Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

By insulting them and failing to seriously consider what they have to say? Does that work?

Linda

Be specific please. Who have I unsulted?

If you mean calling woo beliefs woo beliefs... yes, some idiots find that offensive... ! I don´t care. :p

... or calling that obviously silly comment about christmas trees "stupid", yes, perhaps I was a bit harsh, but I could think of no other more appropriate word to describe it...

I apologise, Opinionated Jerk! Your comment was just silly, not stupid. Silly is not a real insult is it?

...

Anyone can choose to feel insulted by someone´s comments. (remember the Muhammed cartoon controversy...) I might find Loss Leader´s jewish nationalism (or whatever that is) insulting too. But that serves nothing. What we have to do is provide real arguments, not emotional appeals to sidetrack the discussion.

...

Still no properly rational defense of RIC. IMO. If anyone thinks it has been provided could they please summarise it briefly?
 
I am seriously interested in how you perceive the duty of others to consider your ideas.

Linda

An attempt at clarification....

How do you perceive the issues of rights and duties?

Do other people have a duty to consider your ideas? What is the practical application of this duty? What are your duties in this exchange? How do you lose the right to be considered? Etc?

Linda
 
So far, my restoration is proceeding nicely! If all goes well, within a few months I will begin to notice and enjoy the benefits of that which was unjustly taken from me at birth. I am so very happy that I can undo what was done to me. This device works pretty well!




Just thought I'd throw that in here, seeing that this thread has become a war zone of sorts... *blushes* =)


By the way, Loss Leader, seeing your position on the issue has brought up a question in my mind...

If an adult male was intact, and decided to become Jewish, would he be required to get circ'd?

Just curious.
 
Last edited:
Be specific please. Who have I unsulted?

If you mean calling woo beliefs woo beliefs... yes, some idiots find that offensive... ! I don´t care. :p

The idea that humans have thrived because they naturally form groups, and that rituals can strengthen group ties, is well-established and hardly what falls under the category of "woo".

... or calling that obviously silly comment about christmas trees "stupid", yes, perhaps I was a bit harsh, but I could think of no other more appropriate word to describe it...

I apologise, Opinionated Jerk! Your comment was just silly, not stupid. Silly is not a real insult is it?

...

Anyone can choose to feel insulted by someone´s comments. (remember the Muhammed cartoon controversy...) I might find Loss Leader´s jewish nationalism (or whatever that is) insulting too. But that serves nothing.

You didn't answer my question. Of course anyone can choose whether or not they feel insulted. However, it is reasonable to expect that someone may feel insulted when you purposely say something insulting to them. And that would probably be the main (only?) reason for saying something insulting - the hope that your words would invoke an emotional response.

Do you think this is more effective than other means of persuasion? (This is a serious question - not at all rhetorical.)

What we have to do is provide real arguments, not emotional appeals to sidetrack the discussion.

Your actions give lie to these words. It seems to me that rational arguments are considered ineffective on this issue. In order to affect real change, it is necessary to stir up a passionate response.

Still no properly rational defense of RIC. IMO. If anyone thinks it has been provided could they please summarise it briefly?

I don't think you mean routine infant circumcision, because no one here has defended the idea of routine infant circumcision. No one is saying that all male infants should be circumcised, but rather that it's a private, family decision. I think you mean infant circumcision for reasons other than strictly physical (or medical depending upon how you define it), right?

The rational defense for infant circumcision comes from the WHO definition of health:

"health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".

It is reasonable to take mental and social well-being into consideration when weighing benefit and harm. The weighing of those considerations is an individual, private matter. It is a public matter to uphold basic human rights. Circumcision has not met the standard of what a reasonable person would consider a violation of basic human rights. We know this because it is not a criminal offense to circumcise an infant. I am fully aware that this process is fluid and progressive.

Linda
 
By the way, Loss Leader, seeing your position on the issue has brought up a question in my mind...

If an adult male was intact, and decided to become Jewish, would he be required to get circ'd?

Just curious.


I don't know. I'm sure the information is available on the web somewhere.


This site says converts to the orthodox or conservative way of thinking must be circumcised but reform converts may not be required to. I have no idea if this is good information or not.
 
The idea that humans have thrived because they naturally form groups, and that rituals can strengthen group ties, is well-established and hardly what falls under the category of "woo".

I didn´t mean that. That´s not woo, it´s just a crap attempt at justifying circumcision but not woo.

You didn't answer my question. Of course anyone can choose whether or not they feel insulted. However, it is reasonable to expect that someone may feel insulted when you purposely say something insulting to them. And that would probably be the main (only?) reason for saying something insulting - the hope that your words would invoke an emotional response.

Do you think this is more effective than other means of persuasion? (This is a serious question - not at all rhetorical.)

I don´t really care about that right now. I just want to talk about how RIC is immoral, which happens to be what this thread is about.

Your actions give lie to these words. It seems to me that rational arguments are considered ineffective on this issue. In order to affect real change, it is necessary to stir up a passionate response.

I find it really difficult to understand you, most of the times. You mean I´m trying to "affect real change stirring up a passionate response"? I don´t know, I´m just debating an issue... and trying to stick to it...

I don't think you mean routine infant circumcision, because no one here has defended the idea of routine infant circumcision.

I´d call what Loss Leader defends RIC.

No one is saying that all male infants should be circumcised, but rather that it's a private, family decision. I think you mean infant circumcision for reasons other than strictly physical (or medical depending upon how you define it), right?

Yes, that´s what I´d say RIC is. Since it´s routine for some collectives it could be called RIC, but yes, "Medically unnecessary circumcision for underaged persons" would be more accurate. Or even more "Medically unnecessary and irreversible physical alterations for underaged homo sapiens"...

The rational defense for infant circumcision comes from the WHO definition of health:

"health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".

It is reasonable to take mental and social well-being into consideration when weighing benefit and harm. The weighing of those considerations is an individual, private matter. It is a public matter to uphold basic human rights. Circumcision has not met the standard of what a reasonable person would consider a violation of basic human rights. We know this because it is not a criminal offense to circumcise an infant. I am fully aware that this process is fluid and progressive.

The fact that at present it is not a criminal offense to circumcise an infant is not a valid argument, for reasons already provided. (Is that what you mean with "I am fully aware that this process is fluid and progressive."?)

"The weighing of those considerations is an individual, private matter"

Exactly. Do you consider a newborn AND his parents to be "an individual"? That´s the problem, see? basic human rights are for people, for individuals, not for cultures, nations, "parents+infant units", religions or anything. Individuals. Since a newborn IS (as far as I know) an individual and WILL have the right to choose, parents shouldn´t have the right to do anything to him that he cannot undo in the future. They´d be taking away his right to choose freely what to do with his own body.

See Emperor´s example.
 
Linda said:
It is reasonable to take mental and social well-being into consideration when weighing benefit and harm. The weighing of those considerations is an individual, private matter.

Exactly. Do you consider a newborn AND his parents to be "an individual"? That´s the problem, see? basic human rights are for people, for individuals, not for cultures, nations, "parents+infant units", religions or anything. Individuals. Since a newborn IS (as far as I know) an individual and WILL have the right to choose, parents shouldn´t have the right to do anything to him that he cannot undo in the future. They´d be taking away his right to choose freely what to do with his own body.

Oops! I think I misunderstood what you said. But you know what I mean, right? I´m still making a point. But I´ll quit for now, shouldn´t be doing this in a hurry.
 
Last edited:
So all of the things you say may be true. Heck, just to be sociable I will agree that they are all true. But they are only one side of the equation. They are the harm caused by circumcision. We still must balance that with the harm caused by prohibiting Jews from practicing their religion. That harm is difficult to calculate but that doesn't make it zero.

The only aspect of Jewish religion I wish to curtail is that which physically alters other people. That is my only interest in limiting your freedom.

As I have said over and over, anything that reduces the plurality of practices in this country reduces overall energy and creativity in our culture.

So why did you become a lawyer? It is one of the occupations that actively limit “plurality of practices”, the other being politician.

Add in the great psychological torment you will cause observant Jews by your decree. Add in the unknown effect on the religion as a whole. Add it the horrifying precedent you set of limiting the religious practices of others because they ... have no effect on your personal life whatsoever but yet you find them distasteful.

I know; I’m a heartless anti-Semite. I care more about the mutilation of children that what will happen to your faith if routine infant circumcision is stopped.

Just as you cannot measure the physical pain felt by another person (let alone a newborn), you cannot measure the emotional torment caused to an adult when you limit the ability to freely practice one's religion.

I’ll agree that you cannot ask an infant “does this hurt?” just after you start cutting away at it’s genitalia, but there are other measurements that can be taken, such as stress hormones and fMRI brain scans. However, very few medical professionals and parents appear to want to know about what distress the child may be suffering at their hands.

Would you object to better pain relief being insisted upon for all circumcisions? Some Jews in Canada did.

Now, you have said that you place a value of zero on all religions and I think that's ... odd ... but I'm going to go with you on it. I'm going to agree with you that the continued practice of any religion is worthless.

Why proscribe a Jewish practice without limiting the practice of other religions? Why take away circumcisions without taking away Christmas trees (which even many Christians agree are just stupid)?

I have no interest in stopping Jewish people stomping on wine glasses or Christians putting up Christmas trees, or Greeks smashing plates because these acts do not physically affect other people.

I have an interest in stopping Muslims, Jewish, Christians, Atheists and any other people mutilating their children for non medical reasons.

If all religions are worthless and you stop Jews from practicing Judaism but don't keep others from their practices, you have treated Judaism differently. You're not treating all religion the same. Everything has a value of zero but Judaism, which you've taken something away from, has a negative value.

Do you think I’m singling out Judaism in particular? I’m not. I want all unnecessary circumcisions to stop, be they for religious (Jewish and Muslim faiths) or fashion (most of the American public) reasons.

As I have already said. When everyone in America agrees to give up religion completely, I will give up Judaism and circumcisions along with it. Otherwise, whether you value religion or not, you have to treat them all the same.

I am treating them all the same with respect to circumcision.

Now, you may again fall back to your refuge that circumcision is a painful amputation and all painful amputations should be cleansed from all society regardless of religion. But when you do that, you make a value judgment about the harm caused by circumcision. And that value exists nowhere but in your head. It hurts ... or does it? Do we know what an eight day-old feels as pain? It reduces sexual pleasure ... or does it? Do we have any way to compare what pleasure a man would have felt with or without? These are all value judgments.

How about the radical idea that we let the individual choose for themselves? I’ll even let you have 18 (or 21 – you’re the lawyer;)) years to convince your son it’s the right thing to do.

And they all are still only one side of the equation. And they all may not add up to enough to tip the scales. In fact, we know that so far they have not tipped the scales in any jurist or legislature's mind.

Rational minds may differ.

I wonder if it’s for similar reasons that keep public ownership of hand-guns legal in the US?
 
"How stupid is this discussion becoming..."
Only from a couple of perspectives....

I'm still very surprised the hoops that self-described Intelligent People will jump through trying to justify bobbing their male childrens genitals as if they were a dog.... If YOU want to be circumcised, go right ahead.... if you want to INFLICT it on anyone else, I'm here to label you cruel. If you want to circumcise people because some invisible man in the sky told you to, you need treatment.

Darkness and ignorance...
 
Last edited:
I don't think you mean routine infant circumcision, because no one here has defended the idea of routine infant circumcision. No one is saying that all male infants should be circumcised, but rather that it's a private, family decision. I think you mean infant circumcision for reasons other than strictly physical (or medical depending upon how you define it), right?

Not quite. I don't think anyone would care if a mentally healthy person decided to be circumcised when they were old enough to make that decision. What age that is may be open to debate.

The rational defense for infant circumcision comes from the WHO definition of health:

"health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".

Oh pleeeze. A persons social well-being should not be affected one bit by being circumcised or not. For you to argue this is to argue for discrimination based on physical and mental attributes. Something that is illegal.

Or are you saying we should tolerate discrimination against people with certain physical or mental characteristics so long as they can be changed?

It is reasonable to take mental and social well-being into consideration when weighing benefit and harm. The weighing of those considerations is an individual, private matter.

Some of the most reasonable people who have ever lived have committed the greatest atrocities against humanity. Using reason is not enough. That little part of your brain that stops you from smothering a crying baby you're hiding with from the enemy has to be used as well.

It is a public matter to uphold basic human rights.

Finally, some sense. Why aren't you doing it?

Circumcision has not met the standard of what a reasonable person would consider a violation of basic human rights. We know this because it is not a criminal offense to circumcise an infant. I am fully aware that this process is fluid and progressive.

Linda

Lots of acts didn't meet the standard of what a "reasonable" person would consider a violation of basic human rights for an embarrassingly long time. A couple of examples:

A man being allowed to rape his wife. It was a valid defense against a rape charge for a very long time.

A parent or teacher beating a child. (I'm referring to the use of objects such as belts, rulers and canes). It's amazing how many people grow up and say of this type of abuse that they deserved it.

Circumcision of a non-consenting individual is exactly the same, ethically, as these acts. If you consider these to be wrong then, if you are consistent, you must consider the mutilation of a child's genitals (male or female) for no clear medical benefit to be wrong as well.

ETA: You can be sure that there were plenty of people like you Linda, arguing that the current state of affairs was reasonable because it was legal and should not be changed.
 
Last edited:
Loss Leader, are you ignoring me because of my "insults"? It´s just the way I express myself. Please look at what I say rather than the way I say it.

Let me ask you:

Would you consider giving Rushdie to the Iranians?
Would you take into account the emotional torment caused by limiting their ability to freely practice their religion (by murdering him)?
I mean, if I understood correctly your position, you´d have to weigh this emotional torment against the value of Rushdie´s life.
Perhaps one life is not too much comparing it to the millions of emotionally tormented muslims?
 
How stupid is this discussion becoming...

There are laws, safety restrictions that apply to christmas tree lights. Ever heard anyone complaining about them, feeling persecuted by them? Come on...


So what? You and/or others on this thread have argued that religion has NO value or that it only has a SUBJECTIVE value. Fourteen Americans die every year because of Christmas tree fires, some of them children too young to consent to having a Christmas tree. 5,800 people are injured so badly they need hospitalization every year in America from Christmas decorating, some of them children forced by their parents to help decorate when they are too young to consent for themselves.

These are injuries and deaths that could be completely and permanently prevented by outlawing Christmas decorations. The value of celebrating Christmas is zero but there is a value to the lives and healths of the children killed and mutilated every year because of Christmas.

So, why allow Chirstmas decorations?

After all, Christians survived for hundreds of years without making a big deal about Christmas. People from 1899 would hardly recognize the holiday if transported to 1999. If the belief in Jesus as one's personal savior requires that one also drag a flamable tree into one's house, it's not much of a religion. You cannot honestly argue that Christianity or American society would fall apart if we banned Christmas decorations. If you say such a thing, you are saying it Without Evidence.

Now you think that my example about Christmas is just plain silly. You think that there is no comparison between the deaths caused by Christmas decorations and the harm of circumcision.

Here's what I believe:

I believe the reason that you are willing to tolerate the dead and maimed children each Christmas is because Christmas is familiar to you. Oh, you may not believe in Jesus anymore but you were raised celebrating Christmas, your family celebrates Christmas, your friends celebrate Christmas and perhaps you still do. It is part of your culture and part of what defines you and your society.

I believe that you don't see a similarity between Christmas and religious circumcision because Christmas is familiar and religious circumcision is not. It's not part of your world. Your family and friends don't circumcise their sons for religious reasons.

Now try to believe this:

Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture. It is familiar to us. We have fond memories of attending the circumcisions of our family and friends' children. We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised. We see nothing unusual or untoward about it.

I find Christmas unbearable. You find Christmas normal and natural.

You find circumcision unbearable. I find circumcision normal and natural.

Why is there so much difficulty understanding that?
 
Last edited:
"How stupid is this discussion becoming..."
Only from a couple of perspectives....

I'm still very surprised the hoops that self-described Intelligent People will jump through trying to justify bobbing their male childrens genitals as if they were a dog.... If YOU want to be circumcised, go right ahead.... if you want to INFLICT it on anyone else, I'm here to label you cruel. If you want to circumcise people because some invisible man in the sky told you to, you need treatment.

Darkness and ignorance...

Loss Leader I can at least understand. It's Linda and the other medical professionals are the ones that worry me. I'm hoping she is arguing as an intellectual exercise only. Though I may be deluded;)
 
Loss Leader, are you ignoring me because of my "insults"?


No, I'm ignoring kellyb because of her insults. In fact, in all my time on this board, she is the only person I have ever put on Ignore. She implied that I do not have compassion for my children. One can say almost anything they want about me but insulting my parenting is something else altogether.

It´s just the way I express myself.

That is neither an excuse nor an explanation. I would counsel you not to say anything in cyberspace that you wouldn't say to a person's face. Or, at least, that you wouldn't say if you wanted reasoned debate to continue.


Please look at what I say rather than the way I say it.


Generally, I do. However, some might not. Manners exist for a reason.
 
"why allow Chirstmas decorations?"
Asked and answered.... again....

"Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture."
That doesn't make it right...

"We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised."
That's disgusting and barbaric....

"We see nothing unusual or untoward about it."
Then so are you.

"I find circumcision normal and natural."
You're wrong. Full stop.
Why is there so much difficulty understanding that????

John Wayne Gacy didn't think he was doing anything wrong either... Nor do the so-called "faiths" that brutally mutilate their daughters genitals....

"Loss Leader I can at least understand."
I understand that lots of people do lots of stupid things in the name of Ghawd, or tradition.... That they struggle to cling to those stupid things just makes me shake my head and pity them.
 
Last edited:
So why did you become a lawyer? It is one of the occupations that actively limit “plurality of practices”


As a courtesy to you, I will chalk this statement up to the prejudice and generally poor lay understanding of what lawyers do that pervades our culture.

Otherwise, I would be constrained to point out how very rude it is to insult a man's chosen vocation without evidence.
 
These are injuries and deaths that could be completely and permanently prevented by outlawing Christmas decorations. The value of celebrating Christmas is zero but there is a value to the lives and healths of the children killed and mutilated every year because of Christmas.

So, why allow Chirstmas decorations?

Because it is not the intent of the parents to alter their child's body or kill them because of an accident involving christmas decorations.

Here's what I believe:

I believe the reason that you are willing to tolerate the dead and maimed children each Christmas is because Christmas is familiar to you. Oh, you may not believe in Jesus anymore but you were raised celebrating Christmas, your family celebrates Christmas, your friends celebrate Christmas and perhaps you still do. It is part of your culture and part of what defines you and your society.

They are not tolerated. Attempts are made to try and correct it and make it safer. If someone is found to be at fault they are prosecuted.

I believe that you don't see a similarity between Christmas and religious circumcision because Christmas is familiar and religious circumcision is not. It's not part of your world. Your family and friends don't circumcise their sons for religious reasons.

Totally incorrect. I see no similarity because there is none. The intent is totally different. Children get hurt at christmas because of accidents. Children get mutilated at circumcisions because their parents want them mutilated.

I'm all for discussing analogies, but please try to find one that is remotely similar to what you are comparing it to.

Now try to believe this:

Circumcision is part of the Jewish culture. It is familiar to us. We have fond memories of attending the circumcisions of our family and friends' children. We are immensely proud when our own children are circumcised. We see nothing unusual or untoward about it.

I find Christmas unbearable. You find Christmas normal and natural.

You find circumcision unbearable. I find circumcision normal and natural.

Why is there so much difficulty understanding that?

Hey, I find Christmas unbearable too;) I find circumcision unbearable only when it is performed on a non-consenting individual for non-medical reasons. Otherwise I'm fine with it.

Why can't you change just a little bit and wait until the boy is older, say 16?
 
This isn't a rational way to weigh risk and benefit. Some poor little kids have lost their lives from kidney failure and sepsis too. That risk is greater if you are not circumcised.
The risk of having appendicitis is greater if you don't remove the appendix. Some poor little kids have died of appendicitis.

Those who have a need to genitally mutilate defenceless children really can't use your point as a valid argument.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom