Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Loss said:
Now, you can argue that Jews might be able to get by just fine without circumcision. After all, we have the Pidyon Ha'ben and baby namings and all sorts of other good life cycle rites that we could fall back on. But you don't know that. You think it, you suspect it, but you don't know it. Outlawing circumcision could be devastating to Judaism. We know for a fact that Jews do OK wih circumcision but we have no data and no way to gather data on what would happen if you demanded Jews stop the practice.

And you have no evidence that if Jews were to decide to quit circumcising their kids, Judaism would fall apart.
If sexually mutilating your kids is the glue that holds your culture together, you're probably not going to make it anyway.
Fortunately, there's no reason to believe this is the case. Mormons dropped polygamy and they're still going strong. In fact, it appears that Jews used to do lots of weird stuff thousands of years ago (as did all humans back then, so don't think I'm throwing stones) that got dropped somewhere along the way, and yet, Judaism survives.
In fact, it has progressed. Change can be either bad or good. Do you have any evidence at all that abandoning circumcision, one parent and child at a time, would be anything beside beneficial?
Can you even identify the mechanism by which abandoning circumcision might destroy your people?
How it could bring about an end to Judaism?
 
"That is not rational."
+1

902 posts and the "NO" answer is still the best answer to the OP


Yes, well as I said you can just define "rational" to exclude my explanation. It doesn't make you right. So what part of my defense is irrational, in your opinion?
 
And you have no evidence that if Jews were to decide to quit circumcising their kids, Judaism would fall apart.
If sexually mutilating your kids is the glue that holds your culture together, you're probably not going to make it anyway.
Fortunately, there's no reason to believe this is the case. Mormons dropped polygamy and they're still going strong. In fact, it appears that Jews used to do lots of weird stuff thousands of years ago (as did all humans back then, so don't think I'm throwing stones) that got dropped somewhere along the way, and yet, Judaism survives.
In fact, it has progressed. Change can be either bad or good. Do you have any evidence at all that abandoning circumcision, one parent and child at a time, would be anything beside beneficial?
Can you even identify the mechanism by which abandoning circumcision might destroy your people?
How it could bring about an end to Judaism?

You mean like Jews (and probably many other cultures) used to do to disobedient children?
 
Yes, well as I said you can just define "rational" to exclude my explanation. It doesn't make you right. So what part of my defense is irrational, in your opinion?

I'll tell you what's irrational about it. It's based entirely on argumentum ad antiquitatem. If I may be so bold, you need to move beyond "is" into the territory of "should".

We have not defined rational to exclude your explanation. Logic has! You can claim all you want that we're moving the goalposts to keep you from scoring, the fact is the goalposts haven't moved, it's merely your crippled leg that keeps you from making any points.
 
Last edited:
That's exactly what I was thinking of. :D

While I was checking up on this I found that it is not just a few small Islamic communities were it is still legal to practice this form of execution, but many of the countries in the middle east, including (from wikipedia):

Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Sudan, Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, Pakistan,
and the United Arab Emirates.

It is also practiced commonly in Iraqi Kurdistan.

Seems some traditions really do die hard...:eek:

(Every time I think of someone being stoned I can't help but think of The Life of Brian)
 
I'll tell you what's irrational about it. It's based entirely on argumentum ad antiquitatem. If I may be so bold, you need to move beyond "is" into the territory of "should".


I'm sorry; if you were right, I'd agree with you.

I am NOT arguing that circumcision is right because it is a long-standing tradition.

I am arguing that Jews circumcise their children and that preservation of the Jewish faith is a good thing .

Now, if you claim that there is no reason why Jews should want to circumcise their children and I responded "But we've always done it that way," I would be making an argument from antiquity.

Instead, you claim that there is no reason why Jews should want to circumcise their children and I respond thusly: You are not a Jew or a scholar of Jewish law, you do not know what effect prohibiting circumcision would have, you do not know what effect removing an element of diversity from our pluralistic society might have, your personal beliefs about circumcision should not be enforced at the expense of our religion.

I'm not saying WHY Jews circumcise their children. I'm saying that the fact that they do is an aspect of Judaism. Changing it changes an aspect of Judaism. And having an outsider come and dictate a change to an aspect of Judaism may destroy it.

If you place a value of zero on the Jewish faith, you might subjectively believe my argument is irrational. I must warn you, however, that some who have in the past placed a value of zero on the Jewish faith have not faired well.
 
I'm sorry; if you were right, I'd agree with you.

I am NOT arguing that circumcision is right because it is a long-standing tradition.

I am arguing that Jews circumcise their children and that preservation of the Jewish faith is a good thing .

It is neither good nor bad. The Jewish faith will almost certainly disappear (or change beyond recognition) given enough time.

Now, if you claim that there is no reason why Jews should want to circumcise their children and I responded "But we've always done it that way," I would be making an argument from antiquity.

Instead, you claim that there is no reason why Jews should want to circumcise their children and I respond thusly: You are not a Jew or a scholar of Jewish law, you do not know what effect prohibiting circumcision would have, you do not know what effect removing an element of diversity from our pluralistic society might have, your personal beliefs about circumcision should not be enforced at the expense of our religion.

They are not personal beliefs. They are objective facts.

About 2% of circumcisions go wrong.
Cutting off flesh hurts during and after the operation.
Generally, humans do not enjoy pain. If it is prolonged it triggers a physiological stress response.

Which one of these is a "personal belief"?

I'm not saying WHY Jews circumcise their children. I'm saying that the fact that they do is an aspect of Judaism. Changing it changes an aspect of Judaism. And having an outsider come and dictate a change to an aspect of Judaism may destroy it.

That's why Jews should get their house in order themselves, so the law does not have to be changed to force them to. It appears some already are.

If you place a value of zero on the Jewish faith, you might subjectively believe my argument is irrational. I must warn you, however, that some who have in the past placed a value of zero on the Jewish faith have not faired well.

LOL!:D

I place a value of zero on ALL faiths, not just yours. However, I acknowledge it's your right to believe whatever you want.
 
I'm not saying WHY Jews circumcise their children. I'm saying that the fact that they do is an aspect of Judaism. Changing it changes an aspect of Judaism.
Yeah...it would change it for the better.

And having an outsider come and dictate a change to an aspect of Judaism may destroy it.
#1- Provide evidence to support that claim
#2- The change your culture from within, if you really think that's the case

I must warn you, however, that some who have in the past placed a value of zero on the Jewish faith have not faired well.
Oh, blablabla....

Are you going to have your deity send a bear to eat us all or something?
 
I have to say, I never would have expected circumcision to be defended on the basis that ending the practice may destroy Judaism. If Judaism will fall without ritual genital mutilation, we're better off without it.

The world has far too many who use their religious beliefs to justify the harm they inflict on others. Of all people, Jews should recognize this.

Also, your posts carry an implied accusation that anyone who opposes you circumcising your boys is an anti-semite. That is poisoning the well, and IMO should be resented by everyone here.
 
Yes, well as I said you can just define "rational" to exclude my explanation. It doesn't make you right. So what part of my defense is irrational, in your opinion?

Uh, there is nothing whatsoever that is rational about your "argument". All you say is that preserving circumcision is primordial to preserving Judaism (without evidence, mind you), and that somehow should convince us. :newlol

I have to say, I never would have expected circumcision to be defended on the basis that ending the practice may destroy Judaism. If Judaism will fall without ritual genital mutilation, we're better off without it.

The world has far too many who use their religious beliefs to justify the harm they inflict on others. Of all people, Jews should recognize this.

Also, your posts carry an implied accusation that anyone who opposes you circumcising your boys is an anti-semite. That is poisoning the well, and IMO should be resented by everyone here.
Seconded, on every account.
 
They are not personal beliefs. They are objective facts.

About 2% of circumcisions go wrong.
Cutting off flesh hurts during and after the operation.
Generally, humans do not enjoy pain. If it is prolonged it triggers a physiological stress response.

Which one of these is a "personal belief"?


Yes, well, as I have already said:


In any case, the debate over circumcision's degree of harm is just that: a debate. Remember, the harm to the child has to outweigh all of the harm that would be done to Judaism, whatever that may be. I have no doubt that you in your mind have the ability to assign these things weights and to make a determination. However, you should have no doubt that rational minds may assign them different weights. The pain to the infant might be a 7 to you while to me it's a 3. The possibility of damaging Judaism might be a 2 to you while to me it's a 27. There is nothing objectively measurable about these criteria. Rational minds may differ.


So all of the things you say may be true. Heck, just to be sociable I will agree that they are all true. But they are only one side of the equation. They are the harm caused by circumcision. We still must balance that with the harm caused by prohibiting Jews from practicing their religion. That harm is difficult to calculate but that doesn't make it zero. As I have said over and over, anything that reduces the plurality of practices in this country reduces overall energy and creativity in our culture. Add in the great psychological torment you will cause observant Jews by your decree. Add in the unknown effect on the religion as a whole. Add it the horrifying precedent you set of limiting the religious practices of others because they ... have no effect on your personal life whatsoever but yet you find them distasteful. Just as you cannot measure the physical pain felt by another person (let alone a newborn), you cannot measure the emotional torment caused to an adult when you limit the ability to freely practice one's religion.

Now, you have said that you place a value of zero on all religions and I think that's ... odd ... but I'm going to go with you on it. I'm going to agree with you that the continued practice of any religion is worthless.

Why proscribe a Jewish practice without limiting the practice of other religions? Why take away circumcisions without taking away Christmas trees (which even many Christians agree are just stupid)? If all religions are worthless and you stop Jews from practicing Judaism but don't keep others from their practices, you have treated Judaism differently. You're not treating all religion the same. Everything has a value of zero but Judaism, which you've taken something away from, has a negative value.

As I have already said. When everyone in America agrees to give up religion completely, I will give up Judaism and circumcisions along with it. Otherwise, whether you value religion or not, you have to treat them all the same.

Now, you may again fall back to your refuge that circumcision is a painful amputation and all painful amputations should be cleansed from all society regardless of religion. But when you do that, you make a value judgment about the harm caused by circumcision. And that value exists nowhere but in your head. It hurts ... or does it? Do we know what an eight day-old feels as pain? It reduces sexual pleasure ... or does it? Do we have any way to compare what pleasure a man would have felt with or without? These are all value judgments.

And they all are still only one side of the equation. And they all may not add up to enough to tip the scales. In fact, we know that so far they have not tipped the scales in any jurist or legislature's mind.

Rational minds may differ.
 
"preservation of the Jewish faith is a good thing"
Not if it leads to mutilating children it isn't....

"without taking away Christmas trees"
Christmas trees don't mutilate children.
 
Christmas trees don't mutilate children.


Between 2000 and 2004 there were an average of 300 home fires yearly that started with Christmas trees which caused a yearly average of 14 deaths and 21 injuries. One out of every twenty-two Christmas tree fires results in death. An average of 5,800 injuries per year were reported in US emergency rooms due to Christmas decorating accidents. (source).

Please, won't somebody think of the children!
 
Between 2000 and 2004 there were an average of 300 home fires yearly that started with Christmas trees which caused a yearly average of 14 deaths and 21 injuries. One out of every twenty-two Christmas tree fires results in death. An average of 5,800 injuries per year were reported in US emergency rooms due to Christmas decorating accidents. (source).

Please, won't somebody think of the children!

How stupid is this discussion becoming...

There are laws, safety restrictions that apply to christmas tree lights. Ever heard anyone complaining about them, feeling persecuted by them? Come on...

If cristians (or pagans, more appropriately) required the presence of unsafe christmas lights in every home, do you think we wouldn´t complain about that the same way we complain about jews requiring circumcisions for the integrity of their faith? It would be a similar kind of B.S.
 
"you cannot measure the emotional torment caused to an adult when you limit the ability to freely practice one's religion."

You´re starting to sound a bit taliban-ish again.


As I have already said. When everyone in America agrees to give up religion completely, I will give up Judaism and circumcisions along with it. Otherwise, whether you value religion or not, you have to treat them all the same.

Yes, we should require exactly the same from all religions, to comply with secular laws and not to disregard human rights. The problem is that some religions have to change more than others. Many muslims would probably ask to allow for sharia laws to be applied in their communities living in Western societies. Would you deny their right to assasinate apostates? What about the emotional torment caused if you limit their ability to freely practice their religion? See the slippery slope?
 
Circumcision, if I ran the world, would be child abuse, plain and simple (Exception, the very few cases where it's a necessary medical procedure)

The rest of your question, I'm not going to be baited into dignifying with any response.

I am seriously interested in how you perceive the duty of others to consider your ideas.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom