By all means, follow your own beliefs, except where those beliefs have permanent consequenses for someone else, especially someone who can't possibly understand those beliefs or even speak a word of protest as you slice off parts of their genitals.
Oh, my older son did and my new son will protest quite vehemently. I will ignore those protests, however. And I will do so proudly and happily. I'll even video tape it.
How is it pluralistic to make such decisions for your child? If you're allowed your own beliefs, why isn't he? All you're doing is superimposing your own will upon his. Nothing pluralistic about that.
Um ... the pluralism comes when Jews are allowed to follow their own beliefs, Christians theirs, Muslims theirs and whomever else their own. The pluralism is between demographic groups, not individuals.
I disagree. Since we cannot *know* whether I am right or wrong, it is best NOT to permanently alter another human being.
If you block Jews from circumcising their children, you remove one building block in the ediface that is a religion as old as recorded history. Will my religion crumble as a result? I don;t know. But I don't want to find out. If you're wrong, you strike a blow against Judaism itself. If I'm wrong, I ... cause temporary pain to an infant with almost no medical consequences. I would prefer to keep my religion intact.
That was a cheap shot.. oh well, I still laughed. I wonder, does condescension make you feel superior?
I've rethought my answer. I recommend
The Long Goodbye: The Deaths of Nancy Cruzan by William Colby. Read this very short book as an introduction to what substituted decision-making means and the importance of family making decisions for an incompetent person rather than government officials and judges who are complete strangers.
Unfortunately for your position, however, it isn't true. Your will is not your son's will, despite what your textbook says.
Actually, that's fortunate for me because what the textbook says is, in this case, the only thing that matters.
He seems to be denying the possibility that there is any objective standard to which anyone can be held accountable. There's no right or wrong, only belief. We can talk all day and all night about ethics and rights, he can simply refuse to acknowledge that any such things actually exist!
Once again, I outlined that the law of substituted judgement is just in my opinion because (in part) it respects religious and family rights. I also acknowledged that the state does have an interest in the welfare of children. So there are three objective moral positions around which the law of substituted judgment has formed. Lots and lots of Germans believed in the Neuremburg laws; but they were injust because they did not respect the rights of the minority. There is objectivity.
Exactly, but why stop there? Essentially his line of reasoning allows a parent to do ANYTHING to their child. ANYTHING. The parent doesn't even have to actually believe it's in their child's best interests, only to claim to do so. After all, who can say what someone does or doesn't believe..
I have already acknowledged that this is not the case.
I'd rather be right than "win the day".
Good. Then we both get what we want: you believe whatever the heck you want to and I get to circumcise my son.
At least we're heading in the right direction. Yes, this concept that a baby has inalienable rights that even their parents cannot breach is a fairly new one. But it's out there, and as we become more advanced as a society, I believe we will continue in this direction until there comes a day when the law does reflect the fact that a baby is not an object to be owned, but a human being.
I agree that the law is constantly evolving. I agree that it may evolve in the direction you predict. It won't. But I agree it might.
When that day comes, you will be regarded as a criminal.
Watch the hyperbole. The day my religious practices are deemed criminal is the day I join the revolution.
It seems to me that I could be 100% correct and still not convince a single religious person that there are ethical issues that can transcend their superstitions.
That's why I don't think the law is going to evolve in the direction you predict. Which is good because I don't really want to join the revolution. First of all, I'd have nothing to wear.
The thing is, we DON'T allow people to refuse necessary medical treatment for their children. The state WILL take custody of those children, for their own protection from their parents. And rightly so.
How does this fit into your tighly-woven belief system about your will being your child's will?
It fits in as follows: I don't believe you've accurately described the state of law in Canada. I will certainly be glad to check into it.
Or is America the only country that matters..
It is to me.
The evidence for the existence of my child would be undeniable, and the evidence for the existence of heaven is.. well.. I don't have any, do you?
Nope. I don't need any, either. You would be asking the justice system to assign to the JW's beliefs a value of zero. Now, the nice thing about their beliefs are that they are unfalsifiable. That means that their truth value
cannot ever be determined. This gives them the upper hand, here. They may be right. And it is through that sliver of unfalsifiable possibility that all of their beliefs come rushing through to slam headlong into the state's interests.
The only other possibility is that you tell the JWs that their most deeply held religious beliefs have a truth value of absolutely zero.
I, in fact, believe that their beliefs are nonsense and so do you. But our beliefs about their beliefs don't matter one darn bit. All that matters is that we can't prove them wrong.
And, getting back to circumcision, you can't prove my beliefs wrong, either. That's why I will win in any court in the US and why you will lose. And, really, that's all I care about.