Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Well, yes, I guess you'd be right if it wasn't exactly the same as the first post I made when I entered this thread. Here, let me remind you:

I wasn't talking about the first post, I was talking about the ones in between.

So, um, if you want to declare yourself the winner, go ahead. You're not but I understand how it might make you feel better.

I have not declared myself the winner, I have declared you the loser. When I (and others) challenged your position, you attempted to defend yourself with a bunch of BS about how your will is your child's will, etc. Then when each of your arguments were countered, instead of actually conceding any of the relavant points, you said, basically, you just don't care!

You just don't care if your ethics are sound. You just don't care if you're committing a fundamental abuse of human rights and causing pointless pain and suffering. You just don't care!

You get to circumcise, we can't stop you, and to you that's all that matters.

And that makes you the big loser.
 
Again, circumcision is much more like a parental induced haircut than to the butchery you seem to think it is. It is a minor, cosmetic, out-patient procedure (in fact, it is so simple that it has been done for thousands of years without impacting communities) which is, yes, painful to the infant (although no existing research shows it is more traumatic than being hungry for a couple of minutes, which results in the same "pain" cries), but is also harmless, and physiologically irrelevant.
The fact that Loss Leader framed his responses in legal language is also irrelevant to the discussion. How is circumcision in male infants in the developed world at all comparable to female circumcision (misnamed as the adjunct to the male foreskin is not the object of female circumcision) ?
 
I apologize if I seemed flippant. I certainly meant no disrespect to the ideas of others.
As a circumcised male in a largely circumsised society (USA), I can't help but see my state as the "normal" state. Since I have no objective evidence (unlike victims of female genital mutilation) that my state is significantly different than the "other" state (the plural of anecdote is not data), I see the difference as inconsequential.
I actually thought of the earlobe-clipping argument myself, but in the opposite way. I could argue that the earlobe-clipping was transitorially painful, but important to the child's parents. The child would not notice the clipping at all, except by the counter-example of non-clipped peers, and the chances that the clipping would alter the child's normal development would be close to nil.
I do agree that earlobe-nibbling can be unbelievably erotic and stimulating, but at the same time, I would not logically accept that earlobe-clipping impairs the (hypothetical)child in any way.


But the issue is:

Can the parents decide by themselves to chop off bits of their kids?

I can´t believe it but your answer seems to be "yes"!

I could argue that the earlobe-clipping was transitorially painful, but important to the child's parents.

So what? They still shouldn´t be allowed to perform any irreversible mutilations on unconsenting kids! Are we going nuts? And the fact that it´s a "minor" procedure is a purely SUBJECTIVE valoration. The objective reality is that we´re talking about an irreversible amputation. You guys are in denial... Why is it so hard to admit that?
 
Again, circumcision is much more like a parental induced haircut than to the butchery you seem to think it is. It is a minor, cosmetic, out-patient procedure (in fact, it is so simple that it has been done for thousands of years without impacting communities) which is, yes, painful to the infant (although no existing research shows it is more traumatic than being hungry for a couple of minutes, which results in the same "pain" cries), but is also harmless, and physiologically irrelevant.
The fact that Loss Leader framed his responses in legal language is also irrelevant to the discussion. How is circumcision in male infants in the developed world at all comparable to female circumcision (misnamed as the adjunct to the male foreskin is not the object of female circumcision) ?

Hair does not have ANY nerve endings in it.

It is fascinating the way you constantly try to dismiss the pain an infant must feel having one of the most sensitive organs on its body cut away at.

I suggest you go sterilize a pin and push it into the end of your penis. Keep doing this for 1-2 minutes. See if it is about the same level of discomfort as a hair cut or being hungry for a couple of minutes or having your nails clipped:rolleyes:

But as others have said, that is not the real point. The point, which parents who choose circumcision just don't get (or want to get), is that it is not their choice to make in the first place! Only if the procedure is indicated (very rare in newborns), should parents even be asked to consent by physicians.

It's called patient autonomy, something that medical professionals are supposed to promote and usually do.
 
When I (and others) challenged your position, you attempted to defend yourself with a bunch of BS about how your will is your child's will, etc.


Once again, I suppose you would be right if my argument that my will substitutes for my newborn were BS. Instead, it is an exact description of the laws of substituted judgment: laws that have developed over hundreds if not thousands of years, are deeply rooted in the western notions of justice, are affirmed and reaffirmed in courts and legislatures throughout at least my nation, and are broadly applicable and adaptable to unending variations in circumstance.

So, yeah, if all that is BS then you're right.

The simple fact is that you believe circumcision to be such a major invasion of the body that parents should not have the right to substitute their judgment for their children. Okay, I understand that's what you believe. But since the vast majority of my nation's courts, legislatures and citizens don't agree with you, your beliefs are insignificant.

And that's not BS, either.
 
Once again, I suppose you would be right if my argument that my will substitutes for my newborn were BS. Instead, it is an exact description of the laws of substituted judgment: laws that have developed over hundreds if not thousands of years, are deeply rooted in the western notions of justice, are affirmed and reaffirmed in courts and legislatures throughout at least my nation, and are broadly applicable and adaptable to unending variations in circumstance.

So, yeah, if all that is BS then you're right.
.

Strawman! Not arguing about those laws in general, but about particular laws, which can always be improved (without demeriting their grandiose origins)

The simple fact is that you believe circumcision to be such a major invasion of the body that parents should not have the right to substitute their judgment for their children.
.

More exactly: For any medically unnecessary and irreversible body modification or amputation, parents should be legally forced to wait until the kid reaches maturity. Major or not major is subjective, and irrelevant.

Okay, I understand that's what you believe. But since the vast majority of my nation's courts, legislatures and citizens don't agree with you, your beliefs are insignificant.

And that's not BS, either.

It is. Things might change some day. That´s what we´re arguing about here, wether there SHOULD be laws against this (relatively mild) form of child abuse. And that´s not irrelevant.

With your kind of reasoning you´d make a good totalitarian, you could defend any other position that courts, legislatures and citizens at some point have agreed upon... slavery, capital punishment for apostasy or whatever.
 
With your kind of reasoning you´d make a good totalitarian, you could defend any other position that courts, legislatures and citizens at some point have agreed upon... slavery, capital punishment for apostasy or whatever.


I suppose you would be right if my argument were that whatever courts, legislatures and the citizenry agrees on is just. Unfortunately for your reading skills, that's not what I said in my last post and not what I've said repeatedly in this thread. What I said was:

Instead, it is an exact description of the laws of substituted judgment: laws that have developed over hundreds if not thousands of years, are deeply rooted in the western notions of justice, are affirmed and reaffirmed in courts and legislatures throughout at least my nation ...


I also said this:


Once again, I outlined that the law of substituted judgement is just in my opinion because (in part) it respects religious and family rights. I also acknowledged that the state does have an interest in the welfare of children. So there are three objective moral positions around which the law of substituted judgment has formed. Lots and lots of Germans believed in the Neuremburg laws; but they were injust because they did not respect the rights of the minority. There is objectivity.


And this:


The laws about substituted judgment are just, that's the absolute sum total of what I said.

Why are they just?

1. They are the laws of a democratic nation.

2. They were developed over a long time.

3. They have respect for the rights of minorities.

4. They have respect for the rights of families.


And this:

So, when are we justified in believing that legal and right are at least vaguely in the same area as each other?

The answer is to look at how the thing became legal. In a society where laws are made by a dictator, the chance that the laws are just is pretty small. The laws will probably just help the dictator stay in power. The same is true of an oligarchy. Even where laws are made by majority will, there is a chance the majority will use the occassion to crush the minority.

Laws should be arived at democratically, judiciously and with reference to agreed upon definitions of human rights.

Now, the law that allows me to substitute my judgment for my incompetent son - is that a just law? It is certainly the law of a democratic land (my country, the USA). And it didn't come about yesterday: the concept of substituted judgment has evolved through the common law for as long as there has been common law. And it allows minorities to practice their beliefs even when the majority might not make the same decision. It also allows for a husband and wife to control their own home and raise their own children in a manner they believe is appropriate.
...
As the rules regarding substituted judgment are not just legal but are legal within a political framework that is just, we are correct in equating legal with right in this instance.


So, I have repeatedly drawn the distinction between the laws of substituted judgment and "any other position that courts, legislatures and citizens at some point have agreed upon... slavery, capital punishment for apostasy or whatever." The two things are not identical and I have never claimed they were. Thus, I think I'd make a rather poor totalitarian. You, on the other hand, might do absolutely wonderfully in that position seeing as you have apparently zero tolerance for a person whose beliefs differ from your own.
 
" Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?"
888 posts, and still the answer is "NO"


Yes, if you keep redefining the word "rational" to exclude any defense of circumcision, I guess you'd be right. You wouldn't be honest or logical, but you'd be right.
 
I suppose you would be right if my argument were that whatever courts, legislatures and the citizenry agrees on is just. Unfortunately for your reading skills, that's not what I said in my last post and not what I've said repeatedly in this thread. What I said was:




I also said this:





And this:





And this:




So, I have repeatedly drawn the distinction between the laws of substituted judgment and "any other position that courts, legislatures and citizens at some point have agreed upon... slavery, capital punishment for apostasy or whatever." The two things are not identical and I have never claimed they were. Thus, I think I'd make a rather poor totalitarian. You, on the other hand, might do absolutely wonderfully in that position seeing as you have apparently zero tolerance for a person whose beliefs differ from your own.

Ok, so i didn´t read all your comments, and was answering your last post and what it looked like you were saying. Nevermind. Quite possibly you´re right on that particular issue.

BUT the main issue of this thread is:

For medically unnecessary and irreversible body modifications or amputations, should parents be legally forced to wait until the kid reaches maturity or not.

Didn´t you say parents can do ANYTING to their kids? I consider that idea so abhorrent and monstruous that, perhaps that´s why I expected more f*cked up totalitarian B.S: in your post. If you´re a lovely geezer in all other respects, good for you!
 
Loss Leader said:
You, on the other hand, might do absolutely wonderfully in that position seeing as you have apparently zero tolerance for a person whose beliefs differ from your own.

Why do you say that? I´m only arguing that RIC is against human rights. Zero tolerance would just follow logically from this.
 
Last edited:
"if you keep redefining the word "rational" to exclude any defense of circumcision"
I've redefined nothing... I have yet to see a single rational defence of any 'routine' mutilation.

892 posts, and still the answer is "no"
 
" We are a group of educated and enlightened Jews who realize that the barbaric, primitive, torturous, and mutilating practice of circumcision has no place in modern Judaism."

Thank FK!
 
"if you keep redefining the word "rational" to exclude any defense of circumcision"
I've redefined nothing... I have yet to see a single rational defence of any 'routine' mutilation.

892 posts, and still the answer is "no"

What do you all think should be done when you hate someone else's ideas - specific to circumcision and in general?

Linda
 
Circumcision, if I ran the world, would be child abuse, plain and simple (Exception, the very few cases where it's a necessary medical procedure)

The rest of your question, I'm not going to be baited into dignifying with any response.
 
What do you all think should be done when you hate someone else's ideas - specific to circumcision and in general?

Linda

I don't particularly hate the idea of circumcision. All surgery is brutal. I hate the hypocritical behaviour and thought processes behind routine infant circumcision. I really hate the dismissal of another person's suffering just because they can't remember it.

What should be done with respect to routine circumcision of infants:

Physicians should not be offering it as a service. Unless there is clear indication it is required, or is likely to offer the child a clinically significant advantage, circumcision should not be performed by medical professionals.

The obvious argument to this approach is some determined parents will go to "back-street" circumciser's who will not be able to deal with complications arising from the procedure. However, my guess is that if the service was not offered to parents the vast majority would not force the issue, or seek the procedure elsewhere.

In general, the best solution to bad ideas is to come up with better ones, rather than excuses and exceptions to dodge the issue.
 
I've redefined nothing... I have yet to see a single rational defence of any 'routine' mutilation.


Well, let me try to lay it out for you. Again.

Accept as true the following single premise: The continued existence of Jews on this planet is a good thing.

I don't know why you wouldn't accept that as true but let me just remind you that the Jewish people have woven a continuous thread throughout human history. We have, during the dark ages, helped to keep science and mathematics alive in the western world. We carried the burden of banking at a time when the western world looked down on it and those practices (of lending out the money others deposit, etc.) helped add capital to the west. The disproportionate number of Jews in medicine and law continues to this day. And, in countries that would otherwise have almost no diversity, we serve as a reminder that there are other ways to live, other ways to think and other choices to make than the ones approved by the majority. In social situations, diversity of opinion leads to increased creativity and activity.

Lots of very influential historical figures were Jews including Jerry Seinfeld, Krusty the Clown and everybody's favorite example for everything.

You may say that there should be no religion whatsoever in the world and perhaps you're right. When everyone else disbands their religions, Jews might be right in joining them. However, so long as there are other religions, Jews serve an important role in the plurality that makes our civilization so robust.

In any case, I've asked you to just accept as true that having Jews is a good thing.

Now, Jews circumcise their sons. They do. It's as ancient a part of the Jewish tradition as anything - dating back to Abraham living in Ur, one of the first cities in all of human history. I am circumcised, my father was circumcised, his father was circumcised and I could create a macro for "and his father was circumcised" and hit it something like two hundred times (or however many, it's a lot).

That's it. That's my whole argument.

Now, you can argue that Jews might be able to get by just fine without circumcision. After all, we have the Pidyon Ha'ben and baby namings and all sorts of other good life cycle rites that we could fall back on. But you don't know that. You think it, you suspect it, but you don't know it. Outlawing circumcision could be devastating to Judaism. We know for a fact that Jews do OK wih circumcision but we have no data and no way to gather data on what would happen if you demanded Jews stop the practice.

You may argue that the Jewish practice of circumcision is unreasonable but note that you are now arguing within the religion. You are (I suspect) not Jewish, you are (probably) not a Rabbi, you are (likely) not a scholor of Judaism. So you would be telling people how to practice their religion without fully understanding their religion. If religious practices have zero value and if there should be no religion, perhaps you'd be right. But so long as there are religions, an outsider cannot really judge which religious practice has value and which doesn't.

You have one last refuge. Perhaps circumcision is so harmful to a child that no one should be allowed to do it. After all, some religions have practices which society finds so abhorant that they are just disallowed for reasons of public safety. Zoarastrians traditionally threw their dead in a sand pit to be eaten by vultures. This is illegal in the US. Even a Muslim woman wearing a veil in her driver's license picture has been deemed illegal because the public's need to identify the woman was found to be greater than her need to practice her religion.

Is circumcision so harmful to the public's interests that it should be forbidden as a religious practice? The answer is that I don't know. Maybe. There are reasons to think it is - it's permanent, it hurts, it may impair sexual pleasure. But there are reasons to think it isn't - the pain is transitory, it may not impair sexual pleasure, it might have some small medical benefit, lots of circumcised people have led wonderful, fulfilling lives, etc.

In any case, the debate over circumcision's degree of harm is just that: a debate. Remember, the harm to the child has to outweigh all of the harm that would be done to Judaism, whatever that may be. I have no doubt that you in your mind have the ability to assign these things weights and to make a determination. However, you should have no doubt that rational minds may assign them different weights. The pain to the infant might be a 7 to you while to me it's a 3. The possibility of damaging Judaism might be a 2 to you while to me it's a 27. There is nothing objectively measurable about these criteria. Rational minds may differ.

Circumcision for religious reasons is rational so long as: 1) you place any value on maintaining a religious tradition; and 2) you place less value on the state's interest in protecting children from whatever may be the harms of circumcision.

And that's a rational defense. You may not agree with it, but it's rational.
 
Last edited:
Well, let me try to lay it out for you. Again.

Accept as true the following single premise: The continued existence of Jews on this planet is a good thing.

I don't know why you wouldn't accept that as true but let me just remind you that the Jewish people have woven a continuous thread throughout human history. We have, during the dark ages, helped to keep science and mathematics alive in the western world. We carried the burden of banking at a time when the western world looked down on it and those practices (of lending out the money others deposit, etc.) helped add capital to the west. The disproportionate number of Jews in medicine and law continues to this day. And, in countries that would otherwise have almost no diversity, we serve as a reminder that there are other ways to live, other ways to think and other choices to make than the ones approved by the majority. In social situations, diversity of opinion leads to increased creativity and activity.

Lots of very influential historical figures were Jews including Jerry Seinfeld, Krusty the Clown and everybody's favorite example for everything.

You may say that there should be no religion whatsoever in the world and perhaps you're right. When everyone else disbands their religions, Jews might be right in joining them. However, so long as there are other religions, Jews serve an important role in the plurality that makes our civilization so robust.

In any case, I've asked you to just accept as true that having Jews is a good thing.

Now, Jews circumcise their sons. They do. It's as ancient a part of the Jewish tradition as anything - dating back to Abraham living in Ur, one of the first cities in all of human history. I am circumcised, my father was circumcised, his father was circumcised and I could create a macro for "and his father was circumcised" and hit it something like two hundred times (or however many, it's a lot).

That's it. That's my whole argument.

Now, you can argue that Jews might be able to get by just fine without circumcision. After all, we have the Pidyon Ha'ben and baby namings and all sorts of other good life cycle rites that we could fall back on. But you don't know that. You think it, you suspect it, but you don't know it. Outlawing circumcision could be devastating to Judaism. We know for a fact that Jews do OK wih circumcision but we have no data and no way to gather data on what would happen if you demanded Jews stop the practice.

You may argue that the Jewish practice of circumcision is unreasonable but note that you are now arguing within the religion. You are (I suspect) not Jewish, you are (probably) not a Rabbi, you are (likely) not a scholor of Judaism. So you would be telling people how to practice their religion without fully understanding their religion. If religious practices have zero value and if there should be no religion, perhaps you'd be right. But so long as there are religions, an outsider cannot really judge which religious practice has value and which doesn't.

You have one last refuge. Perhaps circumcision is so harmful to a child that no one should be allowed to do it. After all, some religions have practices which society finds so abhorant that they are just disallowed for reasons of public safety. Zoarastrians traditionally threw their dead in a sand pit to be eaten by vultures. This is illegal in the US. Even a Muslim woman wearing a veil in her driver's license picture has been deemed illegal because the public's need to identify the woman was found to be greater than her need to practice her religion.

Is circumcision so harmful to the public's interests that it should be forbidden as a religious practice? The answer is that I don't know. Maybe. There are reasons to think it is - it's permanent, it hurts, it may impair sexual pleasure. But there are reasons to think it isn't - the pain is transitory, it may not impair sexual pleasure, it might have some small medical benefit, lots of circumcised people have led wonderful, fulfilling lives, etc.

In any case, the debate over circumcision's degree of harm is just that: a debate. Remember, the harm to the child has to outweigh all of the harm that would be done to Judaism, whatever that may be. I have no doubt that you in your mind have the ability to assign these things weights and to make a determination. However, you should have no doubt that rational minds may assign them different weights. The pain to the infant might be a 7 to you while to me it's a 3. The possibility of damaging Judaism might be a 2 to you while to me it's a 27. There is nothing objectively measurable about these criteria. Rational minds may differ.

Circumcision for religious reasons is rational so long as: 1) you place any value on maintaining a religious tradition; and 2) you place less value on the state's interest in protecting children from whatever may be the harms of circumcision.

And that's a rational defense. You may not agree with it, but it's rational.

You are trying to equate something with no objective value, with something that is observed every year in the US. That is not rational.

The possibility of damaging Judaism is intangible. Religion has no objective value.

The possibility of your son being damaged by circumcision is an objective reality. Every year about 2% of circumcisions go wrong, in some way or another.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom