Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Disclaimer - As a Jew, I had my first son circumcised and will have my next one circumcised as well. No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.

No amount of evidence could dissaude you from perpetuating ritual genital mutilation?


:jaw-dropp


That's frightening. It would be one thing if you said that the evidence presented has failed to change your mind, but this kind of single-minded adherence to a bronze-age tribal scarring ritual is bizarre.
 
No amount of evidence could dissaude you from perpetuating ritual genital mutilation?

That's frightening. It would be one thing if you said that the evidence presented has failed to change your mind, but this kind of single-minded adherence to a bronze-age tribal scarring ritual is bizarre.


Um ... that's exactly what I did say. I said that no argument that has been produced has changed my mind. I did not say that no amount of evidence could change my mind. Here were my exact words:


No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.
 
Um ... that's exactly what I did say. I said that no argument that has been produced has changed my mind. I did not say that no amount of evidence could change my mind. Here were my exact words:

Oh. To quote Optimus Prime from the new Transformers movie, "My bad."

:boxedin:
 
You're also clearly not reading what I've written. I don't consider the foreskin to be particularly important. I've said it in several places--I don't think the procedure is all that big a deal.

What I do think is important is the individual's right to choose for himself whether or not to permanently alter part of their body. Absent convincing--not "equivocal"--evidence to the contrary, I think that is a significant consideration. Having said that, I also pointed out in my previous post that a parent who was seriously concerned about UTI would be one I would consider performing the procedure for. If parents wish the procedure for other reasons, whether cultural or religious, then it is not unreasonable of me as a (future) medical professional to refer them elsewhere. (The fact is that I would probably send any child to another provider anyway--whoever does it should be experienced.)

Oops, small correction. The previous post quotes my next-to-last response to you; this is from the last one.

So that's twice I've said it, in no uncertain terms.

Still awaiting apology.
 
Last edited:
This is part of my last response to you. I will not bother going through the thread and finding previous discussions.

Awaiting apology.
I said if you could show me your statement was true, that you had already acknowledged you would consider a parent's value of infection risk reduction as meeting your definition of "medically indicated". Obviously you never said that until now.

So instead of simply saying, maybe I have a point, you pretend that was always your position?

Right.
 
That is the silliest, sulkiest response I could have imagined.

"Until now"? Um, yeah. As in, as soon as I responded to you after the subject of UTI came up (as opposed to HIV). Several days ago.

Yes indeedy. Very obviously. :rolleyes: Well, thank you for acknowledging that I did say it.

Apology accepted.
 
If Columbus hadn't circumsized the Earth, America might never have been esposed!!
 
That's not the reason - I pay attention to issues of bias, so I wouldn't be so foolish as to think that my personal experience is likely to be representative.

Yes, I can see that if you choose to describe things in a particular way then the roles will differ in the way that you have described.

But no one asked you to toss the educational/professional influence. I suggested that comparing dissimilar situations doesn't really serve to elucidate the educational/professional influence.

Linda
We could go on forever on this. From my 30 years of experience, I have seen a philosophical difference in nursing and medical approaches to patient care. And while I understand the limits of anecdotal observations, that 30 years has included a really broad number and kind of practice settings. I've worked in a 35 bed rural hospital, a small city hospital and several large urban ones. I've worked in public health, drug rehab, ICU, pediatrics, family practice (NP, not nurse), occupational health, employee health, infectious disease and infection control. I've gone back to college 3 separate times, lived in 4 states and traveled extensively. So I do have quite an extensive collection of observations which I am drawing conclusions from.

As I try to describe just what the difference in professions I speak of is, it has conjured up all sorts of misunderstandings about what I am describing.

The example I gave about the blood exposure patient care was a good example. You can look at the practice settings and say that accounts for the difference. So are you then claiming there is not a fundamental difference in patient interactions between the two professions?

If you think I am talking about 'good' and 'bad' patient care, then I can understand why you might look at the problems in the comparison. But if you stop looking at that aspect, which is not anything I am communicating, and you look instead at how the nursing and medical professions might complement each other because of the differences, then the example is one which merely illustrates a concept. That concept is where nursing and medicine do differ.

This originally started when Dr Hawk made a declarative statement that she would not want to do a circumcision unless it was medically indicated. Since infection risk reduction is a medical indication, then the procedure could be medically indicated for any healthy child. If the statement had instead been, "unless the parents want the procedure for a medical reason" then I wouldn't have reacted to her position in the same way.

The second place we differed was our respective definitions of what constituted "respect" for the parent's values in the decision making. While Dr Hawk has objected to my description that respect meant acceptance and not simply "allowing" the decision, nonetheless, I have a different perspective of what respecting the parent's decision means in this situation. It was an argument over semantics. But there was still an overlying philosophical difference in our professions that likely impacts, in some unknown variable degree, our positions.

While there are a multitude of possible reasons for Dr H's and my different perspectives. I still contend both nursing and medicine approach problems differently. That approach is a layer on top of how individuals practice their respective professions. The individuals themselves are the same. Maybe there are some differences which lead people to each profession, certainly the admission requirements differ. But there are all ranges of values, competence, and mixing of nursing and medicine within each field.

Take the nursing role of patient advocacy, for example. Nursing Spectrum is not the most sophisticated publication, but this interview describes the role well.
Interview with Karen Stanley, RN, MSN, AOCN, FAAN, president of the Pittsburgh-based Oncology Nursing Society.

Q: Would you please tell us your definition of nursing advocacy?

Advocacy is an essential role for all nurses. It addresses one’s individual responsibility to be informed about issues, to educate one’s colleagues and the public about those issues, to collaborate with those who can offer solutions to identified problems, and to effect change in nursing practice that delivers better outcomes.

Q: Describe the need for advocacy as a function of nursing.

Advocacy, on behalf of an improved health care system and the patients for whom we care, ensures that nursing is part of the solution to a growing problem. Nurses are well qualified to speak on behalf of patients and their families.

It is difficult to be a strong self-advocate when one is ill and vulnerable, unfamiliar with the health care system, and/or doesn’t know what rights one has. In these instances, the patient and family must rely on health care providers to advocate for them, and it is our ethical obligation to do so.

There is an unequal relationship between the health care system and the patients it serves. The goal of advocacy is to equalize that relationship by assessing patient/family needs and understanding the circumstances, providing culturally sensitive information and education, ensuring equal access to appropriate care, and supporting the patient and family’s decisions within the context of a multidisciplinary team.

Q: How has the philosophy of advocacy changed?

Historically, advocacy was viewed as ensuring that physician’s orders were carried out. Nurses helped patients conform or comply in order to be well. Today, nursing advocacy requires critical thinking skills, appropriate assessment and intervention, speaking for the patient within the context of the multidisciplinary team approach, and ensuring that patient’s wishes are honored and care is respectfully delivered.

Q: Describe some of the responsibilities nurses undertake in the new paradigm of advocacy for patients.

In addition to being informed about issues and speaking to patients in a way that improves their outcomes, nursing has an ethical obligation to address priority patient needs — physical, psychosocial, and spiritual. It can take courage to speak out for the most appropriate intervention when there is disagreement among the members of the multidisciplinary team. Collegiality is to be honored, but nursing’s responsibility to the patient trumps all else.

[snip]

Q: Give a clinical example of how an oncology nurse can speak up courageously for a vulnerable patient.

Individual patient advocacy occurs on a daily basis in a multitude of settings. In one instance, I consulted about a patient with metastatic cancer who had been admitted with a bowel obstruction and a tremendous pain burden. The obstruction was attended to, but there was an order for “no narcotics,” since the obstruction had been secondary to the use of oral opioids without a concurrent bowel regimen.

Patient-centered advocacy requires the safe and effective management of pain. After consulting with the physician, who was extremely reluctant to order opioids, I was able to initiate intravenous opioids and a concurrent aggressive bowel regimen. I personally administered the first opioid dosage and watched the patient break into tears when his pain was relieved for the first time in several weeks. [Nurses may perceive these kinds of actions differently than the physician. After this thread discussion, I think upon reassessment, this may not be much different from two physicians advocating for different medical interventions.]

Q: You’ve said that evidence-based practice, almost a buzzword, relates to advocacy today. How does it relate to oncology nursing?

The Oncology Nursing Society has done a significant amount of work defining evidence-based practice in the oncology nursing arena. We see this as another part of our organization’s advocacy role for oncology nurses and patients. We have compiled a meta-analysis of evidence-based practice in oncology nursing care. Topics include management of symptoms such as fatigue, nausea and vomiting, and depression, as well as other physical and psychosocial symptomatology. We have compiled evidence that supports best practice for oncology nurses and improved outcomes for patients. The next step is to educate oncology nurses so that practice can be changed.

[snip]
 
... Having said that, I also pointed out in my previous post that a parent who was seriously concerned about UTI would be one I would consider performing the procedure for. If parents wish the procedure for other reasons, whether cultural or religious, then it is not unreasonable of me as a (future) medical professional to refer them elsewhere. ....
Well I'll be.. this was your second mention of accepting the validity of a parent valuing UTI prevention.

Post 442: I do not intend to perform circumcisions unless I think there's a medical reason for it.

Poat 450: At this time, my opinion is that for a child who will grow up in a country like the USA--which is where I will practice--there is not sufficient medical justification for circumcision.

Post 460: exactly what I said: that I don't plan to perform circumcisions routinely, on a medical-evidence basis.

Post 465: the basis of the comparison--if there is no significant benefit, why perform it--is the crux of the disagreement about circumcision, which is why I addressed it.

before any procedure is performed that can't be undone, I need to feel that there is a medical necessity for it.

Post 470: At some point, that may mean saying, "Well, you understand my point of view. If you still want it done, I can give you some names of doctors who do perform the procedure." I don't think that's making a show of advocacy. It's just that in the course of a career, you are not going to win every fight. If they listen to me, and they still want it done, well...it's not illegal and I can't say that I think it's hugely harmful. I just don't think it's necessary.

Post 476: It wouldn't make me feel better to pass it off, but it would make me feel better to know that I've refused to do something I don't agree with.

Post 479: Well, it may be only a matter of time before this 'elective medical procedure' is considered differently. Things change, you see.

But tonsils are a very good example of an 'elective' surgery that has become largely extinct because of awareness by both parents and physicians that it did not do what it was intended to do.

Post 484: Your viewpoint is clear. You think circumcision is a good thing. Fine. You will have to accept the fact that there are other medical professionals who disagree with you. And the reason that people keep responding to the idea that you are espousing the concept of circumcising American boys for the purpose of avoiding HIV infection is that you keep responding this way to those of us who are making the point that it does not apply in non-Third-World nations with posts like these.

[Completely missing the fact I was talking about UTIs in all infants and HIV only in high prevalence areas.]

That is why I feel I should give them the benefit of the knowledge I have worked so hard to acquire. To suggest acquiescing to anything else in the name of "values" is to condescend to them. I have made it clear that I would never try to prevent a parent who, having heard my opinion, still wanted the procedure, from having it done.

Exactly where do you find an attack on a patient's parents values in that?

Post 493: That's the thing--I don't see it as a huge moral issue, I just see it as medically unnecessary,

Post 503: My main issue with it is the permanent alteration, for no good medical reason that I can see.

Then finally, after all those proclamations, we get to your reluctant admission in post 709:
Yes, let's, shall we? Only let's deal with my actual position. My position is that based on the medical evidence, I do not believe circumcision is warranted for every male child. Therefore, since I am considering it as a medical procedure, I don't intend to perform them routinely. As fls has pointed out, most parents are not primarily concerned with the risk of infection (whether of HIV, which seemed to be the predominant example early in the thread, or of UTIs, which have taken over lately) when considering circumcision. If a parent is concerned about UTI, then that is a medical question and a situation in which I would consider the procedure.

I really don't think circumcision is harmful. I think it's unncessary.
So, I don't care that you don't like me. I do believe I have been successful in getting you to recognize your medical opinion in this case, that a circumcision is unnecessary, is not the only way to interpret the medical evidence.

Now if you could just get over being annoyed at bolded text and not assume a different opinion is necessarily an insult...
 
Last edited:
I don't believe it is. If he were saying, look, we used to accept these things as matters of course too, and now we think they're horrible, I would accept that as an analogy. To say "how much harm does rape do? No more than circumcision" is to make a direct comparison and, frankly, invite a heated response.

As Katana also pointed out, rape and beatings are liable to cause more than minor physical harm.

Well, circumcision has the potential to cause more harm than the loss of a little bit of skin. Some poor little kids have lost their peckers just because their parents were too ignorant to consider NOT mutilating their child.

As for rape, well, there can be lots of harm, or there can be no real harm at all. In and of itself, however, there isn't necessarily any harm done. Sure, people might not LIKE being held down and screwed, but it's otherwise a relatively MINOR PROCEDURE.

And most people recover from a beating soon enough.
 
I was hoping for some initial rage then hopefully some recognition (a light-bulb moment) that the similarities, at societal and ethical levels is almost exact. Only a few people seem to have understood this.

Ivor, you da man. You are so right.

My argument is that this construction is a delusion. It is exactly the same delusion that the men raping their wives, the teachers caning children and the households with slaves used to justify their behaviour. They have created it to protect their idea of self (e.g., I am a good person), in a similar way to people who create the delusion of an afterlife or God to protect the self from the realization of death.

Yes, nobody wants to admit to themselves that they are ignorant, barbaric, brainwashed, in denial, intellectually lazy or just plain wrong. That's why they refuse to see the real underlying issue as you present it.
 
Disclaimer - As a Jew, I had my first son circumcised and will have my next one circumcised as well. No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.

"Jewish children are circumsized."

Since you're talking about a primitive superstition, I will also assume that no evidence WHATSOEVER could trump your religious belief.

Too bad for your children. I can't imagine how I would feel if my parents had mutilated me just because it felt right to them. You should not have the right to impose your barbaric notions on your defenseless children.

If there were any justice, I could just call 911 and have you arrested.
 
I don't disagree with much in your post except the bolded part above.

An infant is not a non-consenting individual. An infant has the exact same power to consent to a medical procedure as an adult. It's just that the parent exercises that power for the infant. The infant is not non-consenting; he is incompetent to consent and requires someone to do it for him. A parent who consents to circumcision of an infant stands in exactly the same place as an adult who consents to circumcision on himself.

Lack of ability to consent does not equal lack of consent.




Disclaimer - As a Jew, I had my first son circumcised and will have my next one circumcised as well. No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.

Where I think your argument falls down is that unless it is expected that the patient will never be able to decide for himself and the procedure can be performed later in life, then a non-essential physical alteration should not be carried out.

All you have effectively done is used a period in the life of the individual when he was unable to choose to inflict your will on them.

Can you conceive of a man not wanting to be circumcised?

What is your opinion of uncircumcised men?

If you believe the ~1% absolute risk reduction of UTI is significant, will you be taking action to reduce similar risks by a similar amount?

Once you have answered these questions honestly I think it should be obvious if you are able to make an unbiased, rational choice for your child.
 
Well, circumcision has the potential to cause more harm than the loss of a little bit of skin. Some poor little kids have lost their peckers just because their parents were too ignorant to consider NOT mutilating their child.

As for rape, well, there can be lots of harm, or there can be no real harm at all. In and of itself, however, there isn't necessarily any harm done. Sure, people might not LIKE being held down and screwed, but it's otherwise a relatively MINOR PROCEDURE.

And most people recover from a beating soon enough.
This isn't a rational way to weigh risk and benefit. Some poor little kids have lost their lives from kidney failure and sepsis too. That risk is greater if you are not circumcised.
 
Ivor, you continue to think we should all share your view. But the fact is we don't. It isn't a matter of honesty, bias or irrational thinking.
 
We could go on forever on this. From my 30 years of experience, I have seen a philosophical difference in nursing and medical approaches to patient care. And while I understand the limits of anecdotal observations, that 30 years has included a really broad number and kind of practice settings. I've worked in a 35 bed rural hospital, a small city hospital and several large urban ones. I've worked in public health, drug rehab, ICU, pediatrics, family practice (NP, not nurse), occupational health, employee health, infectious disease and infection control. I've gone back to college 3 separate times, lived in 4 states and traveled extensively. So I do have quite an extensive collection of observations which I am drawing conclusions from.

Do you think your conclusions could differ if your perspective was from within, rather than from without, with regards to medicine?

As I try to describe just what the difference in professions I speak of is, it has conjured up all sorts of misunderstandings about what I am describing.

The example I gave about the blood exposure patient care was a good example. You can look at the practice settings and say that accounts for the difference. So are you then claiming there is not a fundamental difference in patient interactions between the two professions?

No, I'm not claiming that. I think that even if the underlying philosophies were identical that there would necessarily be differences in patient interactions between the two professions.

If you think I am talking about 'good' and 'bad' patient care, then I can understand why you might look at the problems in the comparison. But if you stop looking at that aspect, which is not anything I am communicating, and you look instead at how the nursing and medical professions might complement each other because of the differences, then the example is one which merely illustrates a concept. That concept is where nursing and medicine do differ.

I do believe that you are sincere when you say that you are not talking about "good" and "bad". But the way in which you have chosen to illustrate your points, does communicate this judgment. When you say that physicians and nurses are different because nurses do "this", the implication is that physicians do not, regardless of whether or not you say it out loud. What you may really mean is that physicians do it in a different way, but that is not the message that is conveyed. When the "this" I referred to is "advocate for patients" or "consider patient values", I really find it difficult to believe that anyone wouldn't consider those characteristics "good", and consider "ignore patient values" and "take no responsibility for patients" as "bad", regardless of whether or not you formally applied those labels.

I am not saying that I am unable to look past that and make some attempt to understand what you may be trying to convey. Or that I disagree with or fail to understand the point I think you are trying to make.

This originally started when Dr Hawk made a declarative statement that she would not want to do a circumcision unless it was medically indicated. Since infection risk reduction is a medical indication, then the procedure could be medically indicated for any healthy child. If the statement had instead been, "unless the parents want the procedure for a medical reason" then I wouldn't have reacted to her position in the same way.

Yet, when I read her statement, it seemed to me that that was what she was trying to convey - that for the average or usual situation, the risk reduction for infection is insufficient to overcome the ethical considerations (hence the AAP recommendations), but that in individual situations, the weighing of the medical issues may lead to a different recommendation. If she meant to exclude that possibility, then I would have expected her to state it differently. Who knows. She has clarified the issue for you, now.

The second place we differed was our respective definitions of what constituted "respect" for the parent's values in the decision making. While Dr Hawk has objected to my description that respect meant acceptance and not simply "allowing" the decision, nonetheless, I have a different perspective of what respecting the parent's decision means in this situation. It was an argument over semantics. But there was still an overlying philosophical difference in our professions that likely impacts, in some unknown variable degree, our positions.

While there are a multitude of possible reasons for Dr H's and my different perspectives. I still contend both nursing and medicine approach problems differently. That approach is a layer on top of how individuals practice their respective professions. The individuals themselves are the same. Maybe there are some differences which lead people to each profession, certainly the admission requirements differ. But there are all ranges of values, competence, and mixing of nursing and medicine within each field.

Take the nursing role of patient advocacy, for example. Nursing Spectrum is not the most sophisticated publication, but this interview describes the role well.

This is another example. You make a point of saying that your position and HawkeyeMD's position are different (and I don't really see much of a difference), and that one of the reasons may be differences between the nursing and medical professions. Then you make a statement about one characteristic of the nursing profession, without any reference to the medical profession, which implies (regardless of whether you meant it) that it is not a characteristic of physicians. But it would not occur to me to consider the absence of that characteristic as anything but bad. So what did you intend to convey? Please keep in mind that I am not trying to say that medicine and nursing are not different.

Linda
 
Ivor, you continue to think we should all share your view. But the fact is we don't. It isn't a matter of honesty, bias or irrational thinking.

Actually, I think you share my view for some situations and not for others. My problem (or as I see it, your problem;)) is when two particular situations are fundamentally the same and you consider one right and the other wrong, or one worth doing and the other not. As I said before, subjectivity is ok, so long as you're consistent in your subjective opinion.

I doubt anyone (even me:D) could achieve perfect consistency in their actions, but when sitting down and thinking about why you do what you do in one situation and in another, I see no reason to attempt to defend my own or anyone else's inconsistent behaviour or ethics.

ETA: The example you brought up about parents whose first boy was uncircumcised and had a UTI from which he died having more of a reason to circumcise their second boy is irrational, assuming the UTI and the resulting death was just bad luck. I.e. UTI’s in different children are independent events, barring genetic or environmental factors to link them. Or do you think using irrational thought is (sometimes) valid in the decision to treat a person?
 
Last edited:
"Jewish children are circumsized."

Since you're talking about a primitive superstition, I will also assume that no evidence WHATSOEVER could trump your religious belief.


That is an unwarranted assumption. It is not what I said, it is not what I believe and I don't appreciate being stuffed with straw so you can "win" an argument against a position I never took.

What I said was that no evidence that has been produced has changed my mind. Here is my original quote:

No rational argument that has been produced can trump in my mind the fact that Jewish children are circumcised.

You can assume whatever you like. It does not make it true.


You should not have the right to impose your barbaric notions on your defenseless children.


I am doing no such thing. I am exercising my child's will for him because he is unable to do so.

Parents have exercised their children's desire to refuse all medical treatment even at the cost of death. There is nothing unusual about it.


Where I think your argument falls down is that unless it is expected that the patient will never be able to decide for himself and the procedure can be performed later in life, then a non-essential physical alteration should not be carried out.

All you have effectively done is used a period in the life of the individual when he was unable to choose to inflict your will on them.


No, I have not. I have exercised my child's will because he was unable to.


Can you conceive of a man not wanting to be circumcised?


Sure.


What is your opinion of uncircumcised men?


They're probably not Jewish.


If you believe the ~1% absolute risk reduction of UTI is significant, will you be taking action to reduce similar risks by a similar amount?


I did not circumcise my son for any such reason. Thus, your argument is a non-sequitor.


Once you have answered these questions honestly I think it should be obvious if you are able to make an unbiased, rational choice for your child.


There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history. My relatives who dies in the Holocaust were circumcised. My relatives who were murdered during the black plague were circumcised. My relatives who were slaves in Egypt were circumcised. And my relatives who live and fight so that the Jewish people can have a homeland in Israel are circumcised.

And when the next wave of antisemitism hits - and it will - I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom