Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

From your source, skeptigirl:

"In some cultures and religions, minor amputations or mutilations are considered a ritual accomplishment."

Is it not talking about circumcision or FGM? Seems like we CAN use the term amputation fairly.

The only reason you saw an emotional appeal when you read the term amputation, skeptigirl, is because of your emotional response. If you had no emotional response to it, you wouldn't have a problem with the term amputationl
Did you investigate what the minor amputations referred to?

I stand by my statement, the use of the term 'amputation' of the foreskin is an irregular use of the term. Would you say appendices are amputated? Are gall bladders amputated? It is you who are seeking the emotional response.
 
I think that when doctors are taught to consider patients' emotional states, need for information, values, fears, etc. when caring for their patients, these considerations are not referred to as "nursing diagnoses". I also think that when comparing the actions of nurses and physicians working the ED vs. those working in a specialty clinic, time and priorities will lead to a difference in how those issues are handled regardless of profession. I agree that you may find that nurses are on average more nurturing than physicians, although I recognize that it's also possible that this perception is due to bias. I realize that you choose to compare disparate, rather than similar situations because you wish to emphasize differences. But that makes it unclear when those differences are due to the profession instead of the situation or other factors.

Linda
You are correct that each specialty is going to have different specialists. OR, ICU and ED nurses often have much narrower nursing roles that focus heavily on highly technical skills. Pediatric practices are much more inclusive of nursing interventions. And any physician who specializes in geriatrics has to be incredibly nurturing.

Still, I have observed physicians in many different settings focus on the pill or treatment much more so than on the patient. No doubt those are the incidents which stand out in my memory. I wonder though, if either because your practice is not like that, or perhaps you just haven't been looking, maybe there is more of this than you realize.

I'm not trying to push that overlapping curve apart, now, so don't get me wrong. But I think of the differences more in terms of the medical model and the nursing model. Physicians diagnose and prescribe, nurses assist the patient in carrying out the prescription and help the patient accommodate the illness. Sometimes you need more of one of those than the other. But you can see just from the description, the physician patient and nurse patient roles are inherently different.

The patient's medical care requires variable amounts of both so the roles of the providers are going to have considerable overlap. And we both recognize specialties make a big difference as well. So maybe differences are going to be individual, situational, or professional. I certainly agree with that. But I'm not willing to completely toss the educational/professional influence altogether.
 
When considering whether HawkeyeMD is unreasonably defensive, you may want to take into consideration that there is an implied "and doctors aren't" at the end of that last sentence (regardless of what you meant). You rush in to defend your profession when you see statements that misrepresent it. I don't think it is unreasonable to expect her to do the same.

Linda
It was the third time she made false accusations about my posts meaning something other than what I had said.

"Your viewpoint is clear. You think circumcision is a good thing. Fine. You will have to accept the fact that there are other medical professionals who disagree with you. And the reason that people keep responding to the idea that you are espousing the concept of circumcising American boys for the purpose of avoiding HIV infection is that you keep responding this way to those of us who are making the point that it does not apply in non-Third-World nations with posts like these."

That is not my viewpoint, nor was I ever unclear about HIV risk and circumcision.

"...-please be careful with the innate assumption that all doctors are out there trampling patients' rights and being paternalistic."

A bit of an exaggeration and there is noting in my posts that are as ridiculous as that.

"Then stop bringing it up. Seriously. The more times you qualify your statements with things like "of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others", the more it sounds like your underlying message is "but of course they're all that way underneath." The very sentence you wrote implies it--if some are "less", then clearly all of us are."

Sorry, Linda, but this is defensive. How do you clarify a misunderstanding if "bringing it up" to make the point more clear is distrusted as disingenuous?

While I haven't read past this post yet, I'm still waiting for an answer how one views the parent who might judge the medical indication for a circumcision to be compelling. You have both the AAP and the AAFP agreeing this is sufficient evidence for supporting a legitimate medical reason. Am I the only one here who can empathize with a parent making that decision based on their value of reducing the risk of a UTI which they might legitimately believe is very important? Is it possible the difference in how I would view those parents is because I have a nursing background?

Maybe it doesn't have a thing to do with it. You made a reasonable case. That doesn't change the fact we do have different roles that have to have some impact on each of us. I bring it up, you and Katana say I haven't expressed myself well. I see your point. The discussion moves on.

But you can't move on if discussing it results in accusations of being disingenuous.
 
Last edited:
...Having said that, I also pointed out in my previous post that a parent who was seriously concerned about UTI would be one I would consider performing the procedure for....
If you show me in which past post you said this, I owe you an apology.

I have been asking repeatedly about how you viewed the wishes of a parent who might have lost a child to infection as an example of a legitimate but different value one could base the decision to circumcise on and it would be reasonable to conclude it was medically indicated in a healthy child.

Perhaps you answered in a post replying to someone else.

And re the AAP recommendation, "Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision. In the case of circumcision, in which there are potential benefits and risks, yet the procedure is not essential to the child's current well-being, parents should determine what is in the best interest of the child." The AAFP is more vague citing the evidence with no conclusion other than that of anesthesia. "The evidence indicates that neonatal circumcision prevents UTIs in the first year of life with an absolute risk reduction of about 1% and prevents the development of penile cancer with an absolute risk reduction of less than 0.2%. The evidence suggests that circumcision reduces the rate of acquiring an STD, but careful sexual practices and hygiene may be as effective. Circumcision appears to decrease the transmission of HIV in underdeveloped areas where the virus is highly prevalent. No study has systematically evaluated the utility of routine neonatal circumcision for preventing all medically-indicated circumcisions in later life. Evidence regarding the association between cervical cancer and a woman’s partner being circumcised or uncircumcised, and evidence regarding the effect of circumcision on sexual functioning is inconclusive. If the decision is made to circumcise, anesthesia should be used."
 
Last edited:
:boggled: Are you serious?

Ivor, I have pointed out before that I think basically we agree on this issue. Why on earth you would use the implication that rape, child abuse and slavery are exact equivalents to circumcision is beyond me. You are abandoning your very cogent arguments for nonintervention for the sake of a pithy, oversimplistic smart answer. Please don't do that, and don't let your emotional involvement in the issue lead you into making such comparisons.

I have worked in a rape-crisis center. The very idea of implying that there is no long-term harm involved, or that the long-term harm is no more than that of a minor medical procedure, is absolutely unconscionable.

I understand what you're saying, the problem is he's right. I don't think you quite understand what he's getting at though.

Firstly, he's talking about physical harm not emotional harm, and his point is quite valid. The point I see him making is that one cannot dismiss circumcision as "harmless" or "minor" without simultaneously dismissing a host of other things that are generally regarded as horrible, such as rape, beatings, etc, on the very same logical grounds.

He didn't say they were "exactly equivalent", but they are equivalent in every way that matters to the discussion at hand. I understand why you got defensive about his statement - you work at a rape crisis center and have to deal with the emotional scars rape causes (I know it does, I've known women who have been raped, in one case several times). But that's really an emotional response, one that would be unnecessary had you read his post a little more closely.
 
Did you investigate what the minor amputations referred to?

I stand by my statement, the use of the term 'amputation' of the foreskin is an irregular use of the term. Would you say appendices are amputated? Are gall bladders amputated? It is you who are seeking the emotional response.

Who knows what the wikipedia article writer had in mind? However, as we are talking about ROUTINE INFANT CIRCUMCISION (RIC), your appendix analogy is not valid. And still, reading "In some cultures and religions, minor amputations or mutilations are considered a ritual accomplishment", the first things that come to my mind are Circ. and FGM...
 
I understand what you're saying, the problem is he's right. I don't think you quite understand what he's getting at though.

Firstly, he's talking about physical harm not emotional harm, and his point is quite valid. The point I see him making is that one cannot dismiss circumcision as "harmless" or "minor" without simultaneously dismissing a host of other things that are generally regarded as horrible, such as rape, beatings, etc, on the very same logical grounds.

I don't believe it is. If he were saying, look, we used to accept these things as matters of course too, and now we think they're horrible, I would accept that as an analogy. To say "how much harm does rape do? No more than circumcision" is to make a direct comparison and, frankly, invite a heated response.

As Katana also pointed out, rape and beatings are liable to cause more than minor physical harm.
 
The question was:

"Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?"

And the answer: "Yes, on emotional grounds, or by asserting that the injustice done to the person is neutralized by the apparently very small importance of the issue."

Stealing, wrong.
Stealing one penny from a millionaire... okay let this one go uninspected.
 
If you show me in which past post you said this, I owe you an apology.

I have been asking repeatedly about how you viewed the wishes of a parent who might have lost a child to infection as an example of a legitimate but different value one could base the decision to circumcise on and it would be reasonable to conclude it was medically indicated in a healthy child.

Perhaps you answered in a post replying to someone else.

HawkeyeMD said:
Yes, let's, shall we? Only let's deal with my actual position. My position is that based on the medical evidence, I do not believe circumcision is warranted for every male child. Therefore, since I am considering it as a medical procedure, I don't intend to perform them routinely. As fls has pointed out, most parents are not primarily concerned with the risk of infection (whether of HIV, which seemed to be the predominant example early in the thread, or of UTIs, which have taken over lately) when considering circumcision. If a parent is concerned about UTI, then that is a medical question and a situation in which I would consider the procedure.

This is part of my last response to you. I will not bother going through the thread and finding previous discussions.

Awaiting apology.
 
The question was:

"Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?"

And the answer: "Yes, on emotional grounds, or by asserting that the injustice done to the person is neutralized by the apparently very small importance of the issue."

Stealing, wrong.
Stealing one penny from a millionaire... okay let this one go uninspected.

I'm not sure I understand your point. Are you saying that it's unreasonable for anyone to point out that necessarily subjective considerations come into play?

ETA: Or maybe the disagreement is over the "necessarily"?

Linda
 
Last edited:
I don't believe it is. If he were saying, look, we used to accept these things as matters of course too, and now we think they're horrible, I would accept that as an analogy. To say "how much harm does rape do? No more than circumcision" is to make a direct comparison and, frankly, invite a heated response.

As Katana also pointed out, rape and beatings are liable to cause more than minor physical harm.

Circumcision, when performed in a 21st century hospital by a skilled medical professional using proper anesthesia is an extremely safe and pain free procedure. I would expect nothing less, would you? However, just because it has become hi-tech and sanitized does not change the physical reality of removing healthy, functional tissue or the ethical one of a procedure being performed on a non-consenting individual, for benefits that most men do not see as significant when they are able to choose for themselves.

If the same benefits (e.g., absolute reduction in childhood UTI's of ~1%) were provided to infant females from a similar procedure, such as labia reduction, would any of the pro-circumcision or evidence-based nurse practitioners seriously consider it for their child? My guess is that you would not, simply because the concept of FGM is distasteful to us in the developed world because we don't do it.

Back to my examples:

Caning in schools was incredibly safe too. I'm sure only a insignificant little bit of skin was removed. It soon healed.

A man raping his wife would not have had to use force because she would know that it was his right. She may of had a few bruises after, but nothing life-threatening. Have you heard of learned helplessness?

I'll concede that the life of a slave was likely to be shorter than that of a free person.

HawkeyeMD, you are correct I wanted a response. I was hoping for some initial rage then hopefully some recognition (a light-bulb moment) that the similarities, at societal and ethical levels is almost exact. Only a few people seem to have understood this.

However, it seems that most people posting here have constructed an ethical difference between their own societies' behaviour and what those 'horrible people' in the past (maybe their (great-)grandparents?) used to do in theirs.

My argument is that this construction is a delusion. It is exactly the same delusion that the men raping their wives, the teachers caning children and the households with slaves used to justify their behaviour. They have created it to protect their idea of self (e.g., I am a good person), in a similar way to people who create the delusion of an afterlife or God to protect the self from the realization of death.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I understand your point. Are you saying that it's unreasonable for anyone to point out that necessarily subjective considerations come into play?

ETA: Or maybe the disagreement is over the "necessarily"?

Linda

Subjectivity is fine so long as your subjective opinion does not change for equivalent situations. That's called being delusional, or if you realize they are the same, a hypocrite.
 
Still, I have observed physicians in many different settings focus on the pill or treatment much more so than on the patient. No doubt those are the incidents which stand out in my memory. I wonder though, if either because your practice is not like that, or perhaps you just haven't been looking, maybe there is more of this than you realize.

That's not the reason - I pay attention to issues of bias, so I wouldn't be so foolish as to think that my personal experience is likely to be representative.

I'm not trying to push that overlapping curve apart, now, so don't get me wrong. But I think of the differences more in terms of the medical model and the nursing model. Physicians diagnose and prescribe, nurses assist the patient in carrying out the prescription and help the patient accommodate the illness. Sometimes you need more of one of those than the other. But you can see just from the description, the physician patient and nurse patient roles are inherently different.

Yes, I can see that if you choose to describe things in a particular way then the roles will differ in the way that you have described.

The patient's medical care requires variable amounts of both so the roles of the providers are going to have considerable overlap. And we both recognize specialties make a big difference as well. So maybe differences are going to be individual, situational, or professional. I certainly agree with that. But I'm not willing to completely toss the educational/professional influence altogether.

But no one asked you to toss the educational/professional influence. I suggested that comparing dissimilar situations doesn't really serve to elucidate the educational/professional influence.

Linda
 
Would anyone on the "pro-circumcision" side feel differently if it was proven that it did cause a "siginificant" loss of sexual function? I think that's the main point here. If it truly has no difference at all, then who cares really (although I still think it's silly if nothing else). However, if sexual function is reduced by even a small amount (or even has a chance of being reduced due to side effects) then I think it's immoral to do to a child that cannot make the decision himself.
 
Would anyone on the "pro-circumcision" side feel differently if it was proven that it did cause a "siginificant" loss of sexual function?

Edited-to-delete. Misread the original question.

I think that's the main point here. If it truly has no difference at all, then who cares really (although I still think it's silly if nothing else).
No, that is not the main point at all.

However, if sexual function is reduced by even a small amount (or even has a chance of being reduced due to side effects) then I think it's immoral to do to a child that cannot make the decision himself.
A chance of being reduced due to side effects ? There is always a chance of something going seriously wrong in any surgery, whether it's for cosmetic or medical purposes. So that's you convinced then ?
 
To me, it seems sort of similar to this (though admittedly not nearly as extreme):

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/325/7367/771

A deaf lesbian couple in the United States have deliberately created a deaf child. Sharon Duchesneau and Candy McCullough used their own sperm donor, a deaf friend with five generations of deafness in his family. Like others in the deaf community, Duchesneau and McCullough don't see deafness as a disability. They see being deaf as defining their cultural identity and see signing as a sophisticated, unique form of communication.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In the case of Duchesneau and McCullough, there is no ethical issuethe couple have the right to procreate with whomever they want. And many couples with a family history of deafness or disability seek to have a child without that disability.5 But some deaf couples have expressed the desire to use prenatal genetic testing of their fetus6 or in vitro fertilisation and preimplantation genetic diagnosis to select a deaf child. These choices are not unique to deafness. Dwarves may wish to have a dwarf child.7 People with intellectual disability may wish to have a child like them.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Many people believe that doctors should not help couples to have a deaf child. It is important to distinguish between two meanings of "having a disabled child." Some deaf couples refuse to consent to the insertion of a cochlear implant for a child who is born deaf but who could hear if given the implant.
 
Last edited:
Are you saying that it's unreasonable for anyone to point out that necessarily subjective considerations come into play?
You can make subjective decisions about your own health.

It is unreasonable to claim that circumcision hardly ever benefits a person before he reaches an age when he would be able to do the decision himself too.

If and when the alleged benefits are expected only later in life, there is no need to do it at an age when the person is not capable of making an informed personal decision about it.
 
To me, it seems sort of similar to this (though admittedly not nearly as extreme):

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/325/7367/771

A deaf lesbian couple in the United States have deliberately created a deaf child. Sharon Duchesneau and Candy McCullough used their own sperm donor, a deaf friend with five generations of deafness in his family. Like others in the deaf community, Duchesneau and McCullough don't see deafness as a disability. They see being deaf as defining their cultural identity and see signing as a sophisticated, unique form of communication.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In the case of Duchesneau and McCullough, there is no ethical issuethe couple have the right to procreate with whomever they want. And many couples with a family history of deafness or disability seek to have a child without that disability.5 But some deaf couples have expressed the desire to use prenatal genetic testing of their fetus6 or in vitro fertilisation and preimplantation genetic diagnosis to select a deaf child. These choices are not unique to deafness. Dwarves may wish to have a dwarf child.7 People with intellectual disability may wish to have a child like them.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Many people believe that doctors should not help couples to have a deaf child. It is important to distinguish between two meanings of "having a disabled child." Some deaf couples refuse to consent to the insertion of a cochlear implant for a child who is born deaf but who could hear if given the implant.

What some parents need to have explained is that the rights they have been given to choose for their child are for the child's benefit, not their own. They are only provided so they can fulfil their responsibilities to the child.

I think in the not to distant future, legislation will be required to ensure that people do not abuse the power given to them by genetically selecting characteristics, as appears to be the case above.
 
You can make subjective decisions about your own health.

It is unreasonable to claim that circumcision hardly ever benefits a person before he reaches an age when he would be able to do the decision himself too.

If and when the alleged benefits are expected only later in life, there is no need to do it at an age when the person is not capable of making an informed personal decision about it.

Did you mean "reasonable" in that second sentence?

Linda
 
However, just because it has become hi-tech and sanitized does not change the physical reality of removing healthy, functional tissue or the ethical one of a procedure being performed on a non-consenting individual, for benefits that most men do not see as significant when they are able to choose for themselves.


I don't disagree with much in your post except the bolded part above.

An infant is not a non-consenting individual. An infant has the exact same power to consent to a medical procedure as an adult. It's just that the parent exercises that power for the infant. The infant is not non-consenting; he is incompetent to consent and requires someone to do it for him. A parent who consents to circumcision of an infant stands in exactly the same place as an adult who consents to circumcision on himself.

Lack of ability to consent does not equal lack of consent.




Disclaimer - As a Jew, I had my first son circumcised and will have my next one circumcised as well. No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom