Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

What long term physical harm does rape do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does beating a child do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does enslaving a person do? No more than circumcision.

The people who supported and carried out these acts weren't monsters. They were just like you and me. Ever heard "Spare the rod, ruin the child."?

:boggled: Are you serious?

Ivor, I have pointed out before that I think basically we agree on this issue. Why on earth you would use the implication that rape, child abuse and slavery are exact equivalents to circumcision is beyond me. You are abandoning your very cogent arguments for nonintervention for the sake of a pithy, oversimplistic smart answer. Please don't do that, and don't let your emotional involvement in the issue lead you into making such comparisons.

I have worked in a rape-crisis center. The very idea of implying that there is no long-term harm involved, or that the long-term harm is no more than that of a minor medical procedure, is absolutely unconscionable.
 
Do you see what you did there? You picked the most extreme forms of the acts I used as examples. Some forms of circumcision can be pretty extreme too. Can you think of any?

A person could be enslaved by people who cared for them. Not every slave was tortured. They did not know they were individuals because society decided they were not.

A man could force himself on his wife because she was lead to believe that was her role in life. Love and Obey. She got that idea from society.

A child could be beaten without leaving marks. The child learned that it was the correct way to deal with disobedience. Not every child was beaten to death.


No. Sorry. You can't do that now. You stated that you do not feel that routine circumcision harms the infant. Period.

You then went on to assert that rape, human slavery, and the beating of children are no more harmful. Period.

There is no such thing as a routine rape, beating, or enslavement. They are extreme by their very nature.
 
(Hawk, I think Ivor's being sarcastic.)

I'm not so sure, based on his next post. He appears to be defending the position.

In any event, those are particularly charged and unwarranted comparisons to make.
 
Ok, let's try an example a bit closer to our time and hopefully something you can relate to.

A women not being able to have a higher education and a professional career, such as a physician.

I am not trying to exactly equate the acts of rape with slavery with child beating with the lack of recognition of women as equals with circumcision on a physical level, though some of these practices were often not as brutal as we like to think they were.

I am trying to make you see that the morality of these acts against certain people was wrong for exactly the same reason routine infant circumcision is wrong.

Just because the law allows parents to choose to circumcise their infant, so it allowed the acts I listed at the time periods they were prevalent. We now see them for what they were. Violations of basic human rights.

My reactions to rape is just as intense as yours. Do you think it would be if we had been alive at the time a women was expected to provide sexual favors whenever her husband demanded it? The same goes for child beating and slavery. Sometimes we cannot see the abuses that go on in front of our eyes because we are so used to them. They become normal.

Do you think the men in Afghanistan hate their female children? Do you think they believe they are doing something wrong by stopping them being educated?
 
...snip...

My reactions to rape is just as intense as yours. Do you think it would be if we had been alive at the time a women was expected to provide sexual favors whenever her husband demanded it?

...snip...

Just as a FYI it was as late as 1992 that in England & Wales it was finally decided by the Law Lords that a husband could be found (lgeally) guilty of raping his wife. Before that in England & Wales being married was a legal defence for a husband accused of raping his wife.
 
And do you think that making that comparison is any way to "make" us see anything your way?

Back up. Take a breath. Remember that you are battering people who agree with you with these statements.

Now. What you expect to accomplish by comparing the morality of discrimination against women to the morality of circumcision escapes me. I agree with you, Ivor. I think that unless a permanent physical alteration is medically necessary, it should not be done. I can't think of any comparable reason for keeping a woman from being a doctor. Is that occasionally medically warranted? The two situations are not comparable.

When you say you are trying to "make me see" something, you come uncomfortably close to my "oh no you don't" line. Most people react poorly to being "made to see" anything. Just because I do not phrase my position in tones of extreme moral outrage does not make my thinking on the subject any less solid, nor my conclusions any less heartfelt, than your own. I honestly don't understand how you are swinging so freely between the two extremes (conceding that you do not find circumcision harmful, but then condemning anyone who does not find it a complete moral outrage). You can't have both positions at the same time.

My feeling is that you are letting your annoyance with fls lead you into some intemperate posting, and I am trying to point out that you are coming off as being as bludgeoning as those historical examples you speak against.
 
I'm not trying to batter anybody, especially you, HawkeyeMD. This is more directed toward those people (and physicians and nurse practitioners) who can't (or don't want to) accept what they tolerate every single day and do nothing to protest.

It isn't the acts themselves that are necessarily equivalent, it is the morality of those acts which are. E.g., the powerful in society inflicting their will on the powerless. The powerless just accept it.

How many men who have not been circumcised as infants change there mind when they are older? Very, very few. It is crazy to therefore argue that parents are representing their child's wishes when he is older.

We see all forms of FGM as morally wrong. What is so special about male circumcision, apart from we in the "civilized" world have been performing it for a long time?
 
But some of them really do think that they are conferring a medical benefit. Equating them with rapists and child-abusers does not strike me as a good way to open a dialogue.

Look, I get the frustration. Honest. But once you agree that "the acts themselves are (not) necessarily equivalent", you should not then proceed as though the reaction to them should be. Do you see what I mean? You asked earlier if I thought Afghani fathers (and why not add in mothers) hated their daughters. That in itself is a loaded question, but leaving that aside, let me ask you this. Am I likely to be more successful in convincing them to educate their daughters by calling them names?

I really shouldn't use the example, because again, I don't consider it to be an equivalent. But let's try and look at the situation dispassionately. I think that many parents simply have never thought about it one way or the other--they simply opt for circumcision because that's what they think is normal. It's my hope to get at least some of them to think more about the 'normalcy' of the act--to change their cultural viewpoint, perhaps. But if the two sides of the coin are either "circumcise" or "you are an evil mutilator", I can't imagine that they'd listen at all.

What I am saying is that if you are looking at this as a question of morality and not as one of physical harm, you will never convince about the issue if you attack anyone who disagrees with you as though they are intrinsically evil, because then they are on the defensive from the outset. I am willing to put myself out there as someone who thinks that things should change, but I could never equate a parent who wanted their child circumcised with a child abuser. I said it before: the ethics of pediatrics are complicated. (I'm going to PM you about a specific case.)

As far as why not many men who have not been circumcised as infants change their minds later...:eek: (That's a joke, BTW.)
 
There is no such thing as a routine rape, beating, or enslavement. They are extreme by their very nature.

Only in the developed world today. But in the past (and alas elsewhere in the world today) these activities were (are) accepted by both the oppressors and the oppressed as normal.

My parents both had the cane across their hands. I can't even see the scars.

Some slaves' lives actually improved after being sold.

Not all rape is at knife-point.
 
But some of them really do think that they are conferring a medical benefit. Equating them with rapists and child-abusers does not strike me as a good way to open a dialogue.

Look, I get the frustration. Honest. But once you agree that "the acts themselves are (not) necessarily equivalent", you should not then proceed as though the reaction to them should be. Do you see what I mean? You asked earlier if I thought Afghani fathers (and why not add in mothers) hated their daughters. That in itself is a loaded question, but leaving that aside, let me ask you this. Am I likely to be more successful in convincing them to educate their daughters by calling them names?

I really shouldn't use the example, because again, I don't consider it to be an equivalent. But let's try and look at the situation dispassionately. I think that many parents simply have never thought about it one way or the other--they simply opt for circumcision because that's what they think is normal. It's my hope to get at least some of them to think more about the 'normalcy' of the act--to change their cultural viewpoint, perhaps. But if the two sides of the coin are either "circumcise" or "you are an evil mutilator", I can't imagine that they'd listen at all.

What I am saying is that if you are looking at this as a question of morality and not as one of physical harm, you will never convince about the issue if you attack anyone who disagrees with you as though they are intrinsically evil, because then they are on the defensive from the outset. I am willing to put myself out there as someone who thinks that things should change, but I could never equate a parent who wanted their child circumcised with a child abuser. I said it before: the ethics of pediatrics are complicated. (I'm going to PM you about a specific case.)

As far as why not many men who have not been circumcised as infants change their minds later...:eek: (That's a joke, BTW.)

I have already stated that I don't believe that the vast majority of the people who committed what we would now find abhorrent acts were monsters. Milgram showed us that. I do not think parents who choose to have their boys circumcised for the tiniest of benefits or trivial reasons are evil. I think they don't understand the ethical double-standard they are using to justify it.

I personally think that your approach is probably the only feasible way for you to both stay employed (and hopefully help lots of people and their children) and at the same time indicate that you disagree with the child being circumcised for non-medical reasons.
 
That's what I can't get with the likes of the pro-circumcision people and skeptigirl. They're fast enough to defend parents rights to choose circumcision for their boys, but balk at the idea of doing a clinical trial of a very specific form of FGM with consenting adult volunteers. I don't see how you can have an issue with one but not the other.:confused:
What are you talking about? You have to have a good hypothesis and pass medical ethics committees before some clinical trial of FGM for HIV prevention. This is just getting idiotic, Ivor.

What's you hypothesis and where is your supporting evidence?
 
Uh, yeah. I still don't get what gives the parents the right to perform unnecessary and unreversable surgery on their children. I also personally think it's unethical for medical profressionals to participate in this.

Supporting the claim it is "unnecessary" is the issue here.
 
I got it. Honest. :)

It looked like (and still looks like) you were attempting to push the overlapping curves apart, while I am attempting to push them closer together. I think that within group differences account for much more of what you see than between group differences in attitude.

Of course I'm not claiming that we have suddenly reversed a centuries old philosophy. It was you who brought up the idea of the underlying models and my point is that the underlaying model has changed which is leading to real changes in the behaviour and attitudes of physicians.



There are many reasons for those differences that are not based on paternalism. As you point out, the amount and kind of situations where nurses provide an opinion are quite different from situations involving physicians. Many of the medical decisions involve extensive knowledge and experience that cannot be sufficiently conveyed to the patient in order to let them make the informed decision, leading to situations where providing an expert opinion rather than an inadequate education better serves the patient. The nature of some of the things that physicians recommend (treatment, diagnostic tests) make it obvious when they are rejected, whereas the rejection of a nurse's recommendation may have little opportunity to be discovered. Your contention that you provide education while physicians provide opinion in comparable situations may look different to a neutral third-party.

I think you realize all this. It seemed to me that emphasizing differences in attitude (which I agree is present - less so in comparison of the ideal and more so in comparison of actual practice) ignored the more obvious differences in the nature of the roles and within group variation. And that your examples spoke more to the latter than to the former. I jumped in because your illustration of the situation seemed biased, as does mine, but together they might form some sort of useful picture.



Don't you think, in this case, that it is practice and experience that probably accounts for much more of the difference than attitude? You both seem to have a similar attitude, but Hawkeye pictures her anticipated response differently than how you picture your response. Hers is necessarily speculative, but yours is based on experience. How to help parents (and patients) make decisions is something that you learn, after all.

Linda

I completely agree with you. I will give you another example though, where nursing intervention is called for and not many doctors recognize it. It also, however, is specific to my experience.

I have been seeing workers for blood exposures for ~18 years, (17 on my own and 1 as a hospital employee health practitioner). It's rare that these exposures lead to infection, and I certainly know the medical protocols and provide the needed medical care. However, exposure to blood really has as big an emotional reaction as any medical need. Some workers are petrified, some worried about their family, and some not so much. I'd say 90% of the intervention is taking care of the emotional reaction and 10% is medical intervention. In addition, the drugs used for HIV risk are really risky in themselves. One protease inhibitor, no longer used, caused one worker's liver failure which necessitated a liver transplant.

For exposures, I'm very conservative with medical interventions and liberal treating the emotional response. I also see many workers who already went to the ED so I see what the Docs have already done. I use many more nursing skills than most physicians who tend to offer the medical interventions with these patients and really don't address the emotional issues much at all. Reassurance if not done right, often comes across as downplaying the risk the worker feels.

So do you think physicians are given an education which says, the PEP drugs in such a situation are often not needed, but addressing the exposed worker's fears is the most important intervention? Keep in mind also, this is often an ED Dr. There are a couple hospitals in this area who still refuse to do the worker's baseline HIV test, opting instead to refer the worker to a PMD the next day. Their reason? Our state law requires pre and post test HIV counseling and they didn't want to take on that task.

I think most medical care involves a mix of medical and nursing skills. I recognize that easily as someone with a nursing education which focused on nursing diagnoses and interventions. (Nursing got little credit for such skills until we figured out you had to name them and describe them.) I'd be very interested to know how much focus is given in med schools today covering those "nursing diagnoses" and whether any med school ever refers to them as "nursing orders".
 
Last edited:
Having second thoughts, I'll try one more time.
Then stop bringing it up. Seriously. The more times you qualify your statements with things like "of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others", the more it sounds like your underlying message is "but of course they're all that way underneath." The very sentence you wrote implies it--if some are "less", then clearly all of us are.
This is your paranoia and defensiveness. The more I try to restate what I'm saying in response to your misinterpretations, the more defensive you get.

I can't find the thread I referred to earlier, where you were arguing with someone claiming to be a doctor and spouting off about things like "nurses just take orders and doctors give them", but as I said, I agreed with you there. The idea of nursing and medicine as overlapping magisteria, if you will, is not a bad place to begin, and as I also said, I agreed with what you were saying there. But neither profession has a headlock on education. OR paternalism.
It was this thread, Medical and Healthcare phishing and no one was buying skepticdoc's absolutely unbelievable nonsense. But it was an opportunity for me to describe the nursing profession, something which the public doesn't hear nearly often enough.

I think, from what you have written, that you find the importance of reducing infection risk to be by far the weightiest issue. I find it hard to believe that in the process of educating a parent, this viewpoint would not come across more strongly than the idea that there is "equivocal medical evidence". Anyone who is medically educated and is in the position of advising a patient is going to color their advice by their own knowledge and experience. That's not paternalism.
Perhaps you find that hard to believe because you still don't get the fact I believe what I say, that where the medical evidence is equivocal, then individual assignment of priorities is a neutral medical decision.

You have erroneously concluded the example I gave of a parent who might have reason to value infection risk reduction meant I was promoting that position. I used that example to try to show those people here who were simply discounting the medical evidence of UTI risk that there was another side of the coin. I have had to support the argument for infection risk reduction because no one else here seems to recognize it. It is a valid medical indication for a circumcision in a healthy infant. Either you, as a 4th year medical student, don't believe that the AAP or the AAFP committees who wrote the respective position statements for those organizations were sincere, or you must believe you have the qualifications to contradict their conclusions.

I believe the reduction in infection risk is reasonable. I don't believe the evidence for risk reduction is strong enough to override someone like Ivor or yourself who are convinced the foreskin is so important. And at the same time I have not seen any convincing empirical evidence that circumcisions are a big deal to a majority of men.

Believe it or not, some of us actually believe in the positions we promote. I find the evidence equivocal.

I know you've undoubtedly read the famous Emanuel/Emanuel paper on medical models (which, by the way, we were given during our first semester in med school). The idea that the patient should be solely given information and should make all decisions alone, with the caregiver as a technical informer only, is the 'informative' model and it isn't considered ideal either. There has to be some guidance or interpretation, otherwise the caregiver might as well be Google.com (TM).
Actually, I haven't read it.

Linda noted there was a knowledge difference and that it plays a big role in one's ability to simply inform a patient and have the patient decide. I agree with this completely. And at the risk of having you conclude if I say something I must really mean the opposite, :rolleyes: , I wasn't trying to imply that patient autonomy was some absolute. I was speculating that my nursing background did make it more likely for me to empathize with multiple values influencing the specific decision to circumcise. But maybe it is more my individual experiences than my professional background. Either way, nurses are socialized to accept patient's values and work with them as part of the nursing role.

Point of information: I'm not a physician yet. I appreciate the brevet rank, though. :cool:

You keep claiming this, and yet clearly, three different people are getting a different message. Is it not possible to state that there are differences between the professions of medicine and nursing without implying that one of them is intrinsically better? I know you will respond that you were doing no such thing. But that's how it's coming across.
It's absurd to think I'm claiming one is better. My primary care provider is a physician, not a nurse practitioners. Not that I don't have the utmost respect for nurse practitioners, but I know or can research as much as they know medically. I expect and trust my physician knows a lot more medicine than I know. I'm saying that each has a contribution, but each has a different educational and professional experience.

I have. I've seen nurses who are openly scornful about patients not listening to them, even when it's something as simple as when they should get out of bed. Doesn't mean a darn thing about nurses in general. Your constant use of absolutes ("I have never seen a nurse do this") and implication of rare exceptions (Not all doctors are like this") is what is leading to the appearance that you *are* generalizing about "all doctors".
There are poor nurses out there just as there are poor doctors. The specific role of the nurse is to deal with this kind of patient problem. The absolute is true in the profession of nursing, reality is by no means absolutely ideal.

If that is, as you say, not what you mean, then please stop bringing it up to bolster your position on this specific topic. I agree with Katana that you are clearly extremely knowledgable and you know your subject well; I have no doubt that your patients are well served by you. You are doing yourself and those who might learn from you a disservice by injecting your argument with what is obviously being interpreted as, if not a personal attack, then a professional one.
No Dr Hawk, (and you do have MD after hawkeye so that's why I used the shorthand), in your defensive position, you are reading things into my posts which are not in them. I can't help you there.

Yes, let's, shall we? Only let's deal with my actual position. My position is that based on the medical evidence, I do not believe circumcision is warranted for every male child. Therefore, since I am considering it as a medical procedure, I don't intend to perform them routinely. As fls has pointed out, most parents are not primarily concerned with the risk of infection (whether of HIV, which seemed to be the predominant example early in the thread, or of UTIs, which have taken over lately) when considering circumcision. If a parent is concerned about UTI, then that is a medical question and a situation in which I would consider the procedure.
Then why is it, do you think, that seasoned professionals in the AAP and AAFP have come to a different conclusion?

Your characterization of "willing to allow" and "respecting" other choices is specious. I do think that societal and cultural issues have weight, but I think that my input into them is far less than my input into a medical question. I don't even know what you think you mean by this. By 'respecting' a choice, you mean I should wholeheartedly support it and act on it just because it's the parents' decision? Sorry, but if I don't agree with it, I can't. I assure you I would never roll my eyes and say, "Well, if you MUST do it...." You seem to be assuming a level of judgmentalism on my part. It isn't like that. I really don't think circumcision is harmful. I think it's unncessary. That is different from "how dare you consider mutilating your child". Which, given the direction of some posts in this thread, I do see where that was coming from, but...don't ascribe that tone to me, because I have never and would never use it.
Same question, how do you support your decision to go against two different physician organizations who, by consensus, do find the UTI risk reduction warrants consideration for circumcision of an otherwise healthy infant? At least one of which reversed an earlier position against circumcisions?

And as far as respect vs allow, you have yet to address the parent's legitimacy weighing infection risk reduction above the harm from loss of the foreskin. My issue is with your judgment that such a parent value doesn't rise to the level of "medically indicated". It bothers me you would say that to parents who might have lost a previous child to infection.
 
But some of them really do think that they are conferring a medical benefit. Equating them with rapists and child-abusers does not strike me as a good way to open a dialogue.

Look, I get the frustration.
There may have been remotely some dim sense in the allegory, though.

Some time ago I read the interview of a Russian woman who spent five years in Sweden as the victim of human trafficking, forced to do you know what profession.

Knowing that there are tens if not hundreds of thousands of young women in this situation across the western and eastern world, we might ask why the customers -- millions of quite ordinary men of the mainstream society -- participate in the business by buying the services.

This interviewed Russian ex-victim said that many of her "customers" seemed to earnestly believe that they were doing a favour to her, giving her the chance to earn money.

In the same mindless sense, millions of Africans earnestly believe that they are doing a favour to their daughters by getting them circumcized.

Many also earnestly believe that amputation of the foreskin is a favour to their baby boy.

This discussion will never end I guess, but at this point it would be interesting to hear the voice of the amputees themselves: any statistics available about the thoughts and feelings of circumcized men generally?

I guess most of them are quite perfectly happy with their lives.
 
The only reason to use the term amputation, JJM 777 is to make an emotional appeal. If you had a medical case, you wouldn't need an emotional appeal.

Where is the research showing more than a small percentage of men are mourning the loss of their foreskins?
 
From your source, skeptigirl:

"In some cultures and religions, minor amputations or mutilations are considered a ritual accomplishment."

Is it not talking about circumcision or FGM? Seems like we CAN use the term amputation fairly.

The only reason you saw an emotional appeal when you read the term amputation, skeptigirl, is because of your emotional response. If you had no emotional response to it, you wouldn't have a problem with the term amputationl
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom