Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Prove that the foreskin is 'useful'. Or, should I say, prove that the benefits of having a foreskin outweigh the benefits of not having one. So far, the benefits of having one appear minimal at best, while the benefits of not having one are somewhat greater (at least in our society).

Waitaminute, that's not how it works. Noone needs to justify leaving a child intact, it is the proponents of any alteration that must justify THEIR positions. In short, the burden of proof is on you.

Personally, I agree that parents ought to have the right (and, in fact, they DO have the right) to have surgery done on their children to improve their appearance. But then, I'm something of an extremist in this area, and my commentaries should be treated accordingly.

I literally shudder at the thought of being your child.
 
http://www.aegis.com/conferences/IASHIVPT/2005/TuOa0401.html



So, who's going to volunteer to follow up on this?

My guess: Nobody. The powers that be have decided that FGM is "wrong" in all its forms and circumcision is "right", so long as a parent does it out of concern for their child's well-being.

I wonder if a physician in the US would still be ok performing a circumcision if a parent explicitly said they thought the health benefits were insignificant and the real reason they were insisting on their child's foreskin be removed was because they believed the foreskin was ugly and disgusting?

But given the US is a country with child beauty pageants, I guess it wouldn't make much difference:rolleyes:
 
There is a minimal consideration of "abuse" which would be respresented in the legal system by the "reasonable person", and there is individual opinion. So I think it would more accurately be stated "as a parent I can do anything a reasonable person would do to my child". The "since it is my property" doesn't follow though. There are many reasons that people take action - use of property is just one of many. "Since I am entrusted with the care of this person" could just as easily be inserted, especially since children are not legally considered property in the US (I don't know where you are).

ETA: D'oh! I should have looked at your info.

Linda


Dropping the "because they are property" clause doesn't alter your position, for your claim of a tautology it has to be that parents determine what is abusive or not for their child.
 
I don't think anyone denies that it was once the status quo. However, in the 20+ years I've been involved in medical education (either as a student or a professor), the teaching has been directed toward patient autonomy and the status quo is now very different. I think classes and articles that address paternalism reflect 1) that it takes considerable effort to dramatically alter beliefs and attitudes and 2) that physicians are serious about that effort.

I know that you know better than this. You use extreme examples (and does not the fact that they are noteworthy suggest that they are not the status quo?) to illustrate physician practice and then arbitrarily assign a particular approach solely to a nursing perspective. I am familiar with the physician side of the issue of compliance in transplant patients at a national (technically international) level, and all of the issues discussed in that article receive the attention and consideration of physicians as well.

I actively promote patient autonomy. I have seen many other doctors do that.

Linda
I agree that younger doctors are exposed to a different world than the education and socialization of their older peers. But the idea the medical community has suddenly reversed a century old philosophy is absurd. OTOH, how many times do I have to say various versions of, "not all doctors" and "overlap" and "subtle philosophical difference, not concrete or absolute difference"? I am really being misunderstood here. I have to assume I am not explaining my self well. I am describing an underlying philosophical difference, not some black and white, doctors are this, nurses are that. I'm talking about more subtle differences. And of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others.

I see equivocal empirical medical evidence. I find the importance of reducing infection risk just as legitimate as valuing an intact foreskin. I see my role as giving the parents the information they need to make an informed choice. I don't see my role as imposing my personal values in this case.

I have observed many physician patient interactions and my approach is often much more oriented toward giving patients information to make decisions while physicians are much more inclined to give the patient their medical opinion. That doesn't mean all physicians are going to approach problems in the same way. Nor are all nurses the same either.

Since I'm being challenged that there is a difference, I gave the extreme example to point out an underlying philosophy which you will not find in nursing. I'm trying to show you what the difference is that I am talking about. I'm not using the example to say anything about the majority of physicians. Yet it appears you are the third MD here to deny there is a difference. I'm wondering if you all really can't see the difference or whether you don't understand what I am describing.

I have never observed a nurse expressing offense that a patient did not accept the nurse's opinion. The nurse might be annoyed with a difficult patient, but not offended that the patient rejected the nurse's advice. Tell me you've never seen an MD take offense to a patient rejecting the MD's opinion? I've seen that many times. Maybe as nurses we are less often in a relationship where we are giving the patient 'opinions' but regardless, nurse patient and doctor patient relationships are very different.

But this is really getting off the point. I was speculating about what might be the reason for my differing viewpoint here. The reason is not as relevant as the fact it differs. Take my position here compared to Hawkeye's as an example. She is less willing to consider the legitimacy of personal assignment of weight to different aspects of the risk benefit analysis of the issue, she is willing to 'allow' the parents their choice, and she considers that the equivalent of 'respecting' their choice. From my point of view, as long as the parents are operating with valid facts, then I would respect the decision they arrived at. I don't need to 'allow' it, that isn't my place.
 
Kinda forgotten that it is the body of the child we're talkin about? The decision cannot possibly belong to anyone else, if any sense of justice be respected.

Not that it really would matter much. As far as I can see, people are having a life on both sides of the hedge.
People are assigned medical guardianship for any number of reasons. The parents own that position until the child is older. So like it or not, it is most certainly their right to make a medical decision for their child.
 
Concerning alleged "medical benefits" of circumcision:

How could natural selection create, and preserve, an anatomical feature that is actually harmful to the organism (as the foreskin is alleged to be)? If that were true, nature would select for men with smaller foreskins, and then eventually with none at all. ....
Robert
Take a genetic science course and you'll see the folly of that argument.
 
No. There is no separate area for physicians. I have seen them in other hospitals.

My take on it is that there is an argument to be made for having a separate clinical staff cafeteria so nurse practitioners, nurses, docs, etc could talk a bit more freely over lunch about tough cases or the like. I don't think that docs need to have an area separate from other clinical staff, but it is awkward to have a patient or patients' family members corner me in the sandwich line to discuss sensitive issues. .....
I can relate to that.

I really have been trying to describe something very subtle and realize it is coming across in a different light. And I also am not saying this subtle difference matters in every case, nor that one philosophy is better than the other. I have had many patients not the least bit interested in information or decision making, they want the provider to be in control. I know from the replies I'm coming across like I am saying the whole medical profession is paternalistic but that isn't what I mean at all. So now I'm sorry I brought it into the conversation.

As far as perpetuating the differences and the differences being 'vast', I totally agree with you and the differences are in no way vast. Nurses can be our own worst enemy but I probably shouldn't get started on that one.

In this discussion in particular, I am most concerned about the discounting of infection risk reduction, as if that was just no big deal. The impact of a child dying from infection is so overwhelming. These are often kids who were fine only a few days earlier. The medical evidence is that many of those infants with UTIs were also septic. And if one is going to cite evidence that a UTI is rarely serious or rarely fatal, then evidence is needed that death from septicemia secondary to a UTI is included in those numbers.

From my perspective, I can't imagine not affording any parent the right to hold the value that infection risk reduction was important and to make their decision based on that value. But maybe my position in this case has less to do with a difference in professional roots as in having had more than a few experiences with dying children.
 
Last edited:
Dropping the "because they are property" clause doesn't alter your position, for your claim of a tautology it has to be that parents determine what is abusive or not for their child.

My point was that the parents are not the only source for what is considered abusive with respect to their child - they are sufficient, but not necessary.

Linda
 
My point was that the parents are not the only source for what is considered abusive with respect to their child - they are sufficient, but not necessary.

Linda

That's just saying the same thing with different words. If a parent is sufficient i.e. "as much as is needed" to determine if something is abusive (or not) for their child then you are saying you agree with my first statement "As a parent I can do anything I wish to my child".
 
I agree that younger doctors are exposed to a different world than the education and socialization of their older peers. But the idea the medical community has suddenly reversed a century old philosophy is absurd. OTOH, how many times do I have to say various versions of, "not all doctors" and "overlap" and "subtle philosophical difference, not concrete or absolute difference"? I am really being misunderstood here. I have to assume I am not explaining my self well. I am describing an underlying philosophical difference, not some black and white, doctors are this, nurses are that. I'm talking about more subtle differences. And of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others.

I got it. Honest. :)

It looked like (and still looks like) you were attempting to push the overlapping curves apart, while I am attempting to push them closer together. I think that within group differences account for much more of what you see than between group differences in attitude.

Of course I'm not claiming that we have suddenly reversed a centuries old philosophy. It was you who brought up the idea of the underlying models and my point is that the underlaying model has changed which is leading to real changes in the behaviour and attitudes of physicians.

I see equivocal empirical medical evidence. I find the importance of reducing infection risk just as legitimate as valuing an intact foreskin. I see my role as giving the parents the information they need to make an informed choice. I don't see my role as imposing my personal values in this case.

I have observed many physician patient interactions and my approach is often much more oriented toward giving patients information to make decisions while physicians are much more inclined to give the patient their medical opinion. That doesn't mean all physicians are going to approach problems in the same way. Nor are all nurses the same either.

Since I'm being challenged that there is a difference, I gave the extreme example to point out an underlying philosophy which you will not find in nursing. I'm trying to show you what the difference is that I am talking about. I'm not using the example to say anything about the majority of physicians. Yet it appears you are the third MD here to deny there is a difference. I'm wondering if you all really can't see the difference or whether you don't understand what I am describing.

I have never observed a nurse expressing offense that a patient did not accept the nurse's opinion. The nurse might be annoyed with a difficult patient, but not offended that the patient rejected the nurse's advice. Tell me you've never seen an MD take offense to a patient rejecting the MD's opinion? I've seen that many times. Maybe as nurses we are less often in a relationship where we are giving the patient 'opinions' but regardless, nurse patient and doctor patient relationships are very different.

There are many reasons for those differences that are not based on paternalism. As you point out, the amount and kind of situations where nurses provide an opinion are quite different from situations involving physicians. Many of the medical decisions involve extensive knowledge and experience that cannot be sufficiently conveyed to the patient in order to let them make the informed decision, leading to situations where providing an expert opinion rather than an inadequate education better serves the patient. The nature of some of the things that physicians recommend (treatment, diagnostic tests) make it obvious when they are rejected, whereas the rejection of a nurse's recommendation may have little opportunity to be discovered. Your contention that you provide education while physicians provide opinion in comparable situations may look different to a neutral third-party.

I think you realize all this. It seemed to me that emphasizing differences in attitude (which I agree is present - less so in comparison of the ideal and more so in comparison of actual practice) ignored the more obvious differences in the nature of the roles and within group variation. And that your examples spoke more to the latter than to the former. I jumped in because your illustration of the situation seemed biased, as does mine, but together they might form some sort of useful picture.

But this is really getting off the point. I was speculating about what might be the reason for my differing viewpoint here. The reason is not as relevant as the fact it differs. Take my position here compared to Hawkeye's as an example. She is less willing to consider the legitimacy of personal assignment of weight to different aspects of the risk benefit analysis of the issue, she is willing to 'allow' the parents their choice, and she considers that the equivalent of 'respecting' their choice. From my point of view, as long as the parents are operating with valid facts, then I would respect the decision they arrived at. I don't need to 'allow' it, that isn't my place.

Don't you think, in this case, that it is practice and experience that probably accounts for much more of the difference than attitude? You both seem to have a similar attitude, but Hawkeye pictures her anticipated response differently than how you picture your response. Hers is necessarily speculative, but yours is based on experience. How to help parents (and patients) make decisions is something that you learn, after all.

Linda
 
That's just saying the same thing with different words. If a parent is sufficient i.e. "as much as is needed" to determine if something is abusive (or not) for their child then you are saying you agree with my first statement "As a parent I can do anything I wish to my child".

If discovered, an abusive parent can be held accountable by the criminal justice system.

Linda
 
If discovered, an abusive parent can be held accountable by the criminal justice system.

Linda

So there is an external reference that is used to judge parents behaviour toward their child, just as there is one for physicians and nurses behaviour toward their patient.

Anyone care to speculate on the source of these values and their validity across cultures?
 
Last edited:
If discovered, an abusive parent can be held accountable by the criminal justice system.

Linda

And if you use that definition my statement that I asked you about i.e.

"Parent's shouldn't be allowed to abuse their children"

is not as you claimed a tautology.
 
EJ Armstrong makes an attempt to associate circumcision with indecency.

Perhaps your emotional response prevented you from addressing any part of my argument?

Male infant circumcision is genital mutilation for the cosmetic purposes of the parents if there is no immediate medical reason to do so. As an unnecessary act of mutilation there is a risk that the child will be permanently damaged in the process.

The question is begged as to why stop at genital mutilation? After all, the appendix is a redundant organ but I see little justification for a widespread removal of the appendix in case it should get diseased at a later stage in life.

For a discussion of some of the myths supporting circumcision please see http://mothersagainstcirc.org/. Should a barbaric practice brought in partly because of an ill conceived attempt to prevent masturbation be allowed to continue in decent societies in the twenty first century.
 
And if you use that definition my statement that I asked you about i.e.

"Parent's shouldn't be allowed to abuse their children"

is not as you claimed a tautology.

No, not generally. In the context where you made that statement (i.e. with reference to circumcision), it becomes a tautology because it is necessary as well as sufficient for a parent to consider it abuse, since parental consent to circumcision is not a criminal act.

Linda
 
No, not generally. In the context where you made that statement (i.e. with reference to circumcision), it becomes a tautology because it is necessary as well as sufficient for a parent to consider it abuse, since parental consent to circumcision is not a criminal act.

Linda

None of which is relevant to the statement I asked you about i.e. "Parent's shouldn't be allowed to abuse their children." (which was in a post that I pointing out a strawman you had posted). That statement was not and is not a tautology.
 
Perhaps your emotional response prevented you from addressing any part of my argument?

Male infant circumcision is genital mutilation for the cosmetic purposes of the parents if there is no immediate medical reason to do so. As an unnecessary act of mutilation there is a risk that the child will be permanently damaged in the process.

The question is begged as to why stop at genital mutilation? After all, the appendix is a redundant organ but I see little justification for a widespread removal of the appendix in case it should get diseased at a later stage in life.

For a discussion of some of the myths supporting circumcision please see http://mothersagainstcirc.org/. Should a barbaric practice brought in partly because of an ill conceived attempt to prevent masturbation be allowed to continue in decent societies in the twenty first century.


This is only to address the "If we circ, then why not remove the appendix, too" argument here.

Doing a routine circumcision on a newborn is an extremely quick and safe procedure (again, all arguments about long-term benefits/risks notwithstanding). Removing an appendix is a much different proposition. It is abdominal surgery, requiring general anesthesia (along with all of its risks), time in the operating room, significantly higher costs, and, though rare, the complications can be devastating.

There was a time when appendices were removed routinely during other surgery. The thought was, well, we're here anyway. Why not spare the patient trouble later? This went out of favor as the rate of complications from this began to out-pace the potential benefits.
 
If it's about convenience, then I'll get all their teeth pulled so I don't have to worry about nagging them to brush their teeth. That's turning into a pain in the a**, I tell ya. I have a blender (wedding present), after all.

And all this laundry is pretty inconvenient, so I'm thinking of getting "clothes" tattooed on all my kids. I won't circumcise them, though, cuz it's probably easier to tattoo a foreskin than it is to tattoo a glans.

And if we're making Africans do what we want them to do, I say make them send more chocolate my way.

Linda

I may be mistaken because your post failed to make any recognisably concrete points, but you may be agreeing that there is normally no medical reason to genitally mutilate male babies and that the primary reason is a cosmetic choice of the parent and as such you might as well remove the appendix at birth.

Non medical male circumcision of babies is equivalent to docking dogs and something many rational people no longer do.

If the lust to chop perfectly healthy bits off those who cannot stick up for themselves is unstoppable, perhaps genital mutilation supporters could pick on someone their own size in the future and see what the reaction is? Just a thought.

Should they approach an adult member of the public while wielding a sharp knife and proclaiming that 'this is not going to hurt when you grow up.' I respectfully suggest that the word 'off' will immediately follow a word a decent person couldn't print on the JREF.

Babies just don't have the vocabulary these days.
 
None of which is relevant to the statement I asked you about i.e. "Parent's shouldn't be allowed to abuse their children." (which was in a post that I pointing out a strawman you had posted). That statement was not and is not a tautology.

I'm agreeing with you. My original reference to it being a tautology was only for the specific circumstance that I outlined, not as a general statement.

Linda
 
I may be mistaken because your post failed to make any recognisably concrete points...

I may have misunderstood your original intent. I thought your post was a parody and I was responding in kind.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom