical standard should be set up between males and females. When the genital modification is comparable, the law and medical ethics should treat them as equals. I think, if most people were forced to give the question serious thought, it would end up being a tiny minority of people who would end up wanting it. I think making it a big PITA to have your kid operated on would leave room for personal "parental rights" and mostly fix the problem.

Regarding the UTI thing, I'm still not convinced it's an accurate figure. Most of these studies came from the US in the 1970's. I also think the circumcision complications that present in toddlerhood aren't being correctly accounted for, further skewing the numbers.
And even if the figures are accurate, it still doesn't justify it in my mind, since surely there's some surgery that could be performed on infant girls that would reduce their rate of UTI's. But again, I'm for leaving open a window for parental rights, for those inclined to be motivated by obscure notions of risk.

With Africa...I'm not seeing anyone talking about appropriate pain relief for the infants, and I'm dumbfounded by the idea of using mass circumcision where only one out of 5 people have access to condoms. It just seems bizarre that the resources will be available for a "circumcision rollout" when the resources obviously aren't there to provide people with condoms and education. It's not that I'm particularly opposed to using circumcision to battle AIDS...but the situation is just...weird. I don't get it. Mass sexual mutilation of infants to curb an epidemic seems like it should be a last resort, not the one idea all resources are channeled into as soon as an effect is discovered.
 
Last edited:
These are injuries and deaths that could be completely and permanently prevented by outlawing Christmas decorations. The value of celebrating Christmas is zero but there is a value to the lives and healths of the children killed and mutilated every year because of Christmas.

Well, I'm convinced! Let's all rally together and try to put a stop to fires caused by dangerous christmas tree decorations. Let's pass laws regarding fire hazards and safety in general..

Oh, wait, that's already happening..

If the belief in Jesus as one's personal savior requires that one also drag a flamable tree into one's house, it's not much of a religion.

I agree, but then, I already agree that it's not much of a religion. Same as yours, same as everybody else's.

Now you think that my example about Christmas is just plain silly. You think that there is no comparison between the deaths caused by Christmas decorations and the harm of circumcision.

No, that's a somewhat valid comparison. Although the numbers you cited earlier left out the fact that those deaths and disfigurements resulted from probably greater than 100 million christmas trees. Let's do some quick math here: (warning: I pulled the 100 million number out of my bum.)

Chance of your tree catching fire: 0.000003
Chance of dying by fire: 0.00000014
Chance of injury by fire: 0.00000021
Chance of being injured while decorating tree: 0.000058

Chance of being permanently injured by circumcision: 1.0

If anyone has any real data on the number of christmas trees used every year, please correct me.

Here's what I believe:

meh.. not interested in beliefs.

Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture.

If that's true, then Jews who choose not to circumcise (and they DO exist) are not really Jews. While I myself have no problem accepting the idea that I'm not a real Jew, I suspect they wouldn't be so forgiving.

We have fond memories of attending the circumcisions of our family and friends' children. We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised. We see nothing unusual or untoward about it.

That's just sick.

I find Christmas unbearable.

Yeah, me too. All that traffic, the crowding in the malls, the commercial nature of it..

I find circumcision normal and natural.

Normal I could let slide, but natural? For what definition of "natural" does this alteration of nature qualify?

Why is there so much difficulty understanding that?

I myself have no difficulty understanding what you're saying. The difficulty I have is respecting your right to practice whatyou believe on unconsenting human beings. (Unconsenting in the reality sense, not the legal sense I suspect you're going to attempt to shift the discussion to.)

Here's the problem I see with your comparison between circumcision and christmas trees. With christmas trees, the deaths and injuries are accidental side effects of the desired outcome. With circumcision, the injury itself is the desired effect. Heck, you even feel good about it.
 
Most of my objection comes from the fact that appropriate pain relief isn't usually used with babies. THAT should be banned. No question in my mind.

I totally agree. There is no excuse.

From there, I think an ethical standard should be set up between males and females. When the genital modification is comparable, the law and medical ethics should treat them as equals. I think, if most people were forced to give the question serious thought, it would end up being a tiny minority of people who would end up wanting it. I think making it a big PITA to have your kid operated on would leave room for personal "parental rights" and mostly fix the problem.

I almost agree. Just that I don't think the parents have any right to have the procedure performed on their child. But I think your approach would probably be more effective.

Regarding the UTI thing, I'm still not convinced it's an accurate figure. Most of these studies came from the US in the 1970's. I also think the circumcision complications that present in toddlerhood aren't being correctly accounted for, further skewing the numbers.
And even if the figures are accurate, it still doesn't justify it in my mind, since surely there's some surgery that could be performed on infant girls that would reduce their rate of UTI's. But again, I'm for leaving open a window for parental rights, for those inclined to be motivated by obscure notions of risk.

Again, I almost agree. I'd make it compulsory for equivalent risks to be pointed out to the parents, so that they could see how odd the choice to circumcise really is.

As for the figures, I have a similar feeling. I find it hard to believe over 1% of boys have a UTI. I admit that this is just a hunch though. The reported complication rates vary enormously, ranging from 0.06% to 55%. The best-guess estimate is 2-10%. That just doesn't seem sensible. Why aren't the complication rates known much more accurately after such a long period of time and so many infants circumcised?

With Africa...I'm not seeing anyone talking about appropriate pain relief for the infants, and I'm dumbfounded by the idea of using mass circumcision where only one out of 5 people have access to condoms. It just seems bizarre that the resources will be available for a "circumcision rollout" when the resources obviously aren't there to provide people with condoms and education. It's not that I'm particularly opposed to using circumcision to battle AIDS...but the situation is just...weird. I don't get it. Mass sexual mutilation of infants to curb an epidemic seems like it should be a last resort, not the one idea all resources are channeled into as soon as an effect is discovered.

I too would only support it if effective pain relief was going to be used. My worry is that if they can't afford condoms how are they going to afford effective pain relief?

The other thought I've had is circumcising an infant in Africa today is not going to help him for 12-15 years. How far off is a HIV vaccine? Will there be many more condoms in Africa after that period of time? If not, why not?

Also, like you say, circumcision should not drain resources from the other methods being used to tackle HIV in Africa. I don't think it will though.
 
Ivor said:
I almost agree. Just that I don't think the parents have any right to have the procedure performed on their child. But I think your approach would probably be more effective.
You know, some days I agree with your point of view, too. I'm a bit wishy-washy there. I'm hesitant because I'm aware of how easy it is to slip into "illogical fanaticism".
I find lip plates sort of strange, but I'm not going to advocate going in and getting those cultures to cease the practice when it comes to their children.
So I guess I'm kind of inconsistent there. But...lips are different from sex organs. I find operating on and removing the sex organs of children and babies uniquely horrifying. It just seems deeply, deeply sick that people want to do that. Ick.

The other thought I've had is circumcising an infant in Africa today is not going to help him for 12-15 years. How far off is a HIV vaccine?
Unfortunately, I think it's a long, long, long way off. At this point, no one's even close to a really effective one. There's one in phase III right now, but they're thinking it'll top out at maybe reducing the HIV viral load. And even if tomorrow someone were to figure out how to make a really good vaccine, it would be at least 10-20 years before people would start getting it.
But...there is a pretty effective herpes vaccine that's about to become available before too long, and I think that will have an effect on HIV.

Also, like you say, circumcision should not drain resources from the other methods being used to tackle HIV in Africa. I don't think it will though.
How can it not?
Like DeeTee mentioned in the last thread, it looks like the very best use of resources would be treating the sex workers. Even in the recent HIV/circumcision RCTs you can "see" that it's the sex workers who are the main sources of transmission. Most of the seropositive guys were coming in for other STD's, and turning up positive for HIV at the visit. They're not catching the virus from their girlfriends. They're catching it from prostitutes.
Every dime spent on circumcising a baby is a dime that could go to keeping the viral loads in the sex workers down, and the other co-morbid infections under control.
 
You know, some days I agree with your point of view, too. I'm a bit wishy-washy there. I'm hesitant because I'm aware of how easy it is to slip into "illogical fanaticism".
I find lip plates sort of strange, but I'm not going to advocate going in and getting those cultures to cease the practice when it comes to their children.
So I guess I'm kind of inconsistent there. But...lips are different from sex organs. I find operating on and removing the sex organs of children and babies uniquely horrifying. It just seems deeply, deeply sick that people want to do that. Ick.

I've given this a lot of thought, along the lines of 'am I being fanatical?' I don't think I am because I don't object to circumcision. I don't even object to infant circumcision. I only object circumcision of infants based on the current (equivocal) evidence of benefit, or if it is done without effective pain relief.

If someone, somewhere could demonstrate that it reduced a serious health risk a child was probably going to face before an age when it could choose for itself, I'd start to consider it. But it comes nowhere near this, except for HIV in Africa. Even here the benefit is 12-15 years in the future.

Unfortunately, I think it's a long, long, long way off. At this point, no one's even close to a really effective one. There's one in phase III right now, but they're thinking it'll top out at maybe reducing the HIV viral load. And even if tomorrow someone were to figure out how to make a really good vaccine, it would be at least 10-20 years before people would start getting it.
But...there is a pretty effective herpes vaccine that's about to become available before too long, and I think that will have an effect on HIV.

Yes, herpes sores appear to be an excellent way to transfer the virus.

How can it not?

Hopefully more money will be put in to offer circumcision, rather than it being diverted from what is already being funded.

Like DeeTee mentioned in the last thread, it looks like the very best use of resources would be treating the sex workers. Even in the recent HIV/circumcision RCTs you can "see" that it's the sex workers who are the main sources of transmission. Most of the seropositive guys were coming in for other STD's, and turning up positive for HIV at the visit. They're not catching the virus from their girlfriends. They're catching it from prostitutes.
Every dime spent on circumcising a baby is a dime that could go to keeping the viral loads in the sex workers down, and the other co-morbid infections under control.

I agree that sex workers appear to be a major cause for the spread of HIV and solutions that reduce the chances of men catching an STD from them should be part of the approach. But in some areas 1 in 3 people are infected. Focusing on the sex workers will not control the spread with that many people exposed to the virus.

The evidence from the trials showed circumcision provides a significant risk reduction, is a relatively safe procedure* and can be implemented at little cost.

*The the RCT's used men, not infants, the procedure was carried out by an experienced doctor and the facilities available on a wider scale may not be as hygienic as was used in the trials. These are all factors that could drastically affect the outcome of any role-out.
 
Last edited:
"I have so eloquently stated in previous posts."
A-HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!


Fascinating thread. All posts deeply informative and well-reasoned; fls and skeptigirl of course quoting the latest in the medical ethics papers, and making sure to tie it into a well-learnt basis in philosophy; a lack of emotion overall, and of course a disinterested, thoughtful reply from Clinton that covers all bases, everyone knowing of course that it is only genuine, well-thought debate and not emotive, polemical screaming that will serve the cause of genuine skepticism.

Carry On, oh please do Carry On. * No bris without a hiss.

________

* Brit reference, for those whose knowledge of the rest of the world is on a par with their knowledge of ethics and logic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom