Morrigan
Crone of War
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2006
- Messages
- 8,262
Appeal to emotion noted.There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history. My relatives who dies in the Holocaust were circumcised. My relatives who were murdered during the black plague were circumcised.
Evidence?My relatives who were slaves in Egypt
And they can't do that unless their genitals are mutilated, because...? Is Judaism such a pitiful and pathetic religion/culture?And when the next wave of antisemitism hits - and it will - I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.

And now antisemitism has been brought up and the implications are already flying. Thread Godwinned in 3... 2...
1! Ding ding, here we go.And what if the Nazis come for us when he's fifteen? Or nine? Or six months old?
No, I'm a lawyer.

Really? You'd not only rather die than temporarily pretending to not be a Jew, but would also make sure your son did the same? Because we all know that dying a martyr is so much more constructive and productive and keep on living, where one might actually eventually elude the enemy and then vanquish him.I don't know what you mean by that. If you mean that Nazis might spare my son because he is uncircumcised, I assure you I would rather see my son die as a Jew than live in denial of the same.
I assume then that you are okay with the following statement: "I have pride in my Germanic, Nordic, White heritage."There is a massive difference between *pride* and "consider[ing] Jewish people superior somehow." I have pride in my heritage; I do not consider my religion superior.
Again. What kind of pathetic, wretched religion is actually hurt by the loss of an outdated, irrational, useless procedure? Considering the very same arguments you made could be made, hell, have been made, by the proponents of female circumcision, that's quite telling, anyway. Reminds me also of the Biblical support for slavery.If you block Jews from circumcising their children, you remove one building block in the ediface that is a religion as old as recorded history. Will my religion crumble as a result? I don;t know. But I don't want to find out. If you're wrong, you strike a blow against Judaism itself. If I'm wrong, I ... cause temporary pain to an infant with almost no medical consequences. I would prefer to keep my religion intact.
A rational person with a healthy look on life would use his or her critical thinking to discriminate between traditions that have merit and are worth valueing, cherishing and preserving, and what is obsolete, stupid and/or unethical and to be discarded. Only a blind fanatic or a brainwashed woo would continue a tradition for the sake of tradition.
Thankfully, the "tradition" of slavery has been abolished.
I'm tempted to make a sarcastic comment about how scary a Jewish revolution would be, but... I probably should not. Still,Watch the hyperbole. The day my religious practices are deemed criminal is the day I join the revolution.

Ah, intellectual dishonesty at its finest. "*blocks ears* Lalala I can't hear you!"Don't know, don't care, didn't even click the links.