I have been lurking in the shadows and have read through and followed this entire thread, and I feel that now is a good time to emerge and offer input on this issue from a perspective that was only briefly touched upon -- Foreskin Restoration.
To begin with, I am a 31 year old American male who underwent RIC (Routine Infant Circumcision) as a newborn. From briefly speaking with my parents on the issue not too long ago, I understand that they were not asked about it and it was done automatically without their knowledge or consent. I never really thought much about it growing up, and only began to thing about it after getting married to my wife of now over 10 years.
Being from Mexico originally, she grew up in an environment where RIC was not performed (to my knowledge), and always viewed the intact penis as normal. I have the honor of being her first and only sexual partner, and years ago she expressed to me how attracted she was to the sight of intact penii and how erotic she found them to be. Over time, and especially over the last few months, I thought heavily about what it would be like to have a foreskin, and upon doing some online research came across a few sites and forums dedicated to foreskin restoration.
After reading about the differences and benefits of restoring, from both articles and input from various forum users, I decided to pursue restoration of my own foreskin. I am now using one of the devices on the "market" (not really a market, but I digress) and we both look forward to the results. It is, unfortunately, a lengthy process (a dedicated 2-3 years or more), but I believe it will be well worth it in the end.
Now, to hopefully shed some light on the issue of cut vs. intact, I shall address various points brought up in this thread...
First of all, on the subject of what exactly is lost with most circumcisions, and other unfavorable issues that "arise" (no pun intended.... well, maybe a little pun) from this:
- It is not simply a "little flap of skin" that is lost. In general, the total skin area missing from a fully grown adult who was subjected to RIC is about the size of a 3x5 index card. This removed area of skin does in fact contain many thousands of nerves that enhance sexual pleasure.
- The Frenulum, which "anchors" the foreskin in place and is extremely erogenous. Now, many people do have part or almost all of the frenulum remaining after Circ (I have just about all of mine, thank goodness), however it does usually sustain quite a bit of damage.
- The "ridged band", which helps to hold the foreskin closed and is said to be almost as sensitive and erogenous as the frenulum.
- Inner foreskin/mucosa - This varies greatly between circs, some are left with very little, and yet others (like myself) are left with a good amount. But this tissue is very sensitive and erogenous.
- Keratenization of the Glans and remaining inner foreskin - Since the glans and inner skin is no longer covered and protected, it changes from a moist internal membrane to a "dried-out" keratenized organ. This happens because of the body trying to protect the glans and skin, and the result is a loss of sensation due to the keratenization.
I know many people in this thread have said that "they're plenty sensitive enough" and they don't believe they've lost anything, but it is true that a normal, moist, unkeratenized glans is more sensitive and responsive than its circumcised counterpart. I know a study was posted earlier regarding "sensitivity tests" between cut and intact males, however I will address this point further in a bit...
Unfavorable issues that are commonly experienced include:
- Extremely tight shaft skin due to a very tight Circ, sometimes so extreme that it results in tearing during erection/sexual activity.
- The scrotum being drawn up during erection due to a tight Circ
- Hair on the shaft, causing discomfort for the partner.
- Curves, twists, and a loss in maximum length and girth due to the missing skin and tightness of cut.
Now, on the subject of pleasure and sensitivity:
- As I said above, a normal Glans is more receptive and sensitive to pleasure and other stimuli than a keratenized one. The layer of keratenization does inhibit the nerves to some degree. Regardless of the afforementioned study, this can be verified by those people who have restored some or all of their foreskin, because one of the benifits of foreskin restoration is the de-keratenization of the glans and its return to the normal, moist state of being an internal membrane! With this, they experience a very large increase in sensitivity, resulting in more pleasure, better and stronger orgasms, and overall better enjoyment of sex. As an FYI, the glans will eventually dekeratenize when it is covered all of the time again. The body is pretty smart sometimes! =)
- Regarding pleasure from the skin itself, one of the biggest things that is taken during circumcision is what is known as "gliding action". This is what occurs as the foreskin (skin-tube) moves up the shaft and over the glans during sexual activity. This is something that increases pleasure for not only the man, but the woman as well. Many women have an issue with painful intercourse, or needing a never-ending supply of lube, or pain after intercourse. This is what generally happens with circumcised partners. Many of these same women, upon having sex with an intact male, see all of these problems disappear completely! Lube also becomes a thing of the past for the most part, because the gliding action of the foreskin allows the shaft of the penis to move in and out of the vagina through the skin itself, rather than sliding agaist the vaginal walls, virtually eliminating the friction that requires lubricant to solve. Many women also report a greater "tenderness" and sense of "closeness" with their intact partners as their partners no longer have to "jackhammer" them to acheive climax.
Circumcised men feel plenty of pleasure (as I personally know), but intact men have the potential, and the "equipment" to feel much much more, as has been shown by the restoration community and as I have PERSONALLY experienced, even though I am only beginning the restoration process.
On the subject of cleanliness/cheese/smegma/etc:
- Everybody should be keeping their genitals clean, regardless whether you are cut, intact, male, or female! All an intact person needs to do is pull their foreskin back to clean properly, and it will never be a problem. Children whose foreskin has not naturally retracted on its own yet do not need to retract for cleaning, as no dirt will be getting/forming in there. NEVER MANUALLY RETRACT A BABIES/CHILDS FORESKIN, if it hasn't done so naturally yet, because yes, that specific event could open the door for infection.
- I cannot honestly understand how any woman could *ever* try to justify circumcision based on an intact man's potential for "uncleanliness", or criticize intact men based on that potential. Do you realize how absolutely disgusting you would get down there if you did not clean properly? All of the "cheese" that you thing is so gross about intact men is something you yourself will get if you do not clean!! Does that mean we should "circumcise" you by removing part of your labia to avoid "cheese buildup"? This is a pretty hypocritical stance for a female to take, IMHO.
- While I'm on cleanliness I might as well bring up infection risk, both to men and women. Now, Skeptigirl, you seem to be focusing on UTI as the biggest reason to circumcise. I know you have posted a boatload of studies throughout the thread, so if I missed it, I apologize in advance, but can you show me any studies or reports indicating that there is an epidemic of UTI issues with newborns/children in modernized countries that do not circumcise? Because honestly, I have never heard of UTI's being an issue across the pond or anywhere else for that matter. Also, some people mention Cervical cancer being higher in women whose partners were intact. This again is something I have never heard of... there doesn't seem to be a rash of women in non-circumcisional countries dying of this cancer. Regardless of *potential* for disease/infection by leaving newborns intact, there really doesn't seem to be an actual problem anywhere in the world. Please note that I am not speaking about HIV/AIDS in Africa, as I feel that is a different issue altogether.
On the subject of visual appeal:
- I know it has been stated in this thread already, but it bears repeating -- It really does seem to be based on what you grew up around, and what kind of society you live in. It's possible that the majority of American women find an intact penis to be "gross" and "ugly" and not erotic. However, head over to Europe and the exact same sentiment will be found regarding circumcised penii. Not even Europe, since as I had mentioned before, my Mexican wife finds intact penii much more appealing and erotic.
Now, to summarize:
The foreskin really does have a function, and serve a purpose. It allows for greater sexual pleasure for the male, and it also allows for greater sexual pleasure for the female partner, for the reasons described above. That is its function -- better and easier facilitation of sexual activity.
Foreskin restoration will not bring back some of what was lost, e.g. the Ridged Band. However, when restored, the penis will look virtually indistinguishable from a natural intact penis, it will return "gliding action", and it will return the Glans and Inner foreskin to its natural state as a moist membrane, all helping to increase sensitivity and pleasure greatly. Remember, this is not based on studies or tests between intact and cut males, this is based on the first-hand experience of those who are restoring/have restored (myself included).
In closing, as I grew up most of my life not really thinking about cut vs. intact all that much, it never really bothered me. After learning about the foreskin, foreskin restoration, and actually beginning the process myself, I do honestly feel like I was robbed and cheated out of something that I would have cherished greatly. I am not filled with anger and rage and looking to sue the pants off of the hospital I was born in, but I believe it is wrong, so very wrong, to perform this operation on an infant. I am not an anti-circ activist, but I will never subject any children I have to this.
For now, I am thrilled that I can restore my foreskin and get back much of what was taken. That is my focus. I will, however, do my part when necessary to help educate people on the topic of circumcision. Whether they will throw down their bias and listen, though, is strictly up to them.
I hope this (long long long) post has been helpful, or at least entertaining, and I look forward to any replies that I may receive.