Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

This is only to address the "If we circ, then why not remove the appendix, too" argument here.

Doing a routine circumcision on a newborn is an extremely quick and safe procedure (again, all arguments about long-term benefits/risks notwithstanding). Removing an appendix is a much different proposition. It is abdominal surgery, requiring general anesthesia (along with all of its risks), time in the operating room, significantly higher costs, and, though rare, the complications can be devastating.

There was a time when appendices were removed routinely during other surgery. The thought was, well, we're here anyway. Why not spare the patient trouble later? This went out of favor as the rate of complications from this began to out-pace the potential benefits.

I don't believe that the ease of genital mutilation is a valid argument in favour of genital mutilation per se.

I suspect you were not trying to argue that it is.

My example was merely to address the illogical argument that circumcision is OK because it deals with unnecessary human bits and pieces, such as the appendix. If there is no intrinsic difference other than degree of difficulty I could ask why not cut off the ear lobe or the tips of the fingers or the toenails?

My primary argument still remains. Non-medical male infant circumcision is equivalent to the docking of dogs for for the owners/parents cosmetic preferences. As such it is genital mutilation for no rational purpose and therefore fundamentally abhorrent.
 
Waitaminute, that's not how it works. Noone needs to justify leaving a child intact, it is the proponents of any alteration that must justify THEIR positions. In short, the burden of proof is on you.

It actually looks like the claim being made is that we should or should not be rabid on this issue. And it seems that the default is to be selectively rabid, rather than selectively non-rabid. However, it could be laziness rather than rationality which leads me to assume the former.

Linda
 
It actually looks like the claim being made is that we should or should not be rabid on this issue. And it seems that the default is to be selectively rabid, rather than selectively non-rabid. However, it could be laziness rather than rationality which leads me to assume the former.

Linda

Yes, you're right. It is laziness on your part.
 
my 4th son...

My three oldest sons had this done at birth.

My 4th son had to have this done when he was six years old because he wasn't being good about keeping it clean. Mom can only clean for them for so long, you know. His brothers, all in high school at the time were present. As we walked out, one of the boys told him:

"Wow, you're doing great! When I had mine done I couldn't walk for a year!"

Chicken Pot Pie
 
Last edited:
I agree that younger doctors are exposed to a different world than the education and socialization of their older peers. But the idea the medical community has suddenly reversed a century old philosophy is absurd. OTOH, how many times do I have to say various versions of, "not all doctors" and "overlap" and "subtle philosophical difference, not concrete or absolute difference"? I am really being misunderstood here. I have to assume I am not explaining my self well. I am describing an underlying philosophical difference, not some black and white, doctors are this, nurses are that. I'm talking about more subtle differences. And of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others.

Then stop bringing it up. Seriously. The more times you qualify your statements with things like "of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others", the more it sounds like your underlying message is "but of course they're all that way underneath." The very sentence you wrote implies it--if some are "less", then clearly all of us are.

I can't find the thread I referred to earlier, where you were arguing with someone claiming to be a doctor and spouting off about things like "nurses just take orders and doctors give them", but as I said, I agreed with you there. The idea of nursing and medicine as overlapping magisteria, if you will, is not a bad place to begin, and as I also said, I agreed with what you were saying there. But neither profession has a headlock on education. OR paternalism.

I see equivocal empirical medical evidence. I find the importance of reducing infection risk just as legitimate as valuing an intact foreskin. I see my role as giving the parents the information they need to make an informed choice. I don't see my role as imposing my personal values in this case.

I think, from what you have written, that you find the importance of reducing infection risk to be by far the weightiest issue. I find it hard to believe that in the process of educating a parent, this viewpoint would not come across more strongly than the idea that there is "equivocal medical evidence". Anyone who is medically educated and is in the position of advising a patient is going to color their advice by their own knowledge and experience. That's not paternalism.

I know you've undoubtedly read the famous Emanuel/Emanuel paper on medical models (which, by the way, we were given during our first semester in med school). The idea that the patient should be solely given information and should make all decisions alone, with the caregiver as a technical informer only, is the 'informative' model and it isn't considered ideal either. There has to be some guidance or interpretation, otherwise the caregiver might as well be Google.com (TM).

I'm not using the example to say anything about the majority of physicians. Yet it appears you are the third MD here to deny there is a difference.

Point of information: I'm not a physician yet. I appreciate the brevet rank, though. :cool:

You keep claiming this, and yet clearly, three different people are getting a different message. Is it not possible to state that there are differences between the professions of medicine and nursing without implying that one of them is intrinsically better? I know you will respond that you were doing no such thing. But that's how it's coming across.

I have never observed a nurse expressing offense that a patient did not accept the nurse's opinion. The nurse might be annoyed with a difficult patient, but not offended that the patient rejected the nurse's advice.

I have. I've seen nurses who are openly scornful about patients not listening to them, even when it's something as simple as when they should get out of bed. Doesn't mean a darn thing about nurses in general. Your constant use of absolutes ("I have never seen a nurse do this") and implication of rare exceptions (Not all doctors are like this") is what is leading to the appearance that you *are* generalizing about "all doctors".

If that is, as you say, not what you mean, then please stop bringing it up to bolster your position on this specific topic. I agree with Katana that you are clearly extremely knowledgable and you know your subject well; I have no doubt that your patients are well served by you. You are doing yourself and those who might learn from you a disservice by injecting your argument with what is obviously being interpreted as, if not a personal attack, then a professional one.

Take my position here compared to Hawkeye's as an example. She is less willing to consider the legitimacy of personal assignment of weight to different aspects of the risk benefit analysis of the issue, she is willing to 'allow' the parents their choice, and she considers that the equivalent of 'respecting' their choice. From my point of view, as long as the parents are operating with valid facts, then I would respect the decision they arrived at. I don't need to 'allow' it, that isn't my place.

Yes, let's, shall we? Only let's deal with my actual position. My position is that based on the medical evidence, I do not believe circumcision is warranted for every male child. Therefore, since I am considering it as a medical procedure, I don't intend to perform them routinely. As fls has pointed out, most parents are not primarily concerned with the risk of infection (whether of HIV, which seemed to be the predominant example early in the thread, or of UTIs, which have taken over lately) when considering circumcision. If a parent is concerned about UTI, then that is a medical question and a situation in which I would consider the procedure.

Your characterization of "willing to allow" and "respecting" other choices is specious. I do think that societal and cultural issues have weight, but I think that my input into them is far less than my input into a medical question. I don't even know what you think you mean by this. By 'respecting' a choice, you mean I should wholeheartedly support it and act on it just because it's the parents' decision? Sorry, but if I don't agree with it, I can't. I assure you I would never roll my eyes and say, "Well, if you MUST do it...." You seem to be assuming a level of judgmentalism on my part. It isn't like that. I really don't think circumcision is harmful. I think it's unncessary. That is different from "how dare you consider mutilating your child". Which, given the direction of some posts in this thread, I do see where that was coming from, but...don't ascribe that tone to me, because I have never and would never use it.
 
I'm not seeing the difference between selective rabidness and selective non-rabidness.

:confused:
 
I'm not seeing the difference between selective rabidness and selective non-rabidness.

:confused:

Does one select only those issues one feels most passionate (maybe based on rational criteria, but could be other) about to throw their heart into, or does one throw their heart into most everything, excluding only the excessively non-controversial?

Linda
 
I don't think routine circumcision of infants particularly harms the child. I think it harms the society that tolerates it.

Not so long ago a person could be bought and sold, legally.

Not so long ago a man could rape his wife, legally.

Not so long ago a child could be beaten, legally.

But of course, YOU think routine circumcision is different.
 
I don't think routine circumcision of infants particularly harms the child. I think it harms the society that tolerates it.

Not so long ago a person could be bought and sold, legally.

Not so long ago a man could rape his wife, legally.

Not so long ago a child could be beaten, legally.

But of course, YOU think routine circumcision is different.


You state here that you don't think that routine circumcision of infants hurts the children.

All of the other acts hurt the individuals who we now protect with our laws.

By your own statements, circumcision IS different.

:con2:
 
Does one select only those issues one feels most passionate (maybe based on rational criteria, but could be other) about to throw their heart into, or does one throw their heart into most everything, excluding only the excessively non-controversial?

Linda

It's rather difficult to throw your heart into something you don't feel passionate about, isn't it?
Exclusing some circumstances or qualifying exceptional situations is necessary when you feel great passion about conflicting issues. Sometimes different things one feels strongly about will converge in opposition, creating the effect of tempering.
I don't think that's "excluding only the excessively non-controversial", though. It's balancing conflicting ideals in an attempt to preserve the integrity of both.
 
So there is an external reference that is used to judge parents behavior toward their child, just as there is one for physicians and nurses behavior toward their patient.

Anyone care to speculate on the source of these values and their validity across cultures?

The Courts, as in, the Law, and Religion, as in, God said it. Perhaps Medical Ethics Boards, and maybe the Mores.

I don't think there is a cross cultural validity. Different cultures have different Mores, Laws and Religions. Circumcision seems to be a Jewish based belief, which by proxy spread to Christianity and Muslims.

It probably started as a way to mark men as slaves. Only slaves were circumcised, a way to ensure they couldn't ever pass themselves off as free men.

In these more enlightened times, we don't do primitive rites anymore. Circumcision is not medically necessary. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) does not recommend circumcision as a routine procedure for newborn males.
 
Perhaps your emotional response prevented you from addressing any part of my argument?

Male infant circumcision is genital mutilation for the cosmetic purposes of the parents if there is no immediate medical reason to do so. As an unnecessary act of mutilation there is a risk that the child will be permanently damaged in the process.

The question is begged as to why stop at genital mutilation? After all, the appendix is a redundant organ but I see little justification for a widespread removal of the appendix in case it should get diseased at a later stage in life.

For a discussion of some of the myths supporting circumcision please see http://mothersagainstcirc.org/. Should a barbaric practice brought in partly because of an ill conceived attempt to prevent masturbation be allowed to continue in decent societies in the twenty first century.

Ask yourself if the practice even works, then ask yourself if it's barbaric or not. It doesn't. It is.

(Geez, EJ, something you and I agree on! :eek: )

Ivor brought up and interesting point: we have changed over the years. And while slavery, rape, and child abuse continue, their status within advanced societies has changed. You cannot buy or sell people legally, you cannot rape a woman legally, you cannot beat your child legally. we have come to understand that people have rights to and of themselves. Why is the issue of circumcision any different? Unless you're doing it for a specific medical reason, it simply should not be done.
 
You state here that you don't think that routine circumcision of infants hurts the children.

All of the other acts hurt the individuals who we now protect with our laws.

By your own statements, circumcision IS different.

:con2:

What long term physical harm does rape do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does beating a child do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does enslaving a person do? No more than circumcision.

The people who supported and carried out these acts weren't monsters. They were just like you and me. Ever heard "Spare the rod, ruin the child."?
 
What long term physical harm does rape do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does beating a child do? No more than circumcision.

What long term physical harm does enslaving a person do? No more than circumcision.

The people who supported and carried out these acts weren't monsters. They were just like you and me. Ever heard "Spare the rod, ruin the child."?


There is more than physical harm to be weighed. Have you ever met a rape victim? I suspect that you have not. When you do, tell her that you doubt her experience caused her long-term harm. I dare you. I also suspect that you have not seen the trauma that forced intercourse can do. That CAN have real, lasting, debilitating physical consequences. So comparing this scenario to circumcision, particularly after you claim that circumcision does not harm the child is ignorant at best and offensive at worst. :mad:

As for long-term harm from beating children, well those beaten to death, brain damaged, or otherwise handicapped might take issue with your statements, too. When you bring up the beating of children, that which is illegal, you're raising a category of treatment that is far outside of that of spanking. That's why it is against the law, after all.

Long-term harm of enslaving people? Well, aside from robbing them of their human rights, separating families against their will, depriving them of opportunities for livelihood, and compromising their earning potential not to mention the physical abuses handed down upon them by virtue of their being viewed as property even if that abuse turns out to be lethal, oh I can't think of any real long-term harm that that would cause.
 
It does make maintenance easier, easier to get a woman to perform fellatio on you, slightly reduced vulnerability to certain infections, and having it done at birth is far easier than having it done in your teens. Sure it hurts either way, but most people aren't even aware of what happened until they're about 2 so it's not a big deal.

And while some will complain it reduces sensation, I can state as a healthy 29 year old that I've had PLENTY of sensation, and lots of fun with my circumcized penis.

Tony L
 
There is more than physical harm to be weighed. Have you ever met a rape victim? I suspect that you have not. When you do, tell her that you doubt her experience caused her long-term harm. I dare you. I also suspect that you have not seen the trauma that forced intercourse can do. That CAN have real, lasting, debilitating physical consequences. So comparing this scenario to circumcision, particularly after you claim that circumcision does not harm the child is ignorant at best and offensive at worst. :mad:

As for long-term harm from beating children, well those beaten to death, brain damaged, or otherwise handicapped might take issue with your statements, too. When you bring up the beating of children, that which is illegal, you're raising a category of treatment that is far outside of that of spanking. That's why it is against the law, after all.

Long-term harm of enslaving people? Well, aside from robbing them of their human rights, separating families against their will, depriving them of opportunities for livelihood, and compromising their earning potential not to mention the physical abuses handed down upon them by virtue of their being viewed as property even if that abuse turns out to be lethal, oh I can't think of any real long-term harm that that would cause.

Do you see what you did there? You picked the most extreme forms of the acts I used as examples. Some forms of circumcision can be pretty extreme too. Can you think of any?

A person could be enslaved by people who cared for them. Not every slave was tortured. They did not know they were individuals because society decided they were not.

A man could force himself on his wife because she was lead to believe that was her role in life. Love and Obey. She got that idea from society.

A child could be beaten without leaving marks. The child learned that it was the correct way to deal with disobedience. Not every child was beaten to death.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom