Skeptigirl,
I thought it might help if I provided an example of how I compare and contrast physicians and nurses using your example:
In this situation, both the physician and the nurse seemed to be practicing patient-centered advocacy. However, the physician more heavily weighted death and less heavily weighted discomfort as an outcome, whereas the nurse weighted death less heavily and discomfort more heavily (relative to the physician, not necessarily to each other). And it's possible that the difference is at least partly a result of the different background (medicine vs. nursing) that the physician and nurse have. Although, I have seen the identical discussion between two physicians.
I think this comment applies to just about everything you've presented, so far, including the stuff you bolded from the interview.
Linda
I thought it might help if I provided an example of how I compare and contrast physicians and nurses using your example:
Q: Give a clinical example of how an oncology nurse can speak up courageously for a vulnerable patient.
Individual patient advocacy occurs on a daily basis in a multitude of settings. In one instance, I consulted about a patient with metastatic cancer who had been admitted with a bowel obstruction and a tremendous pain burden. The obstruction was attended to, but there was an order for “no narcotics,” since the obstruction had been secondary to the use of oral opioids without a concurrent bowel regimen.
Patient-centered advocacy requires the safe and effective management of pain. After consulting with the physician, who was extremely reluctant to order opioids, I was able to initiate intravenous opioids and a concurrent aggressive bowel regimen. I personally administered the first opioid dosage and watched the patient break into tears when his pain was relieved for the first time in several weeks.
In this situation, both the physician and the nurse seemed to be practicing patient-centered advocacy. However, the physician more heavily weighted death and less heavily weighted discomfort as an outcome, whereas the nurse weighted death less heavily and discomfort more heavily (relative to the physician, not necessarily to each other). And it's possible that the difference is at least partly a result of the different background (medicine vs. nursing) that the physician and nurse have. Although, I have seen the identical discussion between two physicians.
[Nurses may perceive these kinds of actions differently than the physician. After this thread discussion, I think upon reassessment, this may not be much different from two physicians advocating for different medical interventions.]
I think this comment applies to just about everything you've presented, so far, including the stuff you bolded from the interview.
Linda