I don't think anyone denies that it was once the status quo. However, in the 20+ years I've been involved in medical education (either as a student or a professor), the teaching has been directed toward patient autonomy and the status quo is now very different. I think classes and articles that address paternalism reflect 1) that it takes considerable effort to dramatically alter beliefs and attitudes and 2) that physicians are serious about that effort.
I know that you know better than this. You use extreme examples (and does not the fact that they are noteworthy suggest that they are not the status quo?) to illustrate physician practice and then arbitrarily assign a particular approach solely to a nursing perspective. I am familiar with the physician side of the issue of compliance in transplant patients at a national (technically international) level, and all of the issues discussed in that article receive the attention and consideration of physicians as well.
I actively promote patient autonomy. I have seen many other doctors do that.
Linda
I agree that younger doctors are exposed to a different world than the education and socialization of their older peers. But the idea the medical community has suddenly reversed a century old philosophy is absurd. OTOH, how many times do I have to say various versions of, "not all doctors" and "overlap" and "subtle philosophical difference, not concrete or absolute difference"? I am really being misunderstood here. I have to assume I am not explaining my self well. I am describing an underlying philosophical difference, not some black and white, doctors are this, nurses are that. I'm talking about more subtle differences. And of course there are physicians who are less paternalistic than others.
I see equivocal empirical medical evidence. I find the importance of reducing infection risk just as legitimate as valuing an intact foreskin. I see my role as giving the parents the information they need to make an informed choice. I don't see my role as imposing my personal values in this case.
I have observed many physician patient interactions and my approach is often much more oriented toward giving patients information to make decisions while physicians are much more inclined to give the patient their medical opinion. That doesn't mean all physicians are going to approach problems in the same way. Nor are all nurses the same either.
Since I'm being challenged that there is a difference, I gave the extreme example to point out an underlying philosophy which you will not find in nursing. I'm trying to show you what the difference is that I am talking about. I'm not using the example to say anything about the majority of physicians. Yet it appears you are the third MD here to deny there is a difference. I'm wondering if you all really can't see the difference or whether you don't understand what I am describing.
I have never observed a nurse expressing offense that a patient did not accept the nurse's opinion. The nurse might be annoyed with a difficult patient, but not offended that the patient rejected the nurse's advice. Tell me you've never seen an MD take offense to a patient rejecting the MD's opinion? I've seen that many times. Maybe as nurses we are less often in a relationship where we are giving the patient 'opinions' but regardless, nurse patient and doctor patient relationships are very different.
But this is really getting off the point. I was speculating about what might be the reason for my differing viewpoint here. The reason is not as relevant as the fact it differs. Take my position here compared to Hawkeye's as an example. She is less willing to consider the legitimacy of personal assignment of weight to different aspects of the risk benefit analysis of the issue, she is willing to
'allow' the parents their choice, and she considers that the equivalent of 'respecting' their choice. From my point of view, as long as the parents are operating with valid facts, then I would respect the decision they arrived at. I don't need to 'allow' it, that isn't my place.