Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history. My relatives who dies in the Holocaust were circumcised. My relatives who were murdered during the black plague were circumcised.
Appeal to emotion noted.

My relatives who were slaves in Egypt
Evidence?

And when the next wave of antisemitism hits - and it will - I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.
And they can't do that unless their genitals are mutilated, because...? Is Judaism such a pitiful and pathetic religion/culture? :newlol
And now antisemitism has been brought up and the implications are already flying. Thread Godwinned in 3... 2...

And what if the Nazis come for us when he's fifteen? Or nine? Or six months old?
1! Ding ding, here we go.

No, I'm a lawyer.
:newlol

I don't know what you mean by that. If you mean that Nazis might spare my son because he is uncircumcised, I assure you I would rather see my son die as a Jew than live in denial of the same.
Really? You'd not only rather die than temporarily pretending to not be a Jew, but would also make sure your son did the same? Because we all know that dying a martyr is so much more constructive and productive and keep on living, where one might actually eventually elude the enemy and then vanquish him. :rolleyes:

There is a massive difference between *pride* and "consider[ing] Jewish people superior somehow." I have pride in my heritage; I do not consider my religion superior.
I assume then that you are okay with the following statement: "I have pride in my Germanic, Nordic, White heritage."


If you block Jews from circumcising their children, you remove one building block in the ediface that is a religion as old as recorded history. Will my religion crumble as a result? I don;t know. But I don't want to find out. If you're wrong, you strike a blow against Judaism itself. If I'm wrong, I ... cause temporary pain to an infant with almost no medical consequences. I would prefer to keep my religion intact.
Again. What kind of pathetic, wretched religion is actually hurt by the loss of an outdated, irrational, useless procedure? Considering the very same arguments you made could be made, hell, have been made, by the proponents of female circumcision, that's quite telling, anyway. Reminds me also of the Biblical support for slavery.

A rational person with a healthy look on life would use his or her critical thinking to discriminate between traditions that have merit and are worth valueing, cherishing and preserving, and what is obsolete, stupid and/or unethical and to be discarded. Only a blind fanatic or a brainwashed woo would continue a tradition for the sake of tradition.
Thankfully, the "tradition" of slavery has been abolished.

Watch the hyperbole. The day my religious practices are deemed criminal is the day I join the revolution.
I'm tempted to make a sarcastic comment about how scary a Jewish revolution would be, but... I probably should not. Still, :newlol

Don't know, don't care, didn't even click the links.
Ah, intellectual dishonesty at its finest. "*blocks ears* Lalala I can't hear you!"
 
Really. Just...really. Circumcision is a minor cosmetic procedure often done to infants for a variety of reasons and non-reasons. Yes, the baby often cries. The baby cries during birth, should I have shoved mine back into my wife because breathing was traumatic for him?
What happened the first time any of you trimmed your child's nails?
I can say with great confidence that your child was tormented by the fires of hell during the procedure. But our trimmed nail fetish has no medical indications.
I have no foreskin. Am I missing out on some hypothetical sensations? Perhaps. But I probably discovered my little mushroom before my uncircumsised friends, and got a year of two of extra happy time that might make up for a tiny loss in feeling over the rest of my life.

Oh, by the way, in America most females are a bit put out by the "whole" package, so my son may have gained a slight advantage in getting laid. And I can definitely say that that alone justifies the (irrelevant and not worth arguing about) procedure.
 
Really. Just...really. Circumcision is a minor cosmetic procedure often done to infants for a variety of reasons and non-reasons. Yes, the baby often cries. The baby cries during birth, should I have shoved mine back into my wife because breathing was traumatic for him?
What happened the first time any of you trimmed your child's nails?
I can say with great confidence that your child was tormented by the fires of hell during the procedure. But our trimmed nail fetish has no medical indications.
I have no foreskin. Am I missing out on some hypothetical sensations? Perhaps. But I probably discovered my little mushroom before my uncircumsised friends, and got a year of two of extra happy time that might make up for a tiny loss in feeling over the rest of my life.

Oh, by the way, in America most females are a bit put out by the "whole" package, so my son may have gained a slight advantage in getting laid. And I can definitely say that that alone justifies the (irrelevant and not worth arguing about) procedure.
:D Love the mushroom story.
 
This is either your wishful thinking or just your brain's way of making sense of the world. I can repeat my position. But I ask you to take it as is and not try to make it fit your beliefs. Because I do not see the world the way you see it, nor is your summary of my beliefs the least bit accurate.

Skeptigirl, I’ve just read what you’ve written below and can’t see how I misrepresented your position at all:confused:

I see no reason in the medical literature (the evidence) to recommend to any parent that they do or do not circumcise their child. That is where a provider should be, in my opinion, when the evidence is equivocal.

I stated that you found the evidence for circumcision equivocal. This is what you have said (again).

There is not sufficient evidence to show real harm from circumcisions despite the emotionally charged beliefs coming from a minority of men. While there are a few men who feel strongly opposed to circumcision and seem to think they have lost (or others will lose) significant amount of sexual pleasure. At the same time, there are at least a few men who have had circumcisions as adults to enhance their sexual pleasure (see citations I already posted). It would seem for the vast majority of men who have had a circumcision, they rarely think twice about it.

Others may have made the sexual function argument. I certainly have not. All we can say for certain is that it changes the sensation a man feels.

On the other side, there is some medical evidence circumcising infants prevents UTIs. The incidence of UTI in male infants was somewhere between 1-5% give or take from what I gathered from the research. Of those, especially in infants under age 2, a UTI can be a serious infection commonly including bacteria spreading to the bloodstream. In addition, having a single UTI necessitates invasive procedures and several weeks at least of antibiotics.

The largest study I found was a Cohort study of over 400000 boys, which indicated that the incidence of UTI in uncircumcised boys was just over 1.1% and in circumcised boys it was 0.13%. So it appears circumcision gives a 10-fold reduction in UTI’s. Other research has estimated that ~7.5% of infants who get a UTI have renal scaring.

The complication rates for circumcision are not well researched, but have been estimated at about 2%.

So ignoring the magnitude of the complications (which can be just as serious as renal scaring), for a group of healthy boys circumcision will cause more problems than it prevents.

Neither the emotional appeals by a minority of men which lacks empirical evidence, nor the medical benefits of UTI risk reduction are very strong indicators for or against circumcision. In addition, people hold many different personal beliefs for and against circumcision.

Why do you consider my (and others) ethical argument an emotional appeal? If I were arguing that we should not fondle a women’s breasts (unless she wants them to be fondled;)), would that be an appeal to emotion?

Hopefully you would reply that there is a large amount of empirical evidence that women do not want their breasts fondled unless they request it. I’ll say now there’s just as much evidence that a man does not want his penis altered without his informed consent being asked for first.

Two things are absolutely certain: No mentally healthy person chooses to have their body altered without a great deal of thought. No person wants a part of their body to be altered at the decision of someone else when they are incapacitated.

In this case, I have no reason to be for or against any parent's decision to circumcise or not circumcise their child. I have no ethical concerns about their decision. As far as FGM goes, circumcision isn't a gender rights issue. Tit for tat is an absurd argument to make in any medical decision. Each would be completely dependent on the evidence.

I agree with you 100% that tit-for-tat should be avoided. If the evidence points clearly in one direction then a rational person should be swayed by it. However, after researching male circumcision for over 100 years in the West, the only effects it seems to have clearly demonstrated are a reduction in UTI’s and some increased resistance to HIV infection and some other STD’s.

Not much research has been done into FGM because it has not been widely practiced in the West. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It is therefore hypocritical to play the ethics card to object to FGM, especially since in the regions of the world it is practiced, male circumcision can be pretty brutal too.

If we were living at a time or in a place where condoms were in short supply or men generally did not want to use them, then infant circumcision starts to look like a better option. But we don’t. We live in the richest, most oversupplied part of the world. I can buy a condom 24-7 and I’m pretty sure you can too. We educate our children about the risks of unsafe sex. If the worst happens and they do contract HIV, they stand a good chance of living for decades.

There is no evidence FGM serves any purpose other than to further archaic sexual restrictions on women and girls. Our society has found it acceptable to pursue change of sexual and other forms of discrimination regardless of preserving or respecting cultural values. There is no evidence FGM prevents disease. There is evidence, especially in its most severe forms, that FGM does significant harm.

There is no comparison either morally or ethically of the two procedures.

Are you really trying to argue that male circumcision is used for the same reasons (i.e. your reasons) all over the world? I think if you look into it a bit more closely you’ll find what we would consider ethically dubious (or flat-out wrong) uses of male circumcision.

What do you think FGM would have evolved into if we in the West had liked the idea?
 
Last edited:
Is it different if a delusion is shared but many or just by a few? Or just one person?

Imagine some father has a dream and he believes sometime in the future his kid will be grabbed by the earlobes and abducted by Evil Flying Tin Ravioli Monsters or whatever, and decides to cut his kid´s earlobes off at birth.

Would he have the right to do that? According to Loss Leader he would, wouldn´t he?

How is this different from circumcision for religious reasons? Just because the jewish religious delusion is shared by a lot of people makes it right? How can secular laws discriminate between that and the crazy father who cuts his kid´s ears?
 
I would like to hear Loss Leader condemn FGM.

I still think the HIV transmission thing is a total strawman argument. If there are multiple studies does anyone have some good references? I will read them.

BTW If you cut the whole thing off your HIV risk goes way way down, where do you draw the line? For me it's easy, you draw at the point people try and cut parts off of you!!!

The masaii have an interesting circumcision ritual btw, the kids do it when they are about 15 as a rite of passage. And yes I have been to masaii villages and discussed this with them.
 
Is it different if a delusion is shared but many or just by a few? Or just one person?


I don't know what delusion you think I'm operating under. "I am circumcising my sons because I am Jewish and it is the Jewish practice to circumcise our sons."

So, I'm not deluded about the fact that I have sons (or one and two-thirds sons in any case). I've seen the pictures.

I'm not deluded about the fact that I already have circumcised one and will be circumcising the other.

I'm not deluded about the fact that I'm Jewish. Once again, I have pictures from by Bar Mitvah.

And I'm not deluded about the fact that it is the Jewih practice to circumcise our sons. I have consulted my trusted religious advisors and been instructed as much.

I make no claim as to whether circumcision is a good or bad idea, whether the Jewish religion could survive without it, whether there is any health benefit to it or anything else. Now, I happen to personally believe that there is a sufficient reason for Jews to continue the practice of circumcision but that is not why I am doing it. I am only doing it because it is the Jewish practice to do so.

My only claim is that it is the Jewish practice to circumcise our boys, it's legal, it carries no significant medical risks and you can't stop me.

There is no delusion.
 
I would like to hear Loss Leader condemn FGM.


I'd like to hear the Beatles reunite at Shea Stadium. It isn't going to happen, though.

My interest in this topic extends exactly as far as circumcising my boys. The fact that you want to discuss something else is not my problem.
 
Really. Just...really. Circumcision is a minor cosmetic procedure often done to infants for a variety of reasons and non-reasons.

So what other cosmetic surgery should parents be able to choose for their child? Shaping of the labia? Obviously we wouldn't insist the child be given effective pain relief because we know they won't remember* it when they grow up. So the child's pain isn't that important.

Yes, the baby often cries. The baby cries during birth, should I have shoved mine back into my wife because breathing was traumatic for him?

No. I don't think you and your wife had much choice as to the amount of pain your child was going to experience during birth. Also, as your wife's body was necessarily involved in the process, she had the final say in what happens. When your baby was removed from wife's body it became an individual.

What happened the first time any of you trimmed your child's nails?
I can say with great confidence that your child was tormented by the fires of hell during the procedure. But our trimmed nail fetish has no medical indications.

Ah yes, vets do it to animals just to make them look nice. Also, are you really trying to equate the pain of genitals being cut and torn apart to the sensation of nails being trimmed?

I have no foreskin. Am I missing out on some hypothetical sensations? Perhaps.

One thing is for sure: the sensations are real. You are missing out on them.

But I probably discovered my little mushroom before my uncircumsised friends, and got a year of two of extra happy time that might make up for a tiny loss in feeling over the rest of my life.

My family still haven't realized why I used to lay on my front and rustle around when I was a baby until I, um, went to sleep:D

Oh, by the way, in America most females are a bit put out by the "whole" package, so my son may have gained a slight advantage in getting laid. And I can definitely say that that alone justifies the (irrelevant and not worth arguing about) procedure.

I'm going to visit America soon. Is the etiquette to discuss the state of each others' genitalia on the first or second date?

If I sneakily pull my foreskin back while she isn't watching, will she know the difference?

(*) I burnt my hand when I was 3 on an electric bar fire. It was quite a serious burn (it took the nail off on one finger). I'm 100% confident it hurt. A lot. I now don't remember the pain.
 
The whole discussion about whether the alleged benefits justify routine circumcision is really irrelevant to the issue of whether forced circumcision is (or should be) acceptable, unless you accept that children are the property of their parents.

In reality, it is his body, not yours.
In every way that counts, you are wrong.
Whenever we are forcibly taking away an individual's most fundamental right to their own body, the test shouldn't be whether it is medically beneficial, but whether it is medically required. For example, UTIs aren't even eligible for consideration because they are easily treated.

Medically, amputation is and should always be a last resort, only performed when other treatments can't be used. Circumcision is the amputation of a sensory organ, with the guaranteed side effect of damage to another sensory organ (the glans). Whether you like calling it amputation or not, that's what it is, and should be treated as such by the medical community and the law.

I realize that much of the reason for overlooking the ethical question of cosmetic amputation is because so many think that the foreskin is a useless flap of skin. Since circumcision used to be the norm and most adult American men are cut, their egos often require this belief as a self-defense mechanism. Understandable, but mistaken.

I've read through every post in this gigantic thread, and one thing that has been missing is the "too much information" explanation of the intact male. So here it is.

As a boy growing up, I was embarrassed at public locker rooms, toilets, etc. where other boys would see that I was not circumcized. I was almost always the only one of my peers who was intact. I very much wanted to get circumcized, but my parents wouldn't let me have it done until I was old enough to responsibly make that choice for myself.

So I would often pull the skin back myself, so that I could pretend to be circ'd (looks pretty much the same), but I could never leave it that way for long. You see, the glans of an intact penis is so sensitive that just the contact with underwear would become quite painful. For those of you who are cut, you probably don't realize the enormous amount of desensitization that is required just to carry out your daily activities.

As puberty hit, I started to realize the incredible sensitivity in the foreskin, and finally appreciated that my parents had left me intact (my dad was never given the choice, but was thoughtful enough to give it to me). This whole debate about whether "anything is lost" is just ridiculous; my foreskin is a functioning sex organ with tremendous sensitivity and function. Touching the foreskin gives a sensation unlike any other -- a sensation that would not be possible without the foreskin. When aroused, the sensations in the foreskin are even more pleasurable, and the thousands of nerve endings allow me to feel what's going on inside my wife. The gliding action is wonderful for both me and my wife, and we usually arrange things to maximize this gliding action.

While I can't directly compare to being cut, I do have a good idea of how much desensitization would be necessary to just endure my glans being in constant contact with my clothing. And losing that much sensitivity would definitely reduce the pleasure from foreplay and intercourse.

Some have mentioned fellatio. Well, the cut guys are really missing out here too. The foreskin adds tremendous sensation and pleasure, and the extra sensitivity of the glans is also a huge bonus.

My foreskin is also a very important part of my ability to bring my wife to orgasm. With my foreskin -- and to a lesser degree my fully sensitized glans -- I'm able to feel how she's reacting internally, which allows me to give her more pleasure.

Mr Kellog and the others weren't that unreasonable in thinking that circumcision for males and burning the clit with carbolic acid would reduce masturbation; there is a significant reduction in pleasure and sensitivity that results from those procedures. Where they went wrong is that it does nothing to reduce the male's desire/need for sex, and that it was unethical to advocate genital mutilation for the purpose of trying to stop others from masturbating.

If I somehow developed a condition that required circumcision, I have no doubt that it would have no effect on my sex drive. I would still enjoy sex and would still achieve orgasm, and would still love the orgasm. But it would have a definite negative impact on the quality of sex for both me and my wife nonetheless.

One comment on circumcizing for HIV prevention: I find it hard to believe that circumcision could provide any meaningful and lasting benefit here. The studies done thus far have followed the subjects for a relatively short time frame. As time goes on and the number of exposures for each individual increases, I would expect to see the infection rate between the cut and uncut group converge, eventually settling on infection rates that reflect the individual's lifestyle. I think that time will show circumcision to provide only a delay in HIV infection for those engaged in risky behavior. In other words it would only provide meaningful protection in the portion of the population that engages in non-repeated risky behavior.

The answer to the original question of this thread, as demonstrated by loss leader, is: Yes, but only by sidestepping the ethical issue of forcibly damaging the genitals of another human being and/or claiming that the foreskin has little or no use.
 
I'd like to hear the Beatles reunite at Shea Stadium. It isn't going to happen, though.

My interest in this topic extends exactly as far as circumcising my boys. The fact that you want to discuss something else is not my problem.

You are just as bad as the rest of the "mainstream" relgious nuts that give the fundamentalists their power.

Part of the reason you want to stick your head in the sand is that you know that there isn't any difference between circumcision and FGM and if you opposed one you would have to oppose the other.

I also think that you are perfectly happy to give the parents of these girls the power to mutilate them because it protects your own power to mutilate.

Anyone that doesn't unequivocally condemn FGM is an unethical person in my opinion and I have yet to hear anyone other than nutjob fundamentalists defend the practice. Circumcision falls into the same camp, but it's objectively not as bad as most forms of FGM as it doesn't damage the hardware as much.

I know, I know, you don't care what other people do to the point where you don't even have an opinion. And hey, if it's legal then it's ok too.
 
Part of the reason you want to stick your head in the sand is that you know that there isn't any difference between circumcision and FGM and if you opposed one you would have to oppose the other.

I also think that you are perfectly happy to give the parents of these girls the power to mutilate them because it protects your own power to mutilate.


You can invent any words you want to stick in my mouth, but I haven't said them and there is no reason to conclude that I believe them. Make up arguments for me and then tell me how wrong I am if you absolutely have to. But I am not made of straw, I do not endorse a single word you've decided I believe and I make no comment whatsoever on the issue.



Anyone that doesn't unequivocally condemn FGM is an unethical person in my opinion


Other things I haven't unequivocally condemned in this thread:

- Trans fats
- The cancellation of "Standoff." It was a good show
- The Armenian Genocide by the Turks
- People who don't know the difference between "no comment" and actually approving of something.
- The Irish
- The 9/11 Trooth Movement and their stupid, stupid homemade documentaries
- The lack of nudity on broadcast TV
- The 1/5 liter bottle of soda for the same price as the 2 liter like nobody would notice
and, finally,
- Hootie but NOT the Blowfish

Failure to condemn something on command is not the same as approving of it. I have made no statement about it. I have no comment about it. And it is dishonest of you to pretend that I hold an opinion I have not expressed.
 
My only claim is that it is the Jewish practice to circumcise our boys, it's legal, it carries no significant medical risks and you can't stop me.

Well, to be precise, that's your only claim that hasn't been torn apart and thrown to the dogs.

But at least you've dropped your pretenses of having any sort of rational or ethical leg to stand on. Finally we see the real Loss Leader for who (and what) he is.

There is no delusion.

Unless you believe you're more advanced than your very distant ancestors, who thought the world was flat, thought the sun revolved around it, and decided that ritual genital mutilation is part of what it means to be Jewish.
 
My only claim is that it is the Jewish practice to circumcise our boys, it's legal, it carries no significant medical risks and you can't stop me.


Well, to be precise, that's your only claim that hasn't been torn apart and thrown to the dogs.


Well, yes, I guess you'd be right if it wasn't exactly the same as the first post I made when I entered this thread. Here, let me remind you:


As a Jew, I had my first son circumcised and will have my next one circumcised as well. No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.

So, um, if you want to declare yourself the winner, go ahead. You're not but I understand how it might make you feel better.
 
excellent post Skepticybe. As a woman, I've enjoyed both kinds and orgasm is much easier during sex with intact penises. Sadly, i went along with the pack 16 years ago at the birth of my first son. I did not compound the error, however, at the birth of my 2nd. And its a LOT easier to take care of an intact (and nonretractible) penis than it was to deal with adhesions and poop mess under the glans ridge of my first son.
 
I apologize if I seemed flippant. I certainly meant no disrespect to the ideas of others.
As a circumcised male in a largely circumsised society (USA), I can't help but see my state as the "normal" state. Since I have no objective evidence (unlike victims of female genital mutilation) that my state is significantly different than the "other" state (the plural of anecdote is not data), I see the difference as inconsequential.
I actually thought of the earlobe-clipping argument myself, but in the opposite way. I could argue that the earlobe-clipping was transitorially painful, but important to the child's parents. The child would not notice the clipping at all, except by the counter-example of non-clipped peers, and the chances that the clipping would alter the child's normal development would be close to nil.
I do agree that earlobe-nibbling can be unbelievably erotic and stimulating, but at the same time, I would not logically accept that earlobe-clipping impairs the (hypothetical)child in any way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom