Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Yes and yes.

Actually, no and no, at least not in my country.

You see, there's this country called Canada, and we have a similar legal system to the American one, and it's every bit as legitimate. We are a democracy and have built our legal system on the same principles you Americans have. The "justice" we serve in Canada is every bit as good and properly derived as the "justice" you serve in America.

The thing is, we DON'T allow people to refuse necessary medical treatment for their children. The state WILL take custody of those children, for their own protection from their parents. And rightly so.

How does this fit into your tighly-woven belief system about your will being your child's will? Or is America the only country that matters..

Your statement that this is "insane" is only true if we accept as objectively true your subjective beliefs.

No, it's true for anyone who doesn't have that particular superstition clouding their judgement.

If we accept the JW's beliefs as objectively true, it is you who become "insane."

Sanity is not democratic. My level of sanity does not change in response to what other people think or believe. (Or are you still trying to hide behind American legal terminology?)

You, after all, would lock your child out of heaven for eternity in order to secure a few more years on earth.

The evidence for the existence of my child would be undeniable, and the evidence for the existence of heaven is.. well.. I don't have any, do you?
 
To me, it seems sort of similar to this (though admittedly not nearly as extreme):

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/325/7367/771

A deaf lesbian couple in the United States have deliberately created a deaf child. Sharon Duchesneau and Candy McCullough used their own sperm donor, a deaf friend with five generations of deafness in his family. Like others in the deaf community, Duchesneau and McCullough don't see deafness as a disability. They see being deaf as defining their cultural identity and see signing as a sophisticated, unique form of communication.

<snip>


I don't know how I missed this the first time around, but it actually is more similar than not.

Kellyb, I used to study sign--I wanted to be an interpreter. The situation in the Deaf community is extremely complex on the issue of cochlear implants. There has probably already been a thread on this subject somewhere, but I can tell you right now that it's a contentious issue.
 
You know that the reason beating children is not allowed is because it is considered harmful to the child with no benefit to the child.

You know that spanking children is allowed (despite it being merely a milder form of beating) because it is not considered so harmful to the child that it outweighs any benefit to the child.

You know that circumcision has not been shown to be considered harmful to the child with potentially a variety of benefits to the child (small medical benefits, large societal benefits).

Nobody has been able make such a proof in the 3000+ years that circumcisions have been performed.

A parent is allowed to make a whole variety of decisions for children with the child themselves having little to no say. Where the legal system gets involved in contradicting the parent is only where the law sees a particular decision as being more harmful than good for the well being of the child. Since circumcision is not seen by the law as being more harmful than good, then it is not against the law.

An individuals body is their property. Do you agree? In the case of adults it is only when they are considered incapable of deciding for themselves, in a time period the treatment options are viable and/or significant, that doctors ask a relative for consent.

What medical treatments would you want your relatives to be able to consent to on your behalf if you were in a coma that you were expected to wake from?

I see an infant in the same way. They are an individual who is temporarily unable to make decisions, so the parents should only be making a decision on treatments that are only possible and/or reasonably significant in the time period the child is unable to have an input to that decision.

My only exception to this is circumcision for HIV risk reduction in the developing world.

I don't consider a ~1% absolute risk reduction of a rare (~1.1% of uncircumcised boys, 0.13% of circumcised boys), highly treatable illness (UTI) to be worth the possible complications (estimated anywhere from 0.2% to 4% for circumcision, typically 2%). I don't believe many other people do either.

E.g.

2 groups of 1000 boys each, one group circumcised, the other left intact.

In the uncircumcised group 10 boys get a UTI.
In the circumcised group 1 boy gets a UTI.

In the uncircumcised group there are 0 complications from circumcision.
In the circumcised group there are anywhere from 2 to 40 (typically 20) complications of varying severity (including an extremely rare possibility of death) which require further treatment (or a little coffin).
 
Last edited:
I don't know how I missed this the first time around, but it actually is more similar than not.

Kellyb, I used to study sign--I wanted to be an interpreter. The situation in the Deaf community is extremely complex on the issue of cochlear implants. There has probably already been a thread on this subject somewhere, but I can tell you right now that it's a contentious issue.

Strange how some people see themselves defined by their particular disability.

I don't think I'd refuse treatment if there was something effective and safe for stuttering.
 
They don't see it as a disability. ;)

The question is beyond the scope of this thread, but trust me, there are a lot of considerations involved beyond just the "hearing" or "not hearing" part of it.
 
Now I understand. It is the almighty Loss Leader that has decided for all of us that because a particular law currently allows followers of a religion he subscribes to to mutilate their male children's genitals, it is just.


<sigh> I have done nothing of the sort.

I haven't decreed that the law is just. I have informed you that the vast working of our judicial and legal system have ground for some thousand years or more to a point where it is currently considered by the law to be just.

If you want to try to change that, be my guest. I think you'll fail but I'm sure there are a whole lot of legal reforms that no one ever thought would come about.
 
Strange how some people see themselves defined by their particular disability.

I don't think I'd refuse treatment if there was something effective and safe for stuttering.
Don't let me get up your nose about this- it's just something I've heard, and you might have heard it, too. Try singing. It's supposed to help. IANAD, YMMV.
 
Wow, this thread has really wandered into some interesting territory! Here's my two cents.

For starters, my non-religious parents (from a Christian background) either requested or allowed me to be circumsized when I was a baby, as was done with my other brothers. One of those brothers now has two boys of his own, and they're uncircumsized.

Personally I'm quite neutral about it. I don't miss my foreskin and I have no idea if sex would be better with it. But I don't consider myself to have been mutilated, as Ivor and Osmosis have characterised it; my penis is functioning quite normally.

But I agree with the premise of the OP: routine circumcision is indefensible by skeptics, with the possible exception of sub-Saharan Africa until the AIDS epidemic comes under control. Even that's a dubious call, though, because we don't yet know why the HIV infection rate is lower among circumsized males. It could be that circumcision is a correlation and not a cause.

I'd like to address some things Loss Leader has said, specifically:
1) His will is his baby's will
2) He will circumcize his boys due to his religious or cultural beliefs
3) Those beliefs have a strong traditional backing

First, as Osmosis has pointed out, our law is starting to recognize that infants, even unborn ones, have human rights. There have been cases where a person who kills a pregnant woman has actually been charged with two counts of murder. (I don't know if the second count--for the fetus--has ever been upheld.) The notion that a parent has the right to make potentially harmful decisions for his/her child seems to losing its tenure.

I don't know if these newly described infant rights apply to protecting him a relatively harmless procedure such as circumcision. However, it does produce a permanent change in the infant's body for equivocal results, hence it is something that does concern the man he will become.

(An aside: I agree with the idea of a parent making a decision for vaccination on the child's behalf. The benefits to both the child and society are well documented.)

Now to the Loss Leader's second point: circumcision for religious and cultural reasons. Like Osmosis, I'm Canadian. I'm very happy about that, and proud of the liberal society Canada has been building. But should I have a Maple Leaf tattooed on my (hypothetical) children's butts? Loss Leader would agree that I have the right to do so. But is it a good idea for the child?

I'll extend the metaphor further: what if I was a staunch Pastafarian? Should I extend my religious beliefs to my children by tattooing the FSM on my kids' rear ends? What if they grow up and decide to embrace the IPU instead of the FSM? Or they become skeptics or Buddhists? Or decide to join a more mainline religion such as Christianity or even Judaism? Would they want to have evidence of their parents' unusual beliefs indelibly marked on their bodies?

As to the third point (strong traditional background), that to me is simply the old logical fallacy of argumentum ad populum.
 
By all means, follow your own beliefs, except where those beliefs have permanent consequenses for someone else, especially someone who can't possibly understand those beliefs or even speak a word of protest as you slice off parts of their genitals.


Oh, my older son did and my new son will protest quite vehemently. I will ignore those protests, however. And I will do so proudly and happily. I'll even video tape it.


How is it pluralistic to make such decisions for your child? If you're allowed your own beliefs, why isn't he? All you're doing is superimposing your own will upon his. Nothing pluralistic about that.


Um ... the pluralism comes when Jews are allowed to follow their own beliefs, Christians theirs, Muslims theirs and whomever else their own. The pluralism is between demographic groups, not individuals.


I disagree. Since we cannot *know* whether I am right or wrong, it is best NOT to permanently alter another human being.


If you block Jews from circumcising their children, you remove one building block in the ediface that is a religion as old as recorded history. Will my religion crumble as a result? I don;t know. But I don't want to find out. If you're wrong, you strike a blow against Judaism itself. If I'm wrong, I ... cause temporary pain to an infant with almost no medical consequences. I would prefer to keep my religion intact.



That was a cheap shot.. oh well, I still laughed. I wonder, does condescension make you feel superior?


I've rethought my answer. I recommend The Long Goodbye: The Deaths of Nancy Cruzan by William Colby. Read this very short book as an introduction to what substituted decision-making means and the importance of family making decisions for an incompetent person rather than government officials and judges who are complete strangers.



Unfortunately for your position, however, it isn't true. Your will is not your son's will, despite what your textbook says.


Actually, that's fortunate for me because what the textbook says is, in this case, the only thing that matters.


He seems to be denying the possibility that there is any objective standard to which anyone can be held accountable. There's no right or wrong, only belief. We can talk all day and all night about ethics and rights, he can simply refuse to acknowledge that any such things actually exist!


Once again, I outlined that the law of substituted judgement is just in my opinion because (in part) it respects religious and family rights. I also acknowledged that the state does have an interest in the welfare of children. So there are three objective moral positions around which the law of substituted judgment has formed. Lots and lots of Germans believed in the Neuremburg laws; but they were injust because they did not respect the rights of the minority. There is objectivity.


Exactly, but why stop there? Essentially his line of reasoning allows a parent to do ANYTHING to their child. ANYTHING. The parent doesn't even have to actually believe it's in their child's best interests, only to claim to do so. After all, who can say what someone does or doesn't believe..


I have already acknowledged that this is not the case.


I'd rather be right than "win the day".


Good. Then we both get what we want: you believe whatever the heck you want to and I get to circumcise my son.


At least we're heading in the right direction. Yes, this concept that a baby has inalienable rights that even their parents cannot breach is a fairly new one. But it's out there, and as we become more advanced as a society, I believe we will continue in this direction until there comes a day when the law does reflect the fact that a baby is not an object to be owned, but a human being.


I agree that the law is constantly evolving. I agree that it may evolve in the direction you predict. It won't. But I agree it might.


When that day comes, you will be regarded as a criminal.


Watch the hyperbole. The day my religious practices are deemed criminal is the day I join the revolution.


It seems to me that I could be 100% correct and still not convince a single religious person that there are ethical issues that can transcend their superstitions.


That's why I don't think the law is going to evolve in the direction you predict. Which is good because I don't really want to join the revolution. First of all, I'd have nothing to wear.



The thing is, we DON'T allow people to refuse necessary medical treatment for their children. The state WILL take custody of those children, for their own protection from their parents. And rightly so.

How does this fit into your tighly-woven belief system about your will being your child's will?


It fits in as follows: I don't believe you've accurately described the state of law in Canada. I will certainly be glad to check into it.


Or is America the only country that matters..


It is to me.


The evidence for the existence of my child would be undeniable, and the evidence for the existence of heaven is.. well.. I don't have any, do you?


Nope. I don't need any, either. You would be asking the justice system to assign to the JW's beliefs a value of zero. Now, the nice thing about their beliefs are that they are unfalsifiable. That means that their truth value cannot ever be determined. This gives them the upper hand, here. They may be right. And it is through that sliver of unfalsifiable possibility that all of their beliefs come rushing through to slam headlong into the state's interests.

The only other possibility is that you tell the JWs that their most deeply held religious beliefs have a truth value of absolutely zero.

I, in fact, believe that their beliefs are nonsense and so do you. But our beliefs about their beliefs don't matter one darn bit. All that matters is that we can't prove them wrong.

And, getting back to circumcision, you can't prove my beliefs wrong, either. That's why I will win in any court in the US and why you will lose. And, really, that's all I care about.
 
Wow, this thread has really wandered into some interesting territory! Here's my two cents.

Welcome to the thread!

I'll extend the metaphor further: what if I was a staunch Pastafarian? Should I extend my religious beliefs to my children by tattooing the FSM on my kids' rear ends? What if they grow up and decide to embrace the IPU instead of the FSM?

I'm not getting in the middle of this one, but...I know who the FSM is. What's the IPU? :D
 
Didn't even click on the links? Well I did and I was utterly sickened. This whole this is about perverse sexual control and it's time it stopped. I'm feeling depressed now, I was just reading some 80-year old works of Bertrand Russell and things haven't got much better in the last 80 years. By better I mean getting rid of sick traditions (religious and non-religious) like circumcision.

BTW this whole HIV circumcision thing is retarded. One study? Male/Female HIV transmission is easily stopped by using condoms. Washing yourself immediately afterwards when you have sex with a stranger is probably a good idea as well (maybe even use some soap).
 
Skeptigirl, let me see if I understand your position on routine infant circumcision correctly:

You think it’s similar to parents choosing to vaccinate their child. However, unlike standard vaccinations which have clear benefits and extremely low risks, the evidence for circumcision is equivocal. Even so, you think parents should be allowed to use their judgement after being provided with the evidence. You do not see any significant ethical problems with this approach.

And from what I can gather, the physicians who have contributed so far point of view on this can be summarised by:

You think routine infant circumcision is ethically dubious, but aren’t prepared to stand up for what you believe, or accept some non-medical reasons but not others given by parents for the circumcision of their child. Even if you disagree with the decision to circumcise a child and will not perform it yourself, you will tell the parents of the child where they can get it performed, because you believe that parents will turn their backs on all of 21st century medicine if they can’t get their kid cut.

Both the physicians and Skeptigirl think ALL forms of FGM are wrong, even if they are carried out in 21st century hi-tech hospitals, if performed on non-consenting (infant) girls.

Neither Skeptigirl or the physicians appear to comprehend that the ethics of one are identical to the other, or they do and are hypocrites.

Now would any of you like to summarise what you think my position is (obviously when you’ve stopped bickering about what nurses do that doctors don’t and vice-versa)?

ETA: This makes interesting reading.
This is either your wishful thinking or just your brain's way of making sense of the world. I can repeat my position. But I ask you to take it as is and not try to make it fit your beliefs. Because I do not see the world the way you see it, nor is your summary of my beliefs the least bit accurate.

I see no reason in the medical literature (the evidence) to recommend to any parent that they do or do not circumcise their child. That is where a provider should be, in my opinion, when the evidence is equivocal.

There is not sufficient evidence to show real harm from circumcisions despite the emotionally charged beliefs coming from a minority of men. While there are a few men who feel strongly opposed to circumcision and seem to think they have lost (or others will lose) significant amount of sexual pleasure. At the same time, there are at least a few men who have had circumcisions as adults to enhance their sexual pleasure (see citations I already posted). It would seem for the vast majority of men who have had a circumcision, they rarely think twice about it.

On the other side, there is some medical evidence circumcising infants prevents UTIs. The incidence of UTI in male infants was somewhere between 1-5% give or take from what I gathered from the research. Of those, especially in infants under age 2, a UTI can be a serious infection commonly including bacteria spreading to the bloodstream. In addition, having a single UTI necessitates invasive procedures and several weeks at least of antibiotics.

Neither the emotional appeals by a minority of men which lacks empirical evidence, nor the medical benefits of UTI risk reduction are very strong indicators for or against circumcision. In addition, people hold many different personal beliefs for and against circumcision.

In this case, I have no reason to be for or against any parent's decision to circumcise or not circumcise their child. I have no ethical concerns about their decision. As far as FGM goes, circumcision isn't a gender rights issue. Tit for tat is an absurd argument to make in any medical decision. Each would be completely dependent on the evidence.

There is no evidence FGM serves any purpose other than to further archaic sexual restrictions on women and girls. Our society has found it acceptable to pursue change of sexual and other forms of discrimination regardless of preserving or respecting cultural values. There is no evidence FGM prevents disease. There is evidence, especially in its most severe forms, that FGM does significant harm.

There is no comparison either morally or ethically of the two procedures.
 
...

BTW this whole HIV circumcision thing is retarded. One study? Male/Female HIV transmission is easily stopped by using condoms. Washing yourself immediately afterwards when you have sex with a stranger is probably a good idea as well (maybe even use some soap).
No Newton, not one study. Over 2 decades and many studies. And in many countries condoms are still not enough.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom