Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Skeptigirl,

I thought it might help if I provided an example of how I compare and contrast physicians and nurses using your example:

Q: Give a clinical example of how an oncology nurse can speak up courageously for a vulnerable patient.

Individual patient advocacy occurs on a daily basis in a multitude of settings. In one instance, I consulted about a patient with metastatic cancer who had been admitted with a bowel obstruction and a tremendous pain burden. The obstruction was attended to, but there was an order for “no narcotics,” since the obstruction had been secondary to the use of oral opioids without a concurrent bowel regimen.

Patient-centered advocacy requires the safe and effective management of pain. After consulting with the physician, who was extremely reluctant to order opioids, I was able to initiate intravenous opioids and a concurrent aggressive bowel regimen. I personally administered the first opioid dosage and watched the patient break into tears when his pain was relieved for the first time in several weeks.

In this situation, both the physician and the nurse seemed to be practicing patient-centered advocacy. However, the physician more heavily weighted death and less heavily weighted discomfort as an outcome, whereas the nurse weighted death less heavily and discomfort more heavily (relative to the physician, not necessarily to each other). And it's possible that the difference is at least partly a result of the different background (medicine vs. nursing) that the physician and nurse have. Although, I have seen the identical discussion between two physicians.

[Nurses may perceive these kinds of actions differently than the physician. After this thread discussion, I think upon reassessment, this may not be much different from two physicians advocating for different medical interventions.]

I think this comment applies to just about everything you've presented, so far, including the stuff you bolded from the interview.

Linda
 
However, the physician more heavily weighted death and less heavily weighted discomfort as an outcome, whereas the nurse weighted death less heavily and discomfort more heavily (relative to the physician, not necessarily to each other). And it's possible that the difference is at least partly a result of the different background (medicine vs. nursing) that the physician and nurse have.


As a person who has had multiple heart surgeries from infancy all the way through my life to date, I can anecdotally confirm that doctors are generally far less concerned with patient comfort than averting death. In fact, I have never had the experience even once of a doctor even asking me if I was comfortable or if I was in pain. It has always been the nurses who have advocated for me to get pain medication or to get me on an unrestricted diet (because the stuff they serve the cardiac patients is [rule8]ing nasty), etc.

I've generally held that the way you know for certain that you're dying is when the doctor asks if there's anything that can be done to make you more comfortable.
 
I've generally held that the way you know for certain that you're dying is when the doctor asks if there's anything that can be done to make you more comfortable.

That explains the suspicious looks I get when I bring up certain topics. :)

Linda
 
I am doing no such thing. I am exercising my child's will for him because he is unable to do so.

How do you know this is the child's will ?

Parents have exercised their children's desire to refuse all medical treatment even at the cost of death. There is nothing unusual about it.

Evidence ? I pesonally would find this extremely unusual, if such cases do exist. I'd find it bizarre.

There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history. My relatives who dies in the Holocaust were circumcised. My relatives who were murdered during the black plague were circumcised. My relatives who were slaves in Egypt were circumcised. And my relatives who live and fight so that the Jewish people can have a homeland in Israel are circumcised.

And when the next wave of antisemitism hits - and it will - I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.

Isn't circumcision also common among Muslims ? Just asking ... I was in my early 20s before I even heard of circumcision, never mind seeing the results.

So absent the existence of some other (physical) identification, how is circumcision going to "inarguably and proudly identify" someone as Jewish ?
 
No, I have not. I have exercised my child's will because he was unable to.

Wow! You’ve either got an ability that will win you $1million or you’re fooling yourself. No, the reality is you just picked a time when your son could not choose so you could inflict your will on him. Why not wait until he’s 21? I mean, you’ll have had all that extra time to brainwash him.


So you acknowledge a man might not want to be circumcised, but at the same time you’re certain it won’t be the man you’re son will become. You are clearly delusional.

They're probably not Jewish.

That’s an inference, not an opinion. I’ll ask again: What’s your opinion of circumcised men? (I'm getting the idea from your tone in this post you consider Jewish people superior somehow.)

I did not circumcise my son for any such reason. Thus, your argument is a non-sequitor.

No, you did it for the really dumb reason of “it’s always been done this way.”

There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history.

What value? Would you love your son less if he had a foreskin? Would you only consider him an unclean heathen if he remained intact?

BTW, everybody’s ancestors have been through thousands of years of tumultuous history. Did I tell you about the time my ancestor was being chased by Genghis Karn? Boy, was he upset. Then there was this bloke in 1066…

My relatives who dies in the Holocaust were circumcised. My relatives who were murdered during the black plague were circumcised. My relatives who were slaves in Egypt were circumcised. And my relatives who live and fight so that the Jewish people can have a homeland in Israel are circumcised.

Incorrect. The Jewish women who died were not circumcised. That begs the question: How do Jewish women manage to ‘feel’ Jewish? I think I’m correct in thinking that your religion doesn’t insist you chop any bits off them.

And when the next wave of antisemitism hits - and it will - I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.

The problem is that anything anyone else does that affects Jewish people usually has a few of them complaining it’s anti-Semitic.
 
Last edited:
That explains the suspicious looks I get when I bring up certain topics. :)

Linda

Actually, I'd say you know it's really bad news when they make an unannounced house call just to give you the results of a brain scan.
 
How do you know this is the child's will ?


Because, by definition, what I want for my minor child is what he wants. You can find that to be injust if you like. It doesn't change the fact that the law says that it is true.


Evidence ? I pesonally would find this extremely unusual, if such cases do exist. I'd find it bizarre.


Here, here, and here.



Isn't circumcision also common among Muslims ?


I have no idea.


So absent the existence of some other (physical) identification, how is circumcision going to "inarguably and proudly identify" someone as Jewish ?


Why do you assume that there will be an absense of the existence of some other identification or that physical identification is somehow more important than any other? It is one mark of a Jewish man - necessary, in my view, but certainly not sufficient.
 
Wow! You’ve either got an ability that will win you $1million or you’re fooling yourself. No, the reality is you just picked a time when your son could not choose so you could inflict your will on him.


No, the reality under law is that my decision as to what is best for my son is his decision. I win this argument by definition. You don't have to like it, but it's the law.


Why not wait until he’s 21?


And what if the Nazis come for us when he's fifteen? Or nine? Or six months old?



So you acknowledge a man might not want to be circumcised, but at the same time you’re certain it won’t be the man you’re son will become.


I am certain of nothing of the sort. I am certain that my newborn son will want to be circumcised on the date of his circumcision. I am certain of this because my judgment as to what is best for him legally substitutes for his own.


You are clearly delusional.


No, I'm a lawyer.


That’s an inference, not an opinion. I’ll ask again: What’s your opinion of circumcised men?


In that case, I have no opinion. I'm not sure who is in that group, why they are in there, how they feel about anything, whether they pay their taxes on time or anything else. I have no opinion about them.


(I'm getting the idea from your tone in this post you consider Jewish people superior somehow.)


You are projecting that entirely from within yourself. I have not said males should be circumcised. I have not said people should be Jewish. I have not said that Jews have any special claim to any unique truth. All I have said is that, in my tradition, Jewish males are circumcised.


No, you did it for the really dumb reason of “it’s always been done this way.”


Not every consistency is a foolish consistency. I see a value in keeping a connection with one's past. If you find that stupid, that's your own business. I don't appreciate the implied insult, though.


What value?


I've explained this already. Just because you don't like my explanation doesn't mean I didn't answer you.


Would you love your son less if he had a foreskin? Would you only consider him an unclean heathen if he remained intact?


No and no.


BTW, everybody’s ancestors have been through thousands of years of tumultuous history. Did I tell you about the time my ancestor was being chased by Genghis Karn? Boy, was he upset. Then there was this bloke in 1066…


That must have been tough for them.


Incorrect. The Jewish women who died were not circumcised. That begs the question: How do Jewish women manage to ‘feel’ Jewish?


I don't have daughters.


I think I’m correct in thinking that your religion doesn’t insist you chop any bits off them.


I'm told Jewish mothers have a procedure by which they attempt to circumcise their daughters' self-esteem.


The problem is that anything anyone else does that affects Jewish people usually has a few of them complaining it’s anti-Semitic.


I have made no such complaint and I reject, once again, this straw man attack.
 
Last edited:
Well I'll be.. this was your second mention of accepting the validity of a parent valuing UTI prevention.

Yes, congratulations! You can read! And in the very two posts following your request for clarification on that exact point. In fact, I have to say, I'm honored that you clearly think so much of my opinion that you felt the need to so carefully go through them all...over and over...even the ones that have nothing to do with any conversation with you...just to pick out all the plums. And look at that! Look at all those references to 'medical necessity' and 'medical benefit' and such. You must really understand my position now.

:rolleyes:

Ye gads, skeptigirl. Do you really have that much time on your hands?

If you want me to learn something from you--and as I also said before, I think you have a great deal of knowledge, and whether you believe it or not, my attitude really is that anyone with more experience than me is someone I should be able learn from--then please listen to what fls is trying to explain to you. Your reading of my statements has been skewed. When I've tried to explain my real viewpoint to you, you keep responding with generalizations about doctors and nurses that, as fls has explained several times, are hard to see any anything but denigrations of doctors.

Then when you're called on it, you say "That's absurd! I never meant that!"

But you're fine with characterizing my position as "Dr H instead made the non-evidence based declaration, "there is no medical indication for a circumcision in a healthy infant" so if the parents want one, they are wrong, but I won't interfere."

You might try applying some of that carefully-trained respect to your future colleagues.
 
No, the reality under law is that my decision as to what is best for my son is his decision. I win this argument by definition. You don't have to like it, but it's the law.

That’s bollocks and you know it. Other people have had their children removed to protect them from their decisions.

And what if the Nazis come for us when he's fifteen? Or nine? Or six months old?

Well if they get to you when he’s still young there may be a chance for him if his physical characteristics are up to scratch. Don’t think you’ll make it though.

I am certain of nothing of the sort. I am certain that my newborn son will want to be circumcised on the date of his circumcision. I am certain of this because my judgment as to what is best for him legally substitutes for his own.

A parent’s judgement only extends so far with respect to the child. You are correct that US law currently allows you to mutilate his genitals because of your deluded religious beliefs. You are almost certainly incorrect about what your son wants. Unfortunately for you, that’s a fact that the law cannot change.

No, I'm a lawyer.

What makes you think a lawyer is immune from being deluded?

In that case, I have no opinion. I'm not sure who is in that group, why they are in there, how they feel about anything, whether they pay their taxes on time or anything else. I have no opinion about them.

Good.

You are projecting that entirely from within yourself. I have not said males should be circumcised. I have not said people should be Jewish. I have not said that Jews have any special claim to any unique truth. All I have said is that, in my tradition, Jewish males are circumcised.

Maybe I was. It was just the little speech about the (intangible) “value” of members of the Jewish faith continuing to mutilate their male children’s genitals because their ancestors did it sounded very much like pride to me.

Having a Heinz 57 ethnic background myself (including a Jewish Great-Grandmother) I don’t have any particular pride in my genetic history.

Not every consistency is a foolish consistency. I see a value in keeping a connection with one's past. If you find that stupid, that's your own business. I don't appreciate the implied insult, though.

Consistency is foolish when performing the act does not affect the result. E.g., many parents manage to brainwash their kids with their religious delusions without removing any body parts. Is Judaism really that ineffective at penetrating a male child’s psyche without physically altering his genitals? Has anyone ever tried?

I've explained this already. Just because you don't like my explanation doesn't mean I didn't answer you.

No and no.

I was trying to understand if this “value” was tangible. But since removing the foreskin would not alter the love you feel for your son or make him an outcast from the Jewish faith, this “value” appears to be totally intangible.

That must have been tough for them.

It’s estimated half the people who have ever lived have died of malaria. Now that’s tough.

I don't have daughters.

I'm told Jewish mothers have a procedure by which they attempt to circumcise their daughters' self-esteem.

What has that to do with the question I asked? I’ll try again: How do Jewish women manage to feel Jewish? Do they forget sometimes because their genitals have not been mutilated like their male counterparts?

I have made no such complaint and I reject, once again, this straw man attack.

Oh, it just sounded like you were expecting another wave of anti-Semitism to hit soon.

If the law was changed and routine infant male circumcision became illegal, would you be claiming it was anti-Semitic?
 
That’s bollocks and you know it. Other people have had their children removed to protect them from their decisions.


Oh, there's a limit to which parents can substitute their judgment for their children, but circumcision is nowhere near that limit. So, it is not "bollocks" and, in fact, I know that it is not. I know it the same way an engineer knows if a bridge is safe or a doctor knows if a medication is warranted - I know it because I have been professionally trained to know it.


Well if they get to you when he’s still young there may be a chance for him if his physical characteristics are up to scratch. Don’t think you’ll make it though.


I don't know what you mean by that. If you mean that Nazis might spare my son because he is uncircumcised, I assure you I would rather see my son die as a Jew than live in denial of the same.


A parent’s judgement only extends so far with respect to the child. You are correct that US law currently allows you to mutilate his genitals because of your deluded religious beliefs.


I am not deluded. They actually are my religious beliefs.


You are almost certainly incorrect about what your son wants.


It is, by definition, impossible for me to be wrong about what my son wants. My desires are his desires. The two things cannot be separated. I'm getting a little tired of repeating that, especially since you already conceded that this is the state of the law.


Unfortunately for you, that’s a fact that the law cannot change.


Actually, that would be fortunate for me.


What makes you think a lawyer is immune from being deluded?


Don't generalize. I said that *I* am not deluded and used, as evidence that I am not, the fact that my behavior comports with the law. Lawyers can be deluded. On this issue, however, I am not.




I don't know what we were talking about but I'm glad to see you with such a positive attitude.


Maybe I was. It was just the little speech about the (intangible) “value” of members of the Jewish faith continuing to mutilate their male children’s genitals because their ancestors did it sounded very much like pride to me.


There is a massive difference between *pride* and "consider[ing] Jewish people superior somehow." I have pride in my heritage; I do not consider my religion superior.


Is Judaism really that ineffective at penetrating a male child’s psyche without physically altering his genitals? Has anyone ever tried?


Don't know, don't care.


I was trying to understand if this “value” was tangible. But since removing the foreskin would not alter the love you feel for your son or make him an outcast from the Jewish faith, this “value” appears to be totally intangible.


Um, okay.


It’s estimated half the people who have ever lived have died of malaria. Now that’s tough.


Yeesh! Is there a fund I can donate to?


How do Jewish women manage to feel Jewish? Do they forget sometimes because their genitals have not been mutilated like their male counterparts?


I don't know. I am not a Jewish woman and I don't have daughters.


Oh, it just sounded like you were expecting another wave of anti-Semitism to hit soon.


I'm always expecting it. However, I have not complained that the arguments against circumcision in this thread are antisemitic.


If the law was changed and routine infant male circumcision became illegal, would you be claiming it was anti-Semitic?


Yes.
 
I am exercising my child's will for him because he is unable to do so.
(...)
My desires are his desires. The two things cannot be separated.
(...)
Parents have exercised their children's desire to refuse all medical treatment even at the cost of death. There is nothing unusual about it.
Nothing unusual, it's a wild world out there. But at JREF forum this would be termed "woo". You might want to learn the meaning of that word.

I have exercised my child's will because he was unable to.
You are exercizing your own will, and you are seizing the practical opportunity in control of a helpless person. Happily enough, this will probably not have a great negative impact on his life, since the issue is relatively trivial.

I want my sons to be inarguably and proudly identified as Jewish men.
Finally you are speaking in the correct modus: "I want". What your sons will want when they grow up, remains to be seen.

There is value in being physically identified with the religion that has seen your ancestors through thousands of years of tumultuous history.
You can always have the kippah and long hair on temples. These would conveniently identify your kid as a Jew, for any Nazi roaming the streets of your hometown. Being circumcized would not help at all in America or in Muslim countries, where more than half of population are circumcized without having anything to do with Judaism.

No, the reality under law is that my decision as to what is best for my son is his decision. I win this argument by definition. You don't have to like it, but it's the law.
Why do I have the feeling that you are not referring to the law of the state now? If you are referring to the Law of Moses, please give the readers a better hint. Otherwise they will be wondering where such laws are in effect.

And what if the Nazis come for us when he's fifteen? Or nine? Or six months old?
By the way, the fact that any Jews remain at all is thanks to them trying to hide, many of them escaping death by hiding their true identity.

The fact that you were ever born and are now writing to this forum might be thanks to "policies" that you are now opposing in your texts.

Not to mention the Purim story about Haman and Queen Esther. (I personally find it a work of fiction though. I generally expect that nearly all Biblical stories have a historical background, even if some details may be a bit hazy. But the Book of Esther is fiction from the beginning to the end, in my estimation.)
 
Last edited:
That is an unwarranted assumption. It is not what I said, it is not what I believe and I don't appreciate being stuffed with straw so you can "win" an argument against a position I never took.

What I said was that no evidence that has been produced has changed my mind.

What's evidence got to do with it? You freely admitted that you favor circumcision for "jewish" boys, for, well, no good reason. Because that's how you think jewish boys ought to be.

Where does evidence come into this?

I am doing no such thing. I am exercising my child's will for him because he is unable to do so.

Oh? And just how do you know what your child's will is? Did you ask him? What was his response?

You are not exercising your child's will, you are exercising your own. It may make you feel better to imagine it's what your child really wants, but it makes you no less of a monster.

Parents have exercised their children's desire to refuse all medical treatment even at the cost of death. There is nothing unusual about it.

So when a Jehovah's Witness refuses a blood transfusion for his infant child, he's exercising his child's will? Do you mean to say that every JW child that died because their parents refused them treatment wanted it that way? I hope not, because that would just be patently insane.

uhh.. oh, man.. you know what, I'm just going to drop it. It's obvious to me you're just too far gone to be reached.
 
I am not deluded. They actually are my religious beliefs.

Translation: I am not deluded. They actually are my delusions.

It is, by definition, impossible for me to be wrong about what my son wants. My desires are his desires. The two things cannot be separated. I'm getting a little tired of repeating that, especially since you already conceded that this is the state of the law.

Oh I see what's going on here, you think the world is a court of law, and that what's legal is what's right. That's not an uncommon fallacy.

Sorry Loss Leader, I was thinking about the real world, not the fantasy world you live in where what's "legal" is what's "right".

My guess is you prefer the legal definition of yourself, which is law-abiding citizen, to the "real world" definition of yourself, which is inhumane, atavistic, ignorant, barabaric monster.

You seem to be missing an important point here, and that is that nothing about Nazism was illegal. Hitler's rise to power and subsequent oppression and murder of the Jews was perfectly legal in the Nazi state. According to your logic, there was nothing wrong with it, because it it was in accordance with the law.

Care to rethink your assumption that legal = right?
 
So, doctors, are you all saying anything nurses do, you can all do just as well. Nurses have no special patient care skills unique to their education and experience that physicians don't also have? Physicians learn everything nurses do in addition to physicians' medical education and experience. But of course, nurses can not do everything physicians can.

Does it make any sense that I might be trying to describe two sets of skills, two aspects of medical care, and that by doing so I am not saying the medical portion of the care is not as important?

Should I be offended if you say to me, as an NP, I have some medical education but in no way is it the equivalent of med school? That is a factual statement. Should I view it as insulting?

Because I don't. Yet if I try to describe one thing I think distinguishes physicians and nurses, You've all expressed being insulted by that.
 
Last edited:
Skeptigirl,

I thought it might help if I provided an example of how I compare and contrast physicians and nurses using your example:

In this situation, both the physician and the nurse seemed to be practicing patient-centered advocacy. However, the physician more heavily weighted death and less heavily weighted discomfort as an outcome, whereas the nurse weighted death less heavily and discomfort more heavily (relative to the physician, not necessarily to each other). And it's possible that the difference is at least partly a result of the different background (medicine vs. nursing) that the physician and nurse have. Although, I have seen the identical discussion between two physicians.

I think this comment applies to just about everything you've presented, so far, including the stuff you bolded from the interview.

Linda
Linda, I can also give you a number of examples where the nurses were very wrong and the physicians were not. In one case, for example, we had one patient with advanced terminal lung cancer. She came in for drainage of pleural fluid and during the procedure suffered a pneumothorax. The physician put her on a vent. She begged us constantly to be taken off the vent and allowed to die. I was convinced. We nurses grumbled that the physician wasn't doing the right thing.

But in 3 days she was fine. She left the hospital in good spirits, and I'm sure she had many months or maybe even years to live before the disease took her life. I excuse myself as having been right out of nursing school. But it was one of many experiences I've had that have given me the skills I have today.

Perhaps I have expressed an inoffensive thought in an offensive way. On a forum, that is very easy to do. You don't have a number of communication cues one has in person. But it is also possible that you might be missing the observation that nursing has a significant body of knowledge which contributes to patient care. And that body of knowledge is not simply compassion, or empathy, or respect for patient autonomy.

I was trying to say nursing, by it's nature gives one a different perspective than medicine gives. You're hearing that as doctors are missing something. That's not what I am saying. Our professions overlap, but they are still very different. Nurses are not in a position to 'fire' patients. Physicians need to make medical decisions. Those are differences in our jobs. It doesn't mean nurses don't make decisions. There are very important decisions nurses make all the time. It isn't that physicians cannot be patient advocates or compassionate. That is absurd. But physicians and nurses are not in the same roles. To say they are is just as absurd.

Dr Hawk stated she had no strong feelings opposing circumcision. Yet she said more than 12 times something to the effect if it wasn't "medically" indicated, then another provider was going to have to do it. She was willing to consider the UTI evidence (which I missed on July 1st and argued about for a few more days). You still have a physician who sees her practice as all her decisions. If the family has a religious belief, find another doctor. If the family wants baby to look like Dad, find another doctor. If the family feels more kids in the jr high locker room will be circumcised and they prefer to spare little johnny the teasing (apparently this could go either way), find another doctor. All because Dr Hawk is in control and has decided what she choses to do in her practice.

That position makes perfect sense for the majority of medical decisions. It would be less than ethical to do what some docs do like prescribe anabolic steroids or oxycontin for a price. It's not ethical, in my opinion, to prescribe unnecessary antibiotics to an insistent patient.

But here we have something Dr Hawk feels is an unnecessary procedure, yet she doesn't have overwhelming objections. She is willing to perform the procedure on a healthy infant if the parents use the right words in their request. But if those parents want that procedure Dr Hawk is willing to provide for another family for a reason not meeting Dr Hawk's approval, then Dr Hawk is going to make the decision for them, at least as far as Dr Hawk's practice goes.

As a nurse that just boggles my mind.

Maybe it has nothing to do with our respective professions. I happen to think our respective professions do have an influence here on our different perceptions. Obviously it could be any number of other things or combination of factors.
 
Last edited:
...

Ye gads, skeptigirl. Do you really have that much time on your hands?
I'm fast using the control F function.

...... When I've tried to explain my real viewpoint to you, you keep responding with generalizations about doctors and nurses that, as fls has explained several times, are hard to see any anything but denigrations of doctors.

Then when you're called on it, you say "That's absurd! I never meant that!"

But you're fine with characterizing my position as "Dr H instead made the non-evidence based declaration, "there is no medical indication for a circumcision in a healthy infant" so if the parents want one, they are wrong, but I won't interfere."

You might try applying some of that carefully-trained respect to your future colleagues.
Posts in a forum sometimes require time before what is being communicated is sorted out. One who falsely assumes another is being disingenuous, doesn't allow for that sorting out to occur. One who is offended by another person simply because they hold a different view, or because they won't come around to a viewpoint being expressed, will find a lot of things to be offended about on a forum.

I find if I take offense to other people's positions, then discussions become total wastes of time. And if I worry about pleasing everyone, such as we do in face to face interactions, I'd be much more limited in what I felt I could say.

I know I had no offensive feelings in what I was saying. I'm willing to continue a discourse to clarify any mistaken offense. Beyond that, some people on forums are going to be offended no matter it is a misunderstanding. While that's regretful, it isn't something I often get very bothered about.

As far as my mis-characterizing your position, are you not aware you mis-characterized mine repeatedly? It happens. Forum discussions lend themselves to mis-characterizations. You want to know something interesting I have observed about that? So do in person interactions leave people with completely different messages than those conveyed.

One of the differences on forums is people are posting replies over a number of days sometimes. With in person interactions, discussions are often much shorter. The person who misunderstands what you say goes off believing you said something you didn't. And you may never know that. I never ceased to be amazed at what people believe I said in my infectious disease classes when I ask them later what they remember. It's the nature of human communication.
 
Skeptigirl, let me see if I understand your position on routine infant circumcision correctly:

You think it’s similar to parents choosing to vaccinate their child. However, unlike standard vaccinations which have clear benefits and extremely low risks, the evidence for circumcision is equivocal. Even so, you think parents should be allowed to use their judgement after being provided with the evidence. You do not see any significant ethical problems with this approach.

And from what I can gather, the physicians who have contributed so far point of view on this can be summarised by:

You think routine infant circumcision is ethically dubious, but aren’t prepared to stand up for what you believe, or accept some non-medical reasons but not others given by parents for the circumcision of their child. Even if you disagree with the decision to circumcise a child and will not perform it yourself, you will tell the parents of the child where they can get it performed, because you believe that parents will turn their backs on all of 21st century medicine if they can’t get their kid cut.

Both the physicians and Skeptigirl think ALL forms of FGM are wrong, even if they are carried out in 21st century hi-tech hospitals, if performed on non-consenting (infant) girls.

Neither Skeptigirl or the physicians appear to comprehend that the ethics of one are identical to the other, or they do and are hypocrites.

Now would any of you like to summarise what you think my position is (obviously when you’ve stopped bickering about what nurses do that doctors don’t and vice-versa)?

ETA: This makes interesting reading.
 
Last edited:
Nothing unusual, it's a wild world out there. But at JREF forum this would be termed "woo". You might want to learn the meaning of that word.


Bahahhahahahahahah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!cough.hahahahahahaha!!!!!!!!!


You are exercizing your own will, and you are seizing the practical opportunity in control of a helpless person.


Incorrect.


What your sons will want when they grow up, remains to be seen.


It certainly does. However, what my sons want right now is known to me with perfect clarity because it is identical to what I want for them. The two things are the same.


You can always have the kippah and long hair on temples. These would conveniently identify your kid as a Jew, for any Nazi roaming the streets of your hometown. Being circumcized would not help at all in America or in Muslim countries, where more than half of population are circumcized without having anything to do with Judaism.


I agree that being circumcised is necessary but not sufficient.


Why do I have the feeling that you are not referring to the law of the state now?


Because I am.



By the way, the fact that any Jews remain at all is thanks to them trying to hide, many of them escaping death by hiding their true identity.


Don't speak about things which you do not know. How many Jews have escaped death by hiding their identity? What percentage of all Jews was it? What percentage of living Jews was it? How many Jews escaped death by emmigrating out of Europe without hiding their identities? How do you tie your shoes in the morning? Does your nurse help you or are they those velcro things?

I've really been very polite in the face of some harsh criticism in this thread, but I won't be polite in the face of stupidity.


The fact that you were ever born and are now writing to this forum might be thanks to "policies" that you are now opposing in your texts.


Wrong. At least as far back to the 1800s.


Book of Esther is fiction from the beginning to the end, in my estimation.)


So you are citing fiction to support your point?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom